Ekaterina
Mamontova
a,
Fabrice
Salles
a,
Yannick
Guari
a,
Joulia
Larionova
a and
Jérôme
Long
*ab
aICGM, Univ. Montpellier, CNRS, ENSCM, Montpellier, France. E-mail: jerome.long@umontpellier.fr
bInstitut Universitaire de France (IUF), 1 rue Descartes, 75231 Paris Cedex 05, France
First published on 7th July 2022
Prussian blue (PB) type nanoparticles belong to an exciting family of molecule-based nanomaterials. They combine the possibility of surface engineering with specific advantages related to their porous molecule-based structures and their fascinating chemical and physical properties including redox, magnetic, photothermal and host–guest features. In this review, we focus on recent advances in the Post-Synthetic Modification (PSM) of nano-sized PB and its analogues (PBA) and compare them with the current strategies used in Metal–Organic Frameworks (MOF) in order to give the outlooks on the future researches in this domain.
More specifically, their synthesis at the nanoscale, for which the starting point could be traced back about two decades ago,2,3 has opened tremendous opportunities for the development of new functional materials having applications in multiple fields ranging from batteries to biology and medicine.4,5 Such interest is related to the specific molecule-based nature of PB and PBA, which confers to these nanosystems different physical, chemical and mechanical properties compared to classical inorganic nanoparticles.6–12 In a similar fashion that their so-called Metal–Organic Frameworks (MOF) congeners, PB and PBA exhibit remarkable advantages, such as optical transparency, low density and easy synthesis in soft conditions. Besides, one of their main assets lies in their important chemical and structural flexibilities which affords: (i) a versatility in terms of chemical compositions through the careful choice of the metal ions giving rise to various functional properties (magnetism, optics, conductivity); (ii) an internal porosity that may allow the encapsulation of various species; (iii) a high chemical and thermal robustness in various media (including water over a large neutral and acidic pH range) making them particularly adapted for numerous applications.9,11
Future innovations necessitate however to progressively and carefully adjust the properties of nanomaterials with applications encompassing biomedical area, sensors, microelectronics, catalysis, gas or water treatments, and others.13–17 Moreover, owing to their myriad of different properties, PB and PBA nanoparticles could be classified as intrinsically multifunctional materials,18 but the implementation of additional physico-chemical properties will greatly unleash the full potentiality of these original nanosystems.
In this context, the Post-Synthetic Modification (PSM), which consists in modifying the surface of nano-objects with functional groups or/and integration of some species within the porosity of previously synthesised systems, has widely been employed in the case of classical metal/metal oxides nanoparticles,19,20 quantum dots,21 silica nano-objects,22,23 MOF24,25 and others. This approach allows customizing nano-objects with new functional groups or entities without affecting their structural integrity in the aim to change the existing physical, chemical, pharmacological, mechanical properties or implement new ones. More importantly, PSM may give access to functionalized materials that could not be obtained by a direct synthetic route.25,26 Besides, PSM also allows establishing direct comparison between unmodified and modified nanosystems to monitor the improvement of the functionalization. The advantages of the PSM consist in the possibility: (i) to introduce functional groups incompatible with the conditions of the initial synthesis, (ii) to introduce new functional groups or species with desired properties, (iii) to easily design multifunctional materials.
With this in mind, PB and PBA nanoscaled systems benefit from two important features found also in MOF: their surface may be functionalized, and their porosity may be filled with guest molecules or cations of appropriated size. The PSM could be performed at different levels. The surface functionalization of PB and PBA by various ligands, organic dyes, polymers and biopolymers, antibodies ensures the modification of their physical, chemical and pharmacological properties bringing indeed additional luminescence, improved blood circulation, biocompatibility and the stealth character of nanoparticles for their use as nanoprobes or therapeutic agents. Moreover, the modification of nanoparticles’ intrinsic porosity can also give them additional functionalities (possibility of drug delivery, optical properties for fluorescent dyes and complexes). Although the term “PSM” has been widely employed in the field of MOF in their bulk form for more than 15 years, it has never been formalized and designated in the case of PB/PBA nanoparticles, although examples of surface modifications have appeared just a few years after the first report of the nanoscale synthesis of PB.
Most of inorganic nanomaterials (metal, metal oxides, quantum dots) are not porous and could only be functionalized through their surface modification. The approaches for this latter have been known for decades and numerous books and reviews have already been dedicated to this topic.19,20,27–30 PSM of silica nanoparticles can be achieved through both, modification of their porosity and surface, which have been very well documented in the literature.22,23,31–33 On the other hand, the use of the PSM strategies applied to molecule-based nanomaterials, such as MOF, has only been recently reviewed since the history of these nanoparticles started only around twenty years ago.34–36 Whereas PSM is widely employed in the literature, its systematization for nanoscaled PB and PBA has been only scarcely addressed up to now.
In this contribution, we will provide an overlook on the PSM approach in nanoscaled PB and PBA. Given the similarities between MOF and PB/PBA, we will firstly give a brief overview concerning the general strategies of PSM of the internal porosity of bulk MOF, which can be transposed to PB/PBA. Second, we will discuss the synthesis of PB type nanoparticles. Third, the description of different methodologies used in the literature to post-functionalize PB/PBA either by modification of the internal porosity or using surface engineering will be then carried out. In the last part, we will shed light on the benefits of such approach in terms of different applications and draw some perspectives.
Historically, the first PSM in MOF deals with modification of the organic linkers and has been reported by Wang et al. in 2007 by performing a simple organic chemistry reaction (amide formation) in the IR-MOF3 (IR = isoreticular) using the free amine available on the linker.44 Remarkably, such reaction takes place in the porosity of the framework, highlighting the high chemical robustness of the MOF system to allow the chemical modifications without degrading the structural features. The same year, Dincǎ et al. have proposed the metal ions exchange in a manganese-based MOF,45 while Kim and co-workers have modified an achiral MOF into an active chiral catalyst by coordination of a chiral L-proline derivative on the unsaturated metal centers.46 Small molecules could be adsorbed within the MOF porosity and react with either the ligands or the metal ions,47–49 or, in other terms, with basic and acid Lewis sites.41
The presence of functional groups on organic linkers, or the availability of active metal centres, which could interact with various species via covalent or coordination bonds, open the way to multiple reactions for a considered MOF. Besides, the possibilities are almost infinite since sequential steps PSM could be carried out to finely tune the features of MOF. More than thousand articles have been published demonstrating indeed the success of this approach in the field of MOF. However, some challenges still remain, such as the influence of different factors on the modifications (e.g. ionic radii, coordination geometry, crystallite size, pKa of the linker, etc.).25
Naturally, one obvious synthetic strategy to post-functionalize MOF consists in loading functional guests inside their pores, and sometimes referred as a “ship-in-a-bottle” strategy.50 Since the pore size and chemical functionalities may be adjusted in MOF, the nature of the guests could be miscellaneous and ranges from organic molecules, dyes, drugs, metal complexes, cluster or nanoparticles with applications in gas adsorption, catalysis, drug delivery or sensors.49,51–56
More generally, the PSM permits to modify the properties of MOF, such as the hydrophobic/hydrophilic balance, the pore size, the framework stability, the catalytic features as well as magnetic and conductivity properties.
Yet, the PSM requires that: (i) the windows pore size of the MOF should be compatible with the size of the molecular precursor or guest that needs to diffuse into the porosity of the framework; (ii) the reaction conditions should be compatible with the chemical/thermal stability of the MOF. For instance, some MOF often exhibit water instability, which prevents them from being considered for several applications, such as gas separation in a humid atmosphere.57 For this reason, different strategies have recently been developed to circumvent this weakness.58,59 In addition, various approaches have been followed to tune the hydrophobic–hydrophilic balance in MOFs. Indeed, it is possible to modify the hydrophobic character by changing the nature of the ligand and/or the metal centre by PSM.60 Inclusion or incorporation of different materials inside the pores can also modify the behaviour of solids and in particular their affinity for water. It has thus been possible to change the hydrophobic Cu-BTC (BTC = benzenetricarboxylate) framework into an hydrophilic solid by incorporating hydroxide double lamellar sheets inside the porosity.60 Similarly, the introduction of amino-acids in UPG-1(Zr) (UPG = University of Perugia) has increased the hydrophilicity due to a greater confinement effect.61 Finally the hydrophilicity of MOFs (MIL-101(Cr), MIL = Materials Institute Lavoisier) has been enhanced by introducing alkali cations, which allows a tunability of the hydrophilic character.62 More generally, the introduction of cations inside the porosity, can not only modify the hydrophobic–hydrophilic balance but can also have an impact on the diffusion of guest molecules and therefore enhance the interactions between drugs and framework.63
In this sense, using ligands able to provide strong chemical interactions with the MOF surface (such as coordination or covalent bonds) offer further alternatives. Hence, the post-synthetic exchange of ligands could be performed. Such approach has been firstly demonstrated on a zinc coordination network incorporating carboxylate ligands73 that could be exchanged on specific single-crystal surfaces using a fluorescent boron dipyrro-methene (BODIPY) linker exhibiting a carboxylate group that could substitute the pristine linker. Due to the large steric hindrance of the BODIPY linkers, the exchange is only restrained at the surface, as evidenced by atomic force microscopy (AFM). Such methodology was later applied to others MOF, such as HKUST-1 (HKUST = Hong-Kong University of Science and Technology) or ZIF-8 (ZIF = Zeolitic Imiadazolate Framework).74,75 RAFT co-polymers containing a thiolate function could also be attached through a coordinative bond with the Gd3+ ions on the particles’ surface.76 Remarkably, the used copolymer incorporated a fluorescent tag, a targeting ligand and a therapeutic agent, resulting in a MOF that could be used as a theranostic nanodevice.
The exchange of species at the surface is not only limited to ligands but can also involve metal ions through transmetallation reactions. However, this appears much difficult to control due to the diffusion of the metal ions within the porosity of the framework.52,67,68 Yet, multistep surface functionalization could also be achieved to specifically tune the surface, including the nature of the metal ions. For example, the thermal activation of MIL-101(Cr) creates coordinatively unsaturated sites that are able to react with dopamine.77 The catechol functions of this latter were protected with bulky groups to limit the reactions exclusively on the surface. Upon attachment at the surface through the amine functions, the deprotection provides a bidentate binding site that is able to subsequently react with the transition metal complex [VO(acac)2] (acac = acecylacetonate) yielding to a catalytically active functionalized system. Functionalisation of the surface can also protect the solid from the aggression of the external environment, such as pH effect, by modifying the charge distribution due to reduction of surface active elements.78
Recently, various biomolecules (amino-acids,79 peptides,80 oligonucleotides81,82) have been used to functionalize the surface of MOF nanoparticles for biomedical applications. The possibility to perform bioconjugation using the carboxylate linkers through classical EDC (1-ethyl-3-(3-dimethylaminopropyl)carbodiimide) or DCC (N,N′-dicyclohexylcarbodiimide) couplings or even proteins constitutes also a facile route.83 In a similar vein, the use of surface “click chemistry” using for instance azide/alkyne reaction for targeted applications has also emerged in the last few years.84 Modifications of external surfaces in nanoscaled-MIL-100(Fe) with biopolymers has thus proved to be efficient to enhance the interactions with active drug molecules85 or to allow the cutaneous administration of cosmetic molecules.86,87
In their bulk form, PB/PBA have been widely synthesized in aqueous solutions95,106 by reaction between a hexacyanometallate complex, [M′(CN)6]p−, and a hydrated metal cation, [M(H2O)6]n+. The ambidentate character of the CN− ligand allows to bind selectively two metal ions with an almost linear angle, which leads to a three-dimensional coordination network, made up of perfectly defined M′–CN–M sequences. However this simple structural description does not reflect the high complexity of the atomic-scale arrangement and for which the in-depth understanding still remains a challenge, as we will describe vide infra.1,107
Depending on the experimental conditions during the synthesis, alkaline cations (A) present in the reaction medium could be inserted into the tetrahedral sites of the fcc structure (Fig. 1A). This leads to a wide range of chemical compositions for a unique pair of transition metal ions, limited by two extreme formulas: lacunar M[M′(CN)6]2/3□1/3 (Fe[Fe(CN)6]3/4□1/4 for PB) and non-lacunar AM[M′(CN)6] forms (Fig. 1A and B).
Thus, the electroneutrality of the solid in lacunar structures is ensured by hexacyanometallate vacancies. As a direct consequence, water ligands complete the coordination spheres of Mn+ ions in the vicinity of these lacunas to satisfy their usual octahedral geometry. The average environment of these ions is estimated as four cyano ligands and two water molecules and could be formulated as [M(NC)4(H2O)2]. We would like to emphasize that, however, this mean description does not reflect the distribution in coordination environments generated from the random arrangement of the vacancies in the network.108 In addition, two other types of water molecules (lattice and zeolitic) may occupy the porosity of the framework. Water molecules of different nature may easily be identified by thermal gravimetric analysis since their loss could occur in a more or less stepwise manner.109
In addition to the pores corresponding to the tetrahedral sites of the fcc structure, the presence of hexacyanometallate vacancies conducts to the creation of larger pores (Fig. 1B and C), which are particularly important to perform PSM. We would like to point out that the study of the concentration and ordering of the hexacyanometallate vacancies remains extraordinarily complex and directly affects some physico-chemical properties of PB and PBA. It is therefore more and more admitted that the vacancies arrangement is in some extent ordered in the solids and is also dependent on the chemical composition of the PBA.1,107,108,110,111
The presence of vacancies PBA is also strongly dependent on the experimental conditions during the synthesis. Understanding the atomic scale arrangement of vacancies within the coordination network implies elucidating the diffusion mechanism in these PBA.112 Recently Simonov et al. have shown that the vacancies are not randomly distributed but are somehow ordered in the structure, which allows adjusting the targeted properties for molecules or ions diffusion and authorizes the transport throughout the crystal structure.107 In addition it appears that the vacancies are connected to create a percolation path and the presence of vacancies pairs can be observed (Fig. 2).112
Fig. 2 Description of PB/PBA structure containing a vacancy pair (A) or vacancy-pair free (B). Adapted with permission from ref. 112. Copyright 2019 American Chemical Society. |
First-principles calculations have investigated these arrangements and evidenced that the vacancy pair free configurations are the most favourable at 300 K.112 Although, based on different molecular precursors, it has also been shown that the long distance order can be observed for vacancies of [Bi(SCN)6]3− in the thiocyanate analogues of PBA.113 It has further been proved that adjustment of the size of the vacancies might be achieved by introducing polynuclear cyano complexes with a octahedral arrangement instead of the usual mononuclear hexacyanometallates.114
In PB/PBA, the porosity allows to encapsulate or transport guest ions or molecules of appropriate size and shape (such as H2O, NH3, CH4, CO2, H2, etc.).95–97,106,115–121 However, their porous character drastically differ from their MOF counterpart at several levels: (i) in contrast to numerous MOF, the nature of both, the metal ions and hexacyanometallate moieties could be modulated without affecting the resulting framework topology. Indeed, in MOF solids, the chemical versatility can lead to a variety of porous structures with different dimensionalities (1D, 2D, 3D, presence of cages, etc.) and different pore sizes,60–62 which impact the adsorption of small gases. In contrast, PB and PBA structures present an organized porosity due to the presence of channels and vacancies which are only slightly affected by chemical modifications.112 This allows to decipher the influence of the metal ions over the adsorption features; (ii) the small cubic pores in PB and PBA also offer a high content of π density arising from the cyano groups that could be beneficial to capture certain molecules; (iii) the existence of structural flexibility in MOFs (such as MIL-53 (MIL = Matériaux de l'Institut Lavoisier) or Co(1,4-benzenedipyrazolate) for instance) can drastically modify the adsorption of gases and vapors,122,123 while the mechanical stability of PB/PBA assures a constant adsorption saturation.
Moreover, the porous character of PB and related analogues in association with the presence of alkaline ions in the tetrahedral sites of the PB/PBA structures is attractive for the separation or insertion of small hydrated cations, such as Na+, K+, Rb+, Cs+, and NH4+, which is useful for different applications: membrane for ions separation,124 component for batteries,91,103,125 or for selective trapping of these cations in waste purification or radioactive ions decontamination.126 Compared to conventional zeolites, the Cs+ adsorption performances appear excellent due to the high affinity of the PB network for this cation. In particular, the mechanism of radioactive and non-radioactive caesium and thallium ions capture by PB has been investigated since the 1960s in the aim to enhance the excretion of these ions from the human body.127–131 It has been evidenced from both, human and animal studies, that insoluble form of the bulk PB is an efficient antidote against Cs+ and Tl+ poisoning. In 2003, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration have approved the use of PB for medical treatments under the trademark name Radiogardase®.132,133 Indeed, the preferential exchange in favour of Cs+ is linked to the fact that dehydrated Cs+ cations perfectly accommodate the size of the PB tetrahedral sites. As the Cs+ is a cation, which has a low affinity for water, its adsorption is preferential due to the confinement effect.94 Theoretical studies have shown that the disorder of the position of compensating cations present in the pores is also strongly influenced by the presence and the organisation of the vacancies.112 This latter also plays a role for the diffusion of large molecules or cations inside the pores. For instance, although the ion-exchange mechanism between alkaline ion implemented in the synthesis and Cs+ has been the main adsorption mechanism, the high Cs+ adsorption capacity might involve its migration through the vacancies for certain PBA compositions.94 In this sense, it was also shown that lacunar PB exhibits a greater adsorption capacity with respect to non-lacunar structure. Such behaviour has been explained by the presence of hexacyanometallate vacancies, which engender a high number of coordinated and/or crystallizated water molecules. The proposed mechanism involves a proton elimination from a coordinated water on the iron sites to capture caesium and ensures the electroneutrality.134
Ionic exchange is also being largely used in the field of PB/PBA based batteries in which reversible insertion/deinsertion of alkaline ions may be achieved.91,92,103 Moreover, recent studies have highlighted the possibility to use PBA to design ammonium-ion batteries storage by a simple PSM ion-exchange.135 The Na1.50Ni[Fe(CN)6]0.88 PBA could be for instance PSM modified by simply soaking the solid into an ammonium sulphate solution giving (NH4)1.47Ni[Fe(CN)6]0.88. This study clearly supports the possibility to adsorb small functional organic cation by ionic exchange.
Firstly, one of the most often used strategy for PB consists in the self-assembly reaction between two precursors, Fe3+ and [Fe(CN)6]4− (or Fe2+ and [Fe(CN)6]3−), in water, in the presence of citrate ligands, which are attached at the surface as functional groups and prevented the nanoparticles agglomeration (Fig. 3A).148 This method generally provides water-dispersible nanoparticles with the size varied from around ten to several tens of nanometers.149–151 The coordinating ability of the citrate towards Fe3+ ions appears to be the critical parameter to control the nucleation rate. This approach was also extended to other PBA.151
Fig. 3 TEM images of: (A) citrate-stabilized PB nanoparticles. Reproduced from ref. 149 with permission from the Royal Society of Chemistry. (B) Self-standing charged CsxNi[Cr(CN)6]y nanoparticles. Reproduced from ref. 165. Copyright 2014 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim. (C) Self-standing charged KxNi[FeIII(CN)6]y nanoparticles. Reproduced from ref. 166 with permission from the Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique (CNRS) and the Royal Society of Chemistry. (D) Self-standing charged PB nanoparticles. Reprinted with permission from ref. 167. Copyright 2020 American Chemical Society. (E) Self-standing charged KxNi[FeIII(CN)6]y nanoparticles. Reprinted with permission from ref. 163. Copyright 2020 American Chemical Society. |
Secondly, another strategy particularly relevant for further PSM consists in the design of PB/PBA nanoparticles with a surface free of any stabilizers. Thus, PB nanoparticles without stabilizing agents were first prepared in 2002 by mixing FeCl3 and K3[Fe(CN)6] in the presence of the slight excess of H2O2 following by their self-assembly on a gold electrode (the average particles size was approximately of 50 nm).152 The use of sonochemistry helps obtaining smaller PB nanoparticles with an average size of 5 nm.153 Stable PB nanoparticles’ suspensions were also obtained by mixing K3[Fe(CN)6] and FeCl2 with a large excess of the ferricyanide precursor (molar ratio 5:1).154 They were then coated with a cationic polymer poly(ethylene imine) to design electrochromic thin films. A synthetic route based on potassium ferrocyanide as the single precursor was also published later,155 by slow dissociation of [Fe(CN)6]4− in the presence of hydrochloric acid. The particles size depends on the precursor concentration and the reaction temperature. In 2006, a major advance has been achieved by Brinzei et al. by taking advantage of the electrostatic stabilization of the PB colloids in water and in the absence of any stabilizing agents.156 The controlled self-precipitation of the PBA precursors induces a negatively charged surface of the formed nanoparticles due to the presence of [M′(CN)6]p− moieties. Starting from this, different research groups have optimized this method to obtain a large size and composition ranges of surfactant-free nanoparticles Mn+/[M′(CN)6]3− (where Mn+ = Ni2+, Co2+, Mn2+, In3+, and M′3+ = Fe3+, Cr3+).156–161 For instance, the nanoparticle's size could be controlled from 6 to 200 nm by the simple modulation of the precursors’ concentration and their addition rate (Fig. 3B–D).158,162 Note that fast addition and high concentrations promote the nucleation process, which leads to the formation of small nanoparticles. In contrast, low concentrations and slow addition rate favour the growth of PBA nanocrystals, permitting accessing to large nanoparticles. Moreover, the presence of an excess of alkaline ions, such as Cs+, favours the electrostatic stabilization and allows the formation of ultra-small (less than 10 nm) nanoparticles, as discussed by Catala et al.10 Recently, the growth mechanism of mesoscale (100–500 nm) PBA particles was also investigated by Liang et al. A series of Co2+ and Ni2+ analogues, RbjCok[M(CN)6]l·nH2O (M = Cr, Fe, Co) and RbjNik[M(CN)6]l·nH2O (M = Cr, Fe, Co) are compared, along with the parent PB and the Cu2+ analogue rubidium copper hexacyanoferrate.163 While the Cu2+ and Ni2+ analogues grow by a traditional heterogeneous process, whereby nucleated particles grow by addition of ions from solution, Co2+ analogues and rubidium PB nanoparticles grow by aggregation of precursor particles followed by annealing into crystalline mesoscale particles (Fig. 3E). Contrary to a common belief, such studies clearly point out the chemical-dependence of the size control of the PBA nanoparticles. This emphasizes the necessity to understand the underlying coordination chemistry's concepts in terms of stability/kinetics for the coordination complexes used during the synthesis.
Self-standing charged PBA nanoparticles have opened the possibility to tune their size in a predictive way. For instance, alternative dropwise addition of molecular precursor solutions to a charged colloidal suspension of PBA “seeds” nanoparticles leads to a growth of these latter. This approach was applied to Cs0.5Ni[Cr(CN)6]0.5− under appropriate conditions in order to form the nanoparticles with the size ranging between 5 and 30 nm.164 The obtained nanoparticles are not aggregated and well dispersed thanks to their surface charge high enough to ensure the electrostatic stabilization. Moreover, the influence of the growth conditions on the magnetic properties of such nanoparticles has also been explored.164 Remarkably, the absence of a stabilizing agent on the nanoparticles surface makes them reactive due to the presence of Mn+ and [M′(CN)6]p− groups.
This has been taken as an advantage to design more complex heterostructures, such as core@shell nanosystems with PBA of different chemical compositions combined with other inorganic materials (Au, Fe3O4, etc.).168 Moreover, such approach allows post-functionalizing either the particle's surface by various functional species depending on the targeted applications or the internalisation of targeted ions or molecules into the internal porosity of the coordination framework. This provides an efficient way to implement multifunctionality at the nanoscale without altering the core features (size, composition, intrinsic properties, etc.).
PB and PBA hollow particles have been synthesized using different strategies: the first approach based on the preparation of mini-emulsions, followed by a coordination polymerization at the periphery of the droplets has been reported by Liang et al.171,172 A second route, more specific to PB, has been proposed by Zeng et al. based on the selective etching of already synthesised PB mesocrystals at high temperature in highly acidic conditions.170,173,174 The chemical etching has now become the most popular strategy to design hollow PB structures and has been developed by other groups to prepare hollow PB and PBA nanoparticles of different size and composition (Fig. 4A).169 Most of those have been prepared under acidic hydrothermal conditions (for example, by mixing the pristine nanoparticles with 1 M HCl solution in a Teflon vessel at 140 °C for 20 h; Fig. 4B).170,175,176 The PVP located at the surface particles prevent the surface etching, while the acid can easily diffuse within the porosity of the PB or PBA framework to dissolve the core. Another etching process based on the use of ammonia has also been applied to Ni2+/[Co(CN)6]3− nanoparticles (Fig. 4C).177 However, it is important to emphasize that the chemical etching is highly dependent on the chemical composition of PBA and in turn on the chemical stability of the M′–CN–M linkages. Thus, the formation of different complex architectures could be observed (hollow nanocubes, nano-frames, nanocages, Fig. 4).169 This approach also raises problems concerning the kinetic control of the etching.
Fig. 4 (A) Schematic Representation of chemical etching to prepare hollow nanoparticles; TEM images of: (B) hollow PB mesocrystals synthesized by chemical HCl etching. Inset: Selected-area electron diffraction patterns of one particle. Reproduced from ref. 170. Copyright 2012 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim; (C) etching product obtained after reacting of Ni2+/[Co(CN)6]3− PBA nanocubes with ammonia at room temperature for 6 h. Reproduced from ref. 177. Copyright 2016 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim; (D) hollow nanocubes of Rb0.4Co4[Fe(CN)6]2.8·7.2H2O with Nix[Cr(CN)6]y deposit on the surface. Scale bar = 200 nm. Reprinted with permission from ref. 178. Copyright 2013 American Chemical Society; (E) hollow KNi[Fe(CN)6] nanoparticles after etching of gold core. Reproduced from ref. 179. Copyright 2014 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim. |
Thirdly, a different etching strategy to design hollow systems has been developed by using core@shell heterostructure. Risset et al. designed core@shell PBA@PBA′ heterostructures with a potentially “soluble” Rb1.6Mn4[Fe(CN)6]3.2·4.8H2O core and Rb0.4M4[Fe(CN)6]2.8·7.2H2O (M = Co, Ni) as a shell. The “soluble” Rb1.6Mn4[Fe(CN)6]3.2·4.8H2O compound exhibits weak Fe–CN–Mn linkages that could be broken by an extensive washing, leading to Rb0.4M4[Fe(CN)6]2.8·7.2H2O PBA hollow nanoparticles of 10 nm thickness (Fig. 4D).178 Our group reported also an alternative approach starting from Au@K1.20NiII[FeII(CN)6]0.80 core@shell nanoparticles.179 Metallic gold could be post-synthetically dissolved in the presence of cyanide ions and oxygen, thanks to the high stability constant of the gold cyanide complex, [Au(CN)2]− (1037 M−2). By taking advantage of the intrinsic porosity of the PBA network, hollow PBA nanoparticles can be obtained by simply dispersing the core–shell Au@K1.20NiII[FeII(CN)6]0.80 nanoparticles in a dilute KCN solution without affecting the integrity of the K1.20NiII[FeII(CN)6]0.80 cyano-bridged shell. Since the shell thickness could be easily adjusted, the CN− diffusion in the porosity of the cyano-bridged framework could allow obtaining of tuneable hollow systems (Fig. 4E).179 Recently, other etching approaches using sodium tungstate have also been used to design hollow PB and cobalt hexacyanoferrate nanoparticles.180 In the last case, the in situ etching during the synthesis could be controlled by modulation of the Fe/Co ratio and stirring time, which affect the dissolution/recrystallization process. Employing a complementary approach that was used for Au@PBA core@shell structures, a self-templating synthesis of cobalt hexacyanoferrate hollow structures with controllable morphologies has been proposed.181 Cobalt-hexacyanoferrate nano-objects of different morphologies (spheres, polyhedrons, prisms) were prepared. Dispersion in water induces the dissolution of Co2+ ions that could subsequently react with hexacyanoferrate to yield the hollow nanostructures.
Considerable efforts have been devoted to explore the field of hollow nanoparticles. However, for future applications, a generalized method that can produce PB and PBA hollow structures with controllable size, shell thickness and in large scale has still to be developed.
Nanoparticle formula | Nanoparticle synthesis (surface stabilizing agent) | Method | Chemical species used for PSM | Benefit of PSM | Application | Ref. |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Cox[MIII(CN)6]y (M = CrIII, FeIII) | Reverse micelle (NP-5) | Organic ligand exchange; polymer coating or displacement | Stearylamine | Nanoparticles’ stability | Fundamental study | 137 |
K1−3xGdxFe[Fe(CN)6] | PVP-coated nanoparticles | PEG | Stability in physiological media | MRI contrast agents with stability in an acidic environment | 193 | |
KxFey[Fe(CN)6]z | PVP-coated nanoparticles | Hyaluronic acid grafting polyethylene glycol (HA-g-PEG) and loading with 10-hydroxycamptothecin | Stability in the physiological conditions and long blood circulation | Photo/chemo thermal agent for cancer therapy | 194 | |
KxFey[Fe(CN)6]z doped with Mn2+ | Hydrothermal reaction in the presence of PVP | Doxorubicin followed by red blood cell | Stability in the physiological conditions and long blood circulation | Photo/chemo cancer therapy | 195 | |
KxFey[Fe(CN)6]z | Citrate-stabilized nanoparticles | 3 polymer shells: (1) polyallylamine hydrochloride; (2) anionic poly(acrylic acid); (3) amine terminated PEG | Stability in physiological media | Cancer imaging and photothermal therapy | 189 | |
KxFey[Fe(CN)6]z doped with Mn2+ | Bimodal MRI/Photoacoustic Imaging and Photothermal Therapy | 190 | ||||
KxFey[Fe(CN)6]z | Dopamine followed by human-serum albumin and doxorubicin | Stability in physiological media | pH —/thermotriggered drug-delivery | 196 | ||
KxFey[Fe(CN)6]z | Dopamine followed by bi-amino PEG and folic acid | Biocompatibility, tumor targeting | MRI agent and chemo/photothermal therapy | 197 | ||
Fe3O4@KxFey[Fe(CN)6]z | Self-standing charged nanoparticles | Direct functionalization (coordination bond) | Dopamine followed by bovine-serum albumin and aluminum phthalocyanine | Biocompatibility; prolongation of circulatory half-life; second-generation photosensitizer and fluorescence imaging | NIR/magnetic resonance/photoacoustic imaging and photothermal/photodynamic therapy | 198 |
Fe4[Fe(CN)6]3·15H2O, Co1.5[Fe(CN)6], Ni1.5[Fe(CN)6] | Oleylamine | Organic solvent dispersion | Organic or water dispersible inks | 182 | ||
[Fe(CN)6]4− | Water dispersion | |||||
Fe4[Fe(CN)6]3·15H2O | Alkylamines (C3-, C4-, C6-, C8-, C12-, C16-, C18-) | Water and alcohols dispersion | Realisation of printed electronics | 183 | ||
[Fe(CN)6]4− followed by alkylamines | ||||||
KxFey[Fe(CN)6]z | [Fe(CO)5] | CO release | Photo/chemo thermal agent for cancer therapy | 184 | ||
Amine-terminated PEG | Better blood circulation period | |||||
Fe4[Fe(CN)6]3·15H2O | Oleylamine followed by lipid-PEGylation with doxorubicin in the lipid. | Stability in physiological media; Drug delivery | pH-responsive drug carriers for Photo/Chemo cancer therapy | 191 | ||
Fe3O4@KxFey[Fe(CN)6]z | Oleylamine-PEG/lipid, doxorubicin | Interfacial biocompatibility and stability of nanoparticle; drug delivery | Photo/chemo thermal agent for cancer therapy | 199 | ||
Nix[FeIII(CN)6]y | Toluidine blue | Electron transfer mediator | Electrochemical immunosensor | 200 | ||
KxFey[Fe(CN)6]z | Carboxyl fluorescein modified ssDNA and cyanine 5 modified ss DNA | Fluorescence imaging | Nanoprobes for microRNA detection | 201 | ||
CsxNi[Cr(CN)6]y | Self-standing charged nanoparticles | Direct functionalization (electrostatic or weak interactions) | Cetyl trimethyl ammonium chloride | Nanoparticles’ isolation in powder form | Magnetic properties study | 156 |
PVP | ||||||
K4y−3+xMnIIxInIII1−x[FeII(CN)6]y | Dextran | Nanoparticles’ stability | T1 contrast agents for magnetic resonance imaging | 161 | ||
Na0.10Fe[Fe(CN)6]0.77 | Dextran | Nanoparticles’ stability, biocompatibility | Nanoprobes for SPEC-CT imaging | 185 | ||
Lipid bilayers | ||||||
K0.53Gd0.89FeIII4[FeII(CN)6]3.8·1.2H2O | Avidin-Alexa Fluor 488, anti-human eotaxin-3 antibody | Fluorescence targeting | Multimodal molecular imaging agent | 202 | ||
K0.6Mn0.7FeIII4[FeII(CN)6]3.5·3H2O | Avidin-Alexa Fluor 488, anti-neuron-glial antigen 2, Eotaxin-3 antibody, biotinylated human transferrin | Imaging of pediatric brain tumors | 203 | |||
KxFey[Fe(CN)6]z | Avidin-Alexa Fluor 488, antigen-specific cytotoxic T lymphocites | Immunotherapy | Photothermal therapy for cancer treatment | 192 | ||
Nix[FeIII(CN)6]y | 7,7,8,8-Tetracyanoquinododimethane | Electron acceptor | Host material for sodium ion storage | 204 | ||
Fe3O4@KxFey[Fe(CN)6]@CuInS2–ZnS | Polyethyleneimine | Coupling agent | Coupling with quantum dots nanoparticles for dual fluorescence/MRI imaging and photothermal therapy | 205 | ||
Na0.30FeIII[FeII(CN)6]0.82·3.7H2O | Rhodamine B | Fluorescence imaging | In vitro fluorescence imaging | 167 | ||
KxFey[Fe(CN)6]z | Chitosan-stabilized nanoparticles | DNA | Gene delivery | Photothermally enhanced gene delivery | 206 | |
KxFey[Fe(CN)6]z | Citrate-stabilized nanoparticles | Poly-L-lysine | Improve cell internalization | Photoacoustic imaging of human mesenchymal stem cells | 186 | |
KxFey[Fe(CN)6]z | PVP-stabilized nanoparticles | 11-Mercaptoundecanoic acid | Coupling agent for DNA drugs | DNA drug delivery | 188 | |
KxFey[Fe(CN)6]z | Citrate-stabilized nanoparticles | Ligand conjugation | 5-(Aminoacetamido)fluorescein | Fluorescence | MRI and confocal imaging | 150 |
KxFey[Fe(CN)6]z | Texas red | Fluorescence marker | Cellular imaging and drug delivery | 149 | ||
KxFey[Fe(CN)6]z | Glypican-3 antibodies | Tumor targeting | Targeted imaging and therapy | 207 | ||
KxFey[Fe(CN)6]z | Folic acid | Nanoparticles’ stability and binding affinity for cancer cells | Electrochemical detection of targeted cancer cells | 208 | ||
KxFey[Fe(CN)6]z | Methylene blue | Fluorescence | Optical imaging | 209 | ||
KxFey[Fe(CN)6]z | Human serum-albumin stabilized nanoparticles | Indocyanine green | Fluorescence imaging | Bimodal imaging | 210 |
(i) Surface ligand exchange. When the synthesis of nanoparticles is achieved using stabilizing agent, the ligands coordinated to the metal ions situated on the nanoparticle surface could be exchanged by stronger ones. Hence, the first post-synthetic ligand exchange has been achieved in the beginning of the 2000's in the case of cobalt hexacyanoferrate and hexacyanochromate nanoparticles by substituting weakly-bonded ligands by aliphatic amines.137 In this work, the nanoparticles were firstly synthesized by a reverse micelle technique using poly-(ethylene glycol) mono 4-nonylphenyl ether (NP-5). A long aliphatic amine (stearylamine) was subsequently exchanged as primary amines are stronger donors than oxygens towards transition metal ions situated on the surface, such as Co2+. This surface modification allows the nanoparticles to change their dispersibility in less polar solvents.
(ii) Direct post synthetic functionalization of stabilising agent-free nanoparticles. Both, the Lewis-acid character of Mn+ ions and the Lewis-base character of the [M′(CN)6]p− moieties situated on the nanoparticle surface could be utilized in this purpose. On the one hand, suitable ligands presenting available coordinative functions (amine or carboxylate) can substitute the water molecules completing the coordination sphere of surface metallic ions, Mn+, and interact by coordinative bonds with these surface exposed metal ions (Fig. 5).182,183 For instance, as-isolated undispersible (in water or organic solvents) nanoparticles of PB, nickel and cobalt hexacyanoferrate PBA of 10–20 nm diameter were post-functionalized with oleylamine to afford their good dispersibility in usual organic solvents (Fig. 7A).182 On the other hand, the post-synthetic addition using an “inorganic ligand”, such as [Fe(CN)6]4−, also provides their hydrodispersibility by coordination of [Fe(CN)6]4− to the Mn+ active site. Yet, simple electrostatic stabilization of the nanoparticles by negatively charged hexacyanoferrate could not be excluded. In both cases, the resulting surface negative charge allows the stabilization of the nanoparticles in water. Dual surface modification with both, [Fe(CN)6]4− and various alkylamines (C3 to C18), was later utilized to render surfactant-free PB nanoparticles of 10 nm dispersible in alcohols.183 A mechanism proposed by the authors explaining the appearance of a surface negative charge is based on the acid/base reaction involving the coordinated water molecules of the Fe(OH2) sites and the amine function. The possibility to synthesize size-controllable negatively charged particles dispersible in polar solvents without any stabilizers greatly extends the post-functionalization approaches. For instance, nickel hexacyanoferrate nanoparticles with size ranging from 40 to 100 nm could undergo PSM by a PEG exhibiting terminal amine functions allowing its attachment at the surface of the particles through a coordination bond with the surface-exposed Ni2+ ions. This surface modification allows to compare the PBA nanoparticles of different sizes and establish the impact of the nanoparticles size on their Debye temperature.162
Another example showing the ability of the reactive surface sites of PB/PBA nanoparticles to establish strong coordination bonds concerns the two-steps PSM of PVP-stabilized nanoparticles. Despite the presence of PVP, which could potentially restrain the surface accessibility, the cyano groups of the surface act as Lewis basic sites for the coordination of iron pentacarbonyl, [Fe(CO)5], as confirmed by the change in the PB nanoparticles zeta potential and XPS analysis.184 Remarkably, the nanoparticles could be afterwards reacted with an amine functionalized PEG by coordination with the Lewis acid iron ions at the surface. Such result clearly highlights the intrinsic dual Lewis acid/base character of the PB/PBA surface.
(iii) Post-synthetic coating could also be achieved using electrostatic or weak interactions. As previously stated, PB/PBA nanoparticles could exhibit negative surface charge that arises either from the presence of stabilizing agents, such as for instance citrates, or the presence of hexacyanometallate moieties. Caesium nickel hexacyanochromate was modified using a cationic surfactant, such as cetyl trimethyl ammonium chloride, that would interact with the negatively charged surface through electrostatic interactions. On the other hand, PVP, able to weaky coordinate nickel ions at the surface, could be post-synthetically introduced.156 Other stabilizing agents, such as biopolymer dextran161,185 or lipid bilayers,185 were also employed to post-synthetically functionalize the surface of PB/PBA nanoparticles through the formation of weak bonds or electrostatic interactions. Other example concerns citrate-stabilized PB nanoparticles of 50–60 nm that could be complexed with cationic transfection agent poly-L-lysine via electrostatic interactions.186
(iv) Coupling reactions using the stabilizer attached at the surface of the PB nanoparticles. As an example, a fluorescein-based dye bearing an amine function was conjugated to citrate coated-nanoparticles by a classical coupling reaction between carboxylic acid and amines involving 1-ethyl-3-(3-dimethylaminopropyl)carbodiimide (EDC) to implement luminescence for in vitro fluorescence imaging.187 The same strategy was also applied with the Texas red dye.149 PVP-stabilized nanoparticles could be functionalized by 11-mercaptoundecanoic acid (DUA) for subsequent amino or thiol-based DNA drug conjugation through EDC/NHS chemistry and/or oxidative disulfide bond linkage to allow the DNA drug delivery in cancer cells.188 Multi-steps surface functionalization could also be performed to achieve a layer-by-layer coating.189–191 For example, citrate-stabilized PB nanoparticles react with a cationic polymer (polyaniline hydrochloride) and then with the polyacrylic acid anionic polymer through electrostatic interactions and by EDC coupling, respectively.189 An amine terminated PEG is then conjugated with the carboxyl groups through amide formation. Another example concerns stabilising agent-free nanoparticles of PB that could be firstly functionalized with avidine through electrostatic interactions before conjugation, which could be achieved by reaction with biotin using the strong avidin–biotin interaction.192 The resulting functionalized PB nanoparticles could be then attached with antigen-specific cytotoxic T lymphocites (CTL).
Naturally, all the available chemical interactions could be combined using multistep surface functionalization (Table 1) in order to finely adjust the physico-chemical properties and/or pharmacokinetic features.
To give an example, PB nanoparticles could be first post-functionalized with oleylamine (coordination bond) and subsequently with a PEG-based lipid through a thin-film hydration process to give hydrophilic PEGylated nanoparticles.191 The diversity in the surface interactions results in a chemical “toolbox” that provides numerous strategies for the PSM of the PB/PBA surface. Most of these studies rely on the nanoparticle tailoring for biomedical applications (e.g. bio-imaging or cancer treatments) that would be detailed in the next part.
Nanoparticle formula | Porosity type | Guest | Interaction guest-framework | Application | Ref. |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
KxFey[Fe(CN)6]z | Hollow nanoparticles | Cisplatin | Not discussed | Intracellular drug delivery | 211 |
KxFey[Fe(CN)6]z | Doxorubicin | Electrostatic interaction (negative PB–positive DOX) or coordinative bonding between Fe(III) and amino or carbonyl groups of DOX | Chemo-thermal tumor therapy | 212 | |
Perfluoropentane | Not discussed | ||||
KxFey[Fe(CN)6]z | Doxorubicin | π-stacking or hydrophobic | Chemotherapy against hepatocellular carcinoma | 213 | |
KxFey[Fe(CN)6]z | Doxorubicin | Interaction between Fe(III) and DOX | Chemotherapy of cancer | 214 | |
KxFey[Fe(CN)6]z | Chloroquine, 1-tetradecanol | Not discussed | Autophagy inhibition and cancer treatment | 215 | |
KxFey[Fe(CN)6]z | 1-Tetradecanol, Doxorubicin, camptothecin | Not discussed | NIR light responsive drug co-delivery system | 216 | |
KxFey[Fe(CN)6]z | 1-Pentadecanol, Doxorubicin | Not discussed | NIR-induced chemo-photothermal tumor therapy with trimodal imaging | 217 | |
Na0.45Fe[Fe(CN)6]0.86@(PEG–NH2)0.22 | Tetrahedral sites | 201Tl+ | Electrostatic interactions | Nano-radiotracers for SPECT imaging | 218 |
Na0.10Fe[Fe(CN)6]0.77 | 201Tl+ | Electrostatic interactions | Nano-radiotracers for SPECT imaging | 185 | |
K0.04Ni[Cr(CN)6]0.64·4.1H2O | Hexacyanometallate vacancies | 2-Aminoanthracene (AA) | Coordinative bonds between Ni(II) and amino group of AA | Luminescent NPs | 219 |
Na0.30FeIII[FeII(CN)6]0.82·3.7H2O | 2-Aminoanthracene (AA) | Coordinative bonds between Fe(III) and amino group of AA | In vitro imaging | 167 |
Firstly, the presence of water molecules coordinated on the metal ion located in the vicinity of hexacyanometallate vacancies gives rise to the presence of reactive metal ion sites with an average chemical environment [M(NC)4(H2O)2].
The labile coordinated water molecules could be easily substituted by stronger ligands or simply removed by thermal activation to afford coordinatively unsaturated site. As a consequence, a suitable guest presenting an appropriate Lewis base character would be able to react on these acid sites through a chemisorption process. In the scope of PBA nanoparticles, this methodology appears quite unexplored and has been only recently applied to PB and nickel hexacyanoferrate nanoparticles functionalized by the 2-aminoanthracene luminophore, which is able to enter into the porosity and presents an amine function able to substitute water molecules.167,223 In addition, alkaline ions may be present in the tetrahedral sites of the PB/PBA structure and can be exchanged with another cation of the appropriate size and charge. As previously stated, these guest cations could readily diffuse into the porous structure for ionic exchange. As an example, PB nanoparticles possessing Na+ in their framework have been used for improved Cs+ elimination from living organisms. In this case, the use of PB nanoparticles presents the advantage to enhance the Cs+ adsorption kinetics and change the Cs+ elimination way (glomerular vs. faeces).224
These PSM methodologies could also be applied to hollow PB nanoparticles (Fig. 7B and Table 2) by taking advantage of the large voids accessible in the internal cavity of the nanostructure.194,211–213 Hence, hollow nanoparticles appear to be efficient carriers for therapeutic molecules with applications in drug delivery (see the next section). However, we would like to emphasize that there is, for the moment, only little information about the encapsulation process of the drugs in the nanoparticle cavities and their interaction with the coordination network. Since these nanoparticles are mostly obtained by an etching process, the PB/PBA nanoparticles most likely exhibit larger voids caused by defects with respect to non-hollow ones. To finish, the loading within the porosity could be combined with the nanoparticles’ surface modification. Such few examples are grouped in Table 3.
Fig. 7 (A) Schematic representation of PB nanoparticles inks. The surface modification with oleylamine leads to organic-solvent dispersible PB pigment. TEM image of PB nanoparticles in the toluene-dispersible ink. Scale bar = 100 nm. Reproduced with permission from ref. 182. © IOP Publishing. All rights reserved. (B) Schematic representation of hollow PB nanoparticles loading with cisplatin. TEM image of cisplatin@hollow PB. Reproduced from ref. 211 with permission from the Royal Society of Chemistry. |
Nanoparticle formula | Porosity type | Guest | Interaction guest-framework | Application | Ref. |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
KxFey[Fe(CN)6]z modified with polyethyleneimine | Hollow nanoparticles | Indocyanine green, Doxorubicin | Electrostatic interaction | Fluorescence-guided tri-modal combination therapy of cancer | 220 |
KxFey[Fe(CN)6]z surface modified with hyaluronic acid grafting polyethylene glycol | Hollow nanoparticles | 10-Hydroxycamptothecin | Not discussed | Thermochemotherapy of cancer | 194 |
Na0.38Mn0.12Fe[Fe(CN)6]0.91 | Solid nanoparticles with microporosity | Doxorubicin | Weak interactions | Photothermal therapy and drug delivery | 221 |
In the scope of PSM, the ion capture of radioactive 201Tl-labeled in ultra-small218 or larger PB nanoparticles185 have been designed for their employment as radiotracers for Single-Photon Emission Computed Tomography (SPECT) imaging. PB nanoparticles of 2–3 nm have been synthesized with different coatings by biocompatible ligands (glycol chains and/or carbohydrates). These later are covalently anchored via functional amino groups at the nanoparticles surface allowing an excellent colloidal stability in physiological solutions and a prolonged blood circulation. The PSM is carried out by simply reacting the nanoparticles with small amount of radioactive thallium isotopes (201Tl+) that were irreversibly trapped in the tetrahedral sites of the PB structure due to their appropriate size. In contrast to the commercial 201TlCl, which is commonly used as radiotracer for the scintigraphy of heart and which in majority accumulates in the kidney within a few minutes after injection, the functionalized nanoparticles might act as radiotracers for the scintigraphy of lungs and liver.
One of the main routes to perform PSM for biomedical applications consists in the possibility to encapsulate different drugs in the PB nanoparticles and in the related hollow architectures. The combination of the photothermal therapy with the drug delivery based on the PB type nanocarriers enhances the cancer cell killing activity.211,235,243 Before going into some relevant examples, it should be emphasized that the quantitative comparison between different studies in terms of loading capacity and/or loading efficiency appears relatively difficult due to the absence of strict definition (initial weight of nanoparticles or total weight of nanoparticles, consideration of solvent molecules etc.) to calculate these features The first loading of a drug into PB could be traced back in 2012 by Lian et al. in hollow nanoparticles protected by PVP.211 The anti-cancerous agent cisplatin cis-[Pt(NH3)2Cl2] complex was simply loaded by immersion into an aqueous suspension of PB nanoparticles (Fig. 7B). The loading efficiency was reported to be almost 100%, whereas the proposed mechanism indicates that the cisplatin was loaded into the microporosity of the PB coordination framework by considering a comparable size between the coordination complex guest and the PB pores. Consequently, the large pore of the hollow nano-architecture was apparently not involved in the adsorption mechanism of the drug (even if it can play a role in the diffusion of the molecules in order to reach the microporosity). The resulting loaded nano-objects have been utilized as an anticancer drug on bladder cancer T24 cells, confirming its therapeutic effect.
It was also later suggested that drugs of greater size, such as doxorubicin (DOX), could be adsorbed in both, PB and hollow PB nanoparticles. This subject was largely studied in the literature (Tables 1–3) and mainly in hollow nanoparticles, and it appears that DOX can be captured in the large porosity of PB or attached at the surface of particles. For instance, a drug loading efficiency of 98% was achieved in hollow PB nanoparticles.212 The authors ascribed such high loading efficiency to the presence of numerous mesopores and a huge cavity in the case of hollow particles, as well as to the formation of electrostatic interactions and/or coordination bonds involving the DOX amino, carbonyl or hydroxyl groups with the surface. The release of the loaded DOX could be triggered at low pH values. Remarkably, the thermosensitive phase change material perfluoropentane could be subsequently loaded into the previously functionalized PB/DOX nanoparticles to enhance the ultrasound contrast upon irradiation. The obtained nanosystems exhibit a synergistic effect in the chemo-thermal therapy. In another study, a loading content of 33 wt% and a loading efficiency of 88 wt% was also reported for hollow PB nanoparticles.213 In that case, the authors suggest that the loading of DOX relies on π stacking and hydrophobic interactions into the interior cavity. Remarkably, co-adsorption could also be achieved using DOX and another drug (camptothecin) in hollow PB nanoparticles in association with an introduction of a phase-change material (1-tetradecanol, melting point = 38 °C), the latter acting as both, a thermosensitive gatekeeper and a medium for loading hydrophilic and hydrophobic drugs.216 The NIR light treatment provides a precise light triggered co-delivery of DOX and camptothecin. A closely related example has also been reported using 1-pentadecanol as a phase change material and DOX in hollow PB particles of 130 nm that were obtained from polystyrene nanoparticles as a template.217 Another example consists in the demonstration of the fluorophore (indocyanine green) and DOX entrapment at the surface and possibly within the interior cavity of polyethyleneimine-modified hollow PB nanostructures.220 The surface charge modification using polyethyleneimine affords a nanoparticles’ positive surface charge that allows the subsequent interaction with the anionic indocyanine green molecules at the surface. Then, electrostatic interactions between DOX and indocyanine are responsible for the DOX capture. Despite the fact that the localization of DOX was not clearly demonstrated, such example proves the efficiency of the step-by-step (or layer-by-layer) PSM surface modification. The drug loading efficiency for indocyanine green and DOX was calculated as 5.85% and 6.74%, respectively, while the encapsulation efficiency was estimated at 40% and 32%. The systems could be viewed as a triple-modal combination therapy with photothermal and photodynamic effects associated with a drug release.
In addition to the aforementioned examples of co-drugs or dyes loading, other pharmaceutical guests could be post-synthetically adsorbed. Hence, 10-hydroxycamptothecin, a chemotherapeutic agent, has been successfully adsorbed in hyaluronic acid/PEG modified hollow PB nanoparticles obtained by layer-by-layer surface modification.194 The loading capacity of 10.4% and an encapsulation efficiency of 52% of 10-hydroxycamptothecin suggests its loading in the internal mesopore. Both, in vitro and in vivo experiments confirm its slow release as well as the possibility of photothermally-assisted drug release. Also, chloroquine, which is an autophagy inhibitor, has been simultaneously loaded with a phase-changing material (1-tetradecanol) in hollow PB nanoparticles.215 Both molecules are located in the interior cavity of the mesoporous PB nanoparticles. The functionalized nano-objects are able to deliver chloroquine using NIR light that in turn induces the phase-change of 1-tetradecanol to realize the combination of autophagy inhibition and photothermal therapy.
Remarkably, the PSM with drugs could also be achieved in non-hollow nanoparticles. Chen et al. described a multistep PSM procedure to enhance the DOX loading in PB nanoparticles.191 Surface-free PB nanoparticles were first coated with oleylamine before a lipid-PEG conjugate was used to render the PB nanoparticles hydrophilic. The DOX, in its basic form, was then encapsulated into the hydrophobic lipid region of these PEGylated PB nanoparticles by taking advantage of hydrophobic interactions at the surface of the particles. The DOX loading is estimated at 9.2%. It was found that the drug release was enhanced at acidic pH, whereas in vitro studies indicate an enhanced killing of HeLa cells due to a synergistic effect between chemo and photothermal effect. Another example of multistep surface functionalization was also reported by Lin et al.197 Cubic PB nanoparticles of 55 nm obtained using citrate were firstly decorated with a layer of polydopamine before reaction with an amino PEG. Aiming to favour the nanoparticles accumulation in tumours while reducing side effects, folic acid was attached at the end of the PEG. In a last step, DOX could be loaded in the PEG shell via hydrogen and π–π interactions with a drug loading efficiency of 36%. The drug release could be triggered by both, pH and NIR stimuli. Similarly, citrate stabilized PB nanoparticles could be firstly coated with polydopamine and next reacted with human serum albumin that allows the DOX capture by hydrogen bonding based hydrophobic interactions with a loaded weight proportion estimated at 4.3%.196 In another example, a red blood cell membrane was also associated with DOX and manganese-doped PB nanoparticles by a surface modification involving a co-extrusion method to increase the DOX loading capacity (estimated at 4.7%) and enhance the in vivo circulation time.195 Remarkably, the system could catalyse the H2O2 conversion to generate oxygen, which relieves the hypoxia of tumours. This in turn disrupts the membrane and accelerates the DOX release.
To elucidate the adsorption mechanisms, a combined theoretical–experimental approach appears pivotal. Indeed, molecular simulations (Monte Carlo and DFT calculations) allow obtaining the saturation amount of guest molecules, which can be compared with experimental loading for further optimization processes (modification of solvent, etc.), as well as the interaction energy of these molecules with the framework. Besides, plausible configurations in the pores can also be extracted and adsorption sites can be elucidated. These simulations are validated by comparison between theoretical results and experimental data. Such a strategy has already been used for the drug adsorption in MOF materials.244–247 It has for instance been possible to demonstrate the fact that the presence of solvent molecules prevents the entrance in some pores of MIL-100 due to the chemisorption of ethanol. Similar combined strategy starts now to be used in PB/PBA to understand the adsorption and co-adsorption of drug molecules in non-hollow nanoparticles without any stabilizer at their surface. Hence, using Monte Carlo simulations, it was demonstrated that the size of the DOX is clearly larger in comparison with the size of the pores generated by both, tetrahedral sites and hexacyanometallate single-vacancies.221 Yet, it could not be excluded that PB/PBA most likely exhibit the presence of two adjacent vacancies leading to bi-lacunas with a greater accessible porosity, suitable to accommodate the DOX molecules, as described in Fig. 2. Nevertheless, the comparison between the experimental (7.6 wt%) and theoretical (5 wt% if only the amount adsorbed in the porosity is considered) capacities suggests that DOX is most likely simultaneously located within the porosity of the PB framework and at the surface. Once again, this highlights the fact that understanding the arrangement of lacunas in these cyano-bridged systems, as well as the clear picturing of the mode of interaction through both, experimental/theoretical approaches, are key parameters to enhance and control the loading of drugs, as well as other physico-chemical properties.
Although it will not be discussed here, the surface PSM could also be achieved by combining PB with other inorganic materials to design original core@shell architectures.168 More generally, these results suggest that both, the nanoparticles’ surface and internal porosity of the coordination network, could act together to improve the loading capacity of drugs in the aim to design multimodal theranostic agents.
In light of the recent development in the field of PB-based biomedical applications, it appears that luminescence imaging constitutes an efficient technique to fully develop the PB capabilities with the objective to easily monitor the nanoparticles uptake into the cells, follow their biodistribution and the efficiency of a photothermal/drug treatment. However, and with the aim to circumvent the weak luminescence of PB and tune the emission wavelengths, PSM represents a method of choice.
Firstly, the nanoparticle surface could be easily functionalized. For instance, Shokouhimehr et al. reported that either 5-(aminoacetamido)fluorescein187 or Texas red cadeverine149 dyes could be conjugated to citrate coated-nanoparticles through a chemical coupling to implement luminescence for in vitro fluorescence imaging. In 2014, Dumont et al. reported the PSM of surfactant-free Mn2+-doped PB nanoparticles, whose surface was functionalized with the fluorescent avidin.203 Noticeably, this latter allows the attachment of biotinylated ligands that target paediatric brain tumours. The observed green photoluminescence arises not from PB but comes from the attached avidin moieties at the surface of the particles. In vitro and ex vitro fluorescence studies were used to study the organ biodistribution and in particularly the presence of nanoparticles in the brain. NIR fluorescence could also be implemented by functionalizing the surface serum albumin stabilized PB nanoparticles of 30 nm with the indocyanine green dye.210 These functionalized nanoparticles act as a photothermal and photodynamic agents. An enhanced photothermal effect is therefore observed due to a synergistic effect between the two photothermal agents (PB and indocyanine green). The obtained nanoscaled system associates the dual magnetic resonance imaging features of PB with the NIR fluorescence imaging, as well as the photothermal and photodynamic therapies from both PB and indocyanine green.
The same indocyanine green dye could also be loaded into hollow PB nanoparticles modified by polyethyleneimine. Remarkably DOX could be subsequently loaded to provide a system exhibiting in vivo fluorescence imaging associated with light-induced chemo/photothermal/photodynamic therapies.220
This motivated to study in details the functionalization of PB/PBA particles with luminescent species using a PSM approach. Taking advantage of both, the surface and internal porosity approaches of the PSM, the incorporation/surface attachment of two fluorophores with different sizes, chemical functions and emission wavelengths has been considered (Fig. 8A and B).167 On the one hand, 2-aminoanthracence (AA) exhibits a green emission, an amine function able to strongly interact with the active metal sites and a suitable size to be adsorbed into the pores of non-hollow nanoparticles generated by single hexacyanometallate vacancies (Fig. 1B). In contrast, the larger well-known rhodomine-B (RhB) dye could hardly access into the porosity of the coordination network, exhibits a red emission and show different possible interactions with the PB nanoparticles (electrostatic or covalent by the carboxylic moieties). The simple reaction between surfactant-free cubic PB nanoparticles of about 70 nm with the corresponding fluorophores in aqueous or ethanolic suspensions leads to the formation of PB@AA and PB@RhB. This simple strategy affords the formation of luminescent PB nanoparticles with emission wavelengths in the green or red regions (Fig. 8C), named PB@AA and PB@RhB, respectively. Remarkably, the photoluminescence could be observed in aqueous colloidal suspensions, in physiological conditions and in solid-state. The use of different experimental techniques in association with molecular modelling confirmed the adsorption mechanisms. As a result, AA is able to enter into the internal porosity of the PB framework (and may also possibly be located at the surface), while RhB is only attached at the nanoparticles surface. The estimated loading capacity of AA is of 7.6 wt% to be compared with the experimental one of 4.8 wt%. This suggests a competition with the solvent (EtOH) able to interact with the metal ions and/or diffusion issues during the adsorption of AA. The distribution of AA indicates that it is adsorbed in the pores generated by cyanometallate vacancies. Singularly, both functionalized systems (AA and RhB) do no exhibit a leakage of the fluorophores for several days indicating that such nanoprobes could be used for luminescence imaging. Hence, whereas the functionalized nanoparticles do not exhibit toxicity in the investigated concentration ranges, the cellular uptake and in vitro imaging of cancer cells confirmed that they could be efficiently used to follow the cell internationalization by luminescence imaging.
Fig. 8 (A) Scheme of the 2-aminoanthracence (AA); (B) scheme of the rhodamine B (RhB); (C) photographs of aqueous suspensions of PB, PB@AA, and PB@RhB under excitation with an UV lamp at 365 nm showing their luminescence. Reprinted with permission from ref. 167. Copyright 2020 American Chemical Society. |
This approach was later extended to adsorption of fluorescent dyes eosin Y, rhodamine B and methylene blue in citrate-stabilized PB nanoparticles that have subsequently been decorated with PEG.209
In addition, most PBA also exhibits interesting magnetic properties, which could be easily tuned (magnetic transition temperature, coercive field, magnetization at saturation) depending on the choice of the metal ions.260 Consequently, the association of magnetism and luminescence in multifunctional molecule-based nanosystems could be highly attractive to study the possible cross-effect between these properties, as well as for potential applications in sensors and electronics. The study of luminescent molecule-based magnets constitutes therefore an important topic.261–266 However, combining these two functions appears challenging since most paramagnetic transition metal ions cause a quenching of the emission. In that sense, we recently demonstrated that both, ferromagnetic properties and luminescence could coexist in the functionalized nickel hexacyanochromate (NiCr) nanoparticles by using PSM.223 This PBA analogue was selected because it does not exhibit strong absorption bands in the visible region that may cause a luminescence quenching. Moreover, it possesses a relatively high Curie temperature (TC) characterizing the transition from paramagnetic to ferromagnetic state in its bulk form permitting to easily monitor the possible modifications in the magnetic behaviour. Thus, the PSM of nickel hexacyanochromate particles of 65 nm was performed by employing the AA dye, which is able to enter within the porosity of the cyano-bridged framework. This was confirmed both, experimentally and by Monte Carlo simulations. Investigations of the magnetic properties of the functionalized nanoparticles reveal that the characteristic ferromagnetic ordering related to the nickel hexacyanochromate PBA analogue with a TC at 65 K is preserved (Fig. 9A). In contrast, the photoluminescence is found to be slightly altered due to the modification of the AA environment caused by the interaction with the PBA framework (Fig. 9B). While the emission wavelength is found only slightly modified, the temperature dependence of both, the steady-state and emission lifetimes suggest differences in the non-radiative transition probabilities, which are found being exacerbated for the functionalized nanoparticles with respect to the free AA dye. Yet, the observation of both, a long-range magnetic ordering and luminescence constitutes a rare example of a luminescent molecule-based magnet.
Fig. 9 (A) Zero Field Cooled (ZFC)/Field Cooled (FC) curves performed for NiCr@AA with an applied magnetic field of 100 Oe and showing the Curie temperature (TC) at 65 K; (B) room temperature excitation and emission spectra for NiCr@AA. Reproduced from ref. 223 with permission from the Royal Society of Chemistry. |
On the other hand, the porous structure of PB/PBA could be exploited to modify or implement chemical or physical properties of nano-objects that could not be obtained by direct synthesis. The presence of cyanometallate vacancies generates simultaneously large pores and reactive metal sites. This allows adsorbing by PSM small functional guests (drugs, metal ions or dyes) that could interact at different levels with the cyano-bridged framework confirming its great flexibility. This opens exciting perspectives in various domains, such as catalysis, biomedical applications or separation. For instance, the chemical modification of the pores by ligand exchange may allow to greatly affecting the adsorption features, such as the hydrophobic/hydrophilic balance or the separation/sensing behaviour.116 This could be achieved through a “coordination chemistry within the pores” approach by substituting or thermally removing the water molecules of the [M(NC)6−x(H2O)x] units and subsequent reactions with stronger ligands. One may therefore expect to chemically tune such cavities to specifically capture defined guests or drugs.
Moreover, additional interactions generated by the cyano-bridged coordination network might be further exploited. Although it has never been evidenced in the scope of nanoscaled PB/PBA, the π-character of cyano-ligands of the framework may be employed to promote π-interactions with appropriate guests. Such possibility has been largely exploited for the adsorption of hydrophobic guests in bulk PBA. For instance, it has been shown that the preferential interactions of cyclohexene with the PBA framework is explained by the π-character of CN bonds of the cobalt hexacyanocobaltate PBA.117
In addition, the presence of water molecules in the porosity might also mediate hydrogen bond interactions with the guest. Albeit theoretically possible, this mechanism has not been strongly evidenced to our knowledge in nanoscale PB/PBA systems. More generally, it appears that there is a lack of knowledge concerning the adsorption mechanisms in PB/PBA at the nanoscale. Among the upcoming challenges in the field, the in-depth understanding of the adsorption mechanisms, as well as the vacancies’ arrangement in these non-stoichiometric nanomaterials appear fundamental. In this sense, the input of theoretical calculations to provide a full picture of the interaction appears critical to ultimately engineer enhanced systems.
Considering the recent development of PB nanoparticles in the biomedical field, the surface functionalization will appear as particularly decisive to assure the right biodistribution and organs or tissues targeting with the aim to take advantage of the theragnostic features of PB. In comparison with metal or metal oxides nanoparticles, the surface engineering of PB has not been deeply developed and an important effort are needed in order to provide a complete picture in this area.
Besides, new PSM routes need to be further explored. In this sense, the recent example of mechanochemical PSM in bulk PBA opens interesting perspectives since it would avoid solvent competition or chemical incompatibilities between the guest and the host frameworks.267 Such methodology has to be fully implemented at the nanoscale. Furthermore, the possibility to provide multistep PSM in the internal porosity of bulk PB/PBA has been rarely exploited. For comparison, a seven-step PSM methodology using peptidic coupling was used to introduce specific functional group in a MOF-74 that in turn proved to be an efficient catalyst.268 Moreover, the PSM metal exchange, which is now widely employed in MOF chemistry,25 has never been exploited to PB/PBA materials to the best of our knowledge. Post-substitution of transition metal ions constituting the PB/PBA frameworks will allow to introduce other metal or lanthanide ions to give additional functionalities.
Besides, we have demonstrated that additional properties could be implemented, such as luminescence in PB/PBA nanoparticles by simple guest adsorptions. It appears obvious that other features (chirality, conductivity, etc.) may be added by PSM by the careful choice of the functional guests. Furthermore and although it was not discussed in this review, the PSM could be easily extended to more complex PB architectures including core@shell heterostructures PBA@PBA′ or core@shell X@PBA or PBA@Y (X = Au, Fe3O4, Y = SiO2),10 expanding the number of possibilities.
The large adaptability of the cyano-bridged framework in terms of chemical compositions in concert with the PSM methodologies, both at the surface and in the internal porosity levels, will allow to accurately shape the chemical, physical and pharmaco-kinetic properties of these intriguing nanoscaled molecule-based materials.
This journal is © the Partner Organisations 2022 |