Calcium-stabilised transition metal bis(formyl) complexes: structure and bonding †

Reaction of a molecular calcium hydride with a series of group 9 dicarbonyl complexes [M(η5-C5Me5)(CO)2] (M = Co, Rh, Ir) led to the formation of both mono(formyl) and bis(formyl) complexes. The bis(formyl) complexes are unique. They have been characterised by multinuclear NMR spectroscopy and examples have been crystallographically characterised for the first time.

Metal bis(formyl) complexes are exceedingly rare.3][4] This species was reported to decompose over two hours at room temperature. 21][12][13][14][15][16][17][18][19][20][21][22][23] For example, II was shown to evolve into a C-C coupled product, which may derive from an intramolecular reaction of the ligands. 24Similarly, based on Density Functional Theory (DFT) calculations, III, a bimetallic calcium complex with formyl ligands bridging two calcium sites, has been proposed as an intermediate in ethene diolate formation from reaction of [Ca(m-H)(Me 4 TACD)] 2 [BAr 4 ] 2 ] with CO (Me 4 TACD = 1,4,7,10-tetramethyl-1,4,7,10-tetraazacyclododecane; Ar = 3,5-Me 2 C 6 H 3 ). 25We recently reported the reactions of a molecular magnesium hydride with a range of metal carbonyl complexes (Cr, Mn, Fe, Co, Rh, Ir), giving a series of mono(formyl) complexes. 20rein we describe the reactions of a molecular calcium hydride (1) 26,27 with a series of Group 9 carbonyl complexes [M(Z 5 -C 5 Me 5 )(CO) 2 ] (M = Co, Rh, Ir). 28By altering the reaction conditions both mono(formyl) (2) and bis(formyl) (3) heterometallic complexes could be generated.These new species have been characterised by standard spectroscopic techniques and their electronic structure investigated using DFT methods.The reaction of 1 with [M(Z 5 -C 5 Me 5 )(CO) 2 ] (M = Co, Rh, Ir) in C 6 D 6 solution led to the formation of two products 2-M and 3-M (Scheme 1).Taking M = Co as an example, 2-Co and 3-Co were formed in a 3 : 2 ratio after one hour at 25 1C.Repeating the reaction using 1ÁTHF in place of 1 improved selectivity for 2-Co.Ultimately allowing its isolation in 72% from recrystallisation from n-hexane solution.Isolated samples of 2-Co are remarkably stable and C 6 D 6 solutions can be heated to 60 1C for a week with little or no loss of the mono(formyl) complex.Nevertheless, re-exposing 2-Co to the reaction conditions does not lead to clean formation of 3-Co.The formation of mono(formyl) and bis(formyl) complexes is presumed to occur by stepwise hydrometallation of the carbonyl ligands.DFT calculations are consistent with these steps being exergonic.
Similar reactions between 1ÁTHF and [Rh(Z 5 -C 5 Me 5 )(CO) 2 ] or [Ir(Z 5 -C 5 Me 5 )(CO) 2 ] led to formation of 2-Rh-THF and 2-Ir-THF respectively. 1H NMR spectroscopic data supports the retention of a single equivalent of THF in the complex, likely bound to one of the calcium centres.Bis(formyl) complexes 3-Rh and 3-Ir were again observed as side-products in these reactions.These species are less stable than 3-Co and could not be easily separated from unreacted starting material and by-products.Nevertheless, for M = Rh and Ir, crystals of 3-Rh and 3-Ir formed on multiple occasions, allowing unambiguous confirmation of the bis(formyl) complex as the minor product (Fig. In the solid-state, 2-Co comprises a near planar tetrametallic array comprised of two Co and two Ca sites bridged by formyl and carbonyl ligands (Fig. 2).The calcium centres are fivecoordinate with approximate trigonal bipyramidal geometry.The formyl ligands are located between the two calcium atoms and adopt an anti-configuration.It is likely that this parent structure is retained in solution.The observation of a single set of b-diketiminate ligand and formyl resonances for 2-Co, 2-Rh-THF and 2-Ir-THF would be consistent with retention of a time-average highly symmetric tetrametallic structure in which two halves of the molecule are related by an inversion symmetry element.An alternate plausible structure for 2-Rh-THF and 2-Ir-THF could be the monomeric THF adducts.
3-Ir crystallises in the P21/n space group.This is the first structurally characterised bis(formyl) complex reported.The formyl ligands are mutually cis-at the iridium centre.Each oxygen atom is bridged by two calcium centres, manifesting a Ca 2 O 2 four membered ring.In contrast to 2-Co where the bridging formyl groups adopt a k 1 coordination to each metal  The electronic structures of 3-Co, 3-Rh and 3-Ir were investigated by computational methods.Geometry optimisations were performed with DFT using the oB97X-D 29 functional and a hybrid basis set.Natural Bond Orbital (NBO), 30 Extended Transition State-Natural Orbital Chemical Valence (ETS-NOCV), 31 Quantum Theory of Atoms In Molecules (QTAIM) 32 and Non-Covalent Interactions (NCI) 33 calculations were performed.
NBO calculations revealed a consistent set of highly ionic structures, which can be best formalised as [M(Z 5 -C 5 Me 5 ) (CHO) 2 ] 2À dianions coordinated to cationic calcium fragments.Hence, across the series, NPA charges on calcium are high and positive (+1.80 to +1.81), while those on carbon are close to neutral (À0.03 to À0.07).Most of the charge resides on the oxygen atoms (À0.93 to À0.94).The Wiberg Bond Indices (WBI) for the M-C bonds increase down the group taking values of 0.95 o 0.97 o 1.08 for Co o Rh o Ir.The WBIs for the CQO bonds are consistent between 1.27 and 1.31 with no discernible trends down the triad.The M-C values above 1 and CQO values significantly below 2 are consistent with the formyl ligand adopting metallocarbene character.For comparison, the free dianionic complexes [M(Z 5 -C 5 Me 5 )(CHO) 2 ] 2À (3 0 -M) were calculated.For 3 0 -M, NPA charges on carbon (0.17 to 022) and oxygen (-0.74 to -0.76) were more positive than in 3 but followed the same general trends.The close agreement of NBO data between 3 and 3 0 is consistent with the proposed ionic bonding situation (Fig. 3).
QTAIM calculations further support this bonding formulation.For 3-Ir, bond paths are identified between each calcium and oxygen atom of the bridging motif.Bond critical points show r(r) and r 2 r(r) values of 0.04 e Bohr À3 and 0.19-0.22 e Bohr À5 respectively, consistent with binding of the formyl ligand to calcium being primarily through electrostatic interactions.
ETS-NOCV calculations were performed on 3-Co, 3-Rh and 3-Ir to investigate the interaction of the formyl moiety with the transition metal centre. 34As described previously by us in a related system, 20 the principal contribution (Dr 1 ) to the bonding is the s-donation of the HOMO of the {CHO} À ligand to a transition-metal d-orbital (66 to 75% of DE ORB ).The secondary (Dr 2 ) and tertiary (Dr 3 ) interactions involve p back-donation from a metal-based orbital to the orthogonal p*-orbitals of the {CHO} À ligand and are largely negligible in comparison to Dr 1 (9 to 12% of DE ORB ).
Considering a simplified molecular orbital picture of selected donor-acceptor interactions, it becomes clear that both formyl ligands of 3 should be interacting with the same metal d-orbitals (Fig. 4).A consequence of this effect is apparent on comparing the electronic structures of 3 with the monomeric unit of 2, labelled 2 0 .The carbonyl ligand is expected to be a better p-acceptor than the formyl and compete for electron-density from the d-orbitals.As such, the backdonation component of the bonding to the mono(formyl) ligand of 2 0 is expected to be weaker than that to bis(formyl) ligands of 3. The impact of the competition for electron density is apparent in the M-C WBIs to the formyl group which take values of 0.81-0.97 in 2 0 but 0.94-1.08 in 3. The calculations are consistent with a degree of electronic communication between the two {CHO} À fragments when coordinated to [M(Z 5 -C 5 Me 5 )].
The series of bis(formyl) complexes 3-Co, 3-Rh, and 3-Ir are potentially relevant intermediates in carbon-carbon bond formation from CO and hydride ligands.Based on DFT calculations, III has previously been proposed as a potential intermediate in ethene diolate formation through coupling of the two formyl groups bridging the calcium site. 25Monitoring solutions containing 3-Co, 3-Rh, or 3-Ir for extended periods provided no evidence for carbon-carbon bond formation.Likewise, exposing a sample of 2-Co to an atmosphere of CO Fig. 3 Selected NBO data comparing 3, to the parent dianions 3 0 , and monomeric unit of 2 i.e. 2 0 .Wiberg Bond Indices are listed in italics for each bond with descending list going down the triad Co, Rh, Ir.NPA charges are listed in bold as a range for each atomic position for the whole series of group 9 complexes.resulted in decomposition products only.Given that calcium bis(formyl) complexes have previously been proposed as intermediates in ethene diolate formation, the isolation and apparent stability of 3 toward carbon-carbon bond formation is notable.We thank Imperial College London for the award of a Schro ¨dinger's Scholarship (JMP).Pete Haycock is thanked for assistance with NMR measurements.The EPSRC is thanked for funding (EP/S036628/1).

Fig. 1
Fig. 1 Reported metal bis(formyl) complexes and their proposed role in C-C bond formation.