Electrocatalysis in deep eutectic solvents: from fundamental properties to applications

Electrocatalysis stands out as a promising avenue for synthesizing high-value products with minimal environmental footprint, aligning with the imperative for sustainable energy solutions. Deep eutectic solvents (DESs), renowned for their eco-friendly, safe, and cost-effective nature, present myriad advantages, including extensive opportunities for material innovation and utilization as reaction media in electrocatalysis. This review initiates with an exposition on the distinctive features of DESs, progressing to explore their applications as solvents in electrocatalyst synthesis and electrocatalysis. Additionally, it offers an insightful analysis of the challenges and prospects inherent in electrocatalysis within DESs. By delving into these aspects comprehensively, this review aims to furnish a nuanced understanding of DESs, thus broadening their horizons in the realm of electrocatalysis and facilitating their expanded application.


Introduction
2][3][4][5] The exploration and development of renewable energy sources aimed at mitigating global energy and environmental challenges has come to the forefront.][19][20][21][22][23] DESs represent environmentally friendly liquid media formed by the self-association of two or three components through hydrogen bond interactions between hydrogen bond donors (HBDs) and acceptors (HBAs) (Fig. 1a). 24The term "eutectic" was rst proposed in 1884 to indicate "a lower temperature of liquefaction than that given by any other proportion"; 25 the term "deep" refers to a difference between the actual eutectic temperature and the ideal eutectic temperature in the phase diagram when the ideal eutectic temperature is higher than the actual eutectic temperature. 26,27In 2003, Abbott et al. discovered an abnormal decrease in the melting point at the eutectic composition of urea and choline chloride (ChCl). 28he early DESs are characterized by ionic HBAs and HBDs, aer which they are further expanded to non-ionic molecular HBAs and HBDs, 29 and they are categorized into ve distinct types in the early research (Fig. 2). 30Recently, Chen et al. proposed a new classication of DESs including ionic-ionic, molecular-molecular, ionic-molecular, metallic-metallic, ionic-metallic, and molecular-metallic types. 26In the past decades, DES research has received broad attention, with a large increase in the number of relevant research articles per year (Fig. 1b).As DESs show unique characteristics including simple preparation, costeffectiveness, low vapor pressure, nonammability, excellent solubility and dispersibility, high thermal and chemical stability, high ionic conductivity, wide electrochemical stable window (ESW), designability, compositional tunability, etc., [30][31][32][33][34][35][36][37][38][39][40] they have been widely used in the elds of extraction and separation, 41,42 gas capture and separation, [43][44][45] batteries, 31,40,46,47 energy storage, 48-50 materials preparation, 33,51-53 and catalysis. 54,55olvents play signicant roles in material synthesis and chemical reactions as they can modulate the nucleation and growth of materials and the pathways of reactions. 56,57Due to their special characteristics, DESs are potential solvents to control the synthesis of materials and chemicals.Particularly, DESs are suitable candidates in electrocatalysis because of their high conductivity, wide ESW, and high stability, and they can be employed as solvents for the synthesis of electrocatalysts as well as being used as electrolytes.However, the current research on DESs related to electrocatalysis is very limited (Fig. 1b).Therefore, a prompt and comprehensive review on the application of DESs in electrocatalysis is highly desirable.This review rst summarizes the features of DESs.Subsequently, the distinct advantages of DESs as solvents/electrolytes in electrocatalysis are highlighted, and the unique functions of DESs in electrocatalyst synthesis and electrocatalysis are detailed (Fig. 1c).Finally, this review examines the challenges and opportunities of DESs in electrocatalysis.Such an overview aims to contribute to the development of this emerging eld and to advance the understanding of the role of DESs in electrocatalysis.

Interactions
DESs are composed of at least two components, each of which has a melting point higher than the nal mixture.Their formation is dependent on intermolecular interactions among diverse components, surpassing the inherent interactions within each component. 39Typically, three primary interactions drive the formation of DESs, as illustrated in Fig. 3.
The foremost interaction is hydrogen bonding, which mainly determines the formation of DESs.Such DESs encompass at least one HBA [e.g.ChCl, metal halides, and quaternary ammonium salt analogous] and an HBD (e.g.amide, alcohol, or carboxylic acid molecules). 39The robust hydrogen bond between the HBA and the HBD reduces their original intermolecular interactions, resulting in a reduced melting point. 24,39urthermore, the hydrogen bond determines the eutectic point of the HBD to the HBA. 39For instance, the eutectic points of ChCl/urea and ChCl/thiourea systems are 1/2 (n/n) and 1/3 (n/ n), respectively. 58Thus, varying the molar ratio of HBDs and HBAs selection allows for ner control over the physicochemical properties of DESs.
Lewis acid-base interaction is another important interaction in DES systems.A Lewis acid is dened as a substance with the capability to accept an electron pair, which is donated by a Lewis base.Under the Lewis acid-base theory, cations as well as compounds such as BF 3 that could accept electron pairs can act as Lewis acids while anions as well as compounds like NH 3 and PH 3 containing lone electron pairs are considered as Lewis bases.Indeed, Lewis acid-base interactions in DESs are not considered sufficient for the formation of covalent bonds. 39hey are preferable to only change the coordination environment to obtain a low-melting point eutectic solvent. 39Li + , Na + , and K + are typical Lewis acids and can form DESs with a variety of Lewis bases such as amides, carbonates, and ethers. 39,59an der Waals interactions, comprising Keesom forces (dipole-dipole effect), Debye forces (dipole-induced dipole effect), and London dispersion forces, widely exist in DESs. 39,60eesom force emerges from the interaction of permanent dipoles; Debye force is the attractive energy between a polar molecule and a nonpolar molecule; London dispersion force refers to the weak attractive force between the instantaneous dipole moments of molecules when they are close to each other.van der Waals interaction is the weakest interaction among chemical forces, possessing a strength of about 4 kJ mol −1 . 61van der Waals interactions are weak, yet they can occur and show up between any two molecules, which makes them essential to the whole system.Generally, van der Waals interactions predominate in eutectic systems, which manifests that the original intermolecular interactions of the single component are replaced by the newly produced van der Waals forces aer adding a new component. 39Notably, van der Waals forces play a key role in ne-tuning the physicochemical properties of DESs, working together with other interactions.
The synergy of hydrogen bonds, Lewis acid-base interaction, and van der Waals inuences the formation and properties of DESs.The intermolecular interactions can be further modied by changing the functional group of molecules and the composition of the mixture to determine the properties and phase behavior of DESs.3][64][65] Besides, interactions in DESs could construct supramolecular networks to control the growth direction of materials and could also play signicant roles in activating reactants and stabilizing intermediates, 30,40,[66][67][68] making DESs promising candidates as electrolytes for electrocatalysis.

Physicochemical properties
The interactions in DESs determine the physicochemical properties of DESs.Their unique physicochemical features enable precise control over electrocatalyst production and electrocatalysis.For example, the vapor pressure of DESs is typically low, 69 which not only reduces the solvent loss during the reaction but also allows for a liquid state at a wide temperature range, enhancing the applicability across diverse environmental conditions.1][72] DESs have a wide ESW, which results in the high electrochemical stability of DESs in electrocatalytic reactions. 73,74Variations in the molar ratio of eutectic components can alter the overall ESW, allowing for tailoring electrochemical performance. 74The wide ESW provides a broad prospect for DESs as electrolytes to manipulate the electric double layer (EDL).The inherent ionic properties and relatively high polarity of DESs result in their good solubility that could dissolve various inorganic and organic compounds, 24 and the Lewis acid/base sites or hydrogen bonds in DESs can bind with solutes to promote their dissolution.6][77][78][79] The viscosity of DESs signicantly exceeds that of typical molecular solvents, which leads to low current densities when DESs are used as electrolytes. 80However, the viscosity could be reduced by adding extra molecules, using small ions, and increasing temperature in terms of Hole theory. 24,58The difference in the freezing point at the eutectic composition of a binary mixture of A + B compared to that of a theoretical ideal mixture (DT) is an important parameter concerning the phase behavior of DESs, and the stronger interaction between HBDs and HBAs results in a higher DT value, 58 which extends the liquid range of DESs as electrolytes.DESs can mediate the synthesis of materials and the microenvironment of EDL through its role in pH regulation. 81,82The pH of DESs is closely related to temperature and the ratio of HBDs to HBAs and inuences the EDL microenvironment. 81,82Thus, electrocatalyst synthesis could be modulated by tuning the pH of DESs. 24High entropy is one of the unique thermodynamic properties of DESs.For the formation of DESs [A (solid) + B (solid) / A-B (liquid)], the entropy change of the above processes should be positive because both solid-liquid transformation and mixing processes increase the entropy of the system. 26Inspired by the concept of high-entropy alloys, 83,84 DESs could be high-entropy DESs. 26[87] 3. DESs as solvents

Advantages of DESs as solvents
Electrode materials and electrolytes are two main components in a typical electrocatalytic system.DESs could not only be directly used as electrolytes but also be used as solvents for the  controlled synthesis of electrocatalysts.Fig. 4 illustrates a comparative analysis of the properties of various solvents used as electrolytes. 880][91] As organic solvents have very low ionic conductivity, supporting electrolytes such as ionic liquids (ILs) are usually introduced into the solvent to prepare organic electrolytes. 88,92Although they exhibit high conductivity, the environmentally unfriendly organic solvent and high cost of the supporting electrolyte limit the large-scale applications of organic electrolytes in electrocatalysis.Compared with aqueous and organic systems, DESs exhibit unique advantages such as low cost, high stability, environmental friendliness, etc.The distinctive hydrogen bond structure of DESs plays a pivotal role in regulating the EDL structure to modulate the ionic solvation environment and stabilize intermediates, thus affecting the selectivity and kinetics of electrocatalytic reactions.Due to their excellent dissolving ability, low vapor pressure, and high stability, DESs could be used as solvents for material synthesis at high temperature.The hydrogen bond network and electrostatic interaction in DES systems create a special microenvironment distinct from conventional solvents, and the unique microenvironment can not only modulate the reaction kinetics but also change the thermodynamic behavior of the solution.DESs exhibit unique advantages as solvents for electrocatalyst synthesis and as electrolytes (Table 1), which are summarized in detail in the subsequent section.
3.2 DESs as solvents for electrocatalyst synthesis 3.2.1 Dissolving and dispersing.][98][99][100][101] DESs can be used as excellent solvents for hydrothermal synthesis of highentropy alloy NiFeCoMnAl due to the good solubility of all precursors including MnCl 2 , NiCl 2 , CoCl 2 , FeCl 3 , and AlCl 3 (Fig. 5a). 102DESs can disperse individual metals uniformly which promotes the formation of high-entropy materials (Fig. 5b).Furthermore, the microscopic morphology of highentropy alloys can be precisely modulated by tuning distinct HBAs and HBDs such as urea, thiourea, citric acid, polyethylene glycol (PEG), and ethylene glycol (EG).Among them, NiFe-CoMnAl synthesized in PEG/thiourea shows excellent OER performance with an overpotential of only 220 mV and 317 mV at 10 mA cm −2 and 100 mA cm −2 , respectively.4][105] The solubility of gas molecules in the electrolyte signicantly inuences the adsorption and mass transport, consequently impacting the performance of electrocatalysis. 106or example, ChCl/EG with a molar ratio of 1 : 2 exhibits excellent dissolving ability for CO 2 (1.3 mol CO 2 per mol ChCl/ EG; 329 K, 76.5 kPa), resulting in the boosted CO 2 electroreduction performance. 107Protsenko et al. synthesized Ni/TiO 2 by electrodeposition in ChCl/EG. 108Through intensifying the stirring of ChCl/EG, the transfer of colloidal particles to the electrode surface is accelerated, and hence more dispersed particles can be electrodeposited on the electrode surface.The as-prepared Ni/TiO 2 exhibits enhanced electrocatalytic properties for the HER, compared with that prepared in conventional aqueous electrolytes.The homogeneous dispersion of secondphase particles in the electrolyte is crucial to obtain the uniform coating during the electro-deposition. 109,110Wang et al. prepared a three-dimensional ower-like structure of nickel matrix composite electrodes via facile electrodeposition in ChCl/EG for the HER (Fig. 5c). 111The high viscosity of ChCl/EG is conductive to diminish the settling velocity of particles and the high ionic strength reduces the interactions among particles, preventing extensive particle agglomeration within the electrolyte. 1103.2.2Accelerated kinetics.The kinetics for the material formation could be accelerated in DESs. 30,112This mainly stems from the homogeneous medium provided by their hydrogen-bonding framework and the template effect, as well as energy reduction effects due to their supramolecular properties.Moreover, DESs possess excellent solvation properties and are able to better dissolve reactants, which helps to increase the effective concentration of reactants, improve the reaction rate, and promote collisions and reactions between reactants.Traditionally, cobalt-vanadium oxides are prepared by solid-state reaction, hydrothermal reaction, or coprecipitation methods with a long reaction time and high temperature. 113,114However, octahedral CoV 2 O 6 nanomaterials could be well synthesized under mild conditions in the ChCl/ malonic acid system. 30,112Söldner et al. synthesized spineltype ferrite nanoparticles MFe 2 O 4 (M = Mg, Zn, Co, Ni) in ChCl/maleic acid. 115The synthesis of MFe 2 O 4 in the DES could proceed at much lower temperatures than other methods, and the resultant materials show comparable properties with those synthesized by other strategies. 115In addition to facilitating the synthesis of inorganic materials, kinetics for the synthesis of organic materials such as covalent organic frameworks (COFs) can also be accelerated. 116Qiu et al. prepared 2D and 3D-COFs in the ChCl/glycerol system. 117The 2D-COF TpPA (1,3,5-triformylphloroglucinol (Tp); p-phenylenediamine (PA)) could be generated in a gram-scale at room temperature aer 2 h in DES.In contrast, the synthesis of TpPA requires a temperature of 120 °C for 3 days by a solvothermal reaction.

Morphology control.
The complicated interactions render various phase or aggregation behavior in DES systems, 33 and the domains generated in DESs could be employed as so templates for modulating the micro/nano-structure of materials.In 2004, Cooper et al. pioneered an innovative approach for fabricating porous solids, utilizing DESs as solvent and structure-directing agents. 119Recently, Zhang et al. reported a DES-mediated strategy to synthesize an octahedral NiCo-NH 3 complex, which could be directly transformed into NiCo 2 O 4 nanooctahedrons aer thermal decomposition (Fig. 6a). 120The NiCo-NH 3 precursor in octahedral shape is achieved with the DES-mediated crystallization in ChCl/glycerol. 120The utilization of DES, ChCl/glycerol, not only customizes the morphology of the prepared precursor via a template effect but also effectively restrains its hydrolysis, guaranteeing the successful synthesis of the octahedral NiCo-NH 3 complex with a high yield (Fig. 6b).In addition to acting as single template agents, DESs can also play multifunctional roles.For instance, a ternary-component DES, ChCl/CoCl 2 $6H 2 O/glycerol, is employed as the reaction medium, reducing agent, template, and metal source in the room-temperature synthesis of the CoMnO compound (Fig. 6c). 121The hydrogen-bonding interaction between the DES and manganese precursor facilitates the expeditious formation of CoMnO nanostructures.Moreover, this synthesis process and hydrogen-bonding interaction could be regulated by the introduction of water, and water molecules can weaken the bonding between the formed nanostructures and ultimately affect the morphology of CoMnO (Fig. 6d).
3][124] DESs could be used as solvents for the controlled electrodeposition to synthesize electrocatalysts of small particle size.Ni nanoparticles synthesized by electrodeposition in ChCl/EG exhibit a smaller particle size and more uniform morphology compared with those synthesized in an acetate buffer solution owing to the coordination between Ni 2+ and ChCl/EG (Fig. 6e), 125 leading to the higher catalytic performance for electrooxidation of methanol.The composition of DESs could also inuence the morphology of as-synthesized materials.ChCl/urea and ChCl/EG DESs yield distinct Ni lms, attributable to their disparate growth processes and assembly behaviors. 126Notably, ChCl/EG exhibits lower viscosity and higher conductivity in comparison to ChCl/urea.The diffusion coefficient of Ni 2+ species within ChCl/urea manifests a considerably slower rate than that observed in ChCl/EG, and Ni 2+ exhibits different coordination behavior in the two DESs.Thereby, the Ni electrodeposit obtained in ChCl/EG exhibits a smaller particle size than that produced in ChCl/urea (Fig. 6f-o). 126.2.4Structure control.The structure of electrocatalysts normally determines their performance in electrocatalysis.For example, amorphous electrocatalysts have reduced coordination number distribution, abundant surface dangling bonds, and broadened energy bands, contributing to optimizing catalytically active sites and reducing overpotential during electrocatalysis. 127][130] DESs have a large supramolecular hydrogen-bond network structure formed by HBDs and HBAs, which inhibits the crystallization of materials to generate an amorphous structure. 131ang et al. prepared amorphous CaCO 3 in an alkanolaminebased DES-H 2 O system. 131The experimental results show that the strength of the hydrogen bond is the main factor affecting the solvent properties in the DES-H 2 O system.Moreover, the DES-H amorphous Pt-rich skin (Pt-Pd@NPA). 134The Pt-Pd@NPA shows exceptional catalytic performance towards the HER across a wide range of pH, attributable to the highly integrated 3D nanoporous architecture and designable electronic structure by the deliberate incorporation of Pt into the interfaces of Ag-Pd hybrids.
DESs may partially decompose when the temperature exceeds the pyrolysis temperature of a single component, and the as-generated new species in DESs boost the formation of the porous structure. 33The synthesis of a novel zeotype framework [SIZ-2, Al 2 (PO 4 ) 3 -3NH 4 ] using the ChCl/urea DES as a template and solvent was reported by Cooper et al. (Fig. 7a). 119The partial decomposition of urea produces ammonia to template the porous structure and balance the charge on the framework, facilitating the formation of the interrupted structure of SIZ-2.Parnham et al. synthesized various zeolites in different urea derivative-containing DESs (Fig. 7b). 135As anticipated, the thermal degradation of diverse urea derivatives within DESs at elevated temperatures results in the formation of different organic species, which not only act as templates but also facilitate the delivery of reactants.During the synthesis of metalorganic frameworks (MOFs), DES components or decomposition products formed under ionothermal conditions may be involved in the MOF architecture, either being coordinated as a ligand to the metal centres or located in the pores of the MOF host. 116Zhang et al. synthesized a series of MOFs with the 1,4benzenedicarboxylate (bdc) ligand in different ChCl/urea derivative (urea/N,N 0 -dimethylurea(m-urea)/2imidazolidinone(e-urea)) mixtures, and DESs play vital roles in controlling the structure of these crystalline materials (Fig. 7c). 136For the MOF (Ch)[InCl(bdc) 3/2 (H 2 O) 2 ] synthesized in ChCl/urea, the chloride anion is coordinated to the In(III) cation, and the cholinium cation resides within the pores of the 2D network.In (Ch)[Yb(bdc) 2 (urea)], the cholinium cation is situated within the pores of the 3D architecture, with urea coordinated to the central metal.[Nd(bdc) 2 (Ch)](m-urea) is prepared in ChCl/m-urea, and the cholinium cation coordinates with the metal centre, while m-urea remains unbound within the pores of the 3D structure.As for [Sm(bdc) 3/2 (e-urea)] synthesized in ChCl/e-urea, the e-urea serves as a bridge that connects with Sm(III) cations, and it can be eliminated by heating the MOF to 300 °C without any structural change.The composition of DESs can mediate the synthesis of MOF materials and ultimately affect the structure, and the rational design of solvents can effectively determine the structure-performance relationship and ultimately affect the properties of the materials.
3.2.5 Defect engineering.8][139] The molecular polarity, hydrogen-bonding interaction, and high elemental extraction ability make DESs suitable solvents for building surface defects of materials.Lu et al. leached Bi atoms from the BiVO 4 lattice to fabricate surface defects by directly immersing BiVO 4 into ChCl/EG and heating it at different temperatures (Fig. 8a-e). 140Thanks to the good metal solubility of DESs, when BiVO 4 is immersed in ChCl/ EG, it leads to partial metal dissolution in DESs and thus builds cationic defects.Theoretical calculations indicate that the Bi-O bond is destroyed by the DES to harvest monoclinic BiVO 4 .The charge transport capacity and carrier separation efficiency of Bi 1−x VO 4 are effectively improved by this approach.
3.2.6Element doping.Element doping could be easily realized in DES systems as DESs could not only dissolve various precursors but also serve as precursors directly to prepare   a straightforward strategy to introduce Cl into the CuO lattice using ChCl/urea as the solvent. 145The incorporation of Cl into CuO is achieved at ambient temperature through the modulation of molar ratios between ChCl and urea (0.5 : 1, 1 : 1, 1.5 : 1, and 2 : 1).ChCl serves as the source for Cl − anions, and the doping could be modulated by changing the molar ratio of ChCl and urea. 145.2.7 Regulating redox potential of metals.DESs are able to regulate the redox potential of metals, leading to different metal activity sequences compared to those observed in aqueous solutions. 146Nickel (E 0 = −0.257V vs. SHE) cannot normally be deposited onto copper (E 0 = 0.34 V vs. SHE) without chemical reducing agents in an aqueous solution. 147However, experimental ndings indicate that the redox potential of Ni 2+ /Ni in ChCl/EG stands at −0.154 V while that of Cu + /Cu is −0.350V at 353 K since DESs provide diverse chemical environments compared with molecular solutions. 146Consequently, the galvanic replacement reaction between Cu and Ni 2+ within ChCl/EG becomes thermodynamically favorable, enabling the fabrication of Ni thin lms on the copper substrate.
3.2.8Intercalation and exfoliation.9][150] However, due to interlayer van der Waals interactions, the spontaneous stacking of 2D materials is inevitable, resulting in the reduced exposure of active sites. 151wing to the distinctive hydrogen bond network and substantial ionic radius, DESs could be considered as effective intercalating and exfoliating agents, penetrating into the layers of materials to achieve exfoliation and obtain single-layer or few-layer 2D materials. 35,152,153Mohammadpour et al. demonstrated the remarkable efficiencies of sugar-based natural DESs for the liquid-phase exfoliation of bulk MoS 2 (Fig. 9a-g). 154hrough the size effect of sucrose molecules and the extended hydrogen bond interactions in the DES system, bulk MoS 2 was exfoliated into 2D nanosheets with a yield of 44%. 151MoS 2 nanosheets exhibit a mixed phase (2H-1T) with a 2H/1T ratio of 1.4.The exfoliated MoS 2 shows an overpotential of 0.339 V vs. RHE at a current density of 10 mA cm −2 with long-term durability in acidic environments for the HER.Abdelkader et al. realized the exfoliation of 2D materials including graphene, BN, MoS 2 , and WS 2 by the co-intercalation of Li + and Et 4 N + assisted by the ChCl/urea DES (Fig. 9h-k). 35

DESs as electrolytes
][157] The electrolyte plays a pivotal role in inuencing the interfacial electron transfer process, thereby impacting the electrochemical kinetics. 158Zhen et al. investigated the electron- transfer kinetics in ChCl/EG s. 159 The electron transfer rate constants observed in ChCl/EG are 100 times higher than those observed in the IL system.DESs show high dissolving ability for the reactants.For example, the reported solubility of CO 2 in the prevalent ChCl-based DESs typically ranges from 0.28 to 0.60 mol CO 2 L −1 at 298 K and 1 atm.In contrast, the CO 2 solubility is 0.03 mol CO 2 L −1 in aqueous solutions and 0.16-0.27mol CO 2 L −1 in organic solvents under the same conditions. 157The excellent capture ability for CO 2 increases the CO 2 availability at the electrode surface, thereby beneting CO 2 RR performance.However, despite the unique advantages of DESs in terms of electron transfer as well as improving the concentration of CO 2 near the electrode, the current density obtained in the CO 2 RR using pure DESs as electrolytes is currently quite low.For example, in ChCl/EG, utilizing Au as the working electrode at −1.7 V vs. Ag/Ag + , the current density of the CO 2 RR is about 0.6 mA. 107Other DESs have similar problems, such as ChCl/urea, BmimCl/EG, ChCl/PEG, and BmimCl/PEG. 80Although close to 100% faradaic efficiency (FE) can be achieved for CO in DESs, the low current density due to the high viscosity restricts the application of DESs in electrocatalysis. 80Fortunately, current literature presents several potential strategies to address this challenge: (i) optimizing the electrochemical cell; 80 (ii) modulating the electrode conguration and surface characteristics; 160 (iii) developing DES-based electrolytes in non-viscous molecular solvents. 80,161As an example, the FE CO increases from 15.8% to 59% just by increasing the amount of water in the viscous ChClurea DES. 80This increase in the catalytic activity is a consequence of the great reduction in the medium viscosity to facilitate mass transport.The introduction of water can disrupt the robust hydrogen-bond network inherent in the pristine DES, thereby enhancing the transfer of dissolved CO 2 , reaction intermediates and ions at the cathode surface.However, within a predominantly aqueous environment, the heightened availability of protons may concurrently elevate the FE for H 2 production, attributable to the HER.To enhance the CO 2 RR while concurrently mitigating the competitive HER by diminishing proton availability at the cathode surface, non-aqueous solutions of DESs have been proposed, yielding exceptional outcomes.For instance, substituting ChCl-EG aqueous solutions with the dissolution of these DESs in acetonitrile has enabled an increase in current density during CO 2 electrolysis from 0.4 mA cm −2 in pure ChCl-EG to 7.0 mA cm −2 , alongside elevating the FE towards CO from 78% to 98.8%. 80This improvement stems from enhanced mass transport within these organic media and augmented CO 2 availability at the electrode surface.Notably, the solubility of CO 2 in organic solvents such as acetonitrile can reach levels up to eight times higher than in aqueous solutions, further contributing to the performance enhancements. 157n terms of tailoring the EDL structure, ChCl can play a crucial role in manipulating and stabilizing key intermediates. 162Zhu et al. investigated the effect of ChCl in the HER, formic acid electrooxidation, and CO 2 RR, respectively. 162For the HER in the ChCl-containing system, the cyclic voltammetry (CV) curve over the Pt electrode indicates the absence of characteristic hydrogen adsorption and desorption (Fig. 10a). 162The peak at 0.33 V vs. RHE is assigned to the interaction between choline ions and the catalyst surface. 162Moreover, a hydrogen reduction peak at −0.4 V vs. RHE suggests the inhibition of hydrogen production in the ChCl-containing system.Even with an acid environment, the HER is also suppressed in the ChClcontaining system (Fig. 10b).Without choline ion inhibitors, the surface is negatively charged when the potential exceeds the zero-charge potential, which facilitates proton adsorption on the electrode surface.In contrast, in the presence of choline cations, a thin layer of choline ions arrays on the catalyst surface (Fig. 10e).The choline cation layer results in a positive charge on the surface, reducing the proton concentration on or near the surface.The adsorption layer hinders the proton adsorption, lowering the reaction rate until the potential becomes negative enough for protons to eventually reach the catalyst surface.During the electro-oxidation of formic acid in the ChClcontaining system, a small quantity of ChCl can promote the oxidation of formic acid but cannot poison the catalyst (Fig. 10c).Formate can be stabilized through complexation with the positive charges in ChCl or hydrogen bonding with hydroxy protons in ChCl (Fig. 10f). 162In addition, compared with normal electrolytes, the ChCl-containing solution obtains a lower overpotential for the CO 2 RR (Fig. 10d).These results indicate that ChCl can act as a co-catalyst. 162 DESs can effectively recongure the hydrogen bonding network at the electrode interface to regulate the coordination environment of interfacial ions, inhibit side reactions, and promote ionic conduction.Wang et al. designed an acetamidecaprolactam DES-based electrolyte for stable Zn-metal batteries. 40This electrolyte reconstructs the hydrogen bond network in the electrolyte through acetamide (HBD) and caprolactam (HBA), effectively broadening the ESW and suppressing the reactivity of water that reduces the HER.Moreover, the coordination between Zn 2+ and acetamide-caprolactam in DES-based electrolytes produces a unique solvation structure.Substantial enhancements in electrochemical stability and coulombic efficiency are realized by using DESs.The supramolecular hydrogen bonding network within DESs can facilitate proton conductivity in the solvent. 163Guo et al. designed a novel electrolyte, in which polyoxometalate nanoclusters are used as supramolecular cross-linkers to solidify levulinic acid/hydroxypropyl-b-cyclodextrin DES. 163A high proton conductivity (more than 1 × 10 −4 S cm −1 ) at room temperature is achieved due to the abundant protons from polyoxometalate and the supramolecular hydrogen bonding network in the DES.
Despite the potential of DESs as electrolytes, to our knowledge, the current research based on utilizing DESs as electrolytes for electrocatalytic systems is still quite limited, and more studies are about the synthesis and preparation of electrocatalysts.This may be due to the high viscosity of DESs themselves leading to low current density during electrolysis.In addition, when some other small molecules are added to DESs to reduce the viscosity, the composition has already changed, and it is still questionable whether the mixtures under this composition are still DESs.When choosing the composition of DESs, it may be difficult for macromolecules or molecules with functional groups to form DESs.For alcohols, phenols, and carboxylic acid molecules as the composition of DESs, the potentials may lead to redox reactions of the components under different electrocatalytic reaction systems.Therefore, the current studies are very limited.

Applications of DESs in electrocatalysis
5][166][167][168] The catalytic performance relies highly upon the electrocatalytic system, including the electrocatalyst and electrolyte, which determine the interface microenvironment and double-layer properties.Therefore, the construction of highperformance electrocatalytic systems by the synthesis of efficient catalysts and designing synergistic electrolytes is highly desirable.Thanks to the multiple functions of DESs (solvents, templates, structure-directing agents, precursors, and supramolecular networks), they are emerging as versatile media for building highly efficient catalytic systems.In this section, we summarized the recent developments in utilizing DESs for various electrocatalytic reactions.

HER
The HER represents the reductive half-reaction of water electrolysis, wherein protons obtain electrons to produce hydrogen. 169Although Pt is considered as the benchmark electrode for the HER, the high cost limits its widespread applications. 170Therefore, it is imperative to explore low-cost and highperformance electrocatalysts.
Nickel is a promising alternative to Pt for the HER, however, its robust hydrogen adsorption capacity results in a relatively slow desorption kinetics of H 2 . 30The introduction of S or P onto nickel can nely tune its electronic structure, optimizing both intrinsic activity and the adsorption free energy of H 2 .Zhang et al. prepared S-doped nickel microsphere lms through an electrodeposition method directly onto copper wire in ChCl/ EG. 171 The incorporation of S induces a substantial amount of oxygen vacancies on the surface.The as-prepared materials with different Ni/S ratios exhibit different morphologies (Fig. 11a), and the NiS 0.25 nanosphere exhibits the largest surface area.The synergistic effect between microsphere morphology and oxygen vacancies renders the highest electrocatalytic activity for the HER over NiS 0.25 nanospheres (Fig. 11b-e).NiS 0.25 shows a minimal overpotential of 54 mV to achieve a current density of 10 mA cm −2 and can be used for more than 60 hours in 1 M KOH.
The replacement reaction between Cu and Ni 2+ can hardly occur in the aqueous electrolyte but can be realized in DESs as the redox potential of metals could be changed in DESs. 146Yang et al. fabricated Ni 3 S 2 @Cu via the galvanic replacement reaction, incorporating thiourea and Cu foil into the ChCl/EG-NiCl 2 system. 79During the replacement reaction between Cu and Ni 2+ , S is incorporated into Ni lms, resulting in the formation of Sdoped Ni microsphere lms on nanoporous Cu substrates.The Ni 3 S 2 @Cu exhibits signicant electrocatalytic activity for the HER, conrmed by small Tafel slopes of 63.5 and 67.5 mV dec −1 in acidic and alkaline environments, respectively.Moreover, at a current density of 10 mA cm −2 , the overpotentials in 0.5 M H 2 SO 4 and 1.0 M KOH are 91.6 mV and 60.8 mV, respectively.Ni 3 S 2 @Cu exhibits higher catalytic activity than Ni nanocrystallites@Cu.Furthermore, multi-metallic catalysts applied to the HER have received increasing attention.By adding different metal salts to DESs, multi-metallic HER electrocatalysts can be prepared, such as Ni-Mo, 172,173 Ni-Cu, 174 Ni-Co-Sn, 175 and Ni-Fe. 176These catalysts prepared using DESs presented lower Tafel slopes as well as low overpotentials.

OER
OER is the oxidation half-reaction of water spitting and usually exhibits slow kinetics due to the four-electron transfer process involved. 177Because the OER is the rate-limiting step in water splitting, the development of cost-effective and high-performance OER catalysts is necessary to improve the overall efficiency. 178xide perovskites, owing to their stability and tunable structure, have drawn signicant attention as electrocatalysts for energy conversion. 179,180Hong et al. reported the synthesis of La-based perovskites using an environmentally friendly DES consisting of ChCl and malonic acid. 181The synthesis route involves the dissolution of the metal precursor in the DES followed by high temperature calcination, during which the high temperature leads to partial decomposition of the DES, resulting in the production of NH 3 and HCl to boost the production of perovskite crystals.The DES-involved method realized the convenient, fast, and scalable synthesis of phase-pure crystalline materials compared to traditional solid-state methods.Among the as-synthesized perovskites (LaCoO 3 , LaMn 0.5 Ni 0.5 O 3 , and LaMnO 3 ), LaCoO 3 emerges as the best electrocatalyst for the OER in an alkaline medium (Fig. 12a-c).Current densities of 10, 50, and 100 mA cm −2 at overpotentials of approximately 390, 430, and 470 mV, respectively, are achieved over LaCoO 3 , and a Tafel slope of 55.8 mV dec −1 is obtained.The superior activity of LaCoO 3 is ascribed to its high oxygen vacancy concentration (Fig. 12d), which is associated with the reducing atmosphere generated by the thermal decomposition of DES components.
2D materials have been widely used in the OER due to their large specic surface area and abundance of active sites. 182,183e et al. employed a "water injection" method to synthesize CoFe layered double hydroxide (CoFe-LDH) with an expansive layer spacing in ChCl/urea (Fig. 12e). 184Through the swi injection of water, urea and ChCl undergo decomposition, facilitating the formation of CoFe-LDH.In this procedure, derivative species originating from DESs serve as intercalators to generate large interlayer distances (Fig. 12f), resulting in good OER performance.The structure and composition of DESs exert inuence on the nucleation and growth of multi-metal oxalate. 185The high molecular weight PEG and the gradual release of OA promote the formation of a 2D structure, whereas low molecular weight EG and ample OA favour the generation of 3D nanoparticles (Fig. 12g). 185The well-designed 2D (FeCoNiCuZn)(C 2 O 4 )$2H 2 O nanosheets exhibit an ultralow overpotential of 334 mV at 100 mA cm −2 for the OER with a prolonged durability of over 30 h.Hu et al. developed a onestep ionothermal-accompanied thermolysis method using DESs as precursors for the synthesis of ultrathin NiFe layered double-hydroxide hybridized nanosheets with N-doped carbon quantum dots (NCD@NiFe-LDH). 186The NCD@NiFe-LDH hybrid exhibits a hierarchical ower-like morphology, composed of 2D ultrathin nanosheets (∼1.4 nm thickness) with elevated surface area and excellent conductivity.This electrocatalyst for the OER demonstrates outstanding performance, requiring only 363 mV to obtain a high current density of 500 mA cm −2 .

ORR
8][189] To date, substantial endeavours have been dedicated to exploring costeffective and superior electrocatalysts as alternatives to Ptbased catalysts.DESs can facilitate doping or act as a source of heteroatoms to prepare non-Pt-based high-performance catalysts.For instance, Luo et al. reported the facile preparation of nitrogen-doped graphitic carbon (NGC) via the pyrolysis of DESs. 190The NGCs have high surface areas, rich nitrogen content, and favourable graphitization degree and show excel-

CO 2 RR
CO 2 RR to high-value chemicals is a promising strategy for simultaneously realizing CO 2 utilization and renewable energy conversion. 192Bohlen et al. prepared In coated Cu by electrodeposition in ChCl/EG. 193The as-prepared catalyst shows a FE formate of ∼72.5%.Moreover, gas diffusion electrodes coated with In exhibit a formate concentration of ∼76 mM and a formation rate of 0.183 mmol cm −2 h −1 .0 The CO 2 RR process on the Ag electrode surface assisted with DESs is schematically illustrated in Fig. 13b, and the presence of DESs could affect the local microenvironment during the CO 2 RR.Specically, methyldiethanolamine (MDEA)-based DESs in water not only produce protic species but also form HCO 3 − by reacting CO 2 with isolated OH − ions or the -OH group in HBDs. 160Moreover, the -NH 2 group in DESs is in the vicinity of the electrode surface, which affects the energy barriers for the generation and stabilization of the *COOH intermediate. 160Also, the equilibrium between dissolved CO

NRR
NH 3 plays an imperative role in modern society by serving as a precursor to fertilizers and many other nitrogen-containing chemicals. 195Electrochemical synthesis of ammonia allows the thermodynamically non-spontaneous synthesis reaction of ammonia to proceed under mild conditions, overcoming or mitigating thermodynamic equilibrium restriction. 196,197N 2 xation is a kinetically sluggish and complex multistep reaction due to the high activation barrier for the cleavage of nitrogennitrogen triple bonds. 198,199In order to overcome the activation energy barrier of Recently, Ying et al. synthesized Mn-doped Bi 2 O 3 nanosheets in ChCl/OA. 143The ChCl/OA DES has excellent dissolving capacity for metal salts because OA can coordinate with metal ions. 115,142Mn-doped Bi 2 O 3 nanosheets are prepared by microwave heating in ChCl/OA followed by calcination.Owing to the strong interaction between Bi 6p orbitals and N 2p orbitals, the competitive HER is evidently suppressed. 203,204Moreover, the coexistence of occupied and unoccupied 3d orbitals in the Mn element is conducive to adsorbing and activating N 2 molecules. 205,206The as-prepared 5% Mn-Bi 2 O 3 nanosheets achieve a high NH 3 yield rate of 23.54 mg h −1 mg cat.

Other reactions
4.6.1 5-Hydroxymethylfurfural oxidation.Oxidation of 5hydroxymethylfurfural (HMF) into 2,5-furandicarboxylic acid (FDCA) is a typical reaction for the transformation of biomass into valuable chemicals. 207,208Zhang et al. proposed a facile and controllable strategy for the preparation of carbon-based heterostructures by direct pyrolysis of (NiCl 2 $6H 2 O/CoCl 2 $6H 2 O)/ PEG200/thiourea DES. 209The designed DES is considered as the metal source, N-source, S-source, and C-source.The simultaneous growth as well as the integration of metal sulde and the carbon material occur in a single step, facilitating the uniformity of the composite.Moreover, numerous N, O, and S vacancies inevitably emerge during the calcination process.Notably, the S vacancies serve as anchoring sites for the formation of transition metal sulde heterostructures.The asprepared Co 9 S 8 -Ni 3 S 2 @N,S,O-tri-doped carbon heterostructures exhibit an excellent HMF electrooxidation performance, and FE FDCA could reach 98.6% at a full conversion of HMF.
4.6.2Formic acid oxidation.1][212] Plaza-Mayoral et al. fabricated a Pd-Au bimetallic electrocatalyst by co-electro-deposition in ChCl/urea DES. 213Owing to the capacity of DESs for dissolving precursors and dispersing particles, the electrochemically active surface area (ECSA) of the Pd-Au electrocatalyst is 5 and 12-fold higher than those of Pd(poly) and PdAu(poly), respectively.Based on the high ECSA, Pd-Au alloys exhibit good activity and stability for formic acid oxidation.Yang et al. designed Pd 2 Ni 1 nanocluster-supported multi-walled carbon nanotube (MWCNT) electrocatalysts in ChCl/OA. 214ChCl/OA serves as not only a solvent but also a reducing agent for synthesizing Pd 2 Ni 1 / CNTs, which exhibit four times higher activity for formic acid oxidation than the Pd/C catalyst.The high catalytic performance of Pd 2 Ni 1 /CNTs is ascribed to the special nanocluster structure and appropriate Ni doping, which changes the electron conguration of Pd to reduce the d-band and produce a Pd-Ni bond as a new active site. 214.6.3Alcohol oxidation.Direct alcohol fuel cells have been extensively investigated for portable devices, primarily due to their high energy density and low toxicity. 215However, signicant challenges, such as sluggish electrode reaction kinetics, limited long-term stability, and high cost hinder their commercial applications. 216Therefore, advanced alcohol oxidation catalysts need to be designed.DESs are effective in controlling the dispersion of nanoparticles and enhancing the electron transfer between the nanoparticles and the support material. 217Zhong et al. prepared hybrid PtCu nanoclusters on MWCNTs in ChCl/EG without adding any surface-controlling agent. 217The addition of alloyed Cu and ChCl/EG not only promotes the formation of nanoscale-structure with coarse surface but also decreases the particle size of metals.Moreover, the mass activity of PtCu/MWCNT is 2.5 times higher than that of Pt/MWCNT.Synthesis of electrocatalysts with high-index facets can be easily realized in DESs. 218Wei et al. synthesized Pt-Ru alloy concave nanocubes featuring a high-index (510) facet by the electrochemical square-wave potential technique in ChCl/urea DES. 219In comparison to both monometallic Pt concave nanocubes and quasi-spherical Pt-Ru alloys, the concave cubic Pt-Ru alloy with a high index facet shows outstanding electro-oxidation capability towards ethanol which is attributed to the abundant low-coordinated Pt sites (HIFs structure) and the distinctive electronic structure.

Summary and outlook
This review offers a thorough overview of the diverse applications of DESs in electrocatalysis.It encompasses an examination of DES features, highlighting their unique advantages as solvents for electrocatalyst synthesis and as electrolytes.Additionally, a systematic analysis is presented, detailing the typical applications of DESs in electrocatalysis.Finally, we endeavour to address challenges and provide insights into the future prospects of DESs in electrocatalysis, as illustrated in Fig. 14.

Be "Greener"
DESs have been regarded as green solvents to some extent and have found applications in various elds.However, some evidence suggests that DESs are not always environmentally friendly as initially thought. 220First, under harsh conditions, the hydrogen bonds between HBAs and HBDs in DESs can be disrupted.Additionally, chemical and electrochemical factors contribute to the instability of DESs.During the decomposition of DESs, evaporation may occur, resulting in the generation of toxic gases, environmental pollution, and the loss of atom economy.2][223][224] Given these challenges, it becomes necessary to explore strategies to enhance the green characteristics of DESs.Adjusting components, optimizing ratios, and incorporating stabilizing agents into DESs could help improve stability, reducing issues related to decomposition and evaporation, and ultimately lowering the environmental pollution risk.

Regulating viscosity
The high viscosity of DESs results in the restriction of mass transfer and reducing the reactivity of electrocatalytic systems signicantly.The addition of water to DESs is the most commonly used method to reduce the overall viscosity.Here, we propose several plausible methods to reduce the viscosity of DES systems.(i) Precisely designing DES components from the molecular level.6][227] (iii) Adjusting the temperature of DESs during catalysis.

Exploring novel DESs
Current research in electrocatalyst preparation and electrolyte design mainly concentrates on previously developed DESs.As applications of DESs become increasingly extensive, the exploration of new DESs is very desirable.New combinations of intricate three-component or even four-component DES systems that involve various HBDs and HBAs should be prepared and systematically studied.The design of such multi-component DESs opens up more possibilities for synthesizing multifunctional electrocatalysts and employing them as electrolytes for various reactions.Solvent properties and reaction reactivity could be tuned by adjusting parameters such as chain length and functional groups of DES components.Furthermore, the study of the phase diagram is critical for the design and development of new DESs.However, current descriptions of DES phase diagrams are somewhat limited, with some studies lacking comprehensive information such as three-phase lines or focusing solely on eutectic points.It is anticipated that future research will provide more detailed insights into DES phase diagrams.

Designing DES-based composite solvents
DESs possess unique advantages but also exhibit certain drawbacks, such as higher viscosity than water and organic solvents and lower ion conductivity compared with ionic liquids.Since both solutions and solid materials belong to the condensed matter and share some similarities, especially from a functional design perspective, inspiration can be drawn from composite materials.In future research, DESs can be compounded with various solvents to create composite solvents, thereby leveraging the strengths of each component and mitigating their respective weaknesses.The multitude of possible combinations for composite solvents necessitates theoretical simulations to guide and reduce trial-and-error costs.Through the use of theoretical calculations and simulation methods, a deep understanding of the interactions between DESs and other solvents could be achieved.

Multifunctional electrocatalyst synthesis
DESs enable reactions under harsh conditions to proceed under mild conditions during material synthesis.Therefore, in the future, the exploration of DESs for synthesizing novel materials such as hydrogen-bonded organic frameworks (HOFs), single/ dual-atom catalysts, high index facets, etc. as gentle reaction media is desirable.Considering that DESs could provide a stable reaction environment at low temperatures and pressures, along with their extensive supramolecular networks, they are poised to act as directing and templating agents for the synthesis of complicated materials.Besides, DESs are able to produce nitrogen atoms at certain temperatures for doping purposes, and they exhibit excellent dispersibility for metal ions.Consequently, DESs are potential solvents and precursors for preparing highly active and dispersive single/dual-atom catalysts.

Further understanding of composition, structure, and performance relationship
Until now, the understanding of the roles of DESs in regulating material synthesis and electrocatalysis remains limited.There is still some randomness in controlling the morphology and structure of catalysts.Further research into the involvement of DESs in the nucleation and growth of catalysts is necessary, accompanied by a thorough analysis of compositional change during the reaction.Recognizing and unveiling the structure-composition-performance relationship is crucial to achieve a rational and controllable design of DES-based catalysts.Future research would focus on tracking the surface reconstruction and microenvironment evolution during catalyst synthesis, which is benecial for identifying real active species and mechanisms for specic reactions.The physicochemical properties such as viscosity, polarity, surface tension, hydrogen bonding, and aggregation or phase behaviour of DESs should be focused.These essential parameters are essential for inuencing the reactivity and mass transport to determine the structure-performance relationship.
In summary, suitable DESs could provide distinct advantages over both aqueous solutions and IL-based solutions within electrocatalytic reaction frameworks.Their unique hydrogen bonding networks, phase behaviour, and broad ESW endow DESs with unparalleled functionality in material synthesis and electrolytes.This encompasses a wide range of capabilities, including morphology control, defect engineering, elemental doping, intercalation and exfoliation, modulation of metal redox potentials, and acceleration of synthesis kinetics.Moreover, as electrolytes, DESs effectively manage the EDL interface and ionic solvent environments, while also suppressing side reactions and stabilizing key intermediates.Despite their widespread application in various electrocatalytic reactions such as the HER, OER, ORR, NRR, CO 2 RR, etc., the exploration of DESs remains relatively limited and necessitates further expansion.Future endeavours should prioritize the design of more robust DESs, optimization of viscosity for enhanced mass transfer, innovation of novel DES compositions, fabrication of composite solvents, engineering of nanomaterials utilizing DESs, and elucidation of the structure-performance relationship of DESs.These avenues represent critical directions for advancing the understanding and application of DESs in electrocatalysis.

Hengan
Wang received his BS degree in materials science and engineering from Zhengzhou University in 2023.He has been pursuing his PhD degree under the supervision of Prof. Xinchen Kang at the Institute of Chemistry, Chinese Academy of Sciences (CAS) since 2023.He focuses on electrocatalytic CO2 conversion.Xinchen Kang Xinchen Kang received his BS degree from Shandong University in 2011 and PhD degree from ICCAS in 2016.He worked as a Royal Society research fellow at the University of Manchester from 2017 to 2020.He has been working as a professor in the group of Prof. Buxing Han at ICCAS since June, 2021.His research elds include solution chemistry, materials chemistry and electrocatalysis.

Buxing
Han received his PhD degree in Physical Chemistry from ICCAS in 1988, and did postdoctoral research in Chemical Engineering at the University of Saskatchewan, Canada from 1989 to 1991.He is now a professor at ICCAS.His research interest includes physicochemical properties of green solvent systems and applications of green solvents in green chemistry, especially transformation of CO2, biomass, and waste plastics.

Fig. 1
Fig. 1 (a) Prototypical binary phase diagram for DESs and some representative examples of HBDs and HBAs.(b) The development of DESs in electrocatalysis.(c) Applications of DESs in electrocatalysis.

Fig. 2
Fig. 2 The classification of DESs in two different ways.

Fig. 5
Fig. 5 (a) Preparation of high-entropy materials in DES.(b) EDS elemental maps of the NiFeCoMnAl high-entropy material.Reprinted with permission from ref. 102 Copyright 2024, Elsevier.(c) Electrodeposition of Ni matrix composite coatings on the Cu substrate in ChCl/EG and aqueous electrolytes, respectively.Reprinted with permission from ref. 111 Copyright 2019, Elsevier.

Fig. 6
Fig. 6 (a) Synthesis process of the NiCo-NH 3 complex and NiCo 2 O 4 in ChCl/glycerol.(b) The effect of DES and calcination temperature on the composition and morphology of NiCo 2 O 4 .Reprinted with permission from ref. 120 Copyright 2022, Elsevier.(c) The formation of the ternarycomponent DES.(d) Synthesis of CoMnO in ChCl/CoCl 2 /glycerol ternary DES.Reprinted with permission from ref. 121 Copyright 2023, American Chemical Society.(e) Electrodeposition of Ni nanoparticles in different solvents.Reprinted with permission from ref. 125 Copyright 2021, Elsevier.(f-i) SEM images of the Ni films synthesized in ChCl/urea at −0.6 V (f), −0.7 V (g), −0.8 V (h), and −0.9 V (i) at 328 K for 1 h.The insets are amplified SEM images.(j-o) SEM images of the Ni films synthesized in ChCl/EG at −0.5 V (j, and k), −0.6 V (l, and m) and −0.7 V (n, and o) at 343 K for 1 h.Reprinted with permission from ref. 126 Copyright 2018, Elsevier.
2 O system with inter-and intramolecular hydrogen bonds inhibited the crystallization of CaCO 3 , resulting in the formation of amorphous nanostructures.Zhao et al. synthesized Ni 2 P supported on Ni 3 (PO 4 ) 2 -Ni 2 P 2 O 7 (Ni 2 P/NiPO) by the reaction of Ni 2+ and H 2 PO 2 − in ChCl/urea.The Ni 2 P/NiPO material exhibits a surface area of approximately 210 m 2 g −1 with a mesoporous and amorphous structure. 132Yang et al. prepared self-supported 3D quasi-amorphous Co-O and Co-Se hybrid lms on the Cu substrate (Co-O@Co-Se/Cu) via a facile one-step electrochemical deposition strategy in ChCl/urea. 133The resulting 3D nanostructure with a high surface area and porous architecture increases the number of surface active sites and promotes the intrinsic catalytic activity for the OER.Yang et al. employed the ChCl/EG solvent in combination with an electrochemical activation strategy to fabricate monolithic 3D nanoporous Ag/Pd core/shell hybrids with an ultrathin (<1 nm) doped materials.Sun et al. reported the direct electrodeposition of NiP x lms on Cu foil in a ChCl/EG-based DES. 141Within the ChCl/EG-based DES, P is effectively incorporated into Ni superstructures, thereby enabling the NiP x hybrid lms to obtain a greater number of active sites and enhanced electronic conductivity, which accelerates electron-transfer kinetics for the HER.The ChCl/oxalic acid (ChCl/OA) DES favors doping because it has an excellent dissolving capacity for metal ions and OA can coordinate with various metal ions. 115,142Ying et al. synthesized Mn-doped Bi 2 O 3 for the NRR using ChCl/OA as the solvent.Mn-doped Bi 2 O 3 nanosheets with mesoporous structure have abundant active sites on the surface, which is favorable for mass transfer. 143In addition to promoting element doping as solvents, DESs themselves could be used as the source of heteroatoms to prepare doped electrocatalysts.Mou et al. synthesized a defect-rich, ultrathin, and tri-doped N, S, O-Co 9 S 8 in CoCl 2 $6H 2 O/thiourea, and the decomposition of thiourea in the DES during pyrolysis provides the S source and generates a substantial quantity of gases (such as NH 3 , CO 2 , etc.) that facilitate the doping of N and O. 144 Jaihindh et al. presented

Fig. 7
Fig. 7 (a) Synthesis of SIZ-2 and AlPO-CJ2 in ChCl/urea.Reprinted with permission from ref. 119 Copyright 2004, Springer Nature Limited.(b) Synthesis of aluminophosphate materials in dimethyl urea based eutectic mixtures with tetraethylammonium bromide or ChCl systems.Reprinted with permission from ref. 135 Copyright 2006, John Wiley and Sons.(c) Structure of MOFs synthesized in different DESs.Reproduced from ref. 116 with permission from the Royal Society of Chemistry.

Fig. 8
Fig. 8 (a) Schematic diagram for the Bi leaching from BiVO 4 lattices in DES.(b and c) TEM and HRTEM images of Bi 1−x VO 4 .(d) Schematic diagram of the (010) in-plane lattice of BiVO 4 oriented with respect to the lattice in the TEM image.(e) Enlarged HRTEM image of Bi 1−x VO 4 .Reprinted with permission from ref. 140 Copyright 2021, John Wiley and Sons.

Fig. 9
Fig. 9 (a-c) TEM images of the exfoliated MoS 2 nanosheets.(d) Field emission scanning electron microscopy image of the exfoliated MoS 2 .(e and f) AFM image and the corresponding thickness distribution of MoS 2 nanosheets.(g) Particle size distribution of MoS 2 nanosheets obtained by dynamic light scattering.Reprinted with permission from ref. 154 Copyright 2018, American Chemical Society.(h-k) AFM image and height profile for graphene (h), BN (i), MoS 2 (j), and WS 2 (k) after exfoliation.Reprinted with permission from ref. 35 Copyright 2016, American Chemical Society.

2 −c
Imteyaz et al. investigated the mechanism of the CO 2 RR over the Au electrode in ChCl/EG and proposed three plausible pathways (Fig. 10g): 107 (1) the CO 2 − c undergoes dimerization on the Au electrode surface, generating oxalate salts; (2) the CO interacts with choline cations adsorbed on the electrode surface and is then transformed into CO; (3) in the presence of DESs, the choline cation can stabilize CO 2 − c, preventing its dimerization.High FE CO is achieved, conrming that pathway (2) is more reasonable.

Fig. 10 (
Fig. 10 (a) CV curves over the Pt electrode in various electrolytes.(b) CV curves over the Pt electrode in various electrolytes with different pH.(c) Control potential electrolysis of formic acid electrooxidation over the Pt electrode in various electrolytes.(d) CV curves over the Pt electrode in various CO 2 -saturated electrolytes with different pH.(e and f) Schematic diagram for the influence of ChCl on the performance of the HER and electrooxidation of formic acid.Reprinted with permission from ref. 162 Copyright 2013, Elsevier.(g) Plausible CO 2 RR pathways over the Au electrode in ChCl/EG.Reprinted with permission from ref. 107 Copyright 2023, Elsevier.

Fig. 11 (
Fig. 11 (a) SEM images of NiS x with different amounts of S doping.(b) Polarization curves of pure Ni/CW and NiS x /CW with different amounts of S doping.(c) Comparison of the HER catalytic performance for the NiS x /CW with different amounts of S doping.(d) Nyquist plots of various NiS x / CW samples recorded at an overpotential of −110 mV.(e) CV curves over various NiS x /CW samples with different scan rates in a non-faradaic region and the corresponding capacitive currents as a function of scan rates.Reproduced from ref. 171 with permission from the Royal Society of Chemistry.
lent ORR performance compared with the commercial Pt/C catalyst.Pariiska et al. prepared a Co-N-C electrocatalyst by the pyrolysis of DESs containing 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium chloride ([Bmim]Cl) or tetrauoroborate ([Bmim]BF 4 ) and hydrated Co(NO 3 ) 2 or CoCl 2 . 191DESs used as precursors can provide large amounts of Co and N atoms and promote the homogeneous dispersion of these elements.The Co-N-C shows comparable ORR performance with the Pt/C catalyst in alkaline electrolytes, and exhibit onset potentials of 0.96-0.99V vs. RHE, half-wave potentials of 0.85-0.89V and Tafel slopes of 37-50 mV dec −1 .
FE CO could reach 96% at −0.884 V vs. RHE in the 50 wt% ChCl/urea aqueous solution, surpassing the benchmark KHCO 3 catholyte by over 1.5 times.The enhanced CO selectivity results from various ChCl/urea-

Fig. 12 (
Fig. 12 (a-c) Anodic polarization curves (a), Tafel (b), and Nyquist (c) plots over Ni foam-supported perovskites and reference IrO 2 .(d) Magnified HRTEM image with an overlaid structural model and intensity line scan profile.Reprinted with permission from ref. 181 Copyright 2022, American Chemical Society.(e) Schematic diagram for the synthesis of CoFe-LDH with different layer spacings.(f) The structure of interlayer intercalation of CoFe-LDH.Reproduced from ref. 184 with permission from the Royal Society of Chemistry.(g) Schematic illustration of the effect of DESs with different compositions on the final material morphology.Reprinted with permission from ref. 185 Copyright 2022, Elsevier.

N 2 ,
Zhao et al. synthesized nanostructured Fe 3 S 4 from the PEG 200/thiourea DES via a one-step solvothermal method.200DESs can be used not only as directing agents but also as S sources to realize the formation of Fe 3 S 4 nanosheets.The as-obtained Fe 3 S 4 catalyst is capable of electrochemically reducing N 2 to NH 3 under ambient conditions and exhibits a high NH 3 yield (75.4 mg h −1 mg cat.−1 ) with a FE NH3 of 6.5% at −0.4 V vs. RHE.In addition, Chen et al. prepared a hybrid catalyst containing crystalline Fe 2 O 3 and amorphous FeS using ChCl/thiourea as the solvent and S source. 201The DES exerts a structure-controlling inuence on the development of nanostructures composed of small nanoparticles.Due to the large amount of exposed electrochemical active sites along with interfacial synergy between crystalline Fe 2 O 3 and amorphous FeS, the as-prepared catalyst achieves a high NH 3 yield of 34.31 mg h −1 mg cat.−1 and a FE NH3 of 18.06% at −0.25 V vs. RHE during the NRR, outperforming most of the previously reported Fe-based catalysts.Mao et al. synthesized Pt-RE (RE = La, Y, Sc) alloy concave nanocubes (PtRENCs) with high-index facets (HIFs) by an electrochemical method in ChCl/urea. 202ChCl/urea not only exhibits excellent dissolving capacity for metal salt precursors but also promotes the generation of HIFs during electrodeposition through a unique solvent environment.The resultant Pt-La exhibits a unique electronic structure, leading to excellent NRR performance, with a NH 3 yield rate of 71.4 mg h −1 mg cat.−1 and FE NH3 of 35.6% at −0.2 V vs. RHE in 1 mM HCl.

Fig. 13 (
Fig. 13 (a) The model of the double layer at the electrode interface.Reprinted with permission from ref. 194 Copyright 2020, John Wiley and Sons.(b) Mechanism for the CO production over the Ag electrode in MDEA-based DESs.Reprinted with permission from ref. 160 Copyright 2021, Elsevier.

Table 1
The advantages of DESs in electrocatalysis