Open Access Article
Pedro Alonso-Sánchez
*a,
Emilie Hvidsten Swensenb,
Kesavan Thangaian
b,
Per Erik Vullum
c,
Vadim Diadkind,
Fride Vullum-Bruer
e,
Javier Campo
a,
Ann Mari Svensson
b,
Federico Cova
*f and
Maria Valeria Blanco
*g
aInstituto de Nanociencia y Materiales de Aragón (INMA), CSIC-Universidad de Zaragoza, Zaragoza 50009, Spain. E-mail: p.alonso@unizar.es
bDepartment of Materials Science and Engineering, Norwegian University of Science and Technology, Trondheim, NO-7491, Norway
cSINTEF Industry, Trondheim, NO-7491, Norway
dSwiss-Norwegian Beamlines (SNBL) at European Synchrotron Radiation Facilities (ESRF), Grenoble, 38042, France
eSINTEF Energy, Trondheim, NO-7491, Norway
fALBA CELLS, Cerdanyola del Vallés, Barcelona 08290, Spain. E-mail: fcova@cells.es
gInstitut de Ciència de Materials de Barcelona (ICMAB-CSIC), Carrer dels Til.lers, 08193 Cerdanyola del Vallès, Spain. E-mail: vblanco2@icmab.es
First published on 5th June 2026
Silicon is a high-capacity anode material, yet its scalable production from sustainable precursors requires low-temperature and controllable synthesis routes. Diatom-derived SiO2 provides an abundant biogenic feedstock, but its conversion to silicon by magnesiothermic reduction (MgTR), typically conducted at 600–900 °C, is limited by the highly exothermic nature of the reaction, which induces local overheating, promotes side-phase formation, and often results in incomplete SiO2 reduction. Here, we elucidate the reaction pathway of AlCl3-assisted MgTR as a strategy to decrease synthesis temperature and improve reduction efficiency. By correlating the heating ramp rate, isothermal hold time, and salt-to-silica ratio with phase evolution and the crystalline silicon fraction, we identify the parameters governing oxygen abstraction and Si formation. Time-resolved in situ synchrotron X-ray diffraction provides direct insight into the reaction mechanism, revealing the early formation of metallic Al, the transient formation of MgAl2Cl8 as an intermediate, and the subsequent crystallization of Si concurrent with the consumption of metallic Al, thereby suggesting that Al acts as an effective reducing agent. Silicon formation proceeds within a chloride-rich molten phase and is achieved at temperatures as low as 250–300 °C. The crystalline silicon fraction is primarily dictated by heating conditions and AlCl3 content, with optimized parameters maximizing the Si fraction while suppressing inactive byproducts. Electrochemical evaluation of the graphite-SiOx electrode blends demonstrates enhanced reversible capacity relative to graphite together with moderate cycling stability, confirming the electrochemical activity of the synthesized material. Overall, this work unveils the mechanistic framework of AlCl3-assisted MgTR and provides synthesis guidelines for the low-temperature conversion of diatom biosilica into silicon-based anode materials.
Natural SiO2 sources such as diatom frustules, clays, zeolites, sand, and agricultural residues offer low-cost and sustainable feedstock for silicon anodes, with inherent advantages including hierarchical porosity and high surface area.10–13 These features facilitate Li-ion transport and help buffer the large volume changes of Si during cycling, making biogenic templates highly attractive for advanced anode design.14–18 However, conventional carbothermal reduction, the established industrial route for silicon production, requires high processing temperatures of about 1900 °C, which destroys the intrinsic nanostructure and morphology of biogenic templates, thereby limiting its suitability for nanostructured anode design. Magnesiothermic reduction (MgTR, eqn (1)) has been proposed as a moderate-temperature alternative (600–900 °C), successfully applied to diverse SiO2 sources including diatom frustules, clays, zeolites, sand, and agricultural residues.19–27 Nevertheless, MgTR remains challenging to control: its strongly exothermic nature induces local hot spots that promote sintering and collapse of fragile nanostructures, while incomplete reduction or local Mg excess/deficiency leads to electrochemically inactive byproducts such as Mg2Si and Mg2SiO4.28–31 These drawbacks lower the Si yield, complicate purification, and ultimately compromise electrochemical performance.
| 2Mg(s) + SiO2(s) → Si(s) + 2MgO(s) | (1) |
The use of low-melting AlCl3 (Tm ≈ 192 °C) has recently attracted attention as a means to reduce the effective reaction temperature in metallothermic reductions. Owing to its low melting point, AlCl3 introduces a transient molten-salt environment at temperatures far below conventional MgTR conditions, which can homogenize reactant distribution, facilitate mass transport, and suppress localized overheating. In aluminothermic and zincothermic reductions, this approach has enabled silicon formation at substantially reduced temperatures (200–250 °C).32–36 In the context of magnesiothermic reduction, however, the function of AlCl3 remains unclear. Rather than acting as an inert matrix, several studies indicate that the salt actively reshapes the reaction pathway. Reported intermediates such as MgCl2, AlOCl, and MgAl2Cl8 suggest that chlorine-mediated redox chemistry occurs during MgTR.37,38 In particular, the in situ formation of metallic Al (eqn (2)) has been proposed, implying that reduction may proceed via a secondary aluminothermic step instead of direct Mg–SiO2 interaction. Concurrently, the formation of MgAl2Cl8 has been attributed to a cross-reaction between residual AlCl3 and MgCl2 (eqn (3)). Despite these hypotheses, direct experimental evidence clarifying the sequence of intermediate formation and their thermodynamic hierarchy is still lacking.
| 3Mg + 2AlCl3 → 3MgCl2 + 2Al | (2) |
| MgCl2 + 2AlCl3 → MgAl2Cl8 | (3) |
More recently, Je et al.39 proposed a reaction mechanism based on ex situ X-ray diffraction and density functional theory (DFT) calculations, in which metallic Mg dissolves in AlCl3 to form metal-AlCl3 complexes that act as reactive intermediates for chlorine transfer. These complexes would destabilize the Si–O bonds in SiO2 and enable oxygen abstraction via internal Cl− transfer, leading to the formation of elemental Si along with soluble byproducts such as MgCl2 and AlOCl, rather than solid MgO. These chloride-based byproducts can be removed using mild acid treatments, offering significant advantages in product purification and scalability.
The AlCl3–Mg system also enables SiO2 reduction to proceed at significantly lower temperatures (∼250–300 °C), conditions generally associated with reduced particle sintering, enhanced preservation of the original silica nanostructure, and suppression of undesired Mg2Si and Mg2SiO4 formation. In practice, however, protocols based on this reaction commonly rely on HF etching as a standard post-treatment step to remove residual SiO2, indicating that the reduction frequently remains incomplete. This dependence represents a major limitation: HF processing introduces substantial environmental and safety concerns and can partially dissolve or structurally alter the newly formed silicon, thereby compromising the structural advantages targeted through low-temperature synthesis.
A rigorous elucidation of the reaction pathway governing AlCl3-assisted MgTR is essential to enable rational control over the process. However, uncovering this pathway is intrinsically challenging because the reduction proceeds within a molten-salt environment, where reactive intermediates nucleate and evolve dynamically and are difficult to capture. Consequently, the AlCl3-assisted MgTR route remains mechanistically ambiguous,40–42 hindering the establishment of predictive design rules necessary to fully exploit this low-temperature strategy for silicon synthesis. Notably, existing interpretations rely almost exclusively on ex situ characterization, which does not provide access to the temporal sequence of intermediate formation and phase evolution during the reduction.
In this work, we investigate the AlCl3-assisted MgTR of diatom-derived SiO2 obtained from industrially cultured diatoms13 by combining systematic ex situ characterization with time-resolved in situ synchrotron X-ray diffraction. This integrated approach enables the establishment of a robust mechanistic and parametric framework for the reduction process, elucidating how key synthesis parameters—including heating ramp, salt content, and isothermal holding time—govern the crystalline Si fraction and phase composition. Finally, we show the electrochemical performance of the resulting SiOx/graphite electrode blends, thereby providing design principles for the scalable synthesis of sustainable, high-performance Si anodes from nanostructured silica.
Ex situ X-ray diffraction (XRD) was carried out on a PANalytical X'Pert PRO diffractometer equipped with Cu Kα radiation (λ = 1.5406 Å). Rietveld refinement was employed to determine the phase composition and to calculate weight fractions of the post-reduction products. For quantification of the crystalline silicon fraction in the acid-washed SiOx, the powders were mixed with a known amount of corundum (Al2O3) as an internal standard, which allowed quantification of the amorphous content.
Nitrogen physisorption was conducted using a Micromeritics ASAP 2020 system. Samples were degassed at 150 °C for 12 h prior to analysis. The specific surface area (SSA) was determined by the Brunauer–Emmett–Teller (BET) method, and the pore size distribution was obtained from the adsorption branch using the Barrett–Joyner–Halenda (BJH) model.
Reduction reactions were carried out by thoroughly mixing diatom-SiO2 with Mg and AlCl3 in defined molar ratios. The SiO2
:
Mg molar ratio was fixed at 1
:
2, while the SiO2
:
AlCl3 ratio was varied between 1
:
5 and 1
:
10 to investigate the influence of salt content. For each ex situ experiment, the total reactant mass was 200 mg. The powders were manually ground using an agate mortar and pestle inside an Ar filled glovebox until a homogeneous mixture was obtained. The mixtures were transferred to stainless-steel crucibles with lids and placed in a tube furnace under continuous Ar flow. Temperature programs were systematically varied to study the effect of heating parameters. Heating rates of 2, 5, and 10 °C min−1 were employed, followed by isothermal holds at 250 °C for 12–24 h. Representative images of the precursor mixture inside the reactor and the resulting reaction products are provided in Section S2.1 of the SI. After thermal treatment, the products were washed with 1 M HCl, filtered, rinsed with DI water and ethanol, and dried at 80 °C under vacuum overnight.
Samples are denoted using the format R–T–S, where R corresponds to the heating ramp rate (2, 5 or 10 °C min−1), T indicates the isothermal holding time (12 or 24 h), and S denotes the salt content (L-low or H-high). Details of the reaction parameters are summarized in Table 1.
:
Mg
:
AlCl3) are given in moles
| Sample ID | SiO2 : Mg : AlCl3 |
Ramp rate (°C min−1) | Hold time (h) | Salt content |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| R5-T12-SL | 1 : 2 : 5 |
5 | 12 | Low |
| R5-T24-SL | 1 : 2 : 5 |
5 | 24 | Low |
| R5-T12-SH | 1 : 2 : 10 |
5 | 12 | High |
| R5-T24-SH | 1 : 2 : 10 |
5 | 24 | High |
| R2-T24-SH | 1 : 2 : 10 |
2 | 24 | High |
| R10-T24-SH | 1 : 2 : 10 |
10 | 24 | High |
The slurries were cast onto copper foil using a doctor blade with a gap height of 50 µm, followed by drying at 60 °C under vacuum overnight. Circular electrodes with a diameter of 16 mm were punched out and further dried at 120 °C under dynamic vacuum in the antechamber of an Ar-filled glovebox prior to assembly into coin-type half cells. Electrode mass loadings were 1.05 mg ⋅cm−2. Each cell consisted of a working electrode (graphite, graphite–SiO2, or graphite–SiOx), a lithium metal foil counter/reference electrode, and a Whatman GF/A glass fiber separator. The electrolyte was 1 M LiPF6 dissolved in a 1
:
1 (v/v) mixture of ethylene carbonate (EC) and diethyl carbonate (DEC).
Phase analysis of the unwashed samples indicates the formation of typical AlCl3-assisted MgTR reaction products under both SL and SH conditions, including crystalline Si, Al, MgCl2·6H2O, and AlCl3·6H2O. In particular, elemental Mg was not detected. After AW, the diffractograms reveal the presence of crystalline Si and a broad peak centered at 2θ ≈ 22.5°, corresponding to residual amorphous SiO2. The peaks attributed to Al, MgCl2·6H2O, and AlCl3·6H2O are no longer observed, confirming their effective removal. A consistent low-intensity peak at 2θ ≈ 45°, marked with an asterisk, appears in all AW samples—R5-T12-SL, R5-T24-SL, R5-T12-SH, and R5-T24-SH. This peak does not correspond to any of the known reaction products present before acid washing, suggesting the formation of a minor unidentified phase.
Samples reduced at different heating rates (10, 5, and 2 °C min−1) also show characteristic peaks of AlCl3·6H2O, MgCl2·6H2O, Al, and Si. After acid washing, the patterns are dominated by prominent Si peaks and the same broad feature corresponding to residual amorphous SiO2. The sample R2-T24-SH, reduced at 2 °C min−1, exhibits two additional peaks at 2θ ≈ 26.6° and 45.5° that are not associated with any previously identified phases in the pre-AW diffractograms. The samples R5-T24-SH and R10-T24-SH also display the 45° impurity peak, though the 26.6° peak is absent. These low-intensity peaks, annotated with asterisks, are not clearly discernible in the pre-AW data due to background noise. To further investigate the origin of the unidentified reflections, several control experiments were performed (see Section S2.2 of the SI). The results suggest that the reflections likely originate from residual Al- and/or Cl-containing species, although their low diffraction intensity precludes an unambiguous phase assignment.
Rietveld refinement was performed on samples pre- and post-AW for the quantification of the crystalline Si fraction and other post-reduction products. The phase composition of all samples pre-AW is summarized in Section S2.3 of the SI. After AW, weight phase percentages show a clear trend with varying parameters as indicated in Table 2. First, fixing the heating ramp to 5 °C indicates that prolonged isothermal holding time and the increased salt-to-SiO2 ratio enhance the crystalline Si fraction, with the sample synthesized under SH conditions and 24 h holding time showing 25.52 wt% Si. Among the samples subjected to varying heating ramps under SH conditions and a 24 h holding time, R2-T24-SH displayed the lowest Si content (19.89%) followed by R5-T24-SH (25.52%) and R10-T24-SH (28.71%), which indicates that a faster heating protocol could favor the SiO2 reduction. Moreover, analysis of post-AW samples confirmed the effective removal of the main chloride salts and metallic aluminum phases, although minor residual species cannot be completely excluded.
| Sample ID | Phase wt% post-AW | |
|---|---|---|
| Crystalline Si | Amorphous content | |
| R5-T12-SL | 16.70 | 83.30 |
| R5-T24-SL | 20.14 | 79.96 |
| R5-T12-SH | 19.31 | 80.69 |
| R5-T24-SH | 25.52 | 74.48 |
| R10-T24-SH | 28.71 | 71.29 |
| R2-T24-SH | 19.89 | 80.11 |
The nitrogen adsorption–desorption isotherms for the pristine SiO2 frustules, R5-T12-SL, R5-T24-SL, R5-T12-SH, and R5-T24-SH are presented in Fig. 2a. Up to a relative pressure of p/p0 = 0.95, both low-salt samples exhibit lower adsorption than the precursor. However, beyond this point, the isotherm of R5-T12-SL surpasses that of the precursor, achieving the highest adsorbed gas quantity among the three. All samples show type IV isotherms with hysteresis loops. The isotherms of R5-T12-SH and R5-T24-SH closely resemble those of their low-salt counterparts, confirming the presence of mesoporosity in all samples. Fig. 2b presents the SSA distribution derived from the t-plot method. All MgTR-processed samples exhibit lower SSAs compared to the pristine frustules, which display a total SSA of 69.72 m2 g−1—composed of 46.21 m2 g−1 external and 23.51 m2 g−1 micropore area. For R5-T12-SL, the total SSA is reduced to 44.66 m2 g−1 (28.38 mg2 g−1 external and 16.28 m2 g−1 microporous), while prolonging the isothermal hold time to 24 h (R5-T24-SL) further decreases both components to 26.12 m2 g−1 and 12.56 m2 g−1, respectively. These results indicate a progressive loss of surface area with extended heat treatment under low salt conditions.
The high-salt samples, R5-T12-SH and R5-T24-SH, exhibit similar micropore areas of 15.06 and 15.44 m2 g−1, respectively—lower than the precursor's value. However, in contrast to the low-salt series, the external surface area increases with extended holding time: R5-T24-SH exhibits 37.73 m2 g−1 compared to 26.05 m2 g−1 for R5-T12-SH. This inverse trend suggests that salt content critically influences the evolution of surface area during MgTR.
In terms of BET surface area, both R5-T12-SL and R5-T24-SL show reduced values (44.66 and 38.68 m2 g−1, respectively) compared to the pristine frustules. A corresponding decline is observed in cumulative mesopore surface area, which decreases from 39.21 m2 g−1 in the precursor to 15.38 m2 g−1 and 16.98 m2 g−1 for the 12 h and 24 h samples, respectively. The average mesopore diameter increases significantly upon processing—49.02 nm and 29.49 nm for R5-T12-SL and R5-T24-SL, respectively—suggesting coalescence or collapse of smaller pores during reduction, particularly under prolonged heating. Under high salt conditions, R5-T12-SH exhibits a total SSA of 41.10 m2 g−1 and a mesopore surface area of 13.47 m2 g−1. Extending the hold time to 24 h increases both values to 53.17 m2 g−1 and 28.65 m2 g−1, respectively—an opposite trend to that observed in the low-salt series.
Fig. 2c presents the nitrogen isotherms of samples synthesized at different heating ramp rates. All exhibit type IV isotherms with hysteresis at p/p0 > 0.9. Fig. 2d displays the corresponding SSA distribution, revealing that micropore area remains relatively constant (16 m2 g−1) across all ramp rates, while external surface area increases with faster heating: 24.82, 37.73, and 43.25 m2 g−1 for R2-T24-SH, R5-T24-SH, and R10-T24-SH, respectively. This trend indicates that a faster heating ramp promotes external surface development during reduction. BET and BJH data (Table 3) further support this observation: total SSA increases with ramp rate, reaching 59.35 m2 g−1 for R10-T24-SH, compared to 53.17 m2 g−1 and 40.76 m2 g−1 for R5-T24-SH and R2-T24-SH, respectively. Similarly, cumulative mesopore surface area increases from 15.23 m2 g−1 (2 °C min−1) to 28.65 m2 g−1 (5 m2 g−1) and 33.54 m2 g−1 (10 °C min−1). In contrast, the average mesopore diameter decreases with increasing ramp rate, from 39.94 nm at 2 °C min−1 to 23.44 nm at 5 °C min−1 and 24.17 nm at 10 °C min−1. This suggests that faster heating leads to finer mesopores and greater external surface area.
| Sample ID | SSA [mg2 g−1] | Cumulative mesopore surface area [mg2 g−1] | Avg. mesopore diameter [nm] |
|---|---|---|---|
| SiO2 frustules | 69.72 | 39.21 | 15.61 |
| R5-T12-SL | 44.66 | 15.38 | 49.02 |
| R5-T24-SL | 38.68 | 16.98 | 29.49 |
| R5-T12-SH | 41.10 | 13.47 | 38.90 |
| R5-T24-SH | 53.17 | 28.65 | 23.44 |
| R10-T24-SH | 59.35 | 33.54 | 24.17 |
| R2-T24-SH | 40.76 | 15.23 | 39.94 |
Fig. 2e–h present TEM analysis of selected post-AW samples, illustrating the influence of salt content and thermal parameters on the microstructure and phase composition. Fig. 2e shows HAADF-STEM images of the R5-T24-SL sample, synthesized with low salt content. This sample consists of three main components: amorphous SiO2 frustules, amorphous SiOx, and crystalline Si. Compared to the other samples, it contains a higher fraction of residual SiO2 and a lower relative content of SiOx (x < 1) and crystalline Si. STEM-EELS/EDS mapping confirms the coexistence of these phases, and EDS quantification of SiOx particles in the mapped region yields an average composition of 74 at% Si, 23 at% O, 2.3 at% Cl, and 0.8 at% Al. By contrast, Fig. 2f displays bright-field TEM images of the R2-T24-SH sample, prepared with high salt content and the slowest ramp rate. This sample contains only amorphous SiO2 particles and crystalline Si particles, with no evidence of composite domains (i.e., Si nanocrystals embedded in an amorphous matrix). Elemental mapping (EELS and EDS) of the red-framed region confirms Si and O as the main constituents, along with surface-localized carbon, while Mg, Al, and Cl are absent.
Fig. 2g shows the results for the R5-T24-SH sample, prepared with a high salt content and a moderate heating ramp. The sample contains amorphous SiO2 frustules, amorphous SiOx (x < 1), and crystalline Si. The magnified region reveals the presence of small Si nanocrystals embedded within an amorphous SiOx (x ≪ 1) matrix, indicative of partial composite formation. Fig. 2h presents bright-field TEM images of the R10-T24-SH sample, synthesized at the highest ramp rate. Similar to the slow-ramp counterpart (R2-T24-SH), this sample contains only amorphous SiO2 and crystalline Si particles, with no evidence of composite domains. Elemental maps from the red-framed STEM region confirm Si and O as the dominant elements, with only trace amounts of Al and no detectable Mg or Cl. Taken together, these observations highlight that composite formation is highly sensitive to the heating ramp and salt content, with intermediate conditions favoring the partial embedding of crystalline Si within an amorphous SiOx matrix. At this point, it is worth noting that the apparent preservation of the precursor morphology is associated with the fraction of the material that remains unreacted or only partially reduced. In contrast, regions where crystalline Si particles are formed do not retain the original morphology. This behavior agrees with previous studies on AlCl3-assisted reductions, where silica undergoes structural disintegration prior to Si crystallization.39,47,48
:
Mg
:
AlCl3 molar ratios of 1
:
2
:
5 and 1
:
2
:
10) were employed to investigate the effect of the SL and SH concentrations.
An initial in situ experiment was conducted to define appropriate measurement conditions and temperature protocols, as shown in Figure S4 of the SI. The sample was first heated to 220 °C and held isothermally, followed by a second isothermal step at 250 °C and a final heating stage to 300 °C, where the temperature was maintained for 2 h. Analysis of the diffraction data revealed that an isothermal step of 30 min was sufficient for phase evolution to stabilize at each temperature. Moreover, a markedly higher reaction progress was observed between 250 and 300 °C, identifying this interval as critical for the reduction process. Since the in situ measurements are specifically designed to investigate the reaction dynamics and phase evolution, the thermal protocol initially explored the same synthesis temperature used in the ex situ experiments (250 °C) and was subsequently extended stepwise to 400 °C, with isothermal holding times of 30 min, in order to expand the explored temperature range and gain further insights into the reaction pathway. Nevertheless, the key mechanistic events of the reduction occur within the temperature range investigated under ex situ conditions.
No signal of reaction is observed during the initial heating stage. When the temperature is further increased up to ∼125 °C, within the molten salt activation stage, the first indications of MgAl2Cl8 formation appear. At ∼170 °C, the formation of the mixed salt accelerates, leading to the crystallization of metallic Al and the partial consumption of Mg, indicating no significant difference in the activation onset temperature compared to the SL case. From this temperature to 235 °C, the mixed salt disappears from the diffractograms, while metallic Al continues to form. Mg is further consumed and a strong diffuse scattering signal emerges in the background, as indicated by the red box in Fig. 4a. Therefore, the molten salt activation stage follows essentially the same reaction pathway as in the low salt experiment, with one notable difference: no crystallization of MgCl2 is observed by the end of this stage. The SiO2 reduction stage also follows a similar pathway. During the first holding step, at 250 °C, Si and AlOCl reflections slowly emerge while metallic Al is progressively consumed. This process further accelerates upon heating up to 350 °C, beyond which no significant reaction signal is detected. Moreover, the scattering signal associated with the molten phase persists throughout the entire reduction stage. Upon cooling, reflections corresponding to a new crystalline structure abruptly emerge at 230 °C, while the diffuse scattering signal disappears, indicating the crystallization of a previously molten phase. Importantly, this phase is not residual AlCl3, but is instead consistent with the MgAl2Cl8 structure, confirming the complete consumption of the salt during the reaction. However, its quantification is not possible since it crystallized as a polycrystalline phase rather than as a powder phase, as shown in Figure S8 of the SI. It should be mentioned that under these SH conditions, the Al and Cl supplied by AlCl3 exceed the amount that can be accommodated in the crystalline phases detected by XRD. The excess is therefore attributed to a chloride-rich molten or amorphous reservoir that gives rise to the diffuse scattering observed at high temperature and only partially crystallizes upon cooling.
To further probe the role of metallic Al in the reaction pathway and to detect when the reduction of SiO2 starts, an additional in situ experiment was performed under SH conditions, using crystalline SiO2 as the precursor (see Section S3.5 of the SI). Unlike the amorphous SiO2, using the crystalline precursor enables direct monitoring of SiO2 consumption through its diffraction reflections. Results from this experiment show the concurrent consumption of metallic Al and crystalline SiO2, providing additional evidence that supports the participation of metallic Al during the reduction.
Finally, comparison between SL and SH conditions highlights the influence of AlCl3 content on the evolution of intermediate species and final products. As previously mentioned, MgAl2Cl8 disappears at temperatures of approximately 235 °C, indicating a transition to a molten chloride-rich phase. This behavior is consistent with the reported AlCl3–MgCl2 phase diagram, which shows a pronounced depression of the melting temperature near 67 mol% AlCl3, corresponding to the stoichiometric composition of MgAl2Cl8.49 The evolution of the molten phase strongly depends on the AlCl3 content. Under SL conditions, the system shifts away from this AlCl3-rich composition during heating, promoting the formation of MgCl2 and metallic Al. In contrast, under SH conditions the higher AlCl3 content keeps the system within the AlCl3-rich regime, enabling the recrystallization of MgAl2Cl8 upon cooling.
Gr-SiOx electrodes exhibited markedly higher initial lithiation capacities (460–518 mAh g−1; Fig. 5c–g and Table 4). This capacity enhancement was accompanied by a reduction in ICE (77.6–81.7%), with samples containing higher crystalline Si fractions (R10-T24-SH and R5-T24-SH) showing the lowest ICE values, indicative of increased irreversible reactions during SEI formation and the first alloying cycle. In contrast, R5-T12-SH and R2-T24-SH, with the lowest Si content, exhibited the highest ICE (81.7%).
| Sample ID | Si [wt%] | ICE [%] | Cycle 1 | Cycle 10 | Cycle 50 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Gr | — | 84.52 | 384 | 330 | 331 |
| Gr-SiO2 | — | 79.12 | 395 | 309 | 310 |
| R5-T12-SH | 19.31 | 80.28 | 494 | 350 | 336 |
| R5-T24-SH | 25.52 | 77.94 | 509 | 350 | 342 |
| R10-T24-SH | 28.71 | 77.56 | 518 | 337 | 324 |
| R2-T24-SH | 19.89 | 81.65 | 460 | 325 | 314 |
After 50 cycles, the reversible capacities of the Gr-SiOx electrodes stabilized between 314 and 342 mAh g−1. R5-T12-SH and R5-T24-SH retained 68.4% and 67.2% of their initial lithiation capacities, respectively, and retained capacities above that of graphite (331 mAh g−1). In contrast, R10-T24-SH and R2-T24-SH exhibited faster capacity decay and dropped below the graphite baseline within 20–30 cycles, highlighting the trade-off between Si content and cycling stability. All electrodes reached coulombic efficiencies above 99.8% after 30 cycles, while graphite achieved the highest CE after 50 cycles (99.98%), closely followed by R5-T12-SH (99.93%).
Differential capacity (dQ/dV) analysis (Fig. S10 of the SI) supports these conclusions. While Gr and Gr-SiO2 showed only graphite-related features, Gr-SiOx electrodes exhibited additional peaks at 0.04 V and 0.45 V associated with the lithiation and delithiation of crystalline Li15Si4. These features progressively weakened and disappeared by 30 cycles, indicating early formation but rapid electrochemical deactivation of crystalline Si. The more persistent Li15Si4 signal observed for R2-T24-SH is consistent with its faster capacity decay. Overall, R5-T12-SH and R5-T24-SH deliver the most balanced performance.
The observed electrochemical trends appear to be influenced by the structural properties and phase composition of the synthesized SiOx material. In particular, the higher initial capacity correlates with the higher crystalline Si fraction, and it is also associated with a lower ICE. However, this enhancement cannot be exclusively attributed to the crystalline Si fraction, since contributions from the amorphous content, different surface area, and irreversible reactions occurring during lithiation of SiO2 particles may also play an important role. The present data do not allow all these contributions to be disentangled. These results nevertheless confirm the activity of the synthesized SiOx material when incorporated into SiGr blended electrodes.
Time-resolved in situ synchrotron X-ray diffraction provides important insights into the AlCl3-MgTR reaction mechanism. The results show the early formation of metallic Al and later consumption and the persistence of a chlorine-rich molten phase throughout Si crystallization, enabling SiO2 reduction at temperatures as low as 300 °C. The mixed salt MgAl2Cl8 is identified as the first crystalline intermediate, forming directly from the interaction of AlCl3 with Mg and acting as a precursor to metallic Al generation. These findings support that the Si formation proceeds through the previously reported chlorine transfer mechanism, but with metallic Al acting as the effective redox-active species rather than Mg.
Ex situ structural analysis shows that extended holding times and higher AlCl3 contents increase crystalline Si yield, while faster heating ramps promote higher external surface area and finer mesoporosity. Importantly, only intermediate synthesis conditions favor the formation of Si nanocrystals embedded in an amorphous SiOx matrix, which provides an optimal balance between electrochemical activity and structural stability.
Electrochemical evaluation of Gr-SiOx composite anodes confirms the electrochemical activity of the synthesized powders. Materials containing moderate crystalline Si fractions (20–25 wt%) and that preserve mesoporosity exhibit the most favorable electrochemical response, delivering CE above 99.8% after moderate cycling time. In contrast, samples with a higher crystalline Si fraction show faster capacity fading, suggesting that electrochemical performance is influenced by multiple structural factors.
Overall, this study demonstrates that the performance of biosilica-derived SiOx is not dictated by silicon content alone, but by the interplay of crystallinity, surface area, and impurity phases controlled through synthesis parameters. By combining in situ mechanistic insights with systematic structural and electrochemical analysis, this work establishes clear design principles for AlCl3-assisted MgTR, advancing a low-temperature and scalable route for sustainable silicon anode materials.
Supplementary information (SI) is available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d6ta02278b.
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2026 |