Sachin
Gupta
,
Miroslav
Janata
,
Eva
Čadová
and
Vladimír
Raus
*
Institute of Macromolecular Chemistry, Czech Academy of Sciences, Heyrovského nám. 2, 162 06, Prague 6, Czech Republic. E-mail: raus@imc.cas.cz
First published on 12th July 2024
Synthesis of complex polymeric architectures (CPAs) via reversible-deactivation radical polymerization (RDRP) currently relies on the rather inefficient attachment of monofunctional initiation/transfer sites onto CPA precursors. This drawback seriously limits the overall functionality of the resulting (macro)initiators and, consequently, also the total number of installable polymeric chains, which represents a significant bottleneck in the design of new polymeric materials. Here, we show that the (macro)initiator functionality can be substantially amplified by using trichloroacetyl isocyanate as a highly efficient vehicle for the rapid and clean introduction of trichloroacetyl groups (TAGs) into diverse precursors. Through extensive screening of polymerization conditions and comprehensive NMR and triple-detection SEC studies, we demonstrate that TAGs function as universal trifunctional initiators of copper-mediated RDRP of different monomer classes, affording low-dispersity polymers in a wide molecular weight range. We thus unlock access to a whole new group of ultra-high chain density CPAs previously inaccessible via simple RDRP protocols. We highlight new opportunities in CPA synthesis through numerous examples, including the de novo one-pot synthesis of a novel “star-on-star” CPA, the preparation of β-cyclodextrin-based 45-arm star polymers, and facile grafting from otherwise problematic cellulose substrates both in solution and from surface, obtaining effortlessly ultra-dense, ultra-high-molecular weight bottle-brush copolymers and thick spatially-controlled polymeric coatings, respectively.
Reversible-deactivation radical polymerization (RDRP) methods, and particularly copper-mediated RDRP (Cu-RDRP) and reversible addition–fragmentation chain transfer (RAFT), represent powerful tools for precisely controlling composition, functionality, and topology of polymeric chains, enabling thus a straightforward access to unique CPAs otherwise unattainable with conventional polymerization techniques.19,20 In the key step of CPA synthesis via RDRP, a CPA precursor is decorated with specific functionalities, such as initiators in Cu-RDRP or transfer agents in RAFT, that predetermine the sites of the future polymer chain attachment or growth. The concentration and distribution of these sites within the precursor is essential for determining key CPA characteristics, such as grafting density in graft copolymers or the number of arms in star polymers, and thus the (co)polymer's macroscopic properties and application prospects.3 Importantly, the current implementation of the RDRP strategy operates almost exclusively with monofunctional initiation/transfer sites, allowing for a maximum of one polymeric chain per site. Unfortunately, this inherent limitation is often further exacerbated by the inefficiency of the reactions used for the initiation/transfer site attachment and by the decreased initiation efficiency (IE) observed in some Cu-RDRP systems.21 Collectively, these shortcomings impose significant limitations on the total number of polymeric chains that could be installed onto a given CPA precursor, which is detrimental in applications relying on high grafting density14,22 and generally represents a clear bottle-neck in macromolecular design.
Cu-RDRP can potentially provide an elegant solution to some of these drawbacks in the form of multifunctional initiation sites. In multifunctional Cu-RDRP initiators (e.g., CCl4 or α-di/trichloro esters), more than one of the present carbon-halogen bonds can theoretically undergo activation by a copper catalyst, initiating the growth of multiple polymeric chains from a single carbon atom. In the case of CPA synthesis, bi- or trifunctional initiation sites could possibly be employed, providing instantaneous amplification of the functionality of the precursor-derived (macro)initiator. Interestingly, multifunctional initiators have been considered since the early days of Cu-RDRP but never achieved a widespread use.23–25 This can be ascribed to the uncertainty about the actual functionality of these compounds and also to the field's rapid adoption of active (monofunctional) brominated initiators, such as those containing the 2-bromoisobutyryl (BriB) group, that became the preferred choice in many Cu-RDRP scenarios, including CPA synthesis.14,26–30 A rare example of multifunctional Cu-RDRP initiator usage in CPA synthesis was the grafting from cellulose esters decorated with bifunctional dichloroacetate initiation sites reported by Vlček et al.31,32 However, while these pioneering efforts resulted in a comparatively higher grafting density, they suffered from two serious limitations. Firstly, the dichloroacetate initiator lacked universality, being successfully used for methacrylates only. More importantly, the grafting density was still seriously diminished by the typical inefficiency of the initiation site attachment that traditionally relies on the acylation of precursor's hydroxyl or amino groups with an α-haloacyl halide, whereby only relatively little initiator is often introduced despite using a large excess of the acylation reagent.14,31,33,34 While this issue is also relevant to small-molecule CPA precursors,34 it is particularly pronounced for macromolecular substrates such as cellulose where the supramolecular structure significantly diminishes the acylation efficiency,14,30,33 necessitating the development of elaborate, multi-step strategies to prepare densely-grafted products.14 Furthermore, the standard acylation protocols generate byproducts that need to be removed in a separate step via recrystallization/chromatography (for small molecules)34–36 or precipitation/extraction (for macromolecular precursors).14,32,33,37 In addition, long reaction times ranging from several hours up to a week are typically used in these transformations.13,14,35,38 Collectively, the described limitations have so far prevented the macromolecular community from exploiting the full potential of multifunctional Cu-RDRP initiating sites in CPA synthesis.
Clearly, several criteria have to be met in order to successfully amplify the (macro)initiator functionality through multifunctional Cu-RDRP initiation sites and enable thus the synthesis of CPAs with a severalfold higher number of polymeric chains as compared to current protocols. Firstly, the multifunctional initiation sites must be sufficiently universal, that is, applicable to different monomer classes, ideally under diverse polymerization conditions. Further, the IE should be sufficiently high with respect to both the entire (macro)initiator and the individual multifunctional initiation sites where activation of all the available carbon-halogen bonds should be feasible. Finally, the introduction of multifunctional initiation sites into CPA precursors must be considerably more efficient than with the contemporary acylation protocols.
Herein, we hypothesize that adducts of trichloroacetyl isocyanate (TAI) can potentially meet all these criteria. TAI is a commercially available in situ derivatizing reagent used in NMR spectroscopy to facilitate structural assignment of compounds bearing hydroxy,39–42 thio,43 and amino40 groups. In most cases, these moieties undergo rapid, quantitative, and uncomplicated 1,2-addition reactions with TAI, affording carbamate, thiocarbamate, and urea derivatives, respectively. The TAI method is also routinely applied for end-groups analysis in polymer chemistry.44–48 Besides 1,2-additions, TAI can take part in other reactions, which increases the diversity of CPA precursors it can modify (Scheme 1a).39,49 We propose here that TAI can be repurposed as a highly efficient vehicle for installing trichloroacetyl groups (TAGs) onto a variety of small-molecule- and macromolecular CPA precursors, avoiding the limitations of the traditional acylation approach. Importantly, several studies used TAG-bearing compounds as initiators for transition metal-catalyzed RDRP of different monomers,23,24,50–54 and there is limited evidence that TAGs can act as bi- or trifunctional initiators.23,53 Additionally, the utility of halo-isocyanates as initiating site precursors in the block and graft copolymer synthesis via free-radical polymerization has been recognized already in 1980s by Bamford and coworkers.55–59 As visualized in Scheme 1b, the unique combination of TAI reactivity and TAG multifunctionality could effectively amplify the CPA (macro)initiator functionality and provide thus an access to a whole new group of CPAs characterized by dramatically increased chain density and, potentially, new properties and applications.
In this study, we strived to firmly establish the TAI-based Cu-RDRP strategy as a powerful yet simple tool in CPA synthesis. To this end, we investigated and confirmed the considerable universality of TAI-derived initiators by identifying the polymerization conditions under which well-controlled Cu-RDRP of different monomer classes can be achieved. Subsequently, we used 1H NMR spectroscopy and triple-detection size-exclusion chromatography (TD-SEC) to prove conclusively that the TAI-derived TAGs act as inherently trifunctional initiators, which has a profound impact on the topology of the attained polymeric architectures and distinguishes the TAI-based strategy from earlier RDRP approaches. Finally, we provide examples documenting the strong points of the new strategy in various relevant scenarios such as the (one-pot) synthesis of star-shaped and branched CPAs, including a novel “star-on-star” graft copolymer topology, and the modification of otherwise problematic cellulose substrates yielding ultra-high-MW ultra-dense bottle-brush copolymers and diverse surface-grafted “2D” and 3D objects with unprecedented ease.
In the optimization study, we used methyl acrylate (MA), methyl methacrylate (MMA), and styrene as model monomers together with a model initiator, methyl N-trichloroacetyl carbamate (MTAC), that was readily obtained by the addition of TAI into dry methanol, followed by the evaporation of the methanol excess (Scheme 2 and S1†). We investigated two Cu-RDRP approaches, namely (conventional) atom transfer radical polymerization (ATRP)26,60 and Cu(0)-mediated RDRP [Cu(0)-RDRP],61 employing Cu(I) salts (CuBr or CuCl) and Cu(0) (activated copper wire) as catalysts, respectively. Note that Cu(0)-RDRP is sometimes denoted as single-electron transfer living radical polymerization (SET-LRP)62,63 or supplemental activation reducing agent (SARA) ATRP64,65 with reference to the expected polymerization mechanism; since we do not address the mechanism in this study, we opted for the generic term Cu(0)-RDRP. Me6TREN and PMDETA were used as ligands at different ligand/initiator ratios. Solvents of different polarity were tested to enable future application of the developed strategy to CPA precursors of different solubility. Temperatures ranging from r.t. to 110 °C were utilized depending on the targeted monomer. The monomer/initiator (M/I) ratio of 200:1 was used in optimization runs, with other M/I ratios subsequently employed under selected conditions. MW and dispersity values were obtained through size-exclusion chromatography (SEC) calibrated with appropriate standards.
In Table 1, we summarize the selected optimized polymerization conditions for performing MTAC-initiated Cu-RDRP of the model monomers, selected mainly on the basis of achieving high monomer conversion, low dispersity, and a reasonably good match between theoretical and experimental MWs. Numerous additional experimental conditions tested during the extensive screening process are then collected in ESI (Tables S1–S3†) and might be of use in specific cases, e.g., when a particular ligand/solvent combination is desired.
Entry | Mon. | Cat. | Solvent | Ligand (eq.) | M/I | T (°C) | Time (h) | Conv.b (%) | M n (theor.)c | M n (SEC)d | Đ |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
a Standard polymerization conditions: MTAC initiator; catalyst (cat.): 10 cm of activated copper wire in Cu(0)-RDRP, CuBr (1 eq.) in ATRP; ligands: tris[2-(dimethylamino)ethyl]amine (Me6TREN) and N,N,N′,N′′,N′′-pentamethyldiethylenetriamine (PMDETA); solvent/monomer (Mon.) = 1:1 (v/v). b Monomer conversion determined by 1H NMR (for MA, Fig. S2, ESI) or gravimetrically (for MMA and styrene). c Theoretical Mn calculated from the M/I ratio and conversion, assuming 100% IE. d Determined by SEC with poly(MMA) calibration (for MA and MMA) or polystyrene calibration (for styrene). e CuBr2 (0.2 eq.) was added as a deactivator, and the concentration of ligand was increased to account for this addition. | |||||||||||
1 | MA | Cu(0) | DMSO | PMDETA (0.2) | 200 | 60 | 4 | 96 | 16500 | 22200 | 1.19 |
2 | MA | Cu(0) | DMAc | PMDETA (0.2) | 200 | 60 | 24 | 98 | 17000 | 21100 | 1.27 |
3 | MA | Cu(0) | DMSO | Me6TREN (0.5) | 200 | 60 | 5 | 91 | 15700 | 21800 | 1.17 |
4 | MA | Cu(0) | DMSO | Me6TREN (0.5) | 200 | r.t. | 24 | 95 | 16400 | 20400 | 1.12 |
5 | MA | Cu(0) | Dioxane | Me6TREN (0.5) | 200 | 60 | 24 | 99 | 17000 | 22000 | 1.19 |
6 | MA | Cu(0) | Toluene | Me6TREN (0.5) | 200 | 60 | 24 | 89 | 15300 | 18600 | 1.19 |
7 | MA | Cu(0) | DMSO | Me6TREN (0.5) | 50 | 60 | 5 | 80 | 3700 | 4900 | 1.22 |
8 | MA | Cu(0) | DMSO | Me6TREN (0.5) | 100 | 60 | 5 | 89 | 7800 | 10500 | 1.18 |
9 | MA | Cu(0) | DMSO | Me6TREN (0.5) | 400 | 60 | 7 | 97 | 33500 | 48200 | 1.20 |
10 | MMA | Cu(0) | DMSO | PMDETA (0.2) | 200 | 85 | 3 | 87 | 17600 | 24700 | 1.27 |
11 | MMA | Cu(0) | DMSO | Me6TREN (0.2) | 200 | 85 | 4 | 85 | 17200 | 23000 | 1.20 |
12 | MMA | Cu(0) | DMSO | Me6TREN (0.2) | 200 | r.t. | 24 | 91 | 18400 | 25900 | 1.19 |
13 | MMA | Cu(0) | Dioxane | PMDETA (1.0) | 200 | 85 | 5 | 90 | 18200 | 26600 | 1.16 |
14 | MMA | Cu(0) | Toluene | PMDETA (1.0) | 200 | 85 | 24 | 95 | 19200 | 19600 | 1.12 |
15 | MMA | Cu(0) | DMSO | Me6TREN (0.2) | 50 | 85 | 4 | >99 | 5200 | 5900 | 1.27 |
16 | MMA | Cu(0) | DMSO | Me6TREN (0.2) | 100 | 85 | 4 | 90 | 9200 | 10900 | 1.25 |
17 | MMA | Cu(0) | DMSO | Me6TREN (0.2) | 400 | 85 | 7 | 93 | 37400 | 43700 | 1.20 |
18 | MMA | Cu(0) | Toluene | PMDETA (1.0) | 50 | 85 | 18 | >99 | 5200 | 5100 | 1.26 |
19 | MMA | Cu(0) | Toluene | PMDETA (1.0) | 100 | 85 | 18 | 96 | 9800 | 10800 | 1.22 |
20 | MMA | Cu(0) | Toluene | PMDETA (1.0) | 400 | 85 | 45 | 92 | 37000 | 33000 | 1.12 |
21 | MMA | CuBr | Toluene | PMDETA (1.0) | 200 | 85 | 22 | 90 | 18200 | 15500 | 1.12 |
22 | MMA | CuBr | Dioxane | PMDETA (1.0) | 200 | 85 | 24 | 88 | 17800 | 18200 | 1.09 |
23 | MMA | CuBr | Dioxane | PMDETA (1.0) | 50 | 85 | 18 | >99 | 5200 | 5000 | 1.21 |
24 | MMA | CuBr | Dioxane | PMDETA (1.0) | 100 | 85 | 18 | 85 | 8700 | 9500 | 1.13 |
25 | MMA | CuBr | Dioxane | PMDETA (1.0) | 400 | 85 | 45 | 70 | 28200 | 29700 | 1.11 |
26 | Styrene | Cu(0) | Toluene | Me6TREN (0.2) | 200 | 90 | 24 | 45 | 9700 | 10400 | 1.19 |
27 | Styrene | CuBr | — | Me6TREN (1.0) | 400 | 110 | 21 | 95 | 40000 | 45300 | 1.25 |
28e | Styrene | CuBr | — | Me6TREN (1.2) | 50 | 110 | 2 | 89 | 4900 | 6000 | 1.30 |
29 | Styrene | CuBr | — | Me6TREN (1.0) | 100 | 110 | 6 | 84 | 9000 | 10500 | 1.26 |
30 | Styrene | CuBr | — | Me6TREN (1.0) | 200 | 110 | 6 | 86 | 18100 | 21100 | 1.21 |
31 | Styrene | CuBr | — | Me6TREN (1.0) | 800 | 110 | 24 | 92 | 77000 | 75200 | 1.34 |
Our screening showed that MTAC-initiated ATRP (CuBr or CuCl as a catalyst) of MA was largely unsuccessful. Under host of different polymerization conditions, including different solvents, ligands, and temperatures, no polymerization was observed, or the achieved conversions were very low (entries 1–15, Table S1†). On the other hand, Cu(0)-RDRP catalyzed by Cu wire yielded low-dispersity polymers at high conversion under a range of polymerization conditions, including both polar and non-polar solvents (entries 1–9, Table 1; additional experiments in Table S1†). SEC elugrams of obtained polymers are provided in Fig. 1 and S3;† a kinetic experiment documenting the good polymerization control is shown in Fig. S4.†
Fig. 1 SEC elugrams of selected polymers prepared by MTAC-initiated Cu-RDRP at different M/I ratios. Product characteristics are provided in Table 1. The noticeable low-MW shoulder in the SEC elugrams of the polymers synthesized at the highest M/I ratios (400:1 or 800:1) in non-polar solvents/bulk are ascribed to the products of early termination or competing transfer reactions that tend to be more pronounced when aiming for high-MW products.66 |
Further, we demonstrated that the MTAC initiator works remarkably well for MMA, affording high conversions and low-dispersity products under a range of conditions, including both ATRP and Cu(0)-RDRP methods, different temperatures and solvents of different polarity (entries 10–25, Tables 1 and S2;† for SEC elugrams see Fig. 1 and S5†). A well-controlled character of the polymerization under the developed conditions was confirmed by kinetic experiments (Fig. S6–S8†). The high chain-end fidelity of poly(MMA) prepared via MTAC-initiated ATRP in dioxane was demonstrated by chain-extension experiments. To this end, poly(MMA) prepared at high conversion (Mn = 9 500, Đ = 1.13; entry 24, Table 1) was successfully used as a macroinitiator to initiate chain-extension with MMA and block-copolymerization with styrene, which is visualized by clear shifts of the corresponding SEC elugrams and the significant increases in MWs (Fig. S9†).
Finally, styrene was polymerized at 90 °C through a well-controlled Cu(0)-RDRP (in DMSO and toluene) and ATRP (in toluene); however, the process was rather slow (ca. 50% conversions reached). High conversions were achieved via ATRP in bulk at 110 °C (entries 26–31, Tables 1 and S3† for SEC traces see Fig. 1 and S10;† for kinetics see Fig. S11†). It is of note that Cu(0)-RDRP of styrene in DMSO and DMAc was plagued by gel formation on the copper wire. Such gel formation has been described previously for other Cu(0)-RDRP systems.62,67,68 Collectively, it is rather remarkable that MTAC is able to initiate well-controlled Cu(0)-RDRP of all three studied model monomers in toluene or dioxane because reports on successful Cu(0)-RDRP in non-polar solvents are extremely rare in literature.66,69,70
Next, to verify that the Cu-RDRP conditions established using MTAC are useable also for TAI adducts with other functional groups, we synthesized N,N-diisopropylamine/TAI adduct, 1,1-diisopropyl-3-(2,2,2-trichloroacetyl)-urea (DTAU) (Fig. S12†). DTAU-initiated Cu-RDRP of styrene, MMA, and MA was then performed under the optimized conditions from our library. The experimental results together with the corresponding SEC traces, collected in Fig. S13,† prove that very similar polymers are obtained irrespective of the linker connecting the initiating TAG fragment to the CPA precursor. This finding suggests that the developed library of Cu-RDRP conditions will be applicable to a variety of CPA precursors bearing TAI-reactive functions.
Having successfully identified polymerization protocols for model monomers, we next sought to investigate the universality of the developed conditions with respect to other monomers from the same class, including some important functional variants.71–73 To this end, we applied selected conditions to other (meth)acrylates, including functional ones (Table 2 and Fig. S14†). Although some of the (meth)acrylate analogues (expectedly) did not behave identically as the model monomers, we could easily identify conditions in our library providing well-defined products, which highlights the utility of the extensive screening approach we employed in this study. For example, butyl acrylate (BA) polymerized poorly in toluene (entry 1, Table 2) while quickly affording a well-defined product at quantitative conversion in a bi-phasic system35 in DMSO (entry 2, Table 2). Similarly, Cu(0)-RDRP of 2-hydroxyethyl methacrylate (HEMA) was uncontrolled in DMSO while affording a well-defined product in dioxane75 (cf. entries 7 and 8, Table 2). Further, for 2-hydroxyethyl acrylate (HEA), we obtained a well-defined polymer by using a lower ligand loading (cf. entries 3 and 4, Table 2). On the other hand, conditions originally developed for MMA could be directly applied to butyl methacrylate (BMA) and glycidyl methacrylate (GMA) without any changes (entries 5 and 6, Table 2). Taken together, the results confirm the considerable universality of TAI-derived initiators and manifest that our library of optimized conditions (Table 1) can serve as an excellent starting point when polymerizing other (meth)acrylates.
Entry | Monomer | Solvent | Ligand (eq.) | T (°C) | Time (h) | Conv.b (%) | M n (theor.)c | M n (SEC)d | Đ |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
a Standard polymerization conditions: MTAC initiator, M/I = 200:1, 10 cm of activated copper wire, monomer/solvent = 1:1 (v/v). b Monomer conversion determined by 1H NMR. c Theoretical Mn calculated from the M/I ratio and conversion, assuming 100% IE. d Determined by SEC with poly(MMA) calibration [directly (BA, BMA, GMA) or after acetylation74 (HEMA)] or by TD-SEC (HEA). e Biphasic polymerization mixture. f M/I = 100:1 and 5 cm of activated copper wire were used. | |||||||||
1 | BA | Toluene | Me6TREN (0.5) | 60 | 24 | 16 | 4200 | 4600 | 1.45 |
2e | BA | DMSO | Me6TREN (0.5) | 60 | 7 | 97 | 25100 | 35100 | 1.25 |
3 | HEA | DMSO | Me6TREN (0.5) | 60 | 8 | 50 | 11800 | 46500 | 1.37 |
4 | HEA | DMSO | Me6TREN (0.2) | 60 | 24 | 42 | 10000 | 15000 | 1.18 |
5 | BMA | Toluene | PMDETA (1.0) | 85 | 24 | 84 | 24000 | 20400 | 1.15 |
6 | GMA | DMSO | Me6TREN (0.2) | 85 | 2 | 80 | 23000 | 21400 | 1.23 |
7f | HEMA | DMSO | Me6TREN (0.2) | 85 | 24 | 99 | 13100 | 20000 | 1.85 |
8f | HEMA | Dioxane | PMDETA (1.0) | 85 | 1 | 99 | 13100 | 17200 | 1.28 |
To complement the results on TAG-initiated Cu-RDRP, we also performed a preliminary investigation into the hydrolytic stability of the TAI-derived carbamate linker present in most (macro)initiators used in this study. It can be expected that different TAI-derived linkers, connecting the initiating TAGs with the derivatized precursor, may show different hydrolytic stability/pH sensitivity. We envisage that the properties of these linkers could be potentially exploited in fields such as drug delivery where, for example, the use of CPAs featuring a pH-sensitive carbamate linker has already been established.76–78 Nevertheless, the situation can be rather complex as organic carbamates show very varied hydrolytic stability depending on their structure and experimental conditions.79–82 To get a preliminary insight, we studied hydrolytic stability of in-chain carbamate linkers in a poly(HEA) star polymer. As shown in Fig. S15† and in the accompanying discussion, the carbamate linker showed to be considerably resistant to hydrolysis in a wide pH range.
First, we used 1H NMR spectroscopy to evaluate the initiator functionality for model low-MW poly(MA), poly(MMA), and polystyrene prepared by MTAC-initiated Cu-RDRP. In the respective spectra, we identified the characteristic signals of the initiator fragment (the –OCH3 group) and the terminal (chlorine-bearing) and in-chain monomeric units. We then used the relative intensities of these signals, together with the polymer Mn value determined by SEC, to calculate initiator functionality, obtaining values close to 3 in all cases (for details see Fig. S17–S19† and the accompanying discussion). It is of note that the used poly(MMA) sample was obtained at quantitative conversion (entry 23, Table 1), confirming the high end-chain fidelity attained under the used conditions. Overall, our findings suggest that the MTAC-initiated polymers have the topology of three-arm stars. Consequently, our reported MW values obtained by SEC with relative calibration are slightly underestimated due to the smaller hydrodynamic volume of branched polymers. Additionally, the poly(MMA)-b-polystyrene synthesized above in the chain-extension experiment (Fig. S9†) should be considered as a 3-arm star with diblock arms.
Next, we wanted to verify that the trifunctionality of TAI-derived TAGs is retained also for high-MW CPAs (i.e. a real-world scenario). Since high-MW polymers are not amenable to the simple end-group analysis applied above, we selected a different approach based on the viscometric analysis of the initiation site-related branching using TD-SEC. We reasoned that a standalone TAG provides branching only if the initiator acts as trifunctional while its mono- and bifunctionality leads to a linear polymer.
As model CPAs, we prepared star-shaped poly(MMA) and polystyrene via Cu-RDRP initiated by the pentaerythritol/TAI adduct, pentaerythritol tetrakis((2,2,2-trichloroacetyl) carbamate) (PTAC) (Fig. 2 and S20†). Using TD-SEC, we then analyzed the parent star polymers as well as the individual TAG-initiated polymeric segments released from the pentaerythritol core via alkaline hydrolysis33 of carbamate linkers (Fig. 2). As seen from the data summarized in Table S4,† the poly(MMA) star showed low dispersity of 1.21, with the SEC elugram (Fig. 2b) featuring only a small high-MW shoulder, indicating negligible extent of star–star coupling despite the high monomer conversion of 92%. On the other hand, the polystyrene variant was comparatively less well-defined (Đ = 1.69), probably due to the presence of both the coupling products and free segments as suggested by the SEC elugram shape (Fig. 2c). Nevertheless, the low dispersity of the hydrolytically released star segments/arms indicated that well-controlled polymerization was achieved for both monomers.
Fig. 2 TAG functionality study: general scheme of the synthesis of model multi-arm stars based on a pentaerythritol core (a); elugrams – RI traces (b and c) and M–H plots (d and e) from the TD-SEC analysis of the synthesized poly(MMA) (b and d) and polystyrene (c and e) multi-arm star polymers and of products of their alkaline hydrolysis. Data for broad linear poly(MMA) and polystyrene standards are shown for comparison. See Table S4† for experimental conditions and results. |
Fig. 2d and e shows Mark–Houwink (M–H) plots for both the parent multi-arm star polymers and the hydrolytically released segments, alongside the data for broad linear poly(MMA) and polystyrene standards. In addition, the determined M–H α constants, which provide a good measure of polymer branching, are also displayed. While the broad linear standards provided the expected α ≈ 0.6, the considerably lower α value of approximately 0.4 obtained for the released segments confirmed branched character of these polymers and, thus, the TAG trifunctionality.84 Finally, the α values for the parent polymers, presumably 12-arm stars, are even lower (≈0.2), as expected for the comparatively denser polymeric architecture.84
Note that we performed also PTAC-initiated polymerization of MA (Table S4†); however, we were unable to cleanly release the individual segments using our alkaline hydrolysis method in this case. Therefore, in Fig. S21,† we provide only the TD-SEC analysis of the parent star polymer together with the comparison data for a broad linear poly(MA)standard. The same α constant as for the poly(MMA) star above (≈0.25) was obtained from the M–H analysis indicating a similar number of star arms and hence TAG trifunctionality also in this case.
First, we show that the strategy allows for the clean in situ introduction of initiation sites in multi-step protocols without intermediate isolation, which enables the one-pot de novo synthesis of graft copolymers that avoids the isolation/purification steps typical for standard approaches.14,32,33 To this end, we conducted a three-step protocol depicted in Fig. 3; for experimental details and results see Table S5.† First, we performed a MTAC-initiated copolymerization of HEMA and MMA (20/80 mol%) by Cu(0)-RDRP in dioxane, yielding a well-defined poly(HEMA-co-MMA) copolymer (Mn = 23400, Đ = 1.23) at quantitative conversion (Fig. S22,† top). Subsequently, we in situ modified part of the pendent hydroxyl groups in HEMA units by adding TAI (Fig. S22,† bottom). Finally, upon the addition of another batch of MMA and solvent, we continued the polymerization to yield the final graft copolymer (Fig. S23†). Owing to the TAG trifunctionality, the copolymer involves three-arm stars grafted from a three-arm star backbone, i.e., “star-on-star” architecture – apparently a novel type of CPA that structurally represents a hybrid between a star and a graft copolymer. The inflated dispersity of the final product (1.95) is mainly ascribed to the recombination reactions at the macroinitiator preparation stage where quantitative conversion was targeted (a high-MW shoulder in the SEC elugram of the macroinitiator supports this assumption). Nevertheless, TD-SEC analysis showed that the poly(MMA) grafts, removed by alkaline hydrolysis,33 were extremely well defined (Đ = 1.05), indicating a high degree of polymerization control in the grafting step. Note that there is a small lower-MW signal in the SEC chromatogram of the star-on-star copolymer. This signal is ascribed to the polymer initiated by the products of TAI reaction with present impurities (e.g., water). The M–H plots provided in Fig. 3 showed α values consistent with the expected topology of three-arm stars (for the macroinitiator precursor and cleaved grafts) and with the highly branched final star-on-star copolymer. Collectively, these results illustrate well that the TAI strategy opens avenues for unconventional approaches to the synthesis of graft and hyper-branched (co)polymers and enables designing of new CPA topologies.
Fig. 3 De novo one-pot synthesis of the poly(HEMA-co-MMA)-graft-poly(MMA) hybrid star/graft copolymer of “star-on-star” topology. (Top) General reaction scheme; for experimental conditions see Table S5.† (Bottom) TD-SEC analysis of products at individual stages – elugrams (left) and M–H plots (right). |
In order to highlight the utility of the TAI-based initiator functionality amplification strategy in the synthesis of previously inaccessible multi-arm star-shaped polymers, we conducted polymerization of MMA initiated by a β-cyclodextrin (β-CD)/TAI adduct (Fig. 4). The adduct was prepared by the reaction of pre-dried β-CD with an excess of TAI whereby the unreacted TAI was quenched with DMSO. The 1H NMR spectrum of the reaction mixture (Fig. S24†) confirms the full modification of the β-CD hydroxyl groups as well as the presence of the DMSO/TAI adduct and trichloroacetamide originating from TAI reaction with residual water. The latter two compounds served as low-MW sacrificial initiators.26,33,85 The SEC elugrams of the starting β-CD and the β-CD/TAI adduct displayed in Fig. S25a† show a clear shift of the sharp β-CD peak to higher MWs upon TAI modification. Afterward, the (macro)initiator solution was used to initiate ATRP of MMA in dioxane. Finally, the arms of the isolated star polymer were removed via alkaline hydrolysis for further analysis.
Fig. 4 Synthesis of multi-arm poly(MMA) stars through ATRP initiated by the β-CD/TAI adduct. (Top) General reaction scheme; (bottom) TD-SEC analysis (elugrams – RI traces) of samples taken at different polymerization stages. Experimental details are provided in Table S6.† |
The data shown in Fig. 4, S25b and Table S6† confirmed that the use of a sacrificial initiator represents an efficient strategy33 for suppressing the formation of intermolecular coupling products (visible as high-MW shoulders in SEC elugrams) even at the almost quantitative monomer conversion reached here. Both the star polymers and cleaved arms/free-growing chains were exceptionally well-defined throughout the polymerization course (Đ = 1.15 and 1.05, respectively, at 96% conversion). Additionally, there was an excellent match in Mn and Đ values evaluated for the free-growing chains (the low-MW signal in the SEC of the isolated products) and the mixture of the free-growing chains and the star arms obtained after hydrolysis (Table S6 and Fig. S25b†), proving that both the star arms and free chains grew at a similar rate. At the same time, the determined Mn values were considerably higher than the theoretical ones calculated from conversion and the MMA/TAI ratio. Collectively, these observations suggest that a part of the TAGs on the β-CD/TAI adduct did not initiate polymerization due to the extreme steric crowding at the TAI-modified β-CD while the remaining TAGs acted as trifunctional initiators, owing to the increased reactivity of the chlorine atoms remaining at TAGs that underwent initiation.53 Nevertheless, a simple comparison of the Mn values obtained for the final multi-arm star polymer and for the arms released therefrom suggests that one β-CD core bears approximately 15 poly(MMA) segments that actually are 3-arm stars on their own. Therefore, the product can be considered as a 45-arm star polymer, highlighting the clear advantage of the new strategy over the previous approaches based on monofunctional initiators that yield, at best, 21 arms from the same precursor in a much more laborious process.34,37
Next, we presumed that the high TAI reactivity will make the new strategy particularly useful in the synthesis of CPAs based on difficult-to-modify substrates. Herein, this is exemplified by the modification of cellulose that has been previously shown to be resistant to the introduction of high concentrations of Cu-RDRP initiation sites using standard acylation protocols.14,33 First, we studied the reactivity of cellulose (microcrystalline AVICEL PH-101) toward TAI in different solvents. We found that cellulose, dissolved in the traditional cellulose solvent DMAc/LiCl,86 could be easily fully modified with a slight excess of TAI (4 eq. toward the anhydroglucose units of cellulose) as documented by the 1H and 13C NMR spectra of the isolated adduct (Fig. S26†). Furthermore, overnight stirring of dioxane-activated cellulose86 in dioxane containing 4 eq. of TAI led to complete cellulose modification and dissolution. Similarly, the dioxane-activated cellulose afforded a clear solution of the cellulose/TAI adduct after 2 h of reaction with 6 eq. of TAI in THF. Moreover, we found that pre-dried, non-activated cellulose could be fully modified and dissolved when reacted with TAI (6 eq.) in acetonitrile for 4 days. Most importantly, we also revealed that cellulose becomes highly reactive toward TAI when the modification is conducted in DMSO, i.e., a solvent that strongly swells cellulose and increases its accessibility and reactivity.87 When 5 eq. of TAI were added to a suspension of non-dried (or pre-dried and soaked in DMSO overnight) cellulose in DMSO, a clear solution was obtained within 1 min. This finding is remarkable considering the reactivity of TAI toward DMSO and confirms that the modification of substrates in TAI-reactive solvents (e.g., DMSO or DMAc), as proposed by Samek et al.,39 is possible also for heterogeneous reactions with polymeric substrates. While we did not focus here on testing the universality of this modification protocol with respect to different cellulose types, we can confirm that the same rapid modification in DMSO was obtained also for a considerably higher-MW cellulose Sigmacell type 101. We thus envisage that this protocol may find important applications in the field of cellulose characterization where a similar but considerably more laborious approach based on cellulose modification with phenyl isocyanate is used for cellulose MW determination by SEC.88
Cellulose fully modified with TAI represents a unique macroinitiator that can potentially give rise to 9 polymeric chains per one backbone repeat unit, affording, upon graft copolymerization, extremely dense bottle-brush copolymers. To investigate this option, we synthesized a cellulose-graft-poly(MMA) copolymer via ATRP initiated by a cellulose/TAI adduct (Fig. 5). We first prepared a stock solution containing the cellulose/TAI adduct and MTAC as a low-MW sacrificial initiator by reacting cellulose (AVICEL) with 6 eq. of TAI in acetonitrile and subsequently quenching the excess of TAI by methanol. The TD-SEC analysis of the adduct revealed Mn of 106700 and dispersity of 2.17 consistent with the characteristics of the cellulose precursor (Fig. 5).86 Subsequently, we used the obtained (macro)initiator solution to initiate ATRP of MMA in dioxane. As can be seen from the experimental data collected in Table S7,† 27% conversion was reached in 5 h, which corresponds to the Mn(theor.) of 9644000, as calculated from the macroinitiator number-average degree of polymerization (DPn) of 147, assuming three TAI-modified hydroxyl groups per a repeat unit that initiate polymerization. After 24 h, 72% conversion was attained, corresponding to Mn(theor.) of 25539000. In this context, it is rather remarkable how the application of a sacrificial initiator effectively suppresses intermolecular crosslinking reactions even for such an ultra-dense bottle-brush at very high monomer conversion.33
Fig. 5 Synthesis of the ultra-dense bottle-brush cellulose-g-poly(MMA) graft copolymer via ATRP of MMA initiated by the cellulose/TAI adduct. (Top) General reaction scheme; (bottom) TD-SEC analysis (left – RI elugrams; right – M–H plots) of the cellulose/TAI macroinitiator, the copolymer obtained after 5 h, and poly(MMA) obtained after alkaline hydrolysis of the isolated product. Experimental details are provided in Table S7.† |
It is known that SEC of high-MW bottle-brushes is challenging due to the non-SEC elution behavior of high-MW fractions.16,89 Indeed, we observed delayed elution of high-MW polymer fraction(s), which obscured the MW analysis (for details see Fig. S27† and the accompanying discussion). Nevertheless, for the 5 h sample, we were able to obtain, using universal calibration, rather realistic Mn of 28300 for the free-growing chains initiated by the sacrificial initiator (Table S7†). This value agreed well with that for the mixture of grafts and free-growing chains acquired through the alkaline hydrolysis of the isolated product (Mn = 24400), confirming that the polymer grew at a similar rate from both the cellulose backbone-attached and free initiation sites. The close match between the experimental Mn values and the Mn(theor.), calculated based on the monomer conversion and the MMA/TAG ratio (considering all forms of TAI adducts), indicates that the much lower than theoretical Mn of the graft copolymer determined by TD-SEC (3174000) is severely underestimated due to the effects discussed above. The high compactness of the prepared bottle-brush copolymer is well-illustrated by the low α constant obtained from the M–H plot (Fig. 5). Further, even though we were unable to obtain any MW values from the TD-SEC analysis of the 24 h sample, we note that a good match between the Mn(theor.) and Mn(SEC) values of the hydrolysis product was retained also in this case (Table S7†). Additionally, the unimodal character of the SEC signals (data not shown) together with the low obtained Đ of 1.11 suggested that the Mn of grafts was similar as that determined for the hydrolysate. Altogether, the obtained data point to the extreme MW of the final cellulose-graft-poly(MMA) copolymer despite the rather low-MW cellulose backbone employed. We predict that truly giant cellulose-based graft copolymers with MWs in the order of hundreds of millions should be readily accessible using this strategy when starting from regular cellulose substrates having MWs in hundreds of thousands.
In the last part of this study, we highlight that the use of TAI-derived multifunctional initiation groups can have a much broader impact in the cellulose field as it can be easily adapted for the surface modification of diverse cellulose-based precursors. In the first example, we took advantage of the extremely high reactivity of DMSO-swollen cellulose toward TAI to demonstrate the possibility of spatial control in surface-initiated (SI) grafting from flat cellulose/TAI substrates. To this end, we placed a DMSO-wetted cellulose filter paper (Whatman) into a metallic mask and applied TAI into the mask opening. We then used the purified TAI-modified paper to initiate ATRP of MMA, obtaining within 30 min a thick, macroscopic layer of polymer bound to the regions of the paper surface originally exposed to TAI (Fig. 6). Notably, there was virtually no polymer growth from the rear side of the paper, confirming the instantaneous TAI reaction with the DMSO-wetted paper. We thus envisage that this strategy could be applicable to the fabrication of Janus-type fabrics.90
Fig. 6 Spatial control in the modification of Whatman filter paper with TAI and subsequent ATRP SI grafting of MMA from the modified cellulose surface. |
In another experiment, 5 cm of a thick cotton thread was surface-modified with TAI in DMSO and subsequently used to trigger MMA polymerization, which led to the complete coverage of the thread with a thick polymer layer (Fig. 7 and S28†). In the close-up picture, the disentanglement of the individual strands at the thread ends and the efficient modification of the smallest thread features is well-visible. Finally, to illustrate the feasibility of this strategy also for more complex (cellulose-based) natural substrates, we successfully grafted a polymer layer from TAI-modified pine tree cone in the same way (Fig. 7 and S29†). The non-modified areas visible on the cone scales correspond to the places where seeds blocked the access of TAI during the modification step (the seeds got released during the polymerization step). This further demonstrates the spatial control in the TAI-based SI grafting strategy. Altogether, these preliminary results show the great potential of the TAI-based strategy in both homogeneous and heterogeneous SI grafting from natural polymeric substrates with efficiency and grafting density unparalleled by the traditional protocols.30,91
Fig. 7 A cotton thread (top) and a pine tree cone (bottom) grafted with poly(MMA) via the two step TAI-modification/ATRP-grafting strategy. |
We envisage that in future the scope of the presented strategy will be significantly extended. For example, the broad reactivity of TAI will extend the range of functional substrates that could serve as CPA precursors; moreover, the different reactivity (stability) of linkers through which precursors are connected to the initiating TAGs could be exploited in programmed CPA decomposition. Furthermore, synthesis of miktoarm star polymers based on telechelic precursors or preparation of ultra-dense polymeric brushes with controlled thickness92 represent some of the expected future applications. Last but not least, the study of the physico-chemical properties of the new multi-chain CPAs can be desirable from the viewpoint of future applications of these materials.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d4sc01739k |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2024 |