Open Access Article
Priyanka
Priyadarshini
,
Subrat Kumar
Sahoo
and
Kulamani
Parida
*
Centre for Nano Science and Nano Technology, S ‘O’ A (Deemed to be University), Bhubaneswar, Odisha 751030, India. E-mail: kulamaniparida@soa.ac.in; paridakulamani@yahoo.com
First published on 20th November 2025
The limited photocatalytic performance of individual metal–organic frameworks (MOFs) restricts their practical use. To address this, the integration of distinct MOFs into MOF-on-MOF heterostructures can create well-defined charge-transfer interfaces, significantly enhancing photocatalytic efficiency. Motivated by this, we investigated the in situ assembly of ZIF-67 with NH2-MIL-125(Ti), resulting in a binary ZIF-67/NH2-MIL-125(Ti) all-solid-state Z-scheme heterostructure. Comprehensive characterisation through PXRD, BET, FTIR, UV-Vis spectroscopy, contact angle analysis and electrochemical studies confirmed enhanced structural and optoelectronic properties. Elemental profiling was carried out by ICP-OES, CHNO evaluation, and EDX spectroscopy. The hybrid catalyst exhibited an impressive H2O2 formation efficiency of 1345 µmol g−1 h−1, accompanied by a quantum yield of 3.64% under 400 nm irradiation, and also delivered a H2 evolution output of 215 µmol h−1, each showing a fourfold improvement compared to the individual pristine MOFs. The synergistic interaction between the well-designed MOF-on-MOF heterostructure and the Z-scheme charge transfer mechanism effectively minimised charge recombination, as evidenced by XPS, PL spectra, TRPL, and EIS analyses. Furthermore, free radical trapping experiments and ESR studies confirmed the critical role of ˙O2− radicals in the photocatalytic formation of H2O2. This study provides valuable insights for developing advanced MOF-based heterojunction photocatalysts tailored for efficient solar-to-chemical energy conversion.
Sustainability spotlightWater and energy sustainability are critical pillars of global ecological balance. This study focuses on the development of hierarchically structured MOF-on-MOF photocatalysts for the efficient generation of green fuels, specifically hydrogen (H2) and hydrogen peroxide (H2O2), through solar-driven processes. By addressing the limitations of individual metal–organic frameworks (MOFs) and leveraging their synergistic integration, this work offers a sustainable pathway for clean energy production and environmental remediation. The research aligns with the following UN Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs): SDG 7 (Affordable and Clean Energy); SDG 6 (Clean Water and Sanitation); SDG 9 (Industry, Innovation, and Infrastructure); and SDG 13 (Climate Action). This work underscores the potential of MOF-based photocatalysts to address pressing energy and environmental challenges while advancing global sustainability objectives. |
Following the groundbreaking discovery by Fujishima and Honda, who demonstrated the photolytic splitting of water over a TiO2 semiconductor under photoirradiation, the concept of photocatalytic water splitting has garnered considerable interest as a potential solution to the global energy challenge.8 This pioneering work laid the foundation for the development of sustainable hydrogen (H2) production technologies.9 As the world grapples with the urgent need to transition away from depleting fossil fuels, hydrogen has emerged as a clean and renewable energy carrier with immense promise.10 Among the various renewable energy strategies, photocatalytic hydrogen evolution from water stands out due to its cost-effectiveness, environmental benignity, and relatively straightforward operational setup.11 A broad spectrum of inorganic semiconductors, such as TiO2,12 quantum dots,13 perovskites,14 MoS2,15 layered double hydroxides (LDHs),16 and graphitic carbon nitride-based photocatalysts,17 have been extensively studied for their ability to drive H2 and H2O2 production under solar irradiation. Despite these advances, the practical implementation of these materials remains hampered by intrinsic limitations, including wide band gaps that confine light absorption to the ultraviolet region and suboptimal reaction efficiency resulting from the scarcity of catalytically accessible and inefficient charge separation.18
The domain of photocatalytic H2O2 and H2 production has progressively shifted focus toward inorganic–organic hybrid architectures, attributable to the synergistic integration of the distinct properties of the individual constituents into a unified hybrid system. Metal–organic frameworks (MOFs), ordered materials comprising metal centres coordinated with organic linkers, have emerged as highly promising candidates.19–21 Their structural tunability, adaptable framework design, and remarkably large surface area render them well-suited for photocatalytic applications driven by visible-light illumination, greatly improving both performance and product specificity.22–24 Notably, MOFs with semiconducting properties have exhibited significant promise in diverse photocatalytic applications, including H2 evolution from water, N2 reduction, and H2O2 production, thereby presenting a promising avenue for improving overall photocatalytic efficiency.25,26
Titanium-based MOFs offer photocatalytic performance on par with TiO2, with the added advantage of structural tunability that allows extension of light absorption from the UV into the visible region.27 One of the first titanium-based MOFs developed was MIL-125, which consists of titanium-oxo clusters coordinated with terephthalic acid (BDC) as the organic linker.28 Replacing BDC with 2-aminoterephthalic acid (NH2-BDC) results in NH2-MIL-125(Ti), a structurally similar framework where the introduction of amino groups serves as chromophores. This substitution lowers the band gap, enabling enhanced absorption in the visible spectrum compared to the UV-limited absorption of MIL-125.29 Despite this improvement, NH2-MIL-125(Ti) still exhibits restricted visible-light absorption and relatively low catalytic efficiency. This is primarily because the amino functionalisation predominantly raises the energy level of the valence band, which is situated on the organic moiety, whereas the conduction band, governed by the Ti-oxo nodes, stays mostly unchanged.30 To overcome this limitation and enhance the visible-light activity and photocatalytic efficiency of NH2-MIL-125(Ti) for applications like H2O2 and H2 production, researchers have proposed the incorporation of a secondary component. This approach aims to tune the Ti-oxo nodes and shift the conduction band edge to more favourable levels.31,32
Among various heterostructure engineering strategies, the MOF-on-MOF approach, where one MOF is grown atop another possessing good structural integrity and photocatalytic capability, has shown significant promise, particularly for applications in aqueous environments.33 The intimate interfacial contact achieved in such architectures facilitates more efficient charge separation and carrier transport, thereby markedly enhancing photocatalytic performance. The integration of two or more MOFs has attracted considerable research interest, as MOF-on-MOF structures can preserve desirable features such as high surface area, porosity, and crystallinity, all of which contribute to superior catalytic activity.34,35 For example, Jiang et al. in situ synthesised a MOF-74/MOF-274 hybrid directly on NiFe alloy foam (NFF), resulting in a MOF-(74 + 274)@NFF composite. This structure demonstrated outstanding oxygen evolution reaction (OER) activity, attributed to phase conjugation-induced electronic modulation and the cooperative effect of Ni–Fe multimetallic centres.36 A recent study by Sepehrmansourie et al. introduced an advanced heterostructure where UiO-66 was grown on NH2-MIL-125 and further modified with g-C3N4 nanosheets, creating a UiO-66/NH2-MIL-125/g-C3N4 Z-scheme system. This design significantly enhanced the visible-light photocatalytic degradation of ofloxacin.37 In a 2025 study, researchers developed an innovative dual S-scheme heterojunction by integrating BiVO4 with NH2-MIL-125(Ti) and NH2-MIL-53(Fe), forming a MOF@MOF hybrid. This system demonstrated outstanding photoelectrochemical (PEC) performance in the removal and detoxification of diverse organic pollutants.38 Despite growing interest in MOF-based photocatalysis, studies focusing on NH2-MIL-125(Ti)/MOF heterojunctions for photocatalytic H2O2 and H2 generation remain limited in the literature.
The selection of a secondary MOF to construct a heterojunction with NH2-MIL-125(Ti) should be guided by its optoelectronic characteristics, particularly its light absorption capability. Since NH2-MIL-125(Ti) primarily absorbs in the early visible region, it is advantageous to pair it with an MOF that exhibits extended visible-light absorption. ZIF-67, a robust Co-based MOF known for its strong absorption in the visible spectrum, emerges as a suitable candidate. Accordingly, binary hybrid composites of NH2-MIL-125(Ti) with ZIF-67 were successfully prepared via a simple in situ growth method at room temperature. These demonstrated markedly improved photocatalytic efficiency for visible-light-driven production of H2O2 and H2, surpassing that of the individual parent MOFs. The observed improvement in photocatalytic efficiency is credited to superior light-harvesting ability, more enhanced separation of photogenerated charge carriers, and accelerated charge migration, as confirmed by UV-vis DRS, PL spectra, LSV study, TPC response, and EIS plots.
Additionally, the investigation explores the underlying reaction mechanism of O2 photoreduction to H2O2 through tracer experiments. The results underscore the cooperative interaction involving NH2-MIL-125(Ti) and ZIF-67 within the binary hybrid, which induces substantial modifications in their electronic and optical properties, ultimately boosting photocatalytic activity. Scheme 1 provides a schematic representation of the preparation pathway covering individual MOFs as well as their resulting composite, with detailed procedures outlined in the subsequent section.
![]() | ||
| Scheme 1 Schematic illustration of the synthesis route for NH2-MIL-125(Ti)/ZIF-67 (MNZ) binary hybrid. | ||
:
1 mixture of DMF and methanol. The prepared reaction mixture was introduced into a 100 mL Teflon-lined stainless-steel autoclave, followed by thermal treatment at 180 °C for 24 h. Upon cooling, the yellow solid was separated via centrifugation and thoroughly washed multiple times using a methanol–DMF blend. The product was then vacuum-dried overnight at 80 °C, resulting in the formation of a bright yellow, amino-functionalized MIL-125(Ti) powder (MNH).
![]() | ||
| Fig. 1 (a) PXRD patterns of the synthesized photocatalysts. XPS spectra of MNZ: (b) survey scan, (c) Ti 2p, (d) Co 2p, (e) O 1s. (f) N2 adsorption–desorption isotherms of the samples. | ||
The FT-IR spectra displayed in Fig. S1 provide clear evidence of the successful synthesis and integration of MNH and ZIF-67 within the composite structure. For MNH, characteristic absorption bands are observed at 1600, 1500, 1440, and 1400 cm−1, corresponding to the asymmetric and symmetric stretching vibrations of carbonyl groups. Moreover, the broad and intense absorption band observed around ∼3405 cm−1 can be ascribed to the stretching vibrations of primary amine (–NH2) groups in the organic linker, as well as to O–H stretching vibrations arising from adsorbed water molecules.45,46 Meanwhile, the band appearing at 1625 cm−1 is associated with the N–H bending vibrations characteristic of aromatic amine groups.47 A distinct absorption at 1250 cm−1 arises from benzene ring C–H bonds, while lower frequency modes (400–800 cm−1) represent titanium-oxygen framework vibrations.48,49 ZIF-67 is identified by its distinct peaks at 422, 1350, and 1500 cm−1, associated with Co–N stretching and imidazole ring vibrations. Additional bands in the 900–1350 cm−1 and 500–800 cm−1 ranges correspond to in-plane and out-of-plane imidazole ring vibrations, respectively. A prominent peak at 1598 cm−1 is attributed to C
N stretching.50 Consequently, the N–H stretching band in the MNZ appears to be slightly less intense and somewhat broader compared to MNH, probably because of minor changes in the hydrogen-bonding interactions or molecular environment of the amine groups upon composite formation. Except for this variation, the other characteristic bands of MNH and ZIF-67 have remained essentially unchanged, indicating that the structural frameworks of both the parent MOFs are well retained within the composite.
XPS analysis was conducted to investigate the elemental composition and chemical states of the photocatalysts. As shown in Fig. 1(b), the survey spectrum of the MNZ composite confirms the existence of Ti, Co, C, N, and O, aligning well with the results obtained from elemental mapping. In the case of MNH, the Ti 2p spectrum is deconvoluted into two distinct peaks at 462.10 eV (Ti 2p1/2) and 456.36 eV (Ti 2p3/2), indicative of Ti4+ species within the Ti-oxo clusters of the framework (Fig. S2(a)). In the MNZ hybrid material, the Ti 2p signals exhibit a slight positive shift, suggesting a net migration of electrons from MNH toward ZIF-67 upon heterostructure construction (Fig. 1(c)). The O 1s spectrum of MNH shows two primary peaks at approximately 527.7 eV and 529.3 eV, corresponding to lattice oxygen species (OLt, including O2− in metal-oxo bonds) and surface-adsorbed oxygen (OAds), which may include O−, O2−, or O22− typically associated with surface hydroxyls (Fig. S2(c)). These spectral features are also present in the MNZ composite, with a slight positive shift, as illustrated in Fig. 1(e), further supporting the formation of strong interfacial interactions within the hybrid. The Co 2p XPS spectrum of the MNZ composite (Fig. 1(d)) displays two prominent peaks at 778.08 eV (Co 2p3/2) and 793.49 eV (Co 2p1/2), with a spin-orbit separation of approximately 15 eV. Additionally, broad satellite peaks at 783.19 eV and 799.39 eV, corresponding to Co 2p3/2 and Co 2p1/2, respectively, provide additional evidence for the effective integration of ZIF-67 into the composite. Compared to pristine ZIF-67 (Fig. S2(b)), these peaks exhibit a negative binding energy shift, suggesting charge transfer from the MNH framework to ZIF-67's surface. This shift strongly suggests that MNH functions as an electron donor upon hybridisation with ZIF-67. While determining the exact oxidation states of cobalt centres is often challenging, the binding energy gap spanning the main and satellite peaks provides critical insight: a gap of ∼6.0 eV is indicative of Co(II), whereas Co(III) typically shows a larger separation of 9–10 eV.51 Based on this criterion, the presence of Co(II) as the dominant oxidation state in the composite is evident. Altogether, these findings confirm effective interfacial charge transfer and support the operation of a bioinspired Z-scheme charge transfer mechanism within the hybrid system.
The porosity and textural characteristics of MNH, ZIF-67, and the MNZ composite were evaluated through nitrogen adsorption–desorption isotherm analysis. The linear BET plots for the photocatalysts, used to determine their corresponding surface areas, are shown in Fig. S3(a–c). Further details of the BET analysis are provided in the SI. Table S1 summarises the values corresponding to surface area, pore volume, and average pore size for the synthesised materials. As shown by the nitrogen adsorption–desorption analysis in Fig. 1(f), the parent MNH MOF followed a type IV isotherm accompanied by an H3 hysteresis loop, suggesting the presence of mesopores and the occurrence of capillary condensation at elevated relative pressures (P/P0). Notably, MNH demonstrated a remarkably high specific surface area (SBET) of 981.34 m2 g−1, a feature that significantly enhances the accessibility of catalytic sites and thereby contributes to improved photocatalytic activity. The pristine ZIF-67 displayed a type II isotherm, which is typically associated with materials that are either non-porous or possess macroporous structures undergoing typical physical adsorption, with a notably high specific surface area (SBET) of 1265.30 m2 g−1. This substantial surface area is attributed to its 3D macroporous channel structure. The close consistency between measured and calculated SBET (Table S1) further confirms the reliability of the surface area estimation for all three materials. Fig. S3(d) displays the pore distribution of the as-analysed photocatalysts. Upon forming the MNZ composite, the SBET decreased to 759.78 m2 g−1, and the isotherm exhibited features similar to the type IV isotherm and H3 hysteresis loop observed in MNH. This represents a 23% reduction in surface area and a 20% decrease in total pore volume. Such a reduction is considered moderate and is likely due to partial pore blockage by ZIF-67 within the composite framework, which restricts the internal porosity while simultaneously promoting structural rearrangements that facilitate the formation of mesopores. FESEM and HRTEM analyses further support this finding, revealing changes in the porosity and the development of mesostructured features (Fig. 2(a)–(c)). The presence of such mesopores is beneficial as they enhance the uptake of H2O and O2 species, thereby facilitating improved mass transport throughout the photocatalytic process.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 2 (a) FESEM image of MNZ. (b) HRTEM image of MNZ. (c) Lattice fringe pattern of MNZ. (d) Particle size distribution of MNZ derived from HRTEM analysis. | ||
Morphological and macrostructural features of the fabricated materials were investigated through scanning electron microscopy (SEM). As shown in Fig. S4(a), pure NH2-MIL-125 exhibited a tablet-like morphology, with the surface appearing very smooth, aligning with previous reports.39,52 The large surface area and functional framework of MNH offered a suitable platform for anchoring the dodecahedral ZIF-67. Following the growth of ZIF-67 onto the tablet-like MNH surface, the size, structure, and morphology of both MOFs were retained, confirming the structural stability of the MOF under various solvents and reductive environments (Fig. 2(a)). Elemental composition assessment via EDX for the MNZ nanocomposite confirms the presence of Ti along with Co, indicating the effective integration of ZIF-67 into MNH (Fig. S5). The obtained atomic weight% were 75.2% for C, 11.8% for O, 10.7% for N, 1.6% for Ti, and 0.7% for Co, as shown in Fig. S4(b) and (c). Moreover, no unexpected elements were detected, confirming the high purity of the synthesised nanocomposite. This further validates the formation of composite heterostructures, a feature that is anticipated to improve the effectiveness of photogenerated charge carrier separation and mobility. High-resolution transmission electron microscopy (HR-TEM) was utilised to further investigate the distribution of materials and the formation of heterojunctions between them. Detailed analysis was performed on the morphology and structural attributes of the synthesised samples. HR-TEM image of ZIF-67 displayed a uniform dodecahedral structure, which matches the existing literature (Fig. S6(a)).53,54Fig. 2(b) confirmed the growth of ZIF-67 microcrystals on the MNH surface, with deposition occurring both on the surface and along the edges. The results clearly demonstrate that dodecahedral ZIF-67 was firmly anchored to the cubic MNH, forming well-integrated NH2-MIL-125(Ti)@ZIF-67 MOF-on-MOF binary hybrids. This close interfacial coupling is expected to promote efficient migration of photoinduced charge carriers during photocatalytic reactions. Fig. 2(c) presents the lattice fringes of MNH and ZIF-67, revealing distinct d-spacing values for each component. The MNH sample exhibited a d-spacing of 0.219 nm, corresponding to its characteristic lattice structure.55 For ZIF-67, the measured d-spacing of 0.251 nm was assigned to the (111) lattice planes.56 Particle size distribution analysis (Fig. 2(d)) indicated an average particle size of 150 nm. Although the SBET of the MNZ composite showed a moderate decrease compared to the parent MOFs, this smaller particle size relative to the neat MOFs (Fig. S6(b) and (c)) enhances the material's external surface-to-volume ratio. This increase in exposed surface area, despite a slight reduction in total pore area, improves the accessibility of catalytically active sites and supports more efficient charge transport within the material. These findings align with the BET results, suggesting that while some internal pores may become partially blocked during composite formation, the overall external reactive surface remains more accessible for photocatalytic reactions.
Contact angle measurements demonstrated that the binary MNZ composite exhibited a higher angle (105.3°) compared to neat MNH (88.4°), indicating enhanced surface hydrophobicity (Fig. S8(a) and (b)). This increased hydrophobicity promotes selective adsorption of non-polar O2 molecules necessary for the reduction reaction while minimising excessive water adsorption that could lead to undesirable side reactions. Furthermore, the hydrophobic surface facilitates easier desorption of produced H2O2, thereby reducing its decomposition on the catalyst surface and improving product stability. The synergistic combination of ZIF-67-derived hydrophobicity with the redox-active NH2-MIL-125(Ti) framework in MNZ substantially contributes to its superior H2O2 production efficiency relative to the individual MOF components.
Hydrogen peroxide (H2O2) is inherently unstable at room temperature, as it tends to decompose on the catalyst surface through interactions with photogenerated electrons and holes. Therefore, the overall amount of H2O2 produced is determined by the competing kinetics of its formation and decomposition. The final concentration is influenced by the interplay between the formation rate constant (Kf) and the decomposition rate constant (Kd), as described by eqn (1).57
![]() | (1) |
The H2O2 stability profile is illustrated in Fig. 3(c), beginning with an initial H2O2 concentration of 1000 µmol L−1 in the different catalytic systems under a N2 atmosphere. Both the parent MOFs exhibited a deformation rate greater than the formation rate for H2O2. However, for the binary MOF composite, MNZ, the formation rate was significantly higher than the deformation rate. Out of all the evaluated materials, the MNZ binary heterostructure demonstrated the highest efficiency in decomposing H2O2. This enhanced activity is ascribed to its improved spatial separation and directional migration of photoinduced charge carriers, allowing a greater number of charge carriers to effectively engage in the decomposition process. Accordingly, the kinetics of H2O2 formation and degradation were evaluated using a zero-order rate constant (Kf) to represent the formation process and a first-order rate constant (Kd) to describe the decomposition behaviour, as described by the kinetic model presented in eqn (2).57
![]() | (2) |
As shown in Fig. 3(c), both parent MOFs exhibited relatively low Kf and Kd values, signifying restricted photocatalytic performance. In contrast, the MNZ composite exhibited a Kf value of 11.2 µmol g−1 min−1, nearly fourfold and twofold greater than ZIF-67 and pristine MNH, respectively. Similarly, the Kd value for MNZ exceeded those of the individual MOFs, implying that simultaneous generation and breakdown of H2O2 were more pronounced in the presence of the composite catalyst. Nevertheless, the enhanced decomposition had a minimal effect on the overall H2O2 yield under light irradiation when using the binary photocatalyst. This confirms that the modification of ZIF-67 effectively enhances charge separation, allowing the rate of H2O2 formation to surpass its decomposition.
Additionally, various alcohols were introduced as electron donors into the reaction system, and their influence on the photocatalytic H2O2 production by MNZ was evaluated, as depicted in Fig. 3(d). The findings indicated that isopropanol was more effective in promoting H2O2 generation compared to ethanol and methanol. This is primarily attributed to the fact that an equal volume of isopropanol can release a higher amount of H+ ions, which actively participate in the H2O2 formation process with MNZ. Consequently, the influence of varying concentrations of isopropanol on the photocatalytic performance of MNZ was further investigated and presented in Fig. S9(a). The results indicated that the H2O2 yield by MNZ increased with the rising amount of isopropanol. The highest H2O2 concentration was achieved at 2 mL of isopropanol, which can be considered the equilibrium point rate of the reaction and mass transport. Beyond this volume, an extra addition of isopropanol increased the viscosity of the reaction system, notably hindering oxygen diffusion and slowing down the reaction rate, ultimately causing a decrease in H2O2 concentration.
To assess the apparent quantum efficiency (AQE) for H2O2 generation, the performance of the MNZ photocatalyst was examined under different monochromatic light wavelengths employing appropriate band-pass filters (λband-pass = 340, 400, 450, 500, and 550 nm), as shown in Fig. 3(e). Detailed AQE calculation procedures can be found in the SI. The highest AQE value of 3.64% was achieved at 400 nm, and progressively declines at longer wavelengths as reported in Table S2, which corresponds well with the light absorption spectrum.
To gain a deeper understanding of the photocatalytic H2O2 generation mechanism, a sequence of controlled experiments was designed and executed, as illustrated in Fig. S9(b). No significant H2O2 formation was observed in the absence of light, photocatalyst, or sacrificial agent, confirming their essential roles in the reaction. The significance of O2 was further investigated by altering the reaction atmosphere. Fig. S9(b) shows H2O2 production under different conditions, including air, N2, and O2. Among these, the MNZ nanohybrid demonstrated the highest photocatalytic activity in an O2-saturated environment, while negligible H2O2 generation was detected under air and N2 atmospheres. These findings indicate that the photocatalytic process is highly dependent on the presence of dissolved O2, which is crucial for H2O2 formation.
The influence of several individual parameters, including the initial pH of the reaction medium, the amount of MNZ composite photocatalyst, the type of electron donor, and the donor concentration, was systematically examined to evaluate their effects on the photocatalytic H2O2 production performance. As depicted in Fig. 4(a), the impact of initial pH ranging from 3 to 11 on H2O2 generation by MNZ was investigated. The highest H2O2 yield was obtained at neutral pH (pH = 7), while the production efficiency declined when the medium was either acidic or basic. This trend underscores how crucial interfacial charge dynamics, particularly electron and proton interactions, are in governing the photocatalyst's activity, which is sensitive to the pH of the reaction environment. Under acidic conditions, an excess of H+ ions can interact with H2O2, resulting in its partial degradation. In contrast, under basic conditions, the presence of OH− ions not only consumes H+, thereby lowering the efficiency of H2O2 generation, but also accelerates the further decomposition of the formed H2O2. Moreover, extreme pH values such as 3 and 11 caused a significant drop in H2O2 generation. This reduction is primarily attributed to the structural instability of MNH in these conditions, wherein the terephthalate linkers undergo protonation, resulting in their dissociation from the Ti8O8(OH)4 clusters, ultimately compromising the integrity of the MNH framework.
The quantity of photocatalyst plays a critical role in determining the efficiency of H2O2 production. As observed in Fig. S9(c), an upward trend in H2O2 production is seen with higher catalyst dosage, peaking at an optimal loading of 10 mg. This improvement is linked to the increased number of active sites available for oxygen adsorption, thereby enhancing the oxygen reduction reaction. However, further increase in the catalyst amount led to a decline in photocatalytic activity, primarily due to reduced light penetration and scattering effects, which limit effective light absorption and diminish overall efficiency. Moreover, the MNZ hybrid achieved a solar-to-chemical conversion efficiency (SCC%) of 0.025%, nearly twice that of MNH. The detailed calculation and the values are summarised in Table S3 as provided in the SI.
Reusability and stability are crucial parameters for evaluating the practical applicability of photocatalysts. In this study, the cyclic stability of MNZ was assessed through repeated photocatalytic experiments. Fig. 4(b) illustrates that the H2O2 production efficiency of MNZ declined by only 9% after four consecutive cycles, indicating excellent stability. Additionally, the FESEM, HRTEM, and PXRD analyses of MNZ after four cycles (Fig. S10) revealed no significant structural or morphological changes compared to the fresh sample, further confirming the durability and robustness of the photocatalyst for long-term application.
Beyond H2O2 generation, the catalyst's ability to drive photocatalytic hydrogen (H2) evolution was assessed in the presence of a methanolic aqueous medium serving as a sacrificial hole scavenger under simulated visible-light irradiation (λ ≥ 400 nm). Control tests demonstrated that hydrogen evolution did not take place when either the light source or the catalyst was excluded, confirming that both components are essential for efficient H2 generation. For comparison, the photocatalytic H2 evolution performances of MNH, ZIF-67, and the MNZ composite were investigated, as presented in Fig. 4(c). The hydrogen production of the pure photocatalysts exhibited a linear increase over time, indicating continuous H2 generation under irradiation Fig. 4(d). Upon incorporation of ZIF-67, the hydrogen evolution rate of the composite significantly surpassed that of pristine MNH, demonstrating the enhanced photocatalytic output of the hybrid system. As displayed in Fig. 4(c), the MNZ composite exhibits an average photocatalytic evolution activity of 215 µmol h−1 under visible-light irradiation, approximately two and three times higher than that of ZIF-67 and MNH, respectively. This enhancement suggests that the incorporation of ZIF-67 into the composite framework effectively increases the number of surface-active sites, enhances the utilisation of photogenerated electrons, and suppresses electron–hole recombination, primarily because of the formation of numerous MNH/ZIF-67 interfacial junctions that generate new Co–N and Ti–O coordination centres, facilitating efficient charge transfer. Consequently, despite the slight reduction in SBET, the interfacial synergy increases both the density and accessibility of catalytically active sites, leading to enhanced H2 evolution performance. The calibration curve used for H2 quantification is shown in Fig. S11. The apparent conversion efficiency (ACE) achieved for hydrogen evolution was measured to be 3.45%, nearly three times higher than that of pristine MNH. Detailed calculations and a table summary (Table S4) are provided in the SI. Beyond high H2 evolution activity, reusability is also a vital criterion for an efficient photocatalyst. To assess this, the time-dependent hydrogen evolution performance of MNZ under visible light was tested over four cycles. As shown in Fig. 4(e), the H2 production efficiency remained nearly unchanged, indicating the excellent stability and reusability of the MNZ photocatalyst.
The optical band gap (Eg) is a crucial parameter for evaluating the potential of a material as an efficient photocatalyst. In this study, the Eg values were determined through Tauc plot extrapolation, by plotting (αhν)1/γversus photon energy (hν), following our previous study.25,31 As demonstrated in Fig. S12(a) and (b), the calculated band gaps were 2.53 eV for MNH and 1.95 eV for ZIF-67. For the binary MOF-on-MOF composite, two distinct band gap values were observed, with Eg values of 2.51 eV and 1.85 eV for the first and second transitions, respectively (Fig. 5(b)). These values are notably lower than the reported band gaps of pure ZIF-67 (1.98 eV) and MIL-125-NH2 (2.65 eV), indicating enhanced visible light absorption. Analysis of the VB and CB potentials of MNH and ZIF-67 provides crucial insights into the photocatalytic H2O2 and H2 production mechanism. Examination of the valence band XPS spectra (Fig. S12(c) and (d)) yielded VB potentials of 2.42 eV for MNH and 1.18 eV for ZIF-67. After getting the corresponding VB position, the CB values are calculated using eqn (3).
| Eg = VB − CB | (3) |
The as-obtained CB potentials were observed as −0.11 eV for MNH and −0.77 eV for ZIF-67. These energetically favourable band alignments between MNH and ZIF-67 enable the establishment of an efficient Z-scheme charge transfer pathway in the MNZ composite, which is critical for enhanced charge separation and photocatalytic performance. The flat band potentials determined through Mott–Schottky analysis (Fig. S12(e) and (f)) were −0.50 V for MNH and −1.26 V for ZIF-67 (vs. Ag/AgCl at pH = 7), with the positive slopes confirming their n-type semiconductor nature.
To further explore the separation behaviour of photogenerated charge carriers, steady-state photoluminescence (PL) spectra were recorded. PL analysis serves as a useful tool to assess the recombination efficiency of photoinduced excitons. As shown in Fig. 5(c), the pristine MNH displayed a strong emission peak centred at ∼468 nm when excited at 420 nm, indicating substantial electron–hole recombination. Under identical excitation, ZIF-67 also showed a distinct emission peak at ∼469 nm. Notably, the PL intensity for the MNZ composite was significantly quenched compared to both individual components. This considerable reduction in emission suggests that ZIF-67 incorporation into MNH effectively suppresses charge recombination by serving as a reservoir or mediator for charge carriers. The suppressed PL signal in MNZ confirms the presence of a well-established interfacial charge transfer pathway between MNH and ZIF-67, resulting in improved charge separation and accelerated surface reaction kinetics during photocatalysis. The transient photocurrent response under an on–off simulated light illumination was investigated to assess the charge separation behaviour of the photocatalysts. As presented in Fig. 5(d), MNH displayed the lowest photocurrent intensity, implying poor separation and mobility of photoinduced charge carriers. ZIF-67 also displayed a weak photocurrent, likely due to the insulating nature of its organic ligands, which tend to confine photogenerated electrons near the metal centres and hinder their transport. However, when ZIF-67 was integrated with MNH, the resulting MNZ composite showed a significantly enhanced photocurrent response. This improvement is attributed to the establishment of a heterojunction between MNH and ZIF-67, which effectively promotes efficient charge carrier separation and transfer, thereby enhancing photocatalytic efficiency. To further assess the electrical resistance and charge transfer dynamics, electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) was executed, as depicted in the corresponding Fig. 5(e). The characteristic arc observed in impedance spectra represents the interfacial resistance occurring at the material-electrolyte interface. A smaller semicircle indicates reduced resistance, implying improved charge separation efficiency. All samples exhibited clear semicircular profiles; however, the MNZ composite demonstrated the smallest arc radius among them. This suggests that MNZ possesses superior charge transport and migration abilities, facilitating more efficient surface reactions. Such enhanced conductivity contributes to better light harvesting and minimises the recombination of photogenerated carriers.
Furthermore, linear sweep voltammetry (LSV) measurements were employed to assess the photocurrent responses of the synthesized photocatalysts. As shown in Fig. 5(f), the cathodic photocurrent profiles of MNH, ZIF-67, and MNZ under visible-light illumination were compared. In alignment with earlier observations, ZIF-67 functions as an effective electron mediator, facilitating charge transport. As a result, the MNZ heterostructure displays a significantly elevated cathodic photocurrent. Notably, MNZ achieves a current density of −7861 mA cm−2, which is approximately two and three times greater than that of the pristine ZIF-67 and MNH, respectively. This substantial enhancement in photocurrent suggests improved generation and transport of photoexcited electrons, attributed to effective charge carrier separation within the heterojunction. To further investigate the charge carrier dynamics, time-resolved photoluminescence (TRPL) measurements were conducted, as shown in Fig. S13(a). The pristine MNH exhibited an average emission lifetime of approximately ∼13 ns. In contrast, the binary MNZ composite showed a reduced average lifetime of 8.80 ns, while ZIF-67 alone displayed a lifetime of 9.11 ns. The noticeable quenching of PL intensity and shortened lifetime in MNZ indicate more rapid interfacial electron flow from MNH to ZIF-67 compared to the pristine MOF. These findings align well with previous TPC and EIS results, confirming effective separation of photoinduced exciton pairs and enhanced surface electron mobility in the MNZ system. Collectively, the strong interfacial coupling between MNH and ZIF-67 effectively suppresses charge recombination, accelerates electron transport, and reduces interfacial resistance, thereby improving overall photocatalytic performance.
To identify the primary reactive species involved in the photocatalytic generation of H2O2 using the MNZ photocatalyst under light exposure, radical scavenging experiments were performed, with the outcomes shown in Fig. S13(b). Several specific scavengers were employed to probe the role of different active species: 1,4-benzoquinone (PBQ) for superoxide radicals (˙O2−), tert-butyl alcohol (TBA) for hydroxyl radicals (˙OH), citric acid (CA) for photogenerated holes (h+), and dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO) for electrons (e−). A marked decrease in H2O2 yield was observed upon the addition of PBQ and DMSO, suggesting that O2− and e− play dominant roles in the photocatalytic process, likely through both direct and indirect O2 reduction mechanisms. In contrast, the addition of TBA exerted negligible influence on H2O2 formation, implying ˙OH species play only a minor role in this system. Conversely, the introduction of citric acid (CA) as a hole scavenger resulted in a significant enhancement in H2O2 generation. This improvement is ascribed to CA's ability to effectively scavenge photogenerated holes (h+), thereby allowing a greater number of electrons to participate in the reduction of O2. These observations indicate minimal involvement of h+ and ˙OH radicals in the H2O2 generation pathway. Importantly, the substantial suppression of H2O2 formation following the addition of either p-BQ or DMSO confirms that molecular oxygen reduction serves as the dominant route for H2O2 production. This supports a mechanism wherein H2O2 is formed primarily through a single-electron, two-step reduction process mediated by superoxide radicals (˙O2−). Furthermore, when electrons were selectively scavenged, the MNZ system exhibited a 67% decline in H2O2 yield, underscoring the critical role of photogenerated electrons in driving the reaction. Furthermore, when PBQ was employed to scavenge superoxide radicals (˙O2−), a notable reduction of 74% in H2O2 production was observed. This result indicates that the MNZ photocatalyst predominantly facilitates H2O2 generation through the reaction of photogenerated electrons with adsorbed O2 molecules. It further confirms that the two-step, single-electron reduction mechanism is the dominant pathway for H2O2 production in the MNZ system. However, in addition to this primary mechanism, a minor contribution from the one-step, two-electron reduction of O2, as well as limited oxidation of water by photogenerated holes, cannot be excluded. The involvement of reactive oxygen species was further corroborated by liquid-phase electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) analysis using DMPO as a spin-trapping agent (Fig. S14). No signal corresponding to either ˙OH or ˙O2− radicals was detected under dark conditions, verifying that their formation is triggered by light exposure. Upon illumination with λ > 420 nm light, distinct signals corresponding to DMPO–O2˙− and DMPO–˙OH adducts were observed for MNZ, confirming the light-induced generation of superoxide and hydroxyl radicals. These results highlight the enhanced formation of reactive species over MNZ due to efficient charge carrier separation and align well with the findings from the radical quenching tests.
![]() | ||
| Scheme 2 Schematic representation of the proposed photocatalytic mechanisms for H2O2 and H2 production over MNZ under light irradiation. | ||
To confirm the proposed Z-scheme charge transfer mechanism between MNH and ZIF-67, we performed complementary radical trapping experiments using nitroblue tetrazolium (for ˙O2− detection) and terephthalic acid (for ˙OH quantification). The NBT assay was employed to detect the presence of superoxide radicals (˙O2−), where a notable decrease in NBT concentration was observed for the MNZ heterostructure compared to the individual MOFs, as shown in Fig. S15(a). This confirmed the enhanced generation of ˙O2− radicals in MNZ, indicating a more efficient electron transfer process. Additionally, the TA test was used to monitor hydroxyl radical (˙OH) formation, identified by a characteristic photoluminescence emission peak at 425 nm. As depicted in Fig. S15(b), MNZ exhibited a significantly stronger PL intensity than pristine MNH or ZIF-67, signifying its superior ability to generate ˙OH radicals during photocatalysis. Together, these findings strongly support the presence of a Z-scheme electron transfer mechanism in MNZ, wherein electrons are effectively shuttled to the ZIF-67 component of the binary heterostructure.
Supplementary information: chemicals used; physicochemical characterization techniques; photoelectrochemical characterization procedures; photocatalytic H2O2 and H2 production experiments; calculation of SCC%, AQE, and ACE%; XPS spectra of MNH; FTIR spectra; linear BET plots and pore size distribution curves of MNH, ZIF-67, and MNZ; FESEM image of MNH; EDX image of MNZ; HRTEM of ZIF-67 and histogram plots of MNH and ZIF-67; TRPL plots; Tauc plots of photocatalysts; XPS valence band spectra; Mott–Schottky plots; contact angle analysis; standard calibration curves of H2O2 and H2; effect of IPA dosage, atmospheric conditions, and photocatalyst amount on H2O2 generation; UV–vis absorption spectra and AQE of MNZ; PXRD, FESEM, and HRTEM of MNZ post-photocatalysis; effect of scavengers on H2O2 production; TA and NBT assay plots; ESR spectra for superoxide and hydroxyl radicals. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d5su00595g.
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2026 |