Pengfei
Zhang
ab,
Ziyi
Guo
ab,
Zhiting
Wei
ab,
Wenbo
Chen
*a,
Qinping
Qiang
a,
Bitao
Liu
a,
Tianchun
Lang
a,
Lingling
Peng
a,
Wenjie
Wang
*c and
Lei
Zhao
*b
aEngineering Research Center of New Energy Storage Devices and Applications, Chongqing University of Arts and Sciences, Chongqing 402160, P. R. China. E-mail: qschenbo@sina.com
bSchool of Physics and Opto-Electronic Technology, Baoji University of Arts and Sciences, Baoji, Shaanxi 721016, P. R. China. E-mail: zhaoleibjwl@163.com
cGansu Province Research Center for Basic Sciences of Surface and Interface Chemistry, College of Chemical Engineering, Northwest Minzu University, Lanzhou, Gansu 730030, P. R. China. E-mail: wangwj@xbmu.edu.cn
First published on 6th February 2025
The advancements in the new industrial era demand higher standards for integrated intelligent sensors. These multi-parameter coupling sensors require sensing materials that can swiftly respond to various physical stimuli, including stress, temperature, humidity, etc. Mechanoluminescence (ML), with its unique mechanical–optical response, serves as an effective medium for stress sensing. In ML materials, constructing multiple luminescent centers not only enables multicolor ML but also allows for temperature sensing through the differential thermal quenching properties of various luminescent centers. In this study, we present an energy transfer strategy that leverages high-energy blue-emitting ML from the host material, combined with Tb3+ and Mn2+, to achieve multicolor ML. The mechanical response is correlated with the integrated intensity of ML, while the temperature response is governed by the dynamic ML intensity ratio of ITb/IMn. This approach simplifies the design of multifunctional sensors and facilitates remote, dual-mode sensing. Moreover, we develop a highly secure encryption system based on the integration of multicolor PL and ML with an ML-triggering mechanism that is both convenient and reliable. This work presents an effective strategy for developing multicolor ML materials and advancing multimodal sensing.
At present, the construction method for multicolor ML is to use multiple materials or multiple luminescence centers to achieve preparation, such as SrAl2O4:Eu2+ (green),17 LiNbO3:Pr3+ (red),18 NaCa2GeO4F:Mn2+ (yellow),19 Sr3Sn2O7:Sm3+ (reddish-orange),20 CaZr(PO4)2:Eu2+ (blue)21 and BaSi2O2N2:Eu (bluish-green).22 However, this method demands substantial resources, in terms of both manpower and materials, highlighting the need for a simpler and more cost-effective alternative. In 2016, Jeong et al. physically mixed a red fluorescent dye with ZnS, where the red dye completely absorbed the green ML emission of ZnS, resulting in a color shift from green to red.23 Similarly, in 2018, Du et al. achieved tunable ML colors ranging from green to red by mixing CaZnOS:Tb (green) and CaZnOS:Mn (red), regulating the color through adjustments in the mass ratio.24 The multicolor ML was controlled through external energy transfer (ET) between materials. Furthermore, in 2021, Chen et al. successfully adjusted the ML color from green to red in SrZnSO:Tb,Eu by varying the Tb3+ ion doping concentration, facilitating internal ET.25 Despite these advancements, the limited range of ML colors remains insufficient for current application requirements, and achieving full RGB (red–green–blue) color tuning is resource-consuming. Thus, the selection of appropriate materials is critical. The blue domain, being the most energy-demanding, is key for generating a wide color range. Most ML materials that emit green and red light can be efficiently excited by blue light, so introducing blue-light emitting centers into the matrix is an effective approach. This facilitates dynamic ML color adjustment across the blue, green, and red regions via energy transfer. Additionally, the inclusion of dual-emission centers significantly improves operational efficiency. For material selection, we chose Sr8MgCe(PO4)7, a phosphate-based material. The presence of Ce3+ ions in the matrix provides effective high-energy blue light, and the rich cation coordination in the matrix is conducive to the introduction of multiple luminescence centers.26
In this study, we successfully incorporated the rare-earth ion Tb3+ and the transition metal ion Mn2+ into the blue ML matrix Sr8MgCe(PO4)7. PL and lifetime measurements confirmed that energy transfer facilitated tunable PL and ML emissions from blue to green, blue to red, and green to red. Furthermore, we observed a temperature-dependent intensity ratio (ITb/IMn) due to the energy-level differences between the rare-earth and transition metal ions. By calculating the ratio of Sr and Sa, we demonstrated the feasibility of ML-based temperature sensing without a light source. Finally, we validated the material's significant potential in mechanical displays and electronic signatures through a full-spectrum ML information encryption system.
In the later stages of the ML sensing module, polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS) was selected as the organic medium. Fig. 2a depicts the preparation process, which involves uniform mixing and high-temperature cross-linking. Phase characterization indicated that the XRD patterns of SMCP:0.4Tb3+,0.04Mn2+, PDMS, and the composite device were consistent with standard reference cards, confirming the absence of phase transitions (Fig. 2b). Morphological analysis further demonstrated uniform cross-linking between the powder and PDMS, while cross-sectional energy spectrum analysis validated the successful incorporation of RGB tricolor centers (Fig. 2c). Fig. 2d and e illustrate that after high-temperature cross-linking, the device retains flexibility and can be stretched to 100% strain. These advantages establish a foundation for subsequent ML temperature sensing and full-spectrum ML information readout.
In order to investigate its spectral modulation properties, in this study, we first tested the PL spectra and lifetime curves of different color gamuts. The spectrum of SMCP is shown in Fig. 3a. Under 312 nm excitation, the sample exhibits a broad emission in the matrix ranging from 325 to 450 nm, attributed to the 5D1–4F1 transition of Ce3+ ions. The excitation peaks at 275 nm and 294 nm correspond to the 4f → 5d broadband transitions of Ce3+ ions. For the SMCP:0.4Tb3+ sample, excitation at 312 nm produces two distinct emission spectra: one centered at 373 nm, corresponding to the Ce3+ ion emission peak, and another set of peaks centered at 488 nm, 542 nm, 583 nm, and 620 nm, which are characteristic emission bands of Tb3+ ions due to the 5D4 → 7FJ (J = 2–5) transitions (Fig. 3b). Under 312 nm excitation, the SMCP:0.4Mn2+ sample shows an emission band centered at 373 nm from Ce3+ ions and an additional emission band at 611 nm, attributed to the 4T1–6A1 transition of Mn2+ ions (Fig. 3c). In Fig. 3d, the emission spectrum of the SMCP:0.4Tb3+,0.04Mn2+ sample comprehensively displays all characteristic transitions of Ce3+, Tb3+, and Mn2+ ions. Of particular note, the characteristic excitation spectra of both singly and doubly doped samples overlap with the matrix emission spectrum in the 325–450 nm range. Additionally, in the co-doped SMCP:0.4Tb3+,0.04Mn2+ sample, the emission band of Tb3+ ions at 488 nm shows slight overlap with the PLE spectrum of Mn2+ ions (Fig. S3†), providing strong evidence for effective energy transfer pathways of Ce3+–Tb3+, Ce3+–Mn2+ and Tb3+–Mn2+.
To further verify the energy transfer between the matrix and Tb3+ ions and Mn2+ ions, as well as between Tb3+ ions and Mn2+ ions, the PL spectra and lifetime curves of SMCP:xTb3+, SMCP:yMn2+ and SMCP:0.4Tb3+,xMn2+ were recorded, as shown in Fig. 3b and c, respectively. As shown in Fig. S5,† as the Tb3+ doping concentration increases, the 5D1–4F1 transition peak of the Ce3+ ions gradually decreases, while the intensity of the characteristic transitions of Tb3+ ions progressively increases. The same trend was observed in the Mn2+ series. With the increase of Mn2+ doping concentration, the 5D1–4F1 transition peak of the matrix gradually decreased, while the characteristic emission of Mn2+ gradually increased. Additionally, for the co-doped SMCP:0.4Tb3+,yMn2+ series, as the concentration of Mn2+ ions increases, the characteristic emission of Tb3+ decreases, while that of Mn2+ increases (Fig. S6†). In order to further verify the energy transfer of Ce3+–Tb3+, Ce3+–Mn2+ and Tb3+–Mn2+, the fluorescence lifetime was tested by monitoring the emission at 373 nm (Ce3+) and 542 nm (Tb3+) in the three systems, and the data were well-fitted using eqn (1):27
![]() | (1) |
![]() | (2) |
As mentioned above, most studies focusing on full-spectrum ML responses utilize the monochromatic introduction of various luminescent centers, which restricts dynamic adjustment. In addition, direct dynamic doping of the three primary colors of red, green and blue is difficult to control. Consequently, the introduction of two additional color domain luminescent centers in a matrix containing Ce3+ ions and the realization of full spectral ML via energy transfer represent a more convenient approach. Initially, we developed encryption devices incorporating SMCP, SMCP:0.4Tb3+, SMCP:0.4Mn2+ and SMCP:0.4Tb3+,0.04Mn2+. The congruence of the ML and PL spectra suggests the homogeneity of the luminescent centers, which emit blue, green, red, and orange ML, respectively (Fig. 4a–d). Effective energy transfer between Ce3+–Tb3+, Ce3+–Mn2+ and Tb3+–Mn2+ also causes changes in ML color with varying luminescent center concentrations. The ML spectra at different doping concentrations are presented in Fig. S6–8.† In the SMCP:xTb3+ and SMCP:xMn2+ systems, an increase in the doping concentration results in a decrease in the matrix ML emission intensity, while the characteristic ML emissions of Tb3+ and Mn2+ progressively intensify. In samples from the SMCP:0.4Tb3+,0.04Mn2+ system, an increase in the concentration of Mn2+ ions leads to a ML intensity reduction of Tb3+ ions, whereas the ML emission intensity of Mn2+ ions gradually increases. Fig. 4e illustrates the relative intensity variations of Ce3+/Tb3+, Ce3+/Mn2+, and Tb3+/Mn2+ across different systems; as the doping concentration increases, the relative intensity diminishes accordingly. Further visualization of dynamic PL and ML images reveals consistent colors, confirming the homogeneity of the luminescent centers and the feasibility of ML energy transfer (Fig. 4f–h). Notably, in SMCP:xTb3+ (x = 0.04–0.4), a dynamic transition from blue to green was observed for both PL and ML, while in dual-doped SMCP:0.4Tb3+,yMn2+ (y = 0–0.4), a striking dynamic transition from green to yellow to orange to red occurred. By importing the PL spectral data from Fig. S3a–S5a† and the ML spectral data from Fig. S6–S8† into the CIE color space for analysis (Tables S2 and S3†), the PL and ML colors are represented within triangular regions defined by the vertices of red (SMCP:Mn2+), green (SMCP:Tb3+), and blue (SMCP) (Fig. 4i and j). Obviously, according to the above evidence, we achieve a dynamic full-spectrum modulation through energy transfer between luminous centers, which provides a new strategy for the simple and efficient design of multicolor ML.
After achieving tunable full-spectrum ML, we further investigated the mechanical properties of the device. As illustrated in the mechanical testing schematic (Fig. 5a), ML data were collected under varying mechanical responses using a mechanical testing machine, integrated with a photomultiplier tube and an Ocean Optics detector. The ML spectra of SMCP:0.4Tb3+,0.04Mn2+ under different mechanical stimuli are presented in Fig. 5b. As the applied force increased, the total integrated area of the ML spectra expanded, with the transition intensities of Ce3+, Tb3+, and Mn2+ progressively increasing (Fig. 5c). Simultaneously, photon counts were recorded using the photomultiplier tube, capturing the variations in force and the photon count over time. The study found that during the force application process, the photon number intensity gradually increased, and the increasing stage can be linearly fitted as y = −74.29984 + 4334.43x (Fig. 5d and e). As is known to all, the device's self-recovery characteristic is especially crucial across various fields. In 10 consecutive stretching cycles at a consistent speed and force, we observed that the ML intensity gradually diminished as the number of cycles increased. This reduction in intensity can be attributed to microfractures formed within the elastomer, decreasing friction with the inorganic components. Fortunately, after 24 hours of rest, cross-linking occurred between the organic and inorganic parts, resulting in a recovery of 84% and 62% of the original strength, respectively, during the subsequent stretching process. This self-recovery feature allows ML materials to minimize both material waste and resource consumption.
Temperature sensitivity is a key performance parameter for environmental temperature detection devices. Traditional upconversion-based temperature sensing methods often suffer from drawbacks such as complex operation and high costs. Therefore, exploring cost-effective ML-triggered temperature sensing becomes particularly important, offering the advantages of simplicity and direct visualization.29,30 Due to their different external electron configurations and excited state energy levels, rare-earth ions and transition metal ions have different temperature response sensitivities, this property is also used to study their temperature sensing performance. Therefore, Tb3+ and Mn2+ ions, which exhibit the most distinct color differences, were selected as the temperature sensing centers. Temperature sensing based on the ML intensity ratio (IR) not only minimizes environmental interference but also eliminates the need for external light excitation. First, the ML spectra of SMCP:0.4Tb3+,0.04Mn2+ devices were recorded at varying temperatures (Fig. 6a). As the temperature increased, the intensity of the ML spectra gradually decreased. It is important to note that the decrease in intensity for the Tb3+ and Mn2+ luminescence centers followed different trends. Normalizing the Mn2+ ion intensity revealed an upward trend in the ML intensity of Tb3+ ions, resulting in a significant change in the intensity ratio (Fig. S10†). Based on this observation, we established an exponential relationship between the MLR of ITb/IMn and temperature. As shown in Fig. 6b, the fitted exponential function is given as MLR = 0.23 + 2.83exp(−4806/T), with a fitting factor of 96%, which is sufficient to enable remote temperature sensing based on the MLR. The sensing performance of ML-based IR was evaluated using absolute sensitivity (Sa) and relative sensitivity (Sr), with the values of Sa and Sr estimated using eqn (3) and (4):24
![]() | (3) |
![]() | (4) |
Here, the calculated results are shown in Fig. 6c. With the increase of temperature, Sa increases gradually, while Sr increases first and then decreases, reaching the maximum value at 363 K. In order to ensure the reliability of temperature sensing based on the force-luminescence intensity ratio, the ML spectra under different forces were tested at room temperature. Fig. 6d shows the ML intensity ratios of each pair of luminescent centers, and it was found that the ML intensity ratios of Ce3+/Tb3+, Ce3+/Mn2+ and Tb3+/Mn2+ all fluctuated within a certain range across different forces, which was attributed to their excellent chemical properties and thermal stability.
Research on temperature sensing and information encryption has traditionally focused on fluorescence and phosphorescence techniques, with relatively limited exploration of ML. Specifically, dynamic encryption based on dual-doped full-spectrum systems remains underdeveloped. ML, due to its self-powered nature and high sensitivity, is easily triggered, making it highly effective in temperature sensing and information encryption under harsh conditions. In this study, we demonstrate the information encryption advantages of ML-based devices. Fig. 7a illustrates the preparation process of the encryption device. First, devices with different color gamuts (SMCP: blue, SMCP:0.08Tb3+: cyan, SMCP:0.4Tb3+: green, SMCP:0.4Tb3+,0.1Mn2+: yellow-green, SMCP:0.4Tb3+,0.2Mn2+: yellow, SMCP:0.4Tb3+,0.4Mn2+: orange, and SMCP:0.4Mn2+: red) were cut into circular shapes. Then, these different colored discs with the PDMS organic module were combined and maintained at 80 °C for four hours to form the final encryption device. Fig. 7b presents the images of the device under stretching and under 365 nm and 254 nm UV light, where full-spectrum ML is evident in the stretched state. The force-stimulated readout feature of the encryption device suggests that authenticity can be verified by analyzing the intensity of the ML generated by a signature. Importantly, we propose a new strategy to improve the security of electronic signatures by combining ML materials with three different luminous colors, making individuals’ writing habits difficult to replicate (Fig. 7c(i)). Fig. 7c(ii) shows the stress distribution and the corresponding images of the letter “M”. The electronic signature device comprises three materials: #1 (SMCP:0.4Tb3+,0.4Mn2+), #2 (SMCP), and #3 (SMCP:0.4Tb3+), with the “M” divided into three regions, each exhibiting varying ML intensities based on the applied force. Fig. 7c(iii) illustrates the relative ML intensity using a pseudocolor map, from which the applied force in each region can be inferred, enabling the authentication of the information. The integration of #1, #2, and #3 stress sensors allows for the recording and differentiation of individual writing patterns, enabling precise authentication. This personalized, high-resolution, and full-spectrum ML-based anti-counterfeiting method, enhanced by new materials and intelligent technologies, is poised to become a key technology in future anti-counterfeiting efforts, offering significant improvements in security, environmental sustainability, and user accessibility.
Footnote |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d4qi03338h |
This journal is © the Partner Organisations 2025 |