Understanding the charging of supercapacitors by electrochemical quartz crystal microbalance

the charging of


Introduction
2][3] Supercapacitors have gathered great attention among various EES technologies because of their high power density, fast charging ability and excellent cycling stability. 4iang Niu They are utilized in grid peaking, energy recovery, backup power, and vehicle starting. 5,6Through remarkable progress, commercial supercapacitors could provide a high specific power of 30 kW kg −1 . 7However, their energy density is lower than lead-acid and lithium-ion batteries, impeding their further application. 7,8Numerous studies focus on the way to get high power density and energy density simultaneously.0][11] Hence, a deep comprehension of these phenomena can help redesign supercapacitors with improved performance.

Liang
8][19][20] Moreover, combining EQCM and other in situ characterization techniques and simulation methods has achieved quantitative ion transport detection, providing a molecular-level picture of supercapacitors. 21,22everal reviews have focused on the theory and typical applications of EQCM in supercapacitors. 13,20,23,24Levi et al. 20,23 introduced the in situ gravimetric and deformations monitoring of electrodes during their charging.Shpigel et al. 25 reviewed the application of EQCM in capacitive deionization.Recently, Ji et al. 26 summarized the application of EQCM in batteries for mechanistic studies.These reviews provide insightful information on the recent advance in the application of EQCM in capacitive and battery technologies.However, it remains essential to distill and analyze these studies to establish a comprehensive understanding of ion transport and desolvation.In addition, the combination of EQCM with other experimental or computation methods has not yet been discussed systematically.Herein, we provide an overview of the theory and development progress of EQCM, especially the preparation techniques for coating electrode film on the quartz crystal surface. 23Moreover, we summarize the application of EQCM in supercapacitors concerning ion transport, ion desolvation, and quantitative characterization.Finally, the future research direction of EQCM is explored to inspire new ideas for developing EQCM in supercapacitors.

Theory and history of EQCM
The EQCM system is shown in Fig. 2, comprising a test module, a quartz crystal microbalance (QCM), a potentiostat, and a computer.The theoretical basis of EQCM can be traced 140 years back.In 1880, Jacques and Pierre Curie discovered that some crystals appear to have a voltage proportional to the applied pressure. 27,28When an alternating current voltage is applied to these crystals, they undergo a period of mechanical distortion, called vibrate. 27,28In 1959, Sauerbrey 29 observed a linear relationship between the change of vibration frequency and mass variation of the load on the quartz crystal surface, which was proposed as the Sauerbrey formula: 29 where Δf is the frequency change, f 0 is the fundamental frequency of the quartz crystal, Δm is the mass change of the surface thin film, ρ q is the density of the quartz crystal (2.648 g cm −3 ), μ q is the shear modulus of the quartz crystal (2.947 × 10 11 g cm −1 s −2 ), and A is the surface area of the quartz crystal.The Sauerbrey formula provides a theoretical foundation for nanogram-level mass characterization, but this formula was initially thought to be retained in the gas phase, severely limiting its application.In the 1980s, Nomura and Okuhara 30 showed that this formula was also applicable in liquid, while the frequency response depended on the liquid density and viscosity.Subsequently, Schumacher and Martin developed techniques for measuring the surface mass change of quartz crystals in liquid environments, which broadens the application scope of EQCM. 31,32n addition to the mass response, viscoelastic changes of coatings on the quartz crystal have also been studied.Then, the EQCM technology route has developed in two directions.On the one hand, Rodahl et al. 33 proposed in 1995 the theory of EQCM-D to simultaneous evaluation the change of mass and the viscous properties, where the dissipation factor D was defined as: where E dissipated is the energy dissipated during one period of oscillation, and E stored is the energy stored in the oscillating system. 33This method can determine the viscoelastic changes of coatings by monitoring the dissipation factor qualitatively: an increase of D indicates an increase in coating viscoelasticity.On the other hand, in 2002, the quartz crystal admittance (QCA) theory that considers the effect of surface roughness on the response of the QCM was developed to detect the effect of surface roughness on vibration frequency. 34Based on this theory, a hydrodynamic model was proposed by Daikhin et al. 35 about 10 years later, which is composed of carbon particles (either porous or non-porous) and a polymeric binder layer.This model gave the penetration depth δ as: 35 where η and ρ are dynamic viscosity and density of solvent, respectively, n is overtone orders, f 0 is the fundamental frequency.
According to the derivation of this model, the frequency and halfpeak width variation are linearly related to δ n for an ideal flat electrode: 35 where ρ L is the density of the liquid, μ q and ρ q represent the elastic shear modulus and density, respectively.If the electrode surface is not ideal, the Δf ∼ δ n and ΔW ∼ δ n curves will deviate from the ideal linear curve, thus obtaining information referring to the viscoelastic changes.Daikhin et al. 35 obtained various values for δ n by putting the electrode in different liquids, and the reliable change of aggregate and porous structure parameters was obtained.However, the method by changing solutions requires the re-establishment of a liquid environment, limiting the in situ detection of ion transport.In 2016, Shpigel et al. 36 combined the EQCM-D method and electrochemical quartz crystal admittance (EQCA) models to obtain different values of δ n in the same solution by changing the multipliers, thus in situ detecting the structural parameters of the electrode.8][39] The representative application of EQCM in supercapacitors is listed in Fig. 3.In 2009, Levi et al. 18 used the EQCM to detect ion flux within porous carbon materials, introducing this advanced in situ mean in the analysis of the charging mechanism of supercapacitors.Further, EQCM was utilized to investigate the ion transport and desolvation of supercapacitors by comparing the theoretical mass change with measured experimental mass variation. 19,20,40The application of EQCM in supercapacitors has gained rapid development in the past few years.In 2020, EQCM was used to research the various behavior in twodimensional graphene channels with different spacings. 22In 2021, EQCM helped understand the role of anionic species during the energy stored process in Mxenes. 41In 2022, Zhang et al. 42 demonstrated at a molecular level that N-doping strongly influences the charging mechanism in porous carbon with the aid of EQCM. 42These applications demonstrate the key role of EQCM in the study of the charging mechanism of supercapacitors.

Film coating method
The application of EQCM in supercapacitors is based on the Sauerbrey formula. 18,29This formula is derived by assuming the film and quartz crystal as a unit and no slip occurs during the measurement.Therefore, the Sauerbrey formula is only suitable for rigid films, suggesting that the prepared films must remain rigid without changes in volume or porosity in solution and polarization conditions. 23In practical testing, a low-frequency change and a small dissipation/resistance value is required. 44,45Due to these strict demands, a high-quality film is essential for EQCM measurement, which significantly relies on the film preparation method.
The film preparation commonly includes spray-assisted coating, spin coating, pyrolysis, direct pyrolysis, electrochemical deposition, physical/chemical deposition and vacuum filtration transfer (VFT). 44,46The spray-assisted coating is the most used method owing to its easy operation, low price, and reasonable uniformity, but it still suffers from problems of poor reproducibility and discontinuity. 46The spin coating method can be applied continuously; however, the mass loading is low.The direct pyrolysis method is suitable for some materials (such as LiMn 2 O 4 ). 36evertheless, the temperature is limited to 400 °C and the experiment parameter needs to be optimized.The electrochemical deposition method can be used for in situ mass monitoring but is commonly applicable for metallic substances.Vapor deposition has the advantage of high uniformity and precise thickness control but usually requires high-temperature annealing. 46In 2019, the VFT method proposed by Zhang et al., 44 significantly improved the uniformity of porous carbon, manganese dioxide nanoparticles, carbon nanotubes, MXenes, manganese dioxide nanorods and manganese oxide nanosheet films, which is advantageous for more reliable charging mechanism exploration of various electrode materials by EQCM.In the future, this approach may play an important role in the application of EQCM.

Applications of EQCM in supercapacitors
EQCM, owing to the ability to detect ionic behaviors by monitoring the mass changes during charging-discharging progress, has become a key tool for investigating the charging mechanisms of supercapacitors. 17EQCM results show that the pore size, topological structures, surface functional groups of the electrode, and the ionic size and charge number of the electrolytes, have a crucial effect on charging mechanisms. 19,40,47In addition, the combination of EQCM with other in situ characterization techniques has provided a quantitative molecular-level picture of the charge storage process in supercapacitors, significantly elevating our knowledge of the supercapacitor charging mechanisms. 21

Ion transport in supercapacitors
The crucial role of understanding the charging mechanisms for improving the performance of supercapacitors has been widely accepted. 11,17Ion transport plays a vital role in the charging mechanisms.In 2009, Levi et al. 18 first indicated the feasibility of EQCM to probe ion flux in nanopores, finding that porous carbon represents a more noticeable frequency change during charge-discharge progress than non-porous carbon black (Fig. 4a).Based on this landmark work, Levi et al. 47 proposed to detect the charging mechanisms by comparing the experimental slope with the theoretical slope calculated from the Faraday law (assuming that only bare counter-ion adsorption occurs) where k e is the experimental slope, k t is the theoretical slope, ΔΓ is the molar amount of adsorbed/desorbed ions, and Q is the amount of charge passed during charging.Herein, three cases might occur: (1) k e is lower than the k t , indicating that the charge is stored by the exchange of co-ion and counterion; (2) k e is equal to k t , suggesting charge storage by adsorption of rare counter-ion; (3) k e is higher than the k t , indicating charges storage by adsorption of partial or complete solvation counter-ion. 47The EQCM study of Sigalov et al. 40 investigated the charging mechanisms of activated carbon (Kuraray, type YP-17) immersed in 0.025 M CsCl.It was found that the charge was stored through the exchange of co-ion and counter-ion at low charge density, while through the adsorption of counter-ion as the charge density increased (Table 1).When the charge density increased further, some water molecules entered the electrode pores along with the counter-ion, which was the response to the electrode's expansion under highly polarized conditions. 40,48esides electric double-layer capacitors, EQCM is also essential for investigating pseudocapacitors.Combining EQCM with in situ Raman spectroscopy, Zhang et al. 49 discovered that 2D cation-intercalated manganese oxide Na 0.55 Mn 2 O 4 •1.5H 2 O (NMO) mainly displayed surfacecontrolled pseudocapacitance at low charge densities and intercalation pseudocapacitance under high charge density.Similar to these efforts, the key role of charge density in the charging mechanisms was broadly identified. 11,43,50he concentration and ion size of the electrolyte significantly affect the ion transport behavior.As shown in Table 1, in microporous activated carbon (Kuraray, type YP-17), while the concentration of the CsCl aqueous solution increases from 0.025 M to 0.1 M, the increasing ion number enhances co-ion and counter-ion exchange effects, thus leading to an ion exchange over a wider voltage range (Fig. 4b). 40Similarly, the Industrial Chemistry & Materials Mini review effect of electrolyte concentration on the charging mechanism has been concluded in the same electrode with organic electrolyte. 19In addition to the electrolyte concentration, ion sizes are also thought to affect the performance of supercapacitors.Based on conventional electrochemical tests, it has been widely agreed that the capacitance of supercapacitors decreases significantly when the ion size is larger than the pore size, exhibiting an apparent ion-sieving effect. 51,52However, these methods failed to obtain the detail of the charging mechanism of supercapacitors.The advent of EQCM makes it possible to understand ion sieving at a molecular scale.Compared to NH 4 + ions, the ion-exchange region of symmetrical quaternary tetraalkyl ammonium cations [tetramethylammonium (TMA + ), tetraethylammonium (TEA + ), tetrabutylammonium (TBA + )], or the unsymmetrical surfactant cation (tetradecyl)dimethylbenzylammonium (DMBA + ) with a larger size expands to higher charge density in microporous carbon YP-17 (Fig. 4c). 47This effect is ascribed to the larger ion size decreasing desolvation energy, favoring ion exchange. 47onic liquids have been widely used as supercapacitor electrolytes due to their wide electrochemical window, excellent thermal stability, non-volatility, and non-flammability. 53In ionic liquids, the unique property of strong interaction between anions and cations may result in different charging mechanisms.Tsai et al. 50found that in pure 1-ethyl-3methylimidazolium bis(trifluoromethanesulfonyl)imide (EMIM-TFSI) electrolyte, the charge stored in the pores of CDC-1 nm is dominated by counterion (EMIM + ) adsorption at a negative voltage, similar to the permeation selectivity (charging by permselective cation) introduced by Levi et al. 19,20 The charge storage depended on the electrode charge density under a positive voltage.Specifically, ion exchange dominates at low charge densities, implying a failure of permeation selectivity; while recovering as the charge density increase further. 50The above phenomenon indicates that the ionic migration of EMIM + is easier than TFSI − anion.Moreover, the effect of solvent on charging mechanisms in the ionic liquid is investigated. 50,54he difference in charging behavior between the 2 M EMIM-TFSI acetonitrile solution and pure EMIM-TFSI appears under the positive polarization, where permeation selectivity failed even at high charge density (Fig. 4d).This consequence suggests that the cation exchange dominates the charging of CDC-1 nm in the presence of acetonitrile, differing from the behavior of the microporous activated carbon in the propylene carbonate solution. 19he pore size also impacts the charging mechanisms significantly.The charging mechanisms in microporous/ mesoporous carbon have been analyzed, including activated carbons (such as YP-17, YP-50), carbon black, and carbidederived carbons (including TiC-CDC). 19,20,40,50For instance, Tsai et al. 50 electrodes by their high specific surface area, excellent electrical conductivity, good mechanical stability, and flexibility. 55,56Bo et al. 22 used EQCM to study ion transport behaviors of Li 2 SO 4 aqueous electrolytes in disordered porous carbon and graphene films containing adjustable two-dimensional channels.The porous carbon only showed permeation selectivity at high charge density and stored charge by ion exchange at low charge density, similar to previous results. 19,20,40,50In contrast, the mass of the graphene films changes approximately linearly to the stored charge, and the electrode mass decreases under negative voltage, exhibiting a Li + -dominated charging process (Fig. 4e).This difference is linked to the enhanced ions prefilling caused by the ordered two-dimensional structure, negative surface charge, and better wettability of graphene films. 22As another 2D material, MXenes also store charge through ion intercalation.Therefore, understanding the charging mechanism is vital for applying MXenes as supercapacitors electrode materials.However, the role of anions in charge storage and their influence on electrochemical behavior remained unknown until 2021. 41Shpigel et al. 41 found that the mass of MXene electrodes increased when the voltage changed from positive to negative potential (−0.4 V).In comparison, the opposite trend was identified at positive polarization (from −0.4 to 0.5 V) (Fig. 4f).Furthermore, although the masses of Cl − and Br − varied considerably, the mass change during the above processes was similar.These results indicate that the anions are not involved in the electrochemical process.
In addition to anions, cations exhibit unique behavior in waterin-salt electrolytes.Wang et al. 15 noticed that MXenes show a pair of clearly separated battery-type redox peaks in a 19.8 mol kg −1 LiCl electrolyte.The EQCM results demonstrated that the peaks are related to the desolvation-free Li + insertion progress.This anomalous behavior increased in the layer spacing, thus enhancing the charge storage. 15ompared with two-dimensional materials, single-layer graphene (SLG) provides a platform for understanding the ionic adsorption interaction of graphene under polarization. 43,54In EMIM-TFSI ionic liquid, the mass of the Industrial Chemistry & Materials Mini review SLG electrode shows barely change under negative polarization and linearly decreases with a stored charge under positive polarization.Considering the capacitance still presents under negative polarization, the above EQCM results suggest that the charge storage process is dominated by ion rearrangement under a negative voltage and relies on cation desorption under a positive voltage.This behavior is believed to be related to the strong π-π interactions between EMIM + and the graphene surface. 54The work showed the significant effects of electrode-electrolyte interaction.Yin et al. 57 further test carbon material with a more complex three-dimensional porous structure, demonstrating that the local structure of carbon has an important influence on the charging mechanism. 57

Ions desolvation in supercapacitors
In electrolytes with solvent, the ions are surrounded by solvent molecules, called solvated ions.Previous reports have shown that ions can enter nanopores with a size smaller than the solvated ion by desolvating their solvent molecules, leading to influencing the capacitance. 58,59Further studies reported that an anomalous increase in capacitance occurs when the ion size is close to the pore size, showing the significant effect of ion desolvation on the supercapacitor performance. 58ince the desolvation process is accompanied by mass change, EQCM plays a crucial role in the study of ion desolvation.The solvation number mainly characterizes the desolvation of ions.Levi et al. 20,60 calculated the average solvation number of ions by comparing the theoretical slope calculated from Faraday's law with the experimental slope (Fig. 5a), which is given by: 20,60 where a i is the slope of the experimental slope, a F is the slope of the theoretical slope assuming bare ion adsorption, M F is the molar mass of the bare ion, and M w is the molar mass of the solvent molecule.According to this formula, the EQCM data demonstrated that diverse alkali metal cations and halide anions exhibit desolvation in microporous/ mesoporous activated carbons, and the desolvation degree is correlated with ion size and charge number. 20Specifically, the ions with larger charge-to-size ratios (Li + , Mg 2+ , Ca 2+ , Na + , F − ) lose their solvation shell more easily than the ions with smaller charge-to-size ratios (K + , Cs + , Cl − , Br − , I − ), which may be associated with the distinct desolvation energy. 20In addition to the charge-to-size ratio, the solvation number of Li + increased slightly from 2.6 to 3 when the water solvent was replaced by propylene carbonate (Fig. 5a and b), showing a limited influence. 19,20,60Furthermore, when the halide anion (Cl − ) was replaced by SO 4 2− , the solvation number significantly increased from 2.6 to 5.2. 20,22Considering the electrodes in these two works have a similar pore size and structure, 20,22 this apparent difference seems to inspire the crucial role of anion in the desolvation of Li + .However, more work is needed to explain the fundamental principle.
In addition to the electrolyte, the electrode structure also has a crucial effect on ion desolvation.Tsai et al. 50claimed that in 2 M EMIM-TFSI acetonitrile solution, the solvation number of EMIM + decreased from 3.7 to 1.6 when the pore size of the CDC reduced from 1 nm to 0.65 nm (Fig. 4d and  5c). 50Similar to the CDC porous electrode, Bo et al. 22 found that the solvation number decreased under a smaller layer spacing, and the solvation number of Li + in 1 M Li 2 SO 4 aqueous solution at a layer spacing of ∼0.4 nm is 1.4.These results indicated that solvated ions are partially desolvated when entering narrow pores; meanwhile, the narrower pores lead to a higher degree of desolvation.However, other reports gave a different view: Levi et al. 20 showed that in both alkali metal cations and halide anions, BP-880 (containing 16 nm interstitial pores) had a smaller solvation number than the microporous carbon YP-17 (with an average pore size of approximately 1 nm), as summarized in Table 1.This phenomenon is ascribed to the easier replacement of water in BP-880 without confinement conditions. 20Additionally, Srimuk et al. 61 provided a work of sodium desolvation in different materials.Among these, Mo 1 1/3C-MXene showed a nearly ideal pseudocapacitor behavior, and only 10% of the View Article Online initial number of solvent molecules was maintained after cation insertion between the MXene nanolayers.This may be because of the presence of nanoconfined water between the MXene sheets.Moreover, in pseudocapacitive Na 0.44 MnO 2 with a different structure, sodium would lose all water molecules during the insertion process. 61he electrode-electrolyte correlation also needs to be taken into consideration.Recent EQCM measurements demonstrate that the solvation number of EMIM + on the SLG surface in a 2 M EMIMTFSI acetonitrile solution is only 1, much smaller than that (3-4) in porous carbon with a pore size of 1 nm. 54This result is surprising, as there is no confinement effect on the SLG.The phenomenon is related to the strong specificity interaction of the CH-π and π-π between EMIM + and SLG. 54

Combination of EQCM with other experimental/ computational methods
In EQCM experiments, the change of charge and mass can be detected simultaneously.Nevertheless, it is difficult to distinguish the contribution of each electrolyte component since many electrolytes typically contain cations, anions, and solvent molecules.Undeniably, the qualitative results reported to date have significantly promoted our knowledge of the energy storage mechanism within supercapacitors.However, more precise quantitative characterization is necessary for further elucidation.The attempts hitherto to achieve this objective can be divided into two directions: (1) optimizing the analyte itself, such as using ionic liquids containing only two species or selecting the electrode/ electrolyte so that only cation or anion is involved during the charging process (2) combining various experimental or simulation analysis methods, such as the incorporation of EQCM, in situ NMR, and molecular dynamic (MD)/densityfunctional theory (DFT).
Adopting ionic liquid containing only two species is auspicious and convenient for quantitative characterization.However, ionic liquids are not a predominant choice in EQCM reported hitherto, 43,50 which may be related to the technical problems associated with the high viscosity of ionic liquids. 15In addition to the usage of ionic liquids, Dou et al. 62 grafted anion or cation on silica nanoparticles that is significantly larger than the pore size (Fig. 6a).As a result, only ungrafted anion/cation or solvent molecule can enter the pore. 62Regarding the electrode, some materials, like MXenes may only allow cations and solvent molecules to enter the interlayer, thus enabling quantitative characterization of ion transport (Fig. 6b). 41,63Although quantitative characterizations are achievable without reforming the detection equipment, these methods greatly limit our research region, which is harmful to studying energy storage mechanisms in supercapacitors.
A landmark work about the combination of various characterization modalities appeared in 2015.Griffin et al. 21uantitatively characterized the charge storage process of porous carbon at the molecular level by combining in situ NMR and EQCM (Fig. 6c and d).The in situ NMR provides the precise amounts of anions and cations separately that are not available in EQCM measurements.EQCM allows the characterization of solvent molecules which is difficult to measure accurately in in situ NMR due to their fast mobility. 21Afterward, more and more work has focused on combining EQCM with other detection tools. 15,21,41The combination of in situ Raman and EQCM provides an accurate characterization of NMO, showing that the energy storage mechanism is related to the pH of the electrolyte and the degree of polarization. 49In Na 2 SO 4 electrolytes, NMO displays surface pseudocapacitance at low charge density but intercalation pseudocapacitance at high charge density.In contrast, it exhibits a distinct battery-like behavior during the whole operating voltage window in NaOH solutions. 49urthermore, the combination of EQCM and electrochemical dilatometry links the microscopic energy storage mechanism with the macroscopic electrode swelling behavior, showing that charge storage dominated by counter-ion adsorption at high charge density leads to a significant increase in electrode deformation. 48dditionally, the combination of experiments and simulations synergetically provides added value and enhanced understanding.In this respect, the combination of DFT and MD simulation with EQCM has shown great potential.Wang et al. 15 obtained the solvation number of Li + in the interlayer of MXenes by DFT calculations, which strongly supported the EQCM results (Fig. 6e and f).Using MD simulation, Bo et al. 22 discovered that the effective diffusion coefficients of Li + in the graphene channel were significantly higher than that of SO 4 2− when the interlayer spacing was ∼0.4 nm.The apparent difference in diffusion coefficients resulted in a Li + -dominated charge/discharge mechanism, confirmed by the results of EQCM.Furthermore, the results of the MD simulation show that the addition of solvent to the ionic liquid could promote the counter-ion adsorption mechanism on the electrode surface under polarization, which is also in line with the results of the EQCM. 54he above two attempts provide a novel perspective for understanding the energy storage mechanism of supercapacitors.We believe that the combination of EQCM and simulation methods has great potential.Nevertheless, developing a full combination and quantitative comparison of simulation results and experimental EQCM data is required.

Conclusion and outlook
Through monitoring the mass and viscosity variation of electrodes under polarization, EQCM, as one of the advanced in situ inspection techniques, greatly help understand the energy storage mechanism of supercapacitors.Here, we first introduce the development of EQCM and the film coating techniques that have a crucial impact on the measurement results.Then, we summarize the achievements hitherto of the supercapacitor energy storage mechanism study based on EQCM from three aspects: ion transport, ion desolvation, and quantitative characterization.
Although the EQCM technique has acquired immense success, its application in supercapacitors is still limited.The flaws and perspectives are listed as follows: (1) For systems containing three or more species, since only two types of data, mass and charge, are available, the information obtained from EQCM data using the current analysis methods is still qualitative, thus impeding the research of supercapacitors.The current EQCM testing and data analysis methodologies require further innovation to gather additional information.For instance, Zheng et al. 63 used matrix calculations to deconvolute the real-time fluxes and ion currents of various ions from EQCM data, which provides a new idea for the analysis of EQCM data.In addition, the advanced electrogravimetric analysis method, which combines electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) and EQCM, is considered as a powerful tool for evaluating the chemical structure and dynamics of the electrical double layer. 642) The combination of EQCM with other simulation approaches could deliver more molecular-level information.For instance, the ion orientation 43,54 and diffusion coefficients 22 obtained from simulation enable an accurate interpretation of EQCM data.However, a more comprehensive and quantitative combination between experiments and simulations is desired.Among the different simulation methods, MD simulation can capture detailed information on the mass change, ion exchange, and distribution.In-depth integration of EQCM with MD simulation could improve our understanding of the supercapacitor energy storage process considerably.Thus, combining EQCM and MD simulation is an essential development direction.
(3) Although the combination of EQCM with different experimental techniques has obtained remarkable achievements, the various test methods cannot perform in the same system, which may affect the quality of the obtained data.In the future, simultaneous measurements of EQCM with other experimental techniques in the same system will greatly improve the accuracy of experiments.
Niu received his B.S. from Northeastern University in 2018 and M.S. from Huazhong University of Science and Technology in 2020.He is currently a Ph.D. student in Huazhong University of Science and Technology.His research interests lie in conductive MOFs as electrode materials in supercapacitors and electrochemical quartz crystal microbalance.Guang Feng Guang Feng received his Ph.D. in 2010 from Clemson University (USA).From 2010 to 2013, he worked in Vanderbilt University (USA) as a postdoctoral research associate and then a research assistant professor.Since November 2013, he has been a professor in Huazhong University of Science and Technology (China).His research interests are focused on interface and transport phenomena in electrical energy storage and capacitive deionization for desalination.He was selected as a Fellow of the Royal Society of Chemistry in 2019 and now serves as an associate editor of Energy Advances.a State Key Laboratory of Coal Combustion, School of Energy and Power
investigated the effect of electrode pore size by CDC-1 nm and CDC-0.65 nm in 2 M EMIM-TFSI acetonitrile solution.The CDC-0.65 nm electrode displayed negligible mass change under a positive voltage, indicating the inaccessibility of pores for the larger TFSI − anion and the increased mass caused by adsorbed anions outside the pore is balanced by the expelled acetonitrile molecules.Instead, the CDC-1 nm electrode shows an obvious mass change during positive polarization, and the charge is stored by anions and cations exchange.Two-dimensional materials, especially graphene and MXenes, have become a very active direction for supercapacitor 0

Fig. 5
Fig. 5 (a) ΔΓ vs electrode charge (Q) obtained with BP-880 carbon in 0.025 M solutions of alkaline metal chlorides (Copyright 2013 American Chemical Society); 20 (b) amount of cations and anions (ΔΓ) as a function of the charge density (Q) for the different salts dissolved in propylene carbonate (PC).The inset compares the number of solvent molecules (the solid red curve) (Copyright 2010 American Chemical Society); 19 (c) electrode mass change (Δm) vs. charge (Q) (solid blue lines) during the polarization of CDC-0.65 nm in 2 M EMIM-TFSI + ACN.The red dashed lines are the theoretical mass change of neat ions calculated from Faraday's law.The black dashed line shows the linear fitting of measured mass change (Copyright 2014 American Chemical Society).50