Mario
Gutiérrez
a,
Urbano
Díaz
*b,
Boiko
Cohen
*a and
Abderrazzak
Douhal
*a
aDepartamento de Química Física, Facultad de Ciencias Ambientales y Bioquímica, and Instituto de Nanociencia, Nanotecnología y Materiales Moleculares (INAMOL), Universidad de Castilla-La Mancha, Avenida Carlos III, S/N, 45071 Toledo, Spain. E-mail: boyko.koen@uclm.es; abderrazzak.douhal@uclm.es
bInstituto de Tecnología Química, Universitat Politécnica de Valéncia-Consejo Superior de Investigaciones Científicas (UPV-CSIC), Av. de los Naranjos, s/n, 46022 Valencia, Spain. E-mail: udiaz@itq.upv.es
First published on 25th September 2023
Metal–organic frameworks (MOFs) have gained significant attention for their broad range of applications in a variety of scientific and technological fields. These materials are crystalline in nature and are formed through the self-assembly of metal ions or clusters with organic linkers via coordination bonds. Typically, MOFs adopt three-dimensional (3D) structures by assembling the subunits in all three spatial directions forming a relatively rigid network. However, in recent years, low-dimensional 2D-MOFs have garnered considerable interest due to their distinctive properties, particularly in gas adsorption/separation, sensing, catalysis, and chemical release applications. 2D-MOFs are created through the assembly of a single layer, resulting in sheet-like structures that provide larger active surface areas, thereby enhancing the diffusion of guest molecules. A notable example of this is the ITQ family of 2D-MOFs, which are formed through the assembly of 1D organic–inorganic structural subunits. The resulting mesoscopic lamellar structure of these MOFs favors interactions with organic molecules and hence improves the catalytic performance. Here, we provide a comprehensive overview of the available synthesis, structural characterization, physico-chemical properties, and specific catalytic performance of ITQ 2D MOF hybrid materials. We examine available strategies to obtain tuneable Lewis and Brønsted acid active sites from the 1D sub-domains as well as provide examples for the application of these MOFs in specific reactions. We also review studies on the effect of the nature of organic spacers as well as that of the metal clusters on the spectroscopic and photodynamical properties of composites formed by these MOFs as hosts with well-known organic fluorescent dyes (guests).
Traditionally, it is possible to use different organic and inorganic structural units for the synthesis of 3D ordered porous frameworks, which through a self-assembly process generate specific metal–organic structures, MOF-type, with different properties and levels of structuration.7 Following this approach, a large number of this class of hybrid materials were described in the literature due to the possibility of using a great variety of inorganic units and organic ligands in the synthesis process.8–10 Furthermore, taking advantage of the versatility and reactivity of certain organic units, it is possible to modify and introduce new functionalities in the metal–organic structures through different post-synthesis treatments.11,12 At the borderline of the classical MOFs, in the last few years, new families of hybrid materials based on in situ generated 1D builder sub-units were prepared through solvothermal synthesis processes, using different types of metallic inorganic precursors and monotopic organic spacers usually not used up to that point for the preparation of conventional MOFs.13 Furthermore, post-synthesis modification was considered in some of these obtained materials for providing further functionalities to the hybrid network.14 In this way, MOFs with specific catalytic and photoactive properties were successfully generated.
This review is organized into several sections, with a summary of the main topics depicted in Scheme 1. After the Introduction section, we briefly comment on the novelty, advantages, and use of monotopic organic linkers for the synthesis of new 2D MOFs (Section 2). Section 3 focuses on the synthesis, structural characterization, physico-chemical properties and specific catalytic performance of MOF hybrid materials based on Al nodes and monotopic organic spacers. Section 4 examines the preparation procedures and characterization of 2- and 3D MOFs with tuneable Lewis acidity from 1D sub-domains. Section 5 is dedicated to MOFs based on 1D structural sub-domains with Brønsted acid and redox active sites as effective bifunctional catalysts. Section 6 examines the spectroscopic and photodynamical properties of composites formed by these 2D MOFs as hosts and two well-known organic fluorescent dyes (guests). The review ends with the Challenges and perspectives and Conclusions sections.
Traditionally, the formation of MOFs is based on the use of at least two types of structural building units with different characteristics and properties: one with inorganic nature, providing high thermal and mechanical stability, and the other with organic nature, providing associated flexibility and extra-functionalities. Normally, for the formation of these MOF-type materials, the organic building unit contains at least two reactive points capable of coordinatively interacting with the metal ions or clusters, although sometimes they may contain three or four connection points, which facilitate the formation of a crystalline, highly stable and, in some cases, rigid metal–organic structures after suitable solvothermal assembly processes.19
As a recent novelty, in the present review, a series of MOFs are described where monotopic organic spacers with only one point of interaction (in general carboxylic groups) combined with alkyl chains located in para positions of aryl groups are employed. This type of builder unit exerts a double function: as a structural agent and as a growth modulating assistant. Therefore, with the use of these monotopic ligands, the inhibition of the growth of the structure in the three directions of space is favoured, preventing the expansion during the synthesis process of the MOFs and favouring the generation of hybrid structures based on the in situ formation of 1D organic–inorganic sub-domains. The sub-domains are then organized and assembled along different dimensionalities and morphologies.13,20
These metal–organic structures are formed by inorganic chains composed of the association of metal octahedra, being the most frequent AlO4(OH)2. These are coordinated with monotopic organic spacers, generating 1D organic–inorganic structural units whose long-range associations form further families of MOF-type materials, depending on the nature of the metallic nodes used and the characteristics of the organic spacers involved in the solvothermal synthesis process. Specifically, aluminium octahedra are linked together through hydroxyl groups located in trans positions, typically present in inorganic materials based on trivalent nodes,21,22 such as those described in conventional aluminium MOFs similar to MIL-53 (Al).23–25Fig. 1 represents 1D sub-domains that are expected to form with greater probability during the synthesis process in the presence of monotopic organic ligands, being the fundamental builder units for the preparation of these new families of MOFs.
The influence of different synthesis conditions on the properties and morphological characteristics finally achieved in these families of metalorganic structures should be considered, such as pressure, temperature, time and, especially, the nature of solvents.26 These experimental conditions can direct towards the formation of one or another type of hybrid structure depending on the associations that are favoured between the organic and inorganic low-dimensional building units formed in the solvothermal synthesis medium.27
Specifically, the first family of MOFs obtained was based on the use of water as the only solvent. In this case, X-ray diffraction patterns of the obtained materials resembled those of the conventional 3D MIL-53 (Al)-type materials,29 regardless of the length of the aliphatic chain present in the monotopic organic ligand (ethylbenzoic acid, EB, or heptylbenzoic acid, HB) (Fig. 2a). These results support the hypothesis that structurally more compact 3D materials were formed, similar to the standard MOFs. This confirmed that the hybrid materials are isoreticular structures similar to MIL-53 (Al)-type materials (MIL-53(Al)-EB/HB).30
Fig. 2 (a) (I) PXRD patterns of isoreticular MIL-53(Al)-type MOFs: (a) standard 3D MIL-53(Al), (b) MIL-53(Al)-EB and (c) MIL-53(Al)-HB. (II) PXRD patterns of mesoscopic samples: (a) Al-ITQ-EB, (b) Al-ITQ-HB and (c) Al-ITQ-DB. (III) PXRD patterns of lamellar MOFs: (a) L-MOF-EB, (b) L-MOF-HB and (c) L-MOF-DB. (b) Synthesis routes for obtaining aluminium-MOF-type materials with different morphologies based on the specific structural assembly of 1D nanoribbons as a function of solvothermal conditions. (c) 2D NMR spectra: (I) 1H and 27Al and (II) 1H and 13C (HETCOR) CP-MAS NMR for the Al-ITQ-HB material. (d) TEM images of the exfoliated MOFs with dichloromethane: (I) Al-ITQ-EB and (II) Al-ITQ-HB materials. Reproduced from ref. 28 with permission from the Royal Society of Chemistry. |
A second family of hybrid materials was obtained in the presence of monotopic ligands with alkyl groups in the para position and using only DMF as a solvent in the synthesis process.28 In this case, the X-ray diffraction patterns showed a single band (100) at low 2θ angles positions when specific organic spacers such as EB, HB and DB, respectively, were used (Al-ITQ-EB/HB/DB). The obtained results evidenced that the existence of a mesoscopic type of organization is possible. As it was also observed in the standard M41S materials,31 the mesoporous channels formed exhibited larger internal diameters when the length of the hydrocarbon chain of the incorporated organic unit was longer. This fact was corroborated by the position of the diffraction bands (100), which moved to lower diffraction angles 2θ as the length of the alkyl chain was greater. These results indicate that the use of DMF as the only solvent resulted in the complete dissolution of both organic and inorganic building units in the same medium. Due to the high affinity between the organic molecules and the DMF used as a solvent, a high dispersion of the solved structural sub-domains occurs, favouring the micellar-type self-assembly.
The last family of materials was obtained using a mixture of solvents, like DMF/MiliQ water, giving rise to a lamellar-type structure based on the association of 1D organic–inorganic units assembled along the ab plane and separated by the monotopic organic spacers (EB, HB or DB), which were perpendicularly positioned with respect to the aluminium nodes (L-MOF-EB/HB/DB).28 The obtained basal space was different for each sample (Fig. 2b), indicating that the variation in the separation between the individual sheets depended on the length of the organic spacer used during the synthesis process, which acted as a modulator of the growth of the materials, inhibiting 3D structuring and favouring the formation of lamellar metal–organic structures. In addition, the presence of the diffraction band (100) together with the bands assigned to the diffraction orders (200) and (300), confirmed the high regularity obtained in the distance between the successive individual layers. This mixture of solvents allowed the complete dissolution of both structural units separately, the organic spacer preferably being dissolved in DMF and the inorganic unit in the aqueous solvent. In this way, an interface was generated where the two types of construction units came into close contact, allowing a lamellar-type ordering.
Fig. 2b shows the different families of MOFs obtained using various solvents by the solvothermal process, roughly illustrating the most probable morphology obtained. It is remarkable that in all cases the same 1D organic–inorganic sub-domains, shown in Fig. 1, were forming the hybrid material network.
From IR and NMR spectroscopies, it was corroborated that the groups coming from the different organic units were coordinatively anchored to the aluminium octahedra, remaining intact as well as retaining their initial chemical configuration and preserving their composition. Additionally, 27Al-NMR spectra of the solids evidence that practically all aluminium atoms were incorporated into the structural network in octahedral positions. These formed aluminium octahedra were connected to form inorganic chains present in the 1D sub-domains. Furthermore, NMR measurements in two dimensions of the spectra of 1H with 27Al and 1H with 13C were carried out, confirming the proximity between the aluminium nodes and the carbon atoms of the aromatic rings and of the aliphatic chains of the used organic spacers (Fig. 2c). Specifically, this experiment was carried out for the Al-ITQ-HB material, showing a correlation between the protons of the aromatic ring and the alkyl chain of the 4-heptylbenzoate ligand at ∼7 ppm and ∼1.5 ppm, respectively, with the ∼6.5 ppm signal of the octahedral aluminium nodes. This result implies the effective formation of the 1D organic–inorganic units as structural sub-units, which are associated with each other to form the different MOF-type materials obtained depending on the synthesis conditions used.
On the other hand, the presence of low-dimensional structural sub-domains in the different networks that formed the hybrid materials was confirmed through post-synthesis treatments with solvents of different polarity (methanol, dichloromethane (DCM), diethyl ether (DEE) or toluene). For this, the obtained solutions were analyzed by TEM (Fig. 2d), confirming the presence of small isolated 1D nanostructures, generated after the expansion and exfoliation of the initial metal–organic structures. The possibility of isolating these 1D sub-domains through an exfoliation process allows their use to form further types of nanomaterials when they are combined with other sub-structures.
Generally, benzodiazepines are synthesized through condensation between 1,2-phenylenediamine and carbonyl compounds in the presence of catalysts that exhibit Lewis acidity.36 For this, the catalytic capacity of the hybrid materials, MIL-53(Al)-HB, Al-ITQ-HB and L-MOF-HB, was studied (Fig. 3a) to verify the effect of the different structuration and morphology of each of them in the cyclic condensation of 1,2-phenylenediamine with acetone to obtain 2,3-dihydro-2,2,4-trimethyl-1H-1,5-benzodiazepine, also known as 1,5-benzodiazepine. The reaction kinetics showed a similar catalytic behaviour for MIL-53(Al)-HB and Al-ITQ-HB materials. The reduced reaction rate obtained for the L-MOF-HB catalyst was attributed to the high organic content included in its structure, which is positioned in the interlayer space, causing diffusional problems, and preventing the arrival of the reactants to the active sites of the hybrid catalysts. Furthermore, the leaching phenomenon was not observed during the process and the high catalytic activity presented by the hybrid material MIL-53(Al)-HB to produce 1,5-benzodiazepine was exclusively assigned to the presence of unsaturated aluminium coordination sites (Fig. 3b and c). Finally, the stability and recyclability of the MIL-53(Al)-HB material were studied during several consecutive reaction cycles, evidencing how this hybrid material maintained its high catalytic activity during all uses. This fact would open the door to employ this type of material as an efficient solid acid catalyst in other fine chemical processes and, in particular, in those in which intramolecular cyclizations take place.37,38
Fig. 3 (a) Mechanism for the formation of 1,5-benzodiazepine. (b) Catalytic activity for the production of 1,5-benzodiazepine with the materials: MIL-53(Al)-HB (◊), Al-ITQ-HB (■) and L-MOF-HB (▲). Blank (●). (c) Catalytic activity with the MIL-53(Al)-HB material, observing the disappearance of 1,2-phenylenediamine (▲), the appearance and consumption of the reaction intermediate (●) and the production of 1,5-benzodiazepine (◊). Production of 1,5-benzodiazepine after removal of the catalyst (■).28 (d) Al-ITQ-HB catalyzed multicomponent reaction for the synthesis of spirooxindole product. (e) Enantioselective organocatalytic Michael reactions promoted by Al-ITQ-HB. Organocatalyst 4 was used in the amount of 10 mol% in all cases, except noted. Additives used were Al-ITQ-HB (results highlighted in blue) or MIL-53 (Al) (results highlighted in red) in the amount of 30 mol%. Reproduced from ref. 39 with permission from Springer Nature. |
The reactivity exhibited by this type of MOFs based on low-dimensional building units was extended to another relevant reaction processes, such as condensation reactions in water in the absence of acidic or basic catalysts, as well as organocatalytic Michael-type reactions that also showed superior enantioselectivity when comparing with the host-free transformation.39 Specifically, the mesoscopic Al-ITQ-HB catalyst was effective for the Knoevenagel reaction under mild conditions, being efficient for the condensation of a variety of aromatic aldehydes. Comparative experiments employing conventional MOFs, such as 3D MIL-53 (Al), showed no relevant conversion, remarking the important role of the hydrophobic sub-domains present in Al-ITQ-HB materials and confirming that substrate activation was not a simple consequence of Lewis acid activation by the network or the influence of π-stacking interaction of the aromatic aldehydes with the organic–inorganic network of the catalyst. The reaction process proceeded better with aromatic aldehydes containing electron donating groups, although rate acceleration was detected in all cases.
The reactivity of the mesoscopic hybrid material Al-ITQ-HB was also evaluated in the multicomponent reaction between isatin, dimedone and malononitrile for the synthesis of the spirooxindole product (Fig. 3d), through micellar catalysis in water by means of sodium stearate.40 One more time, in the presence of water in the reaction medium, an improved rate was observed for the Al-ITQ-HB catalyst compared to the MOF-free reaction under similar conditions. These excellent catalytic results were extended to asymmetric organocatalytic Michael-type reactions of isobutyraldehyde to nitrostyrene41 and even for Michael's addition of nitromethane to 4-phenyl-3-buten-2-one.42,43 This fact allowed establishing as general that our host system boosted the organic reactions in aqueous media (Fig. 3e).
Specifically, four new hybrid solids were prepared through the presence of different functional groups (nitro, bromine, ethyl and amino), which were found in the used monotopic organic spacers.47 In the selection of the aforementioned groups, two of them were chosen that exhibited the particularity of electron-attracting character (EWG, electron-withdrawing groups), nitro and bromine, which removed electron density from the conjugated system, making it more electrophilic. Thanks to the incorporation of these two types of substituents, a lower negative charge density in the carboxylic groups of the organic ligands was favoured. Therefore, the non-coordinated metallic centres (CUS, Coordinative Unsaturated Sites) included in the metallic nodes of the MOFs exhibited higher Lewis acidity.48,49 Furthermore, due to their ability to attract electrons, these EWG groups showed a high charge density. Therefore, electronic fields and dispersion forces were generated between the organic spacers themselves, inducing a certain disorder in the formation of the structural sub-domains, which facilitated the generation of 3D MOFs with a more compact structure. This was also favoured by the ease of self-assembly of the organic ligands and the aluminium octahedral units due to the highly polar nature of the organic units, which were easily stabilized in the synthesis medium (DMF/water). In consonance, the diffractograms obtained for these hybrid materials (Al-ITQ-Br and Al-ITQ-NO2) were more similar to those of the conventional 3D material MIL-53(Al) (Fig. 4). Similar to these materials and taking into account the possible use in different catalytic applications, the preparation of MOFs that contain more than one type of metallic nodes in their structure is of great interest, due to the possibility of carrying out different catalytic processes, in which each metal centre exhibits a singular role or can be favoured a cooperative effect, increasing the initial reactivity. For these reasons, bimetallic MOFs with a 3D structure were prepared, called Al/Fe-ITQ-NO2, in which the organic spacer with nitro groups in the para position of the aromatic rings and two different inorganic sources were used, one of aluminium and other of iron.47 Additionally, an EDS-STEM analysis confirmed a homogeneous distribution, along the metal–organic structure, of the two types of metallic nodes, iron and aluminium, present in the hybrid material Al/Fe-ITQ-NO2 (Fig. 5).
Fig. 4 (a) Synthesis routes used to obtain MOFs with different morphologies using monotopic ligands with different substituent groups in the para position of the aromatic ring. (b) X-Ray diffractograms of the synthesized hybrid materials: (a) MIL-53(Al), (b) Al-ITQ-Br, (c) Al-ITQ-NO2, (d) Al/Fe-ITQ-NO2, (e) L-MOF-EB and (f) L-MOF-AB. (c) Representation of the layers present in the solids L-MOF-AB and L-MOF-EB, based on the association of aluminium octahedral in a Kagomé system. Spacers were omitted for clarity. Reproduced from ref. 47 with permission from the Royal Society of Chemistry. |
Fig. 5 (a) EDS-STEM analysis for the two metallic elements, Al and Fe, incorporated in the 3D material Al/Fe-ITQ-NO2. (b) and (c) TEM images of the 2D material L-MOF-AB. Reproduced from ref. 47 with permission from the Royal Society of Chemistry. |
In contrast, the other two selected substituent groups, amino and ethyl, showed the ability to donate electrons (EDG, Electron-Donating Groups), providing electron density to the conjugated system and making the aromatic ligands more nucleophilic.47 Due to the incorporation of these two groups, an increase in the negative charge density of the carboxylic groups would be expected. Therefore, the uncoordinated metal centers present in the inorganic building units of MOFs exhibit lower Lewis acidity. From a structural point of view, it should be noted that although these two functional groups exhibit different chemical properties, a similar lamellar morphology was achieved. This morphology was favoured by the presence of amino groups, which could establish hydrogen bonds between them, facilitating a regular lamellar organization between these organic spacers during the solvothermal synthesis process. In the case of ethyl groups, they showed the tendency to remain ordered among themselves, because of the van der Waals forces that were established. Thus, in both cases, 2D materials with a lamellar morphology were obtained (L-MOF-AB and L-MOF-EB) (Fig. 4). Specifically, these individual sheets are formed by the association between the 1D organic–inorganic units, which favour a 2D order, with separated layers by the organic ligands that are located in the interlayer space. In this case, the aluminium octahedral is organized in the bc plane, following a Kagomé-type structural system, characteristic of lamellar materials formed by trivalent metal octahedra, forming sheets composed of hexagonal rings delimited by six triangular rings.50 TEM images of the samples obtained when electron donor groups (–NH2 and –C2H5) were incorporated into the final metalorganic network confirmed the lamellar morphology of the L-MOF-EB and L-MOF-AB hybrid materials (Fig. 5).
In the case of benzaldehyde cyanosilylation with cyanotrimethylsilane (TMSCN), without using solvents in the reaction medium, the catalytic results were better when the reaction was carried out in the presence of more compact 3D materials (Al-ITQ-NO2 and Al-ITQ-Br), which contained electron-withdrawing groups (Fig. 6a and b). The results showed that the organic ligand with the greatest capacity to attract electrons contributed to the formation of more active Lewis sites, and the catalyst Al-ITQ-NO2 presented higher activity (∼99%). An illustrative way of seeing the influence of the different substituents on the obtained kinetic results was achieved by plotting the relative initial velocities against Hammet's constant (σpara) in each case (Fig. 6c).
Fig. 6 (a) Benzaldehyde cyanosilylation reaction. (b) Kinetics data obtained for the production of cyanohydrins with the different metalorganic materials. The reaction blank reached a 24% yield after 5 hours of reaction. (c) Plot of Hammet's constant against relative initial rates obtained for benzaldehyde cyanosilation with the different Al-ITQ-X catalysts (–X: –NO2, –Br, –NH2 and –C2H5). (d) Oxidation of thiophenol to diphenyl disulfide. (e) Kinetic curves for the production of diphenyl disulfide using Al/Fe-ITQ-NO2, Al-ITQ-NO2, MIL-53(Al) and MIL-53(Al)-NO2 as heterogeneous catalysts under O2 atmosphere. The reaction blank reached 3% conversion after 10 h of reaction. (f) Yields for four consecutive uses in the thiophenol oxidation reaction using Al/Fe-ITQ-NO2 material as a catalyst under an O2 atmosphere. Reproduced from ref. 47 with permission from the Royal Society of Chemistry. |
In addition, catalytic results showed that the incorporation of iron provided additional advantages (Al/Fe-ITQ-NO2), being capable of carrying out different catalytic applications, and even positively modifying the catalytic properties of the aluminium sites.54,55 Specifically, the aerobic oxidation of thiols to disulfides is an important process to obtain interesting chemical compounds in different biological applications, in which the use of molecular oxygen as an oxidizing agent presents a sustainable and environmentally favourable way of carrying out this type of processes.56,57 For all these reasons, the activity of the synthesized bimetallic hybrid material (Al/Fe-ITQ-NO2) was explored by using it as a catalyst in the aerobic oxidation of thiophenol to diphenyl disulfide, using acetonitrile as a reaction solvent (Fig. 6d and e). The results showed high yields (100%) to the desired product in the presence of the Al/Fe-ITQ-NO2 material, while much more reduced were reached when solid Al-ITQ-NO2 or conventional MIL-53(Al) MOFs were used in the same reaction time. Heterogenization of active functions through lixiviated tests and recyclability was clearly confirmed for the used hybrid catalysts. Furthermore, when iron was successfully incorporated into the metal–organic structure, exhibited higher catalytic activity in the benzaldehyde cyanosilylation, presenting a positive effect combined with the structural aluminium, modifying and increasing the final activity of the Lewis acid sites (Fig. 6f).
Fig. 7 Representation of metalorganic materials synthesis: (a) Al-ITQ-SH and Al-ITQ-SO3H and (b) Al-ITQ-SH/Pd and Al-ITQ-SO3H/Pd. The dark spheres represent the palladium nanoparticles. Reproduced from ref. 61 with permission from the Royal Society of Chemistry. |
Fig. 8 (a) TEM images of the Al-ITQ-SH/Pd laminar hybrid materials. (b) HRTEM images of the Al-ITQSO3H/Pd lamellar hybrid materials. The red circles highlight an area where the lamellar morphology is better appreciated. (c) STEM image and EDS-STEM analysis for the two metallic elements incorporated in the Al-ITQ-SO3H/Pd laminar material. Reproduced from ref. 61 with permission from the Royal Society of Chemistry. |
Fig. 9 (a) Kinetic curves obtained from the acetalization of 1,2-propanediol with: (I) benzaldehyde, (●) ratio 1:2, 10 mol% SO3H at 90 °C, (■) ratio 1:2, 20 mol% SO3H at 90 °C, (▲) ratio 1:6, 20 mol% SO3H at 90 °C and (×) ratio 1:6, 20 mol% SO3H under solvent reflux (toluene), and (II) vanillin, (■) ratio 1:6, 20 mol% SO3H at 90 °C and (×) ratio 1:6, 20 mol% SO3H under solvent reflux, using the hybrid material Al-ITQ-SO3H as the catalyst. (b) Kinetic curves obtained for the esterification of hexanoic acid with methanol at 60 °C, using 10 mol% SO3H of the Al-ITQ-SO3H material as the hybrid catalyst. The separation of the solid at 3 h and the kinetics obtained by leaching generated under the same reaction conditions are represented. (c) The yield of different esters was plotted versus time when esterification was performed in the presence of Al-ITQ-SO3H: ethyl hexanoate () using 10 mol% SO3H at 90 °C and ethanol as the solvent; () butyl hexanoate using 10 mol% SO3H at 90 °C and butanol as the solvent; () hexyl hexanoate using 10 mol% SO3H at 90 °C and hexanol as the solvent; () hexyl hexanoate using 10 mol% SO3H at 120 °C and hexanol as the solvent. (d) The yield of different esters was plotted versus time when esterification was performed in the presence of Al-ITQ-SO3H: () methyl hexanoate, () methyl octanate and () methyl laurate. Reaction conditions: 10 mol% SO3H at 60 °C, using methanol as the solvent. Reproduced from ref. 61 with permission from the Royal Society of Chemistry. |
The esterification of an alcohol with a carboxylic acid to form the corresponding ester is a widely known reaction.64,65 Currently, there is great interest in this catalytic process since it is of relevance in different application fields, because organic esters are commonly used as plastic derivatives, solvents, and fragrances as well as in the food and agrochemical industries. Following this scope, the lamellar hybrid material Al-ITQ-SO3H was used as the acid catalyst in the esterification of hexanoic acid with methanol. Fig. 9b shows the high catalytic activity (95%) that the hybrid catalyst reached in short reaction times. In addition, subsequent analysis of leaching showed how the performance remained practically unchanged, confirming the stability and heterogeneous nature of the hybrid catalyst under the reaction conditions, since the release of active species from it to the reaction medium did not occur.
Considering the excellent results obtained, the acid capacity of the Al-ITQ-SO3H hybrid catalyst was studied for the production of other organic esters of great interest in the food industry, as described by FEMA. Fig. 9c shows the kinetics obtained for the different esters produced, using hexanoic acid in all cases and increasing the number of carbon atoms of the alcohol used at the same time as a reaction reagent and a solvent. The results confirmed that by increasing the length of the aliphatic chain of the used alcohol, lower yields were achieved, even requiring more severe reaction conditions to overcome this effect. Similarly, by increasing the length of the alkyl chain of the acid, lower yields were obtained (Fig. 9d). In both cases, the observed effect could be due to the greater impediment exhibited by the reagents by increasing the length of their hydrocarbon chains to react with the active sites of the catalyst and produce the corresponding ester.
On the other hand, epoxides are highly important intermediates in organic synthesis, being used as starting materials for products with high added value on an industrial scale. One of the most relevant processes is the opening of the epoxide ring with an alcohol. This process is catalyzed by an acid to produce β-alkoxyalcohols, which are of interest to the pharmaceutical industry.66,67 For this, the acid capacity of the metal–organic lamellar material Al-ITQ-SO3H was evaluated for the opening reaction of the styrene oxide ring with methanol, using mild reaction conditions during the process. The obtained results showed that the catalytic process was successfully carried out, obtaining 98% yield, being reused during several consecutive reaction cycles without losing the reactivity and maintaining the heterogeneity of the process. This confirmed the validity of the MOFs based on low-dimensional builder units as acid active heterogeneous catalysts for fine chemical processes with industrial interest.
Fig. 10 (a) Kinetic curves obtained for the consecutive reaction of oxidation–acetalization in the presence of different percentages of the Al-ITQ-SO3H/Pd catalyst: (I) 1 mol% Pd, (II) 3 mol% Pd and (III) 5 mol% Pd, where step I was carried out at 100 °C under an oxygen atmosphere and step II at 45 °C under nitrogen atmosphere. (b) Yields obtained during four consecutive cycles in the oxidation–acetalization reaction, using 3 mol% Pd of the Al-ITQ-SO3H/Pd catalyst. (c) Diffractograms for the Al-ITQ-SO3H/Pd catalyst: (a) as-synthesized, (b) first use, (c) second use, (d) third use and (e) fourth use, from bottom to top. Reproduced from ref. 61 with permission from the Royal Society of Chemistry. |
Section | Example | Ref. | Catalyst |
---|---|---|---|
Section 2 | Synthesis of benzodiazepines and asymmetric transformations such as Michael and Knoevenagel condensations, evidencing the influence of defect structural sites together with Lewis acidity in the reactivity of the 2D metalorganic materials | 28 and 39 | Al-ITQ-HB |
Section 3 | Synthesis of cyanohydrins and aerobic oxidation of thiols to disulfides, showing the capacity of tuning the Lewis acid character of the solids through the structural incorporation of electron-donor or electron-attracting organic functions. | 47 | Al-ITQ-X (–X: –NO2, –Br, –NH2 and –C2H5); Al/Fe-ITQ-NO2 |
Section 4 | Acid reactions such as acetalization, esterification and ring opening of epoxides, showing the reactivity of the solids in different reactions which are habitual for organic synthesis of high added value products and also an industrial scale. | 61 | Al-ITQ-SO3H |
Section 5 | Tandem or consecutive processes such as oxidation–acetalization reactions, confirming the possibilities to use these materials like efficient bi-functional catalysts by the incorporation of acid and redox sites, acting concomitantly, for one-pot two-step processes. | 61 | Al-ITQ-SO3H/Pd |
The photophysical behavior of NR and DCM dyes has been a subject of intense debate. For instance, their photophysical properties have been explored in a multitude of different media, trying to reach a consensus about their steady-state and time-resolved photobehavior.82–86 In general, the fluorescence properties of both dyes are similar, showing a well-resolved structured band in non-polar aprotic solvents, which becomes a broader, unstructured band, shifted towards longer wavelengths, in polar and protic solvents.82 This spectral behavior is typically associated with an excited state intramolecular charge transfer (ICT).87 In fact, NR and DCM can be considered as push–pull fluorescent molecules, with an electron donor moiety (N,N-dimethylaniline for DCM and N,N-diethylaniline for NR) connected through a π-conjugated spacer to an electron acceptor group (dicyanomethylene for DCM, and keto group for NR). Moreover, both dyes might present a rotation of the electron donor group, inducing a twist in the conformation known as twisted intramolecular charge transfer (TICT) state.84,88–91 Hence, after photoexcitation, the emission of these dyes might originate from the locally excited (LE), the ICT, or the TICT states depending on the surrounding environment. Based on this, it has been proposed that when these fluorescent probes are in non-polar aprotic dyes, the well-structured fluorescence band is a consequence of the emissive deactivation from their LE state.82,84,90 On the other hand, in polar protic media, the emission might originate from the ICT or the TICT states, being the latter more stabilized and therefore, shifted towards longer wavelengths.82,84,90 These photoproperties have been also investigated by employing time-resolved laser-based spectroscopic techniques. For instance, in solution, NR undergoes an ultrafast (∼1 ps) polarity dependent TICT in its first singlet excited state (S1). Following the TICT, the photoproduced state relaxes radiatively to the ground state in ∼4.4 ns.88 Similarly, DCM can undergo an ICT to produce an emissive charge transfer (CT) state that can be followed by a twisting motion, thus populating an excited TICT state.92–94 A summary of the general photophysics scheme is depicted in Fig. 11b.
Even though these fluorescent molecular probes exhibit great potential to be implemented in the construction of luminescent-based chemical sensors, they suffer from an intrinsic limitation, which is the quenching of their fluorescence in the solid state, a phenomenon known as aggregation-caused quenching (AQC).95 Since many of the sensing detectors require solid-state active materials, the use of NR and DCM dyes as powders constitutes a limitation for their exploitation in real sensing devices. A possible solution to overcome this issue is to encapsulate these dyes within porous materials, in which the porous structure allows the isolation of the fluorophores, minimizing or preventing the aggregation of the dyes, and therefore, enhancing their fluorescence intensity in the solid state. A number of materials have been proposed to encapsulate these fluorescent dyes, including but not limited, to polymers,96,97 micelles,98–100 mesoporous silica based materials,101–103 zeolites,104–106 and MOFs.107–110 When a molecular probe, such as NR and DCM interacts with the MOF support either within the available pores or on its surface, several photoinduced processes can occur. Some examples include electron transfer to the metal cluster part (ligand-to-cluster charge transfer, LCCT) generating a charge separated state (electrons and holes), excited state proton transfer (ESPT), CT and Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET) phenomena. The efficiency of these depends on different intrinsic and external factors, such as the dye concentration, the polarity of the local environment, the presence of electron-donating or accepting groups, etc. A variety of spectroscopic techniques, such as time-correlated single-photon counting, femtosecond–ns Raman and IR, transient absorption and fluorescence up-conversion, can be employed to obtain a detailed information for the related parameters. These photoinduced processes and the available techniques for their characterization in MOFs have been reviewed in detail recently.111 Additionally, the photophysical properties of these dyes upon encapsulation are significantly altered with the concentration of the encapsulated guests.102–104,112,113 This effect has been well explained considering the formation of J- and H-aggregates. In an H-aggregate, the molecules stack predominantly face-to-face, while J-aggregates form when the molecules primarily stack in a head-to-tail arrangement. The formation of such aggregates has important consequences for the energies of the excited states and the oscillator strengths of the transitions to these states from the ground state. Consequently, H- and J-aggregation can strongly modify the optical absorption and photoluminescence spectra.114–116 Following the classical excitonic theory, S1 → S0 is forbidden for the H-aggregates, while for the J-aggregates it will be less energetic than for the monomers. A recent review provides a more detailed overview of the most recent theories for H- and J-aggregates.117 Several strategies can be explored to control the formation of these molecular aggregates. These include, but are not limited to, precise control of the dye concentration, the introduction of bulkier substituents in the molecular structure of the probe or by applying alternative approaches for the inclusion of the dye in the MOF structure – either by diffusion or in a one-pot synthesis. The sensitivity of the photophysical properties of NR and DCM to subtle changes in the local environment was exploited to characterize different mesoporous materials. For example, when NR is encapsulated within Zr- and Ti-doped MCM-41 materials, its photoexcitation leads to an ultrafast ICT phenomenon of <200 fs.113 The photodynamics of NR encapsulated within these materials shows a multiexponential behavior with time constants of τ1 = 0.18–0.34 ns, τ2 = 0.7–1.5 ns and τ3 =1.2–4.0 ns, attributed to the emission lifetimes of H-aggregates, J-aggregates and monomers, respectively.113 This multiexponential behavior was also observed when these molecules are encapsulated within different silica-based materials. Moreover, it has also been reported that NR dye possesses the ability to interact with Lewis and Brønsted acid sites in metal-doped mesoporous materials and zeolites, with key implications for the improvement of catalytic systems.103,104,113 In another example, NR and DCM dyes have been also encapsulated within a Zr-MOF to combine the emission of these dyes with that of the MOF in order to obtain high quality white light emitting materials.107 These and others are examples of how these dyes can be implemented for the development of hybrid emissive materials having great potential for their application in different photonic devices.
In the following subsections, we will focus on the photophysical properties of NR and DCM dyes upon their interaction with the ITQ 2D-MOF family, since these 2D-MOFs exhibit a higher surface area than conventional 3D materials as the ones described above. Hence, these materials are excellent candidates for the development of chemical sensors, but prior to that, it is primordial to deeply understand their photobehavior.
Fig. 12 (a) UV-visible absorption and emission spectra of NR/Al–ITQ-HB at different initial dye concentrations: 1 × 10−4 M (green lines), 1 × 10−3 M (orange lines), and 1 × 10−2 M (blue lines) after thoroughly washing the samples. The emission spectra were recorded upon excitation at 550 nm. (b) Normalized emission decays of NR/Al–ITQ-HB at different initial dye concentrations: 1 × 10−2 M (blue circles), 1 × 10−3 M (orange circles), and 1 × 10−4 M (green circles) upon excitation at 470 nm and recorded at the indicated wavelengths. (c) Schematic illustration of the distribution of NR molecules within the Al-ITQ-HB framework in the form of monomers, and J- and H-aggregates. Adapted with permission from ref. 118 (ACS Omega, 2018, 3, 1600–1608). Copyright 2018 American Chemical Society. |
Femtosecond time-resolved emission experiments have characterized the ultrafast intramolecular charge transfer to produce the CT state (∼1 ps), which is then followed by a vibrational cooling (VC) in ∼8 ps, while the homogeneous distribution of the dye within the MOF was confirmed by scanning confocal fluorescence microscopy of single crystals and agglomerates of the composites. Both time constants are slower than those reported for the ultrafast dynamics of NR in silica-based materials.103,104,113 The slowing down of the ultrafast dynamics was explained in terms of the different types of interactions that occur between the dye and the host materials. In silica-based materials, the hydroxyl groups of the framework can interact with NR via H-bonds, favoring vibrational energy transfer from excited NR molecules to the surrounding environment, while for the NR/Al–ITQ-HB composites, the coupling between the dye and the MOF host is weaker, and occurs through nonspecific interactions thus slowing down the related energy dissipation processes.
Fig. 13 (a) The top image is a schematic illustration of the adsorption of NR molecules on the surface of the Al-ITQ-HB MOF. The bottom images are real photos of NR, thoroughly washed NR@Al-ITQ-HB, and unwashed NR@Al-ITQ-HB powders. (b) Normalized emission decays of unwashed NR@Al–ITQ-HB powder at different initial NR concentrations: 1 × 10−5 M (I), 1 × 10−4 M (II), and 1 × 10−3 M (III) upon excitation at 470 nm, and observation at different wavelengths. (c) Schematic representation of the photoprocesses occurring after the photoexcitation of the unwashed NR@Al–ITQ-HB composites. Adapted with permission from ref. 121 (ACS Appl. Mater. Interfaces, 2018, 10, 20159–20169). Copyright 2018 American Chemical Society. |
Fig. 14 (a) Comparison of the ps–ns emission decays of 1: NR@Al-ITQ-HB; 2: NR@Al-ITQ-EB; and 3: NR@Al-ITQ-AB upon photoexcitation at 470 nm and recording the signals at 725 nm. (b)–(d) fs-emission decays of (b) NR@Al-ITQ-HB; (c) NR@Al-ITQ-EB; and (d) NR@Al-ITQ-AB, upon their photoexcitation with 470 nm light and gating the signal at the indicated wavelengths. Adapted with permission from ref. 125 (ACS Appl. Mater. Interfaces, 2018, 10, 32885–32894). Copyright 2018 American Chemical Society. |
Significantly different behavior was reported for NR interacting with Al-ITQ-4-aminobenzoic acid (AB) 2D-MOF, in which the HB acid linker was replaced with 4-aminobenzoic acid.125 Although the absorption spectrum of the resulting composite is comparable to those of the other MOF composites from this family, its emission spectrum is distinct, showing a much broader band in the 550–650 nm range concomitant with a shift in the emission intensity maximum towards lower wavelengths (from 660 nm to 645 nm). This behavior suggests the presence of additional emissive NR populations and that different photoinduced processes are acting in this NR@Al-ITQ-AB composite. This was further supported by the results obtained from the time-resolved emission experiments, where the decays of NR@Al-ITQ-AB were well-fitted by a three-exponential function giving time constants of τ1 = 0.13 ns, τ2 = 0.54 ns and τ3 = 2.10 ns, and an average lifetime value much shorter than those obtained for its counterparts, as represented in Fig. 14a. The contribution of the longest τ3-component – attributed to NR molecules formed as a result of the homo-ET reaction – decreases from 70 to 5%, suggesting that the ET deactivation channel is not as efficient as in the other MOFs. Moreover, the shortest τ1-component is decaying in the whole spectral region, and therefore, the lack of short rising component indicates that either the homo-ET is not occurring in this MOF or it is too fast to be detected by the system. Interestingly, the amino group of the AB linkers of this MOF can interact with the NR molecules via H-bonds, favoring alternative and more efficient relaxation pathways such as electron transfer from the organic linker to the NR dye molecules. These new deactivation channels could explain the inhibition of the ET phenomenon observed for the other NR composites (Fig. 15a). To further corroborate this mechanism, time-resolved experiments of NR@Al-ITQ-EB in the presence of vapor of aniline were performed. When this material was exposed to aniline, the obtained time constants (τ1 = 0.11 ns, τ2 = 0.55 ns and τ3 = 2.31 ns) were very similar to those reported for NR@Al-ITQ-AB. In contrast to the pristine NR@Al-ITQ-EB, the shortest component was observed as decay in the whole spectral range, providing a clear proof that in the presence of aniline or other electron donating amine moieties (4-aminobenzoic acid – AB), there exists a faster and more efficient deactivation pathway involving an electron transfer from the amine derivative to the adsorbed NR molecules, which hampers the homo-ET reaction (Fig. 15b).
Fig. 15 (a) Illustration of the proposed scenario observed when NR molecules are distributed over the Al-ITQ-AB MOF, while (b) is a scheme displaying the photophysical processes and their corresponding times happening in the excited NR@Al-ITQ-AB composite. Adapted with permission from ref. 125 (ACS Appl. Mater. Interfaces, 2018, 10, 32885–32894). Copyright 2018 American Chemical Society. |
The ultrafast dynamics of NR@Al-ITQ-EB and NR@Al-ITQ-AB was also characterized and compared with the NR@Al-ITQ-HB hybrid material (Fig. 14b and c). The emission decays of NR@Al-ITQ-EB were similar to those described for NR@Al-ITQ-HB, with three time components of 1.2 ps, 87 ps and 2.59 ns. The two shortest components appear as decays in the bluest region and as rising components in the reddest one, reflecting the occurrence of two photoinduced processes. In agreement with the data described above, the intermediate (87 ps) component corresponds to the homo-ET process, while 1.2 ps is the ICT taking place within the NR after its photoexcitation. However, this ICT reaction is much slower (1.2 ps) than that observed for the NR@Al-ITQ-HB composite (0.5 ps) due to the interaction of the adsorbed NR molecules with the more polar regions (Al clusters) of the 2D-MOF because of the shorter linker in Al-ITQ-EB. This increased polarity stabilizes the locally excited state of the NR and increases the energy barrier of the ICT reaction. On the other hand, the ultrafast behavior of NR@Al-ITQ-AB is different from the other materials, with 3 time components of (1 ps, 17 ps and 115 ps, Fig. 14d). The longest component corresponds to the lifetime of NR aggregates, while the shortest reflects the ICT reaction within the NR molecules. However, the intermediate component, not detected for the other composites, reveals the presence of a new deactivation pathway, and in agreement with the mechanism described above, is evidence of the emission quenching of a population of NR species interacting with the AB linker and undergoing an electron transfer reaction (Fig. 15b).
The photodynamics of this material is rich and complex, with the emission decays fitted by a sum of 4 exponential components, giving time constants of τ1 = 0.15 ns, τ2 = 0.34 ns, τ3 = 1.18 ns, and τ4 = 3.31 ns.126 The shortest τ1-component is the emission of NR molecules from their LE state, while the second τ2-component, which appears as a decay in the shorter wavelengths and as a rise in the longer ones, is related to the homo-ET process, similar to what was found for the NR@Al-ITQ-HB composite. However, this ET reaction is much slower (from 0.22 to 0.34 ns) because of the change in the polarity of the MOF material due to the replacement of the Al clusters by the Zr ones. Finally, the 1.18 and 3.31 ns-components are assigned to the emission of NR aggregates and NR molecules formed through the ET reaction, respectively. To further understand this mechanism, the photodynamics of NR@Zr-ITQ-HB was investigated by measuring its time-resolved emission spectra (TRES, Fig. 16a). Clearly, at short times (<200 ps), it is possible to observe an emission band in the region ranging between 600 and 650 nm, which promptly diminishes its intensity until its complete disappearance at 1 ns. Hence, this band corresponds to the emission of NR molecules from their LE state. In addition, at shorter times there is a band at 650 nm, whose intensity decreases, with a concomitant increase in the intensity of the band located at 700 nm (Fig. 16a). This clearly correlates with the ET process where the NR molecules (emission at 650 nm) suffer from a homo-ET process generating the population of NR species emitting at the reddest spectral region (700 nm) and having the longest lifetimes (3.31 ns), therefore further corroborating the proposed photodynamical mechanism.
Fig. 16 (a) Normalized time-resolved emission spectra (TRES) of NR@Zr-ITQ-HB upon its photoexcitation at 470 nm. (b) fs-emission transient decays of NR@Zr-ITQ-HB in powder form upon its photoexcitation at 470 nm and gated at the indicated wavelengths. Adapted from ref. 126; J. Photochem. Photobiol., A, 2021, 404, 112887, Copyright (2021), with permission from Elsevier. |
The ultrafast dynamics of NR@Zr-ITQ-HB is not very different from that described for NR@Al-ITQ-HB.126 The analysis of the fs-emission decays gives a sub-picosecond component of 0.6 ps, which is decaying at shorter wavelengths while rising at longer ones, and a second one of 10 ps, observed only at shorter wavelengths (Fig. 16b). The first component is assigned to the ICT reaction happening within the photoexcited NR, while the 10 ps component is the VC of the molecule. The only difference between the ultrafast photodynamics of those 2 materials is the slightly slower ICT reaction of NR molecules adsorbed on the Zr-based MOF and explained in terms of the different polarity of the local environment in the two materials having different metal clusters.
Fig. 17 (a) The top sections are real photos of the DCM/Al-ITQ-HB (under daylight) containing increasing amounts of DCM, while the top graphs correspond to the UV-visible absorption (left) and emission (right) spectra of these materials. The different dye concentrations are 1 × 10−3 M (blue solid line), 1 × 10−4 M (green dashed line), and 5 × 10−6 M (pink dashed-dotted line). (b) Illustration of the photoprocesses and related times taking place upon photoexcitation of DCM/Al-ITQ-HB materials. (c) Representation of the emission intensity (in %) of the DCM/Al-ITQ-HB material before and after its exposure to vapors of the indicated aniline or aniline derivatives. (d) Schematic artwork of the emission quenching mechanism of the DCM/Al-ITQ-HB in the presence of aniline, involving an electron transfer process favored by H-bond interactions. Adapted from ref. 127 with permission from MDPI. |
In similarity with the NR composites, the time-resolved emission decays of these materials also showed multiexponential behavior with time constants of τ1 = 180–420 ps, τ2 = 1.4–1.5 ns, and τ3 = 2.5–2.7 ns. The intermediate component (τ2) is attributed to the emission lifetime of DCM monomers, as it resembles the emission lifetime of DCM in different organic solvent solutions, whereas the longest component (τ3), whose contribution is higher at longer wavelengths, corresponds to the emission lifetime of J-aggregates (Fig. 17b). The shortest component (τ1), which is decaying at shorter wavelengths but rising at longer ones is attributed to two deactivation pathways. On the one side, this component contributes more to the signal at shorter wavelengths, so it reflects the emission lifetime of DCM H-aggregates. On the other, as it is rising in the reddest spectral region, it also evidences the occurrence of a photophysical phenomenon at S1. In accordance with the mechanism described for the NR@Al-ITQ-HB, this is assigned to a homo-ET reaction happening between neighboring adsorbed DCM molecules (Fig. 17b). Moreover, it was proved that this ET occurs from the H-aggregates, since the rising component disappeared when the material was excited with longer wavelengths (510 nm), where the H-aggregates are not photoexcited.
The luminescent properties of the DCM@Al-ITQ-HB (the initial concentration of DCM was 1 × 10−4 M) were leveraged to detect vapors of harmful compounds such as aniline and some amino derivatives.127 When this material was exposed to a saturated atmosphere of aniline, methylaniline, or benzylamine, it experienced a quenching of its emission intensity (up to 45% of the initial emission intensity, Fig. 17c). At first instance, this quenching could be explained in terms of an electron transfer from the amine derivatives to the photoexcited DCM dye; however, the energy levels of benzylamine are not suitable for such an electron transfer to occur, and the dimethylamine molecule, with a HOMO level much higher than the aniline itself, did not produce any quenching in the emission intensity of DCM@Al-ITQ-HB (Fig. 17c). Hence, the quenching mechanism was explained by attending to the molecular structure of the analytes. Aniline, methylaniline and benzylamine have a H-atom in their structure, which can interact with the DCM dye through H-bonds, thus favoring the electron transfer reaction and quenching the emission of the composite (Fig. 17d). Therefore, despite that the dimethylaniline has a higher energetic HOMO, it cannot undergo this electron transfer, as it does not contain any H-atom in its structure to interact with the DCM molecules adsorbed on the MOF. These results open a novel avenue for the development of luminescent guest@2D-MOF materials for their implementation in sensing devices of toxic pollutants in the vapor phase.
Finally, to summarize Section 6, Table 2 displays the values of the time constants obtained for the related photoprocesses and the fluorescence lifetimes recorded for the different composites formed by NR and DCM interacting with the different MOFs of the ITQ family: Al-ITQ-HB, Al-ITQ-EB, Al-ITQ-AB and Zr-ITQ-HB, where HB = heptylbenzoate, EB = ethylbenzoate and AB = aminobenzoate.
Composite | Photoprocesses | Fluorescence lifetimes | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
ICT/ps | VC/ps | ET/ns | eT/ps | CSS/ns | ETS/ns | Aggregates/ns | |
The terms ICT, VC, ET, eT, CSS and ETS stand for intramolecular charge transfer, vibrational cooling, energy transfer, electron transfer, electron injection, charge-separated state and energy transfer state, respectively.a For DCM@Al-ITQ-HB, the 0.18 ns component is for H-aggregates while the 2.5 ns one is for J-aggregates. | |||||||
NR@Al-ITQ-HB121 | 0.42 | 9.0 | 0.22 | — | 0.22 | 3.61 | 1.33 |
NR@Al-ITQ-EB125 | 1.2 | — | 0.09 | — | 0.09 | 2.60 | 0.93 |
NR@Al-ITQ-AB125 | 1.0 | — | — | 17 | 0.13 | — | 0.54 |
NR@Zr-ITQ-HB126 | 0.60 | 10.0 | 0.34 | — | 0.34 | 3.31 | 1.18 |
DCM@Al-ITQ-HB127 | — | — | — | — | — | 1.4–1.5 | 0.18/2.5a |
NR/dichloromethane113 | 1.0 | 1.0 | — | — | 4.4 | — | — |
DCM/dichloromethane102 | — | — | — | — | 1.1 | — | — |
For the synthesis of more complex hybrid organic–inorganic materials by assembling preformed 1D nanofibers, several methodologies can be explored in the future. The layer-by-layer assembly could be used to build complex multilayer structures by alternately depositing oppositely charged materials. Through this method, preformed 1D metalorganic nanofibers would serve as building blocks. The nanofibers could be surface modified with charged functional groups or even polyelectrolytes to impart electrostatic interactions and immersed in a positively charged solution followed by rinsing to remove excess material and then dipped in a negatively charged solution. This process could be repeated to create multiple layers, allowing control over the overall thickness and composition of the hybrid materials. Another method is the template-assisted assembly based on using a sacrificial template to guide the assembly of 1D nanofibers. One valid approach would be to utilize porous templates, such as membranes or nanoporous materials, with controlled pore sizes and shapes. The preformed 1D nanofibers could be dispersed or impregnated within the template. Post-treatment steps, such as washing or annealing, might be required to enhance the interfacial interactions and stability. Another recently proposed approach is an eco-friendly salt-templated synthesis of luminescent guests incarcerated within 2D MOF nanosheets (MONs) for tunable emissive materials.135 This is a promising methodology for synthesizing 2D guest@MON materials, but more information is still required about how to control the entrapment of guests and whether it is possible to incarcerate guests of larger sizes within the 2D sheets. Finally, a recently reported strategy for fine-tuning the MOF color that could be applied also to 2D ITQ MOFs combines postsynthetic modification (PSM) of the chromophoric linkers of an amino-functionalized UiO-68 MOF with computationally guided selection of specific linker modifiers to rationally tune the chromophore band gap.136
On the other hand, advanced theoretical methods that describe the complex structure of the family of 2D ITQ MOFs and the behaviour of the excited guests interacting with the frameworks are important to get a precise picture of the atomic and orbital levels. Time-dependent density functional theory (TD-DFT) and time-dependent density functional perturbation theory (TD-DFPT) methods with refined functionals and basis sets can be used to calculate the optical properties of the hybrid materials.136 With the advancement and further development of machine learning and artificial intelligence algorithms, there is a great opportunity to apply these prediction tools to design, select and fine-tune the structure and properties of the desired MOFs.137–139 The results of such high-level predictions and calculations must be also experimentally verified. However, the ultrafast spectroscopic techniques still present experimental limitations and technical issues. These limitations are mostly related to the heterogeneous nature of the samples, which affects the quality of the obtained experimental data. In that sense, advanced ultrafast vibrational, electronic and X-ray spectroscopies, and 4D electron microscopy are some of the modern tools to explore the intimate interactions in the formed composites at atomic and short-time scales.140–143 Another step towards relating the structure of the 2D ITQ MOFs with the localization and photodynamics of the guests would be the combination of techniques with enough spectral and spatial resolution that can monitor the weakly bonded composites. In this direction, recent developments have demonstrated the feasibility of scattering-type scanning near-field optical microscopy (s-SNOM) and nano-Fourier transform infrared (nanoFTIR) spectroscopy to characterize MOF–guest interactions at the nanoscale.135,144 This review has demonstrated the possibility to confer luminescence properties to 2D ITQ MOFs by employing the more classical strategy of encapsulating fluorescent dyes within the MOF structures.111 This approach has been successfully applied in both 3D and other 2D MOF composites giving rise to materials with tunable optoelectronic properties, such as generating long-lived charge separated states or long-lived photoluminescence.145–152 However, a more challenging aspect that needs to be addressed would be the fabrication of composites with intrinsic luminescence arising from the organic ligands and the interactions with the metal clusters. Thus, with the improvement of our fundamental knowledge of both the synthesis, structure and photoinduced processes within these MOFs, we should be able to address further challenges in photocatalysis, such as selective control and better yield of photoinduced reaction, and even expand the applicability to the field of photonics to produce sensors with better sensitivity and selectivity or more efficient light absorbing and converting LEDs.
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2023 |