Wenjing
Wang
ac,
Kongzhao
Su
*ac and
Daqiang
Yuan
*abc
aState Key Laboratory of Structural Chemistry, Fujian Institute of Research on the Structure of Matter, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Fuzhou, 350002, China. E-mail: skz@fjirsm.ac.cn; ydq@fjirsm.ac.cn
bFujian Science and Technology Innovation Laboratory for Optoelectronic Information of China, Fuzhou 350108, Fujian, P. R. China
cUniversity of the Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing, 100049, China
First published on 28th July 2023
Gases have played a crucial role in various industries, spanning from manufacturing and medicine to electronics. In these industries, the attainment of pure gases through effective separation methods has been recognized as essential. Porous materials-based adsorption and separation technologies have garnered significant attention due to their advantageous features, including low energy consumption and simplified operational procedures. Among these materials, porous organic cages (POCs) have emerged as a promising class, constructed by individually designed macromolecules possessing inherent cavities that are tailor-made, soluble, easily regenerated, and amenable to precise modifications. Analogous to well-established porous framework materials like zeolites, metal–organic frameworks (MOFs), and covalent organic frameworks (COFs), POCs have exhibited their intrinsic potential for gas separation applications in recent years. In this review, we delve into the progress achieved in the realm of POCs, with a particular focus on their utilization for selective gas separation. Moreover, we present an outlook on the future prospects of this field, along with the existing challenges that demand further attention.
In recent years, porous materials have emerged as a promising solution to address gas storage and separation challenges. Notable porous adsorbents encompass a range of materials, including metal-containing framework adsorbents like zeolites and metal–organic frameworks (MOFs),5–10 porous organic adsorbents such as porous organic polymers (POPs),11–13 covalent-organic frameworks (COFs),14–16 and hydrogen-bonded organic frameworks (HOFs),17–19 and molecular cage adsorbents like porous organic cages (POCs)20 and metal–organic cages (MOCs).21 MOFs have witnessed the most rapid development in the field of gas separation due to their remarkable porosity, tunable pore structures, and unsaturated metal sites, leading to their successful applications in various separations such as carbon dioxide (CO2) separation,22,23 alkene purification,24 noble gas separation,25 and isotope separation.26 However, despite their accomplishments, MOFs face challenges concerning cost, regeneration, stability, and selectivity, making it crucial to explore alternative porous materials for gas separation. It is worth noting that the progress in the development of other porous materials has been notably slower compared to MOFs, despite their inherent advantages. For instance, zeolites offer cost-effectiveness and easy availability, while porous organic materials possess a metal-free nature and native nonpolar/inert pore surfaces. POPs exhibit high stability, and HOFs and POCs allow for easy regeneration and tunability in fine-level pore sizes, respectively. Therefore, it is essential to investigate the gas purification capabilities of these materials to foster the advancement of diverse classes of porous materials in the field of gas separation.
Among the porous materials, POCs are constructed through covalent linkages of organic synthons to form discrete macromolecules with intrinsically hollow cavities (Fig. 1).27–34 This distinctive structure provides POCs with several advantages that include solution processing, regeneration, and post-synthesis modification,35–42 compared to other porous framework materials. Organic cage compounds were first reported by the Nobel Prize-winning chemist Jean-Marie Lehn in 1969, who presented the first example of organic cage molecules constructed from crown ether for cation binding.43 However, it was not until 2009 that Cooper's group confirmed the ability of isolated shape-persistent organic cages to serve as porous solids for gas storage.44 Since then, there has been a rapid increase in the number of POCs with different topologies, shapes, and surface areas, attracting significant attention over the past decade.45–73 The common methods used to synthesize POCs can be categorized into two types: irreversible bond formation and reversible bond formation, which mainly include several condensation reactions.20 Both methods have been extensively reviewed in recent publications.
Fig. 1 (a) Synthesis and characteristics of POCs. (b) Common covalent linkages in construction of POCs. |
POCs, as a relatively new sub-class of porous materials, share many advantages with other porous materials including low density, high surface area and pore volume, tunable window and cavity sizes, and the ability for easy and precise modification. Additionally, POCs show promising potential for numerous applications such as molecular recognition, membranes, catalysis, and separation.74–85 Despite prior reviews covering several applications, there remains an insufficient amount of coverage regarding the efficient gas-selective separation achieved by POCs. Similar to zeolites, MOFs, and COFs, POCs also exhibit gas storage and separation capabilities, fundamental attributes of porous materials. However, POCs are distinct in their construction as discrete molecules held together by weak intermolecular interactions, which results in their porosity arising not only from intrinsic cavities but from extrinsic voids or channels that result from inefficient molecule packing in the solid state. This feature makes POCs vulnerable to structural changes that may significantly impact their porosity and performance in gas storage and separation. Over the last decade, the Brunauer–Emmett–Teller (BET) surface area of POCs has increased from 624 m2 g−1 to 3758 m2 g−1, displaying the ability to selectively store and separate gases such as CO2, hydrocarbons, noble gases, and isotope gases as shown on Fig. 2. Zhang et al. recorded the first shape-persistent prismatic molecular cage capable of high selectivity for CO2 over N2 adsorption in 2010.86 Since then, Mastalerz et al. has developed several shape-persistent POCs that exhibit selective CO2 separation capabilities,87 whereas Cooper et al. reported, in 2014, that an imine-linked tetrahedral POC (CC3) was effective in effectively separating noble gas Xenon (Xe) and Krypton (Kr).88 Moreover, they showed successful separation of greenhouse gas sulfur hexafluoride (SF6) and N2 in 2016,89 and gaseous isotope mixtures (D2/H2) in 2019 by fine-tuning the internal cavities of POCs.90 Furthermore, Zhang et al. achieved efficient separation of binary or ternary C3 hydrocarbon mixtures using a soft imide-based POC (NKPOC-1) with gate-opening behavior in 2019.91 Yuan et al. developed a robust ethane-trapping POC (CPOC-301) in 2021, enabling one-step purification of high-purity ethylene (C2H4) from ethane (C2H6) and C2H4 mixture.92 They also discovered the solvatomorphism, which influenced acetylene (C2H2) and CO2 separation in CPOC-101.93 In 2022, Mastalerz et al. fine-tuned the fluorinated side-chains on the windows of imine-linked POCs,94 subsequently improving the separation of fluorinated alkanes. This review aims to provide a comprehensive overview of the significant progress made by POCs in gas separation. It is divided into distinct sections covering CO2 separation, hydrocarbon purification, rare gas separation, fluorinated greenhouse gas separation, and D2/H2 isotope separation. Additionally, we address remaining challenges and offer an outlook to stimulate further development of POCs in gas separation.
Fig. 2 Timeline of POCs for gas separation applications. Carbon is orange, oxygen red, nitrogen blue, and fluorine green. Hydrogen atoms and alkyl groups are omitted for clarity. |
In 2010, Zhang et al. published a study which reported the use of prismatic molecule cage 6 as an effective medium for CO2 and N2 separation.86 They observed that CO2 uptake capacity was 4.46 cm3 g−1, while N2 exhibited negligible adsorption at 0.061 cm3. The CO2/N2 adsorption selectivity was calculated to be 73, highlighting a profound affinity for CO2 over N2 during adsorption. Later, they successfully produced a series of new organic cage compounds (1–4) using a one-pot reversible imine condensation reaction between triamines and dialdehydes,99 followed by hydride reduction of the resulting imine to amine bonds. The triamine moieties functioned as the top and bottom panels of a trigonal prism, while the dialdehyde moieties served as the three lateral edges. The N2 adsorption isotherms at 77 K revealed that these materials had no pores for N2 gas, as indicated by a BET surface area of less than 10 m2 g−1. Cage 4 had the lowest N2 uptake while also displaying a comparable adsorption capacity for CO2, resulting in the highest CO2/N2 adsorption selectivity with a ratio of 138/1. The selectivity in gas adsorption observed could be attributed to the density of amino groups within the cage molecule and the size of the cage cavity. The amino group density predominantly governed the uptake of CO2, whereas the capacity for N2 adsorption related to the dimensions of the molecular prisms.
Cooper et al. reported a new propeller-shaped organic cage known as CC6 in 2011,100 produced via a one-step [2+3] cycloimination reaction between 1,3,5-tri(4-formylphenyl)benzene and 1,5-pentanediamine. The resulting CC6 had a moderate apparent BET surface area of 99 m2 g−1. Examination of the N2 adsorption isotherm at 300 K and 1.2 bar revealed a low gas uptake of 0.08 mmol g−1. Conversely, the CO2 adsorption capacity of CC6 under the same conditions was determined to be 0.90 mmol g−1. Using these isotherms, the ideal selectivity for CO2/N2 at 300 K and 1 bar was calculated to be 11.
In addition to reversible imine condensation, Zhang et al. successfully produced a tricyclooxacalixarene cage, named cage 1, in 2015 via a one-pot SNAr reaction involving tetrahydroxytetraphenylethylene and 2,6-dichloropyridine-3,5-dicarbonitrile (Fig. 3).101 This tricyclic cage had a grid-like porous architecture and demonstrated remarkable adsorption capacity for CO2, accompanied by high selectivity towards CO2/N2. Despite having a moderate surface area (432 m2 g−1), cage 1 could adsorb 84 cm3 g−1 (0.75 wt%) of H2 and 62.7 cm3 g−1 (12.5 wt%) of CO2 at 1.0 bar. The superior CO2 adsorption performance of cage 1 can be attributed to the optimal congruence between its microporous structure and the dimensions of CO2, as well as the electron-rich nature of nitrogen and oxygen atoms within the cage framework, which facilitate local-dipole/quadrupole interactions with CO2. The analysis of the initial slopes of the adsorption isotherms yielded a calculated CO2/N2 selectivity of 80 for cage 1.
Fig. 3 (a) Synthesis of TPE-based tricyclooxacalixarene cage 1. (b) H2 sorption isotherms at 77 K. (c) CO2 and N2 sorption isotherms at 273 K and 298 K. Reproduced with permission from ref. 101. Copyright 2015, Wiley. |
In 2018, a new cage (cage 5) was synthesized through a reaction between di(p-methylphenyl)-di(p-aminophenyl)ethylene and 2,6-pyridinediformyl chloride.102Cage 5 has a BET surface area of 347 m2 g−1 and displays considerable CO2 uptake of 39.7 cm3 g−1 at 273 K and 1 bar, equating to approximately six CO2 molecules per cage, with each CO2 molecule binding to one pyridyl ring. Moreover, the N2 adsorption under the same conditions was negligible, resulting in an excellent CO2/N2 selectivity of up to 32.
In 2020, Zhang et al. synthesized a triptycene-based cage (TC) using copper-mediated modified Eglinton-Glaser oxidative coupling reaction.103 The initial structure of TC exhibited limited N2 adsorption at 77 K and a relatively low BET surface area of only 7 m2 g−1. However, by rapidly precipitating TC-rp from a methanol/dichloromethane solution, it transformed into a porous state, increasing the BET surface area to 653 m2 g−1. TC-rp also displayed noteworthy CO2 uptake capacities, with values of 42.3 cm3 g−1 at 273 K and 33.6 cm3 g−1 at 298 K. Based on these measurements, the CO2/N2 selectivity of TC-rp was found to be 4.8 at 273 K.
Although it is primarily composed of methane (CH4), natural gas often contains significant amounts of CO2 that must be extracted to increase its heating value and prevent pipeline corrosion. POCs have also been utilized in the separation of CO2/CH4.104,105 In 2011, Mastalerz et al. examined the separation characteristics of CO2/CH4 using cage 3, which they synthesized through a one-pot Schiff base condensation reaction involving triamine and salicylbisaldehyde (Fig. 4).87Cage 3 had a calculated BET surface area of 1375 m2 g−1 and a Langmuir surface area of 1566 m2 g−1. At 77 K and 1 bar, the H2 adsorption capacity was 5.60 mmol g−1. At the same conditions (273 K and 1 bar), the adsorption capacity of CO2 was 2.10 mmol g−1, while only 0.61 mmol g−1 of CH4 was adsorbed. The marked difference in adsorption capacity between CO2 and CH4 implies the usefulness of cage 3 in removing CO2 from natural gas and enhancing CH4 content. The authors credit the hydroxy groups inside the cages for the high CO2/CH4 selectivity (10:1 w/w) of cage 3. Subsequently, a new exo-functionalized [4+6] cage 5 was reported, with a specific surface area of 919 m2 g−1, which exhibited high selectivity for CO2/CH4. At 273 K and 1 bar, cage 5 adsorbs 3.37 mmol g−1 CO2 and only 0.66 mmol g−1 CH4.96
Fig. 4 (a) Synthesis of cage 3. (b) Gas adsorption isotherms of H2 (square, 77 K), CO2 (circle, 273 K), and CH4 (triangle, 273 K) for cage compound 3. Reproduced with permission from ref. 87. Copyright 2011, Wiley. |
Yuan et al. recently introduced two POCs called CPOC-105 and CPOC-106 constructed using two C4RACHO atoms with four p-xylylenediamine and m-xylylenediamine linkers,106 respectively. The corresponding BET surface areas, calculated using CO2 sorption at 196 K, were 277 and 218 m2 g−1 for CPOC-105 and CPOC-106, respectively. At 298 K and 1 bar, CPOC-105 and CPOC-106 showed higher adsorption capacities for CO2 than CH4, with 44 cm3 g−1vs. 17 cm3 g−1 for CPOC-105 and 37 cm3 g−1vs. 20 cm3 g−1 for CPOC-106. Using Ideal Adsorbed Solution Theory (IAST) results under 1 bar, the CO2/CH4 selectivity values were calculated to be 4.5 for CPOC-105 and 3.1 for CPOC-106. Dynamic breakthrough experiments were used to validate the superior separation performance of CPOC-105.
Amendola et al. presented two novel imide/imine organic cages, named C1 and C2 (Fig. 5),107 synthesized through a [2+3] imine condensation reaction using two distinct polyamines and a novel dialdehyde compound incorporating a rigid bicyclo[2.2.2]oct-7-ene-2,3,5,6-tetracarboxydiimide core. At 298 K, the CO2 adsorption capacities of C1 and C2 were 0.61 mmol g−1 and 0.69 mmol g−1, respectively, while the adsorption capacities of CH4 and N2 were much lower. C1 and C2 demonstrated positive results in terms of CO2/N2 selectivity, with IAST selectivity values of 41 and 32, respectively, for CO2/N2 (15:85) mixtures. Moreover, both cages showed potential as fillers for mixed-matrix membranes (MMMs) in combination with polymers such as PEEK-WC and Matrimid® 9725. By incorporating C1 and C2 into Matrimid® 9725, CO2/CH4 selectivity was improved, and inclusion in PEEK-WC enhanced CO2/N2 selectivity.
Fig. 5 (a) Sketches of C1 and C2 (R = ethyl). (b) Overlay of CO2, CH4, and N2 adsorption isotherms, measured at 298 K. Reproduced with permission from ref. 107. Copyright 2022, Wiley. |
In 2021, Mastalerz et al. conducted an investigation on chiral self-sorting of large cubic [8+12] salicylimine cages (Fig. 6).108 The cages formed via the condensation of eight chiral C3-symmetric TBTQ-tris(salicylaldehydes) with 12 p-phenylenediamine. Notably, only three isomers were observed: (P)-4, (M)-4, and (P,M)-4. The comparison between the two enantiomeric cages, (P)-4 and (M)-4, revealed that they had similar BET surface area of 1212 and 1126 m2 g−1, respectively. At 273 K and 1 bar, (P)-4 had an adsorption capacity of 61.1 cm3 g−1 for CO2 and 18.2 cm3 g−1 for CH4, while (M)-4 had an adsorption capacity of 63.6 cm3 g−1 for CO2 and 19.7 cm3 g−1 for CH4. (P)-4 had a CO2/CH4 selectivity of 7.6 and a CO2/N2 selectivity of 24.9, while (M)-4 had a CO2/CH4 selectivity of 7.4 and a CO2/N2 selectivity of 24.7. A comparison between (P,M)-4_1 and (P,M)-4_2 yields intriguing insights. While (P,M)-4_2 has higher crystallinity and a greater specific surface area, it shows lower selectivity. Specifically, it has selectivity values of 5 for CO2/CH4 and 12.3 for CO2/N2, compared to (P,M)-4_1, which has selectivity values of 7.1 for CO2/CH4 and 28.0 for CO2/N2. This finding emphasizes that a higher degree of crystallinity doesn’t always mean superior material properties compared to an amorphous counterpart.
Fig. 6 (a) Condensation of the tri(salicylaldehyde) 2 with p-phenylenediamine 3 leading to the cubic [8+12] imine cage compounds (P)-4, (M)-4 and (P,M)-4. The cage compounds are represented schematically as cubes with the TBTQ-units at their vertices in blue for the (P)-enantiomer, in red for the (M)-enantiomer and the linear p-phenylenediimine linkers at the edges in grey. (b) IAST selectivity curves of the [8+12] cage compounds for CO2/CH4 (50:50) at 273 K and (c) for CO2/N2 (20:80) at 273 K. Reproduced with permission from ref. 108. Copyright 2021, Wiley. |
The structural stability of POCs is crucial in determining their gas separation performance. A highly acid and base-stable shape-persistent porous carbamate cage 3 was introduced in 2017.109 In addition, cage 3 is capable of stability even in hot 1 M hydrochloric acid and in concentrated hydrochloric acid at room temperature without decomposition. Despite its low specific surface area, cage 3 exhibited good selectivity towards CO2/CH4, adsorbing 58 cm3 g−1 CO2 and 21.8 cm3 g−1 CH4 at 273 K and 1 bar. In 2019, Mastalerz et al. synthesized a large shape-persistent [4+6] amide cage 4. The cages’ chemical robustness enabled post-functionalization under harsh conditions, resulting in the formation of demethylated cage 7, brominated cage 8, and nitrated cage 9.110 Notably, all of these cages demonstrated similar CO2 adsorption capacities, measuring 47.8 cm3 g−1 for cage 4, 45.8 cm3 g−1 for cage 7, 46.3 cm3 g−1 for cage 8, and 45.8 cm3 g−1 for cage 9 at 273 K and 1 bar. Under the same conditions, the cages exhibited similar CH4 adsorption capacities, measuring 13.7 cm3 g−1 for cage 4, 11.2 cm3 g−1 for cage 7, 12.1 cm3 g−1 for cage 8, and 12.0 cm3 g−1 for cage 9. Of these cages, cage 8 demonstrated the greatest selectivity for CO2/CH4, with a value of 28.5.
Yuan et al. recently reported on sp2 carbon-linked POCs (sp2c-POCs) that possess distinctive triangular prism structures through a one-step Knoevenagel reaction (Fig. 7).111 The sp2c-POCs are highly stable, maintaining their structural integrity even in the presence of concentrated HCl, concentrated HNO3, or saturated NaOH solutions. Notably, sp2c-POC1 has the highest BET surface area (350 m2 g−1) among all sp2c-POCs. In addition, sp2c-POC1 can absorb 27.4 cm3 g−1 of CO2 and 6.1 cm3 g−1 of CH4, but has negligible affinity for N2 at 298 K and 1 bar. The observed differences in gas uptake capacities imply that sp2c-POC1 can be useful in separating CO2/N2 and CO2/CH4 mixtures. The IAST selectivities of sp2c-POC1 were calculated, yielding values of 21 and 52 for CO2/CH4 (50:50) and CO2/N2 (15:85) mixtures, respectively. Breakthrough experiments have substantiated the excellent separation performance of sp2c-POC1 for CO2/CH4 and CO2/N2 gas mixtures. Moreover, the exceptional stability demonstrated by sp2c-POC1 highlights its potential as a solid adsorbent for purifying and separating natural and flue gases.
Fig. 7 (a) The synthetic route of [2+3] sp2c-POCs and their single-crystal X-ray structures. (b) CO2, CH4 and N2 adsorption isotherms of sp2c-POC1 at 298 K. (c) Experimental breakthrough curves of an equimolar mixture of CO2/CH4 at 298 K and 1 bar over a packed bed of sp2c-POC1. Reproduced with permission from ref. 111. Copyright 2023, Chinese Chemical Society. |
The separation of CO2 and C2H2 is crucial in producing high-purity C2H2 by eliminating CO2 impurities and poses significant challenges due to their similar molecular sizes and physical characteristics. It is imperative to study the gas sorption and separation behavior of CO2 and C2H2 in POC with intrinsic porosity, abundant electron-rich π calix[4]-resorcinarene cavities, and oxygen and nitrogen sites. In 2021, Yuan et al. discovered a lantern-shaped calix[4]resorcinarene-based POC (CPOC-101) that exhibits eight distinct solvatomorphs when subjected to crystallization in different solvents,93 presenting a significant breakthrough. Specifically, the CPOC-101α variant obtained through crystallization in toluene/chloroform demonstrated an apparent BET surface area of up to 406 m2 g−1 as determined by nitrogen gas sorption at 77 K, which was much higher than other solvatomorphs of CPOC-101 with BET surface area below 40 m2 g−1. Most importantly, the CPOC-101α variant showed superior adsorption capacities for C2H2 and CO2 and greater ability in C2H2/CO2 separation than CPOC-101β, which served as the representative solvatomorph with low BET surface areas. At 298 K and 1 bar, the activation of CPOC-101α resulted in adsorption capacities of CO2 and C2H2 of up to 63 and 95 cm3 g−1, respectively, while CPOC-101β resulted in lower adsorption capacities of 39 and 60 cm3 g−1 under the same conditions. At ambient conditions, dynamic breakthrough experiments were conducted to verify the practical separation performance of C2H2/CO2 using CPOC-101. The longer separation time of CPOC-101α compared to CPOC-101β indicates that it has a higher preference for trapping C2H2 over CO2. Calculating the separation factors of C2H2/CO2 for CPOC-101α and CPOC-101β using breakthrough experiments yields values of 2.2 and 2.0, respectively. Additionally, the stability of CPOC-101α was confirmed through recycling experiments where the breakthrough time remained consistent after four cycles.
In 2017, Yuan et al. reported the synthesis of seven water-stable hydrazone-linked POCs with four distinct assembly modes: HPOC-101, HPOC-102, HPOC-103, and HPOC-104.112 These cages were synthesized via coupling reaction between C4RACHO and various dihydrazides (Fig. 8). The characterization of the porous organic cages revealed calculated BET surface areas ranging from 373 to 563 m2 g−1. Additionally, the cages’ adsorption properties towards CO2 and C2H2 at room temperature were investigated, resulting in C2H2 capacities ranging from 31 to 47 cm3 g−1 and CO2 capacities ranging from 24 to 33 cm3 g−1. These cages notably exhibited a preference for C2H2 adsorption over CO2. To assess their applicability in C2H2/CO2 separation, breakthrough experiments using a C2H2/CO2 mixture (50:50), were specifically conducted for HPOC-102 and HPOC-104, which resulted in the effective separation of the C2H2/CO2 mixture. These breakthrough experiments highlight the promising performance of the cages in C2H2/CO2 separation. Furthermore, HPOC-102 and HPOC-104 serve as pioneering examples of hydrazone-linked POC materials successfully achieving C2H2/CO2 gas separation.
Fig. 8 (a) Schematic illustration of the assembly of [2+4] lanterns via hydrazone coupling of C4RACHO and alkanedihydrazides, along with their single-crystal X-ray structures and inner cavity heights. (b) CO2 and C2H2 adsorption isotherms of HPOC-102 at 298 K. (c) Experimental breakthrough curves of an equimolar mixture of CO2/C2H2 at 298 K and 1 bar over a packed bed of HPOC-102. Reproduced with permission from ref. 112. Copyright 2021, Royal Society of Chemistry. |
In 2018, Mastalerz et al. reported the synthesis of a small series of [4+6] boronic ester cages that varied in the degrees of fluorine content within the diboronic ester struts.113 Of the fluorinated cages, cages 10* and 11* exhibited noteworthy properties. Notably, non-fluorinated cage 9* had an excellent specific surface area of 511 m2 g−1. Encouraged by this result, subsequent investigations concentrated on the adsorption and separation performance of cage 9* for small hydrocarbons. The gas adsorption capacity of cage 9* was found to be 2.52 mmol g−1 for C2H6, 2.50 mmol g−1 for C2H4, and 2.53 mmol g−1 for C2H2. The selectivities for C2H6/C2H4, C2H6/C2H2, and C2H4/C2H2 based on a hypothetical 1:1 mixture were evaluated to be 1.29, 1.52, and 1.17, respectively.
Zhang et al. subsequently reported the synthesis of a new class of soft porous crystals utilizing an [2+3] imide-based organic cage referred to as NKPOC-1 (Fig. 9).91 One intriguing characteristic of NKPOC-1 is its guest-induced breathing behavior, where it undergoes reversible transformations from a “closed” nonporous phase (α) to two distinct porous “open” phases (β and γ) upon exposure to various gas molecules. Notably, NKPOC-1-α exhibits remarkable selectivity for propyne (C3H4) adsorption over propylene (C3H6) and propane (C3H8) under ambient conditions. To evaluate its separation capabilities, dynamic breakthrough experiments were conducted using binary and ternary gas mixtures consisting of C3H4/C3H6 (2:1, v/v), C3H4/C3H8 (2:1, v/v), and C3H4/C3H6/C3H8 (2:1 : 1, v/v/v) at 298 K. NKPOC-1-α demonstrates exceptional separation efficiency in the case of binary C3H4/C3H6 and C3H4/C3H8 gas mixtures, with C3H4 saturation uptakes and breakthrough retention times of 75.6 cm3 g−1 and 137 min g−1, as well as 55.2 cm3 g−1 and 100 min g−1, respectively. Noteworthy, NKPOC-1-α also effectively removes C3H4 from a ternary gas mixture (C3H4/C3H6/C3H8, 2:1:1, v/v/v) under ambient conditions, based on a C3H4 retention duration of 135 min g−1 and a calculated C3H4 saturation uptake of 67 cm3 g−1. This outstanding separation performance of NKPOC-1-α is attributed to its selective gate-opening effect for C3 hydrocarbons combined with the strength of the interactions once the gate is open.
Fig. 9 (a) Synthesis of NKPOC-1 (C, gray; N, blue; O, red). Sorption isotherms of NKPOC-1-α for C3H4, C3H6, and C3H8 at (b)253 K, (c) 273 K, (d) 298 K, and (e) 313 K. Filled and open symbols represent adsorption and desorption, respectively. (f) Dynamic experimental fixed-bed column breakthrough results of binary (2:1 v/v) C3H4/C3H6 and C3H4/C3H8 gas mixtures in an absorber bed packed with activated NKPOC-1-α. (g) Ternary breakthrough experiment for a C3H4/C3H6/C3H8 (2:1 : 1 v/v/v) gas mixture. Reproduced with permission from ref. 91. Copyright 2019, American Chemical Society. |
Yuan et al. identified a promising POC, known as CPOC-301, which is composed of a highly porous [6+12] octahedral calix[4]resorcinarene structure (Fig. 10).92 It is important that CPOC-301 shows exceptional ability in selectively capturing C2H6 from mixtures with C2H4, resulting in the direct production of high-purity C2H4. CPOC-301 can adsorb up to 670 cm3 g−1 of N2, a maximal capacity that corresponds to a calculated BET surface area of 1962 m2 g−1. A key finding is that, at 293 K, CPOC-301 selectively binds C2H6 more strongly (87 cm3 g−1) than C2H4 (75 cm3 g−1). The researchers calculated that the heat of adsorption (Qst) at zero coverage for C2H6 and C2H4 is 32.4 and 24.2 kJ mol−1, respectively. This observation suggests that the host–guest interactions between CPOC-301 and C2H6 are much stronger than those with C2H4. The researchers attribute the stronger attraction of CPOC-301 to C2H6 as a result of the creation of multiple C–H···π hydrogen bonds between C2H6 and the resorcin[4]arene cavities, demonstrated by first-principles dispersion-corrected density functional theory (DFT-D) calculations. Additionally, breakthrough experiments have validated the efficient isolation of C2H4 from C2H6/C2H4 mixtures using CPOC-301. The researchers provide the calculated separation factor for an equimolar mixture of C2H6/C2H4, which is 1.3, a value that aligns well with the predicted IAST value. Further, researchers found that the CPOC-301 consistently maintains its separation performance over seven consecutive cycles, which demonstrates its robustness and positions it as a promising candidate for C2H4 purification purposes.
Fig. 10 (a) The X-ray crystal structure of CPOC-301. (b) The Solid-state molecular packing of CPOC-301 viewed from [001] direction, where H atoms are committed for clarity. Color codes: phenyl ring; orange, carbon; gray, oxygen; red, nitrogen; blue, and hydrogen; light turquoise. (c) Experimental C2H6 and C2H4 adsorption isotherms of CPOC-301 at 293 K. (d) Isosteric heat of adsorption plots for the adsorption of C2H6 and C2H4 by CPOC-301. (e) Experimental breakthrough curves for equimolar mixture of C2H6/C2H4 at 298 K and 1 bar over a packed bed of CPOC-301. (f) The recyclability of CPOC-301 under multiple mixed gas column breakthrough tests. Reproduced with permission from ref. 92. Copyright 2021, Springer Nature. |
Recently, Yuan et al. explored the functionalities of the octahedral calix[4]resorcinarene-based hydrazone-linked porous organic cage (HPOC-401) as a prototype for post-synthetic metalation with different transition metal ions.114 The study demonstrated that HPOC-401 has exceptional properties for this purpose, even under mild conditions. The BET surface areas of HPOC-401 after being metalated with various transition metal ions, namely HPOC-401-V, HPOC-401-Cu, HPOC-401-Zn, and HPOC-401-Mo, were significantly increased compared to pristine HPOC-401. The specific surface areas measured were 1456 m2 g−1 (HPOC-401-V), 1099 m2 g−1 (HPOC-401-Cu), 983 m2 g−1 (HPOC-401-Zn), and 710 m2 g−1 (HPOC-401-Mo), while HPOC-401 had a surface area of 474 m2 g−1. Furthermore, the metalated HPOC-401 showed enhanced CO2, H2, and C2 hydrocarbon uptake capacity along with improved selectivity for C2H6/C2H4, compared to the pure HPOC-401. Specifically, HPOC-401-V and HPOC-401-Cu displayed an interesting preference for C2H6 over C2H4. However, HPOC-401 alone does not exhibit selective adsorption of C2H6. Remarkably, HPOC-401-V demonstrated an outstanding C2H6/C2H4 selectivity of up to 2.3, which surpasses the selectivity values of other POCs. The breakthrough results indicate the potential of HPOC-401-V to achieve efficient one-step separation of C2H4 from an equimolar mixture of C2H6/C2H4.
Cooper et al. developed the first reported POC material for Xe/Kr separation with exceptional performance (Fig. 11).88 The team used a [4+6] tetrahedral POC called CC3, which is an imine-linked structure formed by the Schiff-base reaction of 1,3,5-triformylbenzene and 1,2-diaminocyclohexane in a 2:3 molar ratio. CC3 was chosen primarily because the largest inclusion sphere in the CC3 cavity measures 4.4 Å, which is close to the size of Xe (4.10 Å). Notably, the window diameter of CC3 observed in its static solid-state crystal structure is only 3.6 Å, which is theoretically too narrow to allow for Xe and Kr diffusion, with diameters of 4.10 Å and 3.69 Å, respectively. However, the flexibility of the cage structure, attributed to cage vibrations, results in temporary enlargement of the pore diameter. Despite being relatively soft since CC3 is assembled from discrete molecules, it exhibits structural deformations, such as window vibrations and packing changes under certain temperature and pressure conditions, allowing many gas molecules to access the pores of CC3. The simulations and experimental gas adsorption isotherms and molecular dynamics revealed that CC3 can accommodate both Xe and Kr, and it demonstrated a strong Xe preferential adsorption over Kr, as evidenced by calculations of the isosteric heat of adsorption. The calculated Xe/Kr selectivity for CC3 reached a value of 20.4, surpassing many MOF materials. To examine the practical separation performance of rare gases at low concentrations in the air, mimicking the spent nuclear fuels reprocessing, the researchers conducted experimental breakthrough measurements. They used gas mixtures containing Xe (400 ppm), Kr (40 ppm), and other elements of air (N2, O2, and CO2), which were passed through a packed column of CC3 crystals. The Kr gas was immediately detected in the effluent, while Xe gas was retained for more than 15 min, which is consistent with the observation of stronger host–guest interactions between Xe and the cage relative to Kr.
Fig. 11 (a) Schematic illustration of the assembly of CC3. (b) Predicted and experimental single-component gas adsorption isotherms for CC3 at 298 K. (c) Isosteric heat of adsorption calculations of noble and other gases at 298 K. (d) Breakthrough curves for CC3 by Xe, Kr, and common gas mixtures. Reproduced with permission from ref. 88. Copyright 2014, Springer Nature. |
In 2016, Thallapally et al. reported the selective uptake of Xe by two previously reported POCs,116 namely noria and PgC-noria. These POCs were prepared with an acid-catalyzed condensation reaction between glutaraldehyde and resorcinol (for noria) and pyrogallic acid (for PgC-noria), in the presence of concentrated hydrochloric acid. The isotherms for Xe and Kr adsorption were measured for both noria and PgC-noria. It was observed that both POCs showed selectivity towards Xe over Kr, with noria demonstrating greater Xe adsorption compared to PgC-noria. Furthermore, the IAST calculations demonstrated that noria displayed an exceptional Xe/Kr selectivity of 9.4 under dilute conditions. The remarkable Xe/Kr selectivity, coupled with the high thermal stability of noria implies that it could be a promising candidate for capturing Xe from the off-gas produced during the reprocessing of used nuclear fuel.
In 2016, Cooper et al. investigated whether four [4+6] imine-linked tetrahedral POCs (CC2, CC3, CC5, and CC13) could be potentially applied to separate SF6 from N2.89 These POCs were synthesized through a Schiff-base reaction between diamine and tri-aldehyde in a 3:2 molar ratio. Adsorption experiments were conducted to evaluate their capability for SF6 gas uptake, revealing that all four cages demonstrated SF6 adsorption but at varying capacities due to their structural differences. It is important to note that the kinetic diameter of SF6 (5.5 Å) exceeds the window diameters (∼3.6 Å) of CC2, CC3, and CC13, suggesting that they are not capable of encapsulating SF6. However, these POCs possess a flexible nature that enables them to adsorb SF6 despite its larger size than the static window diameter. Further analysis of the adsorption isotherms indicated that CC3α exhibited a typical type I adsorption behavior characterized by sharp increases at low pressures, indicating its higher affinity for SF6. This finding was supported by the calculated Qst values. Furthermore, CC3 showed the highest SF6/N2 selectivity among the four POCs, and activated CC3α achieved selectivities of 178 at 273 K and 74 at 298 K for a 10:90 SF6:N2 mixture, which exceeds those of many reported MOFs. Additional simulations suggested that cooperative diffusion and structural rearrangements within CC3 contribute to the near-ideal behavior of the host for SF6 guest molecules. X-ray crystallography analysis provided insight into the location of SF6 within the CC3 cavity, confirming the strong interaction between the CC3 host and SF6 guest.
In 2022, Mastalerz et al. reported three isostructural [2+3] lantern-shaped POCs, including H-cage (with non-fluorinated n-butyl chains), HF-cage (with partially fluorinated n-butyl chains), and F-cage (with perfluorinated n-butyl chains), all with varying degrees of fluorinated side-chains (Fig. 12).94 Triamino triptycene and terphenyl-based bis-salicylaldehydes were used in a 2:3 molar ratio, catalyzed by trifluoroacetic acid to construct these POCs. The gas adsorption behavior of fluorinated and non-fluorinated alkanes was compared among these isomorphic crystalline states to evaluate the impact of different side chains on gas sorption properties. The study showed that the fluorinated POCs preferentially adsorbed fluorinated gases, whereas the non-fluorinated POCs demonstrated a preference for non-fluorinated gases. Specifically, F-cage exhibited the highest uptakes of PFCs, such as tetrafluoromethane (CF4), hexafluoroethane (C2F6), and octafluoropropane (C3F8), compared to the other two POCs. IAST selectivities of CF4/N2, C2F6/N2, and C3F8/N2 were calculated under different compositions and conditions (273 K and 1 bar), indicating that F-cage had a high selectivity for fluorinated gases over N2. Additionally, F-cage showed the highest selectivity for fluorinated alkanes over non-fluorinated alkanes. Given its advantageous selective adsorption of PFCs, the researchers further investigated the sorption of octafluorocyclobutane (c-C4F8 or PFC-318) in more detail. F-cage demonstrated selectivity for c-C4F8/N2 up to 41475. Experimental breakthrough analyses revealed that F-cage effectively separated c-C4F8 from N2 mixtures with a breakthrough time of 107 minutes, and its separation performance remained consistent over seven consecutive cycles. Furthermore, F-cage demonstrated stability in neutral, acidic, and basic aqueous media as confirmed by 1H and 19F NMR spectroscopy, thermogravimetric analysis (TGA), and N2 sorption at 77 K, indicating that F-cage is robust enough for real-world applications.
Fig. 12 (a) Synthesis of H-cage, HF-cage, and F-cage by imine condensation reactions of triamino triptycene and terphenyl bis-salicylaldehydes, and the single-crystal X-ray structure of F-cage. (b) PFC sorption properties of H-cage, HF-cage, and F-cage in comparison. (c) Space filling models of the fluorinated alkanes, including tetrafluoromethane (PFC-14), hexafluoroethane (PFC-116), octafluoropropane (PFC-218), and octafluorocyclobutane (PFC-318). (d) Applicability investigations of F-cage, including breakthrough curves and stablity tests. Reproduced with permission from ref. 94. Copyright 2022, Wiley. |
Cooper et al. utilized PSM synthesis in 2019, which proved to be effective in modifying POCs' internal cavities and fine-tuning the pore sizes, resulting in outstanding quantum sieves.90 Their work produced six internal functionalized POCs, namely 6ET-RCC3, 1PT-5FT-RCC3, 1AT-5FT-RCC3, 1ET-5FT-RCC3, 5FT-RCC3, and 6FT-RCC3, with PLE values ranging from 1.95 Å to 3.50 Å (Fig. 13). To achieve this, a post-synthetic “tying” and protection-deprotection strategy were utilized based on RCC3, a reduced derivative of CC3. The POCs demonstrated a trade-off behavior, where those with lower PLE values exhibited lower D2 adsorption capacities but higher selectivity while conversely, those with higher PLE values exhibited high D2 adsorption capacities and lower selectivity. The upscaling of the internal functionalized POCs for practical applications presented significant challenges. Nonetheless, combining the small-pore and large-pore functionalized POCs through cocrystallization into a single solid resulted in a material with optimal separation performance, exhibiting excellent D2/H2 selectivity (8.0) and high deuterium uptake (4.7 mmol g−1). In 2022, Vogel et al. used ab initio molecular dynamics (AIMD) simulations to explain how the internal functionalized POCs could manage D2 and H2 separation, leading to the targeted design of novel porous adsorbents for hydrogen isotope separation.128
Fig. 13 (a) Full synthesis route for the internal functionalized POCs (including 6ET-RCC3, 1PT-5FT-RCC3, 1AT-5FT-RCC3, 1ET-5FT-RCC3, 5FT-RCC3, and 6FT-RCC3). (b) Representative single-crystal structures of the modified cages showing accessible cavities (colored), along with calculated PLEs for each system. (c) D2/H2 selectivities and gas uptakes as a function of exposure time at 30 K for CC3, 6FT-RCC3, and 6ET-RCC3. (d) Summary of hydrogen isotope KQS selectivities and adsorption capacities for various porous materials. Reproduced with permission from ref. 90. Copyright 2019, American Association for the Advancement of Science. |
This journal is © the Partner Organisations 2023 |