Magnetic phase transition from paramagnetic in Nb2AlC-MAX to superconductivity-like diamagnetic in Nb2C-MXene: an experimental and computational analysis

Transition metal carbides (TMCs) have recently emerged as competent members among the family of two-dimensional (2D) materials, owing to their promising applications. There are many promising applications of MXenes; however, their magnetic properties lack a wide margin, both experimentally as well as theoretically, which needs to be investigated for potential use in spintronics. In this study, we carried out a comprehensive etching process via selective extraction of Al layers from Nb2AlC-MAX using a wet electrochemical route under well-optimized conditions to obtain fine 2D-Nb2C MXene sheets. Structural analysis using X-ray diffraction (XRD) confirms the effective removal of Al followed by confirmation of a 2D layered structure from morphological analysis using scanning electron microscopy (SEM). Zero-field-cooled (ZFC) and field-cooled (FC) measurements of MAX and MXene at different field strengths were performed using a superconducting quantum interference device (SQUID). Magnetic measurements reveal the paramagnetic nature of Nb2AlC-MAX measured under 5 mT; however, this changes to a clear superconductor-like diamagnetic behavior with a shift of the magnetization from positive to negative values at low temperatures when measured under 5 mT and 10 mT for Nb2C MXene. The diamagnetism, however, is changed to paramagnetism at 100 mT, which shows the existence of critical fields known typically for a type-II superconductor. To gain an insight into this unusual behavior in MXene, density functional theory (DFT) first-principles calculation was also performed in Wein2K software using spin-polarized generalized gradient approximation (sp-GGA). The magnetic moment of the compound is calculated to be negative, which corresponds well with the experimental finding and suggests that the negative magnetic moment originated from the d-orbital of Nb2C. The present report provides a pathway to deeply understanding the existence of superconductivity-like diamagnetic behavior in Nb2C MXene, which is useful for future magnetic applications.

In two-dimensional (2D) materials, magnetism at the nanoscale is at the forefront of many cutting-edge technological applications, such as spintronic devices. Naguib et al. have synthesized a new class of two-dimensional materials, known as MXenes (M n X n+1 ), discovered in 2011, giving a possibility of magnetism in such 2D materials and their promising uses in spintronic devices. 1 These 2D layer structured early transition metal carbides and/or nitrides are known as MXenes, so named to indicate their structural similarities with graphene. 2 MXenes are derived from 3D MAX phases (space group P6 3 /mmc) in which "M" is an early transition metal, e.g., Ti, Ta, V, etc.; "A" is mainly a group 13 or group 14 element (group III-A or IV-A), e.g., Si, Al; "X" is a carbide, nitride or can be both; and n ¼ 1, 2, 3 represents the number of layers, forming 211, 312 and 413 phases. [3][4][5] Over the past decade, this new material has gained enormous attention, thus developing an entirely new research eld to disclose the properties of the 2D state of this material. The materials in the 2D regime own a cluster of astonishing physical properties as compared to the 3D nature, but intrinsic two-dimensional magnetism has proved to be challenging. As 2D semiconductors have revamped the eld of electronics, similarly, magnetism in 2D materials could remodel spintronic devices that can employ a spin degree of freedom. 6,7 Nb 2 C MXene was rst synthesized by Naguib et al., but they just reported its electrochemical activity as a promising electrode material. 4 Further work has been reported in Nb 2 C with various biomedical applications, energy storage, supercapacitors, and nanoelectronics. [9][10][11][12][13][14][15][16][17][18][19] As far as the magnetism in such 2D MXenes is concerned, it remains less investigated, and this research void needs to be lled. Recently, Babar et al. reported the observation of superconductivity in as-prepared powdered Nb 2 C for the rst time, with the highest onset transition temperature T c,onset ¼ 12.5 K among the MXene family. However, the authors did not discuss the magnetic nature of the parent Nb 2 AlC MAX itself and did not reason for the presence of unusual magnetic effects in MXene. 8 MXenes are favorable members of 2D magnetism, and different magnetic natures are computationally predicted in various carbide and nitride MXenes. 7,20 The existence of novel room-temperature ferromagnetic order in doped MXene and the coexistence of different magnetic phases in MXene, along with experimental evidence, indicate its potential of hosting diverse magnetic natures. 21,22 Considerable research has been focused on these 2D structures due to their importance and favorable applications, such as spintronics. MXene could provide a vast platform for exploring the magnetic properties and is one of the best candidates that can host superconductivity as compared to other members of the 2D family. Experimental studies are generally dependent upon numerous variables, thus affecting the research pace. However, density functional theory-based rst principles calculation and theoretical simulations are a successful way to examine and foresee the properties of low-dimensional materials. This provoked us to theoretically explore superconductivity in Nb 2 C and their validation through superconductivity measurements of experimentally synthesized Nb 2 C MXene. In this work, we report a systematic etching mechanism of Nb 2 C MXene to obtain ne 2D sheets via a chemical etching route using hydrouoric (HF) acid. Structural and morphological studies using the X-ray diffraction technique (XRD), scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and elemental analysis by energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (EDX) show the effective removal of Al from the parent 3D-Nb 2 AlC MAX, thus revealing an accordion-like sheet structure. Optical analysis indicates a signicant reduction in bandgap aer chemical etching. Magnetic properties were carried out to observe the signatures of superconductivity (a perfect diamagnetic state, negative magnetic moment) and its magnetic nature at room temperature. To study the magnetic nature of as-prepared powder-form Nb 2 C, density functional theory (DFT) rst principles calculation was carried out through Wein2K using spin-polarized generalized gradient approximation (sp-GGA). The magnetic moment of the compound is calculated to be À0.00485, which although but small is important, as the value is negative, which is an indication of the presence of diamagnetism in Nb 2 C. Here, the detailed chemical etching process, magnetic properties of Nb 2 AlC MAX and its effect on magnetic phase of Nb 2 C MXene, and the density functional theory calculation are reported, which were not discussed by Babar et al. in ref. 8.

Results and discussion
The structural and phase purity of resultant MXene powder was characterized by X-ray diffractometer (XRD, Bruker, D8 Advance, Germany) using Cu-Ka radiation. X-ray diffraction (XRD) patterns of Nb 2 AlC MAX and 2D layered MXene are shown (see Fig. 2a and b). There are two main peaks in the XRD pattern of MAX, the rst peak at q ¼ 12.9 and the second peak at q ¼ 38.8 . Aer chemical treatment, the total disappearance of the second peak indicates the removal of Al from the parent compound.
The broadening of the peak at q ¼ 12.9 and its downshiing indicates that MAX is converted into MXene. Middle Al layers can be selectively removed due to the weaker nature of Nb-Al bonds than the Nb-C bond in the Nb 2 AlC MAX phase aer high- Fig. 1 Detailed synthesis schematics and etching mechanism to obtain 2D Nb 2 C-MXene sheets. temperature treatment with hydrouoric acid. 4,23 Weaker hydrogen bonding in M-Al layers comes in place of stronger metallic bonds that result in facile separation of sheets upon HF treatment and subsequent intercalation of water molecules during the washing process. These different relative bond strengths allow the selective removal of Al without affecting the M-C layer, 8,23,24 resulting in hexagonally stacked 2D sheets of Nb 2 C MXene. The elemental composition, obtained from energy-dispersive X-ray spectrum (EDX), is shown in the table provided in Fig. 2. The EDX elemental mapping shows a signicant reduction of Al content aer HF treatment, showing the successful etching process. Both O and F are also present in MXene as functional groups, which are unavoidable during the synthesis process. It is worth noting that aluminum in Nb 2 AlC is very active and could easily adsorb oxygen. Aer the etching, Al is dissolved, and oxygen contents associated with Al are therefore decreased. The high content of O in MAX phases may be attributed to several reasons. Oxygen contaminations in primary precursors (i.e., metal powders) emanate oxygen impurity phases such as alumina. 25 Experimental studies on similar MAX phases reveal that oxygen could possibly substitute carbon without affecting the MAX structure. 26 J. Rosen et al. have reported oxygen as a potential element in comparison to nitrides or carbides that could dictate the carbide/nitride lattice sites. 27 T. Liao et al. have also indicated that the treatment of MAX at high-temperature conditions could trigger oxygen to reside at c-sites. 28 They reported 50% of carbon being replaced by oxygen content. Moreover, due to the high affinity of aluminum towards oxygen, weighing the initial precursors in an open environment or MAX precursors may lead to the formation of Al 2 O 3 even if the synthesis is carried out in vacuum. 28,29 The results also suggest that the formation of such impurities unintentionally incorporate signicant oxygen content. Elevated temperature treatment of MAX phase with strong HF etchant leads to the removal of Al and its associated content, resulting in a more ordered structure. 30 To observe the morphology of the sheets, scanning electron microscope (SEM) images at different resolutions were recorded using a eld emission electron microscope (FESEM, VEGA3-TSCAN) operated at 20 kV. Structural morphological images, determined by scanning electron microscope (SEM) of MAX and MXene, are shown in Fig. 2c and d, respectively, showing a layered structure of the resultant MXene compound having a typical MXene morphology. [31][32][33][34][35] Transmission electron microscopy (TEM) images of Nb 2 C-MXene are shown in Fig. 2e, clearly revealing the typical MXene layered structure. The exfoliated 2D-Nb 2 C MXene sheets are transparent and quite thin, as observed by TEM imaging. The variation of c-LP of MAX to MXene is presented in Fig. 1b as c-LP was increased to 22.6 A from 13.83 A (MAX phase), which satises the facile separation of the sheets aer HF treatment. 4,36,37 Raman spectra were measured with Horiba Scientic, Xplora Raman analyzer with a laser wavelength of 532 nm in the region of 200-2500 cm À1 . Fig. 3a and b shows the Raman of Nb 2 AlC before and aer HF treatment done at various temperatures. The maximum number of peaks is downshied, broadened, and shied to higher wavenumber aer terminating with F and OH groups, which indicates a strengthening of the bond between atoms. [38][39][40][41] Peaks I and II in MAX are suppressed aer HF treatment, indicating the removal of Al atoms or exchange of Al atoms by lighter atoms. 42 Peak III was broadened and downshied, which is related to C atoms. 43 Peaks IV and V are representative of D and G bands of carbon species. The D band characterizes carbon disordered structure to sp 3 hybrid carbon, and G is the graphitic band or sp 2 carbon. 44 The ratio of intensity of I D to I G tells us about the crystallinity defects, showing more ordered MXene phase than the MAX phase. 45,46 The I D /I G ratio of intensities in Fig. 3c tells us about the crystalline defects, which shows more ordered MXene phases than the MAX itself. This ratio is 1.6 for MAX, and it varies between 0.89 to 1.33 for MXene at different temperatures. 45 This shows that the sample obtained and carried forward at 55 C is more ordered, with less defect density as compared to the other samples synthesized at different temperatures.
The Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) spectra of Nb 2 C etched at different temperatures, i.e., 55 C, 65 C, 75 C and 85 C, and are compared to the FTIR spectrum of pure MAX (Fig. 4a), indicating three absorption bands at 2357 cm À1 , 2295 cm À1 , and 483 cm À1 , respectively, which are common and appear in all samples. These bonds can be attributed to the triply bonded carbons, Nb]C]Nb, and Nb-C, respectively. 47 It is to be noted that the FTIR spectra of Nb 2 C is irrelevant to the etched temperature and shows a similar trend. A bond at 1643 cm À1 can be attributed to unsaturation mainly due to the C]C bond in the MXene structure. The presence of C-H bonds can also be indicated by the bands at 2947 cm À1 and 1363 cm À1 .
Based on the spectra and presence of different functional groups, surface functionalization can be observed in our MXene sheets due to the presence of a distinct C]O band at 1734 cm À1 and C-F band at 1211 cm À1 . 48,49 The absence of these bonds in the spectrum of the MAX phase shows that the etched MXene may have C]O, C-F, and O-H surface terminations. 50 Tauc's plot was used to calculate the band gap of MAX and MXene using following equation: where h ¼ Planck's constant, A ¼ constant, n ¼ the frequency of irradiated light, E g ¼ the bandgap energy, and a ¼ the absorbance of light. 51 The bandgaps of MAX and MXene were obtained by plotting (ahn) 2 against bandgap energy E g . [52][53][54][55][56] The bandgaps of MAX and MXene came out to be 1.62 eV and 1.47 eV, respectively, as shown in Fig. 4b The magnetic nature of MXene has remained a less-explored research eld, with only a few reports available on its magnetic nature. Their magnetic nature is predicted based on the magnetic transition metal elements (e.g., Cr, Mn, V, Fe, and Ni) or in the form of any doped congurations. There exists a large gap between experimental studies and their theoretical verication, or vice versa. Due to limitations in synthesis techniques, there were no experimental reports on the magnetic properties of as-prepared MXene. Until recently, Babar et al. have synthesized Nb 2 C MXene and among the MXene family. In this report, the magnetic nature of Nb 2 AlC-MAX and Nb 2 C MXene is shown. Fig. 5a and b show the zero-eld-cooled (ZFC) and eld-cooled (FC) magnetization curves measured for Nb 2 AlC MAX and Nb 2 C MXene, respectively, under an applied magnetic eld of 5 mT using a SQUID magnetometer (Quantum Design, MPMS).
From these curves, one can see that the magnetic behaviors of MAX and MXene are different.
The FC-ZFC curves of MAX correspond to a paramagnetic material in which the magnetization increases positively with the decrease in temperature, whereas the FC-ZFC curves of MXene are opposite; the magnetization reverses its direction at a critical temperature and becomes negative at low temperatures. This trend of MXene ts well for a typical  This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2020 RSC Adv., 2020, 10, 25669-25678 | 25673 superconductivity-like diamagnetic response of a material. Recently, Babar et al. reported the Meissner effect in Nb 2 C MXene, which showed typical type-II superconductivity in the material with an onset transition temperature of 12.5 K. However, the authors did not discuss the origin of this behavior, as it might be inherent to the Nb 2 AlC MAX itself, and the contribution of the spin of the constituent elements needed to be discussed. Here, the magnetization vs. temperature (M-T) trend of MAX does not show any diamagnetic transition at any temperature, but a paramagnetic behavior. [61][62][63] Hence, the MAX structure itself is not responsible for the previously observed superconductivity-like diamagnetism in MXene.
Contrary to the MAX phase, the FC-ZFC curves shown in Fig. 5b clearly indicate a magnetic phase transition showing a clear diamagnetic behavior that gives traces of the superconductivity effect in MXene. The inset of Fig. 5b indicates M-T curves of Nb 2 C MXene at a much higher applied eld of 100 mT, at which the magnetization becomes positive at low temperature and is no longer a diamagnetic material. The sharp upward trend in magnetization, as well as the splitting between ZFC-FC curves at low temperature, indicates a signicant paramagnetic contribution arising from the Nb ions. 64 This also gives an indication of the existence of a threshold eld that supports the presence of superconductivity in Nb 2 C MXene, as the threshold eld corresponds to a type-II superconductor. 8 Fig. 5c shows the quadrant of magnetization vs. magnetic eld (M-H) curves measured at 2 K, 4 K, 6 K, 7 K, 8 K, 9 K, 11 K and 12 K. The curves clearly show a transition of magnetization from lownegative to high-negative, and then to low-negative values, representing the presence of Meissner effect at these temperatures as well as the presence of the respective threshold elds. At 12 K, the M-H response is linear to the eld and refers purely to a paramagnetic curve, indicating the transition temperature.
Several theoretical studies have been carried out to explore the magnetic properties of different MXenes. The Cr-based carbide and nitride MXenes are predicted to be magnetic according to theoretical studies carried out by M. Khazei et al., and their electronic properties were reported to be altered upon adding the surface terminations. 65 Different functionalized MXenes are predicted to be semiconductors with the bandgap range of 0.25-2 eV. Bare MXenes (MXenes without surface terminations) are supposed to have metallic nature, but the OH, O or F terminated MXenes show semiconductive nature, with bandgaps ranging from 0.05-1.8 eV. 66,67 The asymmetric functionalized MXene, such as the Janus Mn 2 N, is a ferromagnet, while Mn 2 C is reported to be anti-ferromagnetic. 68 Zhang et al. have reported the paramagnetic nature of as-prepared Ti 3 C 2 and its magnetic variation on different synthesis conditions. 69 Akgenc et al. theoretically pointed out the ferromagnetic half-metal and antiferromagnetic semiconductor nature of Ti 2 C MXene. 70 Since the magnetic behavior of 2D nanostructures could be intrinsic or defectinduced, the wet chemical etching route could produce 2D sheets with intrinsic magnetic properties with high-yield and lowcost mass production. 71 Considering the above ndings, the magnetic behavior of our sample is found to be independent of the surface functionalization, providing the clue towards the intrinsic behavior of our Nb 2 C MXene. Its superconductivity-like behavior (the Meissner effect and the perfect diamagnetism at low temperature, negative magnetic moment) is calculated by density functional theory calculations.
Our group has recently reported a detailed experimental and theoretical analysis on stable ferromagnetism in Ti 3 C 2 MXene. This report carries out experimental magnetic analysis with theoretical validations of doped and undoped Ti 3 C 2 MXene. 72 To further explore the reason for the existence of the observed superconducting-diamagnetism in Nb 2 C MXene (niobium carbide MXene), the structure was simulated in WIEN2k package, which employs the full-potential linear augmented plane wave method. 73,74 The structure was optimized for the clattice parameter obtained from XRD analysis, where the space group is P6 3 /mmc and the positions for niobium (Nb) and carbon (C) are (1/3, 2/3, u) and (0, 0, 0), respectively. For the minimization of the structures, 500 k-points were used in the irreducible Brillouin zone, with a k-mesh of 14 Â 14 Â 2, while the self-consistent eld was also performed at the same number of k-points. The function that is used for solving Kohn-Sham equations is spin-polarized Perdew-Burke-Ernzerhof generalized gradient approximation (PBE-GGA). 75 The crystal structure of Nb 2 C is shown in Fig. 6a. The magnetic moment of the compound is calculated to be À0.00485 mB, which although small is yet important, as the value is negative, which is an indication of the presence of diamagnetism in Nb 2 C. Moreover, the magnetic moment of Nb and C, as well as the interstitial position, are À0.00046 mB, À0.00017 mB, and À0.00485 mB, respectively. From the density of states (DOS) calculations, DOS versus energy graph is obtained, where Fig. 6b-d shows the total DOS for the compound, total DOS for Nb and partial DOS (PDOS) for the d-orbital of Nb, and total DOS of C with PDOS of the p-orbital of C. In Fig. 6b, at Fermi energy, there is a very small difference between the DOS of spin up and spin down. Fig. 6c and d claries the reason for the negative moment, which is the d-orbital of Nb 2 C, whereas for C, the majority of states present is the valence band, and for Nb, the DOS is spread through the energy range, i.e., valence band and conduction band. Lei et al. have studied the different phases of Mo 2 C with functional groups and suggested superconducting behavior. The critical temperature varied according to the functional groups and was found to be in the range of 0 K to 13 K. 76 Baber et al. showed that pristine MXene Nb 2 C exhibits type-II superconductor-like behavior. Magnetization versus applied eld curves showed that the behavior is diamagnetic below 12.5 K. 8 The negative total magnetic moment, i.e., À0.00485 mB in the present calculation, is an indication towards that diamagnetic behavior of Nb 2 C. The abovementioned computational studies verify the experimental superconductor-like diamagnetic nature of Nb 2 C MXene.

Synthesis of Nb 2 C MXene
To obtain Nb 2 C MXene, the wet chemical etching route was followed. The Nb 2 AlC MAX powder (200 mesh size) was immersed in 48-50% concentrated HF (1 g : 10 ml, Sigma Aldrich) at room temperature. Etching at continuous magnetic stirring for 90 hours 4 was not successful. We started etching at an optimized time of 40 hours while varying the temperature from 45 C to 85 C in equal intervals of 10 C. Aer the etching process was completed, centrifugation was done, and each sample was washed repeatedly with deionized water. Aer removing the supernatant, the resulting powder was collected using ethanol and was le at room temperature to dry. The synthesis schematics and detailed etching mechanism are shown in Fig. 1. The rudimental yield comes out to be approximately 100% (yield here is dened as the ratio of the mass obtained for MXene aer etching with the mass of MAX taken at the start). The best sample was the one etched at 55 C, for an optimized etching time of 40 hours. This etching scheme came out to be effective to obtain the required accordion-like layered MXene structure.

HF handling protocol
It is always risky to handle hydrouoric acid owing to its harmful and noxious attributes irrespective of its concentration. HF effectively penetrates into the skin, causing damage to deep layer tissues and bones without any visible effects within 1-24 hours. 77 This leads to the death of tissues and limb loss. So, it is directed to use safety goggles, acid-resistant apron, face-shield and polyvinyl chloride (PVC) or polythene gloves to avoid any direct contact of HF with your skin. Since the inhalation of HF can cause swelling of the respiratory tract, in order to avoid it, the reactions should be carried out in a protective fume hood along with the usage of masks at all times. 78,79

Conclusion
In conclusion, we have successfully synthesized 2D-Nb 2 C MXene sheets via wet-chemical etching using hydrouoric (HF) acid. Structural analysis indicated the effective removal of the Al layer, and SEM images show the formation of the resultant layered structure. FTIR spectra indicate the presence of surface terminations that are unavoidable during the etching process. The optical analysis shows a reduction in bandgap that was characterized due to the presence of surface functionalization. Raman spectra show that the MXene is more ordered than the MAX itself. The magnetic analysis shows the variation of the magnetic behavior of MXene upon application of different eld strengths as well as entirely different behaviors of MAX and MXene. Our theoretical analysis validates the diamagnetic nature of MXene. Although the value of the negative magnetic moment is small, it very importantly signies the experimental diamagnetic nature of MXene, giving clear signatures of the possible existence of superconductivity in Nb 2 C MXene, which can be veried further by transport measurement to make it a 100% certainty in the future. It is notable that to our knowledge, this is the rst study on Nb 2 C-MXene that conducts This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2020 RSC Adv., 2020, 10, 25669-25678 | 25675 experimental studies in combination with the theoretical validation of experimental ndings. For our MXene, these physical properties are signicant, which could make it a leading member of the 2D MXene family in terms of its novel magnetic nature for possible application in two-dimensional spintronics.

Conflicts of interest
The authors declare no competing nancial interest.