Open Access Article
Alexander Karr†
,
Hye Joon Lee†,
A. Talim G. K,
Chloe A. Ramsperger,
Cesar A. Reyes,
Kelly Biv and
Elias Picazo
*
Department of Chemistry, Loker Hydrocarbon Research Institute, University of Southern California, 837 Bloom Walk, Los Angeles, California 90089-1661, USA. E-mail: epicazo@usc.edu
First published on 12th December 2025
Donor–acceptor Stenhouse adducts (DASAs) are molecular photoswitches with applications spanning materials to molecular machines. Although structural modularity has enabled seminal DASA studies, sulfonyl substituents in amino DASAs remain unexplored. Evaluation of sulfonyl substituents reveals a distinct photoswitching pathway between acyclic isomers about the C3–C4 bond, as evidenced by UV-vis spectroscopy and low-temperature NMR spectroscopy. This discovery was achieved by significantly improving DASA structural stability under irradiation, which in turn enables the creation of a compound that sets the record for amino DASA isomer distribution at the photostationary state. Thermal reversion is rapid with little to no fatigue in dichloromethane and solvent versatility is demonstrated with photoswitching and full recovery in toluene, albeit with slower thermal recovery rates. Sulfonyl substituents are also found to modulate molar absorption coefficients and structural charge distribution in a manner that broadly follows Hammett substituent constants with modest correlations, thereby providing qualitative guidance for molecular design. These findings enable the greater DASA photoswitch class to selectively access multiple isomers through structural design, offering opportunities for further developments in responsive materials, soft robotics, and selective reactivity.
The donor–acceptor Stenhouse adduct (DASA) class was discovered in 2014
13 and has since gained great interest for its synthetic modularity, multistep switching mechanism, and use in photoresponsive polymers and logic-gated devices, among other applications.14–24 Unlike photoswitches requiring UV light to undergo single-step transformations,12,25–28 DASAs use visible light to toggle between A, B, and C states, where A represents the thermodynamically favored acyclic form, B is a series of metastable acyclic alkene isomers, and C is a series of metastable cyclic forms (Fig. 1B).29–36 The triene photoswitch unit in DASAs enables both actinic E/Z isomerizations from A to B and a thermal pericyclic rearrangement from EZE B to C. Although metastable acyclic isomeric B forms have been characterized,37 precise DASA switching between the A form and a single B isomer without C formation remains elusive despite vastly different properties between B and C isomers that are of interest for (bio)electronic and conductive responsive materials.38 The continued advancement of DASA structural modularity has repeatedly unlocked insights into swtiching mechanisms, functional behaviors, applications, and tunable properties,13,39–47 raising the prospect that further structural innovation may ultimately deliver the selective A to single-B photoswitching.
DASAs produce equilibria with low B-series exclusivity as a result of an electron rich C5 from C2-hydroxyl electron donation through resonance,29–36 which distinguishes them from traditional merocyanine dyes.48 In the development of a multi-stage system, an equilibrium of A, B, and C isomers was established using strategically tuned donor and acceptor units bearing sterically demanding groups to increase the kinetic barriers of isomerization.49 In a separate study, removal of the backbone heteroatom was shown to circumvent 4π-electrocyclization while unselectively forming multiple B-series isomers,32 highlighting the critical heteroatomic electronic effect on interrupting the full A to C DASA switching sequence. We recently developed a pyrrole rearrangement that introduces C2 heteroatomic variation on the DASA structure.50,51 Despite creating an amino DASA of each generation using a 4-bromobenzenesulfonyl group on the C2 nitrogen atom, photoisomerization was not discernible by NMR due to inefficient photoswitching. The additional bonding orbital on the C2 nitrogen atom in amino DASAs is an unexplored structural domain that is of high interest for its potential to achieve selective A to B DASA photoswitching while simultaneously advancing amino DASA switching function and photophysical tunability by strategically altering steric and electronic profiles.
Herein, we report the exploration of sulfonyl substitution effects on amino donor–acceptor Stenhouse adducts (DASAs) and the discovery of a new photoswitching paradigm within this widely studied negative photochrome family. By introducing sulfonyl groups on the C2 nitrogen atom, we suppress the conventional multi-step pathway involving cyclization or competing acyclic isomers and instead achieve clean isomerization about the C3–C4 bond (EEZ open form A to EZZ open form B) and retain a fully conjugated, acyclic structure in both states. This selective conjugated-to-conjugated switching is accompanied by exceptional photostability, enabling the creation of an amino DASA with the highest reported population of the photogenerated isomer for the amino DASA subclass. A rapid, nearly quantitative thermal reversion after extended periods of irradiation in dichloromethane is coupled with solvent versatility that extends to non-polar media such as toluene, albeit with slower thermal recovery rates. Low-temperature NMR and UV-vis spectroscopy confirm the exclusive formation of the EZZ B isomer from the EEZ A isomer upon irradiation, while systematic variation of the sulfonyl substituent reveals qualitative electronic trends in molar absorptivity and charge distribution. These findings establish a rational, modular strategy for accessing selective, open-form DASA photoswitches and expand their potential in responsive materials, soft robotics, and light-gated selective reactivity.
To draw trends between sulfonyl substitents and DASA photophysical properties, and to investigate their impact on photoswitching, we synthesized a library using N,N-dimethyl barbituric acid as the acceptor and unsubstituted indoline as the donor. These amino DASAs are therefore reminiscent to second-generation hydroxy DASAs, which are comprised of a weakly donating arylamine donor and a relatively weakly withdrawing acceptor.42,43 The scope and overview of compound photophysical properties are shown in Fig. 2B. Benzenesulfonyl amino DASA 6 serves as the parent compound, synthesized in 61% yield, with extended sulfonyl conjugation explored through 1-naphthyl DASA 7. Sulfonyl amino DASAs containing electron donating groups on the sulfonyl group, such as 4-methoxy 8 and 4-methylthio 9, are isolated in 15 and 29% yields, respectively. Halogenated sulfonyl groups like 4-fluoro- 10, 4-chloro- 11, and 4-iodobenzene 13 yield product in 70, 29, and 74%, respectively. Compounds containing groups with stronger withdrawing capacity, including 4-azido- 14, 4-nitro- 15, 2-nitro- 16, 4-trifluoromethyl- 17, and 4-cyanobenzene 18, are prepared in 47–76% yield. 4- and 2-nitrobenzenesulfonyl DASAs 15 and 16 allowed us to evaluate an electronic effect when comparing to benzenesulfonyl amino DASA 6 while simultaneously validating an observed steric effect on stability during irradiation (vide infra). Halide-containing sulfonyl amino DASAs 10–13 and azide-containing DASA 14 offer useful reactive cross-coupling or click reaction handles at previously unobtainable molecular regions,54 highlighting the potential utility of the additional bonding orbital on nitrogen beyond pyrrole activation and DASA property adjustments. Although DASAs have been functionalized at the donor and acceptor compartments,20 and have themselves been embedded into polymer backbones,55 functionalizing at the sulfonyl group provides a fourth distinct spatial arrangement with photophysical advantages like unaltered λmax values despite undergoing electronic changes at sulfonyl group (vide infra). Sulfonamides substituted with multiple halides, such as 2,4,5-trichloro- 19 (68% yield) and pentafluorobenzene 20 (99% yield), enable comparisons with monosubstituted analogs. Heterocycles including 3-pyridine- and 2-thiophene-containing products 21 and 22, synthesized in 57 and 72% yield, respectively, further diversify the library. Finally, we synthesized sulfonyl amino DASAs featuring mesityl 23, 4-t-butyl mesityl 24, and methyl 25 sulfonyl groups to assess steric effects.
The absorption bands of sulfonyl amino DASAs have λmax values ranging from 577–582 nm in dichloromethane. This is demonstrated in Fig. 3A through the narrow range of absorption λmax values displayed by amino DASAs 6, 8, 18, 21, and 25, containing structurally diverse sulfonyl groups. Sulfonyl amino DASAs exhibit a slight hypsochromic shift in λmax relative to hydroxy DASA analogs (615 nm),50 attributed to the strong electron-withdrawing nature of the sulfonamide group, despite nitrogen being a less electronegative atom than oxygen.50,56 The narrow range of absorption λmax values is consistent with sulfonyl group substituents primarily exerting inductive effects with negligible resonance contributions to the triene system.
Time-dependent density functional theory (TD-DFT) calculations, which model responses to time-dependent perturbations like light,57 were performed on benzenesulfonyl, 4-methoxybenzenesulfonyl, and 4-cyanobenzenesulfonyl DASAs 6, 8, and 18 to visualize the S0 → S1 transition. These calculations reveal that sulfonyl substituents have little impact on the electron distribution involved in the S1 excited state. As shown in Fig. 3B, electron density in both the hole, the orbital from which the electron is excited, and the electron, the orbital occupied upon excitation, remains localized in the same regions across compounds. This supports the minimal influence of sulfonyl groups on λmax values. Additionally, ground-state DFT calculations on DASAs 6, 8, and 18 confirm that sulfonyl substituents do not significantly alter the HOMO or LUMO (see SI Fig. S269). Notably, molar absorption coefficients in dichloromethane span a wide range between 18
000 and 140
000 M−1 cm−1, with 2-nitrobenzene and thiophene-containing sulfonyl amino DASAs 16 and 22 showing significant variation. The low molar absorption coefficient of 2-nitrobenzene sulfonyl amino DASA 16 is thought to arise from an ortho-steric effect that also impacts amino DASAs 19 and 23. In contrast, sulfonyl amino DASA 22 contains a polarizable sulfur atom in the thiophene unit, which is known to increase molar absorption coefficients.58
Solvatochromic slope values, quantifying charge distribution in the conjugated A form, were derived from normalized Dimroth–Reichardt ETN parameters59,60 and range between −6 and −20 nm. A steeper slope from increased solvatochromism is consistent with increased push–pull character. The slopes reflect a predominantly hybrid character with minimal charge confinement, consistent with second-generation hydroxy DASAs, and showcase the ability to fine-tune within the hybrid zone through sulfonyl group modifications. This is significant since current modifications in donor or acceptor units typically lead to large changes in charge separation. A general trend is observed (Fig. 3C) wherein sulfonyl amino DASAs containing electron neutral or donating groups on the sulfonyl, such as 6–9, exhibit lower slopes between −6 and −9 nm, consistent with lower charge separation. Conversely, sulfonyl amino DASAs containing strong electron withdrawing groups on the sulfonyl generally display larger solvatochromic slopes, such as −19 nm for 4-cyanobenzenesulfonyl amino DASA 18, indicating enhanced zwitterionic character in the conjugated A form. The electronic effects of sulfonyl substituents on solvatochromic slope and molar absorption coefficient of amino DASAs were also explored for future predictability by plotting Hammett substituent constants (σ)61 against these properties. Although strong correlations (R2 > 0.9) are not observed, the data reveal a qualitative trend (Fig. 3D). A larger, more positive Hammett constant is associated with both a higher molar absorption coefficient and a larger absolute solvatochromic slope value. Therefore, in the absence of ortho-steric effects, increasing electron withdrawing strength of the sulfonyl substituent only modestly leads to increased light absorptivity and greater A-form zwitterionic character.
The stable switching of cyano-substituted DASA 18 warranted subsequent combinatorial studies with varying donors and acceptors. For donor evaluation, maintaining the N,N-dimethyl barbituric acid acceptor (Fig. 4B), we assessed 4-cyanobenzenesulfonamide DASAs composed of unsubstituted indoline 18, 5-methoxyindoline 26, 5-fluoroindoline 27, and isoindoline 28. Isomer distribution values, per consumption of λmax, between 2 and 26% were observed at PSS under 590 nm LED irradiation in toluene. Electron withdrawing substituents on the donor result in larger decreases in λmax intensity under irradiation than donating groups, with isoindoline producing the lowest conversion. We reason that greater partial negative charge in the acceptor carbonyl, further verified by solvatochromic slopes, renders the acceptor carbonyl a stronger hydrogen-bond acceptor. This in turn strengthens the H-bond interaction and reduces switching efficiency in amino DASAs. Together, we conclude that an amino photoswitch with a weaker donor and/or acceptor, resulting in decreased charge separation in the A form, per solvatochromic analysis, will result in increased λmax consumption under irradiation. Attempts at weakening the interaction from the donor compartment were limited by failed pyrrole rearrangements when using highly electron withdrawn nucleophiles, such as 5-nitroindoline.
Using unsubstituted indoline as the donor, an acceptor evaluation revealed that highly withdrawing acceptors, such as trifluoromethyl pyrazolone in sulfonyl amino DASA 29, hamper λmax consumption under irradiation (Fig. 4C). We then sought to weaken the H-bond accepting capacity of the carbonyl units in the acceptor through extended conjugation and by removal of donating heteroatoms. As such, we synthesized 1,3-indandione-containing sulfonyl amino DASA 30, which provides a λmax decay of 49% in toluene under irradiation, consistent with our hydrogen-bonding hypothesis. Though faster in dichloromethane (see SI Fig. 120), full reversion is observed for amino DASA 30 in both toluene (31 minutes) and dichloromethane (45 seconds). Faster reversion in dichloromethane compared to toluene is consistent with prior studies demonstrating that this effect is attributable to the use of an arylamine donor.43,44,62 Amino DASA 30 with the 1,3-indandione acceptor exhibits an unusual solvatochromic slope of 3 nm and increased stability under irradiation, decreasing <1% in λmax intensity after 10 minutes of irradiation, while the hydroxy DASA equivalent undergoes irreversible consumption upon irradiation.44 These variations demonstrate a synergistic effect between the donor, acceptor, and sulfonyl groups in tuning DASA properties through modifications of intramolecular H-bonding interactions, molecular charge distribution, and the HOMO–LUMO gap. As a result of increased compound stability under irradiation with 4-cyanobenzenesulfonamide, optimal λmax decay with a 1,3-indandione acceptor, and increased reversion rate in dichloromethane, we conducted a cycling study of amino DASA 30 in dichloromethane (Fig. 4D). As expected, little to no fatigue was observed over nine cycles with 45 seconds of irradiation followed by 45 seconds of recovery, further highlighting the increased stability and function of sulfonyl amino DASAs. Overall, sulfonyl evaluation enabled the creation of DASA 30 which sets the record for amino DASA distribution at the PSS, photoswitches and fully recovers rapidly in dichloromethane, showcases solvent versatility with photoswitching and full recovery in toluene, and shows little to no fatigue in both solvents.
:
0.05 to a 1
:
0.78 ratio at 11.0 ppm without the formation of an upfield signal between 10.3–8.0 ppm corresponding to the EEE isomer, 30B′. Furthermore, an apparent C4–H triplet consistent with EZZ isomer 30B formation appears near 6.29 ppm. In addition to not observing signals for EEE isomer 30B′, the EZE (30B″) and cyclic (30C) isomers are not observed. The 1
:
0.78 ratio represents a 44% conversion, which is close to the 37% distribution established under UV-vis conditions in dichloromethane (see SI Fig. 120). The slight deviation between UV-vis λmax depletion studies and NMR studies may be a result of concentration effects or experimental setup. The 1H NMR spectra at 278 K preceding and following in situ irradiation studies confirm thermal reversion to the A form. Critically, this analysis was reproduced with lower conversion but consistent A to B isomerization results for sulfonyl amino DASA 18 containing N,N-dimethyl barbituric acid as the acceptor (see SI Fig. 125, 126, and 134), underscoring that the A to single-B switching is a sulfonyl effect as opposed to a 1,3-indandione effect. Amino DASA 18 formed a ratio of 1
:
0.06 under in situ irradiative, low-temperature NMR conditions at 208 K in CD2Cl2 using 590 nm LED irradiation. None of the remaining compounds were evaluated by NMR due to lower isomerization efficiencies, lower stabilities, or both. Attempts to prepare 1,3-indandione-derived amino DASAs bearing 3-pyridyl or 1-naphthyl sulfonyl groups failed because the respective pyrrole substrates did not undergo the desired rearrangement. Such efforts remain interesting future directions.
:
51 (B : A) isomer distribution at the photostationary state with rapid and full thermal recovery in dichloromethane (45 seconds) and with little to no fatigue over 9 cycles. An amino DASA record isomeric distribution under irradiation was achieved by decreasing the strength of the hydrogen-bond interaction with the use of 1,3-indandione as the acceptor unit. Although thermal reversion is slower in toluene (31 minutes), the optimal amino DASA shows great solvent versatility with full reversion in toluene. Together, these advances enabled the characterization, by UV-vis spectroscopy and low-temperature NMR spectroscopy, of the distinct A to single-B (EEZ A to EZZ B) isomer photoswitching about the C3–C4 bond without forming the traditional cyclic or other acyclic isomers. Sulfonyl substituents were also found to modulate molar absorption coefficients and structural charge distribution in a manner that broadly follows Hammett substituent constants with modest correlations, thereby providing qualitative guidance for application-specific molecular design. This mode of selective conjugated-to-conjugated switching is of interest for DASA incorporation in smart materials and the EZZ B isomer presents an opportunity to develop light-initiated, site-selective reactivity by arranging the donor near the sulfonyl fragment upon switching.
010 for “Photoresponsive Compounds”. Specifically, this patent claims the use of our synthetic route for amino DASAs, amino DASAs themselves, and the predictive tool based on carbon NMR for DASA preparation. E. P., C. A. Reyes, and H. L. declare no further competing interests and A. K., A. T. G. K., C. A. Ramsperger, and K. B. declare no competing interests.
Footnote |
| † These authors contributed equally to this work. |
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2026 |