Synthesis of cyclic carbonates from CO2 cycloaddition to bio-based epoxides and glycerol: an overview of recent development

Anthropogenic carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions contribute significantly to global warming and deplete fossil carbon resources, prompting a shift to bio-based raw materials. The two main technologies for reducing CO2 emissions are capturing and either storing or utilizing it. However, while capture and storage have high reduction potential, they lack economic feasibility. Conversely, by utilizing the CO2 captured from streams and air to produce valuable products, it can become an asset and curb greenhouse gas effects. CO2 is a challenging C1-building block due to its high kinetic inertness and thermodynamic stability, requiring high temperature and pressure conditions and a reactive catalytic system. Nonetheless, cyclic carbonate production by reacting epoxides and CO2 is a promising green and sustainable chemistry reaction, with enormous potential applications as an electrolyte in lithium-ion batteries, a green solvent, and a monomer in polycarbonate production. This review focuses on the most recent developments in the synthesis of cyclic carbonates from glycerol and bio-based epoxides, as well as efficient methods for chemically transforming CO2 using flow chemistry and novel reactor designs.


Introduction
A terpene is a hydrocarbon consisting of at least two isoprene units (C 5 H 8 ) and is odourless. Five carbon atoms with double bonds make up an isoprene molecule, also referred to as an isoprene unit. Isoprene itself, a gaseous hydrocarbon, is emitted by leaves as a natural by-product of plant metabolism. Monoterpenes (C 10 H 16 ) contain two isoprene units ( Fig. 1), while sesquiterpenes have three, diterpenes have four, triterpenes have six, and tetraterpenes have eight isoprene units. 1 The name of a terpene always ends with -ene. The structure of terpenes determines whether they are cyclic or acyclic, with cyclic terpenes forming a ring and acyclic terpenes being linear. Most terpenes are monoterpenes, which can be categorized into groups based on their structure. Terpenes have low molecular weight, which enables them to evaporate quickly. Terpenes are sometimes confused with terpenoids, but the key difference is that terpenes do not contain oxygen while terpenoids do.
Monoterpenes are volatile and commonly used for avouring and perfumes due to their strong odour. They are also lipophilic, allowing them to easily penetrate cell membranes, and are known to have antispasmodic properties. [2][3][4] Cannabis contains approximately 200 terpenes, which is only a small fraction of the 20 000 terpenes known to exist in plants. 5 Among these, limonene and pinene are major terpenes. 6 Limonene, a colourless liquid, has a boiling point of 175°C and is comprised of two isomers: D-limonene and L-limonene. Dlimonene is the primary component of essential oils found in citrus fruit rinds, such as oranges, lemons, mandarins, grapefruits, and limes. On the other hand, L-limonene is emitted as a key component of volatile oils by oaks and pines. 7 Orange peels contain around 97% of limonene, 8 and with around 110 million tons of citrus fruits produced annually, this waste can be a source of essential oil extraction. Various methods, such as solvent extraction, steam distillation, and water distillation Fig. 1 Two isoprene units give monoterpene, the chemical structure of limonene and pinene. 1 extraction, have been employed to extract the oil from orange peels. Steam distillation has been found to produce the maximum yield of oil at 4.40%, followed by water distillation extraction at 3.47% and solvent extraction at 2.53%. 9 D-Limonene is widely manufactured globally, with approximately 300 orange oil distillation plants operating worldwide to produce technical-grade (95%) and food-grade (96%) D-limonene from orange oil. 7 The market for D-limonene was estimated to be worth USD 473.72 million in 2021, and it is anticipated to increase to USD 694.59 million between 2022 and 2029, increasing at a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of 4.90%. 10 Limonene is mainly used in the avour and fragrance industry, as a solvent, and for making polymers and adhesives. 11 It was rst used in 2008 to obtain fats and oils, replacing toxic solvents like n-hexane, effectively eliminating toxicity and environmental impact. D-Limonene is also an excellent cleansing agent, with a high KB (74) and density of 0.84, which allows it to hold a large amount of dirt before becoming ineffective. A compound's KB value is a measure of its ability to hold dirt. 7 Additionally, L-limonene and D-limonene are among the 44 sustainable solvents developed by GlaxoSmithKline (GSK). 12 In Kra wood pulping, turpentine oil is produced as an energy recovery oil. The increasing demand for chemical products containing articial avours, fragrances, and solvents is driving the demand for turpentine oil, which is also a promising alternative fuel for various industrial applications. 13 Turpentine oil is currently the primary source of pinene, with an average yield of 0.3-1 kg per tonne of pulp production. Worldwide, the pulping industry produces an estimated 3.5 × 10 5 Mt per year of turpentine oil, with a-pinene accounting for 70% of the total monoterpene content. 14,15 a-Pinene is the dominant form of pinene, found in pine trees and cannabis, and responsible for the characteristic pine scent. The majority of applications use a-pinene. Pine-sol, a cleaning product, contains this terpene. a-Pinene has signicant potential as an engine biofuel, as it is comparable to rocket fuel in terms of volumetric heating. 16 Glycerol is a versatile chemical that may be processed through numerous paths to creating a variety of products with value-added, such as reforming, dehydration, esterication, selective oxidation, hydrogenolysis, and acetylation. 17 However, a direct reaction of glycerol and CO 2 is an attractive route that effectively combines two waste products to produce glycerol carbonate. The production of glycerol is a by-product of the biodiesel or green diesel industry, where approximately 10 wt% of glycerol is obtained from every kg of biodiesel, and around 70% of glycerol is produced in this manner. 18 The biodiesel market was estimated to be worth USD 40.6 billion in 2021 and is anticipated to increase by 4.4% to USD 52.7 billion by 2027. 19 With the expected increase in biodiesel production, there will be a surplus of glycerol that can be utilized as a low-cost chemical feedstock to produce glycerol carbonates and glycerol acetates (also known as acetins). Acetins are non-natural, synthetic products that can be obtained either through traditional chemical conversion or new biological conversion. Chemical conversions involve toxic solvents and reactants (such as acetic acid and acetic anhydride) and require harsh temperature and pressure conditions, making them non-green and polluting. In contrast, biological processes for acetin production are considered green as they use enzymes or microbes as biocatalysts. Acetins have various applications, such as plasticizers, explosives, emulsiers, food additives, and fuel additives.
Both terpenes and glycerol offer pathways for the conversion of low-value compounds into high-value chemicals with diverse applications. Terpenes, such as limonene, can be coupled with CO 2 to produce terpene-based cyclic carbonates, while glycerol can be transformed into glycerol carbonate (GC). Glycerol carbonate (GC) is a liquid with a high water solubility, high boiling point, and low toxicity. It has potential applications as a solvent, as a surfactant, and as an electrolyte in Li-ion batteries. 20,21

CO 2 and its utilisation
In 2020, global CO 2 emissions reached 34.8 Gt, resulting in a reported temperature increase of 1.16°C relative to 1920. 22 In April 2022, global monthly mean CO 2 emissions were at a record high of 418.39 ppm, up from 415.82 ppm in April 2021. 23 It is projected that by 2050, 5.6 Gt per year of CO 2 will need to be captured and stored, equivalent to 40 Mt year of CO 2 today. 24 However, currently, only 100 Kt of cyclic carbonates are produced annually, consuming 40 Kt of direct CO 2 each year. 25,26 Approximately 35 Mt of CO 2 is released each year, with less than half being emitted by large point sources that can be captured, stored, and utilized. 27 To address this global CO 2 challenge, a multifaceted approach is necessary, which includes Carbon Capture and Storage (CCS) primarily focusing on capturing and storing, Carbon Capture and Utilization (CCU) focusing on utilization aer capturing, energy transition to non-fossil fuels such as solar, wind, and tidal, aiming to improve energy efficiency and minimizing heat loss. 25 There are now competitive technologies such as solar and wind that can replace fossil fuels. 28 However, renewable energy resources are intermittent, posing a signicant concern. 29 To reduce greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, efforts are being made to replace fossil fuel-based power plants and synthesis gas generators with biomass-based processes. Nevertheless, biobased fuel requires being used as a combined mixed fuel due to its low energy density. Thus, conventional power generation may need to be employed to meet peak demands. Moreover, most chemical and fuel production currently rely on fossil fuels as feedstocks, necessitating technologies to reduce negative emissions associated with these processes. 30

Methods of CO 2 utilisation
Two main technologies that have been deployed for CO 2 emission reduction are CCS and CCU. CCS captures and stores CO 2 in large quantities, while CCU methods valorize waste and renewable CO 2 as inputs for added-value products. 31 Both technologies involve CO 2 capture, compression, and storage or utilization using catalytic technologies. However, CCS consumes a lot of energy and provides a negative return on investment due to the associated cost of capturing and storing, whereas CCU consumes less energy and provides a net positive ROI because the product sold aer manufacturing gives a prot. 32 Climate change mitigation is the primary objective of CCS, whereas resource security is the main objective of CCU. The focus of current research is on developing CO 2 utilization methods that consume less energy.
CCS targets large source points or ambient air to capture a large amount of CO 2 , while chemical production quantities vary regionally in CCU, limiting the CO 2 demand. CCS deployment currently has few economic incentives, while incentives are already provided for CCU to a variety of actors. By minimizing the cost of CO 2 capture, CO 2 can become an appreciating asset rather than a liability. 33 However, it's important to note that CO 2 stored in CCS is intended to last more than a thousand years, while CCU stores CO 2 in the product only temporarily, which is released at the end of its life cycle back into the atmosphere. CSS is more mature and well-established, while CCU is less familiar and in the early development stages, but the latter is regarded as more positive than the former due to the associated risk of storage and transport with the former technology. 34 CSS, which captures and compresses CO 2 , costs 80% of the total cost associated with the process. Research and development efforts must aim to reduce these costs. Currently, technologies such as pre-combustion, post-combustion, and oxyfuelling can capture CO 2 from cement, steel, iron, and biogas sweetening processes. 35 Once captured and separated, CO 2 should be transported cost-effectively through pipelines to the injection station. To reduce corrosion and surplus costs, impurities and moisture must be removed. CO 2 must be compressed into supercritical form and monitored aer injection to prevent it from seeping out and remaining conned. 36,37 Long-term sequestration is preferred in active or depleted gas reservoirs and deep aquifers. 38 According to the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) and Special Report on Emission Scenarios (SRES), CCS may reduce global CO 2 emissions by 17% by 2050 and is one of the least expensive strategies for doing so in the near future. 39,40 CO 2 is a challenging C1-building block because of its high kinetic inertness and thermodynamic stability, with a standard heat of formation of DH f = −394 kJ mol −1 and a standard Gibbs energy of DG f = −395 kJ mol −1 . 41 To react effectively to epoxide and CO 2 , a catalyst is needed. Metal-containing catalysts can create cyclic carbonate and polycarbonate depending on the nucleophile species, metal species, nucleophile-to-metal ratio, and reaction conditions, but metal-free catalysts are oen more selective towards cyclic carbonates. Optimization is necessary to maximize production. Two broad categories of CO 2 utilization processes exist physical and chemical. To be physically utilised, CO 2 molecules must maintain their identity, either as a distinct entity or suspended in a solution. These processes, which include carbonated drinks, re extinguishers, dry ice, enhanced oil recovery (EOR), enhanced gas recovery (EGR), and enhanced geothermal systems, are based on the physical properties of CO 2 . Some physical utilization processes, such as EOR and EGR, have the potential to store large volumes of CO 2 and are called sequestration processes. 42 Chemical utilization involves CO 2 being converted into a new compound. The chemical potential of CO 2 can be utilized to produce fuels and chemicals. This article focuses on chemical utilization because of its limitless potential to abate CO 2 . Several prominent chemical utilization pathways, such as those summarized in Table 1, are available to convert CO 2 chemically into useful products, with varying production rates, technology readiness levels (TRL), the specic mass (CO 2 utilization in ton per ton of product), and CO 2 uptake potential. [43][44][45][46][47] Technologies for producing urea, salicylic acid, methane, methanol, ethylene carbonate, polyurethanes, and polycarbonates have a technology readiness level (TRL) of 9, indicating that they are well-established and mature. Other technologies listed are currently maturing and developing, while some are still immature and in the early stages of development. The CO 2 uptake potentials mentioned do not include emissions associated with processing. However, the reduction that can be achieved if environmentally benign processes are developed and deployed for utilization is an overview of the overall reduction. Currently, approximately 220 Mt per year of CO 2 is utilized for producing different chemicals, excluding methane, syngas, calcium carbonate, sodium carbonate, ethanol, etc. Urea production consumes the majority of CO 2 , followed by salicylic acid, cyclic carbonate, and polycarbonate. The remaining CO 2 is used for methanol, ethanol, etc. Additionally, around 20 Mt per year of its usage as a technical uid must be added to this amount. It is estimated that today, the chemical industry consumes 92% of the approximately 240 Mt per year of CO 2 that is consumed. 48 Over the next decade, a growing synthetic technology industry may increase the rate at which CO 2 is utilized to 350 Mt per year. By 2040, we could see a surge in the consumption of CO 2 for chemicals, rising to around 1000 Mt per year, potentially making a considerable difference. 49

Industrial processes of CO 2 utilizations
The rst mature method for CO 2 chemical utilization is urea production, which consumes 0.735 to 0.75 tons of CO 2 per ton of urea and is highly exothermic (Scheme 1). 28,37 The global urea market has reached 180 Mt per year in 2021, with a predicted growth of 0.8% between 2022 and 2027. 50 A novel process has been proposed to produce urea from power plants and electricity simultaneously by using CO 2 in the ue gas as a reactant for urea production, with 1 ton of CO 2 utilization producing 1.68 tons of urea. 51 Salicylic acid synthesis is a second example of efficient CO 2 utilisation (Scheme 2). 52 The commercialization of this process dates back to the 19th century, and salicylic acid production currently consumes 29 Kt of CO 2 directly, with a total production of 90 Kt per year. 27,53 The production of carbon-neutral fuels like methanol and methane is the third efficient chemical use of CO 2 (Scheme 3). 54,55 These fuels have zero CO 2 emissions when combusted under certain conditions, and their potential scale is almost limitless, as they can replace liquid and gaseous fossil fuels. Methane and methanol production has the potential to reduce 2.75 and 1.373 tons of CO 2 per ton of product produced, respectively. 44 Hydrogen is the main reactant needed for the feasibility of methanol and methane production, and methane can also be used for the production of carbon black and rubber. 56 The production of polycarbonates is the fourth illustration of efficient CO 2 utilisation, which uses renewable, economical, and non-toxic CO 2 instead of the poisonous phosgene route (Scheme 4). 57,58 Similarly, the h example of effective CO 2 utilization is the production of polyurethanes (PU), 59 which have dominated coatings, adhesives, sealants, and elastomers for the past three to four decades and can be tailored for different applications (Scheme 4). [60][61][62] The current production rate of polycarbonates and polyurethanes is 5 and 15 Mt per year, respectively. 45,47 Other developing CO 2 utilization technologies include dimethyl carbonate (DMC), dimethyl ether (DME), ethanol and algae. Ethanol is produced conventionally by fermenting sugars or corn, and it has the potential to be used as a zero-emission fuel, but the process design and low catalyst activity remain challenges. 61,62 DME is an alternative green fuel that results in fewer GHGs and can coproduce electricity, while DMC has potential as a methylating agent but faces catalyst selection issues (Table 1). 63,64 Algae cultivation has great potential as a biomass source for green fuel production and can absorb CO 2 and convert it to oxygen for water purication. 65 Fig. 2 shows examples of mature CO 2 utilization technologies and applications of cyclic carbonates.

Cyclic carbonates
The production of ve-membered cyclic carbonates through the reaction of epoxides and CO 2 is a commercially viable green and  Scheme 4 Synthesis of cyclic carbonates from epoxide and CO 2 . 32 sustainable chemistry reaction (Scheme 4). 32 This process uses CO 2 as a readily available, non-toxic, renewable reactant, which is one of its key advantages. Additionally, it is a 100% atomefficient reaction as the product is comprised of all reactants, with no need for a solvent. The reaction is also thermodynamically favourable, as epoxides have greater free energy than CO 2 , which offsets the required thermodynamic stability of CO 2 . 66 Therefore, cyclic carbonates production from CO 2 and epoxides is a promising and environmentally friendly approach to chemical synthesis.

Applications of cyclic carbonates
Propylene carbonate (PC) is a highly desirable polar aprotic solvent due to its high dipole moment, high dielectric constant, odorlessness, colourlessness, and low viscosity. 68,76 Additionally, it remains liquid across a wide temperature range and is biodegradable, hydrolyzing in air and water. PC is also nontoxic, non-ammable, and corrosion-resistant, making it an excellent solvent from a health and safety standpoint. 66,68,77 PC ranks highly on the GSK solvent suitability ranking, making it a green solvent. However, it has a high boiling point, which requires energy-intensive distillation for separation, and therefore, it may not be considered a green solvent under all circumstances. 78 Despite this, PC can replace harmful polar aprotic solvents affordably and sustainably. EC is not used as a solvent due to its solid nature, so it is combined with other compounds to overcome this issue. Several other cyclic carbonates, such as 1,2-limonene carbonate (1,2-LC) and styrene carbonate, have the same restraint. 66 Glycerol carbonate (GC) has similar properties and applications, but its use as a solvent is limited by its high viscosity. 77 Due to their dielectric characteristics, cyclic carbonates make excellent electrolytes for Li-ion batteries. 79 Li-ion batteries have become popular due to their use in portable devices. 80 Among Li-based battery electrolytes, EC and PC are commonly used as solvents. Lithium salts can dissolve in cyclic carbonate, providing the high dielectric constant needed for conductive electrolytes. 25 PC and EC have various uses such as cleaning,  Ingestion or skin absorption can be harmful paint stripping, degreasing, and the production of paints and coatings, lubricants, dyes, cosmetics, and personal care products. 74,75 Cyclic carbonates can also be employed as monomers in the production of polymers like polycarbonate and polyurethanes without isocyanate. 59,81 Cyclic carbonates are more effective than urea or salicylic acid at sequestering CO 2 in electronic devices, which typically have a lifespan measured in years. Electric cars may have a lifespan of decades, making cyclic carbonates even more effective at sequestering CO 2 . 26 Fig. 4 represents the applications of cyclic carbonates.

Terpene-based cyclic carbonates
The diverse structure of terpenes makes them an excellent source of complex cyclic carbonates, as opposed to other biobased feedstocks. The use of waste CO 2 as a coupling agent aer oxidation is a straightforward process. Recently, the synthesis of cyclic carbonates from terpenes has gained prominence in research. While past efforts focused on preparing veand six-membered cyclic carbonates, there is now a growing interest in developing more complex compounds. 82 It is thermodynamically efficient to react CO 2 with compounds that have high free energy. In nature, r cone oil and citrus fruits produce cyclic terpenes like limonene (both isomers). Extensive studies have been conducted on 1,2-LO due to its wide availability. However, when comparing sterically demanding 1,2-LO with other epoxides, the former exhibits lower reactivity during coupling. As a result, a longer reaction time (16-66 h) is required at higher temperatures and pressures (75-100°C, 10-50 bar). Fig. 6 summarises metal-based catalytic systems that have been reported for the coupling of 1,2-LO and CO 2 . [83][84][85][86][87] Several catalyst systems, including 1, 2tBu, and 3, have been reported to selectively form trans-1,2-LC, leading to different reactivity between the cis and trans isomers of 1,2-LO. 83,84,86 In 2016, efficient conversion of various terpene-based substrates was achieved using 2 R /PPNCL, which produced LDO with good yield. However, the synthesis of LDC was unsuccessful due to the formation of polyether (PE) side products. The reaction conditions for LDO synthesis were 1.0 mol% 2R, 3.0 mol% PPNCL, 1.0 mL MEK, 66 h, 85°C, p(CO 2 ) = 1 MPa. 84 Another study reported the formation of LDC with a concentration of up to 78% in the presence of 10.0 mol% 5/2.0 mol% PPh 3 catalyst, aer 48 h at 75°C and 50 bar. 85 Tetrabutylammonium halide (TBAX) is an efficient and effective catalyst for synthesizing 5-ring cyclic carbonates. 88 Therefore, a similar reaction was carried out using TBAX as a catalyst for the reaction between 1,2-LO and CO 2 with the substrate being ct-LO [43 : 57]. 89 The reaction conditions were extreme with high temperature, pressure, and reaction time (100°C, 3 MPa, 20 h) and the catalyst consisted of 10 mol% ct-LO without any solvent. Tetrabutylammonium chloride (TBAC) had a 51% conversion rate of cis-trans-LO, with the individual conversion of trans-LO and cis-LO being 76% and 19%, respectively. However, the conversion rate and NMR yield decreased when tetrabutylammonium bromide (TBAB) and tetrabutylammonium iodide (TBAI) were used as activating catalysts. The order of catalytic activity increment was reported as TBAX > TBAB > TBAI < TBAC. The research group continued their investigation using TBAC as the catalyst model to study the effect of reaction conditions. The typical conditions used were a 10 mol% catalyst based on cis-trans-LO, 20 h reaction time, 100°C temperature, and 3 MPa of CO 2 pressure. The study focused on varying reaction times, CO 2 pressure, and the amount of TBAC. Prolonging the reaction time did not improve the conversion of cistrans-LO, as 48 h and 72 h resulted in 65% and 69% yields, respectively. The next step was to vary the CO 2 pressure while keeping all other parameters constant. The results showed that only increasing the pressure by 5 MPa increased the individual yield/conversion to cis-LO/trans-LO to 27 : 85. Finally, increasing the amount of TBAC increased trans-LO yield, while cis-LO conversion remained low.
A detailed kinetic study of the coupling reaction between 1,2-LO and CO 2 in the presence of TBAC was recently reported, which found that the trans-isomer exhibits greater reactivity. The reaction was determined to be a rst-order reaction with respect to all reactants, and the Eyring equation was used to determine the thermodynamic parameters of conversion. The entropy value was found to be 60.6 kJ mol −1 and the enthalpy value was −103.6 J (mol K) −1 . 90 In another recent study by Mikšovsky et al., 91 tetrabutylammonium-based halides and 1ethyl-3-methyl imidazolium halides were used as homogeneous catalysts, while a supported ionic liquid was used as a heterogeneous catalyst for the synthesis of cyclic carbonates from limonene epoxides. It was found that imidazolium-based liquids have less catalytic activity in comparison or are even inactive when LO (cis/trans-mixture) is used as a substrate. TBAC proved to be the most selective and highest-yielding catalyst for converting the diastereomeric mixture (cis/trans = 44/56). Silica without immobilization, TBAC, and TBAB showed lower yield, while in the case of imidazolium-based catalysts TBAI yield increased, but the overall selectivity was still low. The same order of catalytic activity was seen for supported ionic liquid phases and ammonium-based ionic liquids (ILs) physisorbed on silica as it was for homogeneous mode.
Mülhaupt's research group used LDC to prepare polyhydroxy urethanes (Scheme 5). 92 For the synthesis of LDC on a one-kilogram scale, TBAB was used, and the reaction parameters were optimized to allow for 3 mol% TBAB usage in less than 50 h to achieve complete LDO conversion. The resulting product was a brownish oil, which can be directly used to prepare non-isocyanate polyurethanes (NIPUs). Several byproducts were identied aer analyzing the reaction. LDC was cooled and crystallised to create a pure product, resulting in a 3 : 1 combination (cis-to-trans ratio). X-ray analysis proved that the trans-LDC produced by further crystallisation was 100% pure. 93 Through TBAB-mediated reaction, 8,9-LC was formed by reacting CO 2 with 8,9-LO. To synthesize the desired carbonates, the less hindered terminal alkene of (R)-(+)-limonene was selectively epoxidized (Scheme 6). Perchloric acid was used as the oxidant, and bulky polyoxometalates (POM) were used as the catalyst. Compared to 1,2-LO, 8,9-LC is easier to produce due to less steric hindrance, reaching maximum conversion in only 2.5 h under comparable reaction conditions. Additionally, the two diastereomer-isomers obtained showed the same reactivity during coupling with CO 2 , which is in contrast to 1,2-LO, where trans-1,2-LO was found to be more reactive. 94

Glycerol carbonate
Glycerol carbonate (GC), also referred to as 4-hydroxymethyl-1,3-dioxolan-2-one, is a bio-derived 5-membered ring carbonate synthesized from glycerol. It is one of the few newly commercialized bio-derived products from biomass.
2.3.1 Glycerol carbonate synthesis from glycerol and CO 2 . Glycerol carbonate (GC) is a 5-membered ring carbonate synthesized from glycerol and is an example of a new bioderived product from biomass that has been commercialized recently. The most suitable reaction is the direct reaction of glycerol with CO 2 , which produces solely the required product and water. This reaction is completely green and combines two waste reactants, as indicated in Scheme 7. Due to thermodynamic limitations and the requirement to identify a suitable dehydrating agent to remove water from the reaction, this reaction is not feasible for industrial production. 95 Vieville et al. reported the rst attempt to synthesise GC from glycerol and CO 2 in 1998. 96 The reaction did not occur under supercritical CO 2 conditions. The rst successful production of GC was reported by Aresta et al. in 2006 using Sn-based catalysts under 5 MPa and 180°C of pressure and temperature, respectively. 97 A maximum yield of 5.7% was achieved without the use of a solvent, and molecular sieves were used for the removal of in situ water. During the mechanistic study, it was proposed that the Sn-based catalyst and CO 2 could be inserted into glycerol by forming the active Sn-glycerate intermediate. George et al. intensied this process in 2009 using MeOH as a medium, increasing the yield of GC to 35%, as shown in Scheme 8. 98 Methanol acted as a solvent and was involved in the reaction mechanism as well. Metal oxide/complexes, supported metal catalysts, modied zeolites, or hydrotalcite have been reported as catalytic systems. For GC synthesis, most heterogeneous catalysts require CO 2 at high pressures and temperatures above 40 bar and 150°C, respectively.
The dehydrating reagent for the removal of water was more efficacious than using molecular sieves. However, in some cases, a decrease in chemo selectivity towards GC was noted. The most used dehydrating agents for this reaction are acetonitrile, adiponitrile, and 2-cyanopyridine, as shown in Scheme 10. In most studies, acetonitrile is the rst choice because it is cheap, but upon reaction with the water molecule, it generates acetamide in situ. The produced acetamide reacts with another water molecule to produce acetic acid, which decreases selectivity by forming mono-and di-acetins. McGregor et al. 18 used  adiponitrile as a dehydrating agent to remove water and found that it degrades to ammonia upon reacting with glycerol, resulting in a mixture of two regio-isomers of 4-HMO (4-(hydroxymethyl)oxazolidine-2-one). In 2016, Liu et al. 99 employed 2-cyanopyridine as a highly effective dehydrating reagent. By using 3 equivalents of 2-cyanopyridine with a CeO 2 catalyst in DMF at 4 MPa of CO 2 and 150°C, GC yields can increase to 79%. Recent research by Zhang et al. 100 has shown the benets of employing CaC 2 as a dehydration agent for GC production. In their work, CaC 2 was combined with Zn(OTf) 2 / phen (1,10-phenanthroline) in N-methyl-2-pyrrolidone (NMP), and the reaction was carried out at 50 bar CO 2 pressure at 180°C for 24 h to get 88% GC. In their experiment, CaC 2 in combination with Zn(OTf) 2 /phen (1,10-phenanthroline) in NMP (Nmethyl-2-pyrrolidone) at 50 bar CO 2 pressure and 180°C for 24 h yielded 88% GC. Su et al. 101 reported a year later that GC can also be produced using 2-cyanopyridine at 15 MPa of CO 2 and 180°C without the use of a metal catalyst, with a 19% yield (Scheme 9). FTIR analysis conrmed the formation of a 5membered ring via the activation of CO 2 by 2-cyanopyridine, followed by a reaction with glycerol to form GC. The formation of this heterocycle was also supported by theoretical analysis, and glycerol was subsequently transesteried by it. Notably, there was no substantial GC production when using acetonitrile, 4-cyanopyridine, or 3-cyanopyridine (Table 3).
2.3.2 Glycerol carbonate synthesis using coupling agents. Glycerol carbonate (GC) can be effectively synthesized through the reaction of glycerol and CO 2 , facilitated by a coupling agent. This coupling agent enables the formation of a cyclic carbonate intermediate in situ, which facilitates the transesterication process, resulting in the formation of glycerol carbonate along with a by-product (Scheme 11). By incorporating a third reactant, this approach overcomes the inherent thermodynamic constraints of the direct glycerol-CO 2 reaction and generates an additional by-product derived from this supplementary component. In 2012, Ma et al. 102 (entry 1, Table 4) utilized propylene oxide (PO) as the rst additive in the one-pot reaction of CO 2 and glycerol. The substance with a hydroxyl group can act as a co-catalyst for halide-catalyzed reactions, promoting the   increasing the yield to 80%, the catalysts could be reused up to ve times. By using 4 wt% catalyst loading of P-DVB-(vIm-BuBr), 25 mmol of glycerol, and 100 mmol of PO, a 75% yield of GC could be achieved under 100°C and 2 MPa in 4 h. Propargylic alcohol (dimethyl ethynyl carbinol) has been used as a coupling reagent along with PO. He et al. 104 utilized Ag 2 CO 3 /xanthaphos catalyst in MeCN with 1 MPa CO 2 pressure at 80°C to produce a good yield of GC in one pot approach using CH 3 CN as a solvent (entry 3, Table 4). Li et al. 105 improved the process by using silver sulfadiazine and the Et 4 NBr synergistic system without any solvent (entry 4, Table 4), but the yield of GC decreased. Silver sulfadiazine activated the hydroxyl groups simultaneously in propargylic alcohols (or vicinal diols), resulting in an excellent performance. The Lu and Liu groups reported GC preparation by organo-catalytic approach. Zhou et al. 106 Table 4). Alkyl halides can also be used as effective reactants, but they generate halogencontaining waste, making the method unsustainable. Jang et al. 108 reported the use of DBU, BmimPF 6 , and CH 2 Br 2 for direct coupling of various alcohols, including glycerol, without using any Mitsunobu-type reagents (entry 7, Table 4). At 70°C and 1 MPa, it was possible to achieve 86% yield. Mihara et al. 109 used tert-butyl tetramethyl guanidine and n-BuBr as an additional component at 50°C and 0.1 MPa CO 2 pressure employing NMP (N-methyl pyrrolidone) as a solvent to obtain GC in 74% yield (entry 8, Table 4). The authors suggest that the ionic liquid is effective in improving CO 2 solubility, glycidol (Gly) may react with an NHC carbene formed that can capture/activate CO 2 .
2.3.3 Glycerol carbonate synthesis from glycidol. Glycidol (Gly), an epoxy alcohol derivative, can be converted into glycerol carbonate (GC) as a precursor, instead of using bio-glycerol. This waste product from epichlorohydrin synthesis can be recycled in two steps to produce GC with excellent atom efficiency and eco-friendliness. 110 Many catalytical systems have been reported for CO 2 cycloaddition to oxirane and glycidol (Gly). Gly has relatively high reactivity compared to PO and styrene oxide. Two ways in which non-innocent hydroxyl groups can actively participate in the reaction have been identied. A paramount progress in this eld was reported in 2016 by Monica et al. 111 using TBAB as a catalyst. Under optimal conditions, more than 99% conversion was afforded to GC. Furthermore, binary catalyst derived from Gly/TBAB was successfully tested on other epoxide/CO 2 combinations, with signicantly higher substrate conversions than without Gly.
Rintjema et al. 112 discovered that the hydroxyl group on Gly, which can be used to create transitory hemi-carbonate species, can be used to activate CO 2 . Halide-free processing is made possible by this activation, which causes the oxirane ring to be opened by an intramolecular nucleophile under mild conditions and without the requirement for an external nucleophilic addition. It has been determined the exact process by which the oxirane ring of Gly is opened intramolecularly by the production of hemi-carbonate. Additionally, metal and halide-free production of GC using a packed bed reactor under ow conditions has been reported. 113 Several catalytical systems, including heterogeneous, homogenous, and organo-metallic, have been reported to produce GC from Gly. However, not all catalytic systems are superior to simple TBAB.
2.3.4 Glycerol carbonate synthesis using heterogeneous catalysts. Heterogeneous catalysts offer the advantage of easy recovery aer post-synthesis processes such as product ltering or extraction, as illustrated in Scheme 12. Numerous heterogeneous systems used to synthesise GC from Gly are derived from ILs. [114][115][116][117][118][119] The reaction occurs in two steps: rstly, the nucleophilic anion opens the oxirane ring, and secondly, an IL forms hydrogen bonds between the acidic C2 proton of the imidazolium ring and the oxirane ring.
Multifunctional components integrated into composite materials can enhance the activity for specic uses. Jiang et al. 120 reported an efficient composite catalyst, polyILs@MIL-101, by conning imidazolium-based polyionic liquids (polyILs) into a metal-organic framework (MOF) material MIL-101 via in situ polymerizations of encapsulated monomers. This material has CO 2 -capturing capability and is a good catalyst without any cocatalyst under normal atmospheric pressure. With high surface area and hierarchical pores, PolyILs@MIL-101 is a promising catalyst material. The superior catalytic activity of polyILs@MIL-101, in comparison to either polyILs or MIL-101, is due to the synergy between the CO 2 capturing capability, the Lewis base site in polyILs, and the Lewis acid site in the MOF. Only a few reports have explored the synergistic effects of CO 2 capture and conversion. The results of this study demonstrate the necessity of enriching CO 2 using a heterogeneous catalyst to assist in its conversion. Moreover, this paper proposes a strategy for designing practical catalysts that could be used in the future to directly capture and convert CO 2 from ue gases.
Ghosh et al. 121 reported using iron-phosphonate hybrid organic-inorganic nanoparticles HPFP-1(NP) as a nano-catalyst for synthesizing organic carbonate at mild conditions and CO 2 under atmospheric pressure. This catalyst demonstrated excellent recyclability and reusability. In addition, a polystyrene-zincanthra complex was found to be an efficient catalyst, achieving 89% conversion to GC in 5 h. 122 While both HPFP and PS-Zn require TBAB as a co-catalyst, zinc stannate nanocrystals do not need any co-catalyst. These nanocrystals could also be recovered and reused without losing their activity in the presence of PEG-600 as a green solvent, showing the potential of nano-catalysts as an environmentally friendly solution. 123 The summary of the homogenous catalytical system reported for GC production from Gly is given in Table 5. 2.3.5 Glycerol carbonate synthesis using homogeneous catalysts. Compared to their heterogeneous counterparts, homogeneous catalysts offer several advantages due to their use of earth-abundant materials and lower loading requirements. Halide ion-based bifunctional catalysts have shown promising results in terms of conversion and selectivity. Martínez et al. [124][125][126] reported the use of aluminium scorpionate complexes (Scheme 13) as an efficient catalyst for the conversion of Gly to GC with low catalyst loading (0. 25 The summary of the homogenous catalytical system reported for GC production from Gly is given in Table 6. 2.3.6 Glycerol carbonate synthesis using organocatalysts. Organocatalysts have shown activity analogous to metal-based catalysts in activating the oxirane ring. They achieve this by forming a hydrogen bond that facilitates ring opening by a nucleophile. Several organocatalytic compounds have been reported that are recyclable and efficient. For example, Anthofer et al. 130 and Castro-Osma et al. 131 reported an organocatalyst containing imidazolium rings and halide counter anions (Scheme 14), while Kim's group reported a scorpionatetype organocatalyst comprising an aminophenol scaffold and a quaternary ammonium salt. 132 Yadav et al. reported ascorbic acid combined with a co-catalytic amount of halide TBAI that achieves high yields of GC at mild temperature and pressure conditions. 133 Zhang et al. reported alterable organoboron bifunctional catalysts that are the most efficient catalysts known to date. 134 These catalysts can withstand high temperatures of up to 150°C and harsh conditions of 20 MPa CO 2 and 120°C. They achieve activation of the oxirane ring through a Lewis acidlike boron that activates the ring near the ammonium iodide unit.
Sopeña et al. 135 concluded that DBU can enhance GC production from Gly and other epoxy alcohols by creating Hemicarbonate intermediates in mild conditions. Furthermore, a new organocatalytic process has been discovered to couple triand tetra-substituted epoxides with CO 2 , allowing for the  3. New methods for the synthesis of cyclic carbonates

Synthesis of cyclic carbonates in ow reactors
The production of cyclic carbonates from epoxides and CO 2 comprises a gas-liquid process in which mass is transferred from the gas phase to the liquid phase, followed by a catalytic cycloaddition reaction. 136 The rate of CO 2 mass transfer has been identied as a critical factor for controlling the reaction rate in batch reactors. 137 An effective reactor design is required to attain high rates of heat and mass transfer. However, traditional batch reactors are less efficient, costly, and less secure. In contrast, continuous ow systems have several advantages, including lower reaction temperatures, shorter residence times, and ease of industrial scaling. 138 As a result, continuous ow reactors can address many of the drawbacks of conventional batch reactors. Moreover, the design of the reactor signicantly affects the gas-liquid reaction rates. 139 Recent advancements in ow chemistry have enabled the chemical transformation and incorporation of CO 2 into valuable organic compounds. These advances have made CO 2 attractive to both industry and academia. [140][141][142][143] Batch transformations using CO 2 as a C1 synthon have rapidly developed, 144-147 while CO 2 reactions in continuous ow systems have become increasingly popular. Compared to conventional batch reactors, ow reactors provide several advantages. Firstly, they have a large surface-to-volume ratio, enabling effective mixing of different phases and precise temperature control. This rapid heat and mass transfer can greatly increase the effectiveness of reactions. Secondly, ow reactors can be much safer due to their excellent thermal management and low material hold-up, facilitating transformations that are difficult to perform in batch reactors, streamlining multistep processes, and optimizing reactions. [148][149][150] Additionally, small ow reactors can produce large quantities of product because of their numbering-up methodology. Thus, lab research can be applied feasibly in the industrial setting within a short period. 151 Although ow chemistry offers several advantages for CO 2 transformation, its application is still a challenge. The low reactivity of CO 2 makes many batch reactions slow, and different ow patterns can occur due to the reactor geometry and operating conditions. 152 These patterns, such as annular ow, bubble ow, slug ow and churn ow, directly affect the experimental results. Thus, continuous processes require different operating parameters than batch processes, which must be adjusted accordingly. Additionally, CO 2 xation under ow conditions poses other challenges, such as product  separation, catalyst recycling, and solvent and/or waste compatibility during multistep reactions. Innovative approaches have been reported to solve these issues, but further developments are necessary, including the development of new concepts, more efficient catalysts, and novel equipment. Process intensication has exciting possibilities and ow chemistry should be viewed as a complement to batch chemistry rather than as its competitor. Research and development efforts are needed for commercialization, and high-potential applications of process intensication include biological CO 2 transformation, catalytic CO 2 transformation, electrochemical CO 2 transformation, and CO 2 transformation using plasma technology. 153 These advancements can signicantly reduce the feasibility gap between newly developed sustainable technologies and previous technologies. Flow platforms are commonly equipped with the equipment listed in Fig. 7.
Ionic liquids have become a popular catalysis method in recent years due to their stability, non-ammability, recyclability, and tailoring ease. 137,155 The cycloaddition of CO 2 and propylene oxide (PO) to create PC was reported on by Takahashi et al. in 2006. 156 They used a packed-bed reactor with an effective organic-inorganic hybrid catalyst. Compared to homogeneously used onium-salts, immobilized phosphonium-halides increased catalytic activity signicantly. The inorganic-acid support also synergistically enhanced the organic component (Fig. 8). SiO 2 -C 3 H 6 -P (n-Bu) 3 I had a pseudo-rst-order rate constant 300 times greater than P (n-Bu) 4 I, normalized to phosphorus atoms. The xed bed ow reactor used 10 g of SiO 2 -C 3 H 6 -P(n-Bu) 3 Br as a catalyst, with CO 2 and PO ow rates of 0.1 and 0.2 mL min −1 , respectively. Under 10 MPa, the temperature increased from 90 to 160°C, yielding 80% in over 1000 h with 99% selectivity. One phosphonium group can produce more than 11 500 molecules of PC. Using packed-bed reactors and supported catalysts, this ground-breaking study found that the cycloaddition of CO 2 to PC could be accomplished with remarkable efficiency.
Zhang et al. 157 examined the utilisation of a packed-bed reactor for the cycloaddition of epichlorohydrin in 2015. They used coconut shell activated carbon (CSAC) anchored ionic liquids as a catalyst and no solvent (Fig. 9). The epichlorohydrin owrate was maintained at 1.0 mL min −1 and the CO 2 owrate at 50 mL min −1 . The reaction was carried out at 1.4 MPa and 140°C, resulting in an 82% yield in 5 h, with a liquid hourly space velocity (LHSV) of 6 h −1 .
In 2017, Wang et al. 158 utilized a xed-bed reactor to perform the cycloaddition of CO 2 to PO to PC using newly synthesized PSIL(IMD) Imidazolium-based polymer-supported ionic liquids as a catalyst, without the use of a solvent. A total of 0.3 g of the catalyst was used in the experiment (Fig. 10). The gas hourly space velocity (GHSV) of the PO was kept constant at 4000 h −1 while the ow rate was kept at 15 mL min −1 , under a 2 MPa pressure. With a liquid hourly space velocity (LHSV) of 6 h −1 , a yield of 41 to 45% was attained in 130 hours. This system  For CO 2 cycloaddition to epoxides in a continuous ow reactor, Valverde et al. 159 looked into the use of multifunctional polymers based on ionic liquids and Rose Bengal (RB) fragments (Fig. 11). A highly effective catalyst was produced under ow conditions by modifying the RB characteristics by changing the chemical nature of the supporting liquid. The substrate and CO 2 owed at rates of 5 and 50 mL min −1 , respectively. At 140 bar and 150°C, the system achieved 53% conversion over 10 days, with no leaching and no decrease in catalytic activity.
In 2021, Yin et al. 160 investigated the use of a green DBUbased IL catalyst (DBU@SBA) for CO 2 xation and PC synthesis in a new packed bed reactor design (Fig. 12). The reactor had a substrate ow rate of 0.1 mL min −1 and CO 2 owrate of 5 mL min −1 . At 2 MPa and 90°C, the reaction was conducted, yielding 57.1% conversion aer 2 h and 16.86% aer 24 h of continuous operation. However, the catalytic activity was lost aer 26 h, resulting in only a 4% yield.
Bui et al. 161 reported the use of a vertical-xed bed reactor for the cycloaddition of CO 2 to epichlorohydrin and 1,2 butylene oxide using economical Mesoporous melamine-formaldehyde resins (MMFR) as a heterogeneous catalyst (Fig. 13).

Synthesis of cyclic carbonates in microow reactors
New types of ow reactors have been developed to improve the efficiency of production. Microreactors are ideal for two-phase gas-liquid processes due to their controllability and large specic surface area. Moreover, they offer opportunities for homogeneous catalysis for CO 2 -based chemical reactions. 162,163 Zhao et al. 136 investigated the use of a microreactor for the cycloaddition of PO to PC using a hydroxyl functionalized ionic    liquid (HETBAB) as a catalyst. The high surface-to-volume ratio of the microreactor resulted in a signicant improvement in heat and mass transfer compared to a conventional CSTR (Fig. 14). The reaction achieved a yield of 99.8% in just 14 seconds at 180°C and 3.0 MPa.
Li et al. 164 reported the use of a microreactor followed by a delayed reactor for the cycloaddition of CO 2 to various epoxides using a binary catalytic system (Fig. 15). The owrate of epoxide and CO 2 was maintained at 0.3-1.2 mL min −1 and 195.2-770 mL min −1 , respectively, achieving 90 to 99% conversion in less than 100 seconds with TOF ranging from 6800 to 14 700 under 2.0 MPa and 150°C. Compared to a conventional stirred reactor, the microreactor reaction exhibited signicantly higher TOF values, a higher and stable reaction rate, and negligible effect by the CO 2 /epoxide molar ratio. Furthermore, the "Electrophile-Nucleophile" synergistic effect in the microreactor could be enhanced to further improve the catalytic activity.
In 2021, Wu et al. 138 stated the use of a micro reaction system in a continuous ow setup for CO 2 xation, using 1-butyl-3-    In 2021, Rigo et al. 165 used a micro-uidic reactor to perform cycloaddition to epoxides with a binary system NaBr/diethylene glycol (DEG) as a catalytic system, using DEG as a reaction medium (Fig. 17). The ow rate of epoxide and CO 2 was kept at 0.1 mL min −1 and 1.0 mL min −1 , respectively. At 120 bar and     220°C, they obtained a conversion of 91 to 99% for a range of cyclic carbonates. Tube-in-tube reactors are gaining attention as an intelligent process for gas-liquid transformations. In 2018, Rehman et al. 166 studied the CO 2 cycloaddition of styrene oxide (SO) using a ZnBr 2 /TBAB catalytic system in a gas-liquid continuous ow reactor of this type. They achieved 100% conversion at 6 bar and 120°C in 45 min (Fig. 18). The kinetic study showed that it was a rst-order reaction with respect to the reactants. The decrease of activation energy by 23 kJ mol −1 using ZnBr 2 as a co-catalyst highlighted the importance of synergy.
In 2021, Zanda et al. 113 used a tube-in-tube reactor followed by a packed bed reactor in series for the preparation of GC from Gly. They used 1.59 g of heterogeneous TBD @ Merrield as a catalyst and MEK as a solvent (Fig. 19). In 48 h, 99% conversion was attained while the reaction was being conducted at 70°C and 3 bar of CO 2 pressure.

Synthesis of limonene carbonate using a ow reactor
A novel continuous ow method for converting 1,2-LO and LDO to limonene cyclic carbonates was recently reported. 91 Supercritical CO 2 was the only reagent and solvent used in the experiment, and easily producible heterogeneous supported ionic liquid phase (SILP) catalysts were applied. ILs are excellent candidates for use as reaction media in catalytic processes due to the high solubility of supercritical CO 2 in them. SILP materials have a high surface area that is benecial for catalytic processes and are made up of a thin layer of ionic liquid on a supporting material, such as mesoporous silica. This enables the researchers to overcome mass transfer limitations caused by short diffusion lengths in the thin lm.
The setup for continuous ow reaction is shown in Fig. 20. Both scCO 2 and substrate were mixed and sent to the preheater when a temperature greater than 80°C was required, followed by a second heating unit to heat the catalyst cartridge to 150°C. The catalyst input for two different cartridge lengths (150 and 250 mm) was 1.34 and 2.22 g of SILP material, respectively. Back-pressure regulators were used to enabling reactions to occur at different pressures. The nal product was collected aer passing through a gas-liquid separator, containing carbonates and unreacted starting material. Optimization was performed on the temperature, pressure, catalyst loading, and ow rates of CO 2 and substrates. The reaction required a 2-3 h preliminary lead time under the low ow rate of 1,2-LO of 0.01 mL min −1 . The SILP catalysts used were easily producible heterogeneous and best-performing supported ionic liquid phase (SILP) catalysts (Fig. 21).
Various factors were studied to optimize the continuous ow process for the conversion of 1,2-LO and LDO to limonene cyclic carbonates. Firstly, an increase in temperature from 80 to 120°C increased yield. However, at 150°C, both degradation and Hoffmann elimination of TBAC 1 to tributylamine caused a decline in yield over time. Secondly, to prevent the leaching of the catalyst from its supporting material during prolonged industrial use, the corresponding pressure of 6 to 20 MPa was Fourthly, catalyst loading of 20 to 40 wt% was studied, and it was found that a 30 wt% loading instead of 20 wt% increased the yield, while a 40 wt% loading was unsuitable and overburdened the pressure. Lastly, the ow rates of scCO 2 and substrate (LO-cis/trans) were studied. The ow rate of CO 2 between 1.99 and 2.49 mL min −1 was found to be optimum, while a ow rate of 0.99 mL min −1 caused choking and a ow rate of 3.99 mL min −1 caused leaching. Similarly, a higher ow rate of (LO-cis/trans) 0.02 L min −1 instead of 0.01 mL min −1 resulted in leaching. Using a heterogeneous catalyst optimized under specic conditions (48 h reaction time, 15 MPa pressure, 120°C temperature, 2.22 g of SLIP 1 catalyst input, 0.01 mL min −1 of LO-cis/trans substrate ow rate, 1.99 mL min −1 of CO 2 ow rate, and a 250 mm catalyst cartridge), a maximum yield of 22% and an overall yield of 16% were achieved. This resulted in a novel production ow rate of 0.12 g h −1 , which had not been reported before. To further optimize the process, future experiments could focus on using only the more reactive cis isomer for the chemical xation of CO 2 under ow conditions. Diastereomeric mixtures of epoxy carbonate and bicarbonate can be formed by converting LDO, as shown in Fig. 22. Epoxy carbonate, being less sterically hindered, yields higher yields than bicarbonate. To optimize the reaction, a heterogeneous catalyst was used under specic conditions (12 h, 20 MPa, 120°C , 2.22 g of SLIP 1, 0.01 mL min −1 of LO-cis/trans, 1.99 mL min −1 of CO 2 , 250 mm catalyst cartridge), resulting in a maximum yield of 27% for epoxy carbonate and 14% for bicarbonate, with an overall yield of 16%. Table 7 provides a summary of cyclic carbonates synthesis under ow conditions, showcasing the various types of reactors and their respective reaction conditions.

Summary
This review summarizes the latest developments in using CO 2 to produce cyclic carbonates from bio-based precursors. Future research should focus on proposing catalytical systems that can reduce the temperature and pressure requirements for CO 2 and epoxide reactions. The selection of product routes based on CCU is complex, and economic and environmental assessments of each route are necessary. Novel designs for integrating Capture and Utilization at the same station are anticipated, and research should aim to improve nancial and energy penalties. Ethanol, methanol, and syngas production have high potential, but research and development efforts are needed to make them feasible. Processes that require hydrogen will need a sustainable or green method of hydrogen production for commercial viability. Process Intensication tools such as intensied equipment and processes can improve mass and heat-transfer rates. Over 50% of processes are laboratory-based, so industrialization efforts are necessary. Recent advances in ow chemistry have enabled the use of CO 2 as a C1 synthon and packed-bed and microreactors have shown promise for coupling CO 2 and epoxides. Further research should focus on developing robust catalytic systems, novel reactor designs, and efficient synthesis techniques. With the growing number of publications in this eld, a bright future is forecasted, and this review provides a starting point for further advancements.

Conflicts of interest
There are no conicts to declare.