High performance nanostructured bismuth oxide – cobaltite as a durable oxygen electrode for reversible solid oxide cells †

The high reactivity between bismuth oxide and cobaltite oxygen electrodes is a bottleneck in developing active and reliable bismuth oxide – cobaltite composite oxygen electrodes for solid oxide cells (SOCs). Herein, a Sr-free Sm 0.95 Co 0.95 Pd 0.05 O 3 (cid:1) d (SmCPd) oxygen electrode decorated with nanoscale Er 0.4 Bi 1.6 O 3 (ESB) is synthesized and assembled on a barrier-layer-free Y 2 O 3 – ZrO 2 (YSZ) electrolyte ﬁ lm. The cell with the ESB decorated SmCPd composite oxygen electrode exhibits a peak power density of 1.81 W cm (cid:1) 2 at 750 (cid:3) C and 0.58 W cm (cid:1) 2 at 650 (cid:3) C. More importantly, excellent operating stability is achieved in the fuel cell mode at 600 (cid:3) C for 500 h, and in electrolysis and reversible modes at 750 (cid:3) C for over 200 h. The results demonstrate the feasibility of applying bismuth oxide – cobaltite composite oxygen electrodes in developing high-performance and durable SOCs.


Introduction
The depletion of fossil fuels and the global climate crisis necessitate the development of innovative technologies to efficiently use renewable energy sources such as nuclear, solar and wind power. Solid oxide cells (SOCs) are such a device of choice for efficient storage and regeneration of renewable sources by alternately operating in solid oxide electrolysis cell (SOEC) and solid oxide fuel cell (SOFC) modes. [1][2][3][4] Manganite and cobaltite based perovskite oxides such as La 0.8 Sr 0.2 MnO 3+d (LSM) and La 0.6 Sr 0.4 Co 0.2 Fe 0.8 O 3Àd (LSCF) are the most investigated oxygen electrodes for SOCs. [5][6][7][8][9] LSM is predominantly an electronic conductor without ionic conductivity and it is favourable for use at high temperatures (800 C and above). On the other hand, cobaltite oxides with mixed ionic/electronic conductivity (MIEC) are ideal for application at intermediate temperatures (600-800 C). However, the surface segregation of Sr-containing cobaltite oxygen electrodes and the combination of segregated Sr with volatile species such as chromium and sulphur constitute a major degradation mechanism of SOC stacks. [10][11][12][13][14][15][16][17] One straightforward means to address this critical issue is to develop Sr-free cobaltite electrodes, 18 such as La(Co,Fe) x Pd 1Àx O 3Àd . 19,20 Recently, we have successfully developed a high performance Sr-free Sm 0.95 CoO 3Àd electrode doped with 5% Pd in the B-site of the perovskite structure (SmCPd) and assembled it on a barrier-layer-free Y 2 O 3 -ZrO 2 (YSZ) electrolyte. 21 The combination of SmCPd with an ion-conducting phase such as Gddoped CeO 2 (GDC) leads to remarkably enhanced electrocatalytic activity for the oxygen reduction reaction (ORR). 21 Cubic bismuth oxides such as Er and Y stabilized bismuth oxides (ESB and YSB) possess excellent surface exchange capability and the highest ionic conductivity among the electrolyte materials of SOCs. 22,23 However, due to its phase instability in reducing environments, bismuth oxide is mainly applied as an interfacial layer between the electrolyte and oxygen electrode, [24][25][26] as well as an active promoter for LSM 24,[27][28][29][30][31][32][33][34][35] and Ag electrodes. [36][37][38] On the other hand, incorporation of bismuth oxide into cobaltite electrodes is rarely reported, possibly due to the high reactivity between bismuth oxide and cobaltite at low temperatures. 24 41 On the other hand, Li et al. incorporated YSB into LSCF scaffolds by inltration and heat-treatment at a low temperature of 600 C, leading to a remarkably enhanced electrocatalytic activity for proton conducting SOFCs. 41 Herein, we report the development of a nanostructured ESB decorated Sr-free SmCPd composite oxygen electrode, which is applied on a barrier-layer-free YSZ electrolyte via a direct assembly approach. The incorporation of the highly ion conductive ESB phase is expected to remarkably enhance the electrocatalytic activity of SmCPd, similar to the case of adding GDC. 21 Our recent report has demonstrated the feasibility of preparing ESB decorated LSM at a low temperature of 600 C. 33 Furthermore, the direct assembly approach involves the in situ fabrication of oxygen electrodes under the operating conditions of SOCs (700-800 C) by applying electrochemical polarization. [42][43][44] Therefore, the adoption of low temperature powder synthesis and in situ electrode fabrication processes at 600-800 C may minimize the potential chemical reaction between ESB and SmCPd, making it possible to develop a bismuth oxide-cobaltite composite oxygen electrode. The results demonstrate that the nanostructured ESB decorated SmCPd oxygen electrode is high performing and stable for running in fuel cell, electrolysis and reversible modes.

Fabrication of supported electrolyte lms
Hydrogen electrode-supported YSZ lms were fabricated by slurry spin coating. The hydrogen electrode supports were composed of NiO (J.T. Baker), YSZ (TZ-8Y, Tosoh) and tapioca in a mass ratio of 40 : 40 : 20, and the hydrogen electrode functional layer (HEFL) was composed of NiO and YSZ in a mass ratio of 50 : 50. The supported YSZ lms were co-red at 1450 C in air for 5 h. The diameter of the as-sintered button cells was 14.5 mm. The thickness of the hydrogen electrode support, HEFL layer and YSZ lm was 0.8 mm, 14 mm and 12 mm, respectively. The geometric surface area of the oxygen electrode was 0.23 cm 2 . The detailed fabrication processes are available elsewhere. 45 The metal ions/CA/EDTA was xed in a molar ratio of 1 : 1.5 : 1. The aqueous solution was stirred on a hot plate and the gel was heat-treated at 180 C in an oven for 12 h. The SmCPd and ESB powders were calcined at 900 C and 600 C in air for 2 h, respectively. 40 wt% ESB decorated 60 wt% SmCPd (decorated ESB-SmCPd) composite powder was prepared using the same modied Pechini method mentioned above. A 0.15 M ESB aqueous precursor solution containing Er(NO 3 ) 3 , Bi(NO 3 ) 3 , CA, EDTA and ammonia (the same purities and suppliers as above) was prepared in a beaker. The as-synthesized SmCPd powder was placed into the beaker, magnetically stirred and heated on a hot plate to evaporate the excess water. The solution was stirred continuously until a viscous gel was obtained. The black gel was thoroughly dried at 180 C for 12 h and the resultant ash was ground in an agate mortar, followed by calcination at 600-750 C in air for 2 h to obtain the decorated ESB-SmCPd composite powder. The details of the decoration process have been described elsewhere. 33 The ESB-SmCPd powder was combined with an ink vehicle (Fuel Cell Materials) in a mass ratio of 50 : 50 to form an electrode paste. The paste was coated on the YSZ electrolyte lms via direct assembly by simply drying at 100 C in air for 2 h without an additional pre-sintering process at a high temperature as in the case of conventional electrode fabrication processes. 44,47 Pt paste (Gwent Electronic Materials Ltd) was painted on the electrodes as a current collector and heat-treated at 150 C in air for 2 h.

Cell testing
The button cells were sealed on ceramic tubes using a sealant (Ceramabond 552, Aremco Products Inc.) and dried at room temperature in air for at least 12 h. Electrochemical polarization curves and impedance spectra of the cells were measured using a Gamry Potentiostat Reference 3000 and Interface 1000 in a temperature range of 600-750 C. The hydrogen electrode was owed with H 2 , H 2 -H 2 O, H 2 -CO 2 or H 2 -H 2 O-CO 2 at a rate of 25-50 ml min À1 , and the oxygen electrode was open to static air. Steam was generated using a humidier and to avoid the condensation, the stainless steel gas line was wrapped with heating tape and the temperature was maintained at 105 C. The operating stability of the cells was investigated at a constant current density of 0.5 A cm À2 at 750 C in the fuel cell mode, electrolysis mode and reversible mode and of 0.25 A cm À2 at 600 C in the fuel cell mode. The impedance spectra were collected with a 10 mV AC signal applied from 100 kHz to 0.01 Hz under open circuit conditions. Three identical cells were tested to conrm the reproducibility, and the testing history and initial peak power densities are summarized in Table 1.

Phase, microstructure and elemental characterization
The phase of as-synthesized powders was examined using a Bruker D8 Advance X-ray diffractometer with a Cu Ka X-ray source. The morphologies of ESB and SmCPd powders, the SmCPd electrode and decorated ESB-SmCPd electrodes were characterized using eld emission scanning electron microscopy (FESEM, Zeiss Neon 40EsB and Supra-55 Sapphire) combined with energy dispersive spectroscopy (EDS). The morphology and elemental distribution of the decorated ESB-SmCPd powder were measured using a high angle annular dark eld scanning transmission electron microscope (HAADF-STEM, FEI Titan G2 80-200 TEM/STEM with ChemiSTEM Technology). The powders were mounted on copper grids for the SEM observations. In order to characterize the electrolyte surface aer polarization, the oxygen electrodes were removed from the YSZ electrolyte surface by treatment in 32% HCl solution at room temperature for 24 h. To investigate the electrode/electrolyte interface, a lamella was milled across the tested ESB-SmCPd/YSZ interface region using an FEI Helios Nanolab G3 CX DualBeam focused ion beam (FIB)-SEM. Microstructural observation and elemental mapping analysis of the lamella were performed using the aforementioned HAADF-STEM.  Fig. 1a), while the ESB powder calcined at a lower temperature of 600 C is irregularly shaped and in a greater size range of 20-1500 nm (630 nm on average, Fig. 1b). The greater size of the ESB powder than that of the SmCPd powder is due to the low melting point of bismuth oxide (824 C). 48 In the case of the directly assembled ESB-SmCPd electrode, the electrode is characterized by a very ne structure with ESB nanoparticles in a size range of 40-100 nm (60 nm on average, Fig. 1c), very different from the submicron structure of the directly assembled pristine SmCPd electrode ( Fig. 1d and S1, ESI †). This indicates the successful decoration of SmCPd particles by the nanoscale ESB phase, which is conrmed by the HAADF micrograph and EDS maps of the ESB decorated SmCPd powder (Fig. 1e). The particle size of ESB in the decorated ESB-SmCPd electrode is much smaller as compared to that of the individual ESB powder, indicating that the presence of SmCPd has a remarkable inhibiting effect on the agglomeration and grain growth of ESB. Quantitative EDS analysis on the ESB-SmCPd electrode surface reveals that the relative cation ratios are close to those of the experimental target (Fig. S2, ESI †). Fig. 2a and b show the XRD patterns and Rietveld renement of as-synthesized powders. In the case of individual SmCPd and ESB powders, pure orthorhombic perovskite and cubic uorite phases are obtained without impurity phases, respectively (Fig. 2a). For the decorated ESB-SmCPd powders calcined at 600 C and 750 C, in addition to the expected diffraction peaks from ESB and SmCPd, there are additional peaks related to a new phase of Bi 2 SmO 4 (Fig. 2a). The formation of the new phase is also conrmed by Raman spectra (Fig. S3, ESI †). The occurrence of a reaction at a calcination temperature as low as 600 C indicates that ESB is highly reactive with SmCPd. The phase identication is also conrmed by the Rietveld renement on the decorated ESB-SmCPd powder calcined at 750 C (Fig. 2b), which estimates the mass ratio of ESB/SmCPd/ Bi 2 SmO 4 to be 17 : 51 : 32. In such a case, the mass ratio of ESB relative to ESB + SmCPd is 25 wt%, lower than 40 wt% of the target composition. This is due to the fact that the formation of Bi 2 SmO 4 needs more Bi from ESB than Sm from SmCPd.

Initial phase and microstructure
The decorated ESB-SmCPd composite powder was heattreated at 750 C in air for 20-300 h, and the XRD patterns are shown in Fig. 2c. Aer the heat-treatment for 20 h and longer, Bi 2 SmO 4 disappears and a new phase of Sm 0.6 Bi 1.4 O 3 is formed, while the SmCPd and ESB phases are still observable. This indicates that Bi 2 SmO 4 is most likely metastable, as is also conrmed by the presence of a predominant Sm 0.6 Bi 1.4 O 3 phase when we tried to synthesize the Bi 2 SmO 4 phase using the modied Pechini method (Fig. S4, ESI †). Nevertheless, Sm 0.6 Bi 1.4 O 3 has been reported to possess reasonable ionic conductivity. 49

Electrochemical performance and stability
Although Bi 2 SmO 4 is formed in the as-synthesized ESB-SmCPd composite powder, the ESB-SmCPd composite electrode exhibits outstanding electrocatalytic activity. Fig. 3 shows the polarization performance of a hydrogen electrode-supported YSZ lm cell with a directly assembled decorated ESB-SmCPd oxygen electrode (Cell-#1) as a function of polarization time at 0.5 A cm À2 and 750 C. The cell produces an open circuit voltage of 1.12 V, close to the theoretical value, demonstrating that the YSZ electrolyte lm is dense and crack-free with excellent gas impermeability. The initial peak power density (PPD) is 1.21 W cm À2 and rises to 1.81 W cm À2 aer polarization at 750 C for 20 h (Fig. 3a). The increase of voltage by the polarization is particularly remarkable in high current regions above 2 A cm À2 (Fig. 3a). Testing history Step 1. Polarization at 750 C for 20 h in the fuel cell mode ( Fig. 3a and b) Step 1. Polarization at 750 C for 20 h in the fuel cell mode (Fig. S6a, ESI) Step 1. Polarization at 750 C for 20 h in the fuel cell mode (Fig. S6b, ESI) Step 2. Testing of I-V-P curves at 750-550 C (Fig. 3c) Step 2. Testing of I-V-P curves in varied atmospheres at 750 C (Fig. 4) Step 2. Polarization at 750 C for 300 h in the fuel cell mode (Fig. 5a and c) Step 3. Polarization at 600 C for 500 h in the fuel cell mode (Fig. 5b and d) Step 3. Polarization at 750 C for 80 h in the electrolysis mode and for 132 h in the reversible mode (Fig. 6) PPD at 750 C, polarized for 0 h/W cm À2 The increase of PPD is primarily related to the decrease of electrode polarization resistance (R P ), as the cell ohmic resistance (R U ) remains constant at 0.07 U cm 2 . The initial R P is 0.52 U cm 2 and decreases to 0.43 U cm 2 aer polarization for 20 h (Fig. 3b). R U is mainly contributed by the ohmic resistances of the electrolyte, electrodes and contact at the interfaces of electrode/electrolyte and electrode/current collector. The insensitivity of the R U of the decorated ESB-SmCPd electrode to the polarization most likely indicates the instantaneous formation of the electrode/electrolyte interface of the directly assembled ESB-SmCPd electrode during the test. This is very different from the signicant decrease of R U in the case of directly assembled pristine SmC and SmCPd-GDC composite electrodes during the polarization. 21 The impedance spectra consist of two distinctly separable, depressed arcs at a high frequency of $1000 Hz and a low frequency of $0.1 Hz (Fig. 3b), indicating that there are at least two electrode processes. The electrode processes at high and low frequencies can be divided by tting the impedance spectra using an equivalent circuit (see the inset of Fig. 3b). In the equivalent circuit, L is related to an inductance, Q and R represent the constant phase element and electrode polarization resistance, respectively, and subscripts H and L represent the high and low frequency arcs, respectively. The initial R H and R L are 0.29 and 0.23 U cm 2 , and decrease to 0.22 and 0.21 U cm 2 aer polarization at 750 C for 20 h, respectively. Plenty of evidence including our previous studies has demonstrated that the high frequency arc is related to the reaction on the oxygen electrode, while the low frequency arc is related to the reaction on the hydrogen electrode. 16,[50][51][52] Thus the pronounced decrease of R H indicates that the increase of cell performance is mainly due to the enhanced electrocatalytic activity of the decorated ESB-SmCPd oxygen electrode during the polarization. The performance enhancement of the oxygen electrode is probably due to the conversion of Bi 2 SmO 4 to Sm 0.6 Bi 1.4 O 3 during the test at 750 C (see the XRD data in Fig. 2c). Aer polarization at 0.5 A cm À2 and 750 C for 20 h, the cell polarization curves were measured as a function of temperature. The cell produces PPDs of 1.81, 1.12, 0.58, 0.27 and 0.12 W cm À2 at 750, 700, 650, 600 and 550 C, respectively (Fig. 3c). The PPD of 1.81 W cm À2 at 750 C is substantially higher than that of 0.60 W cm À2 in the case of the directly assembled pristine  SmCPd electrode (Fig. S5, ESI †), indicating that the decorated ESB nanoparticles are very effective in enhancing the electrocatalytic activity of SmCPd. Fig. 4 shows the polarization curves of another identical cell (Cell-#2) with the decorated ESB-SmCPd electrode in fuel cell and electrolysis modes with the hydrogen electrodes exposed to different atmospheres. Prior to the test, the cell was polarized at 0.5 A cm À2 and 750 C for 20 h in the fuel cell mode (Table 1 and Fig. S6a, ESI †). In the fuel cell mode, the cell voltage decreases with increasing concentration of H 2 O and CO 2 , and there is an abrupt decrease of voltage at high currents related to concentration polarization when the concentration of H 2 O or CO 2 exceeds 50% (Fig. 4a), due to the excess dilution of reactant (H 2 ) for the reaction in the hydrogen electrode. In contrast, in the  electrolysis mode, the cell performance is enhanced with the increase of concentration of CO 2 and in particular H 2 O (Fig. 4b), due to the increased concentration of reactants (CO 2 and H 2 O) for the electrolysis. The performance of co-electrolysis of 25% CO 2 -25%H 2 O-50%H 2 is in between that of electrolysis of 50% CO 2 -50%H 2 and 50%H 2 O-50%H 2 (Fig. 4c). At an electrolysis voltage of 1.3 V, the current density is 1.24, 1.45 and 1.71 A cm À2 with 50%CO 2 -50%H 2 , 25%CO 2 -25%H 2 O-50%H 2 and 50% H 2 O-50%H 2 , respectively. It is noted that the electrolysis performance is much less sensitive to the concentration of CO 2 than that of H 2 O, most likely due to the greater diffusion coef-cient of CO 2 and poor adsorption capability of CO 2 on the Ni surface. [53][54][55] The electrolysis performance of the cell with the ESB-SmCPd electrode is comparable or even superior to that of the cells with other oxygen electrodes, such as mixed LSM-YSZ composites, 56,57 LSM inltrated YSZ, 58 co-synthesized YSB-LSM, 32 and LSCF-GDC composites. 59 The long-term operating stability of the cell in the fuel cell mode was measured at 0.5 A cm À2 and 750 C (Cell-#3) as well as at 0.25 A cm À2 and 600 C (Cell-#1), and the results are shown in Fig. 5. In the case of the stability test at 750 C, the cell voltage increases in the rst 20 h and decreases very slowly by the further polarization up to 300 h (Fig. 5a). The initial voltage is 0.94 V, and increases to 0.96 V aer polarization for 20 h, but decreases to 0.93 V aer polarization for 300 h. The polarization curves and PPDs of Cell-#3 during the initial polarization for 20 h can be seen in Table 1 and Fig. S6b, ESI. † The performance loss aer polarization for 20 h is due to the increase of both R U and R P . R U and R P are 0.075 and 0.33 U cm 2 aer polarization for 40 h and increase to 0.109 and 0.37 U cm 2 aer polarization for 300 h, respectively (Fig. 5c). The impedance spectra are tted using the aforementioned equivalent circuit (see Fig. 3b). The derived R H and R L are 0.18 and 0.15 U cm 2 aer polarization for 40 h, and change to 0.23 and 0.14 U cm 2 aer polarization for 300 h, respectively. Thus the increase of R P is due to the deteriorated high frequency electrode process which originates from the oxygen electrode as discussed above, indicating that the oxygen electrode is degraded during the polarization at  750 C. On the other hand, at a lower operating temperature of 600 C, the cell is more or less stable during the polarization at 0.25 A cm À2 for a longer period of 500 h (Fig. 5b). Consistently, the impedance spectra are unchanged by the polarization (Fig. 5d). This indicates that under the fuel cell operating conditions, the decorated ESB-SmCPd oxygen electrode is more suitable for operation at a lower temperature of 600 C.
The operating stability of the cell with the decorated ESB-SmCPd electrode (Cell-#2) was also investigated in electrolysis and reversible modes at a current density of 0.5 A cm À2 at 750 C, and the results are shown in Fig. 6. The cell exhibits good stability during the electrolysis operation for 80 h (Fig. 6a), much better than the signicant performance decay in the case of LSM-based oxygen electrodes in the electrolysis mode. [60][61][62][63][64][65] In addition, the reversible operation, i.e., 4 h in the fuel cell mode and 4 h in the electrolysis mode in each cycle is more or less stable over 16 cycles for 132 h (Fig. 6b). The high performance and the excellent operating stability demonstrate that the decorated ESB-SmCPd is a potential active oxygen electrode for durable SOCs. Fig. 7 shows the electrolyte surface in contact with the decorated ESB-SmCPd oxygen electrodes aer the stability tests at 750 and 600 C in the fuel cell mode. In this case, the oxygen electrodes were removed by acid treatment. Aer polarization at 0.5 A cm À2 and 750 C for 300 h (Cell-#3, see Fig. 5a and c), the electrolyte surface is covered by a rough deposition layer and the grain boundaries of the YSZ electrolyte are invisible ( Fig. 7a  and b). On the other hand, aer polarization at 0.25 A cm À2 and 600 C for 500 h (Cell-#1, see Fig. 5b and d), there is no such deposition layer, as is evident by the relatively clean surface and clear grain boundaries (Fig. 7c and d). The electrode was polarized at 750 C for 20 h prior to the stability test at 600 C, and therefore, the clean electrolyte surface indicates that there is no severe interfacial reaction between the oxygen electrode and the YSZ electrolyte during such a short period of test at 750 C. There are also irregularly shaped contact marks on the YSZ electrolyte surface (indicated by the arrows, Fig. 7d), an indication of the in situ formation of the electrode/electrolyte interface under the inuence of electrochemical polarization. The absence of the deposition layer and the presence of contact marks on the electrolyte surface are consistent with the good operating stability at 600 C in the fuel cell mode (see Fig. 5b and d).

Microstructure and cation interdiffusion at the interface
To gain compositional information on the deposition layer on the YSZ electrolyte surface of Cell-#3 aer polarization at 0.5 A cm À2 and 750 C for 300 h (see Fig. 7a), FIB-SEM was used to prepare a lamella sample across the electrolyte surface and the STEM-EDS results are shown in Fig. 8. The electrolyte surface is covered by a dense deposition layer with a loose cluster located on the layer (see the HADDF image, Fig. 8a). The cluster is identied as Pd by EDS analysis (spectrum of spot 1, Fig. 8b). Previous XPS analysis has shown that for asprepared SmCPd, Pd exists in the lattice of the SmCPd perovskite structure. 21 Thus the observation of the Pd phase is because of the occurrence of Pd exsolution out of the SmCPd lattice by the electrochemical polarization. Pd exsolution was also observed in the directly assembled SmCPd-GDC electrode aer the cathodic polarization. 21 The great size of the Pd phase is most likely due to the high tendency of agglomeration and grain growth of Pd at the high operating temperature of SOCs. 66,67 The deposition layer has a nominal composition of Sm 0.53 Er 0.51 Y 0.06 Bi 0.44 Zr 0.46 O 3+d (spectrum of spot 2, Fig. 8b), which may belong to a (Bi,Zr) 2 O 3+d solid solution co-doped with Sm and Er. There is a lack of the conductivity properties of (Bi,Zr) 2 O 3+d in the literature, but its formation probably leads to the increase of cell ohmic resistance aer polarization at 750 C for 300 h (Fig. 5c).
We have successfully synthesized a nanostructured ESB decorated SmCPd composite electrode, which is directly assembled on a barrier-layer-free YSZ electrolyte lm. Although the powder synthesis and cell operation at low temperatures (600-750 C) cannot eliminate the chemical reaction between ESB and SmCPd, forming metastable Bi 2 SmO 4 and later thermodynamically stable Sm 0.6 Bi 1.4 O 3 , the ESB-SmCPd electrode exhibits exceptionally higher electrocatalytic activity in comparison with the pristine SmCPd. This implies that the chemical reaction between ESB and SmCPd is not that harmful as originally expected. More importantly, the partial consumption of ESB and formation of a new Sm 0.6 Bi 1.4 O 3 phase in the composite electrode are benecial to the stable operation in particular at 600 C for 500 h (Fig. 5b). In the case of ESB, it tends to undergo drastic conductivity degradation at 600 C and below, due to the transformation in the arrangement of oxygen vacancies from the disordered state to the ordered state 68 or due to the transformation from the cubic phase to the rhombohedral phase. 69 On the other hand, the consequence of losing the highly ion conductive ESB phase is that at a reduced temperature of 650 C and below, the cell performance with ESB decorated SmCPd is lower than that with ESB decorated LSM 33 (PPDs at 650 C: 0.58 vs. 0.71 W cm À2 , see Fig. S7, ESI †). This is most likely due to the higher activation energy for the electrocatalytic reaction on decorated ESB-SmCPd than on decorated ESB-LSM ( Fig. S8 and S9, ESI †). In the decorated ESB-LSM electrode, ESB is retained due to its chemical compatibility with LSM. 33

Conclusions
Nanostructured ESB decorated SmCPd is investigated as a potential oxygen electrode for SOCs and directly assembled on a barrier-layer-free YSZ electrolyte lm. A metastable Bi 2 SmO 4 phase is formed in the decorated ESB-SmCPd and is transformed to Sm 0.6 Bi 1.4 O 3 aer dwelling at 750 C. The presence of Sm 0.6 Bi 1.4 O 3 in the decorated ESB-SmCPd oxygen electrode has no detrimental effect on the electrode activity, as the cells with the directly assembled ESB-SmCPd oxygen electrodes exhibit exceptionally high electrocatalytic activity and operating stability for power generation and high temperature electrolysis, with excellent stability at 600 C for 500 h in the fuel cell mode, and in electrolysis and reversible modes at 750 C for over 200 h. The present study demonstrates the feasibility of developing a Sr-free cobaltite oxygen electrode combined with bismuth oxide for active and stable SOCs.

Conflicts of interest
There are no conicts to declare.