Yujie
Fan
ab,
Li
Zhong
ab,
Haotian
Tian
b,
Chensheng
Lin
b,
Lingli
Wu
b,
Tao
Yan
*b and
Min
Luo
*b
aCollege of Chemistry, Fuzhou University, Fuzhou, Fujian 350108, China
bKey Laboratory of Optoelectronic Materials Chemistry and Physics, Fujian Institute of Research on the Structure of Matter, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Fuzhou, Fujian 350002, China. E-mail: lm8901@fjirsm.ac.cn; yantao@fjirsm.ac.cn
First published on 14th January 2025
Designing deep-ultraviolet (DUV) nonlinear optical (NLO) materials that simultaneously achieve DUV transparency and strong second-harmonic generation (SHG) remains a significant challenge. Here, we overcome this hurdle by harnessing the versatility of the perovskite (ABX3) structure to develop a novel DUV NLO crystal. Specifically, we have successfully synthesized a non-centrosymmetric Cd-containing sulfamic compound, KCd(NH2SO3)3, inspired by the perovskite architecture. The strategic incorporation of SO3NH2− groups at the X-sites not only induces distorted [CdO3N3] octahedra, thereby enhancing the SHG response, but also ensures an ultrawide bandgap, which enables excellent DUV transparency. Consequently, this material exhibits a strong SHG response, approximately 1.1 times that of KH2PO4 (KDP), with a DUV cutoff edge below 190 nm. Furthermore, large transparent single crystals (20 × 17 × 5 mm3) can be readily grown via a simple aqueous solution method, underscoring its potential for practical application. This innovative approach offers new design strategies for DUV NLO materials, overcoming the traditional trade-off between SHG response and UV transparency.
Prof. Min Luo received his B.S. in metallurgical engineering from Central South University, China, in 2011, and his Ph.D. from the Fujian Institute of Research on the Structure of Matter (FJIRSM), Chinese Academy of Sciences in 2016. In the same year, he started his independent career as an assistant professor at FJIRSM. From 2020 to 2022, he was an associate professor at FJIRSM and was promoted to full professor in 2023. He is a recipient of the National Natural Science Foundation of China Excellent Young Scientists Fund. His current research interests include the design, synthesis, and crystal growth of new nonlinear optical materials. |
Perovskites (ABX3), with their flexible lattice structures, inherent stability, and adaptable design capabilities,9 have excelled in various domains such as photovoltaics,10 catalysis,11,12 and superconductivity.13,14 Prominent perovskite-type oxides, including BaTiO3 (λ = 400 nm),15 LiNbO3 (λ = 300 nm),16 and LiTaO3 (λ = 280 nm),17 are classic commercial NLO materials, distinguished by their significant SHG effects and their ability to be grown as large crystals. Their robust SHG performance stems from the second-order Jahn–Teller (SOJT) effect,18 where the distortion of [BX6] (B = Ti4+, Nb5+, Ta5+) octahedra formed by d0 transition metals (TMs) provides active units for SHG. Research, including studies by Ok et al.,19 has revealed that these distorted octahedra enhance polarizability, promoting non-centrosymmetric (NCS) structures necessary for effective SHG. However, distorted octahedra constructed from d0 TMs suffer from d–d transitions that significantly limit the bandgap, preventing classic perovskites from accessing the DUV region.20 Thus, designing distorted octahedra within the perovskite framework to achieve DUV capabilities while maintaining strong SHG presents an intriguing and innovative research avenue.
To tackle this challenge, d10 transition metals, such as Zn2+ or Cd2+, emerge as ideal B-site candidates, as they not only induce polar displacements conducive to forming distorted polyhedra but also, owing to their lack of d–d transitions, mitigate red shifts in the absorption edge.21–23 To further amplify octahedral distortion for enhancing SHG responses and expanding the bandgap, we strategically employed X-site ligands, guided by several considerations. First, according to ligand field theory,24 the coordination of different ligands with central atoms affects electronic configurations, leading to ligand field splitting. This process modifies the length and strength of metal–ligand bonds, creating favorable conditions for further distortion. Second, a greater electronegativity difference between the ligand and the central atom promotes band expansion and reduces the negative impact of TMs on the bandgap.25,26 Based on these principles, we identified NH2SO3− containing mixed anions with strong electronegativity as the optimal X-site ligand. Additionally, NH2SO3− features ultra-large HOMO–LUMO gaps (approximately 8.17 eV),27 which should be conducive to further expanding the band gap.28,29
Furthermore, ensuring the geometric stability of the perovskite structure is paramount, as excessive octahedral distortion can result in structural instability. The octahedral factor (μ) and tolerance factor (t) play crucial roles in evaluating structural stability: stable octahedral formations necessitate a range of 0.44 < μ < 0.90.30 In light of this, we chose Cd2+ (μ = 0.48) as the B-site cation, as Zn2+ (μ = 0.37) could potentially lead to structural collapse. The tolerance factor, t, serves as an indicator of structural behavior, where a range of 0.89 < t < 1.00 indicates a stable cubic phase. When t is in the range of 0.81 to 0.89, the cubic phase structure can distort into lower-symmetry space groups while maintaining overall structural stability, while t < 0.81 suggests the possibility of collapse.31,32 Notably, the cubic phase is unsuitable for NLO applications due to its lack of birefringence. Therefore, we identified K (t = 0.88) as the most appropriate A-site cation for NLO materials, ensuring both structural stability and the desired optical properties.
Consequently, with these considerations in mind, we successfully synthesized a novel perovskite-type crystal, polyhedral (NH2SO3)3, exhibiting a substantial SHG response and a short UV cut-off edge enabling DUV access. Notably, this material can be easily grown using a simple aqueous solution evaporation method, yielding large single crystals measuring 20 × 17 × 5 mm3. This breakthrough elegantly reconciles the challenge between achieving strong SHG and a short UV absorption edge, thereby setting a new paradigm for the design of DUV NLO materials.
:
3 stoichiometric ratio. The beaker was placed on a temperature-controlled heated magnetic stirrer, dissolving NH3SO3 in 300 ml of water at 50 °C. Once dissolved, KOH and CdCO3 were gradually added. The mixture was allowed to react for 2 hours, and then the solution was filtered. Next, the filtered solution was put in an oven at 50 °C for evaporation. When crystal grains were formed, the solution was transferred to a 50 °C water bath and cooled at 0.5 °C per day to grow crystals. As the temperature reached 40 °C, the reduced solute concentration slowed down crystal growth, and impurity ions increased, causing defects. At this stage, the crystals were removed.
:
Cd
:
N
:
S
:
O of approximately 1
:
1
:
3
:
3
:
9 (Fig. S4†), consistent with the chemical formula. Notably, the crystal maintained its transparency even after exposure to air for several months. Thermal analysis demonstrated excellent thermal stability, with the crystal remaining stable up to 210 °C (Fig. S5†), comparable to most reported sulfamic NLO crystals.27–29
The crystal structure of KCd(NH2SO3)3, as depicted in Fig. 1(a) and (b), belongs to the non-centrosymmetric hexagonal space group P63 (no. 173). In this structure, a significantly polar [CdN3O3] octahedron is formed, where three N atoms and O atoms are located on opposite sides, leading to differences in bond lengths. Adjacent octahedra are interconnected by sharing SO3NH2− with dipole moments of all octahedra uniformly aligned along the c-axis, thus forming a non-centrosymmetric structural framework. To maintain charge balance within this framework, K+ ions fill the gaps, resulting in the three-dimensional crystal structure of KCd(NH2SO3)3.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 1 (a) The dipole moment of KCd(NH2SO3)3 along the c-axis; and (b) the 3D crystal structure of KCd(NH2SO3)3 in the a–b plane. | ||
The transformation from the classic cubic perovskite structure ABX3 to KCd(NH2SO3)3 is depicted in Fig. 2 and can be understood through a strategic three-step structural design approach. (1) Inducing octahedral distortion and bandgap expansion: To create a distorted octahedron while widening the bandgap, NH2SO3− was selected as the X-site in the BX6 unit. The presence of highly electronegative N and O atoms provides varied coordination environments for the B-site cation, facilitating distortion. Additionally, the large HOMO–LUMO gap of NH2SO3− (approximately 8.17 eV)27 contributes to an extensive ultraviolet transparency window for the material. (2) Stabilizing the octahedral model and avoiding red shift: The selection of the B-site ion is crucial for forming a stable B(NH2SO3)6 octahedral configuration with NH2SO3− while preventing the cutoff edge red shift associated with the second-order Jahn–Teller effect in d0 metals. Using the octahedral factor calculation, Cd2+ (μ = 0.48) was chosen from d10 metals as the B-site cation. Both N and O atoms in NH2SO3− can form covalent bonds with Cd2+, resulting in a distorted [CdN3O3] octahedral unit with Cd–O and Cd–N bond lengths of 2.303(4) Å and 2.371(5) Å, respectively. As each atom originates from the tetrahedral NH2SO3−, the eventual BX6 unit formed is Cd(NH2SO3)6. (3) Ensuring structural stability and crystal system modification: To ensure the stability of the ACd(NH2SO3)3 structure and avoid crystallization in a non-birefringent cubic crystal system, K (t = 0.88) was selected as the A-site cation. This choice was guided by electroneutrality principles and tolerance factor calculations (Fig. 3). The reduction in the tolerance factor facilitates the transition of the cubic perovskite of ABX3 into a monoclinic phase, thus enabling changes in the crystal system. Ultimately, KCd(NH2SO3)3 was realized on the perovskite framework, maintaining the quintessential ABX3 structure.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 3 The tolerance factor for each alkali metal (Li, Na, K, Rb, and Cs) and the maintained reasonable range for phase transition and structural stability. | ||
The ultraviolet transmission spectrum of KCd(NH2SO3)3 reveals an exceptionally short UV cutoff edge below 190 nm (Fig. 4a), corresponding to a large bandgap of 6.5 eV, which is in excellent agreement with the HSE06-calculated value of 6.22 eV (Fig. S6†). According to the anionic group theory, the formation of a large bandgap is primarily attributed to the HOMO–LUMO gap of the group. Our calculations on NH2SO3− reveal a HOMO–LUMO gap of approximately 8.17 eV, significantly larger than 6.5 eV, indicating that sulfamate salts possess a distinct advantage of wide ultraviolet transmittance. This is further corroborated by a series of examples of sulfamate salts.
To gain insight into the mechanism underlying the formation of this large bandgap, we further calculated the projected density of states (PDOS). As shown in Fig. 4d, the conduction band minimum of KCd(NH2SO3)3 is predominantly composed of Cd-s states, while the valence band maximum is jointly occupied by O-p and N-p states, suggesting that the bandgap is primarily determined by the Cd(NH2SO3)6 octahedron. Notably, our previous studies have shown that the –NH2 group exhibits a stronger electron-withdrawing effect compared to O, which may effectively confine the electron cloud around Cd, resulting in bandgap widening. This is likely the primary reason for the large bandgap in KCd(NH2SO3)3.
The non-centrosymmetric structure of KCd(NH2SO3)3 encouraged us to explore its SHG properties using the Kurtz–Perry method,38 with KDP as a reference sample. As depicted in Fig. 4b, KCd(NH2SO3)3 exhibited distinct phase-matching characteristics during frequency doubling from 1064 nm to 532 nm, accompanied by a significant SHG effect (1.1 × KDP). Theoretical calculations revealed that the largest NLO coefficient, d33, is −0.47 pm V−1, which is 1.2 times that of KDP (0.39 pm V−1), closely corroborating the experimental results. To elucidate the mechanism underlying its NLO coefficient, we calculated the SHG density map. As shown in Fig. S7,† the SHG density is predominantly concentrated around Cd2+ and SO3NH2−, indicating that the SHG effect is mainly attributed to the [Cd(NH2SO3)6] octahedra, whereas the K+ ions contribute negligibly. We have compiled most of the known UV/DUV Cd-based NLO materials, as shown in Table S6.† To the best of our knowledge, this may be the largest crystal size grown for a Cd-based DUV NLO material with large SHG effects.
To further elucidate the impact of octahedral distortion on SHG, we performed theoretical calculations on the degree of distortion, dipole moment, and hyperpolarizability of the octahedron. The standard deviation method (
, where Li is the edge length of the octahedron, and
is the average value of the edge lengths) was employed to quantify the degree of distortion, as shown in Fig. S8,† when the three O–Cd–N bond angles increased from 169.007° to 180°. Also, as calculated from the data in Fig. S8† using the above formula, the degree of distortion decreased from 0.2174 to 0.0482. Concomitantly, the dipole moment decreased from 7.5713 D to 6.96 D, and the hyperpolarizability decreased from 667.01 to 512.71 (Table S5†). These findings clearly demonstrate that reducing the degree of distortion diminishes the polarity of the octahedron and corresponds to a decrease in hyperpolarizability. In contrast, an increase in the degree of distortion contributes to the enhancement of hyperpolarizability, leading to improved SHG response, which is in line with our design concept. Notably, the arrangement of units also plays a crucial role in the SHG effect of NLO crystals. In the case of KCd(NH2SO3)3, the consistent alignment of [CdN3O3] octahedra results in a dipole moment of 17.6877 D along the c-axis, and the uniform arrangement of distorted octahedra provides favorable conditions for large SHG effects.
Footnote |
| † Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available: Crystallographic and structure data (Tables S1–S4), and figures containing the measurement results and detail of KCd(NH2SO3)3 (Fig. S1–S7). CCDC 2393438 for KCd(NH2SO3)3. For ESI and crystallographic data in CIF or other electronic format see DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d4qi03043e |
| This journal is © the Partner Organisations 2025 |