Open Access Article
Li Zhang
abc,
Beth E. Murdock
abc,
Xiao Hua
ac and
Nuria Tapia-Ruiz
*bc
aDepartment of Chemistry, Lancaster University, Lancaster LA1 4YB, UK
bDepartment of Chemistry, Molecular Sciences Research Hub, White City Campus, Imperial College London, London W12 0BZ, UK. E-mail: n.tapia-ruiz@imperial.ac.uk
cThe Faraday Institution, Quad One, Harwell Science and Innovation Campus, Didcot OX11 0RA, UK
First published on 24th March 2026
The ongoing advancement of rechargeable batteries has motivated extensive efforts to optimise cathode materials through targeted chemical doping to enhance electrochemical performance. Yet, the atomic-scale consequences of transition metal substitution, particularly its influence on atomic arrangement and/or cation ordering, remain insufficiently understood. A central challenge arises because transition metal dopants frequently occupy the same crystallographic site as the host transition metal species, complicating the analysis of the resulting cation distribution. Previous neutron pair distribution function (NPDF) investigations of the spinel cathode LiMn1.5Ni0.5O4 have shown that comparing local (short-range) and average (long-range) site occupancies of Mn and Ni can provide valuable insight into transition metal arrangements. Building upon this strategy, the present work employs NPDF to examine how Fe doping modifies lattice parameters and cation ordering within the spinel framework. Fe substitution is particularly attractive because it offers cost advantages and has been linked to improved electrochemical performance. This study identifies how Fe incorporation modifies the site occupancy of Mn and Ni, determines the preferential lattice sites adopted by Fe, and establishes an analytical framework for disentangling dopant-induced structural modifications in oxide cathodes.
One widely adopted approach to enhance cathode performance is cation substitution, which enables fine-tuning of composition and structure to improve electrochemical behaviour through modulation of redox processes, structural evolution and ion diffusion pathways.2–4 Among commonly explored dopants, iron is particularly attractive due to its natural abundance, low cost, and environmentally benign character. Its favourable metal–oxygen bond covalency facilitates redox activation and has been shown to enhance cycling stability and rate capability.5,6 Although numerous studies have shown that dopants can improve morphology and structural stability, among others, the influence of substituted cations on the local atomic arrangements, particularly transition metal (TM) ordering, remains poorly understood.7–9
Alkali-metal (AM) transition metal oxides with inherently good electronic conductivity represent one of the most promising families of cathode materials for commercial deployment.10–12 Their crystal structures are fundamentally governed by the alkali-to-metal ratio, where for lithium-based cathodes with formula Li1+xTM1−xO2 (0 ≤ x ≤ 1/3), compositions adopt layered or disordered rocksalt structures, whereas LiTM2O4 materials crystallise in the spinel structure.13,14 For sodium oxide-based cathodes, e.g., NaxTMO2 (0.44 ≤ x ≤ 1), compositions generally exhibit layered structures, though the stacking arrangement and Na coordination environments differ substantially from those in Li analogues.15
Building on these structural insights, detailed structural analyses have shown, for example, that species such as Ni and Mg can partially occupy AM sites in some layered oxide compositions, displacing alkali ions into TM layers and thereby altering the local atomic environment.16,17 These findings highlight that cation distributions can be highly complex and, as a result, are often difficult to distinguish by conventional X-ray or neutron diffraction. This is a significant issue because cation ordering is widely recognised as a key determinant of electrochemical performance.18–23 This becomes even more pronounced in multicomponent oxides, where dopant distributions may be heterogeneous and subtle variations in local structure can exert significant electrochemical consequences.24 Advanced techniques such as reverse Monte Carlo (RMC) modelling combined with pair distribution function (PDF) analysis have emerged as powerful tools for probing short-range order, yet further methodological refinement is required to reliably capture TM configurations in these complex systems.25,26 Addressing this gap, by clarifying how dopants influence cation ordering, would enable stronger structure–property correlations and guide the rational design of next-generation cathode compositions.
TM ordering in the high-voltage LiMn1.5Ni0.5O4 (LMNO) spinel plays a decisive role in defining Li-ion transport pathways, redox accessibility, and long-range structural stability.27 While LMNO is often described as ordered or disordered, recent neutron PDF studies have demonstrated that ordering is highly length-scale dependent: local Mn/Ni arrangements remain largely intact at short distances, whereas substantial cation disorder emerges beyond ≈10–20 Å.28 This structural heterogeneity originates from inter-unit Mn–Ni exchange processes and produces domains with differing TM compositions that are invisible to average crystallographic models. Consequently, probing LMNO across multiple real-space windows is essential for identifying the true distribution of Mn, Ni, and dopant/substituent atoms, as well as understanding their influence on electrochemical behaviour.
In parallel, cation substitution has emerged as an effective strategy for tuning the structural and electrochemical characteristics of spinel cathodes.32,33 By adjusting the local bonding environment, modulating oxygen coordination, and altering the valence states of TM atoms, substituents can stabilise the spinel framework, regulate redox chemistry, and enhance Li-ion transport. Fe, in particular, offers unique advantages due to its natural abundance, stability in the Fe3+ state, favourable metal–oxygen bond covalency, and demonstrated ability to influence Mn and Ni valence states.29–31 Prior studies have shown that introducing Fe into LMNO can improve cycling stability, modify redox potentials, and expand the Mn3+/Mn4+ contribution near 4.1–4.2 V, thereby tuning both lattice parameters and electrochemical behaviour.32
To accurately resolve these structural subtleties, real-space PDF analysis using the P4332 structural model is essential.28 Unlike the commonly adopted Fd
m model, which places Mn and Ni on the same 16d site and therefore masks important cation redistributions, the P4332 symmetry explicitly distinguishes Mn and Ni within the 12d and 4b sites, respectively. This site specificity enables detailed interrogation of TM ordering across short-, intermediate-, and long-range environments, providing a powerful platform for understanding how thermal treatment, compositional tuning, and targeted Fe substitution reshape the structural landscape of LMNO. Moreover, structural connections among layered, spinel, and rock-salt Li-oxide cathodes provide a broader context for understanding these effects.33–36 Such structural relationships highlight the importance of understanding how dopants, particularly in this case, redox-active species like Fe, shape the evolution of local TM environments.32,33
In this work, we combine multiscale neutron PDF (NPDF) analysis with systematic Fe substitution to investigate how dopants redistribute within the spinel lattice and how these rearrangements correlate with electrochemical behaviour. By examining both Ni-substituted LiMn1.5Ni0.5−2xFe2xO4 and Mn/Ni co-substituted LiMn1.5−xNi0.5−xFe2xO4 (x = 0.05 and 0.1) compositions, and comparing post-annealed (PA) and non-annealed (NA) LMNO, we directly track the evolution of Mn, Ni, and Fe occupancies from the local (1–6.5 Å) to extended (5–40 Å) structural regimes. This approach reveals how Fe dopants alter Mn/Ni ordering, how cation–exchange processes propagate across structural domains, and how these modifications influence the electrochemical behaviour of these materials. Through this combined structural–electrochemical framework, we provide new insights into the design of high-performance spinel cathodes based on controlled TM ordering and site-selective doping.
:
1 molar ratio of oxalic acid to total cations, stirred for 2 h at ambient temperature, and dried overnight in a 50 °C water bath under continuous stirring. The resulting precipitates were preheated at 500 °C for 6 h to remove residual organics.
For LiMn1.5Ni0.5O4 and Fe-substituted materials, the preheated powders were pelletised under a pressure of 5 N cm−2 and calcined at 900 °C for 24 h without post-annealing, using heating and cooling rates of 10 °C min−1. The obtained LiMn1.5Ni0.5O4 is referred to as non-annealed LMNO (NA-LMNO). A second batch of LiMn1.5Ni0.5O4 was calcined at 900 °C for 24 h, followed by post-annealing at 700 °C for 48 h, with heating and cooling rates of 3 °C min−1 and 1 °C min−1, respectively. This sample is designated as post-annealed LMNO (PA-LMNO).29
:
10
:
10 using a planetary ball mill (TOB energy). PVDF was dissolved in N-methyl-2-pyrrolidone (NMP, 99.9%, Aladdin) to make a 5 wt% solution. Slurries were cast onto Al foil (16 µm, 99.45%, TOB New Energy) using a doctor blade and dried overnight at 80 °C. Electrodes of 12 mm diameter were punched, pressed at 3 N using a hydraulic press, and vacuum dried at 120 °C overnight before they were transferred into an Ar-filled MBraun glovebox (<0.1 ppm H2O and O2). The mass loading of the active materials was approximately 2.8 mg cm−2.
CR2032 coin cells were assembled using lithium metal chips (99.99%, TOB New Energy) as counter electrodes, 1 M LiPF6 in EC/DMC (1
:
1 v/v, Sigma-Aldrich) as electrolyte, and glass fiber separators (Whatman, GF/F). Galvanostatic cycling was performed at room temperature using a Neware CT-4008Tn system at 1C (1C = 147 mA g−1) over a voltage window of 3.5–4.9 V.
All NPDF refinements of LMNO were carried out using the P4332 structural model (Fig. 1, S1 and S2), which assigns Mn and Ni to crystallographically distinct 12d and 4b sites, respectively (Fig. 1b, left). In contrast, Fd
m locates both cations on the same 16d site (Fig. 1b, right). As the Mn/Ni disorder increases, Mn occupancy on the 12d sites decreases while its occupancy on the 4b site increases; complete disorder corresponds to 75% Mn occupancy on both sites. When Mn occupation on the 12d sites falls below this threshold, some unit cells necessarily accommodate fully Mn-occupied 4b sites, leading to a combination of intra-unit cell and inter-unit cell disorder motifs.
The NPDF patterns of PA- and NA-LMNO (Fig. 1a and c) reveal that both materials exhibit highly similar local structures over the 1–6.5 Å range, whereas substantial divergences appear at intermediate and extended ranges (5–40 Å). This is consistent with reported NPDF results of ordered and disordered LMNO.28 Following established refinement protocols for spinel LMNO, the Mn/Ni occupancies were constrained during fitting (Table S1), where the Ni-4b occupancy (occTM1) defines all other site fractions: Mn-4b = (1 − occTM1), Ni-12d = (1 − occTM1)/3, and Mn-12d = (2 + occTM1)/3.
Short-range NPDF refinements (1–6.5 Å) indicate that both PA-LMNO and NA-LMNO retain predominantly ordered cation arrangements, with only a minor degree of local TM mixing. Mn occupies the 12d sites at 99.58% in PA-LMNO and 97.13% in NA-LMNO (Tables S4 and S5), confirming that the Mn–O and Ni–O coordination environments remain largely intact immediately surrounding each TM atom.
However, a clear structural divergence emerges as the fitting range is extended. Over 5–40 Å, PA-LMNO maintains a highly ordered TM configuration, with Mn occupancy on the 12d sites remaining at 95.70%. In contrast, NA-LMNO shows a pronounced increase in disorder, with Mn-12d occupancy falling to 77.38%, approaching the statistical limit for complete Mn/Ni disorder. This pronounced redistribution across the 12d and 4b sites in NA-LMNO highlights the coexistence of locally ordered domains embedded within a disordered matrix and provides a sensitive platform for probing dopant-driven cation rearrangement and preferential site occupancy in subsequent Fe-substituted compositions.
To evaluate Fe site preference, two structural models were tested: Model 1, with Fe initially placed on the 4b site; and Model 2, with Fe initially located at the 12d site (Table 1). The initial structural models were constructed with Mn and Ni fully occupying the 12d and 4b sites, respectively. For simplicity, the total octahedral site occupancies were constrained to equal 1, although true occupancies may be reduced by cation loss to impurity phases or by anti-site defects that place TMs on tetrahedral Li 8a sites. This simplification is justified because the impurity concentration in the Fe-substituted samples is negligible, as evidenced by the X-ray diffraction patterns shown in Fig. S7. Moreover, although anti-site defects are present (≈2% TM on the Li site), as reported previously, their concentration does not vary with Fe content.29 Subsequently, site exchange of TM atoms between the 12d and 4b sites was allowed using the initial Fe/Mn or Fe/Ni ratios listed in Table 1, thereby allowing all three TM atoms to occupy both sites. The occupancy rates of TM atoms in Fe-substituted materials are summarised in Tables S2 and S3.
| Occupancy rates (×100%) | Model 1 – Fe in 4b-site | Model 2 – Fe in 12d-site | ||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 12d site | 4b site | 12d site | 4b site | |||||||||
| Mn | Ni | Fe | Mn | Ni | Fe | Mn | Ni | Fe | Mn | Ni | Fe | |
| LiMn1.5Ni0.4Fe0.1O4 | 1 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 4/5 | 1/5 | 14/15 | 0 | 1/15 | 1/5 | 4/5 | 0 |
| LiMn1.5Ni0.3Fe0.2O4 | 1 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 3/5 | 2/5 | 13/15 | 0 | 2/15 | 2/5 | 3/5 | 0 |
| LiMn1.45Ni0.45Fe0.1O4 | 29/30 | 1/30 | 0 | 0 | 4/5 | 1/5 | 14/15 | 0 | 1/15 | 1/10 | 9/10 | 0 |
| LiMn1.4Ni0.4Fe0.2O4 | 14/15 | 1/15 | 0 | 0 | 3/5 | 2/5 | 13/15 | 0 | 2/15 | 1/5 | 4/5 | 0 |
Ni occupancy became unphysical (negative) in Model 2 during refinements of Mn/Ni co-substituted compositions, indicating that Fe substitution favours the Ni site (4b) rather than the Mn site (12d). Thus, Model 1 was adopted for all Fe-substituted materials. We note that the individual site occupancies of Ni and Fe cannot be determined with high confidence due to their similar coherent neutron scattering lengths.40 Consequently, their refined occupancies should be interpreted as reflecting relative trends rather than absolute values. Nevertheless, the collective refinement consistently indicates a strong preferential substitution of Fe on the Ni sites, with only minor variation in this preference as the overall Fe content increases. This also suggests that despite the intrinsic limitation of neutron scattering, a comparative analysis across a systematic composition series still yields convincing composition-dependent structural information to enable identification of important site-substitution behaviour in our materials.
As the fitting range increases from 5–20 to 5–40 Å, PA-LMNO and NA-LMNO display divergent lattice evolution trends (Fig. 3a). The opposing behaviours reflect differences in how the four configuration units accumulate and propagate across longer structural length scales. NA-LMNO, in particular, shows a greater degree of structural complexity, indicative of more pervasive and correlated disorder within the A1–A4 network.
These observations are consistent with prior studies reporting that post-annealing reduces the oxygen-vacancy concentration in LMNO.41,42 Charge neutrality is maintained predominantly through Mn4+ → Mn3+ reduction, which decreases Mn–O electrostatic attraction and shortens Mn–cation distances. Such changes in local bonding geometry manifest directly in the interatomic distances obtained from PDF analysis and correlate with the refined site occupancies reported in Tables S4 and S5.
All four Fe-substituted samples exhibit systematically larger lattice parameters than LMNO across all fitting ranges (Fig. 3a and Tables S6–S9). For instance, in the short-range window, the lattice parameter (a) increases to 8.162 Å (LiMn1.5Ni0.4Fe0.1O4), 8.177 Å (LiMn1.5Ni0.3Fe0.2O4), 8.160 Å (LiMn1.45Ni0.45Fe0.1O4), and 8.169 Å (LiMn1.4Ni0.4Fe0.2O4). These lattice differences indicate two clear trends: (a) for a fixed Fe concentration, Ni-substituted compositions exhibit larger lattice parameters than Mn/Ni co-substituted materials; and (b) for both substitution routes, increasing Fe content leads to progressively larger lattice parameters. The consistency of these trends across all fitting ranges (1–6.5 Å, 5–20 Å, and 5–40 Å), and their agreement with published neutron diffraction data on Fe-substituted LMNO, underscores their robustness.29
The lattice expansion in these samples is governed by the valence states and charge-compensation mechanisms associated with Fe incorporation. Previous work shows that Fe adopts the Fe3+ valence state in LMNO when substituted.30,31 In Ni-substituted materials, the presence of Fe3+ is charge-compensated by the reduction of Mn4+ to the larger Mn3+ ions, driving lattice expansion.43 This behaviour correlates directly with the electrochemical profiles of these materials, which display an enhanced capacity contribution from the Mn3+/Mn4+ redox plateau near 4.2 V as Fe content increases.29 More detailed electrochemical behaviour of these Fe-substituted LMNO materials will be discussed below in Section 3.5. Fe serves as an effective modulator of TM valence states, influencing both the lattice structure and charge–compensation processes that occur during electrochemical cycling. In contrast, the comparatively smaller lattice expansion observed in Mn/Ni co-substituted materials suggests a reduced extent of Mn4+ reduction, consistent with smaller changes in Mn/Ni cation distribution. These findings collectively demonstrate that Fe dopants not only alter the magnitude of charge compensation but also control how local TM rearrangements evolve across different length scales within the spinel framework.
To rationalise the observed local-to-long-range evolution in cation occupancies, Fig. 5 illustrates how specific exchange events between Mn and Ni reshape the population of the 12d and 4b sites in the A1-type configuration. In the ideal P4332 spinel (Fig. 5a), Ni exclusively occupies the 4b sites, while Mn fills the 12d sites. Localised TM disorder may occur within individual A1-type configurations via one-to-one cation exchange between Mn-12d and Ni-4b atoms (Fig. 5b). For instance, exchanging one Mn-12d with a Ni-4b atom per unit formula (or swapping one pair of Mn and Ni in the unit cell) reduces the Ni-4b site occupancy from 100% to 75% and the Mn-12d occupancy from 100% to ≈91.7% (Fig. 5b, denoted as one pair). A higher degree of exchange, e.g., a complete replacement of all Ni-4b atoms by Mn atoms, with the displaced Ni atoms occupying the 12d sites (Fig. 5b, four pairs), further reduces the Ni-4b sites to 0% and decreases the Mn-12d sites to 66.7%. However, these simple intra-unit cell-exchange schemes (i.e., swapping pairs of Mn–Ni within one unit cell) cannot account alone for the experimentally observed 1–6.5 Å TM occupancies in PA- and NA-LMNO (Tables S4 and S5) ca. 90% for Ni at the 4b site, which is larger than 75% under the “one pair” scheme. To rationalise this discrepancy would require inter-unit cell exchange schemes, where Mn replace the Ni(4b) in the neighbouring unit cell (Fig. 5c), producing localised TM clusters that become increasingly evident at extended length scales. Such inter-unit cell Mn–Ni exchanges align with prior observations of complex, spatially heterogeneous TM ordering in spinel LMNO.44–46 The ordered arrangement of Mn and Ni in the other three spinel structures (A2, A3, and A4 configurations shown in Fig. 3b), after exchange via these mechanisms, follows the same trend in site occupancy as observed in the A1 configuration.
As the structural length scale probed by NPDF fitting increases, Mn/Ni cation exchange differences become markedly more pronounced. In PA-LMNO, Ni-4b occupation remains high at 94.01% (5–20 Å) and 91.82% (5–40 Å), indicating that the long-range structure is dominated by ordered configurations, with only minor and spatially heterogeneous Mn/Ni exchange. Conversely, NA-LMNO undergoes a substantial disordering at longer distances: Ni-4b occupancy drops to 42.77% at 5–20 Å and further to 32.13% at 5–40 Å, indicating extensive substitution of Ni-4b by Mn atoms, and a reciprocal increase of Ni atoms at the 12d sites. These extended-range changes confirm that NA-LMNO contains numerous Mn-rich 4b sites and Ni-rich 12d sites distributed across its structural domains, consistent with a highly disordered TM framework.
Fe-substituted LMNO materials exhibit further complexity arising from dopant-induced modifications to Mn/Ni site preference. In the 1–6.5 Å range (Fig. 4a), Mn-4b occupancies in the Ni-substituted materials, LiMn1.5Ni0.4Fe0.1O4 and LiMn1.5Ni0.3Fe0.2O4 (12.98% and 17.24%, respectively), exceed that of NA-LMNO (8.60%), despite identical Mn contents. This indicates that Fe incorporation promotes Mn-4b migration in a concentration-dependent manner and likely involves partial substitution of Mn by Fe. Over the 5–20 Å range, Mn-4b occupancies in these compositions increase above 75% (76.69% and 81.95%), demonstrating that certain lattice domains possess fully Mn-occupied 4b sites. These extended-range trends indicate the formation of Mn-rich regions whose prevalence increases with Fe content. Even at longer ranges (5–40 Å), the Mn-4b occupancies (71.49% and 78.20%) remain significantly high, indicating persistent spatially non-uniform TM distribution.
The Ni distribution shows complementary behaviour. In the 1–6.5 Å range (Fig. 4c and d), Ni-4b occupancy differs substantially between LiMn1.5Ni0.4Fe0.1O4 (69.62%) and LiMn1.5Ni0.3Fe0.2O4 (49.66%), while the Ni-12d occupancies remain nearly identical (≈3.5%). This implies that Fe dopants displace Ni predominantly from 4b sites, rather than 12d sites. This site specificity is confirmed by direct Fe occupancies: at short range (Fig. 4e and f), Fe shows a strong preference for 4b sites (17.40% in LiMn1.5Ni0.4Fe0.1O4 and 33.11% in LiMn1.5Ni0.3Fe0.2O4). However, this strong 4b site preference weakens as the fitting range increases. At 5–20 Å and 5–40 Å, Fe is distributed more evenly between 4b and 12d sites, indicating that Fe-induced disorder propagates over longer distances and promotes a more homogenised TM distribution at the extended scale.
The Fe site-occupancy behaviour in LiMn1.45Ni0.45Fe0.1O4 and LiMn1.4Ni0.4Fe0.2O4 follows trends consistent with the Ni-substituted compositions and is summarised in Fig. 4e, f, Tables S8 and S9. Within the short-range region (1–6.5 Å), Fe shows a strong preference for the 4b site, with occupancies of 18.71% and 38.50% for the two compositions. These values are significantly higher than the corresponding Fe occupancies on the 12d sites (0.43% and 0.50%), confirming that Fe incorporation in Mn/Ni co-substituted materials preferentially occurs at the 4b site. This preferential 4b occupation displaces Ni, driving its redistribution onto the 12d site, where Ni reaches 4.98% in LiMn1.45Ni0.45Fe0.1O4 and 7.34% in LiMn1.4Ni0.4Fe0.2O4 (Fig. 4d). For a fixed Fe concentration (Fig. 4e), Ni-substituted materials exhibit a lower Fe-4b occupancy than the Mn/Ni co-substituted samples, and this divergence increases with increasing Fe content.
At extended length scales (5–20 Å and 5–40 Å), the Mn/Ni co-substituted materials show marked reductions in Fe occupancy on the 4b sites, accompanied by increased Fe occupancy on 12d sites (Fig. 4e and f), indicating progressive redistribution as structural coherence length increases. Among all Fe-substituted compositions, LiMn1.4Ni0.4Fe0.2O4 exhibits a unique behaviour: its Fe-4b occupancy decreases from 18.59% (5–20 Å) to 15.97% (5–40 Å), accompanied by an occupancy decrease in Ni-4b and a compensating increase in Mn-4b (Fig. 4a and c). These changes parallel the trends observed in PA-LMNO and NA-LMNO, suggesting a common origin of the Mn/Ni disorder in these three materials that differs from the behaviour of the other Fe-substituted samples. Furthermore, these results might further indicate that co-substitution at controlled compositional limits can preserve the intrinsic TM site-occupancy preferences characteristic of LMNO.
In summary, across PA and NA-LMNO, and Fe-substituted LMNO compositions, PDF analysis reveals a clear progression in TM site occupancy from locally ordered environments to increasingly heterogeneous extended structures. While all materials show relatively ordered Mn/Ni arrangements over short length scales, long-range refinements expose substantial Mn-4b and Ni-12d redistribution in NA-LMNO and in Fe-substituted samples, consistent with extensive cation disorder at larger coherence lengths. Fe consistently prefers the 4b site at short range, displacing Ni and driving its migration to 12d positions, but this preference diminishes at longer distances as Fe, Mn, and Ni become more homogenously distributed. Notably, Mn/Ni co-substituted compositions show disorder evolution similar to NA-LMNO. Overall, these results demonstrate that cation redistribution is both range-dependent and composition-sensitive, with dopants serving as key drivers of local and extended TM disorder.
As established from our NPDF refinements, LMNO and Fe-substituted derivatives exhibit distinct degrees of cation disorder that evolve from locally ordered (1–6.5 Å) to increasingly heterogeneous extended structures (5–40 Å). These structural variations translate directly into differences in Li-diffusion environments, redox behaviour, and rate capability.
In the ideal P4332 spinel arrangement, each Li atom is coordinated by three 12d-site and one 4b-site TM neighbours, producing various diffusion environments (highlighted in blue in Fig. 5d). However, the introduction of Mn/Ni exchange, and especially Fe substitution, produces a distribution of local Li-migration geometries, including (i) three-12d/one-4b, (ii) two-12d/two-4b, and (iii) four-12d TM configurations. Our PDF results show that such environments proliferate in NA-LMNO and in all Fe-substituted compositions, particularly over extended length scales where Fe, Mn, and Ni become increasingly redistributed across both TM sites. These mixed cation environments modify local TM–O bond lengths, the electrostatic landscape experienced by Li, and the energy barriers for Li hopping. As a result, compositional and spatial fluctuations in TM occupancy directly shape lithium transport and, consequently, the electrochemical signature of these materials.43,47
These structural effects are mirrored in the galvanostatic cycling shown in Fig. 6. Ni-substituted samples (LiMn1.5Ni0.4Fe0.1O4 and LiMn1.5Ni0.3Fe0.2O4) exhibit enhanced Mn3+/Mn4+ activity near 4.1 V relative to NA-LMNO, consistent with Fe3+ substitution for Ni2+ ions, and the charge-compensating generation of Mn3+ ions.29 The corresponding expansion of the a parameter (see Section 3.3) and different redox peak intensities shown in the dQ/dV plots (Fig. 6b) reflect the modified local coordination environments observed by NPDF in these compositions. Likewise, the suppressed and shifted Ni2+/Ni4+ redox activity between 4.6–4.8 V is consistent with our observation that Fe preferentially occupies 4b sites at short range, displacing Ni toward 12d sites and disrupting its ordered electronic environment.
Mn/Ni co-substituted compositions (LiMn1.45Ni0.45Fe0.1O4 and LiMn1.4Ni0.4Fe0.2O4) reveal a distinct behaviour: although Fe should not theoretically change the nominal TM valence states compared to NA-LMNO, their non-uniform Fe distributions, evidenced by NPDF-derived long-range cation gradients, produce spatially varying Mn and Ni redox environments. These samples exhibit modified plateau intensities near both the Mn and Ni redox regions (Fig. 6a and c), signalling heterogeneous local electronic structures created by the Fe-regulated cation arrangements.
The influence of Fe concentration on capacity is directly correlated with its impact on TM disorder. Initial discharge capacities of LiMn1.5Ni0.4Fe0.1O4 and LiMn1.45Ni0.45Fe0.1O4 are 126.1 and 124.3 mA h g−1, which are higher than that of NA-LMNO (118.8 mA h g−1) (Fig. 6d and e). This indicates that moderate Fe substitution (x = 0.05) yields higher initial capacities and improved cycling stability relative to NA-LMNO. This improvement aligns with NPDF evidence that shows that this sample introduces controlled disorder, expanding the diversity of Li-migration environments without fully disrupting long-range structural coherence.
In contrast, higher Fe content (x = 0.1) leads to capacity degradation in both Ni-substituted and Mn/Ni co-substituted materials, being the capacity fade trend almost identical for both samples. The capacity decay is attributed to altered charge compensation mechanisms in the Fe-doped samples. The introduction of Fe, which undergoes redox processes above 4.9 V within the spinel structure, enhances the contribution of the Mn3+/Mn4+ redox couple to capacity. This increased manganese activity promotes the disproportionation of Mn3+ into Mn2+ and Mn4+ atoms, while dissolution of Mn2+ into the electrolyte is a cause of the cycling performance deterioration.32 At this level, NPDF refinements show substantial redistribution of Fe onto 12d sites at extended ranges, producing broad structural heterogeneity that hinders Ni redox activity and introduces kinetic limitations during Li extraction. Notably, Fe-substituted samples no longer exhibit activation, characteristic of charge capacity during cycling of NA-LMNO (Fig. 6e). This suggests that Fe-induced cation redistribution may stabilise Li diffusion pathways and suppress the local structural transformations associated with activation.
Overall, the combined NPDF and electrochemical analyses demonstrate that Fe substitution modifies performance not simply by altering composition, but by reshaping the spatial distribution of Mn, Ni, and Fe across different structural length scales. The resulting evolution of Li-migration environments provides a structural framework for understanding the tuneable redox behaviour and rate capability of Fe-modified LMNO.
Fe substitution introduces an additional layer of complexity. All Fe-containing compositions display site-selective dopant behaviour, with Fe3+ occupying Ni-4b sites at short range, yet increasingly populating Mn-12d sites as structural disorder propagates across extended distances. This progressive redistribution perturbs the local TM coordination landscape, amplifies Mn/Ni/Fe heterogeneity across domains, and produces a wider set of Li-migration environments than in pristine LMNO. Notably, the balance between short-range selectivity and long-range redistribution differs between Ni-substituted and Mn/Ni co-substituted compositions, underscoring the sensitivity of Fe-site preference to the surrounding cation chemistry.
These structural findings correlate strongly with the observed electrochemical behaviour. Moderate Fe substitution (x = 0.05) in LMNO enhances Mn3+/Mn4+ redox activity near 4.2 V, modifies Ni2+/Ni4+ contributions between 4.6–4.8 V, and suppresses the activation process characteristic of undoped NA-LMNO, which is also consistent with changes in lattice size and regulation of local Li–diffusion pathways evidenced by NPDF investigation. Higher Fe levels (x = 0.1), where NPDF refinements show more pervasive long-range cation disorder, lead to diminished capacity and accelerated fading, illustrating that the extent of disorder, and not merely its presence, is critical. Optimal performance, therefore, arises from controlled cation heterogeneity, where Fe subtly reshapes the TM lattice without generating excessive structural incoherence.
Overall, this study provides a unified structural–electrochemical framework for understanding how dopant distribution across local and extended length scales governs Li transport and redox processes in high-voltage spinels. By combining tailored substitution chemistry with quantitative short- and extended-range NPDF analysis, we demonstrate a general strategy for rationally tuning cation order, migration pathways, and functional performance. This approach may be broadly applicable to complex transition-metal oxide cathodes for Li-ion and next-generation energy storage systems, offering a pathway toward the predictive design of cathode materials with enhanced stability and rate capability.
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2026 |