Emre
Güzel
ab,
Diana-Paola
Medina
a,
María
Medel
a,
Mehmet
Kandaz§
ac,
Tomás
Torres
*ade and
M. Salomé
Rodríguez-Morgade
*ad
aDepartamento de Química Orgánica Universidad Autónoma de Madrid Cantoblanco, 28049 Madrid, Spain. E-mail: salome.rodriguez@uam.es; tomas.torres@uam.es
bDepartment of Fundamental Sciences, Faculty of Technology Sakarya University of Applied Sciences, Sakarya, Turkey
cDepartment of Chemistry, Sakarya University, TR-54100 Adapazarı, Sakarya, Turkey
dInstitute for Advanced Research in Chemical Sciences (IAdChem) Universidad Autónoma de Madrid Cantoblanco, 28049 Madrid, Spain
eInstituto Madrileño de Estudios Avanzados (IMDEA)-Nanociencia c/Faraday, 9 Cantoblanco, 28049 Madrid, Spain
First published on 17th May 2021
A method to prepare key synthetic intermediates of ABAB- and ABAC-phthalocyanines and other tetraazaporphyrin analogues of interest for molecular electronics is described. These intermediates consist of ABAB-tetraazaporphyrins wherein the two B-subunits are endowed with iodine substituents at the meta-positions, whereas the substitution of the A-subunits is not conditioned to sterically demanding ortho-substituents, but rather can include a variety of functional groups at meta- or ortho-positions. The synthetic procedure includes the assembly of an ABAB tetraazaporphyrin by crossover cyclotetramerization of 5(6)-nitro-1,1,3-trichloroisoindolenine with a diiminoisoindoline or diiminopyrroline derivative, followed by a three-step conversion of the two peripheral nitro groups into iodine substituents. The effectiveness of the method is based on two principles. On one hand, the inability of the trichloroisoindolenine derivative to self-condense, together with the mild reaction conditions, favors the preferential formation of an ABAB derivative, without conditioning the substitution at the pyrroline or isoindoline A-precursor. On the other hand, the opposite diiodo-tetraazaporphyrin can be easily functionalized through a variety of metal-catalyzed cross-coupling reactions, thus being a valuable synthetic intermediate for ABAB and ABAC tetraazaporphyrins. A molecularly engineered phthalocyanine-like dye, which features the prototypical structure of a donor–π-bridge–acceptor, was prepared using this method.
In the literature, there is a very limited number of methods to prepare non-uniformly substituted tetraazaporphyrins. The main obstacle lies in the scarce number of synthetic intermediates, which often constitute unstable species and offer a very limited variety of substitution patterns. Furthermore, their use does not necessarily provide acceptable yields of unsymmetric macrocycles either.3 This is in stark contrast with porphyrins, for which useful dipyrrolic or tripyrrolic synthetic intermediates have been developed. However, for phthalocyanines or porphyrazines containing two types of substitution A and B, crossover cyclotetramerization of two differently functionalized phthalonitrile, maleonitrile, diiminoisoindoline or diiminopyrroline precursors constitutes the most widely used synthetic procedure. The latter affords a mixture of six compounds wherein four of them constitute non-uniformly substituted tetraazaporphyrins (the so-called AAAB, AABB, ABAB and ABBB tetraazaporphyrins) and the other two are symmetric macrocycles (AAAA and BBBB).3
The yield for each type of macrocycle depends upon statistical considerations,2 the relative reactivity of the two precursors bearing A and B,4,5 the used stoichiometry of reactants and the reaction conditions (i.e. metal template, solvent, temperature, etc.).6 The target unsymmetric compound is obtained in moderate-to-very-low yields (0–40% in the best cases) after a laborious chromatographic separation that is not always possible. Crossover cyclotetramerization is particularly inefficient to prepare the opposite ABAB-isomers as they are statistically unfavoured (theoretically 12.5% against 25% of the adjacent AABB-isomer).3,4,6 These elusive compounds can be prepared with reasonable yields by condensation of a trichloroisoindolenine derivative bearing B, with a diiminoisoindoline or diiminopyrroline derivative bearing A.7,8 Although the method is not fully selective, the trichloroisoindolenine precursor cannot self-condense and, hence, the number of products decreases to three (ABAB, AAAB and AAAA). The limited scope of this method constitutes its major drawback, as trichloroisoindolenine derivatives are very labile,9 and only unsubstituted7 or nitro-substituted compounds8,9b have really shown some utility. The other procedure to prepare the opposite ABAB-tetraazaporphyrins involves the use of phthalonitrile or diiminoisoindolenine precursors with impediments to self-condense, because they are substituted at the ortho-positions with sterically demanding A moieties, such as tert-butyl,6a isopropoxy,5 or benzene rings.6b,10 However, the non-formation of sterically constrained macrocycles (that is, AAAA, AAAB and AABB) depends strongly on the reaction conditions and does not always guarantee acceptable yields of the ABAB compounds.4a,6,10b
It is easy to understand, based in the preceding considerations, that tetraazaporphyrins with triple (A, B and C) or quadruple (A, B, C and D) substitution patterns are almost non-existent, as more than two types of precursors generate very complex mixtures in crossover macrocyclizations (more than 15 compounds for triple and more than 35 compounds for quadruple patterns), which are impossible to separate. To the best of our knowledge, only an ABAC-type phthalocyanine has been prepared by a cyclotetramerization reaction. The compound was obtained in 9% yield by the reaction of two different diiminoisoindolines bearing the B and C substituents, respectively, and a trichloroisoindolenine bearing substituent A.11 The other reported method to prepare ABAC-tetraazaporphyrins is based in the peripheral fabrication of a preformed ABAB macrocycle that contains reactive halogen substituents at the B subunits. This entails garnering important amounts of an ABAB precursor, a compound whose synthesis is problematic in itself. Nonetheless, there are some examples in the literature of preparations using palladium catalysed cross-coupling reactions at the halogen-functionalized opposite-isoindoles to afford the B and C subunits, while the A moieties contain bulky phenyl10a or 3,5-bistrifluoromethylphenyl substituents,4b respectively, at the ortho-positions. The latter proved to be essential for gathering sufficient ABAB precursor to work with. Again, the scope of these methods is very limited, since the design of other ABAC-systems is restricted to compounds containing 3,6-diphenyl- or 3,6-bis(3,5-bistrifluoromethylphenyl)-substituted isoindoles as the A subunits.
In this work we have overcome this limitation. Thus, we wish to report a divergent procedure to prepare ABAC-tetraazaporphyrins, wherein the A substituents arise from a diiminoisoindoline or diiminopyrroline derivative, while the B and C substituents originate from the different derivatization of two iodo-substituted, opposite isoindoles, in an ABAB-precursor. As demonstrated by us and others, iodo-substituted phthalocyanines can be used in a variety of palladium catalysed reactions such as carboxylation,12 alkynylation,13–15 amination,13,16 arylation,13,17 vinylation,15,18 or the introduction of phosphinic groups.19 In the present work, the ABAB diiodo-tetraazaporphyrin precursor is prepared by reduction of two peripheral nitro groups, followed by a sequential diazotization reaction and iodide coupling in a preformed opposite isomer. The versatility and effectivity of our approach depends on three important conditions:
(i) The use of trichloroisoindolenine derivatives in the method to prepare the ABAB precursors; this ensures definite reliability to obtain enough amounts of the opposite isomer, precluding the formation of the statistically favoured adjacent isomer, which is also difficult to separate.6b
(ii) The use of 5(6)-nitro-1,1,3-trichloroisoindolenine as a starting material; this compound is more stable and is easier to handle than other trichloroisoindolenine derivatives, such as alkyl- and halogen-substituted compounds, as proved before.9
(iii) There is a wide range of functional groups that can be introduced as the A-type substitution, since the latter arises from a diiminoisoindoline or diiminopyrroline derivative; the synthesis of these precursors by reaction of the corresponding dinitrile with ammonia is well established20 – indeed, just a quick search in Scifinder provides more than 440 of these derivatives, more than 150 of which are commercially available.
Therefore, we report here a convenient synthesis of ABAB-phthalocyanine analogues, endowed with two iodine atoms at the meta-positions of both opposite isoindole units. These compounds are intended to become general key precursors of highly asymmetric ABAC-phthalocyanines and other tetraazaporphyrins of interest in molecular electronics. As a proof of concept, we include the controlled synthesis of a push–pull, ABAC dibenzoporphyrazine, a molecularly engineered phthalocyanine-like dye, which features the prototypical structure of a donor–π-bridge–acceptor, in a linear arrangement. This type of disposition has been shown to be very effective in the design of dyes for dye-sensitized solar cells (DSSCs).4b,21
This afforded a mixture of free base porphyrazines, with 1 and the A3B benzoporphyrazine as the major compounds. The mixture was subsequently metallated with zinc(II) acetate (Scheme 1). The self-condensation of A to afford the symmetric A4 porphyrazine was almost suppressed24 most probably owing to the low temperature used for the reaction.25
The mixture of 1 and A3B was treated with sodium sulfide, affording the diamine 2 and the corresponding A3B monoamine, which were separated using column chromatography.8a Both 1 and 2 should consist of a cis and trans regioisomeric mixture of porphyrazines, owing to the unsymmetric nature of the 5(6)-nitro-1,1,3-trichloroisoindolenine. Indeed, the 13C NMR spectrum of this precursor (Fig. 2) exhibits eight different double resonances, indicating the presence of both 5-nitro and 6-nitro-isomers. Judging by the similar intensity of the two components for the eight signals, a ∼1
:
1 ratio of the regioisomers can be inferred. Conversely, the presence of the two regioisomers for 2 could not be confirmed by NMR.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 2 13C NMR spectrum of 5(6)-nitro-1,1,3-trichloroisoindolenine indicating the presence of the regioisomeric mixture. | ||
Porphyrazine 2 was subjected to a diazotization reaction by treatment with NaNO2 in H2SO4, to afford the corresponding bis(diazonium) salt, which was in situ converted into the diiodo-porphyrazine 3 by treatment with KI. The efficiency of this process was very much influenced by the stoichiometry of the reactants and the reaction temperature (Table 1). Thus, the yield of isolated 3 could be optimized up to 36% by using 40 equivalents of KI at a temperature of −15 to −10 °C.
:
4
:
5) ratio
A lower ratio of KI and/or higher temperatures led to different amounts of porphyrazines 4 and 5 (see Fig. 3), arising from the loss of one or both diazonium substituents under the reaction conditions. As indicated in Table 1, this side reaction could be minimized by carrying out the diazotization/substitution reaction under the above-mentioned conditions.
Compound 3 showed in 1H NMR a doublet of doublets at 8.47 ppm (J = 8.0, 1.6 Hz) that is attributed to HB (see Fig. S1, ESI‡). A second signal centred at 9.55 ppm is constituted by two overlying doublets (J = 1.6 Hz) assignable to HA, while two other doublets (J = 8.0 Hz) centred at 8.97 and 8.98 ppm, respectively, are assigned to HC. The splitting of the signals corresponding to HA and HC arises from the presence of the two cis and trans regioisomers for 3, which seemed to be in a similar ratio. Likewise, all the aliphatic carbons and seven out of the ten non-equivalent aromatic carbons showed split signals in the 13C NMR spectrum of 3 (Fig. S2, ESI‡). Separation of the two regioisomers using chromatographic techniques was not attempted for 3 and nor was it for any of the forthcoming regioisomeric mixtures. Using UV/Vis spectroscopy, the ABAB porphyrazine 3 showed a Q-band at λmax = 626 nm with a full width at half maximum of 32 nm (see Fig. 5 below). For the ABAB and ABAC porphyrazines 5 and 4, the corresponding Q-bands split into the corresponding Qx and Qy components, appearing at 651 and 615 nm for 5 and 643 and 618 nm for 4, respectively (Fig. S13 and S9, ESI‡).
The preparation of the related push–pull ABAC tetraazaporphyrin 12 is accessible by hydrolysis of the corresponding ester 11 (Scheme 2), which can be assembled using a three-step synthetic sequence from 3. The three-step sequence consists of the introduction of an ethyne linker by Sonogashira coupling on one of the iodo functions of 3, followed by functionalization with the electron-donor moiety 8 by Buchwald–Hartwig reaction on the opposite iodo substituent, and attachment of the electron-acceptor moiety 10 to the ethyne linker (Scheme 2).
The regioisomeric mixture of 3 was first subjected to a copper-free Sonogashira coupling with one equivalent of triisopropylacetylene, using Pd(PPh3)4 as the catalyst, in the presence of Et3N, affording the monoethynyl-substituted macrocycle 6, together with the disubstituted compound 7. Porphyrazine 6 was isolated in 37% yield after column chromatography on silica gel. Fig. 4 displays the aromatic region of the 1H NMR spectrum of 6, which appears as six sets of resonances between 8.1 and 9.2 ppm, corresponding to the six different nuclei, designated as A, B, C, D, E, and F in the figure. The presence of the two regioisomers is clearly evidenced by the splitting of each set of signals. On one side, three broad singlets at 9.13, 9.11 and 9.05 ppm that integrate for two protons correspond to the two A, A′ and D, D′ types of protons (Fig. 4). Two doublets at 8.92 and 8.85 ppm (J = 8Hz) that integrate for one proton are assigned to C and C′, by analogy to the precursor 3. The integration of this signal gives a 45
:
55 ratio for the cis and trans regioisomers, in line with our previous observations for the tetraazaporphyrin 3 and its trichloroisoindolenine precursor. B and B′ protons are observed at 8.26 ppm as a single doublet (J = 8Hz) integrating for one proton. The two doublets at 8.53 and 8.52 ppm (J = 7.5 Hz) are assigned to the F, F′ protons, while two doublets of doublets at 8.21 and 8.19 ppm (J = 1 Hz and J = 7.5 Hz) correspond to the E, E′ protons. The MS spectrum of 6 showed the cluster corresponding to the expected molecular ion at m/z = 951–957, accompanied by weaker ions at m/z = 1005–1011 and m/z = 790–795, assignable to 7 and deprotected 6, respectively, which could be present as traces, since they were not detected by NMR. HRMS (APCI+) confirmed the structure of 6 with a peak at m/z = 951.2724 corresponding to [M + H]+ (Fig. S18, ESI‡).
Compound 7 displays a simpler 1H NMR spectrum, with all the aromatic signals between 7.8 and 7.3 ppm, and a narrower multiplet (3.8–3.6 ppm) corresponding to the methylene protons directly attached to the pyrrole subunits. The molecular ion [M + H]+ appeared at m/z = 1005.5089 in HRMS (APCI+) (Fig. S21, ESI‡).
The donor moiety consisted of the diarylamine 8, which was prepared following reported procedures,26 and attached to the tetraazaporphyrin 6 by Buchwald–Hartwig coupling, giving tetraazaporphyrin 9 in 70% yield. The structure of 9 was assessed by 1H NMR and especially by HRMS (MALDI-TOF), which showed a peak at m/z = 1543.8604 corresponding to [M]+ (Fig. S27, ESI‡).
The benzothiodiazole accepting unit 10,21,27 was incorporated to 9 by deprotection of the ethynyl linker with TBAF, followed by a Sonogashira coupling with the bromo derivative 10. This afforded the push–pull tetraazaporphyrin 11 in 33% yield. Finally, saponification of 11, followed by treatment with hydrochloric acid afforded 12 in 70% yield. Compounds 11 and 12 showed in MS (MALDI-TOF) the clusters corresponding to their molecular ions [M]+ at m/z = 1656–1662 and 1642–1648, respectively. HRMS confirmed the structure of 12, with a value of m/z = 1641.7414, which matches the theoretical value for this compound (1641.7412) (Fig. S34, ESI‡). Based on the ∼1
:
1 regioisomeric mixture observed for the trichloroisoindolenine precursor and the tetraazaporphyrin intermediates 3 and 6, we assume that both compounds 11 and 12 consist of cis and trans regioisomeric mixtures, although this could not be confirmed spectroscopically.
Fig. 5 displays the absorption spectra in CHCl3 of tetraazaporphyrin 12, and its synthetic intermediates 3, 6, 9 and 11. Despite their non-symmetric ABAB or ABAC structures, all the compounds exhibit non-split, though broad, Q-bands.28 As a general feature, compounds 9, 11, and 12, containing the amine function (red and light- and dark-green lines, respectively, in Fig. 5), exhibit broader (full width at half maximum of 41–44 nm) and red-shifted Q-bands (λmax = 650–657 nm vs. λmax = 626–632 nm for macrocycles 3 and 6). This reflects the extension of the conjugation through the amine group.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 5 Normalized UV/Vis spectra of 3 (navy blue), 6 (light blue), 9 (red), 11 (dark green) and 12 (light green) in CHCl3. | ||
DFT calculations for the trans isomer of 12 were performed at the B3LYP/6-31G(d,p) level, using the GAUSSIAN 09 package.29 The frontier orbitals estimated for 12 are represented in Fig. 6.
As for the parallel porphyrin,21 compound 12 shows a high degree of orbital partitioning. Thus, the HOMO orbital is predominantly localized on the macrocycle and the donor moiety. By contrast, the LUMO orbital is fully localized on the accepting unit, showing a high density in the BTD ring. Hence, the HOMO–LUMO transition should have a considerable CT character for this regioisomer.
:
1 mixture of toluene/pyridine. The first fraction was collected affording a blue solid that was washed with methanol to give 46 mg (36%) of 3. 1H NMR (300 MHz, THF-d8): δ (ppm) = 9.55 (2d, J = 1.6 Hz, 2H), 8.98, 8.97 (2d, J = 8.0 Hz, 2H), 8.47 (dd, J = 8.0, 1.6 Hz, 2H), 3.9–3.8 (m, 8H), 2.4–2.3 (m, 7H), 1.3–1.2 (m, 12H). 13C NMR (75.5 MHz, THF-d8): δ (ppm) = 158.46, 158.38, 158.30, 158.21, 153.49, 153.40, 152.63, 152.51, 144.69, 144.64, 139.20, 138.69, 132.56, 124.95, 96.09, 29.09, 28.97, 26.57, 26.34, 15.31, 15.24. FTIR (KBr): ν (cm−1) = 3063 (Ar-H), 2956, 2865 (R-H), 1597, 1454, 1365, 1291, 1261, 1134, 1103, 1002, 897, 822, 760, 750. UV-vis (THF): λmax (nm) (log
ε (dm3 mol−1 cm−1)) = 639 (sh), 626 (3.90), 571 (3.19), 357 (3.63). MS (MALDI-TOF, DCTB): m/z = 896–901 [M]+. HRMS: m/z = 896.0248; calculated for [C36H34I2N8Zn]: 896.0282.
ε (dm3 mol−1 cm−1)) = 643 (3.61), 618 (3.76), 592 (sh), 566 (3.05), 352 (3.54). MS (MALDI-TOF, DCTB): m/z = 770–775 [M]+.
ε (dm3 mol−1 cm−1)) = 651 (3.52), 632 (sh), 615 (3.48), 595 (sh), 578 (sh), 559 (sh), 349 (3.53). MS (MALDI-TOF, DCTB): m/z = 644–649 [M]+.
ε (dm3 mol−1 cm−1)) = 644 (sh), 632 (3.87), 577 (3.18), 440 (sh), 358 (3.57). HRMS (APCI+): m/z = 951.2724; calculated for [C47H56IN8SiZn]: 951.2728 [M + H]+.
ε (dm3 mol−1 cm−1)) = 6.34 (3.98), 5.79 (3.32), 355 (3.68), 3.42 (sh). HRMS (APCI+): m/z = 1005.5089; calculated for [C58H77N8Si2Zn]: 1005.5096 [M + H]+.
ε (dm3 mol−1 cm−1)) = 650 (3.79), 598 (3.23), 362 (sh), 346 (3.67). MS (MALDI-TOF, DCTB), m/z: 1544–1550 [M]+. HRMS: m/z = 1543.8604; calculated for [C95H121N9O4SiZn]: 1543.8597.
:
1 solution (2 mL) was added, and the mixture was heated at 60 °C until all the starting material had reacted (4 h, monitored by TLC). After evaporation of the solvent at reduced pressure, water was added to the residue and the solution was extracted using CH2Cl2. The organic extracts were washed with water and brine and dried over MgSO4. After evaporation of the solvent, gel permeation chromatography of the residue, using toluene as the eluent, afforded 11 (6 mg, 33%) as a greenish-blue solid. UV-vis (CHCl3): λmax (nm) (log
ε (dm3 mol−1 cm−1)) = 657 (3.79), 600 (sh), 441 (sh), 414 (sh), 344 (3.68). MS (MALDI-TOF, DCTB), m/z: 1656–1662 [M]+.
:
2 mixture of THF/MeOH (2 mL), a solution of NaOH in water (1 mL, 20%) was added and the mixture was heated at 40 °C for 2 h. After cooling to rt, diethyl ether (5 mL) was added, and the solution was washed using HCl and water. The organic solution was dried (MgSO4) and the solvent was rotary evaporated. The residue was chromatographed on silica gel using DCM, followed by a 1
:
99 mixture of MeOH/DCM, affording 12 (4 mg, 75%) as a green solid. FTIR (KBr): ν (cm−1) = 2958, 2928, 2866 (R-H), 1726, 1716, 1683, 1668, 1558, 1456, 1374, 1230, 1064, 1038. UV-vis (CHCl3): λmax (nm) (log
ε (dm3 mol−1 cm−1)) = 650 (3.86), 600 (3.48), 4.52 (sh), 418 (sh), 346 (3.94). MS (MALDI-TOF, DCTB): m/z = 1642–1648 [M]+. HRMS: m/z = 1641.7414; calculated for [C99H107N11O6SiZn]: 1641.7412.
As a proof of concept, the controlled synthesis of a push–pull, ABAC dibenzoporphyrazine, containing a linear arrangement of the donor and acceptor fragments, has been prepared. This molecularly engineered phthalocyanine-type dye, which features the prototypical structure of a donor–π-bridge–acceptor, improves light-harvesting properties, and opens a route to push–pull phthalocyanine-like compounds of interest, for example, in DSSCs,10a,21 electrocatalysis,36 nonlinear optics,37 or amphiphilic chromophores for biological applications.38 We are currently applying the developed method to the preparation of regioisomerically pure compounds in related ABAC systems by examining the separation of regioisomers, in order to study their properties as photosensitizers in DSSCs.
Footnotes |
| † Dedicated to Professor Jaume Veciana and Professor Concepció Rovira on the occasion of their retirement. |
| ‡ Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: 10.1039/d1tc00990g |
| § M. Kandaz passed away in October 2017. |
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2021 |