Correction: Synergistic effect of carbon fibers and carbon nanotubes on improving thermal stability and flame retardancy of polypropylene: a combination of a physical network and chemical crosslinking

The authors declare that the funding body attributed with supporting the work reported in the original manuscript through grant no. 2011/03/D/ST5/06119 was inaccurately recognised in the Acknowledgements section. The funding details were incorrectly presented as ‘Polish Foundation (no. 2011/03/D/ST5/06119)’, and should instead have been ‘The National Science Centre (no. 2011/ 03/D/ST5/06119)’. The Royal Society of Chemistry apologises for these errors and any consequent inconvenience to authors and readers.


Introduction
Nowadays, polypropylene (PP) has been widely used in many fields such as electronic and electric industry, automobile and housing due to its good mechanical properties, excellent electrical resistance, low toxicity, low density and good chemical resistance.However, one of the main drawbacks of PP is its inherent flammability, which restricts its application in many fields for safety consideration.][3][4][5][6][7] Among various methods for improving flame retardancy of polymer, forming carbonaceous protective layer during combustion has been proven to be an effective method.A common way is to add intumescent flame retardant, 8,9 which typically consists of three components, namely, an acid source, a carbon source and a blowing source.The carbonaceous protective layer results from the carbonization of the added carbon source.
1][12][13][14][15][16][17][18][19][20] The most dominant mechanism is that the formation of a network-like filler structure within polymer matrix significantly reduces the flammability of polymer, 21,22 because the continuous network-like protective layer from fillers acts as a thermal shield of energy feedback from the flame.
4][25][26][27][28][29][30][31][32][33] Song et al. reported the improvements of flame 50 retardancy of PP by C60-decorated carbon nanotubes (CNTs) due to the free radical trapping effect of C60 and the network of CNTs. 34Jose et al. showed that the alumina-clay nanoscale hybrid improved the mechanical and thermal properties of PP. 35 Liu et al. prepared the ternary polyurethane/graphene 55 nanoribbon/CNTs composite with excellent mechanical properties and high electrical conductivity. 36Wang et al. demonstrated the synergistic effect of graphene/Ni-Fe layered double hydroxide (LDH) hybrid on improving the flame retardancy of epoxy resin, which was owing to the adsorption and 60 barrier effect of graphene and the thermal oxidative resistance of the char layer improved by Ni-Fe LDH. 378][49] The resultant CF reinforced polymer composite provides an 70 alternative to obtain light weight material with high mechanical, electrical, thermal and chemical properties.Mirzapour et al.  found that the combination of CFs and silica improved the mechanical, thermal stability and ablation properties of phenolic resin. 50Moaseri et al. used electrophoretic deposition and pyrolysis process to fabricate CF/CNT hybrid, which considerably enhanced tensile strength and elastic modulus of epoxy resin. 51Puch et al. showed the improvements of Young's modulus and tensile strength of Nylon 6 by increasing total volume contents of CFs and CNTs. 52Liao et al. proved that functional CNTs enhanced the mechanical properties of CF/vinyl ester (VE) composite by providing strong interfacial interaction between CNTs and VE matrix for improving the stress transfer from VE matrix to CFs. 53 However, as can be seen, most of studies are limited to mechanical properties, and little attention has been paid to improving the flame retardancy.The combustion process of polymer is complicated, which takes place at least in three interdependent phases, namely, condensed phase, gas phase, and interphase.From the viewpoint of reaction, it can be simply thought to involve the breakdown of polymer chains to form macroradicals and H•, which in turn speed up the degradation of the polymer.As one of the most promising nanofillers to manufacture high performance polymer composites, [54][55][56][57] CNTs have recently been found to reduce the flammability of PP by trapping free radicals and in situ forming a gelled ball crosslinking network in the condensed phase. 41Accordingly, it is possible to improve the flame retardancy of PP/CF composite by incorporating CNTs.Besides, compared to other commonly used fillers such as graphene and LDH, CFs and CNTs show advantages such as easier ability to be well dispersed in polymer matrix due to their low effective contact areas and weak interactions.More importantly, to the best of our knowledge, the synergistic effect of CFs and CNTs on improving flame retardancy of polymer has not yet been reported.
On the other hand, as described earlier, the in situ formation of the continuous network-like protective layer from fillers is extremely important for polymer composites to enhance the flame retardancy.This is because the continuous network-like protective layer from fillers not only prevents the diffusion of oxygen into the matrix and hinders the migration of volatile decomposition products out of matrix during thermal degradation, but only acts as a thermal shield for energy feedback from the flame.Li et al. reported the addition of CNTs into polyethersulfone/CF composite to improve the flame retardancy.Unfortunately, the combined CF/CNT fillers did not form a dense and compact char layer; as a result, the flame retardancy of polyethersulfone did not be improved obviously. 58Therefore, the design and fabrication of dense and compact CF/CNT hybrid are of great significance to improve the flame retardancy of polymer.
Herein, based on the work of Kashiwagi, 21 our work is inspired by the structure of the reinforced concrete slab as shown in Fig. 1a.The long and straight rebar (Fig. 1b, just like long CFs) acts as framework, while the concrete (just like short CNTs) connects the rebar and strengthens the structure.As a result, the reinforced concrete slab shows characteristics of light weight and high strength.So, what will happen by adding CFs into polymer/CNT composite?Can CFs favor the formation of a better char layer to further improve the flame retardancy of polymer/CNT composite?In this work, the combination of CFs and CNTs was applied and demonstrated to show a synergistic effect on significantly improving flame retardancy and thermal stability of PP.The in situ formation of dense and compact 60 CF/CNT hybrid (Fig. 1c, just like the reinforced concrete slab) during combustion acted as a thermal insulation layer and a barrier for evolved degradation products to the gas phase.Besides, CFs (Fig. 1d) promoted the dispersion of CNTs in PP matrix, which accelerated the oxidation crosslinking reaction of 65 PP radicals.To the best of our knowledge, this is the first report to demonstrate the synergistic effect of CFs and CNTs on improving flame retardancy and thermal stability of polymer.anhydride grafted PP (PPMA, molten flow index = 32 g/min at the temperature of 230 o C under pressure of 2.16 kg) with 0.8 wt % of maleic anhydride group was supplied by Starbetter (Beijing) Chemical Materials Co., China.CFs with an average length of 3 mm were purchased from Shanghai Yingjia Special 85 Fiber Material Co., China.Multi-walled CNTs with a purity of more than 98% (the main metal impurities are nickel (0.86 wt %) and iron (0.04 wt %), a diameter of 15 ± 5 nm and a length of about 30 µm were purchased from Chengdu Institute of Organic Chemistry.CNTs were ball milled at 400 rpm for 45 min before 90 being used, and the length of CNTs was reduced to 1-3 µm according to morphology characterization.

Preparation of PP composite
PP composite was prepared by mixing PP powder, PPMA (10 wt %), CFs (5 wt %) and CNTs (5 wt %) in a Haake batch 95 intensive mixer (Haake Rheomix 600, Karlsruhe, Germany) at 100 rpm and 180 o C for 10 min.The resultant sample was designated as 5CF5CNT.For comparison, PP with 10 wt % PPMA (simplified as PP), 10CF and 10CNT were also prepared.
The content of CFs or CNTs was selected according to the previous work. 21,22,42

Characterization
The dispersion states of CFs and CNTs in PP matrix were examined with FE-SEM (XL30 ESEM-FEG).The samples were fractured in liquid nitrogen, and the fractured surfaces were coated with gold before FE-SEM observation.Thermal gravimetric analysis (TGA) was performed on a SDTQ600 thermal analyzer (TA Instruments).The samples for PP and its composites with mass of 7.5 ± 0.2 mg were heated from room temperature at 10 °C/min under air atmosphere.Cone calorimeter tests were performed using a Fire Testing Technology Ltd. (West Sussex, UK) device according to ISO 5660 at an incident flux of 50 kW/m 2 .The samples were hot pressed by compression molding at 180 o C with the size of 100 × 100 × 6 mm square plaques.Each sample was mounted in aluminum foil and placed on a holder filled with a mineral fiber blanket, so that only the upper face was exposed to the radiant heater.All the samples were burned in triplicate, and the data were the average of three replicated tests.The photographs of the residual chars after cone calorimeter tests were collected by a digital camera.The interior structure of the residual chars was examined by FE-SEM (XL30 ESEM-FEG).The limiting oxygen index (LOI) values were measured on an HC-2C oxygen index meter (Jingning Analysis Instrument Company, China) with sheet dimensions of 130 mm × 6.5 mm × 3.2 mm according to ISO4589-1999.The samples were hot pressed by compression molding at 180 o C with the size of 130 mm × 6.5 mm × 3 mm rectangle plaques.All the samples were tested in fivefold, and the data were the average of five replicated tests.The rheological measurements of PP and its composites were carried out on a controlled strain rate rheometer (ARES rheometer).The size of samples measured was 25 mm in diameter, with a gap of 1.0 mm.Frequency sweeping was performed at 180 °C at a frequency from 0.01 to 100 rad/s in nitrogen environment, with a strain of 1% in order to make the materials be in the linear viscosity range.Temperature scanning test was performed in the range from 180 to 350 °C after samples were preheated at 180 °C for 10 min, with a strain of 1% and a fixed frequency of 0.1 rad/s in air environment.Before the measurement of gel content, PP and its composites were compressed into a film with a thickness of 0.1-0.01mm, and then heated at 360 o C for 15 min in a muffle according to a previous reference. 3,22The gel content was measured using a Soxhlet extractor by refluxing the samples in boiling xylene at 140 o C for 24 h, and subsequently drying in a vacuum oven at 80 o C for 24 h.
The gel content was calculated by dividing the remaining mass by the original mass of the samples.Infrared spectra were recorded with a Bruker Vertex 70 FTIR spectrometer; 64 scans were collected with spectral resolution 2 cm -1 .Original CNTs, CFs and the residues from PP composites after Soxhlet extraction were mixed with KBr in the proportion 0.5-1 wt %, and compressed to a thin disk for analysis, respectively.Neat PP was thermalpressed into a thin film, and then subjected to FTIR measurements under the same testing conditions as original CNTs.As can be seen, the CF sticks in the binary 10CF composite were uniformly distributed (Fig. 2a).The surface of pulled-out CFs was relatively smooth and some cavities were visible.Nevertheless, the three dimensional CF structure was formed in the PP matrix as depicted in the insetting image of Fig. 70 2a.In the case of binary 10CNT composite, a large number of short CNTs were homogeneously distributed throughout PP matrix with few aggregates (Fig. 2b).A similar phenomenon was observed in PP/CNT/Ni 2 O 3 composite from our recent study. 42urthermore, it was found that CNTs were adhered firmly to the 75 PP matrix, indicating a strong interfacial interaction between CNTs and PP chains.This is ascribed to the compatibilization of PPMA, which helps to improve the dispersion of filler and the matrix-filler interaction.Similar result was found by Song et al. 7 As displayed in Figs.2c and 2d, both CFs and CNTs were well  Table 1 Summary of the TGA results (Fig. 3) for PP and its composites.To study the influences of CFs and CNTs on the thermal stability of PP, TGA measurement was conducted.Fig. 3 shows TGA and the derivative TGA (DTG) curves for PP and its 15 composites under air atmosphere at 10 o C/min.T 10wt% , T 50wt% and T max represented the temperature at which 10 wt %, 50 wt % and the maximum weight loss rate occurred, respectively.The detailed data are summarized in Table 1.It was apparent that the thermal stability of all the PP composites increased compared 20 with those of neat PP.In the case of binary 10CF composite, T 10wt% , T 50wt% and T max were increased by 10.3, 28.T 50wt% and T max were 18.9 and 9.6 o C higher than those of 10CNT, respectively.Thereby, the combination of CFs with CNTs was more efficient than CFs or CNTs in enhancing the thermal stability of PP.   2. Fig. 4a shows the HRR plots of PP and its composites.Neat PP burnt very fast after ignition and a sharp HRR peak appeared with a PHRR as high as 1284 kW/m 2 .The PHRR in the HRR plot (915 kW/m 2 ) and t i of binary 10CF composite changed slightly compared to those of neat PP, indicating that the flammability of PP was not influenced strongly by adding CFs alone.However, the PHRR of binary 10CNT composite (367 kW/m 2 ) was reduced by 71.4% compared to that of neat PP, suggesting that the flammability of PP could be 5 reduced by adding CNTs.The lower t i of binary 10CNT composite compared to neat PP (Table 2) was attributed to the increased thermal absorbance of PP composites by introducing CNTs.When the combination of 5 wt % CFs and 5 wt % CNTs was applied, the PHRR from the HRR plot of ternary 5CF5CNT composite (364 kW/m 2 ) showed a slight reduction comparing with that of binary 10CNT composite.It was worthy to note that the HRR plot of ternary 5CF5CNT composite reduced further after the peak, and stayed at a very low level throughout.Similar with 10CNT, 5CF5CNT showed lower t i value than neat PP.Fig. 4b presents the THR curves for PP and its composites.Compared to neat PP, the THR of binary or ternary PP composites showed no obvious decreases.However, since the slope of THR curve was assumed as representing the fire spread rate, 46 the flame spread of ternary 5CF5CNT composite decreased significantly in 20 comparison with neat PP.The mass loss rate of a polymer during combustion is very important to evaluate the flammability property.Fig. 5a shows 30 the changes of normalized mass loss of PP and its composites with combustion time.Addition of CFs alone into PP matrix did not notably decrease the MLR, while adding CNTs alone into PP matrix led to a dramatic reduction of the MLR in the later stage of combustion.However, the combination of CFs with CNTs into 35 PP resulted in a more dramatic increase in the residual mass during combustion for more than 450 s compared to binary 10CNT composite, meanwhile 5CF5CNT showed lower average MLR.Besides, the highest yield of residual chars for PP composites (Table 2) was 14.4 wt % from ternary 5CF5CNT 40 composite, a little higher than the initial total loadings of CFs and CNTs.This meant that a part of pyrolytic flammable gases did not quickly volatilize during combustion in the case of ternary 5CF5CNT composite.

Thermal stability
Smoke in a real fire means more risk of suffocation, even 45 more fatal than heat release.Fig. 5b displays the SPR plots of PP and its composites with combustion time.The increased SPR of binary 10CF composite compared to that of neat PP was probably ascribed to CFs promoting the aromatization of PP degradation products, while after adding CNTs, the SPR decreased obviously.
Besides, for the ternary 5CF5CNT composite, the SPR decreased further to a very low level.As a result, the peak SPR (PSPR) and total smoke production (TSP) were reduced from 0.126 to 0.055 m 2 /s (by 56.3%) and from 50.8 to 27.2 m 2 (by 46.5%), respectively.All of the results proved that the combination of CFs and CNTs suppressed the formation of smoke very well, which is advantageous in reducing fire risk.To study the synergistic effect of CFs with CNTs on improving the flame retardancy of PP, the structures of the residual chars after cone calorimeter tests were analyzed.Fig. 7 presents the photographs of the residual chars from PP and its composites.There was no any char left for neat PP after 30 combustion at 700 o C (Fig. 7a), because of its inherent flammability with whole aliphatic hydrocarbon structure.In the case of binary 10CF composite, some blotch-like residual char was left (Fig. 7b), while a few black solids were found from binary 10CNT composite, and the char layer was not continuous 35 (Fig. 7c).However, as shown in Fig. 7d, the char layer from ternary 5CF5CNT composite became dense, thick and fully covered, compared to that from binary 10CF or 10CNT composite.That is to say, the combination of CFs and CNTs improved the quality of char layer.The interior structure of residual chars was observed by FE-50 SEM.As depicted in Fig. 8a, the residual char from binary 10CF composite consisted of many individual CF sticks with little carbon remained on the surface (Fig. 8b).The residual char from binary 10CNT composite was composed of short winding CNTs (Fig. 8c).A lot of CF sticks with block-like carbon were observed 55 in the residual char from ternary 5CF5CNT composite, but more residual carbon were adhered onto the surface of CFs (Figs. 8d-8f).Particularly, many CF sticks were inserted in the block-like carbon, demonstrating the formation of integrated and continuous three dimensional CF/CNT hybrid structure (just like the reinforced concrete slab as shown in Fig. 1a) in the residual char from 5CF5CNT during combustion.In other words, the combination of CFs with CNTs promoted the formation of a better dense and continuous carbon protective layer than CFs or CNTs alone.The carbon layer enhanced the physical barrier 10 effect, which not only prevented the diffusion of oxygen into PP matrix, but also hindered the migration of volatile decomposition products out of PP.Additionally, the carbon layer acted as a thermal shield for energy feedback from the flame during combustion.Consequently, the improved char layer was contributed to the synergistic effect of CFs and CNTs on improving the flame retardancy of PP.To study whether the combination of CFs with CNTs formed a 25 percolated network structure in PP matrix, melt rheological properties of PP and its composites were investigated.Fig. 9a shows the variations of storage modulus (G′) and complex viscosity (η) as a function of frequency (ω) for neat PP and its composites at 180 °C under nitrogen atmosphere.Neat PP 30 exhibited a typical linear polymer-like terminal behavior with scaling properties of approximately G′ ~ ω 2 , indicating that PP molecular chains were fully relaxed at low frequencies.When 10 wt % CFs were added, there were no plateau at the low frequencies, implying that the content of CFs did not reach the 35 threshold values to form the network.However, this terminal behavior was significantly changed when 10 wt % CNTs were incorporated into PP matrix, and the dependence of G′ on ω at low frequencies became weak.For ternary 5CF5CNT composite, the G′ curve exhibited a distinct plateau at the low frequencies.40 Similar phenomena were observed in polystyrene/CNTs and polystyrene/clay, 1 PP/CNTs 59 and PP/graphene/fumed silica. 60he above results demonstrated a transition from liquid-like to solid-like viscoelastic behavior in ternary 5CF5CNT composite.

Combined CF/CNT forming a network structure in PP matrix
It is well known that the melting process and degradation will 45 take place before a material starts to combust, and combustible gas products will traverse the decomposition zone to the flame zone to maintain combustion.If the melt viscosity is high, the gas products need more time to reach the flame zone, and the combustion process will thus be slowed down.Correspondingly, 50 the change of η for PP and its composites is shown in Fig. 9b.
Neat PP displayed a pseudo-Newtonian behavior at low frequency range, and this behavior did not change significantly with the addition of 10 wt % CFs.Interestingly, in the binary 10CNT and ternary 5CNT5CF composites, a much higher 55 complex viscosity and a pronounced shear thinning behavior were present.This behavior confirmed that the combination of CFs with CNTs promoted the formation of percolated network, which was essential to improve the char layer and the flame retardancy of PP.

RSC Advances Accepted Manuscript
through β-scission of polymer chains, and the degradation will speed up in the presence of O 2 .Thus, it was possible that the CF/CNT hybrid promoted the thermal-oxidative crosslinking degradation reaction of PP, which made a positive contribution to the thermal stability and flame retardancy.To confirm this speculation, dynamic temperature scanning measurements were performed on the neat PP and its composites under air atmosphere.Fig. 10 presents the curves of temperature dependence of complex viscosity for PP and its composites.All of the PP composites firstly showed a decrease in the complex viscosity with the increase of temperature, followed by a subsequent sharp increase, while a continuous decrease throughout to nearly zero was observed for neat PP.This behavior could be explained as follows: Upon heating, the easier movement of PP chains and the degradation at high temperature resulted in a decrease in complex viscosity of the samples.The increase of complex viscosity in PP composites was owing to fillers acting as oxidation crosslinking sites and the oxidation crosslinking reaction overwhelming the PP decomposition.In the case of binary 10CF composite, the temperature at which the complex viscosity began to increase was around 306 °C, implying a positive effect on restricting the oxidation degradation of PP chains, while that for binary 10CNT composite decreased down to 295 °C.This was ascribed to the quenching free radicals effect of CNTs due to their high electron affinity with sp 2 bond architecture.Comparatively, the ternary 5CF5CNT composite showed the onset temperature for complex viscosity increase at 285 °C, much lower than that of binary 10CF or 10CNT composite, which demonstrated the synergistic effect of CFs with CNTs on accelerating oxidation crosslinking reaction of PP radicals.This was probably ascribed to CFs promoting the dispersion of CNTs in PP matrix (Fig. 2), resulting from the interaction between CFs and CNTs, which decreased the interaction of dispersed CNTs to an extent (preventing reaggregation), and the milling media role of CFs to break up CNT agglomerates during mixing.In order to verify the oxidation crosslinking reaction, the gel content of PP and its composites was determined.Fig. 11 presents the gel content of neat PP and its composites after heat treatment.The gel content of neat PP was very low, indicating no obvious thermal oxidation crosslinking reaction.In comparison, the gel content of PP composites was much higher than that of neat PP, 45 and 5CF5CNT showed the highest gel content.The above results provided the evidence of the oxidation crosslinking reaction between PP and CNT/CF.FTIR analysis also provided important evidence for the reaction.Fig. 12a shows the FTIR spectra of original CNTs, CFs, 50 neat PP and the residues from PP composites after Soxhlet extraction.There were no apparent absorption peaks for original CNTs and CFs due to the highly absorbing nature of CNTs and CFs.Several strong bands appeared in the spectra for the residues from 10CF, 10CNT and 5CF5CNT composites.Compared to 55 these bands with the characteristic bands of neat PP, their main peaks were good consistent with those of PP.These results proved that PP chains were grafted onto the surface of CFs and CNTs.Furthermore, new peaks at 1220 and 887 cm -1 appeared in the 10CF, 10CNT and 5CF5CNT composites in the amplified According to the above results, a schematic drawing for the mechanism of the synergistic effect between CFs and CNTs on improving the flame retardancy of PP is shown in Fig. 13.In the combination of CFs with CNTs, on one hand, a network structure of CFs and CNTs in PP matrix was formed, which facilitated the formation of a better dense and continuous CF/CNT hybrid 10 protective layer (just like the reinforced concrete slab as shown in the Fig. 1a) in the residual char during combustion (physical effect).This not only prevented the diffusion of oxygen into PP matrix, and the migration of volatile decomposition products out of PP during thermal degradation, but also acted as a thermal shield for energy feedback from the flame.On the other hand, CFs facilitated the dispersion of CNTs in the PP matrix and contributed to trapping PP radicals by CNTs to promote the oxidation crosslinking reaction (chemical effect).Thereby, the synergistic effect of CFs and CNTs was displayed on improving 20 the flame retardancy of PP.

Conclusions
We demonstrated the synergistic effect of CFs and CNTs on improving thermal stability and flame retardancy of PP.According to the morphology characterization of the brittle-

Synergistic effect of carbon fibers and carbon nanotubes on improving thermal stability and flame retardancy of polypropylene: A combination of physical network and chemical crosslinking
70

Fig. 1
Fig. 1 Photographs of the reinforced concrete slab (a), its structure without concrete (b), and field-emission scanning electron microscope (FE-SEM) images of the in situ formed CF/CNT hybrid (c) and CFs (d).

Fig. 2
Fig. 2 presents the dispersion states of CFs and CNTs in the PP matrix.The dispersion of fillers in polymer matrix is one of most important factors influencing the properties of polymer 65 80 dispersed without orientation (Figs.S1 and S2 in ESI †) in ternary 5CF5CNT composite and formed the composite as shown in the insetting image of Fig. 2d.

Fig. 3
Fig. 3 TGA (a) and DTG (b) curves of PP and its composites under air atmosphere at 10 °C/min.

a
T10wt% represented the temperature at which 10 wt % weight loss occurred.b T50wt% represented the temperature at which 50 wt % weight loss occurred.c Tmax represented the temperature at which the maximum 10 weight loss rate occurred.
3 and 38.2 o C, respectively, compared to neat PP, indicating that CFs improved the thermal stability of PP to an extent.Comparatively, T 10wt% , T 50wt% and T max of binary 10CNT composite were significantly 25 improved by 58.8, 73.8 and 82.8 o C, respectively.Interestingly, the combination of CFs with CNTs further enhanced the thermal stability of PP.T 10wt% , T 50wt% and T max of 5CF5CNT were raised by 50.4,92.7 and 93.4 o C, respectively, compared to those of neat PP.That is to say, despite of slightly lower T 10wt% of 5CF5CNT,30

Fig. 4
Fig. 4 Effects of CFs and CNTs on the heat release rate (a) and total heat release (b) of PP.

Fig. 5
Fig. 5 Effects of CFs and CNTs on the normalized mass loss (a) and smoke production rate (b) of PP.

Fig. 6
Fig. 6 Effects of CFs and CNTs on the CO2 production (a) and CO production (b) of PP.

Fig. 6
Fig.6shows the CO 2 production and CO production curves

Fig. 9
Fig. 9 Effects of CFs and CNTs on linear viscoelastic properties: Storage modulus (a) and complex viscosity (b).

60 3. 5 Fig. 10
Fig. 10 Dependence of complex viscosity on temperature for PP and its 65

Fig. 11
Fig.11The content of gel from PP and its composites after heat treatment at 360 o C for 15 min.
25 fractured surfaces of PP composites, both CFs and CNTs were well dispersed in the PP matrix, resulting in the formation of the composite.The temperature at the maximum weight loss rate of PP under air atmosphere was dramatically increased by 93.4 o C, and the peak value of heat release rate measured by cone 30 calorimeter was remarkably reduced by 71.7%.The significantly improved thermal stability and flame retardancy of PP were partially attributed to the in situ formation of the dense and continuous CF/CNT hybrid protective layer, and partially to the accelerated oxidation crosslinking reaction of PP radicals by 35 CNTs.The dense and continuous CF/CNT hybrid protective layer prevented the diffusion of oxygen into PP and the migration of volatile decomposition products out of PP, and acted as a thermal shield for energy feedback from the flame.It is believed that this work opens up a new and exciting opportunity for fabricating 40 hybrid to improve chemical properties (such as thermal stability and flame retardancy) of polymeric materials.

Jiang Gong ,
Ran Niu, Xin Wen, Hongfan Yang, Jie Liu, Xuecheng Chen, Zhao-Yan Sun, Ewa Mijowska, 5 and Tao Tang* CFs and CNTs showed a synergistic effect on significantly improving the thermal stability and flame retardancy of PP.

Table 2
Combustion parameters obtained from cone calorimeter and LOI tests.
a Mass percentage left after testing finished.3.3Flammability propertiesThe influences of CFs and CNTs on the flame retardancy of PP were investigated by means of cone calorimetry.Cone 40 calorimetry is one of the most effective small-sized polymer fire behavior tests.It provides important information about fire risk via parameters such as the time to ignition (t i ), heat release rate (HRR), peak heat release rate (PHRR), total heat release (THR), mass loss rate (MLR) and smoke production rate (SPR).The 45 results are shown in Figs.4-6 and Table