Open Access Article
Satyam Dixit
a,
Anil Kumar Jhawarb,
Birendra Adhikarib,
Marcus Trygstadb,
Craig Piaceka and
Paul A. Charpentier*a
aDepartment of Chemical and Biochemical Engineering, University of Western Ontario, 3333 Claudette MacKay-Lassonde Pavilion, London, Ontario N6A 5B9, Canada. E-mail: sdixit7@uwo.ca
bDepartment of Research & Development, Aduro Clean Technologies Inc., 542 Newbold Street, London, ON N6E 2S5, Canada
First published on 29th April 2026
Benzene, toluene and xylenes (BTX) serve as critical components in enhancing cold flow properties in high-performance fuels such as jet fuel, preventing fuel gelling and crystallization at low temperatures while maintaining combustion efficiency; however, their production remains largely reliant on conventional crude oil-derived processes. Alternate pathways such as catalytic pyrolysis, methanol-to-aromatics processes, etc. remain underexplored for sustainable synthesis of these aromatic hydrocarbons. This study presents a novel approach for producing aromatic hydrocarbons using MoOx/HZSM-5 catalyst in a continuous fixed-bed reactor. Feedstocks of interest such as oleic acid (OA), linoleic acid (LA), corn distiller's oil (CDO), and used cooking oil (UCO) were individually co-fed with water through the catalyst bed. A comprehensive design of experiments was employed to systematically elucidate the effect of critical reaction parameters such as temperature (350–375 °C), space time (1–4 h), and Mo(VI) loading on HZSM-5 (0–10 wt%). With no additional H2 requirement for the process, the maximized operating conditions generated a maximum yield of 85% aromatic hydrocarbons in the liquid product obtained. The major platform chemicals produced during the conversion were benzene, toluene, ethylbenzene, and xylenes (BTEX), which were characterized using GC-MS. Further evidence for the extent of deoxygenation of feedstocks and presence of aromatic compounds in the product was supported by IR and 1H-NMR analyses respectively. The catalysts synthesized were characterized using BET, XRD, IR, SEM, NH3 and XPS. This study positions MoOx/HZSM-5 as a promising catalyst enabling the efficient, H2-free production of BTX from renewable fatty acid feedstocks, advancing the development of sustainable routes to produce these platform chemicals.
Renewable feedstocks containing triglycerides and free fatty acids, commonly sourced from both edible and non-edible oils, have emerged as promising candidates for the sustainable production of bio-based aromatics. The source of these feedstocks includes used cooking oil (UCO) such as canola, corn, soybean, sunflower, and safflower oil etc. Corn Distiller's Oil (CDO) is a by-product of ethanol production,4 and is mainly comprised of triacylglycerols with (poly)unsaturated fatty acids; mainly oleic acid (OA) and linoleic acid (LA). These feedstocks contain oxygenated compounds, which can undergo deoxygenation, hydrotreating, and alkylation reactions to produce drop-in fuels, and can be blended with conventional jet fuel without any modifications.5 UCO has also been evaluated as a promising feedstock for the production of sustainable aviation fuels (SAFs).6,7 In this context, Singh et al.8 recently provided a dedicated review of deoxygenation pathways specifically for SAF production from UCO, documenting how catalyst choice and process parameters critically govern selectivity between decarboxylation, decarbonylation, and hydrodeoxygenation routes and their consequences for jet-range hydrocarbon yield. Moreover, a highly selective NiMo/Al2O3–SiO2 catalyst system demonstrated a UCO conversion of over 86% with 74.8% jet-range hydrocarbon selectivity in a fixed-bed reactor, confirming the growing interest in tuning supported metal catalysts for SAF applications from waste lipid feedstocks. However, this requires additional regulatory checks to ensure the standards of the biofuel produced are met.9 Aromatic hydrocarbons such as BTEX possess high octane number, which makes them suitable for blending with gasoline and jet fuel to improve anti-knocking properties as well as cold-flow properties.10 With the growing demand for reducing our dependency on conventional feedstocks, upgrading bio-based feedstocks for production of aromatics such as BTEX can be considered as an alternative to support the drive towards sustainability.
Catalytic pyrolysis has been explored as a potential thermocatalytic technology to produce BTEX from bio-based feedstocks. The conversion involves a two-stage sequence: (i) pyrolysis of the feedstock at elevated temperatures (>550 °C), and (ii) subsequent cyclization and aromatization of the pyrolyzed vapors in a fixed-bed reactor over a reforming catalyst, operated under relatively high H2 pressures (10–30 bar), to generate aromatics.11 Anellotech LLC has demonstrated this catalytic pyrolysis approach for production of drop-in aviation fuels.12 However, catalytic pyrolysis produces substantial amounts of unsaturated compounds such as alkenes as by-products, which are undesirable in the petrochemical complexes for isomerization and blending purposes in drop-in fuels.13 A recent study by Wang et al. on enhanced bio-BTX formation from glycerol co-fed with in situ produced toluene over H-ZSM-5/Al2O3 illustrated that even optimized catalytic pyrolysis approaches struggle to surpass peak BTX carbon yields of ∼30 C% and suffer from rapid catalyst deactivation, reinforcing the fundamental limitations of high-temperature pyrolysis routes for selective monoaromatic production.14 Similarly, Miller et al. demonstrated a sequential ketonization–aromatization pathway over HZSM-5 for converting wet-waste-derived volatile fatty acids to BTEX at 350–450 °C, yet highlighted that the co-production of substantial light alkane by-products at near-equal proportions remains an unresolved challenge for achieving high aromatics selectivity from oxygenated bio-feedstocks.15
Catalytic deoxygenation is generally preferred over catalytic pyrolysis, as it proceeds at lower operating temperatures and minimizes the generation of undesirable by-products such as alkenes. These advantages not only improve process efficiency but also enhance selectivity toward desired liquid aromatics, thereby offering a more practical and sustainable pathway for upgrading renewable fatty acid-derived feedstocks. Transition metal-based catalysts for deoxygenation of fatty acids and their derivatives have been investigated under H2 pressures of 20–30 bar. These include NiMo,16–18 CoMo17–21 and Pt/Pd,22–28 which rely mainly on external H2 pressures for facilitating deoxygenation chemistry.29 Murzin et al.28,30 were among the pioneers to investigate the catalytic activity of Pd supported on activated carbon and alumina (Al2O3). Metal loadings between 1–5% were studied in a batch system with temperatures in the range of 300–370 °C and pressure range of 2.5–10 MPa. The increased reaction rates of decarboxylation were found with activated carbon as compared to alumina, in part due to its higher surface area (920 m2 g−1). Higher metal loadings generated favourable decarboxylation chemistry, primarily because of the large number of active sites available for the reaction. However, regeneration of the Pt/C catalyst resulted in the structural changes of the activated carbon support after regeneration at 650 °C and therefore impacted its catalytic activity. Wu et al. investigated decarboxylation under inert atmosphere with Ni/C as the catalyst.31 It was reported that same extent of decarboxylation similar to hydrotreating condition was achieved at 430 °C.32 They also showed that though transition metal-based catalysts such as Ni(II) and Co(II) have greater catalytic activity towards decarboxylation, they tend to deactivate quickly in comparison to Pd and Pt. Furthermore, the liquid fraction was dominated by aliphatic hydrocarbons enriched in alkenes, with no evidence of aromatic hydrocarbons. The high hydrogen consumption associated with conventional hydrotreating routes has spurred growing interest in hydrogen-free deoxygenation strategies. In a recent 2025 study, Pacheco et al. investigated a H2-free fast cracking of oleic acid over acidic HZSM-5 and Y-zeolites under conditions analogous to the fluid catalytic cracking process, establishing that the balance between Brønsted and Lewis acid sites governs the selectivity between deoxygenation pathways and the distribution of aromatic versus aliphatic products.33 Notably, they reported that HZSM-5 yielded a higher aromatic fraction than HY under comparable conditions, attributing this to the former's unique pore architecture and stronger Brønsted acidity, consistent with the mechanistic importance of acid site density in directing cyclization chemistry. The acidity of the catalyst support also contributes to the product distribution, which was demonstrated by Hengst et al. in their research for producing drop-in jet fuel.34 Similar conclusions were derived from the recent works by Charpentier et al.,25,35–37 where comparison of catalytic activity of Ni(II) and Mo(IV) loaded on Al2O3 for production of green diesel was demonstrated. Savage et al.38 also performed extensive research on different metal supported systems for conversion of mono-unsaturated and polyunsaturated fatty acids into heptadecane, which can be used as a drop-in diesel product. The group utilized Pt on activated carbon in the presence of water (sub-critical and supercritical). Han et al.39 investigated the decarboxylation and saturation of micro-algae oil in the presence of Pd:Au catalyst system in a packed bed system, which resulted in better catalyst stability as compared to standalone Pd. However, elimination of oxygen from the feedstock without isomerization or improving the octane rating of the resulting product does not address the requirement for jet fuels, which typically contains 8–25% aromatics.40 High operation costs and limited ability towards cyclization and aromatization with metal-based catalysts draws attention towards exploring other alternatives.
Direct conversion of fatty acids and their derivatives into aromatics at comparatively low temperatures (300–380 °C) without external H2 pressure has been underexplored. A few studies have emphasized on valorizing these feedstocks while investigating different catalyst systems at elevated temperatures (>400 °C).41–44 In some of these findings, catalytic decarboxylation of vegetable oils was carried out at temperatures ranging from 400–470 °C, resulting in low aromatic yields. Recent efforts using hierarchical ZSM-5 architectures have attempted to address the dual challenge of improving accessibility to active sites while preserving shape-selective aromatization. Liu et al. synthesized hierarchical ZSM-5 nanosheets with interconnected mesopore networks for the catalytic cracking of oleic acid, demonstrating that a self-pillared nanosheet structure with a Brønsted-to-Lewis acid ratio optimized toward strongly acidic Brønsted sites achieved markedly higher yields of light olefins and aromatics relative to conventional microporous ZSM-5.45 Nonetheless, the aromatic yields remained modest in the absence of a metal co-function capable of activating the C
C bonds of polyunsaturated fatty acids at moderate temperatures, pointing to a clear gap that bifunctional metal–zeolite catalysts are better positioned to fill. In a particularly relevant and recent contribution, Charpentier et al. reported the tandem deoxygenation and aromatization of oleic acid under subcritical hydrothermal conditions over MoO3/HZSM-5 catalyst, demonstrating synergistic interplay between the molybdenum oxide phase and the Brønsted acid sites of HZSM-5, thus enabling direct conversion of a model fatty acid to BTEX without the need for external hydrogen in a single-pot batch system.46 A clear consensus therefore indicates that transition metal-based catalysts have been reported to facilitate both deoxygenation and cyclization of fatty acids and their derivatives.47–51
In this study, we explore a novel thermocatalytic process using MoOx/HZSM-5 catalyst to facilitate tandem deoxygenation–aromatization of (poly)unsaturated fatty acids and their derivatives to produce BTEX, without added H2 in a continuous tubular reactor. The continuous-flow configuration used here offers specific benefits for interpreting the tandem deoxygenation–aromatization chemistry. By operating under well-defined space times and collecting products at fixed time-on-stream intervals, we anticipate that transient changes in conversion, deoxygenation extent, and aromatic selectivity can be linked more directly to catalyst-state evolution than in batch experiments, where concentrations, temperature history, and water content co-evolve in a less controlled manner. From a process-design perspective, we expect that the continuous system demonstrated here could be more readily translated into modular or pilot-scale units for decentralized upgrading of lipid-derived feedstocks. This work investigates MoOx/HZSM-5 as a novel catalyst for the tandem deoxygenation and aromatization of bio-based feedstocks without external hydrogen pressure, addressing a gap in the current literature where this specific metal–zeolite combination has not been explored in continuous mode for these coupled reactions without H2. This research further evaluates and emphasizes on comprehending the correlation between the reaction parameters (temperature, space time, and Mo loading on HZSM-5) and the extent of tandem deoxygenation–aromatization in a fixed bed tubular reactor.
:
1 was purchased from Zeolyst International, USA. It was obtained in powder form, the particle size being in the range of 20–200 nm. Ammonium molybdate tetrahydrate (AMT) > 98% purity, CAS no. 12054-85-2, oleic acid (OA) > 99% purity, CAS no. 112-80-1 and linoleic acid (LA) > 99% purity, CAS no. 60-33-3 were obtained from Sigma-Aldrich, Canada. Corn Distiller's Oil (CDO) was obtained from Greenfield Global and used as is. Used cooking oil (UCO) was obtained from the author's home and filtered before use. Ultrapure water system (EASY pure LF, Mandel Scientific Co., USA) was used to prepare deionized water (18.2 MΩ) for catalyst impregnation steps.
:
1 (w/w). This specific ratio was selected based on established protocols from prior research conducted by the same group on the deoxygenation of fatty acids.25,52 These parameters were investigated in a continuous fixed-bed tubular reactor system at temperatures ranging from 350 to 375 °C to evaluate their correlation with the efficiency of the tandem reaction. A comprehensive design of experiments was employed where the space time was varied between 1 and 4 hours. The process schematic for the reaction system is provided in SI (Fig. S1). The feedstocks and water were introduced into the reaction system using a dual-syringe pump system (260 D Teledyne Isco LLC). The feed-water mixer and the tubular reactor were placed inside a heated oven maintained at about 200 °C. The reactor assembly consisted of a 5 mL tubular reactor (316 SS) and was equipped with a band heater to maintain desired reaction temperatures. The catalyst bed inside the tubular reactor was prepared such that the desired amount of catalyst was sandwiched between known weight of ball bearings and quartz wool at both ends. The desired space time was achieved by adjusting the flow rates of the feedstock and water through the catalyst bed using the following equation:
![]() | (1) |
:
1; carrier gas (helium) flow rate was 25 mL min−1; and the flow rate of H2 was 30 mL min−1 while that of ultrapure air was 400 mL min−1. The temperatures for injector and detector were set at 300 °C and 320 °C, respectively, and the following temperature program was applied after injection: 5 min hold at 50 °C; ramp at 5 °C min−1 to 150 °C; ramp at 10 °C min−1 to 300 °C; and a final hold at 300 °C for 2 min. Qualitative identification of compounds in the samples was based on comparison with retention times for aliphatic and aromatic hydrocarbons compounds in standards (Restek Inc). The GC instrument was calibrated using aromatic standard obtained from Restek (Certified Aromatics Mix, 5500 µg mL−1, P&T Methanol, 1 mL per ampul, catalog no. 30485) with known concentrations of individual components present. The calibration of the GC followed a series dilution methodology to establish a five-point calibration curve for each individual compound in the aromatic standard, which was in accordance with ASTM D5580 calculation procedure.53 The solvent used for preparing these standards was methanol, ensuring consistent dilution and accurate concentration measurements across the calibration range. Methanol was used as the solvent due to its compatibility with obtained standard for aromatic compounds and thus preventing interference and ensuring accurate standard preparation. Gaseous products formed during the reaction were collected in Tedlar gas bags and analyzed against a standard calibration mixture of gases (CO, CO2, N2, O2, H2, and gaseous hydrocarbons). The gas sample (1 mL) was filled into a gas tight syringe (Model 1001 LTN SYR, Cemented NDL, 22 ga, 2 in, point style 5) was injected with helium as the carrier gas. The gases were detected with a thermal conductivity detector (TCD). In GC-TCD analysis, the oven temperature was kept at 30 °C for 2 min followed by 15 °C min−1 ramp to 250 °C, held at 250 °C for 1 min. The temperature of both the injector and detector were maintained at 200 °C. 1H-NMR spectra of product hydrocarbon samples in deuterated chloroform (CDCl3) solvent were acquired with a Bruker 400 MHz spectrometer with referencing against the residual solvent signal (at δ 7.26 ppm) relative to tetramethylsilane at δ 0 ppm. All spectra were obtained under the same conditions (298 K, gas flow rate of 300 lph) and were processed with MestreNova software. Infrared spectra of the feed and the liquid products were acquired with a Nicolet 6700 Fourier Transform Infrared Spectrometer (Thermo Scientific) in the range of 600–4000 cm−1 with 64 scans at 8 cm−1 resolution. The extent of deoxygenation was calculated according to eqn (2) adapted from ASTM D3242,54 where peak area corresponding to absorbance band around 1710 cm−1 for carbonyl stretching mode characteristic of unconjugated carboxylic acids was calculated in feedstock and liquid product mixture.
![]() | (2) |
:
feed (w/w) = 4
:
1. The selection of water
:
feed ratio was based on previous studies conducted by our research group addressing the deoxygenation of various fatty acids and their derivatives for production of green diesel.37 Fig. 1 represents the IR spectra of the liquid hydrocarbon products obtained under the above-mentioned reaction conditions. The reduction in the band intensity at 1710 cm−1 corresponding to the carbonyl group was observed in the liquid products; which was strongly influenced by MoOx loadings on HZSM-5; achieving 64% reduction in carbonyl band intensity using 5 wt% MoOx/HZSM-5, 99% reduction using 7.5 wt% MoOx/HZSM-5, and 90% reduction using 10 wt% MoOx/HZSM-5. Furthermore, when HZSM-5 was used without metal impregnation, the infrared spectra of the liquid products showed minimal changes in the carbonyl stretching vibration at 1710 cm−1 relative to oleic acid (OA), indicating that the carbonyl functional group remained unaltered under these conditions. The appearance of the significant C
O stretching vibration at 1710 cm−1 can be primarily attributed to the inadequate catalytic activity of unloaded HZSM-5, resulting in incomplete deoxygenation. This finding was found consistent with deoxygenation studies done over Ni/MgO–Al2O3 catalyst by Liu et al.55 In their research, it was reported that metal loading improved the catalytic activity towards deoxygenation, however; increasing the metal loading after a threshold plateaued the catalytic activity due to agglomeration of NiO on the catalyst support. The IR spectroscopic analysis of the liquid products also revealed significant structural changes in comparison with OA, as evident by the diminished intensity of absorption bands corresponding to C–H stretching (2850–2950 cm−1) and bending (1460–1480 cm−1) vibrations of CH2 groups present in fatty acids (Fig. 1). Beyond the carbonyl region, the absorption bands associated with the aliphatic C–H stretching (2850–2950 cm−1) and bending (1460–1480 cm−1) vibrations also provide insight into the support's activity. In the case of liquid product obtained with pure HZSM-5 (0 wt% Mo), these bands demonstrated non-significant decrease in intensity compared to the raw oleic acid, suggesting partial transformation of aliphatics into cyclic compounds. In contrast, the Mo-promoted catalysts (5.0–10.0 wt% Mo) exhibit a much more dramatic suppression of these methylene vibrations. This near-disappearance of the aliphatic signature correlates with the high selectivity toward aromatics, indicating that the intermediate cracking products are rapidly undergoing cyclization and dehydrogenation over the bifunctional MoOx/HZSM-5 active sites. Furthermore, the appearance of weak vibrations in the 3000–3100 cm−1 (aromatic C–H stretch) and 1600–1650 cm−1 (aromatic C
C ring stretch) regions for the Mo-loaded samples indicates towards transformation of the long-chain aliphatic backbone into desired cyclic aromatic structures. In all the remaining cases, the suppression of C–H stretching and bending vibrations corresponding to long methylene backbone in the product IR suggested a decrease in linear alkane chain content, attributed to C–C cleavage.
The evaluation of deoxygenation activity of varying MoOx/HZSM-5 loadings was continued for a time-on-stream (TOS) of 84 h through the fixed-bed reactor. The liquid product was collected after every 8 h from the start of the run and analyzed by IR to measure the extent of deoxygenation under identical operating conditions, as shown in Fig. 2. The gaseous products from each experimental run were collected in Tedlar gas bags and subsequently analyzed for CO and CO2 concentrations to validate and corroborate the results obtained from infrared (IR) spectroscopy. The normalized concentrations for CO and CO2 evolved during the experimental runs have been provided in Fig. S2. For the products collected at the same time intervals, notable reduction in catalytic activity towards decarboxylation of OA was observed with 5 wt% MoOx/HZSM-5 and HZSM-5 compared to 7.5 wt% MoOx/HZSM-5 and 10 wt% MoOx/HZSM-5. In case of 10 wt% MoOx/HZSM-5, agglomeration of MoOx in the zeolite channels could inhibit the reactant/product diffusion and therefore a potential reason for reduced deoxygenation activity, when compared to 7.5 wt% MoOx/HZSM-5.
![]() | ||
Fig. 2 Extent of decarboxylation of oleic acid. Reaction conditions: T = 370 °C, τ = 4 h, water/feed = 4 : 1. | ||
:
feed ratio on deoxygenation. Parametric studies with OA were carried out with 7.5 wt% MoOx/HZSM-5 by varying temperature (350–375 °C); space time (1–4 h) and water
:
feed ratio (1
:
1–4
:
1) to investigate their synergistic effect on the extent of deoxygenation and conversion. Infrared (IR) analysis of the liquid products presented in Fig. 3 revealed that the extent of deoxygenation (calculated using eqn (2)) increased with reaction temperature. The extent of decarboxylation increased from 57% at 350 °C to 96% at 375 °C, which can be attributed to improved rates of decarboxylation due to increase in temperature. Notably, a near-complete deoxygenation (∼99.5%) was achieved at 360 °C. It is plausible that at higher temperatures, such as 375 °C and beyond, side reactions including coke formation, over-cracking, and condensation reactions become more prominent on MoOx/ZSM-5 catalysts. These side reactions lead to the deposition of carbonaceous species on active sites, blocking them and causing catalyst deactivation, which lowers the effective catalytic activity for decarboxylation. Furthermore, performing deoxygenation reactions with oleic acid at temperatures greater than 400 °C could result in trade-offs with product distribution and yields, as reported by Charpentier et al.56 In order to evaluate whether an increase in temperature above 375 °C would result in further improvement in deoxygenation, a control study was done at T = 390 °C. The total extent of deoxygenation obtained was 89.6% (Fig. S3) and was synonymous with those obtained at 370 °C, and therefore 360 °C was selected as the process temperature to evaluate other model compounds.
![]() | ||
Fig. 3 ATR-FTIR spectra of (a) oleic acid and liquid products formed at (b) 375 °C, (c) 370 °C, (d) 360 °C and (e) 350 °C; catalyst: 7.5 wt% MoOx/HZSM-5, τ = 4 h, water : feed = 4 : 1. | ||
The effect of variation of space time and water
:
feed ratio on deoxygenation has been depicted in Fig. 4. Fig. 4(a) suggests that under the reaction conditions of 360 °C and 4
:
1 water
:
feed ratio, increasing space time from 1 to 4 hours substantially improved decarboxylation efficiency. Charpentier et al.56 have explained the correlation of longer space times with higher decarboxylation percentages, with 4 h yielding optimal results for deoxygenation of conversion yields. It can further be deduced from Fig. 4(b) that temperature significantly influences the deoxygenation of OA, with a marked increase from 350 °C to 360 °C and plateauing at higher temperatures. The decrease in deoxygenation of oleic acid (OA) at 370 °C compared to 360 °C is likely due to secondary reactions that dominate at higher temperatures, resulting in increased formation of light gases and coke rather than desired hydrocarbon products. Although temperature initially enhances catalyst activity and promotes deoxygenation up to a certain point, further increases lead to excessive decomposition, which lowers the yield of liquid products and can decrease deoxygenation efficiency. At temperatures greater than 400 °C, secondary reactions such as cracking, polymerization, and condensation are favored, leading to coke formation that blocks active sites on the catalyst. This hinders the access of oleic acid and intermediates, reducing deoxygenation efficiency.57
![]() | ||
Fig. 4 Extent of decarboxylation under different experimental conditions: (a) space time (τ); (b) temperature and (c) water : feed ratio. | ||
This aligns with published findings showing that increasing temperature from 325 °C to 375 °C enhances decarboxylation from 55% to 92%.58 As shown in Fig. 4(c), increasing the water
:
feed ratio from 1
:
1 to 4
:
1 at 360 °C with 4 h space time progressively improved the decarboxylation efficiency. Earlier studies on optimization of reaction parameters have found that water
:
OA ratios between 1
:
1 and 4
:
1 significantly impact performance, with higher ratios generally yielding improved results.56 The literature reveals that water serves as an effective reaction medium, facilitating heat transfer and enabling more uniform temperature control throughout the reaction system, which helps achieve reproducible conversion results. Additionally, water promotes dispersion of the catalyst particles, which enhances interaction with OA, and plausibly would help in suppressing coking by providing a source of steam that helps prevent catalyst deactivation. The results obtained indicated that longer space times (4 h) and high water
:
feed (4
:
1) ratio showed a greater extent of deoxygenation of OA. Under preferred reaction conditions, the overall liquid yield during catalyst lifetime was found to be ca. 85% with OA. The liquid yield was calculated on a normalized mass basis of heptadecene present in the system, after complete decarboxylation of OA. Accordingly, the following conditions were selected as suitable conditions to achieve deoxygenation of poly(unsaturated) fatty acid: 7.5 wt% MoOx/HZSM-5, T = 360 °C, τ = 4 h, and water
:
feed = 4
:
1.
The IR spectra of the liquid products collected after the first 8 h of the experiments were analyzed to understand the changes in the functional groups during deoxygenation of OA, as depicted in Fig. 5. The prominent band at 1710 cm−1 corresponding to the C
O stretching vibrations of carboxylic acid group present in OA (Fig. 5(a)) was significantly suppressed in the spectra shown in Fig. 5(e)–(g); therefore, suggesting the prominent effect of increasing severity of reaction parameters on deoxygenation. The fingerprint region below 1500 cm−1 reveals that the product consists of aromatic compounds, evident with IR signals around 1400–1460 cm−1 corresponding to vibrations associated with C–C stretching of aromatic ring. The C–H wag (900–675 cm−1) corresponding to aromatic ring was particularly notable in spectra (e) through (i). Absorbance bands corresponding to
C–H stretching for aromatic compounds (3068 cm−1, 3028 cm−1) and C–C stretching attributable to the aromatic ring (1614 cm−1, 1506 cm−1 and 1465 cm−1) were observed. The IR results not only confirmed the catalytic activity of MoOx/HZSM-5 to promote deoxygenation but also indicated the potential of the catalyst to effect tandem deoxygenation and aromatization of OA.
| Feedstock | Reaction conditions, catalyst | Maximum aromatic production | Ref. |
|---|---|---|---|
| Peanut oil | WHSV of 5.4 h−1, T: 450–550 °C, TOS: 30 min over H-ZSM-5 | BTEX: 33 vol% | 58 |
| Palm oil | WHSV of 5 h−1, T: 500 °C, TOS: 3 h over Zn/HZSM-5 | BTEX: 65 wt% | 59 |
| Vegetable oil | WHSV of 2.6 h−1, T: 550 °C, TOS > 6 h over FCC catalyst | Average aromatic yield: 25 wt% with different feedstocks | 32 |
| Camelina oil | WHSV of 0.6 h−1, T: 500 °C, TOS: 12 h over Zn/ZSM-5 | BTX yield: 6.2 wt% | 60 |
| Soybean oil | WHSV of 6.69 h−1, T: 460 °C, over Si-MCM-41 | Aromatics: 25 wt% | 61 |
| Canola oil | WHSV of 5 h−1, T: 400–500 °C, over SiO2 and similar | BTX yield: 22.5 wt% | 62 |
| Rapeseed oil | WHSV of 7.6 h−1, T: 550 °C, TOS: 3 h, over Ga and Zn/ZSM-5 | Aromatics: 43% | 63 |
| Oleic acid | WHSV of 0.25 h−1, T: 500 °C, TOS: 30 min over Al2O3, ZrO2, AC, MCM-41 | BTX: 78% at 550 °C | 55 |
| Used cooking oil | Batch reactor studies, catalyst: 4 mg, feed: 1 mg, T: 600 °C, over HZSM-5, reaction time: 4 h | BTXNE: 58.6% | 64 |
| Vegetable oils | WHSV of 0.1 h−1, reaction time: 180 min, T: 400 °C, over alkali treated HZSM-5 | BTX: 28.4 wt% from coconut oil, 48 wt% from peanut oil | 59 |
| Palmitic acid | Reaction time of 3 h, T: 400 °C, over zeolites Y, β | BTX: 43.9 wt% | 26 |
| C18 fatty acids | Reaction time: 180 min, T: 400 °C over HZSM-5 | BTX: 7.6 wt% | 50 |
| Soybean oil | Reaction time: 60 min, T: 430 °C, over HZSM-5 | Aromatics: 21 wt% | 65 |
| Oleic acid | Reaction time: 180 min, T: 400 °C, over HZSM-5 | Aromatics: 47% | 11 |
| Oleic acid etc. | Reaction time: 360 min, T: 360 °C, over Mo/HZSM-5 | BTX > 75% | Current work |
Furthermore, Fig. 6 presents the composition of various compounds at different reaction temperatures: 350 °C, 360 °C, 370 °C, and 375 °C. The compounds identified, as per the standard aromatic hydrocarbons, include benzene, toluene, xylenes, ethyl toluene, 1,3,5-trimethylbenzene, and isopropylbenzene. These results suggest that increasing the reaction temperature from 350 °C to 360 °C significantly enhanced the formation of aromatic compounds, while reducing non-aromatic byproducts. At 350 °C, the GC-MS analysis revealed that a substantial fraction of the liquid product remained non-aromatic, consisting predominantly of partially deoxygenated and unsaturated C18 derived intermediates, which is consistent with an incomplete progression of the tandem deoxygenation–aromatization network under these milder conditions. However, further increases in temperature (beyond 375 °C) begin to reduce the deoxygenation and liquid yields of the aromatics. We anticipate that the relatively lower extent of decarboxylation at 350 °C (≈57%) compared to 360–375 °C, as determined by IR, implies that a significant pool of long-chain olefinic and paraffinic species persists in the liquid phase and competes with cyclization pathways for consumption of reactive intermediates. Similar temperature-sensitive behavior has been reported for zeolite-catalyzed upgrading of C18 fatty acids and triglycerides, where operation near 325–350 °C favours the formation of long-chain alkanes/olefins and oxygenated residues, while higher temperatures are required to drive aromatic ring closure and subsequent dehydrogenation over Brønsted acid sites.25,66 It is worth noticing that the proportion of benzene in the product remained relatively low at different reaction temperatures. The major product in the reactions were toluene, ethylbenzene, m-xylene, and p-xylene followed by some minor products such as 1,3,5-trimethylbenzene and isopropyl benzene. The concentration of toluene significantly increased with increase in temperature, roughly from 18% at 350 °C and to about 35% at 360 °C and 375 °C, indicating that higher temperature favors the formation of toluene. Similar trends were observed for xylenes and ethylbenzene. This is in accordance with other relevant literatures, which demonstrated the role of temperature and catalyst concentration during the decarboxylation of fatty acids such as oleic acid, linoleic acid, stearic acid, palmitic acid, and linolenic acid.67 Yang et al.68 reported that an increase in temperature promotes α/β scission of the hydrocarbon backbone, which is directly correlated with a higher degree of aromatization and enhanced deoxygenation rates at temperatures greater than 360 °C found in our studies.
C) groups (resonating in 4.5–6.5 ppm region) and aromatic (resonating in 6.5–8 ppm region) groups were taken into consideration. The integral ratios of the protons corresponding to these moieties/functional groups were calculated to assess the transformation of aliphatic moieties of oleic acid into aromatic moieties. A typical 1H-NMR spectrum of OA is presented in Fig. S5, where the 1H-NMR signals for different moieties/functional groups have been attributed as follows: protons attached to vinylic (C
C) group resonated at 5.34 ppm; protons associated with methylene group (–CH2) resonated in 1.25–1.62 ppm region; and the protons associated with terminal methyl group (–CH3) resonated at around 0.87 ppm. The 1H-NMR spectrum of the deoxygenated product of OA obtained under maximized operating conditions is shown in Fig. 7. The integral ratio of protons associated with aromatic, benzylic, and aliphatic functionality/moiety in the product of OA is 2.5
:
2.78
:
1, which is commensurate of substantially aromatic compounds.
![]() | ||
Fig. 7 1H-NMR spectra of decarboxylated product (reaction conditions: T = 360 °C, water : feed ratio = 4 : 1; τ = 4 h). | ||
A comparison of the integral ratios of protons resonating in aromatic (A), vinylic (B), benzylic/allylic (C), and methyl and methylene regions (D) in the 1H-NMR spectra of OA and its product are presented in Fig. S6. The deoxygenated product of OA contained high integral ratio for protons resonating in benzylic and allylic region of the 1H-NMR spectrum but had negligible vinylic protons; signifying that the protons resonating in the allylic and benzylic regions of the 1H NMR spectrum of the deoxygenated product were primarily benzylic protons (the protons in the alkyl substituent of benzene). It was also observed that the deoxygenated product had significantly lower integral ratio for protons resonating in methylene and methyl (–CH2– and CH3) region of the 1H-NMR spectrum, suggesting that the alkyl substituents were short-chain molecules.
Further analysis of splitting patterns and position of 1H NMR signals in Fig. 7 of deoxygenated product further highlighted distinctive triplet signal at δ = 0.97 ppm; attributed to the protons associated with terminal methyl groups of short-chain alkyl groups. Multiplets in δ = 6.9–7.3 ppm indicated the presence of substituted benzene, whereas singlets at δ = 7.37, 7.11, and 7.09 ppm indicated the presence of symmetrically substituted (2,4-disubstituted and 1,3,5-trisubstituted) benzene. Singlets at δ = 2.28, 2.32 and 2.37 ppm were indicative of methyl groups attached to benzene, suggesting methyl substituted benzene like toluene, xylenes, and mesitylene. Multiplets in δ = 2.24 to δ = 2.68 ppm connoted that some alkyl substituents contain two or more carbon atoms (e.g. ethyl, n-propyl, isopropyl, etc.). Comparison of the 1H-NMR of the deoxygenated product of OA with that of a simulated/predicted 1H-NMR spectrum for a mixture of aromatic hydrocarbons containing benzene, toluene, xylene, and ethylbenzene obtained by using an open access tool (https://nmrdb.org) indicates identical integral ratios and 1H-NMR signal splitting patterns; corroborating that the deoxygenated product of OA is the mixture of alkyl aromatic compounds where the alkyl groups are primarily methyl, ethyl, and propyl. The predicted 1H-NMR spectrum, for the mixture of aromatic hydrocarbons is shown in Fig. S7.
A comparison of the 1H-NMR spectrum of the deoxygenated product of OA obtained by using HZSM-5 and 7.5% MoOx/HZSM-5 as catalyst (demonstrated in Fig. 8) signifies the role of MoOx to promote tandem deoxygenation and aromatization of OA. The two products compared in Fig. 8 were obtained under identical reaction conditions (T = 360 °C, τ = 4 h, and water
:
feed ratio = 4
:
1). The 1H-NMR spectrum of the product using 7.5% MoOx/HZSM-5 as catalyst (Fig. 8(b)) signifies substantially aromatic compounds whereas the 1H-NMR of the product using HZSM-5 as catalyst is commensurate of open-chain hydrocarbons with small proportion of aromatic hydrocarbons (Fig. 8(a)). The relative abundance of protons in aromatic, benzylic/allylic, and aliphatic regions in the product of HZSM-5 catalyst is 0.09
:
0.37
:
1, suggesting that only limited tandem cyclization–aromatization of OA was achieved with HZSM-5 catalyst without Mo loading. On the contrary, the integral ratio of protons in aromatic, benzylic/allylic, and aliphatic regions in the product with 7.5 wt% MoOx/HZSM-5 was found to be 2.54
:
2.81
:
1, indicating that remarkable enhancement in aromatization. This is attributed to the presence of MoOx on HZSM-5, which promotes dehydrogenation of aliphatic hydrocarbons and subsequent cyclization to aromatics presumably via Brønsted acid sites within the catalyst channels.
:
feed ratio = 4
:
1, catalyst = 7.5 wt% MoOx/HZSM-5) were used for evaluation of deoxygenation, cyclization, and aromatization efficacy of the catalyst with different feedstocks.
O at 1710 cm−1 present in OA (vide supra) were shifted to 1743 cm−1, confirming the presence of esters (R–C
O–OR) in UCO and CDO. In the IR spectra of the liquid products obtained from OA, UCO and CDO, remarkable reduction in the intensity of C
O stretching signal is observed (Fig. 9(b), (d) and (f), respectively), which indicates the outstanding efficacy of 7.5 wt% MoOx/HZSM-5 catalyst for deoxygenation of fatty acids and fatty esters. Additionally, the IR band at 3005 cm−1 due to C–H stretching vibrations attributing to C
C were significantly reduced and shifted to 3028 cm−1, corresponding to
C–H aromatic stretching vibrations. C–H wag attributed to aromatic and alkyl aromatics was predominantly visible in the fingerprint region from 860 cm−1 and 770 cm−1, further validating the tandem deoxygenation–aromatization chemistry during the run.
Liquid yields of ca. 82%, ca. 75% and ca. 61% were reported on mass basis for products obtained with LA, UCO and CDO. The reduction in the total liquid yield is attributed to the chemical structure of these feedstocks, which contain a bulky aliphatic backbone (–CH2–CH–CH2) attached with three fatty acids per mole. As water is used during the reaction, hydrolysis of these feedstocks results in formation of three moles of free fatty acids and glycerol per mole of feedstock. The glycerol formed doesn't take part in the deoxygenation and aromatization chemistry, and thus results in overall yield loss on mass basis. This finding was further supported by analyzing the feedstock and hydrolyzed product without deoxygenation and aromatization using 1H-NMR spectroscopy (Fig. 11). A substantial decrease in the integral area corresponding to the proton associated with the acyl group in the feedstock (splitted doublets between δ 4.3 and 4.35, followed by quintet at δ 4.15) was observed in the hydrolyzed feedstock, confirming the absence of aliphatic backbone and generation of glycerol as a side product. In addition, 3 moles of CO2 are also removed per mol of hydrolyzed fatty acid derivatives upon deoxygenation, leading to an overall mass reduction of ∼30%.
The gaseous product obtained with these feedstocks were also analyzed using GC-TCD, which majorly comprised of CO, CO2, H2 and short chain alkenes (
C5) (Fig. S9). The production of gaseous products during decarboxylation and aromatization chemistry arose from distinct yet interconnected reaction pathways. Decarboxylation generated CO2 through the elimination of carboxyl groups (–COOH), while CO could have formed via secondary processes such as partial oxidation or thermal decomposition of intermediate carbonyl species. Concurrently, aromatization chemistry could be attributed to H2 evolution through dehydrogenation steps required to establish stable aromatic systems, and short-chain alkenes (
C7) emerged as fragmentation products from catalytic cracking of larger molecules, side-chain elimination from aromatic intermediates, or β-elimination reactions. The coexistence of CO2, CO, H2, and light alkenes in the gas profile reflected the parallel progression of these processes, with decarboxylation liberating volatile carbon oxides and aromatization producing hydrogen and unsaturated hydrocarbons.
| Product of | Integral value of protons resonating at different chemical shifts/regions of 1H-NMR spectrum | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aromatic (A) | Vinylic (B) | Benzylic & allylic (C) | Methylene and methyl (D) | |
| Linoleic acid | 4.42 | Negligible | 3.75 | 1 |
| Used cooking oil | 0.99 | Negligible | 0.99 | 1 |
| Corn distiller's oil | 3.04 | Negligible | 2.96 | 1 |
O and C–O bond cleavage.69–72 This holds valid for both saturated and unsaturated fatty acids. It is plausible that used cooking oil and corn distiller's oil after hydrolysis also undergo similar reactions, liberating CO2. The absence of long-chain alkanes or olefins in the liquid product indicates that MoOx/HZSM-5 not only facilitates deoxygenation but also actively promotes C–C bond fragmentation, olefin generation, cyclization, and aromatization reactions. Fig. 12 highlights a proposed mechanism pathway for tandem deoxygenation–aromatization of fatty acids and their derivatives, which plausibly follows a series of reaction steps.
In the proposed mechanism scheme, Reaction A involves the catalytic decarboxylation/decarbonylation of fatty acids, whereby CO2 is released, and shorter-chain alkenes such as heptadec-8-ene are generated. This is accompanied by homolytic bond scission at T ≥ 360 °C, giving rise to highly reactive free radical intermediates. Reaction B corresponds to β-scission and isomerization of radical species. Alkyl radicals undergo fragmentation into olefins and smaller radical intermediates, while the unsaturated hydrocarbons generated undergo skeletal rearrangements consistent with Zaitsev's rule, leading to more stable alkene isomers. Reaction C denotes disproportionation and hydrogen abstraction processes, where radical intermediates are quenched to form equimolar amounts of an alkane and an alkene. These pathways further contribute to the olefinic pool available for downstream transformations. Reaction D highlights the crucial cyclization of unsaturated intermediates as radical species undergo 1–6 endo cyclization or 1–6 exo cyclization reactions. The resulting cyclic intermediates, upon subsequent abstraction and stabilization, yield cycloalkane structures. Reaction E represents the dehydrogenation of cycloalkanes to stable aromatic compounds, a transformation strongly facilitated by the MoOx/HZSM-5 system. The resulting products predominantly consist of alkyl-substituted aromatic hydrocarbons, including toluene and xylenes. Product characterization by GC-FID and 1H-NMR supports the predominance of BTX-type aromatics while simultaneously confirming the absence of oxygenated intermediates.
Additionally, the environment provided by MoOx/HZSM-5 promotes secondary transformations such as alkylbenzene disproportionation, whereby toluene is converted to xylenes and mesitylene under the prevailing reaction conditions, as mentioned in other studies with ZSM based catalyst.73 Toluene produced via pathways shown in Fig. S12 shows interaction with another toluene molecule to produce xylene (specifically para-xylene) and benzene. This is also supported with the GC-MS results obtained in the previous section, where m-xylene and p-xylene are formed in higher amounts as compared to o-xylene. Taken together, these results highlight the dual functionality of MoOx/HZSM-5 in promoting both deoxygenation and hydrocarbon skeletal rearrangement, providing experimental evidence that consolidates the mechanistic scheme in Fig. 12 and establishes aromatization as the dominant terminal reaction route.
| Catalyst | S.S.A (m2 g−1) | BJH pore volume (cm3 g−1) | BJH pore size (Å) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pure HZSM-5 (calcined) | 398.4 | 0.295 | 86.2 |
| Fresh catalyst (5% MoOx/HZSM-5) | 410.2 | 0.310 | 83.5 |
| Fresh catalyst (7.5% MoOx/HZSM-5) | 445.6 | 0.304 | 81.3 |
| Fresh catalyst (10% MoOx/HZSM-5) | 432.6 | 0.280 | 82.4 |
| Spent catalyst (5% MoOx/HZSM-5) | 378.3 | 0.278 | 79.7 |
| Spent catalyst (7.5% MoOx/HZSM-5) | 412.3 | 0.27 | 76.5 |
| Spent catalyst (10% MoOx/HZSM-5) | 401.2 | 0.256 | 74.9 |
| Catalyst | Total acid sites (mmol g−1) | Peak temperature | Distribution of different acid sites (mmol g−1) | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Weak | Strong | Weak | Strong | ||
| Calcined HZSM-5 | 0.33 | 210.5 | 433 | 0.312 | 0.017 |
| 5 wt% MoOx/HZSM-5 | 0.24 | 198.2 | 462.1 | 0.236 | 0.004 |
| 7.5 wt% MoOx/HZSM-5 | 0.29 | 194.9 | 456.7 | 0.287 | 0.003 |
| 10 wt% MoOx/HZSM-5 | 0.26 | 205.4 | 466.4 | 0.254 | 0.006 |
Upon impregnation with Mo, the NH3-TPD profile demonstrates a marked reduction in the intensity of the high-temperature peak, signifying a loss of strong acid sites. Incorporation of Mo into HZSM-5 results in a notable decrease in the total number of acid sites, with the most significant reduction observed at 5 wt% Mo loading. The persistence of weak acid sites associated with dispersed MoOx may also contribute to aromatization through facilitating hydride abstraction and carbenium ion stabilization, albeit less efficiently than strong acid sites. Furthermore, a reduction in overall acid site density, particularly of strong acid sites, carries the ancillary benefit of suppressing undesirable side reactions such as excessive cracking, coke precursor formation, and secondary oligomerization, all of which compete with the desired aromatization pathway and compromise catalyst longevity.52 At 7.5 wt% Mo loading, a partial restoration of total acid sites is observed compared to 5 wt%, suggesting an optimum Mo content where both acidity and acid strength are balanced. In Fig. S13, a NH3-TPD analysis for 2.5 wt% MoOx/HZSM-5 catalyst can be seen. It is visible that the reduction in the peak corresponding to the strong acid sites starts at a lower loading, suggesting that during impregnation and calcination, Mo species can potentially migrate into the zeolite channels and substitute the Brønsted protons and thereby reducing the number of accessible acid sites. Furthermore, the introduction of the Mo species on the zeolite can initiate and accelerate the dehydration of strong acid sites within the zeolite channels, resulting in lower strong acid sites. These trends align closely with literature findings reported by Bao et al. wherein progressive Mo loading leads to a partial replacement of protons by MoOx species, diminishing overall strong acid sites but enhancing weak/medium acid sites.76 In parallel, the area associated with weak acid sites remains similar, likely due to the generation of additional acidic centers resulting from Mo species dispersed in or on the surface of the zeolite.
O stretching) and 2920 cm−1 (C–H stretching vibrations), suggested the deactivation of the catalyst due to pore blockage.
:
2.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 17 XPS of fresh catalyst (a) 7.5% MoOx/HZSM-5 and spent catalyst (b) 7.5% MoOx/HZSM-5370 °C, 4 h. | ||
Mo(VI) 3d5/2 and Mo 3d3/2 components were located at 232.69 and 235.81 eV respectively. There is a visible shift towards higher binding energy in Mo(VI) 3d3/2, compared to the BE value of Mo(VI) 3d5/2 in bulk MoO3, which can be explained based on strong metal–support interaction. In case of the spent catalyst, the observable shift in the spin–orbit doublets likely reflect a lower oxidation state. However, it was evident from the XPS data that both fresh and spent catalyst samples contained significant fraction of Mo6+ species in the form of MoO3. To complement the surface-sensitive XPS analysis and obtain bulk elemental composition of the catalysts, inductively coupled plasma optical emission spectrometry (ICP-OES) was employed. The measured Mo concentrations for the 7.5 wt% and 10 wt% nominal loading catalysts were 74
800 mg kg−1 (7.48 wt%) and 98
700 mg kg−1 (9.87 wt%), respectively, confirming successful incorporation of molybdenum onto the HZSM-5 support via incipient wetness impregnation. (Fig. S15) The close agreement between theoretical and measured Mo loadings, combined with the predominance of Mo6+ species identified by XPS, is consistent with the formation of well-dispersed MoO3 surface domains rather than bulk-phase segregation.
:
Al ratio to alter the acidity of the solid acid support, followed by alternate methods for catalyst preparation. A life cycle assessment (LCA) with energy and mass balance, environmental impacts, etc. would result in a deeper understanding of the scalability of the process. The pathway described for production of BTX under given reaction conditions without hydrotreating, along with the achieved product yields during the process represents significant improvements over what has been reported in this research domain, thereby serving as a cornerstone for future research endeavours.
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2026 |