Ralf H. Kerna,
Noemi Hillera,
Klaus Eichelea,
Hartmut Schuberta,
Christina Tönshoffb,
Holger F. Bettingerb and
Lars Wesemann
*a
aInstitut für Anorganische Chemie, Eberhard Karls Universität Tübingen, Auf der Morgenstelle 18, 72076 Tübingen, Germany. E-mail: lars.wesemann@uni-tuebingen.de
bInstitut für Organische Chemie, Eberhard Karls Universität Tübingen, Auf der Morgenstelle 18, 72076 Tübingen, Germany
First published on 27th March 2025
Boradigermaallyl, valence-isoelectronic to an allyl cation, stabilized by Ge-bound C6H3-2,6-(Trip)2 (Trip = 2,4,6-C6H2iPr3) groups shows triple insertion of ethylene into the Ge–B bonds (2) or an addition of styrene at the Ge atoms (3) followed by CH addition of a Trip methyl group at a GeB unit. Phenylacetylene forms two addition products (4, 5) with the GeB unit or both Ge atoms, which are also followed by a CH insertion of a methyl group. Under CO atmosphere the CH addition was prevented in the case of the phenylacetylene addition, and a CO adduct of this cycloaddition product (6) was characterized. Subsequently this CO adduct exhibits a CO insertion into the B–C bond and an α,β-unsaturated acylboron compound (7) was characterized. In the case of the anthracene addition to boradigermaallyl the observed CH addition was also suppressed by CO adduct formation (8). Biphenylene reacts with boradigermaallyl at room temperature under insertion of a boron atom into a phenyl moiety (9).
We introduced a chelating germylene A (Scheme 1) as a novel means of stabilizing chloroborylene.22 The GeBGe linkage extends the reactivity beyond that of typical borylene chemistry and it is thus an attractive system for the exploration of novel chemical space. Addition of boron trichloride to a bis(germylene) moiety followed by reduction of the bridging Ge(BCl2)Ge B unit results in a delocalized low valent boron compound with chloroborylene coordinated by two germylenes 1 (Scheme 1). Due to delocalisation of the boron electron pair into the empty p-orbitals of the germylenes a boradigermaallyl results. The electronic situation of this species is comparable with the allyl-cation and can also be regarded as a bis(germylene) adduct of chloroborylene exhibiting a high amount of π-back bonding from boron to the germanium atoms.22 High reactivity of the boradigermaallyl is documented by insertion into a C–C bond of benzene at room temperature.
![]() | ||
Scheme 1 Synthesis of boradigermaallyl 1. (a) Me2S·BCl3, (b) {(MesNacnac)Mg}2, [MesNacnac = {[(Mes)NC(Me)]2CH}−, Ar* = C6H3-2,6-(Trip)2, Trip = 2,4,6-C6H2iPr3].22–24 |
In this publication we present reactions of boradigermaallyl with the unsaturated molecules ethylene, styrene, phenylacetylene, anthracene, and biphenylene. For the phenylacetylene and anthracene reactions the influence of carbon monoxide is investigated. The coordination of CO at boron was found to suppress subsequent CH addition reactions. Furthermore, we present a rare example of isolation and structural characterization of both a borane CO adduct and the resulting CO insertion product.
Multiple addition of ethylene has been observed for a variety of main group element compounds: disilyne,26,27 digermyne,28–30 distannyne,31 silylsilylene,32 germylene, and gallylgermylene.33 In the cases of the digermynes and distannynes this addition is a reversible reaction. In comparison to the small ethylene molecule, an excess of the more sterically demanding styrene in reaction with boradigermaallyl (1) leads to product 3, which was isolated by crystallization at room temperature (Scheme 3, left). Compound 3 is the product of a single olefin addition at the germanium atoms of 1 followed by a CH bond activation of a methyl group of the Trip moiety by a GeB unit (see ESI† for molecular structure of 3). The resulting GeH unit shows in the solid-state structure an interaction with the boron atom to give a bridging Ge–H–B moiety. In the solution 11B NMR spectrum of 3 a signal was not observed.
The reactivity of the boradigermaallyl towards a CC triple bond was also evaluated in the reaction with phenylacetylene (Scheme 3, right). Two different types of colorless crystals were found after crystallization of the reaction mixture between 1 and phenylacetylene. By single crystal diffraction two products (4, 5) were characterized (see ESI† for molecular structures), but a further separation of crystals was not possible. Therefore, NMR characterization of 4 and 5 in the product mixture is not possible. Compound 4 is the product of an addition reaction between a GeB unit and the C
C triple bond. In the case of compound 5 the alkyne shows a twofold bond formation with the Ge atoms of 1. Like in compound 3, in both cases 4 and 5 a reaction of a CH unit of a Trip methyl group with a GeB unit was found to give a BCH2 and a GeH moiety. This GeH unit exhibits an interaction with the boron atom in the molecular structures of 4 and 5.
Based on the molecular structures of the reaction products of the styrene 3 and phenylacetylene reactions 4, 5 we assume that after addition of unsaturated organic molecules to 1 a triply-coordinate electrophilic boron species, having a Ge–B bond, is initially formed, which subsequently reacts with a Trip methyl CH unit to give the isolated products 3, 4 and 5. To prevent this undesired CH addition we added a weak Lewis base to the reaction mixtures to coordinate at the intermediately formed electrophilic boron atom of the presumed olefin or alkyne addition products. A strong Lewis base was not used because boradigermaallyl (1) was found to add MeNHC to the germanium atom.22
Thus, boradigermaallyl was reacted with the unsaturated organic molecules styrene or phenylacetylene under an atmosphere of carbon monoxide, which should react as a weak Lewis base and is known to form adducts with boranes (Scheme 4 and Table 1 C–I), but not with 1.7,34–40 Deduced from NMR spectroscopy, the styrene/CO reaction mixture with 1 resulted in a product other than 3, which however, could not be isolated. However, in the case of phenylacetylene we characterized a CO adduct 6 of the alkyne addition product (Scheme 4 and Fig. 2).
11B (ppm) | 13C (ppm) | IR (cm−1) | B–C (Å) | C–O (Å) | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
a H3B(CO) C,34 (F2B)3B(CO) D,7 (Cl2B)3B(CO) E,35 perfluoropentaphenyl-borole(CO) F,36 (CF3)3B(CO) G,37 (C2F5)3B(CO) H,38 [borole(MeNHC)(CO)]+ I [Ph* = 3,5-tBu2(C6H3)].39b ![]() |
|||||
C | 1.534(10) | 1.135(10) | |||
D | — | — | 2162 | 1.522(5) | 1.117(3) |
E | −20.7 | — | 2176 | 1.544(15) | 1.091(14) |
F | −16 | 166.4 | 2199 | 1.609(3) | 1.115(3) |
G | −17.9 | 159.8 | 2252 | 1.69(2) | 1.11(2) |
H | −16.4 | 160.3 | 2252 | 1.618(2) | 1.109(2) |
I | −18.8 | 169.5 | 2128 | 1.56(2) | 1.10(2) |
6 | −23.2 | 181.6 | 2077 | 1.492(5) | 1.139(4) |
8 | −21.4 | 173.0 | 2115 | 1.538(3) | 1.125(2) |
The best preparative results were obtained by first freezing the boradigermaallyl and phenylacetylene at −38 °C in cyclohexane and only allowing the mixture to warm up to room temperature after replacing the argon atmosphere by CO. Freezing prevents the premature, undesired reaction of both reactants with each other. The CO adduct 6 was isolated as colorless crystals in a yield of 70%. Phenylacetylene addition at a Ge–B bond was observed and the CH addition reaction was prevented. Compound 6 shows at room temperature a subsequent slow insertion reaction of the CO molecule into a B–C bond (vide infra). To avoid the CO insertion reaction, 6 must be stored at −38 °C. CO adducts of boranes are rather rare substances, and analytical data of these adducts are listed in Table 1.7,35–39,41,42
In the 11B NMR spectrum a signal at −23.2 ppm was observed for the tetracoordinate boron atom in 6. The literature examples of B–CO adducts were found to show 11B NMR signals at a comparably low frequency (Table 1). The stretching frequency for the CO group of 6 was observed in the IR spectrum at 2077 cm−1 (Table 1). The observed 13C NMR signal of the CO unit of 6 at 181.6 ppm lies at a slightly higher frequency in comparison to the published examples. In the molecular structure of 6 shown in Fig. 2 the carbonyl group exhibits the shortest B–C and longest C–O bond in the series of adducts, consistent with the smallest IR stretching frequency for 6 underpinning the tendency found for 6 to show the highest amount of π-backbonding to the CO molecule in the presented series (Table 1). Based on DFT calculations and NBO analysis the π-backbonding observed in the B–CO unit of 6 can be rationalized as an effect of hyperconjugation of the two Ge–B bonds into a π*-orbital.43–57
The bond lengths of the unsaturated GeBC2 ring (6, Fig. 2) can be compared with an intramolecular germylene/borane Lewis pair {[tBuC(NCy)2]GeC(Ph)C(C6F5)B(C6F5)2} featuring also a GeBC2-ring with a C–C double bond and only slightly different bond lengths [Ge–B 2.160(2), C–C 1.359(3), B–C 1.659(3), Ge–C 1.935(2) Å].58 The Ge–B interatomic distances in 6 are within the range of Ge–B single bonds found in the literature.59–62
Since the 1H and 11B NMR spectra revealed the slow formation of a new reaction product at room temperature in solution, a solution of 6 was heated to 50 °C for 44 h to complete this subsequent reaction more quickly (Scheme 4). The color of the solution changed from colorless to yellow and finally orange. The signal in the 11B NMR spectrum also changed from −23.2 to 10.1 ppm. Single crystals of 7 were obtained from n-pentane overnight, the molecular structure of which is shown in Fig. 2. The CO group is inserted into the B–C(vinyl) bond to give an α,β-unsaturated acylboron compound 7 while the chloride ligand migrated simultaneously from the germanium to the boron atom. The bond lengths in the α,β-unsaturated acylboron moiety [C5–C6 1.350(3), C6–C8 1.466(2), C8–B 1.605(3), C8–O2 1.275(2) Å] are close to the values documented for examples found in the literature.63,64 The oxygen atom of the acyl group exhibits coordination to the germanium atom O2-Ge(2) 2.0098(13) Å, which is comparable with acetamide [2.0145(14) Å] and carboxylate coordination [2.045(1), 2.043(1) Å] at germanium atoms.65–67 The Ge–B bond lengths in 7 are similar to single bonds between these elements.59–62 For a rare example of a borane–CO adduct and a subsequent carbon monoxide insertion, we can present the molecular structures and analytical data for both compounds, the adduct and insertion product. The observed reaction sequence (Scheme 4) can be compared with the findings of Piers et al. who described the reaction of pentaphenylborole with carbon monoxide to give a CO adduct at −78 °C, followed by room temperature ring expansion insertion of the CO group into a B–C bond.36 Carbonylations of organoboranes have been known for a long time and are important reactions in organic synthesis.68–70 These reactions were postulated to proceed by alkyl group migration from the boron atom to the carbon atom of the coordinated CO group.68,70 CO insertion into B–C bonds without detection of a CO coordination intermediate were reported for α-borylated phosphorus ylides, and zwitterionic titanium and platinum borate complexes.71–74 Using frustrated Lewis pairs (FLP) reactions of [HB(C6F5)2] with CO give formylborane, presumably via CO insertion into a boron–hydrogen bond.75–77 Aldridge and coworkers employed a trapping strategy to isolate a CO adduct of a BNB bis-borane FLP in reaction with tri(tertbutyl)phosphine. This approach revealed the reversible uptake of CO and the reversible migration of an aryl group (C6F5) between boron and the carbon monoxide carbon atom.78 Acylboranes represent an important target in organic synthesis and a variety of synthetic pathways have been established.79–81 However, coordination of carbon monoxide followed by insertion of the CO moiety into a B–C bond has not been developed as a preparative route for the synthesis of acylboranes.
Interestingly, computational analysis of the relative stabilities of 6 and 7 suggests that the observed reactivity is driven by the two bulky terphenyl substituents, and not the consequence of the inherent reactivity of the GeC2B(CO) moiety. Replacing the two bulky C6H3-2,6-(Trip)2 groups by hydrogen or phenyl results in 7 being higher in energy than 6 by 8 and 6–10 kcal mol−1, respectively, using different density functional methods without and with correction for London dispersion as well as ab initio methods (see ESI†).
Coordination of CO to preclude follow-up reactions can also be employed in other reactions of 1. Recently, we discovered that treating boradigermaallyl with anthracene results in a (4 + 3) cycloaddition followed by a CH addition reaction involving a GeB unit to give compound J (Scheme 5).22 In the presence of a CO atmosphere (Scheme 5), the (4 + 3) cycloaddition product of 1 with anthracene was isolated as a CO adduct 8 (Fig. 3) and the CH addition reaction was prevented. Storing compound 8 at room temperature gradually leads to the formation of product J after decarbonylation as determined by NMR spectroscopy. The 11B NMR signal at −21.4 ppm and the 13C NMR signal at 173.0 ppm found for 8 are close to the signals of 6 (Table 1). Together with the B–CO interatomic distances (Table 1) in comparison to 6 a reduced π-backbonding was observed for 8. The Ge–C distances with the anthracene molecule [C6–Ge1 2.0247(19), C9–Ge2 2.0243(18) Å] are only slightly longer than the distances between the germanium atoms and the other aryl-groups [C1–Ge1 2.0066(19), C2–Ge1 1.970(2), C3–Ge2 2.0084(18), C4–Ge2 1.968(2) Å].
We were also interested in the reactivity of boradigermaallyl towards biphenylene, as biphenylene has already been used for comparative reactivity studies against low-valent main group element compounds.82–87 Kinjo et al. reported an oxidative addition of a cyclic Al(I) anion into the weakest C–C bond, a bridging C1–C7 bond in the four membered cycle, of biphenylene (see Scheme 6 for numbering).83 The same group published the reaction of a dianionic dialane with biphenylene to yield a reduction product of biphenylene featuring a C–C bond split and formation of two Al–C bonds.84 Crimmin et al. found chemoselective C–C bond activation treating an aluminium(I) compound [{HC(CMeNAr)2}Al] (Ar = 2,6-iPr2C6H3)85 with biphenylene.86 In the first step of this reaction at room temperature a (1 + 4) cycloaddition intermediate was formed over 7 days, which was thermolyzed for 3 h at 100 °C to yield a mixture of two double aluminium insertion products into the less reactive phenyl moiety of biphenylene.86 Liu and coworkers reported an Al(I)-insertion reaction into a phenyl moiety of biphenylene at 100 °C treating an NHC-adduct of an aluminylene compound.87
When the boradigermaallyl was treated with one equivalent of biphenylene at room temperature a slow change in color was observed, shifting from turquoise to green and finally orange over the course of two weeks. Crystallization from n-pentane gave the insertion product in 65% yield. Boradigermaallyl does not show a reaction with the weak bonds of the four membered ring in biphenylene. In contrast to the low valent aluminium species (vide supra), which inserts at 100 °C into the phenyl moiety, the low valent boron compound 1 reacts with biphenylene at ambient temperature. Like in the aluminium insertion reported by Liu et al. boron splits the C3–C4 bond of biphenylene (Scheme 6 and Fig. 4).87
Compound 9 is reminiscent of the benzene reaction product of 1, exhibiting also insertion of the boron atom into the phenyl ring followed by (2 + 4) cycloaddition of a germylene moiety.22 The bond lengths inside the seven membered ring of 9 are comparable with the distances found in the boradigermaallyl–benzene reaction product.22 The signal in the 11B NMR spectrum was observed in the solid state at 71 ppm, very close to the signal for the benzene reaction product with 1, which was found in the solid state at 69 ppm.22
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. CCDC 2418123–2418130. For ESI and crystallographic data in CIF or other electronic format see DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d5sc00881f |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2025 |