Cation selectivities in zwitterion grafted nanopores: effect of zwitterion architecture

Abstract

Selective separation of monovalent cations is a critical challenge in applications such as water purification and lithium recovery from salt brines. Cross-linked zwitterionic amphiphilic copolymer (ZAC-X) membranes have gained attention for their exceptional anion permselectivity, attributed to self-assembled zwitterion-lined nanodomains that interact preferentially with anions according to their hydrated radii r_hyd. However, these membranes show minimal selectivity among monovalent cations, despite significant differences in their hydration structures, motivating studies on the underlying mechanisms of cation transport and selectivity in this family of materials. In this study, we conducted molecular dynamics simulations of aqueous salt solutions within zwitterion-functionalized nanopores to elucidate the influence of dipole orientation of the zwitterionic (ZI) ligands on cation diffusivities, partitioning, and permeabilities. To this end, we examined two contrasting ZI ligand architectures: Motif A (surface–cation–anion, S–ZI⁺–ZI⁻) and Motif B (surface–anion–cation, S–ZI⁻–ZI⁺). Our results show that in Motif A, the sulfonate groups of the ZI ligands are localized near the pore center radially, leading to strong electrostatic interactions with small bare cations (Mg²⁺ and Li⁺). This configuration results in high cation partitioning but low cation diffusion, maintaining solution-diffusion tradeoff typical of functionalized membranes. In contrast, Motif B show that sulfonate groups shift radially toward the mid-region of the pore. This shift, especially for small bare cations, introduces steric constraints that weaken their interactions with the sulfonate groups, thereby enhancing hydration and lowering partitioning, while still maintaining their low self-diffusivity. These findings establish zwitterion dipole orientation as a powerful design lever for tuning cation selectivity in membrane systems and offer molecular-level insights for engineering next-generation ion separation materials.