Open Access Article
Qingqing
Wu
a,
Huajie
Luo
*b,
Yuhang
Hu
a,
Yuhui
Huang
c,
Xiangwei
Guo
*c,
Hubo
Zhu
a,
Haishan
Xu
a,
Shenglin
Jiang
d,
Tianyu
Li
*be and
Bing
Xie
*a
aSchool of Power and Energy, Jiangxi Key Laboratory of Green General Aviation Power, Nanchang Hangkong University, Nanchang 330063, China. E-mail: xieb@nchu.edu.cn
bSchool of Materials Science and Engineering, University of Science and Technology Beijing, Beijing 100083, China. E-mail: hjluo@ustb.edu.cn; tianyuli@ustb.edu.cn
cState Key Laboratory of Silicon and Advanced Semiconductor Materials, School of Materials Science and Engineering, Zhejiang University, Hangzhou, Zhejiang 310058, China. E-mail: l240441@zju.edu.cn
dSchool of Integrated Circuits, Huazhong University of Science and Technology, Wuhan 430074, China
eDepartment of Physics, City University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong SAR, China
First published on 3rd March 2026
Dielectric capacitors are highly attractive for advanced power electronics owing to their ultrafast charge–discharge rate, high power density, and excellent reliability. Yet their application is hindered by the persistent trade-off between high recoverable energy density (Wrec) and high efficiency (η) owing to the inherent coupling in single-phase dielectrics, where stronger polarization generally comes at the expense of higher hysteresis and limited breakdown strength. Here, we present a polar–nonpolar hierarchical phase architecture design in BaTiO3–BiMg0.5Ti0.5O3-based ceramics to overcome this limitation by modulating thermodynamic spinodal decomposition. The polar Ba-rich phase provides large maximum polarization, while the non-polar Cd-rich precipitation with a large bandgap acts as a high-resistivity barrier that isolates polar regions and enhances the breakdown field. Atomic-scale electron microscopy analysis reveals that the nanoscale polar regions (∼1–3 nm) with locally disordered configurations emerge in the ceramic, which lowers the energy barrier for domain switching and enables near-zero hysteresis losses. As a result, the optimized hierarchical composition achieves an ultrahigh efficiency of 92.8%, a high recoverable energy density of 9.7 J cm−3, an outstanding high figure of merit WF of 135 at 460 kV cm−1, along with excellent stability against temperature, frequency, and cycling, and fast discharge with a power density up to 185 MW L−1. This work demonstrates a robust design paradigm based on complementary dual-phase coexistence, offering fundamental insights and a practical pathway toward high-performance, lead-free dielectric capacitors.
, where Wtotal, Pmax, Pr and E represent the total energy density, maximum polarization, remnant polarization and applied electric field, respectively. In this case, achieving excellent overall energy storage performance requires dielectrics with a high breakdown strength (Eb) and a large polarization difference (ΔP = Pmax − Pr). However, the widely developed single-phase ferroelectrics face an intrinsic conflict: enhancing polarization tends to increase remanent polarization and hysteresis, while improving breakdown strength typically requires suppressing polarization.9–12 This trade-off has become the major bottleneck restricting the practical deployment of high-energy-density, high-efficiency capacitors.
In recent years, significant efforts have been devoted to overcoming this limitation in single-phase relaxor ferroelectrics through structural and compositional engineering. Typical strategies include chemical substitution to tune ionic size and valence, domain engineering to manipulate switching dynamics, high-entropy design to stabilize multiple configurations, and the construction of superparaelectric states to suppress long-range order.13–19 These approaches have successfully improved energy storage density and efficiency in various BaTiO3-,20–24 (Bi0.5Na0.5)TiO3-,25–27 BiFeO3-,28–31 and NaNbO3-32–35 based systems. Nevertheless, most of these strategies involve increasingly complex multi-component chemistries, which not only raise processing costs but also compromise phase stability and reproducibility, hindering large-scale practical application. Against this backdrop, the introduction of a secondary phase into perovskite ceramics has emerged as a promising alternative design route. By combining phases with distinct functionalities, dual-phase systems can simultaneously regulate polarization and breakdown behavior, leveraging the combination of advantages from different dielectric phases, offering a new pathway beyond the limitations in single-phase ferroelectrics and dielectrics.36–39 Traditional two-phase composites or core–shell structures employ components that do not react with each other and do not form solid solutions, (e.g., perovskite ferroelectrics with SiO2 or MgO),40,41 leading to limited phase selection, structural discontinuities, and complex interfacial effects, while requiring delicate control of microstructure (core size, shell thickness) and coating/sintering process. By contrast, the polar–nonpolar hierarchical phase architecture forms in situ via thermodynamically driven phase separation, producing stable microstructures that enable complementary dielectric response rather than simple superposition.
Here, we propose a hierarchical polar–nonpolar phase architecture in BaTiO3–Bi(Mg0.5Ti0.5)O3 (BT–BMT)-based ceramics, in which polar and non-polar phases, formed by spinodal decomposition, play complementary roles to promote energy storage. The polar Ba-rich phase provides large reversible polarization, while the non-polar Cd-rich phase acts as a high-resistivity barrier that enlarges the bandgap, suppresses leakage, and reduces hysteresis (H) (Fig. 1a). To achieve this configuration, CdZrO3 (CZ) was incorporated into the 0.5BT–0.5BMT matrix. The smaller ionic radius of Cd2+ (1.31 Å) relative to Bi3+ (1.34 Å) and Ba2+ (1.61 Å), combined with the chemical potential difference and limited mutual solubility between CdZrO3 and the matrix, drives thermodynamically favored phase separation at the grain level. This synergistic dual-phase structure overcomes the intrinsic trade-off between energy density and efficiency, enabling the optimized 0.5BT–0.3BMT–0.2CZ composition to achieve an ultrahigh η of 92.8% at 460 kV cm−1, a high Wrec of 9.7 J cm−3, a corresponding high figure of merit WF of 135, an excellent temperature/frequency/cycling stability, and rapid discharge with a power density of 185 MW L−1. These results establish a robust design paradigm based on in situ dual-phase coexistence, providing mechanistic insight and a practical route toward high-performance, lead-free dielectric capacitors.
To clarify the polarization configurations and local structural features of the coexisting phases, we carried out a detailed atomic-scale scanning transmission electron microscopy (STEM) investigation on the x = 0.2 dual-phase ceramic. The STEM-EDS mapping images further confirmed the presence of the BT–BMT matrix phase alongside the Cd-rich secondary phase (Fig. 2a). Fig. 2b and d shows high-angle annular dark-field STEM (HAADF-STEM) along the [001]pc zone axis. No superlattice reflections are observed in the corresponding fast Fourier transformation (FFT) patterns of the BT–BMT matrix and Cd-rich phases (insets in Fig. 2b and d). This indicates the absence of long-range oxygen-octahedral tilting and concurrent ferroelectric ordering in both phases (Fig. 2b and d), consistent with the characteristic of relaxor ferroelectrics. The measured crystal-plane spaces further confirm the pseudo-cubic nature of both phases. The Cd-rich nonpolar phase exhibits a noticeably smaller lattice parameter (a = 4.027 Å) (Fig. 2d), whereas the polar matrix phase shows a larger value (a = 4.238 Å) (Fig. 2b), highlighting the lattice mismatch between the two coexisting phases and agreeing with the XRD characterizations. Quantitative c/a ratio mapping further reveals values very close to unity in Cd-rich phase (c/a ∼ 1, see Fig. S5, confirming that it adopts pseudo-cubic symmetry rather than developing a tetragonal distortion. This structural homogeneity provides a stable framework in which local polar heterogeneity can be accommodated.44
Quantitative polarity-vector mapping (Fig. 2c and e) provides further insights into the distribution of polarization and its differences between the two phases. The arrows denote the orientations of local polarization vectors, while their lengths correspond to the magnitudes. Within the polar main phase, island-like clusters with sizes of 1–3 nm are observed, which correspond to ultrafine polar nanoregions (PNRs) (Fig. 2c). These PNRs are spatially confined yet polymorphic in orientation, resulting in a broad distribution of polarization angles (Fig. 2c1 and c2). Such polymorphic PNRs are highly dynamic, which weakens the anisotropy of polarization orientation, lowers the energy barriers for domain-wall movement, and thereby facilitates smoother and more reversible domain reorientation under applied electric fields. In contrast, the Cd-rich nonpolar phase remains free of long-range polarization (Fig. 2e and e1–e41-e4), effectively acting as a structural matrix that accommodates polar clusters without imposing rigid constraints. This coexistence of nonpolar and polar regions gives rise to markedly different polarization amplitudes (Fig. 2c3, c4, e3 and e43-c). In the polar regions, the average polarization amplitude reaches 1.6 pm, whereas the stronger matrix-like regions show a significantly larger value of 18.0 pm very close to the background signal. The combination of strongly and weakly polarized regions introduces both stability and flexibility into the system. According to Landau theory,30,45,46 nanoscale domains with weak inter-domain interactions yet strong polarization strength can readily relax back to their initial configurations once the external field is removed. This spontaneous relaxor minimizes remanent polarization, suppresses hysteresis, and simultaneously preserves the capacity for high maximum polarization. Collectively, the results reveal that at x = 0.2 the ceramic develops a distinctive dual-phase configuration, wherein a Cd-rich nonpolar phase is characterized by reduced lattice dimensions and the absence of spontaneous polarization, and a polar pseudo-cubic matrix possesses highly active, polymorphic PNRs at the nanometer scale. Such a hierarchical microstructure effectively suppresses long-range ferroelectric ordering while enabling localized polar activity, thereby reducing hysteresis losses and enhancing energy-storage efficiency under high electric fields.
The energy-storage performance of different components was systematically investigated through comparative P–E loops measurements at their respective breakdown fields (Fig. 3a and b). With increasing CdZrO3 content, the loop shape evolves markedly. For the x = 0 single phase, the loop is characterized by a large Pr and a narrow maximum applied field, indicative of limited energy-storage capability (Fig. 3a and e). By contrast, at x = 0.2 the P–E loop becomes slim, with Pr values approaching zero across the entire applied field range. Of equal importance is that the maximum electric field that can be applied to the x = 0.2 ceramic is significantly higher (460 kV cm−1) than that of the pure x = 0 ceramic. This increase in withstanding field strength demonstrates that the introduction of the Cd-rich nonpolar phase effectively enhances the dielectric breakdown resistance of the system. Building upon these observations, the x = 0.2 ceramic exhibits markedly improved energy-storage performance (Fig. 3b and f). It achieves a large Pmax of 51.3 µC cm−2 while retaining an ultralow Pr of only 1.7 µC cm−2, compared with Pr = 7.36 µC cm−2 for the pure main phase (Fig. 3a and b). To reveal the inherent differences in the dynamic polarization responses, we analyzed the P–E loops of different samples using the power-law relationship (〈A〉 ∝ Ea).47,48 〈A〉 represents the energy dissipation within one cycle of polarization reversal, which is considered as a characteristic parameter of the dynamic behavior in FEs, while the exponent α is mainly controlled by the domain state and polarization switching mechanism. As shown in Fig. 3c, when x = 0, the ln
E–ln
〈A〉 relationship clearly exhibits two stages: In the first stage, polarization rises rapidly owing to the domain switching, wherein the large hysteresis leads to a large α value. In the second stage, the linear extension happens, corresponding to a slow polarization growth and low hysteresis with small α value. These two stages thereby give rise to an evident non-linear P–E loop and low Wrec. By comparison, the ceramic with x = 0.2 only shows a single linear relationship throughout the entire measurement field range. Such behavior is owing to a continuous polarization evolution by merging these two processes, indicating a highly dynamic nanodomain for dual-high Wrec and η. To further determine the dynamic evolution of under an external electric field, phase-field simulations were conducted on x = 0.2 ceramic (Fig. S6 and S7). The initial PNR morphology in the phase-field model was constructed based on the STEM observations, reproducing the ultrafine polar nanoregions with 1–3 nm size distribution. Upon increasing the electric field, the polarization within individual PNRs progressively aligns with the field direction and undergoes continuous growth and coalescence, leading to a macroscopic polarization response characterized by low hysteresis and relaxor behavior in the P–E loop. Therefore, the simulation result further supports our experimental observation, being consistent with the analysis based on the power-law scaling relationship (Fig. 3c and d).
The energy storage performance was analyzed and compared. For x = 0.2 ceramic, its favorable polarization behavior, together with the improved voltage endurance, results in an outstanding Wrec of 9.7 J cm−3 and an exceptionally high η of 94.1%, in stark contrast to the x = 0 ceramic with Wrec of 3.65 J cm−3 and η of 72.5% (Fig. 3e and f). The multiple P–E loop measurements were performed on different ceramics, where the results show a good consistency with average Wrec = 9.7 J cm−3 and η = 92.8% (Fig. S8). In dielectric energy storage materials, Wrec and η of the material are usually described separately. Therefore, we use the figure of merit WF to comprehensively evaluate the ability of the dielectric capacitors to store and release electric energy, which is defined as: WF = Wrec/(1 − η), where WF represents the energy that the material can store under the unit loss and (1 − η) represents the energy loss rate.6 The higher WF, the more energy the dielectric materials can store under the same loss. The high Wrec and η lead to high figure of merit WF of 135. By comparing the comprehensive performance of representative lead-free dielectric ceramics and dual-phase/composite ceramics, it is evident that the designed dual-phase ceramic exhibits high performance level among them (Fig. 3g and Table 1, S1).20,49–56 Taken together, these results highlight the designed dual-phase ceramic as a promising candidate for high-performance dielectric energy-storage applications.
| Composition | W F | W rec (J cm−3) | η (%) | E b (kV cm−1) | Temperature stability | Ref. |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0.92(Bi0.5Na0.5)0.7Sr0.3TiO3–0.08Ca(Mg1/3Ta2/3)O3 | 68.1 | 8.37 | 87.7 | 530 | ΔWrec < 1.9% | 61 |
| Δη < 10.35% | ||||||
| (Sr0.24Na0.1Bi0.26Ca0.2□0.2)TiO3(□: Sr vacancies) | 75 | 6 | 92 | 440 | ΔWrec < 15% | 62 |
| Δη < 15% | ||||||
| 0.82(0.5Bi0.5K0.5TiO3–0.5Bi0.5Na0.5TiO3)–0.18NaTaO3 | 75 | 15 | 80 | 740 | ΔWrec < 4.1% | 63 |
| Δη < 3.10% | ||||||
| 0.65Na0.5Bi0.5TiO3–0.35SrTiO3 | 95 | 7.6 | 92 | 620 | ΔWrec < 4% | 64 |
| Δη < 8% | ||||||
| 0.75Bi0.5Na0.5TiO3–0.25K0.5Na0.5NbO3 | 96.1 | 12.4 | 87.1 | 713 | ΔWrec < 0.08% | 56 |
| Δη < 0.6% | ||||||
| [Ba0.7(Bi0.5Na0.5)0.3][Ti0.88(Zn1/3Nb2/3)0.12]O3 | 100.7 | 15.1 | 85 | 900 | ΔWrec < 2.9% | 55 |
| Δη < 2.9% | ||||||
| 0.8(Bi0.5Na0.25K0.25)TiO3–0.2BaZrO3 | 109.1 | 12 | 89 | 560 | ΔWrec < 5.4% | 52 |
| Δη < 5% | ||||||
| (Bi1/3K1/6Na1/6Ba1/6Sr1/6)(Ti0.8Zr0.2)O3 | 124.6 | 18.7 | 85 | 770 | ΔWrec < 5% | 59 |
| Δη < 10% | ||||||
| 0.5BaTiO3–0.3BiMg0.5Ti0.5O3–0.2CdZrO3 | 135 | 9.7 | 92.8 | 460 | ΔWrec < 2% | This work |
| Δη < 2% |
To understand the dielectric characteristics closely correlated to the polarization behavior and energy-storage performance, we then measured the temperature-dependent dielectric spectra of the 0.5BT–(0.5 − x)BMT–xCZ composites multiple times (Fig. 3h and S9). It can be noted that all samples exhibit pronounced frequency dispersion, with the peak dielectric constant (εm) decreasing and the corresponding maximum temperature (Tm) shifting to higher temperatures as the measurement frequency increases. Increasing the CdZrO3 content leads to a diffuse ferroelectric–paraelectric phase transition and shifts Tm to lower temperatures relative to the pure BT–BMT ceramics. These are typical relaxor features that originate from not only the presence of highly dynamic polar nanoregions in the main phase but also the contribution from the nonpolar secondary phase. The relaxor behavior of the materials was further evaluated using the modified Curie–Weiss law, expressed as:22,57,58γ = (T – Tm)/C, where C is a Curie-like constant, T is the measurement temperature, and γ quantifies the degree of diffuseness (the values of γ range from 0 to 1 corresponds to classical ferroelectrics, 1 to 2 for relaxor ferroelectrics and 2 corresponds to ideal relaxor ferroelectrics). As shown in Fig. 3i, the x = 0.2 ceramic exhibits the highest γ value of 1.91, exceeding 1.50 for the x = 0 single phase. The larger γ reflects stronger relaxor behavior and reduced hysteresis. Stronger relaxor allows PNRs to reorient more rapidly under an external electric field, which plays a crucial role in reducing Pr while maintaining high Pmax. As evidenced by the repetitive measurements, the dielectric properties of the ceramic are stable, which also supports this conclusion (Fig. S10). These dielectric measurements therefore provide direct evidence that the coexistence of polymorphic PNRs and the nonpolar Cd-rich phase underlies the exceptional energy-storage performance observed in the x = 0.2 ceramics.
Since high Eb and excellent insulating properties play a key role in supporting superior energy-storage performance, electrical breakdown tests were therefore conducted for each sample and statistically validated using the Weibull distribution method (Fig. 4a). Consistent with previous unipolar P–E loop measurements, the maximum Eb of 460 kV cm−1 is achieved for the x = 0.2 composition, and the Weibull modulus β of 8.86 further confirms high reliability and consistency for Eb (Fig. 4b).59 To elucidate the factors influencing Eb, bandgap (Eg) and electrical resistance were evaluated, as they directly affect dielectric breakdown.49,58 According to the empirical relationship for intrinsic breakdown strength
, a larger Eg hinders electron transitions from the valence band to the conduction band, contributing to higher Eb.16,60 As shown in Fig. 4c, the x = 0.2 sample exhibits the largest Eg of 2.82 eV among all compositions. Impedance measurements and corresponding Nyquist plots recorded at 550–630 °C show that x = 0.2 has the largest Debye semicircle radius at 630 °C, indicating the highest electrical resistance (Fig. 4d and S11).
To further verify the experimental observations of breakdown behavior, finite-element simulations for the 0.5BT–(0.5 − x)BMT–xCZ ceramics were conducted based on SEM images and dielectric temperature spectra. It is well known that strong electric fields tend to concentrate at grain boundaries due to their lower dielectric constant compared with the grains.7,10 In the x = 0 composition, breakdown occurs rapidly, with electric dendrites propagating throughout the entire sample. By contrast, in the x = 0.15 and x = 0.2 ceramics, where the grain-separated dual-phase design is realized, the growth rate of the electric tree slows down. When in x = 0.2, the electric tree extends only about two-thirds of the sample thickness (Fig. 4e), consistent with the higher breakdown field observed experimentally. This demonstrates that the deliberate incorporation of the highly insulating Cd-rich nonpolar phase into the dual-phase structure effectively separates grains, enhances local resistivity, and suppresses the propagation of breakdown pathways. Collectively, these results indicate that the improvement of Eb, the increase in Eg, and the elevated electrical resistance all originate from the high insulation provided by the Cd-rich phase, confirming the effectiveness of the proposed grain-separated dual-phase design in supporting superior energy-storage performance. The improved breakdown performance of the x = 0.2 sample correlates with its smaller grain size, lower εr, and the presence of two-phase contact grain boundaries, which are less prone to failure than the boundaries in the BT–BMT single phase. These simulation results confirm the experimental finding that introducing a dual-phase coexistence system effectively enhances breakdown strength and supports the dual-phase design strategy.
Considering the practical requirements for dielectric capacitors to operate under diverse environments and conditions, we evaluated the temperature stability, frequency stability, and cycle stability of the x = 0.2 ceramics at an electric field of 300 kV cm−1. The temperature stability was assessed from 25 °C to 200 °C (Fig. 5a and d), and the sample exhibits excellent performance, with the recoverable energy density and efficiency decreasing by less than 2% across the measured range. Frequency stability tests show minimal variation in recoverable energy density (4.96 ± 0.16 J cm−3) and an efficiency change of only 2% over a broad frequency range of 1–180 Hz (Fig. 5b and e). Remarkably, the ceramics also demonstrate exceptional cycle stability, with negligible variation in recoverable energy density (5.13 ± 0.11 J cm−3) and ultra-low efficiency change (0.2%) over 10 to 106 cycles, maintaining a recoverable energy density of 5.13 J cm−3 and efficiency of 97.1% even after 106 cycles (Fig. 5c and f). These results indicate that x = 0.2 ceramics possess excellent energy storage stability under various operational conditions, highlighting their suitability as high-performance dielectric capacitors.
To investigate the pulse charging and discharging capabilities and power densities of the x = 0.2 dual-phase ceramics, fast charging and discharging experiments were conducted. The slight decrease in efficiency at elevated temperatures is likely related to thermally induced conduction losses. Fig. 5g and h presents the room-temperature discharge energy density of x = 0.2 under different electric fields. As the applied electric field increases from 100 kV cm−1 to 420 kV cm−1, the discharge energy density (Wdis) rises from 0.2 J cm−3 to 2.17 J cm−3. The parameter t0.9, representing the discharge time required to release 90% of the charged energy, is only 108 ns at 420 kV cm−1, confirming rapid discharge capability. Correspondingly, the power density reaches a maximum of 185 MW L−1 at 420 kV cm−1 (Fig. 5i). Overall, these measurements strongly confirm that the x = 0.2 ceramics combine high energy-storage density, exceptionally high efficiency, and excellent stability with ultrafast discharge capability, demonstrating considerable potential for practical dielectric capacitor applications.
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2026 |