Quantitative analysis of modeled ATP hydrolysis in water by a colorimetric sensor array †

Self-assembled colorimetric sensors have been prepared from Zn II –DPA-attached phenylboronic acid (1 (cid:2) Zn) and catechol-type dyes. The 1 (cid:2) Zn–dye sensors display selectivity towards oligophosphate over monophosphates. The colorimetric sensor assay (1 (cid:2) Zn–dye) is utilized to monitor a model of a metabolic reaction where ATP is hydrolyzed to pyrophosphate (PPi) and AMP.

Phosphates are ubiquitous in living matter where they play a number of important roles including energy transfer and transfer of genetic information, etc. 1 Simple rapid assays for phosphates in water could lead to a greater understanding of phosphate metabolism and satisfy the need for real-time phosphate monitoring methods. 2 The currently used Luciferin-luciferase reaction, a common method for detection and quantification of (oligo)phosphates suffers from a relatively low stability of luciferase albeit a significant effort for improvement. 3 Also for this reason, significant attention has been devoted to developing phosphate chemosensors. 4 Despite of recent progress, the sensing of phosphates by molecular sensors in water still remains a challenge because of strong hydration, complicated geometry and multiple protonation equilibria. 5 High-throughput sensor arrays are powerful methods for the detection of various analytes. 6 This is particularly true, when the analyte-induced changes in color or fluorescence are evaluated using pattern recognition methods. 7 This was the motivation for us to develop an array-based high-throughput assay for phosphates.
Zn II -dipicolylamine (DPA) receptors display affinity for anions as well as anionic dyes, a feature utilized in some anion sensors. 8 On the other hand, phenylboronic acids in combination with catechol-type dyes have been used to detect anions 9 and saccharides. 10 We synthesized Zn II -DPA attached to phenylboronic acid 1ÁZn ( Fig. 1) which forms an ensemble with alizarin red S (ARS). 11 This ensemble allows for a turn-on fluorescence detection for oligophosphates in aqueous solution. An interesting binding mode was discovered: in the absence of phosphate, the ARS anion ARS 2À (pK a2 = 5.5) 12 binds preferentially to the Zn II -DPA moiety ( Fig. 1, form A) compared to boronic acid ( Fig. 1, form B). However, the addition of pyrophosphate (PPi) induces reorganization of the original complex to a different boronate ester ensemble ( Fig. 1, 1ÁZn-ARS-PPi), which results in an intramolecular transfer of the ARS anion from the Zn II -DPA moiety to boronic acid. This process results in a fluorescence enhancement. The 1ÁZn receptor may bind a variety of organic and inorganic phosphates, thereby giving rise to certain cross-reactivity. 13 Here, the observed cross-reactivity of the 1ÁZn receptor inspired us to develop a new cross-reactive microarray for biologically relevant phosphate anions in water. Thus, we selected four different dyes, pyrocatechol violet (PV, pK a2 = 7.8), 14 pyrogallol red (PR, pK a2 = 6.3), 15 bromopyrogallol red (BPR, pK a2 = 4.4) 16 and ARS ( Fig. 1), all of which display a deprotonated hydroxyl-group at pH 7.5 and are therefore able to coordinate the 1ÁZn receptor.
In the presence of various phosphate anions these 1ÁZn-dye colorimetric sensors display an anion specific change in color.
Herein we report colorimetric detection of biologically important phosphates such as ATP, AMP and PPi in water. Furthermore, quantitative regression analysis of phosphate mixtures comprised of ATP, AMP and PPi is performed using the data from the colorimetric 1ÁZn-dye array.
Secondly, to obtain insight into the binding and response to ATP, PPi and AMP, UV-vis titration experiments with phosphates were carried out. The concentrations of 1ÁZn and dyes were adjusted to 6.0 Â 10 À5 M and 2.0 Â 10 À5 M, respectively. Fig. 4a shows changes in the UV-vis absorption when PPi was stepwise added into the aqueous solution of the 1ÁZn-PV complex (see ESI † for other titration plots). The addition of PPi to the HEPES buffer solution of the 1ÁZn-PV complex resulted in a change of the color from violet to orange, and a corresponding blue-shift of the absorption maximum in the UV-vis absorption spectra. The spectral shift suggests that addition of PPi causes a reorganization of the 1ÁZn-PV complex to produce an alternative boronate ester assembly. This hypothesis is supported by MALDI-TOF mass spectrometry, which shows [1ÁZn + PV + PPi-2H 2 O-2NO 3 + H + Na] + at 987.41   (calcd 988.07). Fig. 4b-d also show UV-vis spectral shifts upon addition of PPi into the 1ÁZn-PR, BPR and ARS solutions. The vivid colorimetric-response is observable by the naked eye (Fig. 5). The limits of detection for PPi, ATP and AMP were estimated to be 4.5 Â 10 À5 M, 8.2 Â 10 À5 M and 1.3 Â 10 À4 M, respectively. The apparent binding constants for ATP, PPi and AMP are summarized in Table 1. The apparent Ks indicate that the binding affinity for PPi and ATP is higher than that for AMP. The difference in the binding affinity corresponds to guest-dependent color changes, i.e. providing various responsepatterns, which is important for the design of assays for a quantitative determination of phosphates in complex mixtures. A variety of spectral shifts and color changes observed upon addition of phosphates to the sensor assemblies (1ÁZn-dye) encouraged us to develop a high-throughput assay for conditions that resemble ATP metabolism, i.e. hydrolysis of ATP to AMP and pyrophosphate (PPi): ATP -AMP + PPi. Towards this end, we generated ternary mixtures of ATP, PPi and AMP. Here, the concentration of ATP was adjusted to slowly decrease while the concentration of AMP and PPi was slowly increasing relative to ATP. The concentration range of ATP, PPi and AMP was 0-1.0 Â 10 À3 M in a 10 mM HEPES buffer solution with 10 mM sodium chloride at pH 7.5. The concentrations of 1ÁZn and dyes were 6.0 Â 10 À5 M and 2.0 Â 10 À5 M, respectively. UV-vis spectra from 300 nm to 700 nm were recorded in standard 384-well plates using a microplate reader. For the evaluation of the data obtained from the quantitative analysis of the phosphate mixtures we employed an artificial neural network-radial basis function (ANN-RBF) regression method. This method is suitable for modelling complex responses and non-linear behaviour of the data. The ANN-RBF consists of input, hidden and output layers. The input layer does not process the information, and only distributes the input vectors to the hidden layer. The hidden layer of ANN-RBF consists of a number of RBF units.
Each neuron on the hidden layer employs a radial basis function as nonlinear transfer function to operate on the input data. The output neurons calculate a linear combination of the basis function. 18 Here, fourteen standard ternary mixtures of phosphates were used for the calibration dataset, and another five mixtures were randomly employed for verification of the calibrations (i.e. validation dataset). Before building the ANN models, the spectral data were subjected to a principal component analysis (PCA) as a preprocessing method. The predictive ability of each model for ATP, PPi and AMP was evaluated in terms of relative standard error for determination of concentration in the validation dataset (RSEV%). Two parameters in ANN-RBF are very important to achieve low RSEV%, which are the number of neurons in the hidden layer (hidnod; 12) and the width of the radial basis function (spread; 5.2). To obtain the best regression model for phosphates, we selected the spread and number of hidden nodes at which the RSEV% has a minimum value (Fig. S22, ESI †). In this way the same network was trained for ATP, AMP and PPi. The RSEV% shows a very low error (3.4%). The result of regression analysis is shown in Fig. 6.   An evaluation of the model is possible using the visual inspection of the plots of predicted versus actual concentration for ATP, PPi and AMP (Fig. 6) attests to the model prediction power. It is noteworthy that this simple method can simultaneously correctly predict five randomly selected ternary mixtures.
In summary, we have developed self-assembled sensors based on Zn II -DPA-attached to phenylboronic acid 1ÁZn. These sensors form brightly colored ensembles with catechol-type dyes (1ÁZn-dye). In the presence of phosphates such as ATP, PPi and AMP these sensors display analyte specific color changes that enable quantitative measurement of the phosphate concentrations. In general, the titration experiments in HEPES buffer indicate that the 1ÁZn-dye sensors display a higher binding affinity for oligophosphate compared to monophosphate.
The colorimetric sensor array based on the 1ÁZn-dye reflects the observed changes in color that enable a simultaneous quantitative analysis of phosphate mixtures in water. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first time simultaneous quantitative analysis of phosphate mixtures in water is achieved by a supramolecular sensor. This method could be used to generate a variety of sensor arrays for monitoring of anion mixtures in the near future. Further studies of the microarray using 1ÁZn with catechol-type dyes are in progress. P. A. acknowledges support from Office of Naval Research (Contract No. W909MY-12-C-0031) and NSF (DMR-1006761, ECCS-1202439); Y. K. acknowledges support from JSPS KAKENHI Grant Number 24350075.