Application of double-pulse laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy (DP-LIBS), Fourier transform infrared micro-spectroscopy and Raman microscopy for the characterization of copper-sulfides

The combined application of the structure sensitive techniques Fourier transform infrared μ-spectroscopy and Raman microscopy in conjunction with different approaches of laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy (LIBS) including the two-color double pulse (DP-LIBS) have been applied towards the characterization of whole ore copper-sulfide minerals. Discrete information from the surface of the whole ore minerals that lead to the establishment of infrared marker bands and from the surface of bioleached samples that allow the monitoring of jarosite and biofilm formation are provided by FTIR mapping experiments. Raman data can provide information related to the type of the mineral and of the secondary minerals formed on the surface of the ore. Of the four different LIBS approaches applied towards the characterization of the composition of the whole ore minerals, the DP-LIBS shows the highest sensitivity with increasing signals for both the Fe and Cu metals in the whole ore samples.


Introduction
The mineralogy, mineral chemistry, geological occurrences, and mineral processing techniques of sulde minerals have been well investigated and applied because of their economical and environmentally safe signicance. 1-49 There is consensus, that applications of advanced spectroscopic techniques are necessary for the characterization of minerals from whole ores. 3,4,47 In the eld of bio-hydrometallurgy the determination of the chemical and structural properties of minerals prior to microorganism-mineral interactions is the determinant factor towards the successful metal(s) extraction. 3,4 The technique it is simple and has been successfully applied for Cu extraction from sulde minerals. 1-4 Novel techniques have been employed to monitor metal extraction from low-grade sulde ores and for probing the bacterial activities of acidophilic iron-and sulfuroxidizing microorganisms towards elimination of Fe 3+ hydroxysulfates such as jarosite. [13][14][15][16][17][18][19][20][21][22][23][24][25][26][27][28][29][30] A great number of studies have agreed in that jarosite precipitation is linked to the passivation of chalcopyrite. There is consensus that the mechanisms involved in biohydrometallurgy require substantial further research and thus, new methods towards the fast and accurate identication of the metal content of whole ore minerals and the mechanisms involved in their extraction should be further explored. Laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy (LIBS), Raman and FTIR techniques are attractive tools in the areas of environmental monitoring, geology and in the eld of mining. In the mining industry all three techniques have been applied in order to develop sensing technologies that can be used as robust and rugged tools for the positive identication of heavy metals in real-time and because they are cost effective and easier for application (Fig. 1).
The ( Cu 2 S(s) + Fe 2 (SO 4 ) 3 (aq) / 2CuSO 4 (aq) + S(s) + 4FeSO 4 (aq)(2) CuFeS 2 (s) + Fe 2 (SO 4 ) 3 (aq) / CuSO 4 (aq) + 2S(s) + 5FeSO 4 (aq) The passivation of chalcopyrite [CuFeS 2 ] is a major problem that reduces the yields from leaching and bioleaching. Passivation involves the formation of a layer of secondary minerals on minerals surface which creates a diffusion barrier to uxes of reactants and products. We have presented Raman and FTIR evidence toward identication of secondary minerals formed during the passivation of Cu sulde minerals in the presence of iron and sulphur-oxidizing bacteria isolated from the mines of HCM. 3,4,47 The major detectable species in the passivation layer are CuS and elemental sulphur-S 0 . In addition, the surface dynamics of the formation of micro-macro-colonies with variable cell density and the formation of extracellular polymeric substances toward the elucidation of the sulfur bio-oxidation and biolm format has been reported. The Raman and FTIR data indicated the S n 2À /S 0 consumption modication during biolm evolution. This way, the role of the cell density in the primary events with the presence of S 0 was determined and whether the presence of refractory sulfur species on the surface of the mineral affects biolm formation. The constituents of EPS of the biolms was also evaluated. Essential elucidation of the mineralogy of [CuFeS 2 ] and its transformation is necessary to understand the mechanism of passivation. The main objective of our research has been the characterization of the mineral phases generated in the bioleaching processes and gain insights in transformation processes of these phases, as a support to understand its inuence on the passivation of the process.
FTIR spectroscopy is an analytical spectroscopic method for studying subtle changes in secondary structure of proteins as it allows the analysis of chemical bonds. 3,4,47,[50][51][52][53] Monitoring the conformations changes of protein structures may originate from interactions with other biomaterials or inorganic matter. Such interactions are of high relevance in various physiological cellular processes such as cellular attachment in sulde mineral surfaces during bioleaching processing. 47 Laser Raman micro spectroscopy has been applied as a technique for the characterization of biomaterials and secondary minerals formed during the chalcopyrite leaching. [54][55][56] This way, distinct information from a large sample area of a heterogeneous sample is feasible. We have recently applied these microspectroscopic approaches for probing the formation of secondary minerals from the surface of bioleached Cu-containing minerals and also establish the vibrational marker bands for monitoring the formation of different types of jarosite and of EPS.
LIBS has the capability of rapid and in situ analysis with no sample preparation required which allows measurements in the laboratory and in the eld including studies in geological areas. [57][58][59][60][61][62] The specic application of concurrent time resolved LIBS-Raman for monitoring the origin of mining tailings provide a new state-of-the-art approach in the eld. This is important at both the level of the industrial heap bioleaching process, and more generally for the scientic community because the time-resolved approach increases the limit of detection. This is a novel approach in heap bioleaching and although it has been used by scientists in other eld of biotechnology in the copper bioleaching process has not been applied, yet. LIBS employs a high-power laser beam focused onto a sample to create a plasma. A short duration laser pulse strikes the sample increasing the temperature of the sample causing the matter in the spark to be vaporized, reduced to its atomic species, and then electronically excited. Emission lines at discrete wavelengths that characterize the elements present are then resolved spectrally and temporally with a spectrometer covering part or all of the ultraviolet through near infrared range. Each element emits at different wavelengths and therefore the elements contained within a material can be characterized from the spectral peaks present. The peak intensities provide a quantitative description of the material.
The combination of LIBS-Raman and FTIR mapping techniques provides signicant advantage in monitoring chemicalprocesses and composition because the molecular information is added to the atomic data and a more complete description is available. LIBS is more sensitive in the detection of metal elements than nonmetals. The Raman bands of some materials have well known characterized vibrational bands which can specically identify the molecular composition or their crystals and crystal form. No reports with respect the applicability of all three techniques in the eld of bio-hydrometallurgy are available. In this short review, we have extended our time-resolved vibrational approach of Raman and step-scan FTIR on biomolecules and present new results based on different approaches of LIBS to demonstrate the importance of the techniques towards our understanding the bio-hydrometallurgy dynamics of whole ore sulde minerals.

Bioleaching experiments
Samples of copper sulde minerals were collected from the mines of HCM in Skouriotissa, Cyprus, and for the bioleaching experiments the samples were placed in test tubes with the corresponding growth medium and a proper inoculation of cell suspensions of Acidithiobacillus ferrooxidans (DSM 14882) and Erythrobacter Longus (DSM 6997). The bacteria were purchase from Deutsche Sammlung von Mikroorganismen und Zellkulturem (DSMZ). The bacteria were cultured in Difco marine broth 2216 medium at 28 C. Bio-interaction experiments in the tubes were carried out under aseptic conditions in a water bath at 37 C using recirculating solutions. The test tubes were tted with rubber stoppers and the suspension (growth medium and cells) was recirculated by a pump from Cole-Parmer through inlet/outlet tubes. The test tubes were placed in a custom-made plexiglass apparatus of 60 positions. 3,4

FTIR microspectroscopy
Fourier transform infrared microspectroscopy (m-FTIR) was applied at dened time intervals to monitor the conformational changes in amide I during the biolm formation and jarosite formation on the copper sulde ores. Spectra were collected with a Tensor 27 Fourier transform infrared spectrometer and a coupled HYPE-RION 2000 microscope. The microscope was equipped with a liquid nitrogen cooled HgCdTe (MCT) detector and a motorized xy sample stage. Spectra acquisitions were obtained at a resolution of 4 cm À1 over the spectral range 7500-600 cm À1 using a co-addition of 32 scans and a dened optical eld of 100 Â 100 mm by glass slide. Spectra were recorded in reectance mode using a 15Â or 36Â IR objective and processed through Opus 7.0 (Bruker) and OriginPro 9.0 sowares. Attenuated total reection was used to obtain infrared spectra of extracellular polymeric substances in lm form. Spectra were collected using an ATR-Germanium plate (Pike Technologies) and the FTIR Tensor 27 (Bruker) spectrometer equipped with a deuterated triglyceride sulfate (DTGS) detector. The spectra were collected in the 900-4000 cm À1 spectral range with a resolution of 4 cm À1 and 100 co-exposures. Prior to each sample measurement, a back-ground spectrum was collected. The OPUS 7/IR (Bruker) soware package was used to acquire and process the FTIR spectra. Fig. 2 depicts the sample stage used for the experiments of the whole ore copper sulde minerals.

Raman microspectroscopy
Raman data were collected by a LabRAM from HORIBA Jobin Yvon equipped with a CCD detector. It is equipped with an Olympus BX41 microscope 50X. The 442 nm excitation laser beam was provided by a Helium-Cadmium laser. The laser power incident on the sample was 20 mW and the accumulation time 15-20 min for each spectrum. Fig. 3 shows the experimental set-up for the time-resolved LIBS that can be used as a single pulse (1064 or 532 nm), dual pulse (collinear 1064 and 532 nm) and in a time-resolved approach. The present study investigates the single and the collinear twocolor double-pulse LIBS (DP-LIBS) conguration using 1064 nm from a Quantel Brilliant nanosecond laser (7 ns pulse) operating at 10 Hz or 50 Hz and the 532 nm pulse from a Minilite Continuum laser (7 ns pulse) operating at 1-15 Hz. For dual pulse experiments a delay generator (Stanford Instruments Model DG535) will control the triggering and timing of the lasers. We will utilize the double pulse technique with delay time t d ¼ 1.5 ns which is ideal to detect and visualize the distribution of the desired chemical element on the sample surface. The LIBS laser beam that was used for the experiments reported in this paper was the Brilliant from Quantel at a wavelength of 1064 nm. Every spectrum was taken with pulsed energy of 30 mJ at a repetition rate of 10 Hz. The internal delay time was 2.51 ms and the integration time 0.030 ms. In addition, the Minilite laser was used from continuum at a wavelength of 532 nm and at a rep rate of either 1 Hz or 10 Hz and pulsed energy of 8 mJ. A spectrometer from applied photonics was used to analyze plasma emission.

Results and discussion
We have performed Raman, FTIR and LIBS on different types of whole ore copper sulde minerals. Raman spectroscopy is a powerful structure sensitive technique for identifying species on the surfaces of the whole copper sulde minerals. A number of sulphides exist in the Cu/Fe/S system that contain S-S bonds including pyrite, FeS 2 which displays a S-S stretching vibration at 380 cm À1 and is signicantly different from that present in the Cu/Fe/S system that contain S-S bonds and has been observed at 464-467 cm À1 . [34][35][36][37][38][39][40][41][42][43][44][45][46][47] Thus, CuS can be distinguished from other phases that contain S-S bonds, and the position of the S-S stretch provides information on the Fe content of the phase. Elemental sulphur and polysuldes also contain S-S linkages and display sharp S-S stretch bands in the Raman  spectra at 470 cm À1 . This band overlaps with that from CuS and bornite [Cu 5 FeS 4 ] bornite when both species are present on the same region of the surface. Obviously, covellite and bornite cannot be distinguished from sulphur from this band alone. Sulphur also displays an equally strong band from S-S-S chain bending at 215 cm À1 which is not found in covellite and the ratio of the intensities of the two bands can potentially be used to distinguish the two phases.
The Raman spectrum of chalcopyrite is characterized by a weak band at 293 cm À1 which has been assigned to the symmetric anion A1 mode. 21,22 The v(Cu-S) stretching vibration in the Cu/Fe/S systems, bornite, chalcocite and covellite is located in the 470-474 cm À1 . Therefore, it is difficult to distinguish bornite, chalcocite and covellite based on the v(Cu-S). However, there are easily distinguishable by colour. The v(Cu-S) of Cu 2 S which belongs to a Cu/S system is observed at 470 cm À1 providing new information on the iron content in the Cu/Fe/S system. The v(Cu-S) of chalcocite was recently reported for the rst time. 4 It was previously reported that CuS 2 has no Raman peaks between 200 and 500 cm À1 and thus its formation was suggested without providing evidence for its formation. 21,22 The Raman peak at 474 cm À1 is the v(Cu-S), in agreement with previous results. 21,22 The Raman spectra including the images can provide the necessary information for characterization of surface species/phases and spatial variations in composition of the bioleaching of chalcopyrite. Furthermore, information regarding the formation of the passivation layers in all of the above mentioned Cu/Fe/S and Cu/S systems is feasible. Fig. 4 spectra A-B depicts the 442 nm excitation Raman spectra of quartz (spectrum A), and bornite (spectrum) and in the inset the FTIR spectra of chalcopyrite (spectrum A) and idaite (spectrum B). The image of the sample (spectrum A) has some colourcharacteristics of that of either covellite and or chalcocite. However, the Raman spectrum shows an intense band at 464 cm À1 (A1 mode) and a moderate at 206 cm À1 which both have been reported to originate from quartz. Spectrum B is similar to that we have reported. 3,4 As observed in the inset spectrum A, which corresponds to chalcopyrite, the stronger signals could correspond to ferric sulfate at 1064 cm À1 , and hydrated ferrous sulfate and copper sulfate at 968 cm À1 , ferrous sulfate and hydrated ferric sulfate (1185 cm À1 ). The broad band at 1636 cm À1 is due to H-O-H. Spectrum B which corresponds to idaite has characteristic bands of 977 cm À1 due to hydrated ferrous sulfate and copper sulfate at 968 cm À1 and at 1048 cm À1 due to ferric sulfates. For the FeS 2 samples, the main peaks correspond to hydroxyl ferric sulfate (1230 cm À1 ), ferric sulfate (1176 cm À1 ), ferric sulfate cluster (1140 cm À1 ), ferrous sulfate (1089 cm À1 ) and hydrated ferric sulfate (1020 cm À1 ). Nonhydrated ferric sulfates possess strong vibrations in the 1200 cm À1 range, and, as observed in Fig. 6, there is almost no existence of these vibrations in the case of idaite but in the case of chalcopyrite there is a band at 1185 cm À1 . Fig. 5 shows the Raman and FTIR spectrum of bornite [Cu 5 FeS 4 ] in a period of ten months of bioleaching by A. Ferrooxidans. In a recent paper the detailed analysis and assignment of all the vibrations present in the Raman and FTIR data Fig. 4 442 nm Raman spectra of quartz (spectrum A) and bornite Cu 5 FeS 4 (spectrum B). Ex-perimental conditions are the same as previously reported (3,4). The inset shows the FTIR spectra of (A) chalcopyrite (B) idaite. ) vibration which is located observed at 1100 cm À1 in the spectra of K + -jarosite and at 1091 cm À1 in the spectrum of NH 4 + -jarosite 3 and the band at 474 cm À1 was assigned to n(Cu-S) of covellite. 47 Elemental sulphur and polysuldes contain S-S linkages and display the n(S-S) and d(S-S-S) which are characterized by equally strong intensities at 470 at 215 cm À1 , respectively. The intensity of the n(S-S)/d(S-S-S) ratio at 470/215 ¼ 1 has been applied used to distinguish the elemental sulphur from the other S-S and Cu-S bond containing species. 3,4 In addition, all bands attributed to K + -jarosite including the n(Fe-O) at 429 cm À1 are present. 47 In the FTIR spectra shown in Fig. 5B all the characteristic bands were assigned to amide I (1645 cm À1 ), to biolm formation (978-1134 cm À1 ) and near 1700 cm À1 to the v(C]O) vibration of the O-acetyl ester bond of free EPS. The bands at 978, 1021 and 1051 cm À1 are due to carbohydrates and at 1134 cm À1 due to P]O and the band at 1171 cm À1 was attributed to Fe-O-P bonds. 47 Potassium Jarosite [KFe 3 (SO 4 ) 2 (OH) 6 ] is common in acidic and sulfate-rich environments. Jarosite typically is formed in ferric rich, acidic (pH < 3) oxic environments and readily breaks down when removed from its stability region by presumably converting to iron(III) oxide or oxyhydroxide phases. K + -jarosite converts to goethite through the following reaction 43 KFe 3 (SO 4 ) 2 (OH) 6 (s) 4 3FeO(OH)Geothite + K + (aq) + 2SO 4 2À (aq) + 3H + (aq) However, the mechanisms of this reaction, and the specic products formed have not been studied in detail. This knowledge is of profound importance in predicting geochemical reactions in metallurgical environments. Monitoring the fate of K, SO 4 2À and Fe during K-jarosite dissolution will aid in describing the geochemical cycling of these element in ARD/ AMD systems. Jarosite which is formed subsequently to the formation of goethite has a low solubility and high stability (K sp ¼ 10 À11 and G 0 f ¼ À3309.8 kJ mol À1 ). The formation of jarosite is also related to the redox potential of the solution. Redox potential higher than 400 mV favour Fe 3+ precipitation. It has been demonstrated that Acidithiobacillus ferrooxidans is forming jarosite group minerals de-pending on the temperature, pH, aging time and dissolved oxygen (OD) levels. 10 Electron scanning microscopy (SEM) images of unleached and leached chalcopyrite have been reported but it is difficult to differentiate K + -from NH 4 + -jarosite because jarosite morphology depends on the experimental conditions and the shape which is round for K + -jarosite and cubic for the NH 4 + jarosite and size cannot be used as a tool. On the same line are the X-ray diffraction patterns which are difficult to differentiate on the basis of d-spacing. The formation of K + and NH 4 + -jarosite has been observed in 35-100 mm size grains of high-grade chalcopyrite aer bioleaching in laboratory studies but never observed in natural ore samples under experimental conditions that mimic chalcopyrite heap bioleaching processes at 35 C. In addition, the communities of microorganisms (biolms) which are embedded in a hydrogen-like matrix formed by EPS on chalcopyrite surfaces during the bioleaching process contributing in the biosynthesis of jarosite have not been reported yet. An overall equation for the dihydroxylation, dehydration and deammoniation of NH 4 + -jarosite in the 300-400 C range is given by 2NH 4 Fe 3 (SO 4 ) 2 (OH) 6 / 7H 2 O + 2NH 3 + 2Fe 3 O 2.5 (SO 4 ) 2 (5) Fig. 6 shows the FTIR spectra and images of a bioleached area of covellite with A. ferroxidans in a two month period. The bottom spectrum is that of the rst month with characteristic bands due to v 1 and v 3 of (SO 4 ). In a time-period of two months the top spectrum shows variation in the frequencies of v 1 and v 3 demonstrating the real time changes that take time on the surface of the bioleached ore. Comparison of the images also suggest the formation of biolm on the surface. This way we can monitor the kinetics of biolm formation and gain knowledge of the dynamics of the surface proper-ties in the presence of microorganisms and also the time period the microorganisms are active on the surface of the ore. A detailed description of the kinetics involved in the formation of biolm and jarosite is described in references.
Although sulde minerals are important sources of metals, they are potential sources of pollution. The release of sulfur through the weathering of suldes in natural rocks or in mine wastes generates sulfuric acid, resulting in acid rock drainage or acid mine drainage (AMD). Sulfurous fumes are produced by smelting sulde ores which react to form acid rain. Metal suldes are very important in Marine geosciences. Therefore, it is intriguing to gain knowledge on the interactions of the most abundant sulde mineral, FeS 2 with anaerobic marine phototrophic microorganisms. Several theories have been developed following the discoveries of ocean-oor hydrothermal systems Fig. 6 The FTIR and the 100 Â 100 mm FTIR spectra of chalcopyrite which showed changes of the ore over a six-month bioleached time period have been reported by our group.
generating large volumes of sulde minerals and associated with novel life forms and ecosystems. Fig. 7 shows the Raman and FTIR spectrum of whole ore mineral containing FeS 2 in a period of one week of interaction(s) with Erythrobacter Longus. In panel A, the in-tense Raman bands at 344 and 380 and 430 cm À1 originate from FeS 2 . More specically, the 380 cm À1 band originates from the Ag in plane stretch S-S, the 344 cm À1 from the S-S out of phase E g mode and the 430 which has been assigned to T g coupled libration and stretch mode. The full agreement of the Raman bands of the whole ore FeS 2 with those reports from pure FeS 2 samples demonstrates the reliability of the Raman spectroscopy in the characterization of whole ore minerals.
In Fig. 7, panel B, The FTIR spectrum of E. Longus (spectrum A) and the 50 Â 50 mm FTIR imaging spectrum of E. Longus over the one week period of interaction with the FeS 2 surface (spectrum B). The FTIR spectrum of E. Longus is characteristic of the bands at 1639 and 1554 cm À1 which are assign to the amide I and amide II, respectively. There are additional bands in the 1420 and 1100 cm À1 range due to NH 4 + and carbohydrates, respectively. The well separated bands at 978, 1021 and 1051 cm À1 are due to carbohydrates and at 1134 cm À1 due to P]O. In spectrum B the appearance of band in the 970-1070 cm À1 indicates the presence of EPS biolm formation. In addition, the am-ide II vibration has lost its intensity and the amide I vibration is up-shied by 13 cm À1 indicating that the proteins of the EPS-FeS 2 complex are involved in the EPS adsorption on FeS 2 . LIBS is a relatively simple spectroscopic technique with various advantages that has been applied in a number of experiments and provide sustained, in situ, elemental detection in real time. [57][58][59][60][61][62] In addition of having the ability to rapidly analyse the elemental composition of solids, liquids, and gases with little or no sample preparation, LIBS is one of the few techniques capable of non-contact and remote elemental analysis, making it particularly useful for analyses in extreme and hostile environments. The application of single pulse LIBS and development of dual-pulse LIBS (DP-LIBS) and resonanceenhanced LIBS for decreasing the limit of detection and improving reproducibility of LIBS in agricultural soil and  nutrients has been applied towards establishing new methods for improving the detection limit. 61,62 Fig. 8 shows large enhancement in LIBS signals for 532-1064 nm combination in collinear arrangement. For all the comparisons the 1064 nm pulse energy and the in-ternal gate delay kept constant. The spot size for the 1064 nm was approximately 120 micrometers while for the 532 nm was 0.5 mm. The time-delay between the two laser pulses was approximately t d ¼ 1-2 ns. It can be clearly seen that there is enhancement in signal intensity for the collinear DP-LIBS. For all measurements a xed gate delay and t d was used. It remains to be established whether the intensity signals depend on the gate delay and t d . Several mechanisms have been reported suggesting that the increase is due to either the increase in mass ablation or reheating of the plasma plume. The mass ablation rate depends on the wavelength because the shorter wavelength provides stronger laser-target coupling due to higher critical density (n c a1/l À2 ).
We have extended the single and DP-LIBS approaches and applied two additional LIBS methods using the same experimental set-up. In the third approach we have used the 532 nm pulse as a pre-pulse to generate the plasma prior to the use of the 1064 nm pulse for recording the LIBS and in the fourth approach in a similar conguration but using the 1064 nm for the pre-pulse and subsequently the 1064 nm for recording the LIBS. We have applied the four-way approach to Cu/Fe/S containing ores including chalcopyrite and idaite whole ore samples. There is a sequential signal increase in going from the single pulse (1064 nm, black line) to prepulse-LIBS (532-1064 nm, red line) to prepulse-LIBS(1064-1064 nm, blue line) and nally to collinear DP (532-1064 nm, orange line) (Fig. 9).
It is shown that this approach can achieve typical double pulse improvement in the analytical performances for elemental analysis chalcopyrite containing ores. The results show a signicant increase of the intensity and repeatability of the emission signals in the double pulse conguration of both Fe and Cu contents in the chalcopyrite ore. The improvement resulting from the use of DP-LIBS was about 100% when compared to SP-LIBS in all cases. These results are useful in the context of studies investigating how the m-LIBS will assist in the development of portable LIBS systems and improve the utility of this spectroscopy technique for eld applications. 63-68

Conclusions
The combination of LIBS with m-FTIR and m-Raman provides a unique opportunity to probe the content of whole ore minerals, to characterize the minerals and their interactions with microorganisms. The FTIR mapping experiments provide information related to the adsorption induced variation on the bioleached ores. The present work extends our previous investigations of the Cu/Fe/S containing minerals and indicate that similar approaches are feasible for any type of metal containing minerals. It should be noted that the application of single LIBS it is much easier than the DP-LIBS and it is not absolutely necessary to double the signal intensity to identify the minerals.
Time-resolved Raman and TR-FTIR spectroscopies have been applied extensively in the past for the investigation of biochemical mechanisms of nitric oxide and dioxygen respiration by cytochrome oxidases, nitric oxide reductases and the interactions of microorganisms with surfaces and metals in our laboratory. [22][23][24][25][26][27][28][29][30][31][32][33][34][35][69][70][71] The present work extends our previous investigation and the detailed analysis of the data obtained with all three techniques demonstrates the necessity for their concurrent ap-plication towards the elucidation of complex systems such whole ore minerals.

Conflicts of interest
There are no conicts to declare.