Photophysical and photochemical processes in 3D self-assembled gels as confined microenvironments

Numerous challenging transformations take place in nature with high efficiency within confined and compartmented environments. This has inspired scientists to develop spatially microand nanoreactors by ‘bottom-up’ approaches in order to improve different processes in comparison to solution, in terms of kinetics, selectivity or processability. In this respect, investigation of photophysical and photochemical processes in soft gel materials has recently emerged as a new and promising research field oriented towards expanding their applications in important areas such as photovoltaics, photocatalysis and phototherapy. Herein, we summarize the few examples dealing with intragel photo-induced physical and chemical processes involving embedded reactants that do not participate in the assembly of the gel network.


Introduction
In nature, a large number of challenging chemical transformations take place in confined environments such as enzymes and cells. Over the past few decades, this has inspired scientists to develop spatially confined micro-and nanoreactors by self-assembly of low molecular weight building blocks via noncovalent interactions including hydrogen bonding, p-stacking, van der Waals, electrostatic, hydrophobic and metal-ligand interactions. 1 Within this context, substantial efforts have been devoted to alter the selectivity of chemical reactions and activate new reaction pathways by arranging the reactants in a number of heterogeneous and organized media. 2 In particular, the fields of photochemistry and photocatalysis have been also rich beneficiaries of this concept. [3][4][5][6] In general, large active reaction areas, the possibility of tailoring additional functionalities to the microreactor environment, the reduction of overheating and overconcentration effects and reusability are some of the advantages of the spatial confinement of photochemical processes. In such kinetically controlled reactions, properties such as the absorption of light, generation of elementary redox intermediates, frontier molecular orbital energy, lifetime of excited species, rate of competitive steps and adsorption-desorption of chemical entities are largely affected by the nature of the reaction environment. 3,7 The state of the art on confined photo-induced reactions include the use of mesoporous inorganic materials 8 and organized molecular assemblies 9 such as microemulsions stabilized with colloidal photocatalysts, 10 micelles, 11 vesicles modified with semiconductor nanoparticles, 12 polyelectrolyte multilayered capsules 13 and photocatalyst-loaded liquid foams. 14 However, the use of supramolecular viscoelastic gels, 15 made from low molecular weight (LMW) compounds, as reaction vessels for photophysical and photochemical processes has been only scarcely explored despite their potential as nanoreactors. 16 In general, high specific surface areas, remarkable diffusion properties, reversibility, structural/functional tunability and responsiveness to multiple stimuli are some of the major features of these fascinating materials. 15 Such properties offers a versatile platform to overcome some major disadvantages of other confined media including (a) high sensitivity to deactivation by irreversible adsorption or steric blockage of heavy secondary products, (b) difficulty to design the proper geometries of the components and, therefore, to exploit shape selectivity, (c) impossibility of using nonelastic microporous for the synthesis of bulky molecules and (d) competitive binding between reactive and non-reactive species, which makes difficult the recycling of the catalyst and/or the separation of the product. 17,18 Moreover, tailoring the interfacial physicochemical properties of the gel network may allow a more precise control of the reactivity of embedded molecules and enhance their degrees of freedom in comparison to those in the solution state, what may at first seem counterintuitive. 7 Herein, we discuss a growing research area focused on the use of fibrillar gel matrices as versatile reaction vessels to carry out photophysical and photochemical processes of physically embedded reactants, giving similar or superior results than those obtained in solution state. Well-known photopolymerization of gels containing polymerizable groups 16 and the use of gelator systems with intrinsic photoactivity 19 (e.g., chromophoric gelators 20 ) are out of the scope of this manuscript.

Photophysical processes in organogels
Biewer and co-workers 21 pioneered the study of photophysical processes that can take place inside gel materials. These authors succeeded, for the first time, in measuring the rates of thermal decay of different compounds embedded in organogels. In particular, they studied a series of 1 0 -substituted 6-nitro-3 0 ,3 0 -dimethylspiro(2H-1 benzopyran-2,2 0 -indoline) compounds with different functionalities. Interestingly, significant retardation of the decay rate, in comparison to homogeneous solution, was observed for the succinyl ester spiropyran derivative 1 physically incorporated in a supramolecular gel made from 4-tert-butyl-1-phenylcyclohexanol (3, BACO1) (Scheme 1). A unique mode of interaction accounting for the intercalation of the succinyl group of 1 in the gelling agent was proposed to explain these results. The lifetime of the colored photomerocyanine 2 was increased by over 300-fold in the organogel in comparison to solution with a succinyl ester functionality present. Moreover, structurally similar spiropyrans without the succinyl ester functionality showed relatively little change in the lifetime of 2.
Luis and co-workers 22 studied the role of self-assembled fibrillar organogels made from LMW peptidomimetic gelator 5 (Scheme 2) on the rates of an electron transfer (ET) photoreaction. Specifically, a comparison of the anthracene (6) fluorescence quenching by amines in both, solution and organogel medium were performed. From Stern-Volmer analysis of the emission, quenching rate constants were very similar in both media, being a diffusion-controlled process in the self-organized medium using the appropriate donor. The same group investigated later 23 the interaction of naproxen (4), a non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drug, with a self-assembled fibrillar gel network made from 5 by means of time-resolved fluorescence spectroscopy (Scheme 2). In this work, emission lifetime (t F ) of 4 in the presence of the organogel (10.3 g L À1 ) was satisfactory fitted by a biexponential decay and two t F values were found to be 8.3 ns (93%) and 1.16 ns (7%) that were attributed to free 4 and 4 in the vicinity of the fibers formed by the organogel, respectively. It is important to mention that this interaction was accompanied by a destabilization of the corresponding supramolecular organogel.
More recently, the same group 24 used the LMW gelator 5 as a matrix to embed CdSe/ZnS quantum dots (QDs) with consequent fluorescence induction but without detriment of the thermal and optical properties of the parent gel. Very interestingly, the presence of the QDs decreased the critical gelation concentration Scheme 1 Photochromism of spiropyran 1 and LMW gelator 3. 21 necessary to form stable organogels. A full photophysical study highlighted a remarkable example of organogel-nanoparticle symbiosis. Thus, core-shell QDs maintained their photophysical properties in the gel medium (regardless the gelator concentration), whereas a significant increase of the fluorescence intensity (i.e., up to 528%) and the average lifetime (i.e., up to 1.7) was observed for the core QDs embedded in the gel (Scheme 3). Moreover, some of these composites have shown fluorescence sensitivity towards nitric oxide ranging from 0.05 to 0.5 (vol%) without disruption of the semi-solid state of the supramolecular gel. 25 On the other hand, photon upconversion (UC) based on triplet-triplet annihilation (TTA) between organic molecules is one of the most attractive wavelength conversion technologies, which can be performed with low-intensity and non-coherent light, such as ambient sunlight. 26 This phenomenon, TTA-UC, implies the association of multistep photochemical events (Scheme 4). After absorption of low energy photons (hn 1 ), triplet excited state (T 1 ) of the donor (sensitizer) is produced by intersystem crossing (ISC) from the singlet excited state (S 1 ). Subsequently, triplets of the acceptor (emitter) are populated by triplet-triplet energy transfer (TTET) from the triplets of the donor (Dexter mechanism). When two acceptor molecules in their triplet sates are capable to collide during their lifetimes, a higher singlet energy level is formed by triplet-triplet annihilation (TTA) and, consequently generates delayed upconverted fluorescence (hn 2 ). This conversion of low power energy light into higher energy has been successfully applied in diverse scientific areas such as photovoltaics, photocatalysis, bioimaging or phototherapy. [27][28][29][30] It is well assumed that the best efficient TTA-UC systems have been performed in homogenous solutions due to fast diffusion of excited molecules. Within this context, the development of easily processable materials such as viscoelastic gels (i.e., where liquid molecules are trapped in the interstices of fibrillar networks) that could be as efficient as a liquid composition remains a big challenge and it would provide new research areas in terms of applicability. In a seminal work, Simon and co-workers have recently developed new hybrid organogels containing the UC chromophore pair Pd(II) mesoporphyrin IX (PdMesoIX) and 9,10-diphenylanthracene (DPA) using DMF-DMSO as solvent system. In this case, the 3D polymer gel network was formed by covalently cross-linking poly(vinyl alcohol) (PVA) with hexamethylene diisocyanate (HMDI) (Scheme 5). The results demonstrated that these gels displayed an efficient green-to-blue UC with UC quantum yields of 40.6 and 14% under ambient and oxygen-free conditions, respectively. 31 This background could be easily extended to other materials based on other solvents, gel networks (i.e., chemical or physical gels) and/or chromophore pairs. Thus, Schmidt and co-workers have also published a highly efficient photochemical UC in a quasi-solid physical organogel based on 1,3:2,4-bis(3,4-dimethylbenzylidene) sorbitol (DMDBS) as LMW gelator, tetralin as solvent, and the pair palladium tetraphenylporfirin and DPA as photochemically active compounds. 32 The experimental results have confirmed the identical TTA-UC efficiency in the quasisolid gelated sample and in a comparable liquid composition (F TTA = 0.07). As a matter of fact, this finding emerges as a suitable strategy for potential applications in devices where the gel matrix needs to be processed as a thin film (Scheme 6), photovoltaics, and photocatalytic water splitting.
Moreover, an efficient TTA-UC process was also recently developed using supramolecular organogel matrices based on N,N 0 -bis(octadecyl)-L-boc-glutamic diamide (7) as LMW gelator (Scheme 7). 33 In this case, intense UC emission was detected from different donor (sensitizer)-acceptor (emitter) pairs in organogels made of 7 even under air-saturated condition, which undoubtedly represents a major achievement in this emerging field.
These TTA-UC molecular systems were formed by spontaneous accumulation of donor and acceptor molecules in the gel nanofibers, which were apparently stabilized by developed hydrogen bonded networks. These molecules, pre-organized in the gel network, showed efficient transfer and migration of triplet energy, as revealed by a series of spectroscopic, microscopic, and rheological characterizations. Interestingly, efficient TTA-UC was achieved even under excitation power lower than the solar irradiance. These observations reveal the adaptive feature of host fibrillar gel networks that allowed efficient and cooperative inclusion of donor-acceptor molecules while maintaining their supramolecular structural integrity. Moreover, the air-stable TTA-UC in the supramolecular gel was observed for a wide combination of donor-acceptor pairs, which enabled efficient near IR-to yellow, red-to-cyan, green-to-blue, and blueto-UV wavelength conversions (Scheme 8).

Intragel photochemical reactivity
The use of gel networks as confined systems to influence the course of organic photo-induced reactions has been practically unexplored and only few examples can be found in the recent literature. These reports include either photodimerization or photooxidation processes or are discussed next.

Photodimerization
Although anthracene photodimerization is one of the oldest known photochemical reactions, it still remains one of the most studied processes in different hosts or template molecules. In this respect, Shinkai and co-workers reported the first example in which a binary gelator containing a 2-anthracenecarboxylic acid (2Ac) was investigated, resulting in a very high degree of stereoselectivity under simple conditions. 34 Subsequently, they developed a new class of binary organogelator based on 2Ac, attached non-covalently with the gelator counterpart containing a 3,4,5-tris(n-dodecyloxy)-benzoylamide backbone. 35 Different degrees of stereoselectivity for different systems were observed when 2Ac-containing gel samples were irradiated. Furthermore, the nature of both gelator and solvent was found to play an important role in the stereochemistry of the obtained photodimers. Ongoing with this research, the same group demonstrated that a high degree of chiral induction could be also achieved and controlled precisely by the 1D supramolecular gelator assembly, which would path the way for future research in this direction. 36 Although photodimerization of acenaphthylene (8) (Scheme 9, top), which usually yields a mixture of syn (9) and anti (10) dimers along with minor oxidation products, had been previously studied in confined media such as zeolites or micellar solutions. However, Maitra and co-workers investigated the process, for the first time, inside supramolecular hydrogels (i.e., based on LMW bile acids 11-14, Scheme 9, bottom) as potential photochemical nanoreactors. 37 The results showed that the photodimer ratio (9 : 10) obtained for the reaction performed in the gel-bound phase was 3-10 higher in comparison to either micellar solutions or water. Very remarkably, the product selectivity was found to be highly dependent on the rheological properties of the hydrogels, obtaining higher storage modulus (G 0 ) in the most rigid gels (i.e., 13 4 12 4 14 4 11). Fluorescence experiments showed different intensity of the ACN-excimer band in the gel-bound state and in micellar solution, pointing out the existence and a key role of different molecular interactions patterns during the photochemical process.
More recently, Yadav and co-workers 38 have also reported the use of an organogel (i.e., made from enantiomerically pure 3,4-O-isopropylidenearabinose) as a reaction vessel for the production of a bicyclo[3.2.1]octanone via photo-induced electron transfer (PET) upon irradiation at 300 nm. Both yield and reaction time were similar to those obtained in solution state. 39 Importantly from the recycling point of view, the gelator could be also recovered from the mixture after column chromatography.

Photosensitized isomerization
Yang, Trotta, Inoue and co-workers 40 have recently reported the preparation of hydrogels made of polymers based on cyclic nigerosylnigerose (CNN; a saucer-shaped tetrasaccharide) that act as a ''nanosponge'' (NS). The CNN-NSs were prepared by crosslinking CNN with pyromellitic dianhydride (PDA) at different ratios. These polymeric materials effectively worked as chiral supramolecular sensitizers (Sens* in Scheme 10, bottom) and mediated the enantiodifferentiating photoisomerization of (Z)-cyclooctene to chiral (E)-isomer (Scheme 10, top). Note that CNN is a ''pseudo'' host lacking a confining cavity to fully accommodate the guest molecule. Very interestingly, the product's ee was dramatically controlled by the phase evolved. Indeed, the ee of the (E)-isomer was low in solution and suspension, but rapidly increased at the Scheme 9 Photodimerization reaction of acenaphthylene (8) (top) and structure of hydrogelators 11-14 (bottom). 37 Scheme 10 Enantiodifferentiating photoisomerization of (Z)-cyclooctene to chiral (E)-cyclooctene (top) mediated by CNN-NSs (bottom). 40 phase border between flowing gel and rigid gel. These results are very stimulating because they clearly reveal the beneficial role of the chiral void space formed upon gelation of the crosslinked polysaccharide on the outcome (i.e., chirality transfer) of supramolecular photochirogenic reactions. The methodology seems to be applicable to other substrates and reactions by choosing appropriate sensitizing crosslinkers and chiral building blocks.

Photooxidation
Díaz and co-workers established the potential of a various soft gels as nanoreactors for a model photocatalytic reaction (Scheme 11). 41 Specifically, riboflavin tetraacetate (25)-catalyzed aerobic photooxidation of 1-(4-methoxyphenyl)ethanol (23) was investigated as a model reaction under blue visible light in gels made from either high or LMW compounds (11,(14)(15)(16)(17)(18)(19)(20)(21)(22). Three strategies involving different degrees of organization of the photocatalyst within the gel network were explored, and the results were compared to those obtained in homogeneous and micellar solutions. In general, physical entrapment of both the catalyst and the substrate under optimized concentrations into the gels allowed the photooxidation with conversions between 55 and 100% within 120 min (TOF B 0.045-0.08 min À1 ; k B 0.011-0.028 min À1 ), albeit with first-order rates ca. 1-3-fold lower than in solution under comparable non-stirred conditions. Surprisingly, the organogel made in CH 3 CN using the cyclohexane-based bisamide gelator 16 not only stabilized the catalyst against photodegradation but also afforded full conversion in less than 60 min (TOF B 0.167 min À1 ; k B 0.073 min À1 ) without the need of additional proton transfer mediators (e.g., thiourea) as it occurs in CH 3 CN solutions.
It is important to mention that the gelators could be recycled and reused in further runs without detriment to their gelation ability and reaction rates. Moreover, the kinetics of the photocatalytic process could be fine-tuned according to the properties of the gel media (Scheme 12). For example, entangled fibrillar networks with relatively high mechanical strength, as determined by scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and rheological measurements, were usually connected to lower reaction rates, whereas wrinkled laminated morphologies seemed to favor the reaction. In addition, the kinetic results showed in most cases a good correlation with the aeration efficiency of the gel media. 41

Conclusions and outlook
Inspired by the efficiency of self-organizing compartmentation in natural systems to drive challenging transformations, research on photo-induced processes carried out inside gel matrices represents a growing and highly active new area (i.e., involving embedded reactants that do not participate directly in the assembly of the gel network). One of the advantages of photochemical processes for such studies is that it can be triggered without any thermal shock, which could disrupt the organization of the self-assembled fibrillar gel network. On the other hand, large active surface areas, good diffusion properties, variety of compositions, simple preparation from readily available molecular building blocks, very low concentration of gelator molecules, and the reversible stimuli-responsive nature of many self-assembled gels, make them ideal systems to mimic more complex natural systems.
A few initial studies on the rate of electron transfer photoreactions inside gels have provided the background for more Scheme 11 Gelators (11,[14][15][16][17][18][19][20][21][22]  demanding photophysical processes such as photon UC based on triplet-triplet annihilation (TTA-UC). Moreover, additional examples have demonstrated the feasibility of soft gels as reaction vessels and nanoreactors for photochemical processes such as photodimerizations, photosensitized isomerization, and photooxidations. Herein, the efforts are oriented towards the fabrication of spatially confined micro-and nanoreactors to improve kinetics, selectivity and/or processability in comparison to homogeneous solutions. Thus, important fields such as photovoltaics, photocatalysis and phototherapy will undoubtedly be great beneficiaries of future developments with respect to intragel photo-induced processes as well as the use of triple excited states as reporters.
Furthermore, a number of fundamental studies will still be necessary in future work in order to establish the real scope and boost the applicability of these materials as reaction vessels and nanoreactors for photo-induced processes. Those may include, among others, the following: (a) The elucidation of different molecular interactions between the fibrillar network and the reactants that may play a key role in photo-induced processes. This will also shed light on the organization mode of reactants within the gel matrix, (b) the correlation between gel properties (i.e., morphological, mechanical, diffusion, and thermodynamic properties) and the outcome of the photoreaction, (c) the development of reliable strategies to improve the loading capacity of the gel (i.e., concentration of reactants) networks and their robustness for higher operational stability, while retaining their functional properties, (d) the determination of optimal specificity and strength absorption of substrates in the gel matrix as well as the evaluation of possible concentration effects, and (e) the fundamental understanding of mechanisms through which self-assembled gels may favor specific reaction pathways (e.g., steric interactions that could control spatial orientation of specific reactants and influence reaction selectivity, accumulation of reactants into nanostructured subdomains creating ''hot-spots'' of catalytic activity).