Reham
Hassan
a,
Zirui
Zhu
a,
Mingyang
Ji
a,
Ziyuan
Meng
a,
Emily R.
Matas
a,
Damu
Sunilkumar
b,
Dario
Palmieri
b,
Benjamin A.
Conrad
a,
Thomas J.
Magliery
*a and
Jon R.
Parquette
*a
aDepartment of Chemistry and Biochemistry, The Ohio State University, 100 W. 18th Ave., Columbus, Ohio 43210, USA. E-mail: parquette.1@osu.edu; magliery.1@osu.edu
bA Department of Cancer Biology and Genetics, The Ohio State University, Wexner Medical Center and The James Comprehensive Cancer Center, 460 W. 12th Avenue, Columbus, OH 43210, USA
First published on 21st August 2025
A camptothecin (CPT)-dilysine nanotube, stabilized with a layer of polydopamine (PDA), was functionalized on the surface with anti-TAG-72 antibody fragments. Cell viability studies showed that the presence of the targeting anti-TAG-72 scFv significantly enhanced cytotoxicity against TAG-72 positive, LS-174T colon cancer cells, compared with HT-29 cells negative for the antigen.
The active targeting of solid tumors remains as a critical unmet need for most types of cancer.10 Targeted modalities include antibody monotherapy, antibody drug conjugates (ADCs),11 radioimmunotherapy,12 and chimeric antigen receptor (CAR) T-cell therapy.13 All are limited most by the properties of the molecular targets; there are few markers that are pervasively present on cancer cells in large amounts but are absent in normal tissues.14 At best, most are elevated in cancer, putting a floor on the toxicity of a targeted approach. Those that are most selective tend to be applicable to only a small range of tumors, such as HER2 with breast and gastric cancer.15 For many modalities, like most ADCs and radiotherapies, internalization is essential, and not all receptors are internalized. Conjugating chemotoxic agents or radionuclides requires modifications that often compromise the targeting or physical properties of the antibody. However, ADCs must have specific and high-affinity binding to a suitable, internalized receptor, and drug conjugation has proven challenging both in preserving the antibody and in effective release. A broad range of solid tumors, including most adenocarcinomas like colorectal cancer, pancreatic cancer, and ovarian cancer, have no identified agents that meet the criteria.16 Tumor associated glycoprotein (TAG)-72 is a mucinous cell-surface glycoprotein that is associated with nearly all adenocarcinomas, but is essentially absent in normal human tissue, making it an excellent targeting molecule.17 It is shed into the extracellular matrix and some, but little, can be found in the blood, because of the viscous properties of the molecule. TAG-72 does not appear to be internalized, limiting its use as an ADC target, but its accumulation in the tumor matrix makes it excellent for imaging and tumor localization.
Nanoparticle platforms must be modular with respect to size, charge and surface properties because these factors impact the in vivo stability, circulation time, clearance and tumor penetration.18 Additionally, they must remain stable at very low therapeutic concentrations in a rapidly fluctuating, extracellular environment containing salts, serum albumins and the potential for enzymatic degradation.19,20 We have previously shown that the stability of self-assembled nanostructures was significantly enhanced by polymerization of a thin, conformal coating of polydopamine (PDA) onto the surface.21 The PDA surface coating exhibits inherent reactivity toward nucleophilic groups,22 which allows for covalent and ionic bonds to form during the coating process and offers the potential for post-polymerization surface functionalization.23 In this work, we incorporated a single chain variable fragment (scFv) based on the anti-TAG-72 antibody 3E8,24,25 which is fully humanized and optimized for binding, onto the surface of PDA-coated nanotubes constructed from a dipeptide conjugated to the antitumor topoisomerase I inhibitor camptothecin (CPT) (Fig. 1).
![]() | ||
Fig. 1 PDA-coated, CPT-nanotubes with scFv anti-TAG-72 antibody fragments noncovalently bound on the surface showing hydrolysis of ester linkage and CPT release. |
The CPT-nanotube was created by the self-assembly of dipeptide KK(CPT)-NH2 (CPT-KK) in PBS (10 mM) for 24 h.26 To enhance the stability and to permit surface binding, the nanotubes were coated with a layer of PDA deposited on the surface by the in situ polymerization of dopamine (DA) at pH 7.4 (PBS).27 The slightly basic pH of PBS was sufficient to promote the oxidative self-polymerization of dopamine.28,29 Therefore, to deposit a conformal coating of PDA on the surface of the nanofibers, a solution of pre-assembled CPT-nanotubes (10 mM, PBS, 24 h) was treated with varying amounts of dopamine hydrochloride (DA) and aged for 24 h. The optimal DA:
CPT-KK ratio of 5
:
1 was identified by the appearance of PDA nanoparticles in TEM images after deposition at higher ratios, due to excess DA polymerizing in solution (Fig. S1).30 Comparing TEM images of the nanotubes before and after PDA deposition (CPT-KK and DA/CPT-KK) did not permit confirmation of the surface coating, due to the wide range of diameter dimensions (80–120 nm) of the starting CPT-KK nanotubes (Fig. 2a and b). However, a clear increase in the AFM cross-sectional height profiles from ∼4 to ∼6.6 nm could be observed after PDA deposition. This height increase indicated a 1.3 nm increase in wall thickness, as the AFM heights reflected twice the wall dimensions of the collapsed double wall of the nanotube structure. To further probe the structure of the PDA-coated nanotubes by XPS, a sample was pelleted by centrifugation (12
100g) to remove any remaining PDA nanoparticles. The C1S spectra of CPT-KK and DA/CPT-KK were fitted to five components assigned to C–C(H) at 285 eV, C–OH/C–N at 286.05 eV, N–C
O at 287.18 eV, O−C
O at 288.4 eV, and CF3 at 292.5 eV (from CF3CO2− peptide counterions). Comparison of the CPT-KK and DA/CPT-KK spectra revealed a decrease in the N–C
O peak (12.0 to 8.2%) and an increase in the C–OH/C–N peak 21.8% to 30.8% after deposition, as expected for the structure of PDA (Fig. S2).22
Many of the factors of nanoparticle delivery, such as biodistribution, circulation time, and cellular uptake, critically depend on size, particularly length.31–33 Ultrasound-induced shear has been shown to efficiently disperse aggregates and to cut polymers,34 carbon nanotubes (CNTs)35,36 and self-assembled nanostructures37 into smaller fragments. Therefore, sonication was investigated as a strategy to modulate the length of the nanotubes. Deposition of the PDA coating on the surface did not alter the length distribution of the CPT-KK nanotubes (Fig. S3). However, sonication (37.5 W, 1 min) of the uncoated CPT-KK nanotubes induced elongation of the nanotubes, whereas the same treatment of the PDA-coated nanotubes significantly shortened the nanotubes (Fig. 2c–d, S4). This contrasting behavior emerged from the ability of sonication to induce self-assembly, which would more profoundly impact the dynamic structures of the CPT-KK nanotubes, compared the static PDA-coated system.38 Importantly, the shortened state of the coated nanotubes persisted, even after 1 week in PBS (10 mM) (Fig. S5). The dynamic structures of self-assembled materials often allow the fragmented structures to regain the prior elongated state. We previously observed that nanotube fragments, shortened by sonication, could be stabilized by polymer-wrapping to slow the self-healing process.39 Thus, the stability, with respect to elongation, of the shortened states could be attributed to the PDA coating.
Drug release from the PDA-coated nanotubes requires hydrolytic cleavage of the 20-O-succinyl linkage. Previously, we found that intact CPT-KK nanotubes sequestered the CPT molecules within the hydrophobic walls of the nanotube, thereby rendering the hydrolytic release of CPT, under neutral conditions in PBS, concentration dependent.26,40 Furthermore, the noncovalent nature of the interactions that stabilize the nanotube structure could be disrupted under physiological conditions. For example, human serum albumin, which is abundant in human serum, has potential to destabilize the nanotubes, leading to more rapid hydrolytic drug release. These factors, along with the presence of hydrolases, would be expected to impact the rate of drug release. The conformal layer of PDA on the CPT-peptide nanotubes stabilized (CMC values of 11 μM for DA/CPT-KKversus 41 μM for CPT-KK) the nanotubes at low concentrations in PBS (Fig. S6). Thus, the presence of the PDA coating could be expected to partially inhibit the rate of CPT release from the nanotubes. To evaluate the impact of the PDA coating, the release rates of CPT-KK and DA/CPT-KK were measured by HPLC in PBS and HS at 37 °C (Fig. S7–S10). Overall, the PDA coating slightly decreased the release rate compared with the uncoated nanotubes. For example, after incubating in PBS for 83 h at 100 μM, CPT-KK and DA/CPT-KK released 71% and 57% of the drug, respectively. Hydrolytic degradation and CPT release was significantly faster for both CPT-KK and DA/CPT-KK in human serum (HS) at 37 °C, releasing 92% and 73% of the drug in 7 h, respectively.41 These experiments confirm that the presence of the PDA coating only modestly reduced the release rate of CPT, compared with uncoated CPT-KK nanotubes.
The surface of the PDA-coated nanotubes was noncovalently functionalized with an scFv of the anti-TAG-72 antibody 3E8, to enhance efficacy against cancer cells positive for TAG-72. The PDA layer exhibits inherent reactivity toward nucleophilic groups, such as amines and thiols, due to the presence of electrophilic catechol quinone components of the coating.22 This reactivity, along with hydrophobic effects, hydrogen-bonding and ionic interactions, offers the potential to bind the 3E8 scFv on the PDA surface.23 At a pH of 7.4 in PBS, electrostatic interactions would not significantly contribute to binding due to the low ζ-potential (6.4 mV) of the DA/CPT-KK nanotubes. To qualitatively assess the binding of the scFv to the nanotubes, we carried out structured illumination microscopy (SIM) of a sample of DA/CPT-KK incubated with fluorescein-labeled scFv after filtration to remove unbound antibody. The nanotubes were then imaged under excitation at 405 and 488 nm, to visualize the CPT within the nanotubes and fluorescein-labelled scFv, respectively. The 405 nm laser only partially overlaps with CPT absorption (λmax ∼360 nm), resulting in relatively weak emission of the nanotubes in the SIM images. As shown in Fig. 3, emission signals were detected when DA/CPT-KK (without scFv) was excited in the 405 nm (DAPI), but not in the 488 nm (GFP) channel. In contrast, excitation of DA/CPT-KK, after incubation with 3E8, produced images in both the 405 and 488 nm channels that colocalized when the images were overlayed. These experiments confirmed that the fluorescent 3E8 scFv co-localized with the nanotubes (Fig. 3) upon binding to the PDA surface of the nanotubes.
To estimate the affinity of the scFv for the nanotubes, we incubated the fluorescein-labeled scFv (2.5 μM) with a range of concentrations of DA/CPT-KK, from 312.5 μM to 15 mM (with respect to CPT-KK monomer). The solutions were then filtered and washed to remove unbound antibody. Direct measurement of the fluorescein emission appeared to be much less than the balance of what was in the filtrate, likely due to quenching by the nanotubes. Therefore, we estimated the amount bound from the difference between the input and filtrate. A 1:
1 binding model suggested a KD of about 2.1 mM, but a higher Hill coefficient value of nH = 2.4 provided the best fit, suggesting some cooperativity of binding (Fig. S11). Together, these results suggest relatively weak binding, consistent with the non-specific nature of the interaction, but persistent interactions that may be due to the large interaction surface (Fig. S12 and S13).
Cell viability studies showed that the presence of the targeting anti-TAG-72 scFv (3E8) on the nanotube surface significantly enhanced cytotoxicity against LS-174T colon cancer cells, which are positive for the TAG-72 antigen,42 compared with HT-29 cells, which are thought to be negative for the antigen.43 For example, the IC50 values at 96 h, measured by MTT assay, of DA/CPT-KK and DA/CPT-KK-3E8 were 90 ± 10 and 42 ± 5 nM (p = 0.01), against LS-174T; and 250 ± 30 and 170 ± 90 nM (p = 0.23) against HT-29 cells, respectively. The presence of 3E8 scFv on the nanotube surface did not produce a statistically significant increase the cytotoxicity against HT-29 (p > 0.05), but it markedly increased toxicity against LS-174T (p < 0.05) (Fig. 4). As expected, exposure of both cell lines to 3E8 scFv alone showed no toxicity after 96 h, and free CPT alone was more cytotoxic. We also examined the growth of these two cell lines in the presence of DA/CPT-KK with and without 3E8 scFv by live cell imaging (Incucyte, Fig. S14). At multiple concentrations, HT-29 growth was unaffected by the presence of 3E8 scFv, but LS-174T showed slower growth in its presence. These data suggest that 3E8 scFv increased the effective concentration of the CPT nanotubes near TAG-72 positive cells, leading to targeted cell killing.
In summary, a modular therapeutic platform has been developed to deliver CPT to TAG-72 positive adenocarcinoma tumors. A self-assembled CPT-KK nanotube was coated with a conformal layer of polydopamine, resulting in a stable PDA/CPT composite nanotube with a 1.3 nm layer of PDA on the surface of the nanotube. The conformal PDA layer stabilized the nanotubes, allowing for the release of free CPT in PBS and HS, albeit at a lower rate compared to uncoated CPT-KK nanotubes. The adhesive PDA coating allowed for binding of the anti-TAG-72 scFv (3E8) onto the surface of the DA/CPT-KK-nanotubes, which showed enhanced cytotoxicity toward cell lines bearing the TAG-72 antigen. As TAG-72 does not internalize following binding by the nanotubes, it is possible that CPT enters the cell by passive diffusion after extracellular hydrolytic release. Work is ongoing to more fully understand how the nanotubes or CPT enters the cells.
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2025 |