Programmed assembly of 4,2 0 :6 0 ,4 00 -terpyridine derivatives into porous, on-surface networks †

The use of divergent, V-shaped, 4,2 0 :6 0 ,4 00 -terpyridine building blocks that self-assemble into hydrogen-bonded domains and upon addition of copper atoms undergo metallation with conco-mitant transformation into a coordination network is described; multiple energetically similar structural motifs are observed in both hydrogen-bonded and adatom-coordinated networks. of

We present here an investigation of the imidazolyl-functionalized derivative 1 (Scheme 1) on Au(111) and the effects of the addition of copper adatoms. We have previously reported the solid-state structure of 1 CHCl 3 and showed that NH imidazole Á Á ÁN tpy hydrogen bonds are favoured over NH imidazole Á Á ÁN imidazole interactions, consistent with the relative basicities of the heterocycles. 15 The solid-state structure of only one complex of 1 has been described; in [{2Co(1) 2 (NCS) 2 Á5H 2 O} n ], the imidazole domain and the central N atom of the 4,2 0 :6 0 ,4 00 -tpy unit are not coordinated. 15 A feature of 1 relevant to on-surface assembly is the fact that it is prochiral.
After deposition on an Au(111) substrate, 1 self-assembles into a close-packed phase ( Fig. 1b and c) which co-exists with a regular 6-fold nanoporous structure ( Fig. 1d and e); between the two phases lies a domain with an irregular assembly pattern (Fig. 1a). The two phases can be rationalized in terms of different intermolecular hydrogen-bonding patterns. The co-existence of two phases is reproducible in different samples Scheme 1 General 4 0 -aryl-functionalized 4,2 0 :6 0 ,4 00 -terpyridine and the imidazole-functionalized ligand 1. and is consistent with a small energy difference between the 2-dimensional assembly motifs.
The first compact assembly (Fig. 1b) consists of a hydrogenbonded linear double row arrangement, each of these separated by a small gap, due to resulting repulsive interactions (Fig. S1 †). The principal motif in the porous assembly is a hexameric array. This is well-modelled by molecules of 1 engaging in NH imidazole Á Á ÁN tpy hydrogen bonding and forming a chiral motif ( Fig. 1e and Fig. S2 †). All the hexamers in the domain possess the same handedness and the relationship between adjacent cyclic motifs can be seen by defining the dimer shown in Fig. 1e and Fig. S2. † Domains with opposite handedness are present on the surface (Fig. S3 †). The hydrogen-bonded supramolecular arrangement of 1 is not significantly influenced by the atomic lattice of the underlying substrate which bears the Auð111Þð22 Â ffiffi ffi 3 p Þ reconstruction. 16 The weak corrugation of the supramolecular layer can be attributed to the stacking fault zones of that same reconstruction, visible in both the close-packed and nanoporous phases, and possesses comparable periodicity. This observation of coexisting compact and porous 2-dimensional assemblies is not unique, and of particular relevance are results from Reichert et al. 6 who have described a prochiral carbonitrile derivative assembling on Ag(111) in coexisting dense and enantiopure porous phases. The assembly shown in Fig. 1d is similar to a Kagome lattice; 17,18 the latter comprises a regular network of interconnected hexagons and triangles, whereas in Fig. 1d, closer association of the hexagonal motifs leads to a reduction in the triangular domains.
After sublimation of Cu onto the hydrogen-bonded assemblies of 1 on Au(111), the supramolecular adlayer changes its structure. Chains of linked heterocyclic macrocycles, which generally follow the fcc domains of the Auð111Þð22 Â ffiffi ffi 3 p Þ reconstruction, are clearly observed by STM (Fig. 2a). These mostly form regular polygons. The transition upon adding Cu adatoms from extended networks with pseudo-hexagonal symmetry showing little distortion by the Au(111) surface reconstruction, to the oligomeric structures with a preference for the fcc domains of the reconstructed surface, suggests a modified substrate-adsorbate interaction. Such behaviour is plausible for molecular modules coordinated via metal adatoms which are in registry with the substrate atoms. In addition to the STM topographs recorded at 5 K, the local chemical transitions were also analysed by X-ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy (XPS) measurements. These confirm metal coordination by investigating the N 1s binding energies of 1 (Fig. 2b and Table S1 †). Prior to coordination, two peaks are observed; the higher energy peak corresponds to NH imidazole (399.6 eV, green in Fig. 2b) and the lower to -NQ(398.3 eV, red in Fig. 2b, both tpy and imidazole) with a well-fitting energy difference of 1.3 eV. 19,20 Instead of the ratio being 1 : 4 corresponding to the structure of 1, it is closer to 2: 3. This could be due to surface charge effects and/or intermolecular hydrogen bonds, 21 as the multilayer shows 1 : 4 stoichiometry with corresponding peak positions of 400.3 eV respectively 398.9 eV (Fig. S5 †). As stated earlier, NH imidazole and the central N tpy of 1 remain uncoordinated upon Cu-adatom addition and this is consistent with the XPS peaks shown in green and red in Fig. 2b which remain at the same peak positions (Fig. 2b versus  Fig. 2c). The second N imidazole and the two outer pyridine N tpy undergo coordination which is confirmed by a shift of 1.4 eV to higher binding energy to 399.7 eV (orange in Fig. 2c). 22 The ratio of peak areas (orange : green : red in Fig. 2c) was set to be 2 : 1 : 1. The binding energies for uncoordinated and coordinated molecules are summarized in Table S1. † The presence of various sized and shaped macrocycles (Fig. 3a) is consistent with (i) metal-binding through only the outer N-donors of the 4,2 0 :6 0 ,4 00 -tpy unit (as confirmed crystallographically for 4,2 0 :6 0 ,4 00 -tpy complexes 10 ) and (ii) a balance between molecule-molecule and increased molecule-substrate interactions. The internal angle of the divergent 4,2 0 :6 0 ,4 00 -tpy domain is 1201 and ideally matched to a hexameric assembly. However, the histogram in Fig. 3b reveals that this 6-fold assembly appears only in a minority of on-surface motifs which comprise 3-, 4-, 5-and 6-membered macrocycles, indicating the presence of an additional limiting factor beyond the macrocycle ring strain. This can be attributed to the width of the fcc region of the herringbone reconstruction, limiting the area of the macrocycles. 23 The 6-membered macrocycle represents the most favourable angle configuration, the 4-membered the most favourable size configuration, and the presence of the 5-membered macrocycles represents a compromise of both cases. In each of the 4-, 5-and 6-membered metallomacrocycles, coordination involving only the 4,2 0 :6 0 ,4 00 -tpy domain is proposed. However, this coordination mode would lead to a strained 3-membered cyclic array. Comparison of the four images in Fig. 3a clearly reveals that the larger rings have 6-, 5-and 4-fold symmetry, whereas the trimer appears 'squashed' and is not 3-fold symmetric; furthermore, 3-membered rings are only observed as motifs on the periphery of larger rings. Metal binding involving both N tpy and N imidazole is consistent with these observations (Fig. 3a, right). Other examples are known, where the Au(111) herringbone reconstruction guides the molecular assembly. The fcc and hcp differ not only in topography, but also possess different electronic properties (the hcp stacked top layer is more electron rich). 24 Therefore, molecules have preferential adsorption sites, 25 especially if there is a strong interaction with the substrate (e.g. via dipolar interactions 26 or via metal coordination 4 ).
In conclusion, we have shown that 1 assembles on a Au(111) surface into a close-packed phase which co-exists with a 6-fold nanoporous structure. The prochirality of 1 results in each hexacycle possessing a handedness and the chirality persists throughout the domain, with domains of both chiralities being present. Best-fit models are consistent with NH imidazole Á Á ÁN tpy hydrogen bonds being the dominant interactions. The introduction of (b and c) XPS spectra showing the N environment of 1 before (b) and after (c) deposition of copper adatoms. The peak deconvolution reveals two uncoordinated species (the central N tpy and NH imidazole , red and green respectively), whereas the remaining N energy shift upwards consistent with coordination. Fig. 3 Macrocycle distribution. (a) Models and respective STM images of the most appearing macrocycles. (b) Histogram reveals existence of preferential pore-geometry, which are macrocycles consisting out of 3, 4, 5 or 6 molecular building blocks. copper adatoms switches the on-surface assembly to discrete cyclic structures, the size distribution of which is consistent with the Au(111) herringbone reconstruction guiding the molecular assembly.
We thank the Swiss Nano Institute, Swiss National Science Foundation (Grant 200020_149067), São Paulo Research Foundation FAPESP (Grant 2013/04855-0) and the University of Basel for support. Marco Martina is thanked for supporting the infrastructure and co-developing and maintaining the sample preparation and handling procedures; a prototype of a vacuum suitcase (KTI PSPM and Ferrovac Inc) has been used in this work. Srboljub Vujovic is thanked for supplying ligand 1.