Vassilis
Tangoulis
*a,
Christina D.
Polyzou
a,
Patroula
Gkolfi
a,
Nikolia
Lalioti
a,
Ondrej
Malina
b and
Michaela
Polaskova
bc
aDepartment of Chemistry, University of Patras, 26504 Patras, Greece. E-mail: vtango@upatras.gr
bRegional Centre of Advanced Technologies and Materials, Czech Advanced Technology and Research Institute, Palacký University, Křížkovského 511/8, Olomouc, 779 00, Czech Republic
cDepartment of Experimental Physics, Faculty of Science, Palacký University Olomouc, 17. Listopadu 1192/12, 771 46 Olomouc, Czech Republic
First published on 9th February 2021
Spin Crossover (SCO) particles at the nanometric scale provide an alternative point of view and a new perspective concerning the development of a new generation of spintronic, electronic, photonic and mechanical devices. The coexistence of the SCO phenomenon with the accompanying hysteresis loop enhances the functionality of future devices for storing and processing information. Despite all promising facts, the SCO phenomena are greatly affected by cooperativity issues resulting in a direct relation between the decrease of the size of nanopatricle and the overall decrease of cooperativity towards more gradual spin transitions. This minireview aims to summarise the synthetic techniques for the synthesis of 2-D FeII SCO particles at the nanometric scale, an underexplored area of research, highlighting the effects of the size-reduction on the magnetic properties of the corresponding nanoparticles and hopefuly showcasing the importance of studying in the context of 2D limit the SCO phenomena.
However, the interconnection of physical properties and spin state, especially at the nanoscale, remains to be explored and thoroughly studied, since SCO phenomena are greatly affected by cooperativity issues among the SCO centres influencing directly the abruptness of the SCO transition and eventually the width of the hysteresis.1,12–16 Therefore, experimental and theoretical research is focused on the correlation of the size effect and the first-order phase transition of SCO systems and how the characteristics of the hysteresis are expected to be influenced by the number of molecules forming the nanoparticle. A crucial requirement for successful fabrication of devices is the preservation of the bistability and the cooperativity between the SCO centers during the downsizing experimental protocol.
So far, an extensive amount of studies1,12–22 refers to the downsizing effects on nanoparticles (NP) of the 1-D iron triazole polymers of the type [Fe(Htrz)(trz)]+ and the 3-D Hofmann polymer [Fe(pz)Pt(CN)4]·nH2O, where Htrz = triazole and pz = pyrazine. The study of these systems revealed a direct relation between the decrease of the particle size and the decrease of cooperativity towards gradual SCO transitions, lower transition temperatures, increase of the residual HS fraction and narrower hysteresis phenomena.
The case of 2-D SCO NPs remains almost unexplored, especially for systems consisting of ultra-thin 2-D nanosheets as building blocks. Given the interest of the scientific community for alternative chemical approaches of graphene and graphene related products, 2-D SCO NPs provide an ideal platform for further research due to: (i) the highly accessible active sites on the surface; and (ii) the rich synthetic chemistry based on plethora of organic ligands and metal ions. The correlation of the advantages of ultrathin 2-D nanosheets with the downsizing of SCO materials may provide an ideal fabrication protocol for devices with well optimized SCO properties. The present minireview focuses on the 2-D SCO Coordination Polymers (CPs) describing some important nano synthetic methods while in a parallel manner presents the effects of the size-reduction on the magnetic properties of the corresponding nanoparticles (nCPs). More explicitly, the covered nanosynthetic techniques will be: (a) reverse micelle technique, (b) Layer-by-Layer (LBL) method and (c) Liquid Phase Exfoliation (LPE) method.
In 2010 Martinez et al.25 reported for the first time the downsizing effect on 2-D SCO coordination polymer (Fig. 1a) with the formula [Fe(3-Fpy)2M(CN)4] (MII = Ni, PdII, PtII and 3-Fpy = 3-fluoropyridine).26 The resulting fabricated SCO nanocrystals were synthesized by using two water in oil microemulsions with the anionic sodium bis-(2-ethylhexyl)sulfosuccinate (NaAOT) as stabilizer at constant [H2O]/[NaAOT] ratio. The dimensions of the so called “nanocrystals” were found 400 × 400 × 30 nm as evidenced by TEM microscopy (inset in Fig. 1b). A better quality of nanocrystals was achieved by lowering the temperature reaction at 0 °C which resulted in a narrower size distribution. Fig. 1b shows the magnetic susceptibility measurements for the bulk compound 1 (red solid spheres) and the nanocrystals. It is clear that there is an explicit trend in the decrease of the thermal hysteresis width (from 24 to 10 K) as the size diminishes revealing the dependence of the cooperativity -between SCO centers- on the particle size reduction. A well-defined square shaped hysteresis loop appears for the bulk compound, while for the nanocrystals a gradual hysteresis loop is present due to the large particle-size distribution (olive oil color spheres). Concerning the nanocrystals of the same dimensions but with smaller size distribution a more symmetrical hysteresis loop is revealed (blue color spheres). Furthermore an increase in the residual HS fraction is also present for both cases of nanoparticles. The same trends are also observed for the polymeric PdII and PtII analogues. The SCO phenomenon is also accompanied by a color change between the HS state (red) and LS state (yellow). Further decrease of the size of the nanocrystals (70–200 nm) was possible only with the use of polyvinylpyrrolidone (PVP). However, the covering of nanoparticles with the protecting polymer did not result in a hysteretic behavior and instead took place an incomplete and continous second order spin transition.
Fig. 1 (a) Packing of the 2D layers of [Fe(3-Fpy)2M(CN)4] (MII = Ni(1), PdII (2), PtII (3) compounds along x-axis. Atom code: Fe, red; Ni/Pd/Pt, orange; N, green; C, gray; (b) the effect of downsizing of [Fe(3-Fpy)2Ni(CN)4] on the magnetic properties from bulk crystals (red spheres) to nanoplates with dimensions 400 × 400 × 30 nm (oil spheres) and narrower size distribution of the same nanoplates (blue spheres). Adapted from ref. 25 with permission from the American Chemical Society, copyright 2010. |
In 2019 Rubio-Giménez et al.27,28 prepared nanocrystals with the formula [Fe(py)2Pt(CN)4]29 (Fig. 2a) in different sizes (41 and 129 nm) and its bulk analogue (46 μm) observing the same trend in their magnetic response (Fig. 2). It is worth mentioning that in this case the nanoparticles were not synthesized by the reverse micelle method but with direct synthesis.
Fig. 2 (a) Grid-like layers of [Fe(py)2Ni(CN)4] along the b axis; color code: Fe, red; Pt, turquoise; N, blue; C, grey; (b) the effect of downsizing of [Fe(py)2Ni(CN)4] on the magnetic susceptibility. Adapted from ref. 28, licensed under CC BY 3.0, published by the Royal Society of Chemistry. |
Further investigation of the 2-D system [Fe(py)2Ni(CN)4] was made also by Yang et al.30 in an effort to study the dependence of SCO properties on the morphology of the nanostructures. The reverse micelle technique was used in order to successfully prepare ultrathin nanosheets with a thickness less than 10 nm. Two water in oil microemulsions were mixed with the anionic NaAOT as stabilizer and n-octane as the oil phase. Slight modifications in the experimental process, such as varying reaction temperature/time and reagent concentration ended up in different nanostructures such as square plate-, cube- and box-like shapes. The magnetic susceptibility measurements revealed that the spin-transition is strongly influenced by the shape of the nanostructures as the hysteresis width decreases in the order of nanoplates (ca. 22 K), nanocubes (ca. 16 K), nanoboxes (ca. 4 K) and nanosheets (ca. 2 K). In the case of the two latter examples, the nano-effect is more pronounced accompanied by the weakening of cooperativity and diminishing SCO domain, due to the larger specific surface area. However, size distribution in the case of nanosheets could be an extra factor which might affect the character of spin-transition, adopting a continous shape of the hysteresis with higher than usual Tc.
The latter observation reported also by our group31 in another example of nanofabrication using the reverse micelle method. The synthesized 2-D SCO nanoparticles with the formula [FeII(2-mpz)2Ni(CN)4] (2-mpz = 2-methylpyrazine) were also synthesized by using two water in oil microemulsions with the NaAOT as stabilizer and n-hexane as the oil phase. High Resolution TEM microscopy (Fig. 3a) revealed that the nanoparticles adopt a platelet morphology with distinctive almost square faces between 300 and 600 nm. Fig. 3b shows the magnetic susceptibility measurements for the nanoparticles (blue solid spheres), as well as for the respective bulk material (black solid spheres). Although the bulk material presents a two-step abrupt hysteresis, the downsizing effect on this polymer leads to one-step gradual hysteresis with a much smaller width. This behavior is considered a common trend in 2-D and 3-D coordination polymers when a size reduction is present. Regarding the critical temperatures of the spin-transition for the nanoparticles, these are found to be between the temperature range of the hysteresis width of the bulk material. This behavior is closely related to the polydispersity and large size distribution of the nanoparticles.
Fig. 3 (a) TEM images of nanoplates of [FeII(2-mpz)2Ni(CN)4] and distribution of their sizes; (b) temperature dependence of the susceptibility data, in the form of χMT for the nanoplates (blue spheres) and the bulk crystal (black spheres). Adapted from ref. 16 with permission from the American Chemical Society, copyright 2019. |
Recently our group32 reported an extensive variable-temperature Raman study of these systems which certified not only the dimensionality of the polymers, but also the spin transition. Micro- and nano-sized samples were compared displaying alterations in their transition curves with the latter ones exhibiting smearing of the sharp transition implying the preservation of HS population in the low-temperature region and the persistence of LS population in the high-temperature region.
Rubio-Giménez et al.28 studied for the first time the effect of nanostructuration on the spin-transition in crystalline ultrathin films of the 2-D SCO [Fe(py)2[Pt(CN)4]. The authors optimized the LBL method by creating modifications in the synthetic procedure reported by Kitagawa et al.39,40 and this resulted in the fabrication of controlled thickness films with both higher efficiency and reproducibility. Fig. 4 shows the process of the ultrathin film fabrication on the SAM-functionalized Si/Ti/Au substrate. AFM and X-ray absorption spectroscopy (XAS) were applied for the investigation of the dependence of the SCO bistability on the downsizing effect in films with thickness in a range between 40 and 1 nm (30 to 1 layer). Fig. 4 depicts the SCO behavior of the ultrathin films analysed by XAS data and the correlation with the film microstructure. Raman and magnetic studies were also performed for the same scope but proved to be insufficient due to detection limitations of SCO under 50 nm (ref. 41–43) and 40 nm, respectively. From the XAS study it has been confirmed that the critical value of 10 nm is the marked limit below which the FeII centers cannot exhibit spin-transition. Downsizing below this critical value has shown a detrimental effect on the properties of the SCO ultrathin films, as the partially segregated crystallites surrounded by a matrix of FeII centres are blocked in the HS state. When the thickness of the film increases the crystallites coalesce into a homogeneous film resulted in a SCO behavior close to that of the bulk phase.29 Thus, the dependence of the SCO properties from the thickness cannot be attributed to a size effect, but to interparticle interactions which improve the cooperativity and reduce the residual HS fraction.
Fig. 4 (a) Temperature dependent XAS spectra for a 7-cycle [Fe(py)2Pt(CN)4] thin film; (b) temperature dependent of HS fraction for the 7-cycle film; (c) the dependence of the HS fraction on the number of cycles at 100 K; 1 × 1 μm2 AFM topography images for a (d) 2-cycles; (e) 5-cycles; (f) 10 cycles thin film. The microstructure of each film is represented below each AFM image. Adapted from ref. 28, licensed under CC BY 3.0 published by the Royal Society of Chemistry. |
Sakaida et al.44 moved on a more meticulous investigation regarding the information which can be extracted from variable temperature Raman Spectroscopy related to the monitoring of SCO in thin films from epitaxial growth. This time LBL method was used for the fabrication of various thickness films of the 2-D SCO [Fe(py)2[Pt(CN)4] applying a number of cycles from 20 to 150. Fig. 5 shows the comparison of variable temperature dependent spectra of different thickness films and that of the bulk material. From the graphics is obvious the downsizing effect on the SCO behavior. Starting from the bulk material as the crystallite size decreases the hysteresis is shifted to lower transition temperatures becoming less abrupt. Quite remarkable also is the fact that the thin-film form presents a residual high-spin fraction which is about 20%.
Fig. 5 The effect of downsizing using variable-temperature Raman spectra of bulk-Ptpy (black), film-Ptpy-150L (red), film-Ptpy-60L (cyan), and film-Ptpy-20L (blue). Adapted from ref. 44 with permission from the American Chemical Society, copyright 2019. |
Recently Bartual-Murgui et al.45 reported two new Hofmann-type 2-D SCO polymers with general formulae {FeII(pym)2[MII(CN)4]·xH2O}n and {FeII(isoq)2[MII(CN)4]}n (pym = pyrimidine, isoq = isoquinoline; MII = NiII, PdII, PtII) synthesized in the bulk form. Their respective Pt counterparts were chosen for the fabrication of thin films through the LBL method. Following the same bottom up approach Rubio-Giménez et al.46 had already reported the fabrication of ultra-thin films using the same optimized LBL method in order to study the influence of the different axial nitrogen ligands on the structural flexibility and charge transport properties of the films. However, in this work an intensive structural and magnetic analysis was followed for the crystalline bulk materials showing that both series exhibit strong cooperative thermal induced SCO properties. In the case of films their SCO behavior was investigated through magnetization measurements and then compared with the corresponding samples of the already reported 2-D SCO [Fe(py)2[Pt(CN)4] polymer. Although different cycles for the fabrication of the three films were applied -60 for the FepyPt and 90 for FepymPt and FeisoqPt- all showed that it is possible to monitor their SCO behavior. Fig. 6 shows the magnetic susceptibility measurements for FepyPt, FepymPt and FeisoqPt thin films displaying spin-transition. Downsizing of the primitive samples resulted in thin films where the appearance of the hysteresis occurs at lower temperatures than those reported for the corresponding bulk samples. Besides, it is clear that the FepyPt film presents an abrupt and complete hysteresis in comparison to the FepymPt and FeisoqPt films where a remarkable increase of inactive HS FeII centers is observed. The former exhibits an incomplete and asymmetrical hysteresis, while the latter a complete loss of cooperativity. This is due to the different growth mechanisms-developed for their fabrication- which affect severely their SCO properties. A further confirmation on the effect of SCO properties was given from the thermodynamic parameters extracted from simulation of the magnetization measurements when moving from microcrystalline bulk solids to nanometric thin films.
Fig. 6 Temperature dependence of the susceptibility data of the whole mass contained in the thin films and solid red lines present the results of the magnetic simulations. Adapted from ref. 45 with permission from the American Chemical Society, copyright 2020. |
Several years later Y.-H. Luo et al.49 reported the ultrasonic force-assisted liquid exfoliation of the bulk van der Waals paramagnetic material [Fe(1,3-bpp)2(NCS)2]2 (1,1,3-bpp = 1,3-di(4-pyridyl)propane) into single-layered 2D nanosheets displaying a two-step SCO behavior. The application of the LPE method is considered the first reported in the literature for a 2-D SCO FeII coordination polymer. Fig. 7a shows the crystallographic description of the rhombic-grid repeating unit of the 2-D sheets. Single-layered 2-D nanosheets have been fabricated from 3-D SCO van der Waals MOF, with thickness of sub-2.0 nm. From the downsizing aspect it is clear that the magnetic response changes from paramagnetic to a two-step SCO behavior while passing from the bulk material to the nanosheets (Fig. 7b). These hybrid systems might be promising for near infrared (NIR) light-triggered molecular switching applications under ambient conditions. In a recent report,50 three dimensional (3-D) nanoparticles were synthesized by combining the, previously mentioned, 2-D SCO FeII nanosheets with transition metal ions (CuII, AgI). The copper and silver ions were selected as they create strong coordination bonds with the sulfur atoms on both surfaces of the nanosheets. Further modification of the 3-D nanoparticles with loading of YbIII-sensitized hexagonal phase upconversion nanoparticles (UCNPs) was led to an aqueous colloidal suspension with characteristics such as stability, nontoxicity and environmentally friendly behavior. These elements are considered challenging for NIR light-activated molecular conversion under environmental conditions.
Fig. 7 (a) 2-D sheets are generated by the rhombic-grid unit of (4, 4) Fe(1, 3-bpp)2 color code: Fe, red; N, purple; S yellow; C, grey; (b) temperature dependence of the susceptibility data, in the form of χMT, of the exfoliated flakes (blue cycles) and the bulk crystals (black cycles) along with the temperature dependent color changes. Adapted from ref. 49 with permission from the American Chemical Society, copyright 2018. |
Another example of an exfoliated 2-D SCO material using the LPE method is the polymer [Fe(L1)2](ClO4)2 (L1 = tris(2-(1H-tetrazol-1-yl)ethyl)amine) reported by Suarez-Garcia et al.51 In this case delamination of crystals from the 2-D SCO FeII polymer resulted in the formation of flakes with controlled thicknesses, down to 1–2 nm after 12 hours of sonication. Fig. 8a–c shows the crystallographic description of the 2-D polymer and the packing of the 2-D sheets along the b-axis. Various spectroscopic techniques and theoretical study revealed that the flakes retain their chemical identity upon size reduction. Magnetic measurements and temperature dependent absorption spectra outlined that the flakes also preserve the SCO behavior of the bulk state as their size is close to single molecule level (Fig. 8b). From the aspect of their integration in switchable devices, it is interesting to note that the flakes can be stabilized as an aqueous colloidal dispersion for an appreciable time period and then can be deposited on various solid substrates targeting to the formation of thermochromic thin films.
Fig. 8 (a) The tris-tetrazole ligand (L1); (b) the representation of the FeN6 chromophore in [Fe(L1)2](ClO4) where Fe(II) is shown as a red sphere; (c) packing of the 2D sheets along the b-axis; (d) temperature dependence of the susceptibility data, in the form of χMT, of the exfoliated flakes (orange) and the crystals (blue) confirming the spin transition phenomenon. Adapted from ref. 50 with permission from the American Chemical Society, copyright 2018. |
We sincerely hope that the pioneering work of the researchers in the area of 2-D SCO nanomaterials become an inspiration pole for the scientific community to envisage their technological potential.
P. G. acknowledges the financial support by “K. Karatheodori” 2017 research grant (no. 80623) of the University of Patras.
The authors acknowledge the assistance provided by the Research Infrastructure NanoEnviCz, supported by the Ministry of Education, Youth and Sports of the Czech Republic under Project No. LM2018124. The work was also supported by the ERDF/ESF project “Nano4Future” Development of pre-applied research in nanotechnology and biotechnology (no. CZ.02.1.01/0.0/0.0/17_048/0007323).
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2021 |