Jump to main content
Jump to site search
Access to RSC content Close the message box

Continue to access RSC content when you are not at your institution. Follow our step-by-step guide.


Issue 3, 2019
Previous Article Next Article

Application and testing of a framework for characterizing the quality of scientific reasoning in chemistry students' writing on ocean acidification

Author affiliations

Abstract

Science educators recognize the need to teach scientific ways of knowing and reasoning in addition to scientific knowledge. However, characterizing and assessing scientific ways of knowing and reasoning is challenging. Writing-to-learn offers one way of eliciting and supporting students’ reasoning; further, writing serves to externalize and make traceable students’ reasoning. For this reason, it is a useful formative assessment of scientific reasoning. The utility hinges on researchers’ ability to understand what students can do and think from their writing. Given the challenges in assessing students’ writing, this research offers an adapted framework for assessing students’ scientific reasoning evident in writing. This work will introduce an adapted framework and show an application to general chemistry students’ argumentative writing about ocean acidification. We provide evidence that this framework can be used to validly estimate the quality of students’ reasoning. We argue that this framework offers some affordances that overcome challenges reported in the literature. It serves to define scientific reasoning in a domain-general way by breaking it down into its components, but in a way that can produce a composite score that tells us about how students reason using chemistry content. Further, the framework provides a way to characterize the scientific accuracy of students’ reasoning that can inform instructors’ treatment of alternative conceptions.

Back to tab navigation

Article information


Submitted
07 Jan 2019
Accepted
19 Mar 2019
First published
01 Apr 2019

Chem. Educ. Res. Pract., 2019,20, 484-494
Article type
Paper
Author version available

Application and testing of a framework for characterizing the quality of scientific reasoning in chemistry students' writing on ocean acidification

A. Moon, R. Moeller, A. R. Gere and G. V. Shultz, Chem. Educ. Res. Pract., 2019, 20, 484
DOI: 10.1039/C9RP00005D

Social activity

Search articles by author

Spotlight

Advertisements