Oriol
Martínez-Ferraté‡
a,
Basujit
Chatterjee‡
a,
Christophe
Werlé
*a and
Walter
Leitner
*ab
aMax Planck Institute for Chemical Energy Conversion, Stiftstr. 34–36, Mülheim an der Ruhr, 45470, Germany. E-mail: christophe.werle@cec.mpg.de; walter.leitner@cec.mpg.de
bInstitut für Technische und Makromolekulare Chemie (ITMC), RWTH Aachen University, Worringer Weg 2, Aachen, 52074, Germany
First published on 17th October 2019
Manganese(I) complexes bearing triazole ligands are reported as catalysts for the hydrosilylation of carbonyl and carboxyl compounds. The desired reaction proceeds readily at 80 °C within 3 hours at catalyst loadings as low as 0.25 to 1 mol%. Hence, good to excellent yields of alcohols could be obtained for a wide range of substrates including ketones, esters, and carboxylic acids illustrating the versatility of the metal/ligand combination.
The hydrosilylation of CO groups is a transformation of broad synthetic utility6 and has recently been studied with manganese catalysts.7 This reaction allows the one-step synthesis of protected silyl alcohols, which can be in a second step hydrolysed to the corresponding alcohols. The protocols represent an alternative to hydrogenation reactions where easy and safe-to-handle silanes replace the use of hydrogen.8 Up to now, research in the area has focused mainly on carbonyl substrates using Mn(II) complexes,9 and only a few studies have dealt with Mn(I) or Mn(0).10 The hydrosilylation of carboxyl compounds is even less studied. For carboxylic acids, reduction with a Mn(0)-complex has been reported to yield aldehydes rather than alcohols as the preferred products.10e This lack of knowledge is surprising given that Mn(I) catalysts have already demonstrated a pronounced ability for the transfer of hydrides to substrates displaying electrophilic centres (e.g., in the case of hydrogenation and hydroboration reactions).11 In the previous studies, the Mn(I) complexes under scrutiny were composed mostly of cyclopentadienyl, carbene, or phosphine ligands (Chart 1).10a–d Nitrogen-based ligands can provide an attractive alternative, and triazole units have received attention as versatile donor units.1a,12 Their synthesis takes advantage of the modularity of copper-catalysed azide–alkyne cycloaddition (i.e., click-chemistry), which is convenient to access structurally different ligand frameworks via this atom- and step-economic robust synthetic method.13 Hence, the stereoelectronic properties of the ligand architecture can be finely adjusted. Besides, their denticity can be controlled and thus, bidentate or tridentate variations are accessible, leading to neutral or cationic complexes respectively.13d,e,14
In the present study, we report the catalytic performance of Mn(I) complexes bearing triazol-based ligands for the hydrosilylation of carbonyl and in particular also for carboxyl derivatives. The new cationic complex 3 bearing a tridentate (PNN)-iminotriazole ligand and bidentate neutral complexes previously reported by our group11b were investigated. We found that the selected catalysts were able to convert a wide range of ketones to corresponding alcohols. Notably, the (PNN)-manganese(I) complex 3 showed promising results even in the reduction of ester and acid functionalities.
Scheme 1 Reagents and conditions for the synthesis of 2 and 3: a) MgSO4, toluene, 105 °C, 16 h, 99%; b) toluene, r.t., 60 h, 46%. |
The catalytic activity of complex 3 was first studied for the hydrosilylation of ketones using acetophenone (4a) as a benchmark substrate (Table 1). Reacting 4a with one equivalent of PhSiH3 and 1 mol% of 3 under neat conditions at 80 °C for 20 h, produced alcohol 5a after hydrolysis in 85% yield. In order to improve the efficiency of the reaction, a panel of different solvents were investigated. When the reaction was carried out in tetrahydrofuran (THF) or acetonitrile (MeCN), entry 2 and 3 respectively, yields up to 99% of 5a were obtained. When the reaction time was reduced to 3 hours (entries 4–8), lower yields were obtained with apolar solvents (e.g., 15% in toluene), but yields remained high in the polar solvents (e.g., 99% in THF, 90% in MeCN).
For comparison, neutral triazole complexes 6–8 were prepared following previously described procedures,11b and tested also for the hydrosilylation of acetophenone (Fig. 1). Using 1 mol% of catalyst loading at 80 °C for 3 h, all the studied complexes were able to reduce 4a to 5a with yields up to 99%. To study more precisely the influence of the ligand, the reaction times were reduced to one hour while keeping the catalyst loading unchanged. Under these conditions, iminotriazole complexes 3 and 8 provided the best results, with yields reaching 99%. When complexes 6 and 7 were used, slightly lower yields were obtained (96%). Furthermore, when the catalyst loadings were reduced to 0.1 mol%, catalyst 8 exhibited the best performance. Finally, the activity of Mn(CO)5Br was also verified. When subjected to the standard set of conditions, 56% of conversion and 21% of the corresponding alcohol were obtained.
Based on the standard set of reaction conditions, we examined the substrate scope. These results are summarized in Scheme 2. For acetophenone derivatives, high yields were obtained for all studied para-substituted substrates 5b–e. Only a minor impact related to the electronic properties was observed. The yields decreased slightly in the presence of electron donating groups where 95% and 93% of 5b and 5c were obtained, respectively. Introducing electron-donating groups in meta- and para-position of substrate 4h, provided only 14% of 5h when 0.25 mol% of catalyst loading was used. However, this could be increased to 73% yield with 1 mol% of catalyst loading under otherwise identical conditions. Low yields (2% of 5f and 10% of 5g) were observed also for the ortho-substituted compounds at low catalyst loading. Again, moderate yields (49% for 5g) could be achieved when 1 mol% of catalyst 8 was used. It is conceivable that the lower yields are due to an increased steric hindrance around the carbonyl functionality for these substrates. The heteroaromatic ketone 4i were not reduced under these conditions. The naphthyl derivatives 4j and 4k could be converted with good yields showing different reactivities depending on the relative position of the ketone. In the case of 2-acetonaphtone 4j, 94% of isolated yield could be obtained with only 0.25 mol% of 8. On the other hand, 1-acetonaphthone 4k, required higher catalyst loadings (1 mol%) to furnish 5k in 77% yield. This result can be rationalized by the ortho-substituted nature of ketone 4k following the same trend as for 4f–i. Benzophenone 4l was reduced to the corresponding alcohol 5l in high yield, similar to other substrates containing unsubstituted phenyl rings (4m, n). For the aliphatic substrate cyclohexanone 4o and 1-cyclohexylethanone 4p, good yields (43% and 63% respectively) could be achieved with 1 mol% of catalyst loading. The linear aliphatic ketones 2- and 3-octanone (4q and 4r) were hydrosilylated in high yields, whereby 4q required again higher catalyst loading (1 mol%). Even the sterically congested tert-butyl methyl ketone 4s was readily reduced providing 5s in good yields (79%).
After the successful hydrosilylation of ketones, the catalytic competence of the Mn(I) catalysts was probed for the hydrosilylation of more challenging carboxyl groups in esters and acids. In the case of esters as substrates, the reduction and hydrolysis can lead to either the corresponding alcohols or ethers as products. Ethyl benzoate 9 was chosen as prototypical substrate for the screening of catalysts and reaction conditions (Table 2). Reacting 9 with 2 equivalents of PhSiH3 and 2 mol% of complex 8 in THF at 80 °C for 3 hours led to moderate conversions (53%), with preferential formation of ethyl benzyl ether 11 (94%) relative to benzyl alcohol 10 (6%, entry 1). Catalyst 6 gave slightly higher conversion than 8 forming a nearly 1:1 mixture of ether and alcohol (entry 2). When complex 7 was used, only 18% conversion was obtained with alcohol 10 being the preferred product in this case (entry 3). The highest activity for reduction was observed with complex 3 that fully converted 9 to a roughly 60:40 mixture of 10 and 11 under the given conditions (entry 4).
Entry | t (°C) | Cat. (mol%) | Conv.a (%) | Sel. 10a (%) | Sel. 11a (%) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
0.5 mmol ethyl benzoate, 1 mmol phenylsilane, 3 h, 0.2 mL of THF. a Quantified by 1H NMR using tetradecane as an internal standard. b Slow addition of phenyl silane, 0.33 mmol per hour. c Hydrolysis with Me4NF, and further addition of 10 equivalents of sodium hydride and 5 equivalents of ethyl bromide. d Yield after workup. | |||||
1 | 80 | 8 (2) | 53 | 6 | 94 |
2 | 80 | 6 (2) | 67 | 48 | 52 |
3 | 80 | 7 (2) | 18 | 67 | 33 |
4 | 80 | 3 (2) | 100 | 62 | 38 |
5 | 105 | 8 (2) | 88 | 35 | 65 |
6 | 120 | 8 (2) | 100 | 32 | 68 |
7 | 140 | 8 (2) | 100 | 25 | 75 |
8 | r.t. | 3 (2) | 18 | 83 | 17 |
9 | 60 | 3 (2) | 64 | 77 | 23 |
10 | 100 | 3 (2) | 100 | 57 | 43 |
11b | 80 | 3 (2) | 81 | 84 | 16 |
12c | 80 | 3 (2) | 78d | — | 100 |
To investigate whether the two products 10 and 11 are interconverted under the given reaction conditions, two control experiments were carried out (Scheme S1†). Firstly, reductive ether cleavage was investigated. Only 1% of 11 was converted to alcohol 10 under the optimized reaction conditions established for the hydrosilylation of 9 in presence of excess phenylsilane. Similarly, no etherification was observed when alcohol 10 was reacted with ethanol in the presence of 3 and phenylsilane. These results indicate that the selectivity is controlled through competing pathways, presumable branching from a common intermediate RC(OR′)(OSiH2Ph), rather than by secondary interconversion.
Having established the principle ability for carboxyl reduction, the variation of reaction conditions was investigated (Table 2). The rate of reduction increased at elevated temperatures reaching full conversion above 120 °C for catalysts 8 (entries 1, 5–7). The ether 11 remained the preferred product, but selectivity decreased from 94% to ca. 70% at higher temperature. For catalyst 3, the selectivity towards the alcohol product 10 also increased with decreasing temperature, albeit at the expense of conversion (entry 4, 8–10). The reaction was not very solvent dependent and toluene, as well as neat conditions, provide potential alternatives to THF (Fig. S1†). The reactivity of silanes followed the hydricity strength in the order PhSiH3 > Ph2SiH2 ≫ Ph3SiH with only moderate influence on product distribution (Table S1†). A significant improvement could be achieved when PhSiH3 was added slowly (0.33 mmol per hour) to the reaction mixture at 80 °C. This protocol combined high conversion (81%) with good selectivity towards the alcohol 10 (84%) (entry 11).
Examples for the synthesis of ethers via hydrosilylation of esters are limited and ample scope prevails for further development.10e,g We, therefore, investigated the possibility to combine the reduction step directly with a workup under etherification conditions to provide access to 11 from 9. After reduction of 9 with PhSiH3 using catalyst 3 under standard conditions, the reaction mixture was treated with tetramethylammonium fluoride to remove the silyl group, followed by addition of ethyl bromide and base. The ether 11 was isolated in 78% yield directly from this method after standard workup procedure (Table 2, entry 12).
Subsequently, various esters were hydrosilylated using cationic catalyst 3 under the standard set of reaction conditions to assess the scope and limitation of the reduction (Table 3). When benzoates were used as substrates, comparable results in yield and selectivity for methyl-, ethyl- and benzyl-benzoates were observed (entry 1–3, Table 3). For the bulky tert-butyl ester a low conversion was obtained (14%) with the selectivity favouring formation of ether-type product 11 over the alcohol 10 (60% versus 40%, entry 4). Interestingly, phenyl benzoate (entry 5), provided satisfactory results with 80% conversion and high selectivity 82% for corresponding benzyl alcohol. When ethyl heptanoate was used as substrate we observed a full reduction of the ester, with the ether being the major product (60%, entry 6). Finally, para-substituted methyl-benzoates substrates could be fully converted to the alcohols as the major product (entry 7–8).
Entry | R | R′ | Conv.a (%) | Sel. 10a (%) | Sel. 11a (%) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
0.5 mmol ethyl benzoate, 2 mol% of 3, 1 mmol phenylsilane, 0.2 mL of THF. a Quantified by 1H NMR using tetradecane or mesitylene as an internal standard. | |||||
1 | Ph | Me | 97 | 69 | 31 |
2 | Ph | Et | 100 | 62 | 38 |
3 | Ph | Bn | 100 | 70 | 30 |
4 | Ph | t Bu | 14 | 40 | 60 |
5 | Ph | Ph | 80 | 82 | 18 |
6 | C6H13 | Et | 100 | 40 | 60 |
7 | Me | 100 | 73 | 27 | |
8 | Me | 100 | 78 | 22 |
Then, we explored the hydrosilylation of acids with leading complexes 3 and 8 and benzoic acid as the benchmark substrate (Table 4). Gratifyingly, conversion of 50% with 98% selectivity towards the corresponding alcohol was observed with catalyst 3 at 80 °C (entry 2). At lower (60 °C, entry 1) as well as higher temperatures (140 °C, entry 3) the conversions towards 10 decreased to 26% and 31% respectively. At 60 °C (entry 1), significant amounts of aldehyde 13 were formed (38%). Control experiments at 80 °C for 2 hours in absence of catalyst 3 in solution (entry 8) and neat (entry 9) revealed no conversion. The neutral complex 8 showed lower catalytic activity than 3 (entries 4–6). When catalyst loading for 3 was increased to 2 mol%, 94% conversion (entry 7) with nearly perfect selectivity for the alcohol could be obtained even with lower reaction time of 2 h, setting these conditions as standard conditions for exploring the substrate scope.
Entry | t (°C) | Time (h) | Cat. (mol%) | Conv.a (%) | Sel. 10a (%) | Sel. 13a (%) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
0.5 mmol acid, 1 mmol phenylsilane, 0.2 mL of THF. a Quantified by 1H NMR using mesitylene or tetradecane as an internal standard. b Reaction was performed in the absence of catalyst. c Reaction was performed in absence of catalyst under neat condition. | ||||||
1 | 60 | 3 | 3 (1) | 26 | 62 | 38 |
2 | 80 | 3 | 3 (1) | 50 | 98 | <1 |
3 | 140 | 3 | 3 (1) | 31 | 100 | — |
4 | 80 | 3 | 8 (1) | 28 | 100 | — |
5 | 120 | 3 | 8 (1) | 10 | 80 | 20 |
6 | 140 | 3 | 8 (1) | 2 | 100 | — |
7 | 80 | 2 | 3 (2) | 94 | 100 | — |
8b | 80 | 2 | — | 0 | — | — |
9c | 80 | 2 | — | 0 | — | — |
Based on the standard set of reaction conditions, we examined the substrate scope of carboxylic acids as reported in Scheme 3. It is shown that the para-substituted substrates 15b and 15c could be converted in high yields, albeit with a noticeable influence of the electron-withdrawing substituents. Introducing a NO2 group in the meta-position in substrate 14d, reduced the yield to 12% for 15d. The aliphatic substrates 14e–h could be converted in good yields (67% and 66% for 14e and 14h, respectively) to excellent yields (95% and 86% for 14f and 14g, respectively). In addition, oxalic acid 14i remarkably provided the corresponding diol (15i) with a high yield of 91%. These results indicate a broad portfolio of potential target substrates.
On the basis of the experimental observations and current reports in the literature,7b,15 a tentative mechanism for the hydrosilylation of the carboxylic CO units using Mn(I) complexes can be proposed (Scheme 4). In the presence of phenylsilane, a catalytically active neutral hydride complex [Mn-H] may be formed under concomitant formation of a silyl cation.16 This mode of activation is supported by ex situ reaction of complex 3 with PhSiH3. Analysis of the reaction mixture revealed the formation of a hydride complex 16 based on HR-MS data indicating a molecular formula [C31H25MnN4O2P]+ and a hydride signal in the 1H-NMR spectrum at −8.56 ppm (see ESI† for further details). The [Mn-H] species are expected to catalyse hydride transfer from PhSiH3 to the silyl-activated substrate. The resulting intermediate A can be converted by hydrolysis or desilylation to aldehyde B or it is reduced further via a second Mn-catalysed hydride transfer to the alkyl- or silyl-ether derivatives affording after hydrolysis the corresponding organic product alcohol C or ether D. While the exact nature of the catalytically active [Mn-H] species and how it enables the hydride transfer still needs to be elucidated, the proposed pathway is in line with the currently available experimental data and may thus serve as a working hypothesis for future studies.
Scheme 4 A tentative reaction mechanism for Mn(I)-catalysed hydrosilylation of carboxylic groups in acids or esters. |
In summary, we have shown that manganese(I) complexes based on iminotriazole ligands constitute efficient catalysts for the hydrosilylation of carbonyl and carboxyl groups. Aromatic and aliphatic ketones can be reduced with good to excellent yields at low catalyst loadings within 1 h reaction time, using either neutral or cationic complexes comprising bidentate or tridentated ligands, respectively. Extending the reaction to carboxyl groups, esters were reduced with very high conversions, whereby the bidentate-ligated complex 8 favoured formation of ether products while in complex 3 bearing a tridentate (PNN)-iminotriazole ligand lead preferentially to alcohols. Most significantly, complex 3 provides the first example for effective manganese(I) catalysed hydrosilylation of carboxylic acids to alcohols, we believe that the insights provided herein will encourage further investigations into the dynamic field of manganese(I) catalysis in the prospect of finding greener alternatives to existing catalytic methodologies.
Footnotes |
† Electronic supplementary information (ESI) available. See DOI: 10.1039/c9cy01738k |
‡ These authors contributed equally to this work. |
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2019 |