Correction: The potential of paper-based diagnostics to meet the ASSURED criteria

Correction for ‘The potential of paper-based diagnostics to meet the ASSURED criteria’ by Suzanne Smith et al., RSC Adv., 2018, 8, 34012–34034.


Introduction
In recent years, there has been a drive to develop low-cost, innovative point-of-care diagnostics to reach populations where the burden of disease is greatest, and where resources are fewest.These developments have been guided by the World Health Organization (WHO), through formalization of the ASSURED criteria -Affordable, Sensitive, Specic, User friendly, Rapid and Robust, Equipment-free and Deliverable to end users to which these diagnostics should conform if they are to be successful in resource-limited settings. 1Here, we review we explore various printed functional components that are currently available or under development towards achieving diagnostics that fulll these criteria.
Paper-based microuidics provide a favourable platform on which to develop solutions that address these requirements, 2,3 with paper exhibiting a number of useful properties that are either inherent or that can be achieved through straightforward modications.This includes the low cost, recyclability and disposability of paper to provide devices that can easily be transported, distributed, and safely incinerated.Paper enables automated uidic handling through a porous substrate, with simple, visual result readout by the user typically implemented via a colour change.Paper-based solutions also facilitate high quality mass manufacturing which is based on a long tradition of paper processing.
Printed functionality can be incorporated with these devices, stemming from printed materials development and printed electronics elds [4][5][6][7] to result in devices with enhanced userfriendliness through automated result read-out and communication.This also removes the need for training or external instrumentation to correctly perform a test.Building blocks from the eld of printed electronics, such as sensors, processors, displays, connectivity and power have the potential to be incorporated to extend the functionality of these devices.
Paper-based solutions have successfully been applied to health, environmental and food quality monitoring. 8,9Colorimetric, electrochemical, or uorescence based analysis methods 10 are typically used, relying on either external equipment for analysis, or on visual colorimetric read-out, with the latter being prone to errors and typically not providing quantitative results.More sophisticated result read-out generally requires some form of external instrumentation to perform processing and communication of the result from the paperbased test 11 (Fig. 1).Common methods include the use of existing devices such as scanners, portable glucose meters and mobile phones, 12,13 as well as custom-developed systems such as portable potentiostats, [14][15][16] many of which have been extensively reviewed. 2imited network and maintenance infrastructure, intermittent power, and issues with reliable storage in resource-limited settings create challenges in the successful implementation of instrumented solutions.This highlights the need for quantitative detection, read-out and connectivity to be integrated in to an automated, maintenance-free system, ideally incorporated on the diagnostic device itself.For such a solution, the result would need to be expressed to the user, possibly through a visual display on the device.
Capturing, conveying and storing of the test results would also be required, as this is a signicant challenge in point-ofcare testing, particularly in South African clinics. 17,18Visualbased tests such as standard lateral ow test strips are subject to user bias, with incorrect result readout a common occurrence. 19Additionally, these manual tests do not allow for effective communication of the result or diagnosis, or for data collection for assessment of epidemics or therapy strategies.Automated result readout and communication would enable this data to be captured and analysed, contributing to various health system needs.To facilitate the effective implementation of read-out, displays and communication modules, on-board Dr Dario Mager leads the lowcost MEMS group at IMT at KIT in Germany.For his work on the fabrication of microstructures using inkjet printing he obtained his PhD in MEMS at the University of Freiburg (IMTEK), Germany.He and his team work on MEMS devices that can be fabricated without a cleanroom.The naturally lower level of quality is compensated by using embedded systems for better signal readout and analysis.In this context, the most complex system is the eLoaD platform where centrifugal microuidics are enhanced through the co-integration of embedded systems in the spinning frame of reference.Dr Kevin Land is the platform leader of the microsystems technology group at the CSIR in South Africa.Kevin established the microsystems and micro-uidics technology capabilities at CSIR.Dr Kevin Land obtained a PhD in Microsystems Engineering through the Institute for Microsystems Technology (Imtek), University of Freiburg, Germany, where the main focus was on the development of microuidic droplet systems.He has a passion to develop equipment free or minimally instrumented low cost diagnostics solutions utilising printed functionality, low cost substrates and microuidicsparticularly for developing countries where such solutions would have massively transformative impact and have the opportunity to reach billions of people.

Microfluidics and sample processing
Paper tests such as pH strips and home-based lateral ow pregnancy tests are examples of the rst and most common paper-based microuidic devices 3 (Fig. 3A).Enhanced functionality such as multiplexing and multi-dimensional uidic handling can be garnered from advances in paper-based microuidics, also referred to as microuidic paper-based analytical devices (mPADs), 20 through multi-channel designs within a paper substrate (Fig. 3B), or by stacking and folding of paper in to so-called three-dimensional or "origami" paperbased microuidics 10 (Fig. 3C and D).Wax printing of uidic channels is oen implemented using hydrophobic barriers to contain and guide uids through a paper device.Inkjet printing, screen printing and exographic printing have also been utilized. 21,22Modications in the composition of the paper substrate allow for heightened functionality of paper-based diagnostics 23 and printing of paper substrates themselves are currently being explored, for example by using printable nanocellulose pulp.The use of nanocellulose for implementing printed electronics has gained attention 6 and along with advances in paper-based microuidics and diagnostics, 2,22 forms the foundation on which to further develop augmented printed functionality for paper-based diagnostics.
Paper-based microuidics allow for functions such as sample ltering, uidic movement and splitting of uids in to different reaction zones for multiplexed testing to be achieved, and have been implemented for various biological samples including whole blood, serum, urine and nasal swabs. 2 These paper-based microuidics have been integrated with a variety of sensors for electrochemical, colorimetric or other detection techniques 3 to achieve automated sample processing and detection components towards the envisaged ASSURED device shown in Fig. 2.

Electronics
Augmented functionality for paper-based diagnostics will require a number of individual printed passive and active electronic components to build up more complex electronic circuitry and enable processing capabilities for read-out of results.Advances in printed electronics 24,25 provide both hybrid and fully printed approaches (Fig. 4) on exible, paper-based substrates using printing methods such as screen, inkjet, gravure, exographic, off-set, slot-die, transfer printing, as well as micro-contact and nanoimprinting. 5,26arallels can be drawn between printed electronics and integrated circuit (IC) manufacturing technologies, where in the 1960s, achievable IC lithography line widths were in the region Fig. 2 (A) Envisaged integrated ASSURED device with various functional modules indicated, and (B) graphical summary of the review highlighting the printed functionalities that can be utilized to realize integrated, ASSURED devices. of 10 mm.This is similar to the resolution limit currently achievable using printing technologies such as inkjet printing for electronics, 27 highlighting the signicant progress still required by printed and paper-based electronics.Hybrid printed electronics combine printed, exible electronics with existing IC technologies, with successful integration of bare dies with printed electronics a possibility, improving the exibility and lowering the cost of the circuit.Advances in resolution limits for printed electronics continue to be made, and fully printable components realized, including gravure printed transistors with channel widths as small as 5 mm. 28onductive silver, copper or carbon-based inks are typically used to print electronic tracks, electrodes and antennas.Transparent conductors such as indium tin oxide (ITO) and more recently poly(3,4-ethylenedioxythiophene) polystyrene sulfonate (PEDOT:PSS) and graphene are utilized in printing of components such as solar cells and organic light-emitting diodes (OLEDs). 27Once printed, UV or low-temperature curing is used to remove the solvent and form solid, conductive features that adhere to the substrate.Additional printed materials include semi-conductors and dielectrics. 5,26Both inorganic and organic materials can be printed, and various commercially available functional inks enable printed functionality to be implemented.Control of geometrical dimensions is important for realizing functional printed electronics, and thus a balance between the printed functionality and the substrate suitability to paper-based diagnostics can prove challenging and continues to be explored. 5,29

Hybrid printed electronics
A hybrid approach involves utilizing existing surface mount device (SMD) packaged electronic componentsfrom resistors to light-emitting diodes (LEDs) and ICsthat can be mounted on to printed tracks on exible paper substrates [30][31][32] (Fig. 4A).Low temperature soldering, conductive epoxies and crimping can be used to secure and connect the components to the printed tracks, and compatibility of these with the paper substrate is an important consideration.The rigidity of the packaged components can also limit the exibility of the device, but bare die formats or small, thin and exible packaging can alleviate these challenges to a certain extent.Integration using pick and place equipment for the components is feasible, 27 but in smaller quantities, remains a manual process.

Printed electronic components
4][35] Temperature, bending, and moisture, among other factors, can affect the performance and repeatability of these components. 27.2.1 Resistors.Resistors can be printed simply by varying the resistivity and geometrical dimensions (length, cross sectional area) of a conductive inktypically carbonthat is printed over the ends of two metallic conductive track terminals (Fig. 4B).Dimensions for widths and lengths are typically in the mm range with heights in the mm range, depending on the printing technique chosen. 27The simple design and manufacture process enables various resistor values to be realized as fully printable, accurate and repeatable resistive components that can easily be integrated in to existing printed electronic solutions. 34,36.2.2Capacitors.Interdigitated capacitors can be implemented through lateral printed structures consisting of ngerlike or comb designs.Capacitances achievable with these designs are limited to the picofarad (pF) range.In cases where greater capacitances are required, stacked structures can be utilized to achieve capacitance values in the nanofarad (nF) range.In these designs, a dielectric layer is printed between two conducting electrode layers (Fig. 4C).Thicknesses of at least 5 mm are typically used for the dielectric layers, oen printed in multiple layers to prevent short circuits.Typical values for standard printing processes are less than 5 nF, but values in the mF range can be achieved in special cases. 27.2.3Inductors.Inductors can be realized by surrounding an enclosed area, for example, by printing planar square or circular spiral shapes [33][34][35] (Fig. 4D).The total inductance is calculated from the self-inductances of the straight segments of the spiral shape, as well as the mutual inductances resulting from the magnetic elds of adjacent branches of the inductor.27 The conductivity of the spiral track as well as the width and length of the track segments affect the resistance and thus the quality factor of the inductor, and printing resolution is key.Multilayer printing and alignment is required to provide a connection from the inside of the spiral to the outside of the inductor shape across a good insulator to avoid leakage current.Typical values achievable are in the range of a few mH for inductors operating at 100 kHz.27 3.2.4 Transstors.Transistors are important in almost all electronic systems as switches or ampliers.Printed transistors make use of multilayer printing processes and different materials 37,38 and typically mimic the functionality of a eld-effect transistor.They consist of a gate, drain and source, with dielectric and semiconductor layers (Fig. 4E).Paper-based inorganic and organic transistorsthe latter with an organic semi-conductorhave been developed.Cellulose-based paper is oen used as a substrate or a gate dielectric for paper-based transistors, where the gate electrode can be printed on one side of the paper and the semiconductor and source/drain electrodes on the other.39 Some examples include inkjetprinted organic transistors 40,41 and exible, transparent transistors on nanopaper, 42 as well as more recent exible inorganic/organic hybrid transistors that showcase high performance.43 Low-cost arrays of printed transistors on to paper substrates have also been demonstrated.44 Printing resolution of transistors remains an important consideration to achieve the desired performance, but gravure printed transistors with channel widths of as low as 5 mm have been realized, 28 showing promise for this area of development.
Electrochemical transistors (ECTs) are gated by an electrolyte and show promise for ASSURED devices as they operate at low potentials, typically around 0.5 to 2 V. ECTs have been implemented in disposable alcohol breathalizers, 45 wearable biosensors 46 and have been developed with fast switching times by Acreo and Linköping University 47 for use in logic circuits and active-matrix displays.
Crucial parameters still to be optimized for paper-based transistors include low operation voltages, high stability and high carrier mobility, with nanopaper showing promise as a potential substrate to address these challenges. 48ully printed electronics cannot currently compete with silicon electronic technologies in terms of speed, and thus new technologies for exible, thin silicon devices are being developed towards a Moore's Law for exible electronics. 49This would map a path for the mass production of more and more densely populated exible circuits.Initial developments utilize metal oxide semiconductors to create thin lm transistors that move charge signicantly faster than their organic counterparts, and can be fabricated at room temperature.Integration of these advances with other paper-based functional components would remain a critical challenge in future developments.
While fully printed electronics continue to advance in terms of performance, hybrid solutions with both printed and existing packaged components can already implement many unit operations to build up electronic circuits on paper-based devices.These could be used as building blocks as part of sensors, processors, display and connectivity components in an automated, integrated paper-based ASSURED diagnostic device.

Actuation and control
User interaction with the integrated paper-based diagnostic device will enable the test to be initiated or operational steps to be performed.Both electronic and uidic switches and valves can be implemented for paper-based devices.Commercial exible membrane switches provide a simple solution using printed conductive tracks with spacers that cause the switch to close when the button is pressed (Fig. 5A), while uidic switches for timing, programming and other functional uidic control in paper devices have been explored 10,20,32,50 (Fig. 5B).

Motion
Fluidic movement in paper-based devices is facilitated by the inherent capillary action that paper exhibits and can be enhanced through uidic switching and ow patterns in paper, as previously mentioned.Motion can also be achieved through physical actuators and piezoelectrics implemented on paper.
Paper-based actuators enable physical movement to be realized on paper devices by undergoing dimensional changes as a result of moisture variations, 32 r can be implemented using electroosmotic actuators, 51 oen made from cellulose and hybrid materials. 52High-performance paper actuators using standard printing paper and based on electrothermal activation have recently been demonstrated 53 (Fig. 5C).The low voltage, power and temperature requirements of these actuators are thus well-suited for application in low-cost paper-based diagnostics where additional movement or control may be required.
Piezoelectric papers have been developed, with examples made from functionalized wood cellulose bers 54 and are typically used for pressure and force sensing applications, 55 which are discussed in Section 5. Piezoelectric papers with high exibility and tensile strength have been realized for use as tactile sensors, 56 similar to membrane switches and push-buttons for actuation.Environmentally friendly piezoelectric paper for sensing and actuation has also been developed, with actuation of paper cantilevers presented as an example application. 57This contributes to the development of environmentally friendly micro-electro-mechanical systems (MEMS) with improved foldability and affordability, and which are well-suited to the progression of robust and low-cost point-of-care paper-based diagnostic solutions.
Mechanical actuation using buttons, switches and movement could already be integrated with paper-based diagnostic devices in a straightforward manner for user interaction with the device.Fluidic actuation requires more precise implementation and integration considerations, but is also feasible for assisting with sample introduction and processing.

Heating on paper
Heating is important in various chemical and biological reactions and can facilitate sample concentration on paper through evaporation of liquids, or can support the implementation of valves on paper-based devices. 58,59Advances in materials for printed resistors allows for pastes with either positive or negative temperature coefficients to be printed.These inks can be used as self-regulating heating elements, where a specied temperature can be reached and maintained when a current is applied, without the need for additional control and regulating circuitry (Fig. 5D).Carbon nanotubes have also been printed on paper and textiles to implement heating elements. 60aper-based heaters assist in sample preparation and processing, e.g. for implementing controlled heating cycles for polymerase chain reaction (PCR), towards fully ASSURED devices.Paper-based heaters could also be implemented onboard an ASSURED device for effective control of thermochromic displays (Section 7) to display a result to the user.Effective paper-based heater prototypes operating from a 5 V supply can reach temperatures of over 50 C.These devices can be implemented directly as part of integrated ASSURED devices, contributing to sample processing and display components.

Sensing
Integrated sensing or detection techniques for paper-based diagnostics include colorimetric, electrochemical, electrical conductivity and chemiluminescent methods. 8Printed sensors on exible substrates 61 and printed MEMS 62 have been comprehensively reviewed.Printed resistive sensors form a large part of the printed sensing capabilities on paper substrates where foldable, low-cost designs 36 and multisensory platforms for temperature, humidity, pressure, pH and ow have been implemented. 63

Electrochemical sensors
Electrochemistry is a powerful tool for health and environmental diagnostics, and various paper-based electrochemical sensors have been explored. 64,65Electrochemical sensors typically consist of a working electrode (WE), counter electrode (CE) and reference electrode (RE).WE and CE are oen implemented using carbon-based materials (Fig. 6A), including graphenebased pastes. 66Simple screen printing techniques are oen used to implement electrochemical sensors directly on to paperbased diagnostic tests.Materials development for printed and wearable electrochemical sensors have seen extensive growth, 7 with examples for diagnostic applications ranging from water quality monitoring 67 to cancer detection. 68aper-based electrochemical sensors have been successfully implemented for detection of glucose, diabetes markers total and glycated haemoglobin (HbA1c) and heavy metals in serum, 69 showing high sensitivity within clinically relevant ranges.Stability, accuracy and shelf life of paper-based electrochemical sensors need to be explored but show promise as effective on-board sensors for ASSURED paper-based diagnostics.However, these sensors require electrochemical analysis instrumentation, currently implemented using portable potentiostat systems or smart phones.In future these could be replaced by printed electronic processing components, with an example of a hybrid printed, paper-based potentiostat recently showcased. 70These could be integrated into ASSURED devices in the long-term, along with printed read out components to display the result.

Temperature, humidity and gas sensors
Measurement of environmental parameters plays an important role in paper-based diagnostics.Printed temperature sensors or thermometers consist of temperature sensitive printed resistors, where changes in temperature cause variations in the resistance (Fig. 6B).Examples using both inkjet and screen printing on to various exible substrates including polyethylene terephthalate (PET), paper and fabric have been presented. 61emperature sensitive luminescence indicators with laminated paper devices have also been illustrated to give visual temperature readouts. 71Commercial printed temperature sensor examples on PET substrates by Thinlm in conjunction with Printed Sensor Technologies (PST) 72 use novel silicone inks and show high reliability.Different types of humidity sensors include resistive, colorimetric, capacitive or surface acoustic wave (SAW). 73Capacitive type sensors are linear, require less complex circuitry and can operate over a wide range of humidity.These sensors detect a change in relative permittivity of the surrounding medium, where an increase in capacitance indicates an increase in moisture content 27 (Fig. 6C).Different capacitor structures such as parallel plates, meshes and interdigitated designs can be utilized for humidity sensing.Successful printing of humidity sensors on to cardboard and recycled substrates has been demonstrated 73 and a paper-based electrical respiration sensor based on moisture content serves as a recent example with direct point-of-care applications. 74Paper-based humidity sensors for effective detection in the range of 20-90% rH and with lifetimes of up to 4 months have been demonstrated, 75 showing potential for direct integration into ASSURED devices.
Gas sensors were rst focussed on humidity sensing, but have been expanded through the development of printable gas sensitive lms. 61Flexible gas sensors (Fig. 6D) typically utilize resistive or capacitive sensors printed using specialized materials such as semi-conductive nanoparticle inks and solid electrolyte inks. 27Examples include resistive nitrogen oxide gas sensors, capacitive hydrogen gas sensors, carbon monoxide and oxygen sensors.A exible ammonia gas (NH 3 ) sensor on photo paper showed high stability over several months, 76 while an inkjet printed paper-based wireless humidity and hydrogen sulphide gas (H 2 S) sensor 77 illustrated the feasibility of incorporating various passive, wireless sensors into an integrated paper-based device.

Pressure, touch and proximity sensors
These sensors are applicable to paper-based diagnostics for detection of environmental surroundings, device handling and for user interaction.Similar to humidity sensing, available printed touch sensor technologies include capacitive, resistive, optical touch, acoustic wave, infrared, and others, each suited to different applications. 27The low cost of implementing resistive sensors makes this a favourable technology, followed by capacitive sensing.Piezoelectric papers have been developed for force and pressure sensing applications, 55 and are also discussed in Section 4. Examples such as graphite paper-based piezo-resistive sensors 78 and touch and proximity sensors printed on paper-based substrates 79 show promise for ease of implementation and integration with paper-based diagnostics.
Wearable pressure sensors realized using gold nanowires on tissue paper have shown high sensitivity for blood pulse monitoring, as well as for detecting the weight distribution of small objects across an array of pressure sensors. 80Printed pressure sensitive inks are commercially available, and can be used for large area pressure sensing in various form factors. 5 The resistance of the ink varies with the force applied to the printed ink surface with a common design approach making use of interdigitated electrodes as a base layer with the pressure sensitive material printed over the top (Fig. 6E).
A paper-based 5 Â 5 bimodal sensor has recently been demonstrated for temperature and pressure sensing 81 using conductive inks and carbon nanotubes.Temperature sensing capabilities were demonstrated over a range of 150 C, along with high pressure sensitivity over a range of 100 Pa to 5 kPa with high endurance characteristics.The application proposed is for electronic skin, and shows promise for ease of integration with ASSURED paper-based devices to achieve various sensing capabilities in a single, paper-based device.

Light and image sensors
Printable light sensors or photodetectors have recently been developed 82,83 and are typically realized by an organic (or less commonly inorganic) photoactive layer between two transparent electrodes 61 (Fig. 6F).Applications of printed photodetectors include industrial and medical large-area sensing, particularly for colour detection, with potential application to colorimetric detection implemented on paper-based diagnostic devices.In addition, security features for condential diagnostic testing could potentially be implemented through nger print imaging which could be integrated as part of future envisaged paper-based diagnostic devices.
Photodetectors printed on to paper have been demonstrated, 84 along with inkjet-printed photodiodes, 85,86 UV photodetectors and infrared sensors. 62An overview of the components and integration of these in to a functional exible image sensor have also been showcased, 87,88 consisting of photodiodes integrated with organic thin lm transistors in an active matrix (Fig. 6F).This technology is in the process of being commercialized 89 for a sensor with a 4 cm Â 4 cm active area. 90 low-cost, broadband, paper-based photodetector using ZnS-MoS 2 has recently been presented. 91The demonstrated sensitivity over a broad spectrum shows promise for development of large-scale, low-cost paper-based photodetectors.These devices could be utilized in integrated ASSURED devices for colorimetric readout of paper-based microuidic results.

Data processing and storage
Once detection has taken place, automated and accurate analysis would be ideal for paper-based diagnostics to provide a quantitative, error-free result without requiring user skills or training.Printed components for computational functions are thus required, and both hybrid (Section 3.1) and fully printed solutions have been explored.Hybrid printed or paper-based solutions using existing packaged integrated circuits or die formats of integrated circuits enable the same processing capabilities to be achieved as with traditional electronics, but connection issues between components and exible paper substrates can pose challenges.

Integrated circuits
Processing and amplication stages have been implemented through printed high gain ampliers and digital-to-analogue (DAC) converters, 34 as well as ring oscillator circuits. 92Printed programmable logic circuits have been realized using transistor arrays 93 (Fig. 7A) to demonstrate a ring oscillator, a D-type ip-op memory element, a demultiplexer and a programmable array logic device.Medium-scale integrated circuits consisting of 100 transistors have been showcased, 94 as well as inkjetprinted thin lm microprocessors 95 which can be programmed aer manufacture via inkjet printing.Successful printed ring-oscillators in the range of kHz have been demonstrated, showing promise for complex analogue-to-digital converters (ADCs). 96he development of paper-based transistors, as discussed in Section 3.2.4,will be key in the advances of paper-based integrated circuits.Robust and fast paper-based transistors will enable integrated circuits to be implemented for processing in ASSURED devices, and could be operated using on-board printed energy sources if low operation voltages are achieved.

Memory components
Data storage requirements are an important consideration for sensor data and user input logging.Printed memory functionality has been demonstrated, commonly by applying a current to keep a stored memory state in a transistor.Printed memristors undergo resistance changes in response to an applied current, only requiring a current to change the state, not to keep it, as in the case of a transistor.Memristors are thus advantageous as printed memory components as they are more energy efficient and physically smaller than transistors.Memristors consist of two conductive electrodes with a thin layer of memristive material (typically a titanium oxide derivative) between them and have been inkjet printed on plastic substrates successfully. 97rite once read many (WORM) memory has also been implemented in printed form 98 to allow for more complex memory functionality, including moderate bit counts and read and write functionality. 90Inkjet printing and large scale rollto-roll fabrication using gravure and exography methods have been implemented successfully for this technology. 27hese developments show promise for complex printed integrated circuits to be produced in large volumes and become commercially implemented.Rewritable resistive switching techniques for printed memory have been showcased, 99 with a number of paper-based memory devices demonstrated 100,101 (Fig. 7B).
Paper-based, foldable and disposable memory with a low voltage operation of 1.5 V has been shown, 101 which would allow for on-board battery operation if integrated as part of an ASSURED paper-based device.Additionally, memory performance was maintained up to 100 s of switching cycles aer folding tests were carried out, showing robust and repeatable characteristics that align well with the ASSURED principles.Advances in printing on to paper substrates to improve conductivity, foldability and disposability, 102 will drive effective printed, paper-based data processing and storage systems.

Read out and display
Result read-out is important to provide the user with feedback from a diagnostic test and to digitize the result for further communication, processing and storage.Various current printed display technologies 103,104 can be explored to fulll this role.

Paper-based microuidic visual indicators
Displays that are built in to the paper-based test device itself through chemical reactions and biological processes can be utilized (Fig. 8A).Detection principles such as chemiluminescence, where light is generated based on a chemical reaction, have also successfully been showcased.These techniques are advantageous as they do not require an excitation source, as in the case of uorescence.Comprehensive reviews of read-out and display techniques implemented for paper-based diagnostics summarize recent developments in this eld. 2,3hese techniques have been successfully integrated with paperbased diagnostics towards fully ASSURED solutions, such as a commercial example by haemokinesis105 for blood typing using visual text readout generated from the sample.

Thermochromic displays
Thermochromic readouts were some of the earliest examples of displays on paper-based platforms 106 (Fig. 8B).Seven-segment displays on photopaper 107 and successful integration with paper-based diagnostics 2 using thermochromic techniques have been demonstrated.Thermochromic ink is patterned on to one side of a paper substrate with conducting wires on the opposite, so that when a current is passed through the wires, the thermochromic ink is heated and causes a colour change which is usually reversible.Visual graphics using these techniques are advantageous over text to maximize successful user interpretation, particularly in multilingual or illiterate environments.Although these solutions utilize low-cost materials, analytical applications using this technology have not yet been demonstrated, likely as a result of the high currents (>25 mA) typically necessary for visible changes in thermochromic displays to occur. 2 In addition, environmental temperature plays a role in device functionality and will need to be Fig.7 Printed data processing and storage functionality.(A) Printed integrated circuits and processors, typically constructed from various printed transistor combinations.(B) Memory components, with individual printed units constructed from printed conductive electrodes with a resistive switching material in between.When implemented in a matrix format, a printed conductive electrode matrix can be implemented, with individual printed resistive switching pixels which can each be set to 1 or 0 values by applying positive or negative voltages, respectively.investigated if successful integration with paper-based ASSURED devices is to be realized.

Electrochromic displays
Electrochromic displays (ECDs) operate similarly to thermochromic displays by converting an electrical signal in to an optical readout.A colour change occurs when an electron is gained or lost as a result of an applied current or potential.Reversing the polarity of the voltage causes the material to change back to its original colour.The electrochromic material must be in contact with the electrode and the electrolyte layer to exchange both electrons and ions, respectively (Fig. 8C).Alternatively, the electrochromic material can be dispersed in the electrolyte layer.ECDs can be operated in transmittance or reectance mode, the latter being likely for paper-based implementations.Colour is controlled by the amount of voltage and polarity applied to the electrode terminals, 27 enabling matrix addressed ECD displays to be implemented [108][109][110] (Fig. 8C).Commercialization of printed ECDs has been explored by Ynvisible, Acreo and NTera. 27lectrochromic read-out in an integrated paper-based device with a paper battery and electrochemical sensor using Prussian blue has been showcased, 111 with a more recent example to visually represent changes in resistive sensors. 112The system enables semi-quantitative readout of voltage or resistance changes produced in the circuit, ranging from À0.5 V to À2 V for distance and counting based implementations.The limited detectable resolution could be further explored, but already shows promise for applications towards fully integrated paper-based ASSURED devices.Light is emitted by the active material in response to a voltage applied across the electrodes.(E) Electroluminescent displays, with individual units consisting of a conductive electrode on the paper substrate, followed by a printed dielectric layer, a phosphor material and a top transparent electrode.Light is emitted in response to an electric field.(F) Organic light-emitting diodes (OLEDs) consist of two electrodes with a conductive material and an emissive electroluminescent material in between.The latter emits light through the top transparent electrode in response to a current applied at the electrodes.(G) Electrophoretic displays consist of charged black and white particles that change orientation in response to an applied electric field.

Light emitting electrochemical cells
Flexible, lightweight display modules on paper substrates can be effectively implemented using light emitting electrochemical cells (LECs).LECs are typically made up of an anode, cathode and active material which generates light when a voltage is applied (Fig. 8D).Low operational voltage requirements and airstable electrodes make LECs power efficient with simplied encapsulation requirements. 113These advantages in addition to the compatibility of LECs with paper substrates make this a promising emerging display technology for low-cost, paperbased point-of-care diagnostics.
Different types of paper have been utilized, including standard printing paper, where the fabrication of LECs did not require specialized processing. 114A light emitting textile device using LEC technology has also been presented, 115 with potential applications to brous paper-based diagnostic substrates.Recent advances have resulted in multi-coloured LEC fabrication towards low-cost light sources with high luminance. 116oltages required were approximately 3 V, enabling effective lighting that could be achieved using battery power to realize visual indicators on ASSURED devices.A recent example of biocompatible LECs 117 contributes to the long-term goal of disposable and environmentally friendly ASSURED devices.

Electroluminescent displays
Electroluminescence enables a material to emit light in response to an electrical current or a strong electrical eld.Electroluminescent displays (ELDs) consist of one or more layers of inorganic phosphor and insulator stacks sandwiched between two electrodes (an anode and cathode) that emit light when exposed to an electric eld (Fig. 8E).Different types of electroluminescent displays include powder or thick-im displays, thin-lm displays, and hybrids of these.Powder electroluminescent displays have been successfully fabricated on different paper substrates, including glossy, sticker, newspaper and magazine papers. 118These devices showed satisfactory luminance values for realizing clear visual illumination on lowcost paper substrates.Commercial electroluminescent displays can provide uniform light over relatively large areas and can be manufactured in to thin structures using power efficiently. 104lthough electroluminescent displays usually require small amounts of current to operate, high driving voltages are required, which could be challenging to implement for standalone, integrated ASSURED devices.

Electrochemiluminescent displays
Electrochemiluminescence (ECL) is a derivative of chemiluminescence, where the signal is generated from an electrochemical reaction.Electrochemiluminescent read out thus offers a higher degree of control by the user than purely reaction-based chemiluminescence, but requires power to apply a potential.Existing examples of electrochemiluminescence in paper-based diagnostics usually require external instrumentation to apply voltages, and to read out and quantify the emitted signal. 2 Various power supply methods, including thermal-powered, self-powered, wireless and light-powered methods including digital cameras and smartphones can be implemented as discussed in recent reviews. 119,120ECL readout in paper-based microuidic devices have been successfully implemented for detection of DNA, proteins and cancer cells, for example, and have utilized smart phones for powering the reaction and detecting the result using built-in cameras. 119This shows promise for integration of ECL detection and readout on ASSURED paper-based diagnostics, with low power requirements for ease of visual readout being feasible.

Organic light emitting diodes (OLEDs)
OLEDs enable exible and printable lighting and display solutions. 104A layer of organic material is sandwiched between two conductors (an anode and a cathode) (Fig. 8F).The organic layer of emissive electroluminescent enables bright red, green and blue light to be emitted in response to an electric current. 27LEDs differ from ELDs in that the light emitting material is organic, compared with the inorganic phosphors in ELDs.Inkjet printing has enabled mass production of exible OLED devices through fast deposition of organic material without further patterning required.Encapsulation for protection from moisture and oxygen are important design considerations in the printing of OLED displays. 27The development of paperbased OLEDs has been limited as a result of the high sensitivity of OLED active materials requiring exact thicknesses, which can be difficult to achieve on paper, 114 but functional, exible OLEDs fabricated using standard printing paper 121 and transparent cellulose substrates 122 have been presented.OLEDs manufactured on cellulose exhibited constant current and power efficiencies in ranges of 10 to 100 mA and 4 to 8 V.These devices could be integrated as part of low-cost, exible ASSURED paper-based diagnostics for visual feedback or result readout, making use of on-board battery power and an environmentally friendly approach.

Electrophoretic displays
Electrophoretic materials form shapes by rearranging charged pigment particles using an electric eld, as opposed to emitting light.Positively and negatively charged black and white particles that are bistable are suspended in liquid and allow for print quality resolution to be achieved. 104(Fig. 8G) Electrophoretic displays (EPDs) are found in e-book readers, watches and other electronic displays with additional colours recently becoming available. 123EPDs only consume power when the display is being updated and provide high quality readability regardless of lighting conditions, and are thus well-suited for point-of-care diagnostics in under-resourced settings.Although EPDs are commercially available, they have not been implemented directly on to paper substrates and thus integration of this technology with paper-based diagnostics has not yet been explored.
A merge between uidics and display technologies has been shown through electrowetting displays on paper, 124 and elec-trouidic displays. 125Advances in organic light emitting transistors (OLETs) that combine the light emitting capabilities of an OLED with the switching capabilities of transistors show promise as a printable display applicable to various substrates, including paper. 27

Connectivity
Communication of the result from the paper-based diagnostic device will be required for effective result recording and ling of information towards an integrated solution.Connections between paper devices and external instrumentation can be achieved through physical connectors and cables, including disposable USB connectors on paper 126 (Fig. 9A).
Wireless communication technologies are particularly advantageous for under-resourced settings, as they eliminate the need for physical connections to instrumentation and prevent contamination.The evolution of the internet of things (IoT) has resulted in a drive to include connectivity between devices and systems. 127Various wireless technologies can provide connectivity for paper-based diagnostic devices, with passive technologies such as radio-frequency identication (RFID) being attractive options as these are low-power, printable, low-cost, and thus ideally suited to paper-based diagnostic devices.Other technologies include near eld communication (NFC), Bluetooth, WiFi, ZigBee, Infrared, and cellular technologies such as 3G and 4G, 128 each making use of different standards, frequency ranges and operational distance ranges.Passive short range communication technologies such as RFID and NFC are better suited from a low-cost, disposable device perspective, where power is not required on the device itself, and have been applied to point-of-care solutions for implantable, wearable and hand-held wireless biosensors. 102,129RFID technologies have also been highlighted as benecial solutions for rural e-Health systems 130 and have been used in hospitals for patient monitoring with some success. 131Recently, privacy preservation in RFID systems for healthcare has also been pursued, 132 to enable a secure, condential method of data communication and storage.
RFID is well-suited to paper-based diagnostics as the tag antennas are printable and paper is well-suited for ultra-high frequency (UHF) and microwave applications. 133Printing of antennas [133][134][135][136][137] and specically RFID tags [138][139][140][141][142][143] on to low-cost paper and cardboard substrates has been investigated using both inkjet and screen printing techniques (Fig. 9B).Combinations of RF, microuidics and inkjet printing technologies to implement wireless sensing platforms that are activated by uids in microuidic channels have also been studied. 144,145luids can be used to activate or control the properties of the antennas.
Sensing RFID systems have evolved in recent years, 146 adding to the value proposition of RFID technologies for integrated sensing and connectivity of paper-based diagnostics.Some paper-based communication and sensing modules that have been implemented include patch antennas, UHF oscillators, mixers and frequency doublers, 147 which make up a variety of communication capabilities.In addition, paperbased microuidics have been integrated with selfassembling RFID tags to create a self-powered biosensing platform. 148Commercially available NFC RFID tags embedded in to paper substrates are also available 149 for various applications.These technologies can be integrated with paperbased ASSURED devices in their current form to enable effective wireless communication of information and results from the disposable diagnostic devices for processing and storage.Where wireless power transmission will not suffice to drive the various components of integrated ASSURED paper-based diagnostic devices, built-in power will be required.Printed energy storage developments have led to some commercial examples as well as integration with paper-based diagnostics, with a number of reviews highlighting the progress made, [150][151][152][153] along with various integration considerations. 154

Batteries
A typical paper-based battery consists of two electrodes made from metal or carbon deposited on to paper substrates, with an electrolyte-lled paper in between to connect the two electrodes by a salt bridge or ion exchange membrane (Fig. 10A and B), and demonstrates the usefulness of paper in these devices. 26Foldable or stacked paper designs with wax patterned wells for the various reagents have been implemented, 155,156 with higher porosity papers tending to yield higher current densities.Printed batteries can either be in sandwich (Fig. 10A) or parallel (Fig. 10B) formats, with several printing techniques having been utilized 151 to realize customized batteries. 157Commercially available printed primary (non-rechargeable) batteries have been under development for a few decades, commonly utilizing the well-known manganese dioxide/zinc battery chemistries and with scale up possible for roll-to-roll manufacture. 27Printed secondary (rechargeable) batteries are being explored with potential applications in wearable electronics. 158ithium ion batteries are well suited to applications requiring high power and energy densities and show promise as rechargeable and durable power sources. 150Ions are transported between the anode and cathode through an ion-conductive electrolyte that is electronically insulating.Typical achievable voltages are around 3 V with energy capacities of 2250 mA h 159 Paper-based lithium ion batteries typically make use of commercial papers that are coated with carbon nanotubes to create highly conductive, easily manufacturable battery components 160,161 which can be foldable. 162aper-based lithium-ion batteries can generate power a few orders of magnitude larger than in paper-based electrochemical batteries or biofuel cells, but require multiple layers of materials and stringent packaging requirements.These cost implications and concerns of environmental friendliness could limit integration with existing paper-based electronics and diagnostic devices, particularly in terms of cost and disposability, but could be well-suited to polymer-based exible electronic applications. 150ecent examples of paper-based batteries enable sufficient powering of LEDs and handheld devices such as glucometers, 163 which could be used to drive various sensors and visual readout or displays for paper-based ASSURED diagnostics.

Biofuel cells
Biofuel cells utilize mircoorganisms or enzymes as catalysts to convert fuel such as ethanol and water in to power, instead of using metal catalysts as in the case of electrochemical batteries. 26Biofuel cells are thus low in cost, renewable and environmentally friendly.Microbial fuel cells usually have long lifetimes, but lower power densities, while enzymatic biofuel cells have higher power densities but limited lifetimes of a few days or weeks as a result of enzyme fragility. 150,159,164Typical power densities for microuidic enzymatic biofuel cells have been reported to be several orders of magnitude higher than those achieved for microbial fuel cells, 159 with comparisons made for implantable devices. 165uel cells implemented on lateral ow devices have been investigated 166 (Fig. 10C), as well as bacteria-driven paper-based biofuel batteries, 167,168 capable of powering an LED for up to 30 min.Low-cost (less than $1 per device) paper-based microbial fuel cells utilizing a drop of sewage as fuel have been presented, 169 with a more recent stackable design developed. 170xamples of recently developed paper-based enzymatic fuel cells are capable of illuminating LEDs 171 or powering a digital clock for 3 days. 172The current capabilities of these fuel cells enable them to be used for read-out and display modules for paper-based ASSURED devices, including low power displays such as EPDs or individual LED indicators, and offer an environmentally friendly solution.

Supercapacitors
Supercapacitors are electrochemical energy storage components and are similar to batteries in terms of design, manufacture and structural dimensions, consisting of two electrodes that are electrically isolated by a separator with an electrolyte.When a potential is applied, an electric eld is formed over the interfaces between the electrode and electrolyte.The energy is stored in the electric eld in a way that is comparable to conventional capacitors.Supercapacitors typically have lower energy densities than batteries, but higher power densities, with faster charge/discharge rates, as well as being considered more environmentally friendly and safer than batteries.An in-depth review on the various aspects of supercapacitors provides further details. 173upercapacitors have been implemented on standard office papers with carbon nanotubes and ionic-liquid-based gel electrolytes, 174 as well as on paper substrates using polyanilinebased supercapacitors. 175Commercial pencils and office paper have been utilized to realize interdigitated electrodes 176,177 (Fig. 10D) with supercapacitors implemented in both a pouch format with paper separators and liquid electrolyte, as well as with a solid electrolyte.Various form factors and aesthetic designs have been utilized using this approach. 178A photoelectrical origami device with an internal chemiluminescent light source and an integrated paper supercapacitor was developed to collect and store generated photocurrents. 179rinted supercapacitors have found uses for memory back-ups, as well as in packaging and RFID systems. 27The high current/ power generation possible makes these devices an attractive energy storage solution.
A recent example of all-printed paper-based supercapacitors, fabricated using an aqueous electrolyte, showed a high cycling stability with manufacturing methods that can be scaled for In a parallel format, two current collectors are printed side by side on a paper substrate, one with an anode material printed on top and one with cathode material.An electrolyte layer is printed or applied over these to complete the battery.(C) Biofuel cells can also utilize a stacked configuration with two electrodes on the outside and anodic and cathodic reservoirs on either side of a proton exchange membrane.Biofuel cells can also be implemented in a lateral flow format, where fuel (anolyte and catholyte) are spotted on to the test and electrodes make contact, completing the cell when water is added to the test strip.(D) Supercapacitors can have either a stacked formatsimilar to batteriesor an interdigitated configuration with active material over the electrodes and a printed electrolyte layer covering this.(E) Solar cells have a photoactive material between a cathode and anode, printed on to paper or a transparent electrode through which sunlight is absorbed to generate power.(F) Nanogenerators utilize stretching or twisting of paper structures to generate energy.As an example, layers of polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) and aluminium foil on paper can be used to generate energy through contact and release of the paper surface to the PTFE surface.Market and user acceptance Data security and certication mass production. 180Applications for wearables or portable devices are suggested, and could be extended to paper-based ASSURED devices for energy storage modules to power onboard components required for actuation, detection and display.

Solar cells
Solar photovoltaic systems generate direct current electricity from the sun's rays.Recent developments based on polymers focus on thin-lm inorganic, organic and dye-sensitized solar cell technologies, 27 which can generally be printed using roll-toroll techniques in custom shapes and sizes.Dye-sensitized solar cells on paper substrates 181 and printed photovoltaic cells on paper substrates that are recyclable 92 have been investigated, as well as solar cells inserted in to textiles using conventional weaving processes. 182Novel papers with a balance between transparency and light scattering have been developed for realizing effective paper-based solar cells. 183Oxidative chemical vapour deposition has been implemented to produce solar cells on newspaper and standard printing paper, with a typical structure consisting of an anode and a cathode with a photoactive layer 184 (Fig. 10E).Polymer solar cells with semitransparent top electrodes 185 and cellulose-based electrodes implemented for dye-sensitized solar cells 186 have demonstrated high efficiency organic photovoltaics despite the roughness of the paper substrates.The latter paper-based dye-sensitized solar cells demonstrated compact, robust devices which could be sufficient for powering of components that form part of ASSURED paperbased diagnostic devices.Multiple cells would be required to obtain voltages and currents high enough to drive LEDs, for example, but could be a feasible, durable and environmentally sustainable solution for on-board power for ASSURED devices.

Nanogenerators
Nanogenerators convert thermal or mechanical energy produced by small-scale physical changes into electricity.Thermoelectric generators (TEGs) convert small changes in temperature to electric voltage, and are oen utilized in wearable technologies. 187A recent review of ber-based TEGs summarizes the materials, operating principles and device structures, as well as example applications. 188Spray coating and screen printing are commonly used to realize printed functionality in textile-based TEG devices.Paper-based TEGs have been developed and, as an example, utilize waste heat and folding or origami techniques to generate energy. 189Stacking or folding of layers enables higher power densities to be achieved while maintaining device exibility.
Organic TEGs have been developed by Otego, 190 utilizing printable, low-cost semiconductors which can be massproduced using roll-to-roll techniques and then folded using automated, large-scale processes into small cubes to create a compact power source.TEG devices could be applicable for powering components such as wireless communication or sensing modules for ASSURED point-of-care diagnostics in resource-limited settings, where the environment is harsh and temperature uctuations are extreme.
Other examples of nanogenerators are those that are capable of harvesting energy from human movements, and can be implemented on paper using twistable and stretchable designs (Fig. 10F), making them well-suited to paper-based diagnostics.Origami-based nanogenerators and self-powered pressure sensors have been showcased, 191 as well as paper-based nanogenerators for power generation and active sensor implementation 192 in which the action of turning page of a book can generate currents and voltages sufficient to power LEDs, for example.

Integration
Integration of the various printed functionality components summarized in this work is required for fully ASSURED paperbased point-of-care diagnostics to be realized.Readout of lateral ow devices has evolved from using manual visual analysis to instrumented and automated readout, 193 but for fully integrated paper-based diagnostics with printed functionality, microuidics and electronics need to be combined on the same paper substrate.As each of these aspects is suited to different paper characteristics, 194,195 substrate pre-treatment and modication, 196 substrate integration, 197 and various printing and patterning techniques to optimize both electronic and uidic performance 41,145,[198][199][200] have been investigated.
Point-of-care diagnostic devices on exible substrates 102 and integration of printed electronics in to the real world 201 have been explored with potential for future wearable applications.Printed diodes, antennas and electrochromic displays have been combined to form an all-printed electronic tag for IoT applications. 202Examples of integrated exible devices include a connected electrochemical sensing platform resulting from a collaboration between Acreo AB and Linköping University, 195,201,203 a device to track micronutrient deciencies, 204 and a disposable system to measure hydrogen peroxide and total cholesterol, which is compatible with a mobile application for read-out of results. 205aper-based solutions of co-fabricated microuidics, electronics and batteries 32 and electrochromic readout for electrochemical sensing with on-board power 111 have been showcased, as well as connected paper-based temperature 206 and gas 207 sensors implemented on RFID wireless platforms.Paper-based piezoresistive pressure sensors combined with visual readout for medical applications such as measuring bandage compression, 208 and infant birth weight 209 have also been presented.Paper-based diagnostics that have been introduced to the market have been summarized 2 and include developments by Diagnostics For All (DfA) 210 for liver function and nucleic acid testing, text-reported blood typing by haemokinesis, 105 and lateral ow devices for infectious diseases by INSiGHT. 211stablished techniques such as roll-to-roll printing can be utilized for mass production of printed electronics and functional systems.The pilot factory established by PrintoCent 27 has assembly processes in place for production of hybrid electronic devices.Lateral ow and dipstick tests already use established mass manufacturing techniques, but for newly developed paper-based diagnostics, scalability of microuidic structure patterning, deposition of assay components, and assembly of multi-layered devices will be crucial for successful mass production. 2,199Substrates, inks, manufacturing processes, assembly and integration as well as fabrication time are important cost factors to consider for the successful commercialization of paper-based diagnostics with enhanced functionality.

Conclusion and outlook
This work emphasizes the recent developments made towards integrated printed and paper-based diagnostic solutions, and the variety of functional components that have been and can potentially be realized to enhance functionality.Specically, the review focusses on the functionalities developed to assist with meeting the ASSURED criteria, and shows that paper is wellsuited for the development of the unit operations needed to achieve this.Although headway has been made, seamless integration of the different building blocks into a functional solution, conceptualized by Fig. 2A, requires further development for truly ASSURED paper-based devices to be realized.This review has highlighted both the need and future opportunities to connect and integrate the components into functional systems.Table 1 provides a summary of the strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats (SWOT) of paper-based diagnostics with added functionalities towards fulllment of the ASSURED criteria.
Fully integrated systems are crucial as they will remove subjective and oen incorrect human interpretation of results and allow for robust data collection and data security.This would enable resource-limited settings to improve diagnosis and healthcare infrastructure in the long-term.Beyond ASSURED, additional functionalities are required for modern clinical practises and crisis readiness.Data acquisition and communication are important considerations which a systems approach can ensure through digitized data and connectivity.Rapid data collection is of increasing importance, especially with contagious diseases and outbreaks, and could be included as an overarching function in augmented ASSURED paper-based diagnostic solutions.However, data security remains a challenge where a lack of data certication and condentiality can result in false diagnosis, stigma, and destruction of lives.This will be a crucial challenge to address as digitization of data evolves and information needs to be more tightly managed.
As the need for more data to be collected and processed grows, so will the need for robust, compact and interconnected paper-based electronics.Many current solutions make use of hybrid electronics, which have the speed of traditional electronics, but interconnects are not robust and the solution is not fully integrated.In contrast, exible, paper-based electronics are oen limited in terms of speed, and addressing these constraints will need to form part of the roadmap moving forward.
In addition to the technical integration challenges using printed functionalities are the unique challenges faced in under-resourced settings.These have been discussed in the Introduction and have been highlighted by case studies, 212 and play a crucial role in the development of successful paper-based ASSURED solutions.
Successful implementation will also depend on the ability to scale manufacture to produce high volumes of devices, along with the supply chain infrastructure to ensure deployment to remote settings.From an environmental impact perspective, using paper as a platform may be benecial as it can be considered CO 2 neutral, i.e. incineration of paper does not unnecessarily produce more of a carbon burden.Incineration of paper also deals with the issue of sterility, where in contrast plastic-based medical devices are typically dumped and can pose risks to the public, particularly in resource-limited settings.However, if incineration of paper-based devices starts to occur on a large scale, the logistics and environmental impact of this will need to be evaluated.Self-igniting devices could be explored, as well as biodegradable substrates and materials, where the latter would require further investigations regarding shelf-life and robustness of the devices.
Only once the above mentioned barriers have been overcome will the real impact of these solutions be realizable.Ultimately, the success of paper-based diagnostics lies in the development and optimization of automation, ease-of-use, and shelf life, while incorporating feedback from users performing eld tests in resource-limited settings.Scalability, deployment and disposability will need to form part of the development process from the early stages for large scale feasible, sustainable solutions to be realized.If this can be achieved, fully ASSURED paper-based diagnostics with augmented functionalities for data, connectivity and environmental sustainability for resource-limited settings are a viable solution for the future.

Fig. 1
Fig. 1 Examples of existing external instrumentation solutions that can be used with paper-based diagnostic tests.(A) a desktop scanner, (B) a portable glucose meter used with custom made paper-based diagnostic electrochemical sensors, (C) a custom-made instrument for analysis of paper-based diagnostic test devices, and (D) a phone camera for image capture and processing of a paper-based device and/or for physical connection and analysis of a paper-based device.

Fig. 3
Fig. 3 Microfluidics and sample processing functional modules, illustrating typical paper-based diagnostic test formats.(A) Standard lateral flow test strips with sample pad, conjugate pad, test and control lines and wicking pad, (B) two-dimensional paper-based diagnostics using hydrophobic fluidic barriers (e.g.wax printing), and three-dimensional paper-based diagnostics implemented using (C) stacking of multiple layers or (D) folding or origami paper devices for enhanced fluidic control and multiplexing.

Fig. 4
Fig. 4 Printed paper-based electronics.(A) Hybrid printed electronics with surface mount components such as ICs and LEDs, mounted on to printed circuit tracks on paper.(B) Printed resistor with silver tracks and a resistive material to connect the terminals and create a resistive element.(C) Printed capacitor structures, showing both stacked and interdigitated formats.A dielectric material is printed between two conductive electrodes in the stacked format.(D) Printed inductor design with conductive tracks printed in circular or square spiral shapes.(E) Printed transistor with various functional layers labelled (left) and a typical printed transistor layout (right).

Fig. 5
Fig. 5 Paper-based functional components for actuation and control.Switches and valves are illustrated for both (A) electronic and (B) fluidic set ups. (A) Paper-based push buttons, which when pressed, compress a spacer, create contact and close a switch.Fold-over paper designs to make electrical connections and close a switch can also be used.(B) For fluidic implementations, ionic fluids can be introduced to create an electrical pathway, closing a switch, and three-dimensional stacked paper structures with spacers, fluidic channels and buttons can be used to implement paper-based fluidic switches, with a cross-sectional view illustrating this.(C) Movement can be implemented through printing of functional inks which when subjected to voltage and temperature changes, undergo compression or expansion to create motion.(D) Heating on paper using positive temperature coefficient (PTC) inks.These functional inks increase in temperature in response to an applied voltage and self-regulate at a designed temperature for constant and controlled heating.

Fig. 6
Fig. 6 Printed and paper-based sensing functional modules.(A) electrochemical sensors with working electrode (WE), counter electrode (CE) and reference electrodes (RE) indicated.Conductive materials are used for the connections and RE, while WE and CE consist of printed electrochemical functional materials.(B) Temperature sensors, with printed conductive materials and printed temperature sensitive material which varies in resistance as the temperature changes.(C) Humidity sensors, utilizing printed conductive tracks typically in an interdigitated format, which vary in resistance or capacitance as the moisture content changes.(D)Gas sensors, with a similar structure to humidity sensors but with a printed gas sensing material coating the conductive tracks.(E) Pressure, touch and proximity sensors, typically with printed pressure sensitive material over conductive tracks which varies with resistance and/or capacitance in response to pressure.These individual sensors can be implemented in matrix format to realize touch sensors.(F) Light sensors with a printed conductive electrode (bottom), printed photosensitive material (middle) and printed transparent electrode (top).These photodetector elements can also be implemented in matrix format to realize image sensors.

Fig. 8
Fig. 8 Printed and paper-based read out and display module examples.(A) Paper-based microfluidic visual indicators, which can be distance or time based, counting based or text based, utilizing the sample and resulting flow or reactions to provide user feedback on the test progress and results.(B) Printed thermochromic displays where applying a voltage to conductive elements covered by a printed thermochromic material results in a colour change in response to a temperature increase.(C) Printed electrochromic displays, with individual pixels made up of printed layers on top of paper as follows: conductive electrode, electroactive material, electrolyte, electrochromic material, and a transparent electrode on top.Applying a voltage causes the electrochromic material to change colour.Pixels can be implemented in matrix format to enable effective text displays.(D) Printed light-emitting electrochemical cells consist of an active material between two electrodes, with the top electrode (cathode) being transparent.Light is emitted by the active material in response to a voltage applied across the electrodes.(E) Electroluminescent displays, with individual units consisting of a conductive electrode on the paper substrate, followed by a printed dielectric layer, a phosphor material and a top transparent electrode.Light is emitted in response to an electric field.(F) Organic light-emitting diodes (OLEDs) consist of two electrodes with a conductive material and an emissive electroluminescent material in between.The latter emits light through the top transparent electrode in response to a current applied at the electrodes.(G) Electrophoretic displays consist of charged black and white particles that change orientation in response to an applied electric field.

Fig. 9
Fig. 9 Printed paper-based connectivity modules.(A) Physical printed connectors on a paper-based electronic device to connect to standard ports or adapters.(B) Wireless connectivity through printed NFC and RFID tags, which can also be integrated with microfluidics.

Fig. 10
Fig.10Printed energy storage modules.Batteries can be either in stacked or parallel formats.(A) In a stacked configuration, a paper-based separator soaked with electrolyte is sandwiched between an anode and cathode, each printed on to a current collector on a paper substrate.(B) In a parallel format, two current collectors are printed side by side on a paper substrate, one with an anode material printed on top and one with cathode material.An electrolyte layer is printed or applied over these to complete the battery.(C) Biofuel cells can also utilize a stacked configuration with two electrodes on the outside and anodic and cathodic reservoirs on either side of a proton exchange membrane.Biofuel cells can also be implemented in a lateral flow format, where fuel (anolyte and catholyte) are spotted on to the test and electrodes make contact, completing the cell when water is added to the test strip.(D) Supercapacitors can have either a stacked formatsimilar to batteriesor an interdigitated configuration with active material over the electrodes and a printed electrolyte layer covering this.(E) Solar cells have a photoactive material between a cathode and anode, printed on to paper or a transparent electrode through which sunlight is absorbed to generate power.(F) Nanogenerators utilize stretching or twisting of paper structures to generate energy.As an example, layers of polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) and aluminium foil on paper can be used to generate energy through contact and release of the paper surface to the PTFE surface.

Table 1
SWOT analysis of augmented paper-based diagnostics towards fulfilling the ASSURED criteria