Synthesis of polyoxometalate clusters using carbohydrates as reducing agents leads to isomer-selection

By using sugars as the reducing agents, we demonstrate that it is possible to control the self-assembly of polyoxomolybdates through selective preparation of a single heteropolyanion isomer. D-( )-Fructose has been proved to be an effective reducing sugar compared to the chemically similar carbohydrate D-(+)-glucose. The gentle reduction results in favourable formation of the Wells–Dawson type gamma isomer in 6-fold reduced form at room temperature.

Polyoxometalates (POMs) are inorganic metal-oxide clusters which self-assemble into larger, organised, discreet molecular structures from platonic subunits. Olation and condensation of the anionic transition metal subunits in aqueous solution occurs spontaneously with exposure to acidic media. 1 A closer examination of this process is important and necessary as the study of this area brings forth mechanistic information of self-assembling chemical systems; this information is valuable in the design of promising new materials. [2][3][4][5][6] Reduced polyoxometalate species are of considerable interest lately as is evidenced by newfound applications in diverse fields including medicine, molecular magnetism, and catalysis. 7 In order to explore the physicochemical properties of these materials, it is important to consider alternative routes in producing reduced polyoxometalates. However, the sizeable chemical space employed in POM synthesis means that structural and mechanistic repercussions of several process variables, including the impact of various reducing agents used, remain largely unexplored. Control over the spatial configuration of the many metal centres of polyoxometalate clusters is desirable for fine-tuning of bulk electronic properties for tailored catalyst activity, energy storage material applications, or simply improved mechanistic understanding of complex self-assembling systems. 7,8 While POM synthesis is simple, the self-assembly process is extremely sensitive to reaction conditions including pH, solvent composition, metal, heteroatom, cations, reducing agents, temperature, pressure, reagent concentrations, and other variables (including type of reaction vessel). The intricacies of self-assembly naturally lead to several empirically-designed synthetic conditions in the literature which must be carefully controlled to produce one out of thousands of possible structures. [9][10][11] The Wells-Dawson POM cluster consists of two {XM 6 } moieties that form the belt which are both capped by two {M 3 } units forming a symmetrical cage. Rotating the caps and belts by specific angles yields six theoretically possible rotational isomers: a, b, g, a*, b* and g*. Fig. 1 illustrates the structural difference between the alpha and gamma isomers discussed herein. Computational studies of {P 2 W 18 } isomers with DFT calculations indicate the relative stability between isomers follow the order: a 4 b 4 g 4 g* 4 b* 4 a*. 12,13 Thermolysis of a-H 6 P 2 Mo 18 O 62 reveals the b and g isomers form at high temperatures; 14 however, full characterization of these isomers has not yet been reported. The difficulty in obtaining this complex is very likely due to the fact that the {P 2 Mo 18 } anion is thought to readily decompose in aqueous solutions at mild temperatures over a broad pH range. 15 Chemical reduction is common in polyoxomolybdate syntheses including procedures for {Mo 154 } and {Mo 132 } which involve sodium dithionite (Na 2 S 2 O 4 ) and hydrazine (N 2 H 4 ÁHCl or N 2 H 4 ÁHSO 4 ), respectively. 10,16,17 We employed sugars as organic reducing agents to explore new POM synthetic strategies. Two chemically similar monosaccharides, D-(+)-glucose and D-(À)-fructose (both with the formula C 6 H 12 O 6 ), as non-standard reductants since they demonstrated signs of reduction following initial experiments via an obvious colour change on addition.
The alpha isomer of the molybdenum Wells-Dawson cluster, (NH 4 ) 6 [a-P 2 Mo 18 O 62 ]Á14(H 2 O) (referred to as a-{P 2 Mo 18 } in this work), was prepared using a scaled-down version of Wu's 1920 procedure. 18 This was modified to separately incorporate D-(+)-glucose, D-(À)-fructose, and sodium dithionite for comparison, as reducing agents. Initial screening efforts were focused on low-volume (5-10 mL) reaction mixtures. Aliquots of crude mixtures were examined by electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (ESI-MS) and 31 P-NMR in order to optimise synthetic conditions required for single {P 2 Mo 18 } isomer selectivity. Generally, the sodium molybdate solutions (330 mM) containing no reducing agent remained clear and colourless when stirred at room temperature overnight at 20 1C while those treated with 1 eq. of dithionite rapidly change to dark brown. Similar samples treated with an equimolar amount of either glucose or fructose develop an intense blue colour as a result of intervalence charge transfer indicative of reduced molybdenum. 19 The blue colour that develops in these solutions is easily identifiable through a prominent absorption at 866 nm in the UV-Vis-NIR spectrum (see ESI †).
Samples treated with a very low concentration (0.03 eq.) of fructose yielded needle-shaped crystals of generally poor quality due to co-crystallization of isomers; however, increasing the fructose concentration to 0.1 eq. and above increased a far-upfield 31 P-NMR signal chemical shift at À13.1 ppm with few impurities present. Fructose concentrations above 0.1 eq. enhanced this upfield signal. Crystallization of these mixtures was facile following counter cation metathesis with ammonium chloride. Large block-shaped crystals of these samples were isolated within one day and enabled positive identification of the reduced species, (NH 4 ) 4 H 8 [g-P 2 Mo 18 O 62 ] (referred to as g-{P 2 Mo 18 } in this work), by single crystal XRD supported by ion mobility mass spectrometry confirming the assignment of the À13.1 ppm 31 P-NMR signal to g-{P 2 Mo 18 }. Further increasing the quantity of fructose promotes conversion to the gamma isomer and the application of 80 1C heating overnight with 0.3 eq. yields this isomer with very good conversion observed by 31 P-NMR spectra (see ESI †). Following purification via recrystallization and washing (see ESI † for synthetic details) of isolated crystals, one singlet was observed at À13.1 ppm attributed to the 6e À reduced form of g-{P 2 Mo 18 }. Fig. 2 outlines the result of treatment with the reducing agents used in this study. The 31 P-NMR spectra of glucosecontaining reactions did not exhibit signs of Dawson type POMs or encapsulated phosphate. Further, the slow development of a comparatively weak blue colour implied the reduction with glucose to be far less effective than with fructose. Despite signs of Mo reduction, samples treated with 0.1-2.0 eq. of glucose rarely produced either the alpha or gamma isomer of {P 2 Mo 18 } in significant quantities and crystallization was poor. Despite their similarities, the substantial difference between fructose and glucose likely lies in the structure of the two monosaccharides. Because of their similarity this is likely caused by the limited interaction of glucose with molybdenum as a weaker bidentate ligand compared to the energetically-favoured tridentate interaction with fructose. 20 In their cyclic form both sugars have multiple hydroxyl groups near their anomeric carbon centres. The two hydroxyl moieties of glucose are available for a bidentate interaction with transition metal atoms whereas fructose has three close-proximity hydroxyl groups available for a tridentate interaction. This promotes interaction with, and efficient reduction of, solubilized Mo VI atoms. This was quickly apparent by comparing the rate and intensity of colour change in smallscale samples with equimolar quantities of either sugar (Fig. 2).
Experiments performed with similar quantities of sodium dithionite as a reducing agent were less selective for one isomer and produced isomeric mixtures of {P 2 Mo 18 } evidenced by both the UV-Vis and NMR. A low concentration of sodium dithionite (0.03 equivalents) resulted in two signals in the 31 P-NMR at À3.1 and À4.7 ppm. The peak at À3.1 ppm corresponds to the a Dawson while the second peak at À4.7 ppm is likely due to a partially reduced isomer (see ESI †). 21 The reduced species, g-{P 2 Mo 18 }, was detected by NMR when used in increased quantity (0.2 eq.) of dithionite; however, the lack of selectivity is clear based on the shallow UV-Vis spectra and numerous signals apparent in 31 P-NMR spectra. These solutions did not yield quality crystals for examination by single crystal XRD. UV-vis-NIR spectroscopic characterization of g-{P 2 Mo 18 } prepared with fructose exhibit a bathochromic shift and strong absorption relative to a-{P 2 Mo 18 }. Samples which were treated with 0.2 eq. Na 2 S 2 O 4 absorb across a wide range of the visible region with maxima centred at 680 nm and 863 nm. Scaled-up syntheses with 0.13 eq. of fructose yielded high quality crystals of g-{P 2 Mo 18 }. The degree of reduced molybdenum cores of g-{P 2 Mo 18 } was determined with electrochemical tests on purified crystalline product via bulk electrolysis and redox titration (see ESI †). Electrochemical oxidation indicated g-{P 2 Mo 18 } was reduced by approximately 6 electrons and agrees with the range of 6-8 electron reduction determined by cerimetry. These results are supported by a combination of mass spectrometry, a significant downfield shift of the 31 P-NMR signal, the hyperchromicity of UV-Vis-NIR absorbance, and elemental analysis.
The  24 Additionally, the calculated oxidation state of half of the m 2 -oxo atoms between the caps and belts is near unity in both complexes which clearly indicates protonation at these sites.
Electrospray ionization mass spectrometry proved useful for speciation of crude mixtures and isolated clusters. The broad and poorly resolved signals apparent in mass spectra of samples of g-{P 2 Mo 18 } and a-{P 2 Mo 18 } (see ESI †) are indicative of a family of ions with a range of counter cations, solvent association, and cluster aggregates. This type of aggregation and solvation is known to further complicate standard ESI-MS assignment of POMs even with well-optimised source conditions. 25,26 For this reason, ion mobility separation (IMS) is desirable, if not essential, to observe isotope patterns of the naked parent ion present in complexes g-{P 2 Mo 18 } and a-{P 2 Mo 18 }. Optimization of ESI and travelling wave ion mobility separation (TWIMS) settings (see ESI † for details) serves to greatly clarify solution-phase speciation in complex mixtures. For example, the singly-charged, fully protonated, [H 5 (P 2 Mo 18 O 62 )] À anion centred around m/z 2786 is wellresolved with a drift time (t d ) of 18.85 ms under the TWIMS settings used for all samples. While the protonated, singly-charged parent ion is obvious in samples of a-{P 2 Mo 18 } the analogous anion expected of the 6e À reduced [H 11 (P 2 Mo 18 O 62 )] À is much more elusive, but detectable, in IMS-mass spectra of g-{P 2 Mo 18 } and appears around m/z 2792 with t d = 19.63 ms (Fig. 3). The small difference in collisional cross section distinguishes the gamma isomer from the protonated ion of the pure alpha isomer which normally overlaps significantly with the naked gamma isomer, [H 11 (P 2 Mo 18 O 62 )] À , in a standard ESI-MS spectrum. The increase in m/z and t d support the assignment of z = À12 determined electrochemically with pure samples. A noteworthy feature in mobilograms of g-{P 2 Mo 18 } and a-{P 2 Mo 18 } is evidence of cluster self-aggregation. This is especially apparent in TWIMS-MS spectra of a-{P 2 Mo 18 } in which aggregates are separated by charge state, easily distinguished by shortened drift times. Higher order aggregates with z = À4 are resolvable with IMS. Aggregates above this charge state are also apparent though signal intensity for these high-charge aggregates was generally insufficient to resolve the isotope patterns.
To summarize, we have demonstrated a single synthetic variable in POM synthesis, the reducing agent, exerts isomeric control in formation of the molybdenum Wells-Dawson. Further, we have selectively prepared, isolated, and fully characterised the reduced molybdenum Wells-Dawson, g-{P 2 Mo 18 }, for the first time. The relatively low fructose concentration required for the 6e À reduction of {P 2 Mo 18 } suggests that fructose is an efficient and effective organic reducing agent. The striking contrast between similar reducing sugars indicates careful selection, and quantity, of reducing agent is extremely important in polyoxometalate syntheses. Fructose is an economically and environmentally sustainable reagent which alters polyoxometalate self-assembly through mild reduction and, potentially, stabilization of intermediate building blocks during the stepwise assembly. This effect has been demonstrated via real time monitoring with other alkoxo ligands in the preparation of {Mo 132 }. 27 The evidence in this study suggests fructose acts as a ''soft-coordinating'' ligand which stabilizes intermediate metal cluster transition states prior to reduction and effectively modifies the assembly process in a unique way. However, additional studies are required for a closer examination of synthetic process variables in POM synthesis. The multiple roles of organic reducing agents (which may serve as both ligands and reductants) will require further exploration to develop a comprehensive toolkit for the synthetic chemist to manage cluster formation and produce new materials by design.