Lindong
Ma
,
Meihui
Liu
,
Xinyuan
Zhou
,
Cancan
Li
and
Tie
Wang
*
Tianjin Key Laboratory of Life and Health Detection, Life and Health Intelligent Research Institute, Tianjin University of Technology, Tianjin 300384, China. E-mail: wangtie@email.tjut.edu.cn
First published on 14th July 2023
Advancements in life and health detection technology can greatly improve early disease diagnosis and treatment options for patients. Surface-enhanced Raman scattering (SERS) technology has become a preferred method for life and health detection due to its numerous advantages over traditional detection methods. However, the construction of SERS substrates with high sensitivity, selectivity, and repeatability remains a challenge. To overcome these challenges, metal–organic frameworks (MOFs) have emerged as promising solutions because of their unique structures and functions. The design and construction of MOF-based SERS sensing platforms with specific structures and functions are crucial to achieving the goal of life and health detection. This review outlines the synthesis strategies for MOF-based SERS substrates with various structures and functions and highlights the unique roles and performances of MOFs in SERS sensing platforms. During the detection process, MOFs can enrich trace target molecules to enhance detection sensitivity, capture selectively target molecules to improve specificity, exhibit synergistic effects to increase detection signal intensity and improve detection reproducibility and stability. Furthermore, this review explores the applications of MOF-based SERS sensing platforms in life and health detection, including breath analysis, fluid detection, and bioimaging. Finally, the challenges and opportunities faced by MOF-based SERS sensing platforms are discussed in the field of life and health detection, as well as their trend toward miniaturization and intelligentization. With continuous research and development, MOF-based SERS sensing platforms are poised to become a cornerstone of life and health monitoring in the future.
Traditional Raman spectroscopy has several limitations, including low sensitivity, weak signals, poor reproducibility, and susceptibility to fluorescence background interference, which restrict its application.9 To overcome these limitations, researchers have been exploring new Raman detection technologies. The emergence of SERS has significantly improved the sensitivity of Raman spectroscopy analysis and has thus been widely used in various analytical detection fields.10 SERS is a highly sensitive vibrational spectroscopy technique that combines Raman spectroscopy with plasmonic materials that exhibit electromagnetic enhancement effects.9,11,12 The plasmonic substrates can enhance the Raman signal, making it particularly useful for detecting trace targets. This enhancement provides many benefits, including detection sensitivity and accuracy. The effectiveness of SERS depends mainly on the substrates of SERS, typically composed of plasmonic nanoparticles or nanostructured surfaces with strong surface plasmon resonance. In addition, the target analyte must be close to the SERS hotspots to obtain a strong signal. Designing and synthesizing SERS substrates with high Raman signal enhancement is crucial to building a powerful SERS sensing platform.13,14 Although some SERS platforms meet specific requirements such as reproducibility, stability, and sensitivity, existing SERS substrates have difficulties handling low concentrations, high speed flow, and complex real samples due to insufficient affinity between the plasmonic surface and the analytes and other molecular interferences.15,16 These problems seriously hinder the widespread application of SERS in life and health detection. Therefore, there is an urgent need for new materials to construct high-performance SERS sensing platforms for life and health detection.
Materials science has played an important role in the advancement of analytical and detection technologies by developing advanced materials to improve sensitivity, selectivity, and reproducibility.17,18 MOFs, or metal–organic frameworks, are a class of crystalline porous materials composed of metal ions and organic ligands that can be designed and synthesized to overcome these challenges.19–21 MOFs possess excellent properties such as good stability, a large surface area and porosity, a uniform nano-level cavity structure, and functionalized modification on both inner and outer surfaces, making them ideal for analysis and detection.22–25 In particular, MOFs have gained attention in the field of SERS technology due to their outstanding performance characteristics, including strong affinity for target molecules, molecular sieving effects, and stability in complex environments. By integrating plasmonic nanoparticles into MOFs, researchers can construct MOF-based SERS sensing platforms that offer inherent advantages in improving SERS for life and health detection. For example, the large specific surface area, tunable pore size and easy modification and functionalization of MOFs can effectively enrich and selectively capture trace analytes in complex systems.26–29 Overall, introducing MOFs to prepare high-performance MOF-based SERS sensing platforms has been proven to be an effective method to overcome the current bottleneck of SERS and improve its capabilities in analysis and detection.
MOFs have emerged as a promising solution for overcoming the challenges faced by traditional SERS sensing platforms in SERS detection. Researchers widely recognize the crucial role of MOF-based SERS sensors in analysis and detection. As these platforms continue to be designed and prepared, their advantages and opportunities become increasingly apparent. While some review articles have examined the development of MOF-based SERS sensing platforms, they lack a detailed overview of MOF-based SERS sensing platforms in life and health detection.30–34 This article primarily reviews the latest progress of MOF-based SERS sensing platforms, highlights the significant role of MOFs in MOF-based SERS sensing platforms and discusses their applications in life and health detection (Fig. 1). First, we classify and summarize the synthesis strategies and structures of MOF-based SERS substrates. Next, we elaborate on the unique roles and detection performance of MOFs in SERS sensing platforms, such as enriching trace target molecules to improve detection sensitivity, selectively capturing target molecules to improve specificity, synergistic effects to increase detection signal intensity, and improving detection reproducibility and stability, combined with classical examples. Then, we explore the application of MOF-based SERS sensing platforms in life and health detection, including exhalation detection, body fluid detection, and biological imaging. Finally, we discuss the challenges and opportunities faced by MOF-based SERS sensing platforms in life and health detection, and their future development trends towards miniaturization and intelligence. This review aims to encourage further advancement of MOF-based SERS sensing platforms in the field of life and health detection.
In this method of synthesizing MOFs, the presence of capping agents or surfactants on the surface of PNPs plays a vital role. These agents provide interaction sites for the synthesis of MOFs, with the PNPs serving as heterogeneous nucleation centers, which to some extent suppress the spontaneous formation of MOFs in solution. A common approach is to introduce “binders” such as polyvinyl pyrrolidone (PVP) and cetyltrimethylammonium bromide (CTAB) to modify PNPs, thereby facilitating the growth and nucleation of MOFs on their surfaces.49 For instance, Huo and his team reported a controllable encapsulation strategy in which PVP-stabilized NPs of varying sizes, shapes, and compositions were encapsulated within ZIF-8, resulting in well-dispersed and fully encapsulated NPs within the ZIF-8 framework (Fig. 2A).48 This strategy involved functionalizing the surface of the NPs with PVP and optimizing the crystallization of ZIF-8. Under optimized experimental conditions, core–shell-structured NPs@MOFs composite materials were prepared by crystallizing ZIF-8 in the presence of PVP-modified NPs in methanol. This strategy works for a wide range of NPs, allowing various NPs to be incorporated without aggregation and controlling their spatial distribution within the MOF shells, thereby opening up new avenues for the use of NPs@MOFs composite materials as SERS sensing platforms. Wang and his team have successfully synthesized gold superparticles (GSPs) that possess the ability to self-assemble into spherical shapes.14 These GSPs were then encapsulated with ZIF-8 to create core–shell structures called GSPs@ZIF-8, which serve as excellent substrates for surface-enhanced Raman scattering (Fig. 2B). The production of GSPs was accomplished via a revised technique for assembling microemulsions with water-in-oil (W/O). In this method, the hydrophobic bonds linking the oil amine on the AuNPs with the alkyl chains of dodecyl trimethyl ammonium bromide (DTAB) were weakened to generate superparticles that possess SERS “hot spots”. (Fig. 2C). PVP was introduced to stabilize GSPs in different solvents and promote the growth of MOF shells. A ZIF-8 shell with a thickness of approximately 150 nm was coated on a single GSP core to form GSPs@ZIF-8 (Fig. 2D). Ionic surfactants such as DTAB were used to adjust the surface of superparticles to minimize the energy required for MOF nucleation and growth, thereby suppressing the uniform crystal growth of ZIF-8. Energy-dispersive X-ray elemental mapping revealed that Zn was evenly distributed throughout the nanostructure, while Au was concentrated in the core (Fig. 2E and F). Meanwhile, Li and his team showed that by controlling the volume and concentration of the precursor, different core–shell Au@ZIF-8 and their structures could be obtained.39 For example, the addition of organic ligand dimethylimidazole to a low concentration gold solution could precisely prepare nanostructures with different shell thicknesses (3–50 nm) by adjusting the amount of Zn2+ and 2-methylimidazole added. On the other hand, adding the organic ligand dimethylimidazole to a high-concentration gold solution can control the formation of multi-core–shell structures, leading to better control of the distance between AuNPs.
Fig. 2 Composite materials of PNPs/MOFs with core–shell structure. (A) A schematic diagram of a controlled encapsulation strategy to prepare NPs@ZIF-8.48 Reproduced with permission from Springer Nature, copyright 2012. (B) A schematic diagram of the preparation of GPSs@ZIF-8. Scale bar: 1 μm. (C) SEM image of the GSPs. Inset: the schematic diagram of GSPs. (D) TEM image of the GPSs@ZIF-8. Scale bar: 100 nm. (E and F) Energy-dispersive X-ray elemental map of GSPs@ZIF-8.14 Reproduced with permission from John Wiley and Sons, copyright 2018. |
To establish a highly effective SERS sensing platform for the accurate detection of biomarkers, many research teams have developed MOF-based SERS substrates with yolk–shell structure. These yolk–shell SERS substrates can effectively eliminate interference from other components and have lower detection limits compared to core–shell structured SERS substrates. The hollow MOF shells in these substrates enrich more gas molecules and the enriched molecules come into contact or react with the surface of PNPs, producing strong SERS signals. For example, Wang and his team prepared a hollow Co–Ni layered double hydroxide (LDH) nanocage on Ag nanowires (Ag@LDH) (Fig. 3A).41 They accomplished this by preparing a hollow Co–Ni LDH nanocage to adsorb gas molecules, resulting in SERS sensing platforms based on Ag@LDH. In the first step, 2-methylimidazole nucleated with Co2+ ions on the surface of polyvinylpyrrolidone-modified Ag nanowires and continued to grow to form an Ag@ZIF-67 composite material (Fig. 3C). In the second step, ion etching of the metal–organic framework transformed it into a cobalt–nickel-layered double metal hydroxide with a nanocage structure, forming an Ag@Co–Ni LDH composite material (Fig. 3D). Similarly, to precisely identify the biomarkers present in exhaled breath and remove any obstacles from other components, Wang and his team proposed employing hollow ZIF-8 that encloses GSPs that possess yolk–shell structures as the SERS substrate (GSPs@H-ZIF-8).40 The team fabricated a composite material with yolk–shell structures by incorporating GSPs into a hollow ZIF-8 framework, which was formed using tannic acid (Fig. 3E). The PVP-stabilized GSPs were introduced into a solution containing ZIF-8 precursors, resulting in the formation of a GSPs@ZIF-8 composite material (Fig. 3G). Subsequently, the interior of the ZIF-8 was etched with tannic acid, leading to the creation of a hollow layer of ZIF-8 that preserved the structure of the framework (Fig. 3H).
Fig. 3 Composite materials of PNPs/MOFs with yolk–shell structure. (A) Schematic diagram of the synthetic pathway of Ag@LDH. (B) TEM image of Ag nanowired. (C) TEM image of Ag@ZIF-67. (D) TEM image of Ag@LDH.41 Reproduced with permission from John Wiley and Sons, copyright 2019. (E) Schematic diagram of the synthetic pathway of GSPs@H-ZIF-8. (F) TEM image of AuNPs. (I) TEM image of GSPs. (G) TEM image of GSPs@ZIF-8. (H) TEM image of GSPs@H-ZIF-8.40 Reproduced with permission from John Wiley and Sons, copyright 2022. |
Using the “bottle-around-ship” strategy, researchers have successfully synthesized SERS substrates with both core–shell and yolk–shell structures, which have important applications in the field of life and health detection. While both structures are commonly used in SERS-based detection, they also have their own advantages and disadvantages. One advantage of the core–shell SERS substrate is that it can provide good SERS activity and aggregated PNPs can form a porous structure, further enhancing the SERS signal. For instance, compared to bare GSPs, the GSPs@ZIF-8 structure synthesized using the “bottle-around-ship” strategy can offer a larger hot spot field.14 Another advantage is that MOFs, as a new class of nanomaterials, have a controllable pore size, highly structured and detailed surface chemical properties, and can protect PNPs from contamination by encapsulation. Thus, under the protection of the MOFs' shells, PNPs can maintain their stability and repeatability during life and health monitoring, thereby improving the accuracy and reliability of SERS detection. The core–shell SERS substrate can also adjust its SERS performance by controlling the composition, shape, and size of the nanomaterials, achieving selective detection and quantitative analysis of the target molecules. Additionally, the large specific surface area and adjustable pore size of the MOF shell allow molecules to diffuse to the surface of the SERS substrate, thereby improving the detection sensitivity. However, there are also some limitations to the core–shell SERS substrate, such as the complex synthesis steps and high preparation cost, because of the need to modify the MOFs’ shell on the surface of PNPs. The encapsulation of the MOFs' shell may also reduce the contact between PNPs and samples, weakening the SERS signal. Furthermore, the addition of the MOFs' shell may lower the SERS sensitivity of the metal NPs since the MOFs' shell can absorb some laser energy and inhibit Raman scattering. However, researchers can reduce this signal attenuation by adjusting the composition of the MOFs' shell, such as controlling parameters like the thickness of the MOFs, the size of the pores and the chemical composition to improve the SERS response. Compared to other SERS substrates, yolk shell structures offer some distinct advantages. First, the PNPs in these structures are enclosed within the porous shell layer of MOFs. This layer provides a larger surface area for adsorbing target molecules and can help aggregate these molecules around PNPs, thereby strengthening the SERS signal intensity. For instance, the hollow structure of Ag@LDH synthesized using the “bottle-around-ship” strategy mitigates the diffusion limitation of the original MOF microporous structure for target molecules, thus increasing the detection sensitivity.41 This is particularly useful for capturing and detecting trace gas molecules in exhaled breath. Second, the proximity between PNPs in the yolk shell structures and target molecules is greater, leading to a significant boost in SERS signal intensity due to near-field effects. As a result, SERS substrates with yolk shell structures can achieve higher sensitivity and lower detection limits. However, there are some drawbacks to using yolk–shell structures as SERS substrates. Their fabrication processes are complex and expensive, and they are less stable than core–shell structure SERS substrates, making them susceptible to environmental factors that could affect their performance unpredictably. Therefore, it is essential to choose the appropriate SERS substrate based on the specific application requirements. To develop high-performance SERS sensing platforms for life and health detection, further exploration of PNPs/MOFs with better performance is necessary.
In the conventional impregnation reduction process, confining PNPs inside the pores of MOFs and preventing their aggregation on the exterior surface of MOFs pose significant challenges. Cao and his team effectively utilized an impregnation approach to synthesize MOFs decorated with AuNPs, resulting in enhanced SERS performance (Fig. 4A).53 Artificially created composite materials made up of AuNPs/MOFs exhibit localized surface plaque resonance (LSPR) characteristics and possess a significant adsorption capacity of MOFs. This ability enables the preconcentration of analytes in close proximity to the surface of AuNPs, leading to outstanding SERS performance. This work lays the foundation for the preparation of PNPs/MOFs composite materials as high-performance SERS sensing platforms for life and health detection by utilizing a simple solution impregnation strategy. Feng and his team prepared an AuNPs/AE-MIL-101(Cr) composite material via a solution impregnation method (Fig. 4B and C).54 In this strategy, the pore structure of the MIL-101(Cr) composite material was optimized by phosphoric acid etching, which widened its pore size distribution and made PNPs more accessible to the interior of MOFs. The AuNPs were embedded in acid-etched (AE)-MIL-101(Cr) to prepare the AuNPs/AE-MIL-101(Cr) composite material. By combining the prepared AuNP/AE-MIL-101(Cr) composite material with an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA), a SERS sensing platform was constructed and successfully used to determine human carboxylesterase 1 (HCE1) in plasma from patients with hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC), showing good clinical application potential.
Fig. 4 The randomly embedded PNPs/MOFs composites were synthesized by solution impregnation. (A) Schematic diagram of the synthesis process of AuNPs/MOFs composites for the determination of an analyte.53 Reproduced with permission from the Royal Society of Chemistry, copyright 2017. (B) SEM image of AuNPs/AE-MIL-101 (Cr). (C) TEM image of AuNPs/AE-MIL-101 (Cr). Inset: TEM images of AE-MIL-101 (Cr).54 Reproduced with permission from Springer Nature, copyright 2021. |
The dual solvent method is an effective technique that overcomes the limitations of traditional impregnation methods and prevents the generation of PNPs and the aggregation on the outer surfaces of the MOFs. In this method, a solution containing the metal precursors and MOF materials is thoroughly mixed. The capillary effect of the MOF pores enables the metal precursor solution to penetrate spontaneously into the internal pores of the MOFs. The reducing agent then converts the metal precursor solution into PNPs, resulting in PNPs/MOFs composite materials. Hu and his team used this strategy to prepare AuNPs@MIL-101 composite materials to construct a SERS sensing platform that detects glucose and lactate in tissues (Fig. 5A and B).55 They fully mixed MIL-101 with HAuCl4 solution and prepared AuNPs using a sodium citrate solution as the reducing agent. After a centrifugation treatment, the AuNPs@MIL-101 composite materials were obtained. These composite materials not only act as peroxidase mimetics that catalyze the conversion of non-Raman active reporters into Raman-active reporters but also enhance the Raman signal of active reporters as SERS-active substrates. Furthermore, the team further modified the AuNPs@MIL-101 composite materials by oxidases, creating AuNPs@MIL-101@oxidase-integrated nano-enzymes that measured changes in glucose and lactate related to ischemic stroke in live animal brains. Similarly, Jiang and his team synthesized Au/MIL-101(Fe) SERS substrates with good anti-interference properties by mixing pre-synthesized MIL-101(Fe) with different concentrations of chloroauric acid to allow metal precursors to fully enter MIL-101(Fe) (Fig. 5C–F).56 They rapidly added a sodium citrate solution to prepare the AuNPs. The team constructed a SERS sensing platform to monitor creatinine in urine using the AuNPs@MIL-101 composite materials. The electrostatic interaction between the MIL-101(Fe) framework and creatinine brought it close to the SERS hotspots, significantly enhancing the SERS signal.
Fig. 5 The randomly embedded PNPs/MOFs composites were synthesized using a dual solvent method. (A) TEM image of AuNPs@MIL-101. (B) Schematic illustration of AuNPs@MIL-101 acting as a SERS substrate.55 Reproduced with permission from American Chemical Society, copyright 2017. (C) In situ construction process of Au@MIL-101(Fe). (D) SEM image of MIL-101(Fe). (E and F) TEM images of MIL-101(Fe) and Au@MIL-101(Fe).56 Reproduced with permission from World Scientific Publishing Co Pte Ltd, copyright 2021. |
Using the “bottle-around-ship” strategy, a SERS substrate with a randomly embedded structure was successfully synthesized. The SERS substrates with random embedding structures are commonly used and have the following advantages and disadvantages: (1) compared to core–shell structured SERS substrates, the SERS substrates with random embedding structures are easier to prepare. (2) Due to their complex morphology and high surface roughness, the SERS substrates with random embedding structures can provide very high SERS enhancement effects, resulting in higher sensitivity. (3) The SERS substrates with random embedding structures can be used for various types of targets (including liquids and gases) in life and health detection, making them widely applicable. However, there are also disadvantages in using the SERS substrates with random embedding structures: (1) since their morphology is uncertain, their SERS signals may fluctuate significantly, leading to signal instability. (2) It is difficult to precisely control the size, quantity, and distribution of PNPs within MOFs on SERS substrates with random embedding structures, making their preparation process relatively uncontrollable and challenging for batch production and repeat manufacturing. (3) When PNPs are embedded in MOFs, pore blockage may occur, making it difficult for target molecules to reach the SERS hotspots and thus reducing the performance of the SERS sensors.
For example, Jiang and his team created the SERS substrate AgNPs/MIL-101(Fe) by synthesizing AgNPs in situ on the outer surface of MIL-101(Fe) (Fig. 6A and B).59 In the early stages, TA was coordinated with the unsaturated hydroxyl group of Fe3+ on the surface of MIL-101(Fe) to serve as a reducing agent during functionalization. As a result, Ag+ was able to be reduced by TA directly on the surface of MIL-101(Fe), leading to the formation of the composite material AgNPs/MIL-101(Fe). MIL-101(Fe), being a stable host material, provides an ultrahigh surface area and a large number of adsorption sites that enrich guest molecules near the surface of AgNPs, producing strong SERS signals. Furthermore, using the peroxidase-like activity of Fe-MOFs, the obtained AgNPs/MIL-101(Fe) composite material has been used to construct a SERS sensing platform for detecting biological signal molecules such as dopamine (DA). Yang and his team created a new SERS substrate, Ag–Au-MIL-101, which was modified with para-amino thiophenol (PATP) for detecting DA in serum.61 By utilizing the azo reaction between DA and PATP, the detection selectivity was significantly improved. MIL-101 was dispersed in a silver nitrate solution, followed by the addition of trisodium citrate to form an Ag-MIL-101 solution. Then, NH2OH and HAuCl4 solutions were added to obtain the Ag–Au-MIL-101 composite material. The porous structure of MIL-101 selectively captured DA molecules, bringing them close to the surface of the MOFs with the PATP reaction sites to produce a strong SERS signal response.
Fig. 6 The satellite PNPs/MOFs composites were synthesized. (A) SEM images of AgNPs/MIL-101(Cr). (B) TEM images of AgNPs/MIL-101(Cr).59 Reproduced with permission from American Chemical Society, copyright 2015. (C) Schematic illustration of the preparation of AgNPs/MIL-101(Fe). (D) SEM images of AgNPs/MIL-101. (E) TEM image of AgNPs/MIL-101.60 Reproduced with permission from the Royal Society of Chemistry, copyright 2016. |
Li and his team designed a novel SERS substrate that combined the remarkable adsorption capacity of MIL-101(Cr) with AgNPs as SERS hotspots (Fig. 6C).60In situ synthesis of AgNPs was carried out on the outer surface of MIL-101(Cr) by first initiating the self-polymerization of DA in water to generate polydopamine (PDA), which subsequently was polymerized on the surface of the MOFs. PDA reduced Ag+ on the surface of MIL-101(Cr), leading to the formation of the satellite structure of AgNPs/MIL-101(Cr) (Fig. 6D and E). AgNPs/MIL-101(Cr) was synthesized, which demonstrated the capacity to capture folic acid (FA) through electrostatic interaction, generating a powerful SERS signal. This led to the creation of a SERS sensing platform that could detect FA in biological samples. The research team has also synthesized many SERS substrates with PNPs anchored on MOF surfaces, including AuNPs/Cu-TCPP,62 AgNPs@MOF helical structure,63 AuNPs@MB@HP-UiO-66-NH2,64 TM–Ag@NU-901,65 AuNPs@MOFs,66,67 and Ag@MIL-101(Cr).68
Despite the significant progress made in anchoring PNPs to MOF surfaces as SERS substrates, there are still some challenges that need to be addressed. These challenges include: (1) the relatively high cost of manufacturing satellite-structured SERS substrates, which may hinder their widespread use for life and health detection applications; (2) the complex shape of satellite-structured SERS substrates may make it difficult to achieve directional control and obtain uniform and stable SERS hotspots, which could affect the experimental results; (3) the surface area of satellite-structured SERS substrates is typically smaller than those of other types of SERS substrates, limiting their application in life and health detection; and (4) PNPs located outside the MOF pores pose a challenge in using MOFs as molecular sieves or in studying molecular diffusion kinetics.
Tang and his team prepared AuNPs@MOF-5 nano-composites with uniformly shaped and adjustable sizes using the one-pot method.69 To prepare core–shell AuNPs@MOF-5, they mixed gold and MOF precursors directly in a reaction solution containing DMF, PVP, and ethanol. The growth rate of AuNPs and MOF-5 can be effectively adjusted by controlling the reaction conditions. Subsequently, MOF-5 grew spontaneously on the surface of PVP-coated AuNPs resulting in the creation of a consistent PVP-stabilized core–shell composite material comprising AuNPs@MOF-5. This work opens a door for constructing SERS substrates for life and health detection in SERS sensing platforms by providing a universal technology for preparing PNPs@MOF composite materials with different types of core–shell structures using the one-pot method. Similarly, Zhang and his team synthesized core–shell Au/MOF-74 composite NPs using a one-step method. The composite material comprising Au@MOF-74 showed outstanding SERS activity, signal reproducibility, and stability. A sensitive detection method for 4-NTP was successfully established based on the Au@MOF-74 composite material.70
Although PNPs/MOFs SERS substrates constructed using the one-pot strategy have many advantages, there are still some issues, such as difficulties in forming uniformly distributed SERS “hotspots” with high enhancement efficiency and in controlling the synthesis of MOF shells with different thicknesses and good uniformity after all the reactants are added together. Therefore, more research is needed to develop high-performance SERS sensing platforms for life and health detection using the one-pot strategy.
To improve the ability to capture gaseous biomarkers, Wang and his team applied a coating of ZIF-8 onto self-assembled GSPs, which effectively slowed down the flow rate of gaseous molecules and reduced the decay of the electromagnetic field around the surface of the GSPs.14 The researchers observed significant differences in adsorption between bare GSPs and GSPs@ZIF-8 structures for high-speed moving gaseous molecules. The collision between these molecules and bare GSPs is close to perfectly elastic, with a very short contact time. After impact, most molecules float away at their original speed without losing kinetic energy (Fig. 7A). The MOF shell of GSPs effectively prolongs the contact time, allowing for increased interaction between gaseous molecules and the porous media (Fig. 7B). This interaction involves both molecular interactions between gas molecules and collisions between gas molecules and the porous medium. An increase in the frequency of collisions between SERS substrates and gaseous molecules means that there is a higher possibility of reaction or absorption in GSPs@ZIF-8 than in GSPs, as immediately observed by total internal reflection fluorescence microscopy (Fig. 7C and D). The researchers were able to quantitatively detect the typical lung cancer biomarker 4-ethylbenzaldehyde in exhaled breath, with a limit of detection (LOD) of 10−9 (ppb level).
Fig. 7 MOFs for preconcentration of analytes. (A) and (B) Schematic diagrams of the GSPs and GSPs@ZIF-8 with gas collisions. (C) and (D) Total internal reflection fluorescence micrographs of the gas adsorption process on GSPs and GSPs@ZIF-8 at different times.14 Reproduced with permission from John Wiley and Sons, copyright 2018. |
To detect biomarkers in human breath more sensitively and accurately, Wang and his team prepared hollow Co–Ni LDH nanocages on Ag nanowires to obtain SERS sensors based on Ag@LDH.41 Silver nanowires offer enhanced Raman signals for detecting trace analytes, while hollow LDH nanocages serve as gas-constrained cavities to enhance capture and adsorption of gaseous analytes. As VOCs pass through the porous LDH medium, the speed in the vicinity of the surface of the silver nanowires alters. Although the tortuosity of the flow path between ZIF-67 and LDH is similar, it is larger than the simulated value using the bare silver nanowire streamline diagram (Fig. 8A). As a result of the dissipation of molecular kinetic energy, gaseous analytes can be effectively adsorbed in both the Ag@ZIF-67 and Ag@LDH models. LDH nanocages possess a unique characteristic of loose, hollow structure and a diverse range of pore sizes. This distinctive feature enables them to have superior gas permeability in comparison to ZIF-67. The reason behind this is their specific surface area and pore size distribution properties. In contrast, ZIF-67 has a denser structure with a narrower pore size distribution at the molecular level, which leads to a smaller diffusion coefficient. LDH nanocages have very low adsorption capacity for gaseous analytes, whereas Ag@LDH exhibits a concentration gradient that is comparable to that of Ag nanowires (Fig. 8B). This indicates that the target molecules are restricted to the surface of the Ag nanowires rather than the LDH medium. Further validation was carried out through experiments involving the adsorption of fluorescent molecules. The spatial locations of fluorescent molecules were examined using laser scanning confocal microscopy, for silver wires that were uncoated, coated with ZIF-67 and coated with LDH. Due to elastic collisions between molecules and substrates, the number of fluorescent molecules observed on the exposed Ag nanowires was limited (Fig. 8C). The utilization of the ZIF-67 coating resulted in uniform dispersion of fluorescent molecules within the MOF layer. (Fig. 8D). The presence of LDH nanocages caused fluorescent molecules to be fixed closer to the surface of the silver wire. (Fig. 8E). The detection limit of aldehydes for the SERS sensor was 1.9 ppb.
Fig. 8 MOFs for preconcentration of analytes. (A) Simulation streamline graphs of Ag nanowires, Ag@ZIF-67, and Ag@LDH. (B) Modeling fluctuations in the concentrations of Ag nanowires, Ag@ZIF-67, and Ag@LDH through simulations. (C–E) The confocal microscopy images of surface adsorption of fluorescent gaseous molecules experiment: (C) Ag wires, (D) Ag@ZIF-67, and (E) Ag@LDH. Inset: the florescence image and overlays of fluorescence and transmission images.41 Reproduced with permission from John Wiley and Sons, copyright 2019. (F) Illustration showing the adsorption process between molecules in exhaled gas and various substrates. (G) Modeling the variation in concentrations of GSPs@ZIF-8 and GSPs@H-ZIF-8 through simulations. (H) Simulations of alterations in the concentrations of GSPs@ZIF-8 and GSPs@H-ZIF-8. Inset: TEM images of GSPs@ZIF-8 and GSPs@H-ZIF-8.40 Reproduced with permission from John Wiley and Sons, copyright 2022. |
Hollow ZIF-8 layers are capable of efficiently enriching gaseous molecules, similar to their solid ZIF-8 layers. After enrichment, the gas molecules can bind with functionalized molecules on the surface of PNPs, resulting in a strong and detectable reset signal. Wang and his team have developed a reliable SERS sensing platform strategy by coating GSPs with hollow structure ZIF-8 to detect exhaled VOCs (Fig. 8F).40 Gas molecules are decelerated in their diffusion rate and accumulate within the cavity, while passing through the porous ZIF-8 (Fig. 8G). As a result, the efficiency of the chemical reaction for the target molecules is enhanced in the absence of kinetic energy. This leads to an increased number of molecules being trapped on the surface of the GSPs, resulting in the generation of robust Raman signals. (Fig. 8H). In contrast to solid MOFs, the active sites of modified molecules are free from non-reactive interfering molecules, thus allowing for more efficient target molecule capture. As a result of this, the lower LOD and reduced interference of non-target molecules in the SERS spectra make the results more trustworthy compared to GSPs@ZIF-8.
VOCs serve as crucial biomarkers for the early diagnosis of diseases. However, due to their low concentration and high mobility, there are limited collisions between gas molecules and SERS substrates, which severely affect the detection sensitivity. However, the MOF shell plays an essential role in the selective detection of gaseous targets in complex VOC systems by pre-excluding them. Wang and his team used GSPs@ZIF-8 SERS substrates for selective detection of aldehydes, which are lung cancer biomarkers found in exhaled patient breath (Fig. 9A).14 Studies have shown that ZIF-8 can adsorb gaseous aromatic compounds such as benzene, xylene, toluene, and even 1,2,4-trimethylbenzene. In this system, benzaldehyde, glutaraldehyde, and 4-ethylbenzaldehyde can penetrate GSPs@ZIF-8, while 2-naphthaldehyde is excluded (Fig. 9B). Prolonged contact time between gaseous aldehyde molecules and SERS hotspots can help in producing Raman signals from gaseous aldehyde analytes.
Fig. 9 Selectivity and synergistic effect based on MOFs. (A) The method of achieving selectivity for a particular analyte. (B) The largest size of the four primary analytes could permeate the holes of ZIF-8. (C) The chemical process is employed to bind aldehyde vapors covalently to the GSPs. (D) Schematic diagrams of LSPR hotspots located at the periphery of GSPs and GSPs@ZIF-8. (E) 2D-FDTD simulations of AuNPs and AuNPs@ZIF-8.14 Reproduced with permission from John Wiley and Sons, copyright 2018. |
In addition to physical adsorption, MOFs can selectively adsorb target molecules through chemical recognition. Yusuke and his team combined mesoporous plasma gold films with microporous homochiral metal–organic frameworks (HMOFs) to prepare graded porous hybrid membranes.82 They selectively detected pseudoephedrine (PE) in complex biological samples using surface-enhanced Raman spectroscopy. HMOF thin films are based on chiral ligands (alanine derivatives) as functional layers. In the presence of complex biological matrices, mixed-layered porous substrates provide control over molecular transport within pores and prevent blood protein penetration. The SERS substrate mentioned above utilizes surface-enhanced Raman spectroscopy technology to effectively detect and distinguish between two PE enantiomers with exceptional accuracy and sensitivity in even the most complex biological matrices, all without the need for preliminary separation.
Wang and his team utilized the finite-difference time-domain (FDTD) method to simulate the electric field distribution of GSPs and GSPs@ZIF-8.14 The simulation results demonstrated that the electromagnetic field intensity at the GSPs@ZIF-8 interface was stronger than that at the GSPs/air interface (Fig. 9D). This is attributed to the high dielectric constant of metal/medium (ZIF-8), which prevents radially attenuated electromagnetic fields.85 Compared to bare GSPs, the GSPs@ZIF-8 structure provided a larger hotspot field (Fig. 9E), where both the bound and unbound analytes may be enhanced by the electromagnetic field. As a result, the Raman scattering intensity of the probe molecules on the GSPs@ZIF-8 core–shell structure under experimentation was roughly 1.5 times higher than that observed on the uncoated GSP substrate. These findings suggest that increasing the SERS signal strength through MOF-based SERS systems to increase electromagnetic field penetration depth is a universal strategy.
Recently, Jiang and his team created a pliable SERS substrate by embellishing AgNPs with ZIF-67 as the active constituent and adopting cotton fabric as the support framework.87 When AgNPs come into direct contact with ZIF-67, charge transfer often occurs between them to balance the Fermi level and achieve equilibrium. Therefore, upon laser irradiation, polarization and charge transfer take place, leading to local electromagnetic field enhancement at the interface between AgNPs and ZIF-67, resulting in significantly improved SERS performance. Although there is limited research in this area currently, utilizing the synergistic effect of MOFs and metal NPs to develop efficient SERS substrates is a promising strategy.
Wang and his team conducted an extensive study on the stability of the GSPs@ZIF-8 and GSPs@H-ZIF-8 SERS sensing platforms in complex gas environments.40 In such environments, interfering molecules could potentially appear at the detection site, leading to unstable SERS sensor signals and reduced detection ability, which limits the practical application of these sensors. To ensure the stability of the substrates under these conditions, researchers injected mixed gases with interference molecules and 4-ethylbenzaldehyde in concentrations of 10 ppm into both substrates for continuous testing. Due to the remarkable adsorption ability of MOFs at the detection site, Raman signals for different molecules such as toluene and hydrocarbons were observed randomly on the GSPs@ZIF-8 substrate. However, the Raman signal of the hollow structure remained stable throughout the test. Both substrates underwent ten parallel experiments and the results showed that the spectral signal of the hollow structure had a higher repeatability and stability than that of its counterpart.
MIL-101 is a type of MOF that is highly regarded due to its impressive characteristics such as high surface area, large pore size, and exceptional stability in water and solvents. Recently, Li and his team created an extremely sensitive SERS substrate by embedding AuNPs into MIL-101.44 The researchers then evaluated the stability and reproducibility of this substrate by measuring the SERS performance of both AuNPs/MIL-101 and AuNP colloids in different pH solutions containing benzidine. MIL-101 functions as a reliable host material by offering a closed space and adsorption field for analyte enrichment near the embedded metal surface. The SERS activity of AuNPs/MIL-101 remains stable within the pH range of 2–12, making it a highly desirable substrate for SERS detection. In comparison, the use of gold colloidal suspensions for detecting SERS can be limited because of the inherent instability caused by changes in the detection environment such as pH or ionic strength. This instability can result in a loss of the SERS signal, and colloids may even precipitate from the solution. Additionally, due to the irregular aggregation of AuNP colloids, their Raman intensity varies significantly with pH. Overall, Li and his team's study demonstrated that the composite AuNPs/MIL-101 SERS substrate is not only highly sensitive but also possesses excellent stability and reproducibility.
To optimize MOF-based SERS sensing platforms, it is important to take into account the impact of the MOFs' crystal structure and chemical reactions on their stability. This will help ensure that the platform performs well and remains stable in applications such as life and health detection. In addition, it is crucial to select appropriate MOFs based on the specific application environment. This will ensure that the MOFs exhibit good stability and optimal performance under these conditions. By considering both the crystal structures and chemical properties of the MOFs, as well as the specific environmental factors of the intended applications, researchers can design more effective and reliable MOF-based SERS sensing platforms.
Structures | MOF-based substrates | Synthesis strategies | Targets | Applications | Ref. |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Core–shell | GSPs@ZIF-8 | Bottle-around-ship | 4-Ethylbenzaldehyde | VOCs | 14 |
Yolk–shell | Ag@LDH | Bottle-around-ship | 4-Ethylbenzaldehyde | VOCs | 41 |
Yolk–shell | GSPs@H-ZIF-8 | Bottle-around-ship | 4-Ethylbenzaldehyde | VOCs | 40 |
Core–shell | Ag@ZIF-67 | Bottle-around-ship | Benzaldehyde | VOCs | 97 |
Core–shell | GNRs-QDs@NU-901 | Bottle-around-ship | Benzaldehyde | VOCs | 98 |
Core–shell | AgNC@CA@ZIF-8 | Bottle-around-ship | Benzaldehyde, 3-ethylbenzaldehyde | VOCs | 99 |
Randomly embedded | AuNPs@MIL-101(Cr) | Ship-in-a-bottle | Toluene, 4-ethylbenzaldehyde | VOCs | 100 |
Satellite | AgNPs@ZIF-67/g-C3N4 | Ship-on-a-bottle | Benzaldehyde | VOCs | 101 |
Satellite | AuNPs@Cu-TCPP | Ship-on-a-bottle | Carboxylesterase 1 | Serum | 102 |
Satellite | AgNPs@MIL-101(Fe) | Ship-on-a-bottle | Cholesterol | Serum | 103 |
Randomly embedded | AuNP/AE-MIL-101(Cr) | Ship-in-a-bottle | Carboxylesterase 1 | Serum | 54 |
Satellite | AgNPs@homochiral MOF | Ship-on-a-bottle | D/L-cysteine, D/L-asparagine | — | 57 |
Core–shell | Ag@Ni-MOF-1 | Bottle around ship | Cys | Microdialysate | 104 |
Satellite | IRMOF-3@AuTPs | Ship-on-a-bottle | NT-proBNP | Serum | 105 |
Randomly embedded | AuNPs@MIL-101 | Ship-in-a-bottle | Glucose, lactate | Microdialysate | 55 |
Satellite | AuNPs/Cu-TCPP(Fe) | Ship-on-a-bottle | Glucose | Saliva | 62 |
Satellite | AgNPs/MIL-101(Fe) | Ship-on-a-bottle | DA | Urine | 59 |
Randomly embedded | AuNPs/MIL-101 | Ship-in-a-bottle | Alpha-fetoprotein | Serum | 44 |
Satellite | AuNPs/MOF | Ship-on-a-bottle | Transferrin | Serum | 66 |
Core–shell | Au@Cu3(BTC)2 | Bottle-around-ship | Cell | Bioimaging | 106 |
Core–shell | AuNSs@ZIF-8 | Bottle-around-ship | Cell | Bioimaging | 107 |
Core–shell | Au@Ag nanorod@ZIF-8 | Bottle-around-ship | Cell | Bioimaging | 108 |
Wang and his team have proposed a method to enhance the adsorption ability of gaseous molecules on SERS sensing platforms by using GSPs@ZIF-8 SERS substrates to detect VOC biomarkers in the exhaled breath of lung cancer patients, achieving a highly sensitive strategy for early cancer diagnosis (Fig. 10A).14 ZIF-8 plays multiple roles in the core–shell SERS substrates, including: (1) modifying the transport pathways and processes of gas molecules through the porous structure of the ZIF-8 shell, overcoming the obstacle of gas molecule adsorption on solid matrices; (2) significantly prolonging the contact time between gas molecules and the porous substrate by means of the ZIF-8 shell layer of GSPs, achieving the enrichment of target molecules; (3) playing a crucial part in selective detection, particularly in precluding complex VOC targets within the gas mixture, thus enabling selective detection of target molecules; and (4) safeguarding GSPs from external environmental interference by virtue of its stable framework structure, thereby enhancing the accuracy and reliability of SERS detection. By capturing gaseous aldehydes and reacting them with 4-ATP pre-anchored onto GSPs, the detection limit was 10 ppb, demonstrating great potential for early diagnosis of lung cancer. The GSPs@ZIF-8 structure has the ability to selectively track gaseous cancer biomarkers in mixed gases, demonstrating strong practical potential in actual applications and further enabling the non-invasive identification of lung malignancies.
Fig. 10 Schematic diagram of MOF-based SERS sensing platforms used in human exhaled breath. (A) Schematic diagram of VOC detection via SERS spectroscopy.14 Reproduced with permission from John Wiley and Sons, copyright 2018. (B) Schematic diagram of a SERS sensing platform for VOC detection.41 Reproduced with permission from John Wiley and Sons, copyright 2019. (C) Schematic diagram of breath analysis using an Ag@ZIF-67-based tubular SERS sensor.97 Reproduced with permission from American Chemical Society, copyright 2022. (D) Schematic diagram of the mask sensing device for the breath test.40 Reproduced with permission from John Wiley and Sons, copyright 2022. |
Due to the characteristics of gas flow and porosity, the reproducibility and accuracy of SERS sensing platforms are difficult to achieve, but clinical detection of molecular markers using VOC sensors requires essential reproducibility and accuracy. To advance the practical clinical application of SERS sensors, researchers converted them into barcodes. For example, Wang and his team designed a hollow Co–Ni Ag@LDH to enhance the adsorption and capture of gaseous molecules (Fig. 10B).41 In contrast to Ag@ZIF-67, the target analyte had higher reaction or absorption efficiency at the active SERS site. Therefore, the Ag@LDH SERS sensor exhibited an LOD of 1.9 ppb, which was ten times lower than that of Ag@ZIF-67. By integrating the R, G, and B values of the Raman intensity image, the researchers obtained a unique barcode that represents the aldehyde concentration. Electronic devices such as smartphones and handheld scanners can easily scan and decode these barcodes. The findings of this research indicate the feasible capability of utilizing this sensor as a device to identify and screen biomarkers. Similarly, oxygenated metabolites such as aldehydes and ketones are linked to oxidative stress and inflammation,114,115 which may contribute to the development of cancer.116 Wang and his team have developed a tube-shaped SERS sensor with 4-ATP-modified Ag@ZIF-67 to identify various types of aldehyde–ketone VOCs and exhaled breath samples (Fig. 10C).97 We conducted extensive studies on the SERS spectra of respiratory samples from GC patients and healthy volunteers and transformed them into barcodes for easy application in clinical settings. The findings demonstrate that the tube-shaped SERS sensor has high sensitivity and specificity in diagnosing gastric cancer, thereby offering an alternative solution for early cancer screening as it is non-invasive, quick and user-friendly.
Recently, Wang and his team demonstrated the selective detection of biomarkers in exhaled breath samples using a GSPs@H-ZIF-8 substrate, while minimizing the effect of interfering gas molecules on Raman spectra (Fig. 10D).40 The hollow-structured MOF shell of GSPs@H-ZIF-8 does not trap interfering gas molecules within SERS hotspots, thus preventing reduced LOD and interference signals due to occupancy of sensing sites by interfering molecules. Consequently, GSPs@H-ZIF-8 substrates exhibit LODs for aldehyde molecules that are an order of magnitude lower than those of GSPs@ZIF-8 in complex environments. The substrate was then integrated into a respiratory valve to form a mask-type sensor. Raman spectra were acquired after 20 minutes of wearing, and PC-LDA was used to classify the results with an accuracy of 60%. These findings demonstrate the enormous potential of this sensor in the early detection of lung cancer.
The use of MOFs in the yolk structure of the SERS substrate offers several advantages. First, the MOF shell and cavity structure increase the interaction between the target molecules and the SERS substrate, thereby achieving enrichment of the target molecules. This is because the MOF structure effectively prolongs the contact time between the SERS substrate and target molecules. Second, the uniformly sized cavities with molecular sieving effects confer size-selective properties on the substrate, enabling selective detection of the target molecules. This means that the SERS substrate can selectively detect specific molecules on the basis of their size. Finally, the stable framework structure of the MOFs protects the plasmonic nanoparticles (such as Ag nanowires and GSPs) from external influences, improving the accuracy and reliability of SERS detection. Overall, incorporating MOFs into the yolk structure of the SERS substrate enhances its performance and provides several benefits for SERS detection.
Fig. 11 Schematic diagram of MOF-based SERS sensing platforms employed in human body fluid detection. (A) Schematic diagram of the operational mechanism of the AEF-SERS platform.117 Reproduced with permission from American Chemical Society, copyright 2020. (B) Schematic diagram of the fabrication of SERS-active AuNPs/MOF complexes.66 Reproduced with permission from John Wiley and Sons, copyright 2021. (C) Schematic diagram of alpha-fetoprotein detection based on SERS.44 Reproduced with permission from American Chemical Society, copyright 2014. (D) Schematic illustration of SERS-based glucose sensing.62 Reproduced with permission from American Chemical Society, copyright 2020. |
In the application of SERS biosensors, there are two major prerequisites to achieve successful enhancement of SERS signals. Firstly, the SERS substrate should have a high capacity to adsorb reporter molecules and be positioned in close proximity to the outer surface of the PNPs. Secondly, it is important to create numerous plasmonic nanogaps at the active interface between neighboring PNPs. Therefore, the reporter molecules should be located in the vicinity of the plasmonic active site of the SERS-active substrate in order to optimize the enhancement of SERS signals. To meet these requirements, Choo and his team developed a new type of SERS-active AuNPs/MOFs complex by attaching citrate-capped AuNPs to the surface of the amine-functionalized MOFs (Fig. 11B).66 When the AuNPs/MOFs complex is mixed with Raman reporter molecules, the pores in the MOFs can adsorb a large number of reporter molecules, promoting the reporter molecules to approach the AuNPs on the solid MOF matrix. Thus, many reporter molecules are captured near the SERS-active “hotspots”, significantly enhancing their SERS signals. In the presence of transferrin, the transferrin–Fe(III) bond leads to the formation of an aggregated AuNPs/MOF network, further increasing the SERS signal intensity of AuNPs/MOFs. The SERS-based transferrin analysis method provides a new SERS platform for accurately measuring transferrin TIBC in human blood samples.
The MOF-based SERS platform not only enables the direct detection of biomolecules in bodily fluids but also serves as an immunosorbent assay for selective and quantitative biomarker detection. The MOFs coating enhances analyte enrichment and SERS hotspots. Li and his team developed a highly sensitive SERS detection method using AuNPs embedded in MIL-101 (Fig. 11C).44 The synthesis method involved the impregnation of a solution containing chloroauric acid and sodium citrate, followed by their in situ growth and encapsulation within the host matrix of MIL-101. The resulting AuNPs/MIL-101 nanocomposite offers both local surface plasmon resonance properties of AuNPs and the high adsorption capacity of MOF substrates, producing a highly sensitive SERS substrate that concentrates analytes at the SERS-active metal surface electromagnetic field. This new SERS substrate is suitable for clinical samples. The team established a SERS-ELISA-based method to quantitatively analyze alpha-fetoprotein in human serum, with a linear range of 1.0–130.0 ng mL−1 and a correlation coefficient of 0.9938. Tamer and his team employed antibody-functionalized magnetic MOFs as capture probes for urine samples, developing a microfluidic chip-driven immunoassay to detect the human chorionic gonadotropin (hCG) protein banned by the World Anti-Doping Agency.118 With spatial restriction and size selection advantages, the coating of MOFs can be combined with catalysts to promote difficult-to-perform chemical reactions and exclude potential interference with biomarker recognition. MOFs play a crucial role in the randomly embedded structure of the SERS substrate, serving multiple functions such as (1) retaining the high-level nano-porous structure of the network by embedding PNPs within MOF frameworks, allowing for the dispersion and isolation of PNPs/MOFs that can enrich analytes for analysis; (2) locating the SERS active sites of PNPs on the grid structure, which promotes close proximity to target molecules within pores and enhances detection sensitivity; and (3) maintaining water stability of MOFs to ensure the stability of PNPs/MOFs composite materials in aqueous solutions, thereby improving the reproducibility of SERS detection. Yang and his team synthesized a multifunctional AuNPs/Cu-TCPP(Fe) composite material by modifying AuNPs on 2D metalloporphyrin MOFs (Fig. 11D).62 Cu-TCPP(Fe) nanosheet has peroxidase-like activity, while AuNPs have Gox mimetic activity, inducing cascade catalytic reactions converting glucose to H2O2 and then oxidizing non-Raman-active LMG to Raman-active MG via AuNP catalysis. This non-enzyme SERS detection method based on AuNPs/Cu-TCPP(Fe) nanosheets was used for glucose detection in saliva, providing a new approach to designing nano-enzyme-based SERS protocols for biomarker analysis.
Therefore, He and his team used chemically encapsulated Raman reporters to prepare a diagnostic core–shell Au@Cu3(BTC)2 composite material for bioimaging.106 A controllable growth approach was used to prepare Au@Cu3(BTC)2 composite material, which involved depositing a Cu3(BTC)2 shell on a gold core that had been modified with the Raman reporter molecule 4-mercaptobenzoic acid (4-MBA). In contrast to prior core–shell metal@MOFs, this new approach involves the participation of Raman reporter molecules featuring distinguishable Raman signals in connecting both the AuNPs and MOFs, thus eliminating the need for extra modification of Raman reporter molecules and streamlining the synthesis procedure.
However, the inherent water instability of MOFs remains challenging and unresolved. Therefore, Carrillo-Carrion and his team synthesized core–shell gold nanostars/ZIF-8 (AuNSs@ZIF-8) nanocomposites for precise release of thermoplastic-driven active molecules encapsulated in live cells, which can be observed by SERS imaging before and after intracellular release (Fig. 12A).107 MOF-based SERS probes can not only perform SERS imaging of cells but also tissue imaging. Jiang and his team reported the successful creation of Au@Ag nanorod@ZIF-8 for accurate cancer cell imaging through the application of SERS (Fig. 12B).108 The composite material is composed of SERS nano-labels and ZIF-8 coatings. The intermediate layer is a SERS nano-label consisting of Au@Ag nanorods and reporter molecules. In summary, the presence of the ZIF-8 outer coating isolates external interference with the SERS nano-label, making it easy to load and modify, which makes the NPs superior to other probes in biochemical applications. The probe was then utilized for SERS imaging of low-cytotoxicity human colon cancer cells and tumor tissues.
Fig. 12 Schematic diagram of MOF-based SERS sensing platforms employed in bioimaging. (A) Schematic diagram of intracellular SERS imaging of Au nanostar@ZIF-8.107 Reproduced with permission from John Wiley and Sons, copyright 2019. (B) Schematic diagram of the synthetic route and application instructions of Au@Ag nanorod@ZIF-8.108 Reproduced with permission from Elsevier, copyright 2019. |
Despite the rapid development of MOF-based SERS substrates, which have opened up new possibilities for detecting trace biological markers using SERS technology, they still face several challenges. First, while many studies have reported successful preparation of MOF-based SERS substrates, extensive research is needed to design and synthesize MOF-based SERS substrates that are easy to make, stable, reproducible, and have high enhancement factors. The large-scale preparation of MOF-based SERS substrates in a single form is also challenging, as it can impact the uniformity, accuracy, and reproducibility of SERS signals in life and health detection. Second, the introduction of MOFs can reduce interference from non-target molecules in complex environments, thereby enhancing the accuracy of SERS sensing platforms for trace target biomolecules in complex systems. Therefore, further exploration of new MOFs with high selectivity for identifying target biomolecules in complex systems and improving the anti-interference capabilities of MOF-based SERS substrates for analysis and detection applications is necessary. However, achieving the fingerprint identification of individual molecules in biological analysis and detection remains difficult. Third, limited research exists on MOF-based SERS substrates solely used for detecting trace biological markers mainly due to the contribution of MOFs to SERS enhancement not being extensively studied and explained. Hence, these issues require further investigation, and the enhancement mechanism of MOF-based SERS substrates needs thorough research to meet the demands of MOF-based SERS sensing platforms in life and health detection applications.
Despite facing numerous difficulties and challenges, MOF-based SERS sensing platforms offer unique advantages over traditional SERS platforms. These materials form a strong foundation for achieving high-performance SERS detection, particularly for detecting trace amounts of biomarkers. As a result, MOF-based SERS sensing platforms show great promise in the field of life and health detection (Fig. 13). Moving forward, research in this area can focus on various aspects, such as designing and preparing miniaturized MOF-based SERS substrates that can be combined with portable Raman spectrometers to enable chip-based detection and real-time monitoring of multiple diseases. Additionally, 3D printing technology can be utilized to fabricate array-structured MOF-based SERS substrates, allowing for precise control over parameters such as pore morphology, size, and arrangement within the substrate, thereby enhancing the SERS signal. MOFs also provide an opportunity to achieve precise control over pore sizes and shapes by adjusting organic ligands and metal ions within frameworks. This can improve the accuracy and reproducibility of analysis results, while eliminating interference from complex systems. Finally, MOF-based SERS sensing platforms can be designed and constructed with multi-functional and diversified detection capabilities by modifying different functional groups on their surfaces. In doing so, they can facilitate the adsorption of biomarker molecules from various diseases, leading to accurate and rapid diagnosis of different types of diseases. Deep learning-based component identification for the Raman spectra of mixtures holds great promise for achieving accurate and efficient multi-target detection.120 By combining this approach with SERS platforms based on MOFs, it becomes possible to detect multiple targets in complex mixtures with improved precision. Integrating deep learning algorithms into Raman spectroscopic analysis obtained from MOF-based SERS platforms has the potential to significantly enhance the speed and accuracy of multi-target detection and identification. With further advancements in MOFs and SERS, the prospects of MOF-based SERS sensing platforms in life and health detection are remarkably promising.
Fig. 13 The future development direction of the MOF-based SERS sensor platforms for life and health detection. |
This journal is © the Partner Organisations 2023 |