Jump to main content
Jump to site search

Issue 6, 2017
Previous Article Next Article

Hypervalency, secondary bonding and hydrogen bonding: siblings under the skin

Author affiliations


In hypervalent bonding (HVB), secondary bonding (SB) and hydrogen bonding (HB) a nucleophilic and an electrophilic partner form a new bond that is based on a similar bonding pattern across the whole series of interactions. The electrostatic contribution is reflected in the ‘σ hole’ model in which a positive patch on E attracts the nucleophilic component. The nucleophile, Y, possesses a corresponding negative patch, resulting in a linear structure Y⋯E–X having one strong E–X bond and one weaker, longer Y⋯E interaction; this is considered as a SB interaction between Y and E. The covalent component, more important in the stronger interactions, HVB and strong HB, involves charge transfer between the lone pair (n) of Y, and the σ* orbital of E–X as emphasized in the ‘n→σ*’ bonding model. For example, charge transfer from I to I2 gives rise to the linear, symmetrical [I–I–I] anion. We now have two short (2.95 Å) bonds of equal strength corresponding to true HVB. In HB the central element, E, is H, and we can have strong or weak hydrogen bonding. On the HVB/HB analogy, a strong symmetrical HB, as in [F–H–F], can be considered as containing hypervalent hydrogen. In the weak HB case, we have a lesser degree of interaction, leading to normal hydrogen bonds of type Y⋯H–X analogous to secondary bonding. Within both the HB and HVB series, strong and weak types form a smooth continuum with no sharp break in properties. HVB was once considered to involve the expansion of the octet to 10, 12 or even higher valence electron counts. Whether the σ hole or n→σ* model applies, any octet expansion is now seen as largely formal, however, because the central element essentially retains its eight valence electrons. Thus a range of interactions can be placed in one big tent, related by a combination of σ hole and n→σ* bonding contributions with retention of the octet by the central element, E.

Graphical abstract: Hypervalency, secondary bonding and hydrogen bonding: siblings under the skin

  • This article is part of the themed collection: Primer
Back to tab navigation

Publication details

The article was received on 20 Sep 2016 and first published on 27 Feb 2017

Article type: Tutorial Review
DOI: 10.1039/C6CS00688D
Citation: Chem. Soc. Rev., 2017,46, 1720-1729
  •   Request permissions

    Hypervalency, secondary bonding and hydrogen bonding: siblings under the skin

    R. H. Crabtree, Chem. Soc. Rev., 2017, 46, 1720
    DOI: 10.1039/C6CS00688D

Search articles by author