Search for active and inactive ion insertion sites in organic crystalline materials

Abstract

The position of mobile active and inactive ions, specifically ion insertion sites, within organic crystals, significantly affects the properties of organic materials used for energy storage and ionic transport. Identifying the positions of these atomic (and ionic) sites in an organic crystal is challenging, especially when the element has low X-ray scattering power, such as lithium (Li) and hydrogen, which are difficult to detect by powder X-ray diffraction. First-principles calculations, exemplified by density functional theory (DFT), are very practical for confirming the relative stability of ion positions in materials. However, the lack of effective strategies to identify ion sites in these organic crystalline frameworks renders this task extremely challenging. This work presents two algorithms: the (i) efficient location of ion insertion sites from extrema in electrostatic local potential and charge density (ELIISE), and the (ii) ElectRostatic InsertioN (ERIN), which leverage charge density and electrostatic potential fields accessed from first-principles calculations, combined with the Simultaneous Ion Insertion and Evaluation (SIIE) workflow. SIIE inserts all ions simultaneously—to determine ion positions in organic crystals. We demonstrate that these methods accurately reproduce known ion positions in 16 organic materials and identify previously overlooked low-energy sites in tetralithium 2,6-naphthalenedicarboxylate (Li₄NDC), an organic electrode material, highlighting the importance of inserting all ions simultaneously, as in the SIIE workflow. These algorithms are also integrated with off-the-shelf machine learning potentials, yielding promising results comparable to first-principles findings.