Open Access Article
Metodej Dvoraceka,
Yanran Wu
b,
Greta Sambucaric,
Craig Newmana,
Brendan Twamleyd,
Mathias O. Sengee,
Jianzhang Zhao
*b,
Mariangela Di Donato
*cf and
Mikhail A. Filatov
*a
aSchool of Chemical and Biopharmaceutical Sciences, Technological University Dublin, City Campus, Grangegorman, Dublin D07 ADY7, Ireland. E-mail: mikhail.filatov@tudublin.ie
bState Key Laboratory of Fine Chemicals, Frontiers Science Center for Smart Materials, School of Chemical Engineering, Dalian University of Technology, Dalian 116024, P. R. China. E-mail: zhaojzh@dlut.edu.cn
cLENS (European Laboratory for Non-Linear Spectroscopy), via N. Carrara 1, 50019 Sesto Fiorentino (FI) Firenze, Italy. E-mail: didonato@lens.unifi.it
dSchool of Chemistry, Trinity College Dublin, The University of Dublin, Dublin 2, Ireland
eMedicinal Chemistry, Trinity Translational Medicine Institute, St. James's Hospital, Trinity College Dublin, The University of Dublin, Dublin D08 W9RT, Ireland
fCNR-ICCOM, via M. del Piano 10, 50019 Sesto Fiorentino (FI), Italy
First published on 7th April 2026
Controlling the excited-state dynamics of charge-separated (CS) states in donor–acceptor (D–A) systems is challenging due to geometry changes from intramolecular rotations and vibrations. A key question is how molecular geometry governs the formation, stability, and recombination of CS states, and whether these processes can be decoupled from spin-related transitions such as intersystem crossing (ISC). Here, we investigate a rigid design strategy where BODIPY and anthracene chromophores are fused to a bicyclo[2.2.2]octane scaffold, fixing the D–A geometry and eliminating conformational flexibility. This setup enables direct evaluation of how geometric restriction affects charge-transfer dynamics. Femtosecond transient absorption spectroscopy shows efficient charge separation in polar solvents (2–9 ps), followed by rapid recombination (15–205 ps), with no detectable triplet state formation. Nanosecond transient absorption, 77 K luminescence, and singlet oxygen measurements confirm suppression of spin–orbit charge-transfer intersystem crossing (SOCT-ISC). These findings demonstrate that a rigid molecular architecture can block ISC but does not inherently extend CS state lifetimes. Our results provide new insight into the fate of CS states and emphasize that geometric rigidity alone does not ensure long-lived charge separation in D–A systems.
A broad range of molecular scaffolds have been developed to connect D and A units through various linkers (spacers), including flexible alkyl chains,4 π-conjugated systems,5 saturated cyclic systems6 and polycyclic hydrocarbons (Fig. 1a).7 The nature of the spacer, particularly its length, rigidity, and connectivity, defines the spatial arrangement of the donor and acceptor, including their separation, mutual orientation, and degree of conformational flexibility, all of which critically influence the efficiency of the ET process.8 For instance, in systems where D and A are connected by rotatable σ-bonds, thermal motion can induce conformational changes that modulate orbital overlap and electronic coupling, complicating the interpretation of excited-state behaviour (Fig. 1b).9
The use of rigid spacers allows restriction of molecular motion and decoupling of electronic processes from dynamic geometrical changes. In this context, “rigid” refers to molecular frameworks in which the change of the electronic structure and the reorganization of the adjacent solvent layers are not accompanied by any major modifications of their molecular geometry.10
Classic examples include norbornane,11 adamantane,12 triptycene,13 and bicyclo[2.2.2]octane (BCO).14 These saturated frameworks have demonstrated efficient electron15 and energy16 transfer, contradicting early assumptions that non-conjugated systems act as inert insulators and revealed that rigidity and σ-coupling can sustain strong electronic communication between the donor and acceptor units.
Some of these rigid dyads have achieved CT state lifetimes on the microsecond scale,17 indicating that structural rigidity can indeed suppress recombination. However, formation of CS states is often followed by a recombination into a local triplet state (Fig. 1c), known as spin–orbit charge-transfer intersystem crossing (SOCT-ISC).18 This process has attracted considerable attention in recent years as a mechanism for generating triplet states in heavy-atom-free organic dyes.19 Efficient SOCT-ISC typically requires a near-orthogonal arrangement of donor and acceptor units, which enhances spin–orbit coupling through angular momentum changes during charge recombination.20 Consequently, designing D–A systems with long-lived CS states involves a trade-off: while rigidifying the structure can extend CS lifetimes by suppressing structural relaxation, it may also promote SOCT-ISC by enforcing orthogonality, thereby accelerating recombination into the triplet state. This raises a question: can CS lifetimes be extended by introducing a rigid spacer that locks the system into a non-orthogonal geometry – one that disfavours SOCT-ISC? Testing this hypothesis requires access to conformationally locked dyads with a fixed, non-orthogonal configuration, which remain scarce due to the synthetic challenges associated with constructing such geometrically constrained architectures. In cases where the donor and acceptor are connected to cyclic frameworks through single C–C σ-bonds, torsional motion can persist even in conformationally constrained scaffolds such as adamantane or BCO. These motions persist in both ground and excited states, introducing uncertainty into geometry-dependent processes like SOCT-ISC. Furthermore, rigidity is frequently extrapolated from X-ray crystal structures, which do not necessarily reflect conformations in solution.
A few studies have attempted to address this gap by designing dyads in which both the donor and acceptor groups are fused to rigid polycyclic scaffolds. These fused systems eliminate internal rotational freedom and maintain a fixed mutual arrangement of the subunits. For example, the work of Verhoeven and co-workers21 showed that such fused dyads (Fig. 1d) retained efficient charge separation, with electron transfer rates comparable to those of more flexible analogues. Interestingly, although triplet formation was suppressed, the CS state lifetimes were shorter (10–20 ns), attributed to enhanced radiative decay. A similar trend was reported by Chen et al.,22 who observed fluorescence coming from CS states in rigid dyads with lifetimes of ∼9.7 ns. These findings challenge the assumption that rigidity prolongs lifetimes of CS states and suggest that radiative decay may dominate when non-radiative pathways, including vibrations and intersystem crossing, are inhibited.
To address these questions, we synthesized a new class of conformationally locked BODIPY–anthracene dyads in which the chromophores are rigidly fused to a bicyclo[2.2.2]octane scaffold. Previously reported BODIPY–anthracene dyads23 with single C–C bond linkages have demonstrated efficient photoinduced charge transfer and SOCT-ISC, with triplet formation strongly dependent on molecular geometry: orthogonal arrangements yielded triplet quantum yields near unity and lifetimes exceeding 100 µs, whereas systems deviating from orthogonality showed significantly reduced triplet formation. In contrast, a rigid architecture enforces a fixed, non-orthogonal geometry and eliminates conformational flexibility – features not accessible in previously studied meso-substituted BODIPY dyads. These new systems provide rare, structurally defined models to investigate how rigid, non-orthogonal arrangements affect charge-transfer and intersystem crossing dynamics. Femtosecond transient absorption spectroscopy revealed fast charge separation but unexpectedly short-lived charge-transfer states, with no evidence for SOCT-ISC. These results confirm that SOCT-ISC is suppressed in a rigid, non-orthogonal dyad, which can be used to decouple charge separation from triplet formation, offering a new strategy for modulating excited-state dynamics in molecular D–A systems. By establishing clear links between geometry, rigidity, and recombination pathways, this work advances the fundamental understanding of photoinduced processes in donor–acceptor systems and opens new directions for the rational design of fluorophores and molecular photonic devices.
Reference compounds BDP-1 and BDP-2 were prepared to support the interpretation of the photophysical behavior of the dyads. These compounds share the same BODIPY chromophore structure, including the annelated cyclohexane ring on one of the pyrrolic units, but lack the anthracene moiety and therefore do not undergo intramolecular charge transfer. Synthesized compounds were obtained in analytically pure form, as confirmed by NMR spectroscopy and high-resolution mass spectrometry (HRMS, SI).
In DMA-BDP-4, the torsion angle between the mean planes of the BODIPY and anthracene units is 13.109(4)°. The geometry of the bicyclo[2.2.2]octane fragment remains relatively unchanged between the BODIPY and the pyrrole; the DMA-BDP-4 spacer group exhibits external (α) and internal (β) angles of 106.420(2)° and 106.3127(15)° (Fig. 2b), while PA-1 exhibits 104.960(3)° and 106.7620(17)°, respectively. These bicyclo[2.2.2]octane spacer group angles are very similar to those observed in SUTKAU, with α and β angles of 106.733° and 106.231°, respectively. Due to the minimal change in the rigid spacer group geometry, and therefore the alignment of the anthracene fragment with respect to the BODIPY core, it can be seen that the spacer plays a role in the rigid arrangement of the donor and acceptor groups.
A comparison between the crystallographically determined structure and the DFT-optimized geometry, determined with Gaussian 1633 (Table S3, SI), reveals a high degree of agreement, both in bond lengths and in the overall molecular geometry. Key parameters such as the α and β angles of the bicyclo[2.2.2]octane spacer, RMSD values of the BODIPY and anthracene cores, and dihedral angles between the subunits show minimal deviation between the optimized and solid-state structures. These findings confirm the high conformational rigidity of the molecule, as the spatial arrangement of the donor and acceptor units remains essentially unchanged upon crystallization.
| Compound | EOx/V | ERed/V | ΔGCS (eV)/ECS (eV) | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| HEX | TOL | DCM | ACN | |||
| a Cyclic voltammetry was performed in N2-saturated dichloromethane containing 0.10 M Bu4NPF6 as the supporting electrolyte. A platinum wire was used as the counter electrode, a glassy carbon electrode as the working electrode, and an Ag/AgNO3 electrode as the reference. Ferrocene (Fc) was added as an internal standard, and its oxidation peak was set to 0 V. E00 values correspond to the estimated singlet excited-state energy, determined from the intersection of normalized absorption and fluorescence spectra. HEX = hexane, TOL = toluene, DCM = dichloromethane, and ACN = acetonitrile. | ||||||
| BDP-1 | +0.64 | −1.65 | — | — | — | — |
| BDP-2 | +0.44 | −1.96 | — | — | — | — |
| DMA-BDP-1 | +0.59 | −1.63 | +0.33/2.69 | +0.16/2.51 | −0.34/2.02 | −0.49/1.89 |
| DMA-BDP-2 | +0.72 | −1.52 | +0.16/2.48 | +0.06/2.36 | −0.27/2.04 | −0.38/1.96 |
| DMA-BDP-3 | +0.68, +0.80 | −1.29 | −0.24/2.14 | −0.34/2.04 | −0.63/1.77 | −0.74/1.69 |
| DMA-BDP-4 | +0.66, +0.80 | −1.36 | −0.15/2.18 | −0.24/2.09 | −0.52/1.83 | −0.62/1.76 |
The Gibbs free energy changes (ΔGCS) associated with photoinduced charge separation were estimated using the Rehm–Weller equation.35 As shown in Table 1, in non-polar solvents such as n-hexane (HEX) and toluene (TOL), ΔGCS values are positive, indicating thermodynamically unfavourable charge separation. In contrast, in polar solvents like dichloromethane (DCM) and acetonitrile (ACN), ΔGCS becomes negative, suggesting that intramolecular charge transfer is thermodynamically allowed.
These results are consistent with the steady-state fluorescence data (Fig. 3), which show strong quenching of emission for DMA-BDP-1 and DMA-BDP-2 in polar solvents, while fluorescence is retained in non-polar media.
We also estimated the energy of the CS state for DMA-BDP-1 and DMA-BDP-2 in various solvents. As expected, the CS state energy strongly depends on solvent polarity, in agreement with previous reports.18 However, in all cases, the CS state energy remains higher than that of the localized triplet excited state (3LE) of the BODIPY chromophore. This indicates that the lowest excited state is the 3LE state rather than the CS state. Based on the empirical relationship between oxidation potential and the HOMO energy level, HOMO ≈ −(EOx + 4.8) eV, we estimated the frontier orbital energies from the experimental electrochemical data. The resulting values are in good agreement with those obtained from DFT calculations (Fig. S33).
The ester-substituted dyads DMA-BDP-3 and DMA-BDP-4 display noticeably different electrochemical behaviour (Fig. S14). Both compounds show two oxidation processes, with oxidation potentials at +0.68 and +0.80 V for DMA-BDP-3 and +0.66 and +0.80 V for DMA-BDP-4, together with reduction waves at −1.29 and −1.36 V, respectively (Table 1). The substantially less negative reduction potentials of these dyads indicate that incorporation of the ester groups significantly increases the electron-accepting ability of the BODIPY unit. As a result, charge separation becomes thermodynamically favourable already in non-polar solvents: the calculated ΔGCS values are negative in all media investigated, from n-hexane to acetonitrile. Consistent with this, the estimated CS-state energies are markedly lower and decrease from 2.14 and 2.18 eV in n-hexane to 1.69 and 1.76 eV in acetonitrile, respectively. Thus, ester substitution strongly stabilizes the charge-separated state and shifts the electron-transfer equilibrium towards charge separation even in weakly polar environments.
The absorption spectra of DMA-BDP-1 and DMA-BDP-2 (Fig. 3) closely resemble the superposition of the spectra of the parent BODIPY chromophore and 1,4-dimethoxyanthracene, indicating the absence of significant ground-state electronic coupling between donor and acceptor moieties. No new absorption bands attributable to a direct S0 → 1CS (charge transfer absorption) transition were observed for any of the dyads.
Both DMA-BDP and BDP reference compounds show modest negative solvatochromism in their absorption spectra, with the absorption maxima of DMA-BDP-1 and DMA-BDP-2 blue-shifting by 6 nm and 8 nm, respectively, when moving from nonpolar cyclohexane to polar acetonitrile. This shift, although less pronounced than in previously reported unsymmetrical BODIPY systems,28 suggests a decrease in dipole moment upon excitation, consistent with negative solvatochromism. This trend is also reflected in the emission spectra, which display minimal changes in Stokes shift across the solvent series (Fig. 3e–h). A marked solvent-dependent quenching of fluorescence is observed for DMA-BDP-1 and DMA-BDP-2. For DMA-BDP-1, the fluorescence quantum yield drops from 0.95 in cyclohexane to 0.006 in acetonitrile (Table 2). In contrast, the reference compounds BDP-1 and BDP-2 retain high fluorescence quantum yields across all solvents.
| Compound | Solvent (εr)a | λabs (nm) | λem (nm) | Lifetime τ1, τ2 (%) | Δλ (nm) | ΦFlb | ΦΔc |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| a Dielectric constant.b Fluorescence quantum yields were measured using rhodamine 6G as a standard (ΦFl = 0.95 in EtOH).36c Measured using 1,9-dimethylanthracene as a singlet oxygen sensor and 2,6-diiodo-8-phenyl-BODIPY as a reference photosensitizer (ΦΔ = 0.85 in toluene).37 | |||||||
| BDP-1 | CYH (2.0) | 521 | 526 | 4.9 (100) | 5 | 0.82 | — |
| TOL (2.4) | 522 | 529 | 4.5 (100) | 7 | 0.81 | — | |
| EA (6.0) | 515 | 521 | 5.1 (100) | 6 | 0.92 | — | |
| DCM (8.9) | 519 | 526 | 5.1 (100) | 7 | 0.77 | — | |
| ACN (37.5) | 513 | 522 | 5.7 (100) | 9 | 0.79 | — | |
| BDP-2 | CYH (2.0) | 533 | 538 | 5.3 (100) | 5 | 0.72 | — |
| TOL (2.4) | 535 | 541 | 4.7 (100) | 6 | 0.65 | — | |
| EA (6.0) | 528 | 535 | 5.5 (100) | 7 | 0.82 | — | |
| DCM (8.9) | 532 | 540 | 5.5 (100) | 8 | 0.67 | — | |
| ACN (37.5) | 526 | 535 | 5.8 (100) | 9 | 0.63 | — | |
| DMA-BDP-1 | CYH (2.0) | 522 | 530 | 2.4 (47), 4.5 (53) | 8 | 0.95 | 0.075 |
| TOL (2.4) | 524 | 534 | 1.2 (5), 4.3 (95) | 10 | 0.91 | 0.07 | |
| EA (6.0) | 516 | 529 | 0.4 (66), 5.1 (34) | 13 | 0.02 | 0.05 | |
| DCM (8.9) | 520 | 528 | 0.1 (15), 4.9 (85) | 8 | 0.02 | 0.03 | |
| ACN (37.5) | 514 | 524 | 0.3 (8), 4.7 (92) | 10 | 0.01 | <0.01 | |
| DMA-BDP-2 | CYH (2.0) | 533 | 540 | 2.4 (41), 4.9 (59) | 7 | 0.96 | 0.06 |
| TOL (2.4) | 534 | 543 | 1.1 (5.1), 4.4 (95) | 9 | 0.89 | 0.06 | |
| EA (6.0) | 527 | 537 | 1.9 (39), 3 (61) | 10 | 0.37 | 0.09 | |
| DCM (8.9) | 531 | 540 | 0.2 (41), 5 (59) | 9 | 0.03 | 0.03 | |
| ACN (37.5) | 525 | 537 | 0.4 (10), 5.4 (90) | 12 | 0.01 | <0.01 | |
Unlike meso-anthracenyl substituted BODIPY derivatives, where red-shifted, broad emission bands have been previously attributed to emission from the CS state to the ground state,38 no such CT-related emission features were observed here. Comparison of DMA-BDP-1 and DMA-BDP-2, which differ in the substitution pattern at the pyrrolic ring, shows that introducing additional alkyl groups results in a slight red shift (∼10 nm) in emission.
Notably, DMA-BDP-2 retains a higher fluorescence quantum yield in polar solvents compared to DMA-BDP-1, suggesting that increased alkylation reduces the driving force of the photoinduced charge separation, which aligns with earlier observations for related BODIPY derivatives.39 Fluorescence lifetime measurements reveal monoexponential decays for BDP-1 and BDP-2, but biexponential behaviour for DMA-BDP-1 and DMA-BDP-2 (Table 2). The presence of short-lived and long-lived components in the dyads is consistent with excited-state CS dynamics. In line with previous studies, the shorter component is assigned to the rapid depopulation of the singlet excited state via CS state formation, while the longer component corresponds to residual fluorescence from the LE state.40 To assess whether triplet excited states are populated via CS-mediated intersystem crossing (ISC), singlet oxygen quantum yield measurements were conducted. Despite the observed strong solvatochromism and charge transfer behavior, singlet oxygen quantum yields (ΦΔ) for DMA-BDPs were low in all solvents tested. The highest ΦΔ value of 9.1% was observed for DMA-BDP-2 in ethyl acetate, indicating that ISC is inefficient in these systems.
For BDP-1, which displays a reversible reduction wave (Fig. 5a), chemical reduction led to the appearance of new absorption features. The original absorption band at 528 nm decreased, while new bands emerged: a weak broad band in the 400–500 nm region and an intense band centred around 530 nm. These newly developed signals are consistent with the formation of BDP-1 radical anions.45 Similar spectral changes were observed for BDP-2 (Fig. 5b), also consistent with its reversible reduction behaviour.
In contrast, for DMA-BDP-1, no absorption features were detected in the 400–500 nm region following reduction, which differs significantly from the parent BDP-1. This is attributed to the irreversible nature of the reduction process in DMA-BDP-1 (Fig. 5c), suggesting that the radical anion is unstable under the conditions used and decomposes before a stable absorption spectrum can be recorded. DMA-BDP-2 showed intermediate behaviour: the reduction was more reversible than in DMA-BDP-1, and its radical anion spectrum resembled that of BDP-2. However, the intensity of the band in the 400–500 nm range was significantly lower, indicating either lower stability or lower molar absorptivity of the radical species. To support the experimental observations, we also calculated the gas-phase absorption spectra of the radical anions (Fig. S30).
For reference compounds BDP-1 and BDP-2, the EADS obtained from global analysis of the data recorded in toluene and DCM are shown in the SI (Fig. S15). The transient spectra and their evolution were found to be very similar in the two solvents. For both compounds, the transient absorption spectra feature an intense negative signal, attributed to a combination of ground-state bleaching (GSB) and stimulated emission (SE), along with a weak positive excited-state absorption (ESA) band in the 380–450 nm range. The transient spectra display limited spectral evolution, and the kinetic traces are well described using three decay components. The signal recorded immediately after excitation undergoes a slight decay on a 1–2 ps timescale, attributed to solvent-induced relaxation. This is followed by further evolution on a 30–40 ps timescale, during which the negative peak decreases in intensity, while the ESA band remains spectrally unchanged. This component is primarily associated with excited-state relaxation processes, including vibrational cooling and possible structural reorganization. The final EADS persists for approximately 4.3 ns in the case of BDP-1 and 5.1 ns for BDP-2, in agreement with the high fluorescence quantum yields measured for both compounds, which are largely solvent-independent.
The transient spectra of the dyad DMA-BDP-1 were recorded in three solvents of varying polarity: toluene, DCM and ACN. As expected from the measured fluorescence quantum yield values (Table 2), both the transient spectral features and the excited-state lifetimes are influenced by solvent polarity. In toluene, the transient spectra of DMA-BDP-1 (Fig. 6) closely resemble those of the reference compound BDP-1. Immediately after excitation, an intense negative signal corresponding to GSB/SE and a weak positive ESA band are observed. The data are well fitted using four decay components. The transient signal gradually decreases in intensity over the probed time window, while maintaining the same spectral shape throughout. The fastest kinetic component corresponds to solvent-induced relaxation, followed by further excited-state relaxation processes with time constants of 19.5 ps and 93.7 ps. The 19.5 ps component primarily reflects vibrational cooling, while the longer component is likely associated with structural relaxation.
The excited-state lifetime is fitted as 4.7 ns, consistent with the high fluorescence quantum yield observed in this solvent. In more polar solvents, the spectral evolution differs significantly from that in toluene. In DCM, following an initial solvent relaxation component (0.8 ps), a substantial spectral transformation occurs within 8 ps, characterized by a pronounced decrease in the GSB/SE signal and the appearance of a positive band centered around 550 nm. Based on the spectroelectrochemistry measurements presented in Fig. 5, and comparison with previous studies,46 this evolution is attributed to photoinduced electron transfer, resulting in a CS state with the negative charge localized on the BODIPY unit and the positive charge on the anthracene. The CS state in DCM has a lifetime of ∼102 ps, after which charge recombination occurs. Only a weak residual signal is observed at later times.
A similar spectral evolution is observed in ACN, with the main difference being faster dynamics due to the higher polarity. Kinetic fitting indicates that in ACN, charge separation occurs in 3.1 ps and charge recombination in 15.6 ps. The solvent-dependent excited-state behavior is illustrated in Fig. 6, which compares the kinetic traces at the GSB peak across the three solvents (panel d) and the evolution of the CS marker band (panel e).
Measurements were repeated using excitation at 350 nm, selectively exciting the anthracene moiety. As was shown for previously studied BODIPY–anthracene dyads, excitation of the anthracene unit is followed by a fast (few ps) energy transfer to the BODIPY unit. Therefore, the results obtained under 350 nm excitation are very similar to those obtained upon BODIPY excitation (490 nm) in ACN and DCM, while some differences are observed in toluene (Fig. S16 and S17). In the more polar solvents, charge separation occurs on a timescale comparable to that previously observed: in ACN, the positive band associated with the CS state appears in 2.7 ps, while in DCM it forms in 7.8 ps. Under these excitation conditions, energy transfer from anthracene to BODIPY is also expected, but its timescale cannot be distinguished from that of CS. Charge recombination occurs within 15.4 ps in ACN and 128 ps in DCM. Notably, the residual signal observed after charge recombination is slightly more intense than that observed under 490 nm excitation in the same solvents.
In toluene, the dynamics differ somewhat from those observed upon direct BODIPY excitation. On the sub-picosecond timescale, an intense positive signal centred at ∼400 nm is observed and decays within ∼300 fs. Based on previous reports,47 this signal is attributed to a fast solvent response, specifically a two-photon absorption signal from toluene. The subsequent EADS (Fig. S16c) shows the characteristic spectral profile of the BODIPY unit, with a strong GSB/SE band at 520 nm and a weak ESA band at 420 nm. The intensity of the GSB/SE band slightly increases over ∼23 ps, possibly due to energy transfer. On this same timescale, a weak positive band develops on the red side of the GSB, peaking at ∼600 nm, suggesting the occurrence of some degree of CS even in toluene. This positive signal decays in ∼597 ps, while the excited state persists longer, with a lifetime of ∼5.7 ns, primarily decaying via radiative processes.
The results obtained for DMA-BDP-2 are very similar to those discussed for DMA-BDP-1. Charge separation and recombination (CS/CR) are observed upon excitation at 490 nm in both ACN and DCM, while no CS is detected in toluene (Fig. 7). The CS/CR kinetics are slightly slower compared to DMA-BDP-1 and based on the intensity of the positive band centred at ∼565 nm, the efficiency of charge separation appears lower for DMA-BDP-2 in DCM. In this sample, CS occurs in 8.8 ps in ACN (25.2 ps in DCM), while CR takes place within 22.3 ps in ACN and 204.9 ps in DCM.
Excitation at 350 nm yields similar results to those observed for DMA-BDP-1. The transient spectra and excited-state dynamics are comparable under both excitation conditions in ACN and DCM (Fig. S17 and S18). As with DMA-BDP-1, a small degree of CS is also observed in toluene when excited at 350 nm. A low-intensity, broad, positive band appears in the 600–700 nm region within 15.7 ps and decays within 505.6 ps. The excited state persists for approximately 4.4 ns and primarily decays radiatively to the ground state.
Based on the estimated CS-state energies, the CS state is stabilized in more polar solvents, decreasing from ca. 2.08 eV in DCM to 1.95 eV in ACN for DMA-BDP-1, and from 2.04 eV to 1.96 eV for DMA-BDP-2 (Table 1). At the same time, the measured charge-recombination lifetimes become substantially shorter in ACN than in DCM. This trend indicates that lowering the energy of the CS state accelerates recombination, which is qualitatively consistent with charge recombination occurring in the Marcus normal regime.
To clarify the situation, since no transient signal was observed for the compounds alone, we employed an intermolecular photosensitization strategy to populate the triplet state of the compounds. Based on TDDFT calculations, the energy of the T1 state in the BODIPY-based dyads was estimated to be approximately 1.50 eV. Therefore, anthracene (An), which has a higher-lying T1 state (∼1.8 eV), was selected as the triplet sensitizer.48
Upon selective excitation of anthracene in a degassed DMF solution containing BDP-1 (Fig. 8a) using a 355 nm nanosecond laser pulse, a strong transient absorption band centred at 430 nm appeared, attributed to excited-state absorption (ESA) of the An triplet state.49 Simultaneously, a ground-state bleaching (GSB) signal at 530 nm was observed, corresponding to the depletion of the BDP-1 ground state. No transient signals were detected for BDP-1 alone under the same conditions, confirming that the observed signal arises from intermolecular triplet–triplet energy transfer (TTET) between An and BDP-1.
To dissect the evolution of transient species, global analysis was applied to the ns-TA data (Fig. 9b). Two species were resolved: the first corresponds to the T1 state of anthracene (TTET donor), and the second to the T1 state of BDP-1. Under the applied conditions, the TTET time constant was determined to be 25.7 µs, and the lifetime of the BDP-1 triplet state was estimated to be 84.5 µs.
Similar experiments for BDP-2 (Fig. S20) yielded a triplet state lifetime of 50.2 µs. It should be noted that these values are influenced by triplet–triplet annihilation (TTA), which depends on laser fluence and compound concentration. Similar experiments were performed for DMA-BDP-1 and DMA-BDP-2 (Fig. 9 and S21). For DMA-BDP-1, the ns-TA spectra of the An/DMA-BDP-1 mixture closely resembled those of the An/BDP-1 system. Global analysis revealed two transient species: the first was assigned to the anthracene triplet, and the second to the 3LE state of DMA-BDP-1. Notably, the triplet spin density was localized on the BODIPY moiety, suggesting the absence of a 3CT or 3CS character. In contrast, attempts to perform TTET experiments in polar solvents such as acetonitrile failed to generate any detectable signal coming from the triplet state of the dyads.
To confirm the nature of the triplet states, DFT computations were carried out to visualize the electron spin density surfaces of DMA-BDP-1 and DMA-BDP-2 (Fig. S31 and S32). In both polar and nonpolar solvent models, the unpaired electron density was confined to the BODIPY core, consistent with a localized 3LE state rather than a charge-transfer 3CT state. These computational results fully support the spectroscopic data and the energy-level analysis of the CS vs. LE states. The photophysical processes of DMA-BDP-1 and DMA-BDP-2 upon photoexcitation are summarized in Scheme 2 and Scheme S1. In non-polar solvents such as hexane, photoinduced intramolecular electron transfer is thermodynamically unfavourable. As a result, the fluorescence of DMA-BDP-1 closely resembles that of the parent chromophore BDP-1, with no significant quenching observed. In contrast, in polar solvents such as acetonitrile, the CS state is stabilized and lies approximately 0.4 eV below the first singlet excited state (1LE) of the chromophore. This energy difference favours photoinduced electron transfer, leading to efficient fluorescence quenching.
Despite the formation of the CS state in polar solvents, no long-lived charge-separated species are detected in femtosecond (fs-TA) or nanosecond transient absorption (ns-TA) spectra. In all solvents studied, the CS state remains energetically higher than the lowest triplet state (T1), which is localized on the BODIPY core. Although higher triplet states (T2 or T3) may lie close in energy to the 1CS states, no efficient ISC is observed. This suggests that the CS state recombination outcompetes intersystem crossing (ISC) in the studied systems.
Optical spectroscopy and femtosecond transient absorption experiments revealed that despite the rigidity and steric bulk of the spacer, photoinduced charge separation in polar solvents remains efficient, occurring on a 2–9 ps timescale, comparable to that of more flexible analogues. However, a key finding is that no efficient triplet state formation was observed (ΦΔ < 10%), even under conditions that favour SOCT-ISC. Neither phosphorescence nor 3CS intermediates were detected, including at low temperatures or in the presence of external heavy atoms. These results indicate that the rigid D–A geometry successfully blocks ISC from the charge-separated state by preventing the conformational reorganization required for efficient spin–orbit coupling.
This outcome is particularly relevant for systems where triplet formation is detrimental, such as in fluorescence-based sensors, organic photovoltaics, and molecular electronics, where CS state decay into triplets typically constitutes an energy loss channel. The ability to suppress ISC by using the bicyclo[2.2.2]octane spacer offers a new design strategy for such applications.
Our study further reveals that, contrary to prevailing assumptions in the field, the rigid geometry did not lead to extended CS state lifetimes. Instead, the CT states remained short-lived (15–205 ps), undergoing fast recombination. This directly challenges the commonly held view that rigidity in D–A systems correlates with longer-lived CS states. Our results suggest that rigidity alone is insufficient for lifetime extension, and that other factors, possibly electronic structure or energy-level alignment, are responsible for long-lived CS states reported in other systems. This hypothesis warrants further investigation.
CCDC 2517531 and 2517532 contain the supplementary crystallographic data for this paper.54a,b
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2026 |