H.
Yockell-Lelièvre
a,
N.
Bukar
a,
J. L.
Toulouse
a,
J. N.
Pelletier
abc and
J.-F.
Masson
*ad
aDépartement de chimie, Université de Montréal, CP 6128 Succ. Centre-Ville, Montreal, QC, Canada H3C 3J7. E-mail: jf.masson@umontreal.ca; Tel: +1-514-343-7342
bPROTEO,
cCentre for green chemistry and catalysis/Centre de chimie verte et de catalyse (CGCC/CCVC),
dCentre for self-assembled chemical structures (CSACS),
First published on 29th July 2015
Sensing of methotrexate at clinically-relevant concentrations was achieved with a plasmon-coupling assay. In this assay, free methotrexate and folic acid Au nanoparticles competed for human dihydrofolate reductase (hDHFR)-functionalized Au nanoparticles (Au NP). The hDHFR-functionalized Au NPs were immobilized on a small glass sensor inserted in a portable 4-channel LSPR reader. This allowed rapid (minutes) and sensitive (nanomolar range) measurement of methotrexate concentration by means of total internal reflection plasmonic spectroscopy. The large bathochromic shifts of the plasmon-coupling assay led to striking colour changes visible to the naked eye for methotrexate at clinically-relevant concentrations. The results demonstrate the potential for therapeutic drug monitoring of a widely used chemotherapy agent, as assessed with the naked eye.
Colorimetric test strips are amongst the simplest point-of-care test technologies that have had a tremendous impact on the healthcare of patients worldwide. For example, lateral flow immunoassays on test-strips have led to a series of important applications, the best known of which is the pregnancy test.3–5 These sensors are often based on naked-eye detection, as a simple and effective means to read an analytical test. Often, the colorimetric readout is enabled by the use of gold nanoparticles (Au NPs), which present a strong extinction band in the visual range due to their localized surface plasmon resonance (LSPR) properties.6,7 Au NPs are also involved in many solution-based colorimetric tests because of their ability to drastically change colour upon aggregation.8,9 The striking colour changes can also result from the plasmon coupling that accompanies dimerization of Au NP.10,11 Thus, analyte-controlled plasmon coupling can serve as an effective detection mechanism by measuring the shift in wavelength of the absorption band, or, in the best of cases where a large shift occurs, by directly observing colour changes. The design of dimerization or aggregation assays sensitive for therapeutic drugs could provide simple and effective analytical tools for TDM to routinely ascertain that drug concentrations are within the range for efficient treatment and prevent potential toxicity.
Methotrexate (MTX) is an antimetabolite drug commonly used for the chemotherapeutic treatment of various cancers.12,13 It is an unreactive analogue of folate, thereby inhibiting the dihydrofolate reductase (hDHFR) enzyme necessary for synthesis of DNA precursors and thus cell replication. Adequate dosage of MTX for a cancer patient is of the utmost importance: while being mainly cytotoxic toward cancer cells, MTX also acts upon some healthy tissues, leading to toxicity issues. However, insufficient MTX levels are ineffective in halting cancer progression.14 Since MTX absorption and clearance in an individual are influenced by many factors, including age, gender, metabolism, genetics, disease state and renal function, TDM of MTX is highly valuable for optimising the course of treatment. TDM of MTX allows for monitoring drug metabolism and patient compliance (for home-administered treatments), and to adjust treatment schedule in accordance to individualized factors.
Currently, TDM of MTX concentration in a patient's bloodstream is performed with a dedicated analyser or, less commonly, by HPLC-MS.15 Accessibility using either approach is undermined by high instrument cost and requirement for highly-trained personnel. Designing a more affordable assay for MTX that could be used by frontline healthcare workers could improve patient follow-up during chemotherapy.
Other strategies that have been proposed for MTX sensing include methods based on electrochemistry,16–21 nanoparticle-based optical detection22–24 or bioluminescence.25 We recently introduced a colorimetric test for MTX based on a competitive assay involving folic acid-derived Au NP and human dihydrofolate reductase (hDHFR).23 MTX competed with the folic acid-Au NPs for binding to hDHFR, leading to a high LSPR response (shift of wavelength, or color) at low concentrations of MTX, and the absence of LSPR response at high concentrations of MTX. Due to the relatively small absolute wavelength shift of this LSPR test, a UV-Vis spectrophotometer was required to read-out the assay. To address this shortcoming, we recently introduced a multi-channel and portable SPR instrument to monitor MTX in clinical samples using a similar Au NP competition assay.24 For that assay, hDHFR was bound to a gold film deposited onto the surface of a dove prism. The Debye length of the surface-immobilized sample was adjusted to facilitate the interaction of hDHFR and the folic acid-Au NP.26 The SPR assay was sensitive to clinical concentrations of MTX and correlated well with established techniques.
Depositing Au NPs functionalized with a molecular receptor on a solid support leads to colorimetric sensors. While the previous MTX sensor relied on SPR detection for quantifying MTX, here we present a competitive assay for TDM of MTX in the form of a Au NP sensor that provides colorimetric visualisation. In this assay, a solution of MTX and folic acid-Au NPs enter competition for another set of Au NPs functionalized with hDHFR on the sensor surface (Fig. 1). The experimental and theoretical parameters influencing the performance of the competitive LSPR assay are also reported in this manuscript. MTX can be indirectly measured by colorimetry using this assay, or by the naked eye.
Au NPs of 12 nm diameter were synthesized by the microwave-assisted citrate reduction. Sodium citrate dihydrate (0.3 g) and hydrogen tetrachloroaurate trihydrate (HAuCl4·3H2O; 40 mg) were dissolved in 1 L of water at room temperature. The solution was then heated in a 1000 W commercial microwave oven at full power for 5 min. After cooling, the suspension was centrifuged at 15000 RPM for 20 min in order to increase its concentration by about two orders of magnitude.
Another set of Au NPs with a diameter of 60 nm was synthesized using a seeded growth method.28 The concentrated 12 nm Au NPs solution (1 mL) was mixed with 3 mL of a 200 mM solution of hydroxylamine in 400 mL of water, and 5 mL of a 50 mM solution of HAuCl4·3H2O were added dropwise. After 5 min of stirring, the suspension was concentrated by centrifugation at 15000 RPM for 2 min. A TEM image of the nanospheres is provided in Fig. 2.
Nanoraspberries of 80 nm diameter were synthesized using a protocol elaborated by Xie et al.29 To 2.5 mL of a 50 mM solution of HAuCl4·3H2O diluted in 500 mL of water, 25 mL of a 0.1 M solution of HEPES (previously adjusted to pH 7.4) were added and stirred for 1 h at room temperature. The suspension was then concentrated by centrifugation at 15000 RPM for 1 min. To obtain 25 nm Au NPs, the previously synthesized 80 nm raspberry-shaped Au NPs (non-concentrated) were heated for 5 min at full power in a 1000 W commercial microwave oven. The heating induced Ostwald ripening of the particles, producing spherical, 25 nm Au NPs. The suspension was then concentrated by centrifugation at 15000 RPM for 2 min. A TEM image of the nanoraspberries was acquired to confirm the shape and size (Fig. 2).
Dove prisms (20 × 12 × 3 mm) were cleaned in hot piranha solution for 90 min (Caution! Piranha solution is highly corrosive). The LSPR sensors were fabricated by spreading and drying a small droplet of the suspension of PS-capped Au NPs onto the surface of a dove prism using a glass pipette. The PS was removed by etching with an oxygen plasma for 2 hours. The surface of the sensors was functionalized overnight with 2 mg mL−1 3-MPA-LHDLHD-OH in DMF.31 The peptide monolayer has been observed to reduce nonspecific adsorption of biomolecules.31–34 The prisms were then cleaned with ethanol and water. The carboxyl groups on the surface were activated for 20 min with an aqueous solution of N-ethyl-N′-(3-dimethylaminopropyl)-carbodiimide (EDC; 39 mg mL−1) and 5 mM N-hydroxysuccinimide (NHS; 14 mg mL−1) and washed with water and PBS pH 4.5. They were then reacted overnight in an aqueous solution of Nα′Nα-bis(carboxymethyl)-L-lysine (225 mg/30 mL water).31 The remaining activated carboxyl groups were deactivated for 5 min with 1 M ethanolamine at pH 8.5. After washing the prisms with water, they were placed in a solution of copper(II) sulfate pentahydrate (1 g per 30 mL) for 2 hours. Cu2+ is chelated by the surface-bound, modified Lys. The prisms were then washed with water and with ethanol, and dried under nitrogen flow. They were stored in the dark until use.
At the time of use, hexa-histidine-tagged human dihydrofolate reductase (hDHFR) was added to the peptide-modified prisms, such that hDHFR bound to the Cu2+ by virtue of its histidine tag. His-tagged hDHFR was heterologously expressed in Escherichia coli, purified and characterized as previously described.24 It was stably stored at −80 °C, and aliquots were thawed on ice for use.
The fabrication of the LSPR sensor relied on the formation of a monolayer of Au NPs on the surface of a dove prism. To this effect, the Au NPs were functionalized with a monolayer of polystyrene (Mn = 8000 g mol−1). Excess PS was added in order to increase the spacing between Au NPs on the surface in order to avoid surface coupling between neighbouring Au NPs. When no PS excess was present, the colour on the surface of the prism was blue indicating strong plasmon coupling, while the prisms prepared in presence of an excess PS led to a red coloration characteristic of isolated Au NP (Fig. 3). Plasmon coupling should be exclusive to the competition assay to achieve maximum sensitivity and large colour changes. To verify this hypothesis, the LSPR wavelength on the surface of the dove prism was compared with the resonance wavelength in solution. The plasmon resonance of spherical Au NPs of 60 nm diameter was 550 nm for an aqueous suspension, compared to 558 nm for identical Au NPs immobilized on the dove prism also exposed to water. Similarly, the measured plasmon resonance of 80 nm raspberry-shaped Au NPs was 590 nm both in solution and deposited on the substrate, indicating the absence of plasmon coupling. Thus, the immobilisation of the Au NPs on the dove prism did not significantly induce plasmon coupling.
The optical properties of Au NPs depend on their size and shape.6,7 The selection of the size and shape of the Au NPs on the surface of the LSPR sensor is thus a determinant of the optical properties of the sensor. A strong and sharp plasmonic band generally leads to superior plasmonic sensing due to better spectral resolution. For spherical Au NPs, the absorbance cross-section is proportional to the particle volume. However, Au NPs with diameters larger than 60 nm show an increased scattering contribution to their extinction coefficient, causing a broadening of their plasmonic band.35 Hence, Au NPs with sizes around 60 nm were selected to optimise the signal of the LSPR sensor.
Both spherical and branched Au NPs (with shapes like stars or raspberries) have previously demonstrated good performances as LSPR sensors36–39 and both were considered for this assay. When compared to spherical particles within the same size range, branched Au NPs present surface asperities that have both red-shifting and tip-confining effects on their plasmon resonance. While the varying length of the surface features can, in some cases, considerably broaden their plasmon band,29 the fairly regular, short protuberances of the raspberries synthesized here do not significantly induce plasmon band broadening and they remain interesting LSPR probe candidates. The sensitivity of LSPR sensors depends on the field penetration depth of the plasmon resonance into the dielectric layer. Theoretical simulations provide an in-depth look at the field distribution for particles of different shapes and sizes. The electric field distribution around nanoparticles (Comsol Multiphysics 4.2) was thus estimated for a 60 nm Au sphere and a 80 nm Au raspberry (Fig. 2). While the enhanced electrical field surrounding the surface protuberances of the raspberry spreads out for about 20 nm, the field surrounding the sphere reaches over 40 nm. In classical direct detection assays, Au NPs with very short field penetration depth are usually very sensitive. Thus, raspberry-shaped Au NPs are predicted to be better suited for assays involving the direct detection than spheres. However, a longer field depth is more appropriate in the case of a competitive assay involving a second Au NP in a dimerization assay. The entire study was then conducted using 60 nm spherical Au NPs as sensors.
To this effect, Au NPs of 12, 25 and 60 nm diameter were tested as competitor Au NPs. The concentrations of the different sized competitors were set to give an absorbance of 5 at their maximum plasmon resonance wavelength (the absorbance was measured at 1 for a 5-fold diluted sample). This corresponded to approximately 20, 2.5 and 0.16 nM for 12, 25 and 60 nm Au NPs, respectively (the concentrations reported here are for NPs). These concentrations were selected to maximize the shift in the absence of MTX, hence maximizing the range of the MTX assay and the magnitude of colour change observed in the assay. In the absence of MTX, the plasmon coupling resulted in shifts of 27 nm for Au NPs of 25 nm diameter, which was nearly twice that observed with 12 nm NPs (shift = 15 nm). However, the plasmon coupling shift was much lower for Au NPs of 60 nm diameter (shift = 3 nm).
Increasing the particle diameter from 12 to 25 nm resulted in larger shifts as expected, but the unexpected decrease in shift upon using 60 nm Au NP appears to result from poor colloidal stability, as noted by a strong colour change of the suspension. The folic acid competitor Au NPs must retain colloidal stability in the assay buffer.26 Here, the Au NPs are stabilised in PBS due to the surface charges induced by the presence of negatively-charged folate ions bound on their surface. This charge prevented aggregation of Au NPs caused by NP size-dependant van der Waals attractive forces. We recently reported that the Debye length of folate-capped Au NPs should be less than 1 nm to achieve optimal interaction with the sensor surface-bound hDHFR,26 and thus the solution conditions used here were identical to the ones reported in the previous communication. The Debye length was consistent with the size of the folate ion (0.8 nm).26 While 25 nm Au NP are well stabilized in PBS with a ∼1 nm Debye length, the same parameters will cause 60 nm Au NPs to aggregate over the course of a few minutes, thus thwarting the performance of the assay. The 25 nm Au NPs were therefore selected for the MTX assay, in order to obtain the largest shift and thus, colour change.
The 60 nm Au NPs on the LSPR sensor are sufficiently large to host a few 25 nm competitor Au NPs. It is important to understand the influence of multiple Au NP binding events on individual sensor-bound Au NPs. As large scale aggregation should be observed for Au NP suspensions, and since TEM cannot be performed on the LSPR substrates, simulations were performed with Comsol Multiphysics 4.2 to predict the shift expected when a 60 nm Au sphere is in close proximity to one, two or three 25 nm Au NPs, all distanced by a gap ranging from 2 to 6 nm (Fig. 4). The calculated values of the shifts at the 4 nm gap corresponding to the anticipated distance of Au NP in the MTX assay were 19, 25 and 33 nm, respectively for one, two and three 25 nm Au NPs coupled to the 60 nm Au NP on the LSPR sensor. The experimentally observed plasmon coupling of the Au NP competitor with the LSPR sensor led to a 27 nm shift, in good agreement with the simulations for two Au NP competitors binding to a single 60 nm Au NP on the LSPR sensor.
The analysis time was shortened by determining the binding rate during the first seconds following sample injection, as previously demonstrated.24 Normalized calibration curves were obtained from the binding shifts after 10 minutes and from the binding rate calculated from the slope of the first 12 seconds after injection (Fig. 5). Both calibration methods extracted from the same data set are in good agreement, demonstrating that quantification is possible in 12 seconds. The results can be confirmed from equilibrium binding data.
Colorimetric sensing with naked-eye detection was also achieved with the SPR sensor. The large 25 nm shift for the lowest MTX concentrations resulted in observable colour changes. Photographs of dove prism sensors exposed to 0, 100 and 1000 nM MTX standards illustrate the resulting colour changes (Fig. 6). The colour difference is sufficient to distinguish the MTX concentration following MTX administration (above 1000 nM), near the 72 h post-administration safety threshold of 100 nM, and where patients that have completely metabolised MTX. These colour changes can be easily distinguished by the naked eye. Once the samples sensors were dried after being withdrawn from the instrument, the plasmon shift was permanent and the colour remained intact for at least 12 months. Traceability, archiving and verification are key issues in clinical measurements. Long-term colour stability is an additional advantage of this colorimetric MTX sensor for traceability and verification of TDM results.
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2016 |