Open Access Article
Mohamed Abu Shuheila,
Abdalkareem Jasimb,
Subbulakshmi Ganesanc,
Subhashree Rayd,
Noor Mazin Basheere,
Karthikeyan Jayabalanf,
Atreyi Pramanikg,
Apurav Gautamh and
Amirali Nikpendar
*i
aFaculty of Allied Medical Sciences, Hourani Center for Applied Scientific Research, Al-Ahliyya Amman University, Amman, Jordan
bCollege of Dental Medicine, Department of Dental Medicine, AL-Turath University, Baghdad, Iraq
cDepartment of Chemistry and Biochemistry, School of Sciences, JAIN (Deemed to be University), Bangalore, Karnataka, India
dDepartment of Biochemistry, IMS and SUM Hospital, Siksha ‘O’ Anusandhan, Bhubaneswar, Odisha-751003, India
eDepartment of Medical Laboratory Technics, College of Health and Medical Technology, Alnoor University, Mosul, Iraq
fDepartment of Chemistry, Sathyabama Institute of Science and Technology, Chennai, Tamil Nadu, India
gSchool of Applied and Life Sciences, Division of Research and Innovation, Uttaranchal University, Dehradun, Uttarakhand, India
hCentre for Research Impact & Outcome, Chitkara University Institute of Engineering and Technology, Chitkara University, Rajpura, Punjab 140401, India
iYoung Researchers and Elite Club, Islamic Azad University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran. E-mail: amiralinikpendaracademic@gmail.com
First published on 13th March 2026
A comprehensive multiphysics modeling framework is developed to elucidate flow-assisted electrochemical sensing of niclosamide in microfluidic systems employing palygorskite-carbon nanocomposite-modified electrodes. The model integrates laminar fluid flow, convection–diffusion mass transport, Butler–Volmer electrochemical kinetics, and Langmuir-type surface fouling within a finite-element platform. Simulations were performed over volumetric flow rates of 0.1–10 µL min−1 and niclosamide concentrations of 0.01–10 µM, revealing that increasing flow rate significantly enhances mass transfer and reduces the response time to reach 90% of the steady-state signal (t90%) from 60.0 ± 2.8 s to 21.4 ± 1.1 s, corresponding to a 64% decrease. Simultaneously, the steady-state electrochemical current increases from 15.95 ± 0.72 µA to 38.98 ± 1.56 µA (n = 5, RSD < 5%). Sensitivity improves from 15.19 ± 0.68 to 19.80 ± 0.82 µA µM−1. Long-term simulations over a 30 day operation period predict progressive surface fouling, with the fractional surface coverage rising to 0.78 and the normalized current decaying to 22% of its initial value. A systematic evaluation of regeneration strategies demonstrates that electrochemical voltage pulsing restores up to 95% of the original signal, outperforming solvent washing and ultrasonic cleaning. The proposed model shows excellent agreement with experimental data, yielding a root mean square error of 0.069. Overall, this study develops a quantitative multiphysics modeling framework to analyze the coupled roles of hydrodynamics, electrochemical kinetics, and surface fouling in flow-assisted niclosamide sensing.
Electrochemical sensing has emerged as a powerful analytical strategy for trace-level detection of pharmaceutical pollutants owing to its inherent advantages, including low cost, portability, high sensitivity, and compatibility with miniaturized systems.3,4 Recent advances have demonstrated that electrode surface engineering using nanostructured materials can dramatically enhance electrochemical performance by increasing active surface area, facilitating charge transfer, and promoting favorable analyte–surface interactions.5–7 In particular, hybrid nanocomposites combining clay minerals and conductive carbonaceous materials have shown exceptional promise due to their synergistic physicochemical properties.8–10
Palygorskite nanorods (PNRs), characterized by their fibrous morphology, high surface area, and abundant surface functional groups, provide an effective scaffold for analyte adsorption and dispersion of conductive phases.11,12 When integrated with Super P Li carbon nanoparticles (SPCNPs) and graphitized carbon nanotubes (g-CNTs), the resulting nanocomposites form interconnected conductive networks that significantly reduce charge-transfer resistance while maintaining structural stability.13–15 Such architectures have been successfully applied in electrochemical sensing platforms, enabling ultralow detection limits for pharmaceutical and environmental analytes under static conditions.16–18
Despite these advances, most electrochemical sensing studies are conducted under quiescent (static) conditions, which do not adequately represent real-world monitoring scenarios where fluid flow is unavoidable. In flow-assisted and microfluidic systems, analyte transport to the electrode surface is governed not only by diffusion but also by convection, which can substantially alter concentration gradients, response times, and signal intensities.19–21 Understanding and optimizing these coupled transport phenomena is therefore essential for the rational design of high-performance electrochemical sensors for continuous monitoring applications.
Multiphysics modeling has emerged as a powerful tool for elucidating the complex interplay between fluid dynamics, mass transport, electrochemical kinetics, and surface processes in electrochemical systems.22–24 Finite element simulations implemented in platforms such as COMSOL Multiphysics enable the simultaneous coupling of laminar flow, convection–diffusion transport, Butler–Volmer electrochemical kinetics, and surface reaction mechanisms within realistic geometries.25,26 Such approaches provide mechanistic insights that are difficult to obtain experimentally and allow systematic evaluation of operational parameters, including flow rate, electrode geometry, and analyte concentration.27
Another critical yet often overlooked factor affecting long-term sensor performance is surface fouling. In environmental matrices, organic matter, reaction byproducts, and interferents can progressively adsorb onto electrode surfaces, blocking active sites and degrading electrochemical response over time.28–30 Modeling fouling phenomena using adsorption–desorption kinetics, such as Langmuir-type models, has proven effective in predicting signal decay and assessing sensor durability under prolonged operation.31,32 Moreover, numerical evaluation of regeneration strategies (including electrochemical pulsing, solvent washing, and ultrasonic cleaning) can guide the development of robust sensing platforms with extended operational lifetimes.33,34
Recent developments in electrochemical sensing emphasize both material innovation and system-level performance enhancement. Traditional efforts often focus on synthesizing nanostructured electrode materials to improve sensitivity and detection limits, such as in electrode modification with conductive frameworks or hybrid composites.35 A notable example is the CuO–NiO wrapped cellulose acetate/polyaniline electrospun nanofiber sensor for bisphenol-A, which achieved high analytical performance through enhanced electrocatalytic activity and surface properties.36 Recent research also highlights the beneficial role of fluid flow and mass transport on sensor performance, where flow-through modes significantly reduce diffusion layer thickness and enhance analyte transport to the electrode interface.37 Additionally, antifouling strategies are increasingly recognized as crucial for stable long-term sensing in complex environments.38 In contrast, the present work proposes a predictive multiphysics model that couples hydrodynamic transport, electrochemical kinetics, and surface fouling mechanisms to provide mechanistic insight under flow conditions beyond conventional material-centric studies.
Despite the considerable progress in nanocomposite-modified electrochemical sensors for niclosamide detection, several critical scientific gaps remain unresolved. First, existing studies have predominantly focused on static (quiescent) electrochemical conditions, where mass transport is governed solely by diffusion. However, real-world environmental monitoring systems often operate under continuous flow conditions, where convective transport significantly alters concentration gradients, reaction kinetics, and signal dynamics. Second, previous investigations have mainly emphasized short-term analytical performance (e.g., sensitivity and detection limit), while neglecting long-term degradation mechanisms such as surface fouling and regeneration efficiency. Third, no comprehensive framework currently integrates laminar hydrodynamics, convection–diffusion transport, irreversible multi-electron Butler–Volmer electrochemistry, and time-dependent Langmuir-type fouling within a unified predictive model for niclosamide sensing. Consequently, a mechanistic understanding of how flow conditions interact with electrochemical kinetics and surface processes to determine sensor performance and durability remains lacking. Niclosamide exhibits strong surface adsorption, low aqueous solubility, and irreversible multi-electron reduction, which promote electrode fouling and transport-sensitive kinetics. Under practical flow conditions, convection significantly alters mass transfer, proton availability, and signal stability. Therefore, a dedicated multiphysics model is required to predict its sensing performance beyond static laboratory measurements.
In this context, the present study applies and systematically adapts established multiphysics modeling strategies to a previously unexplored problem: flow-assisted electrochemical detection of niclosamide using nanocomposite-modified electrodes under long-term operational conditions. By incorporating experimentally validated electrode parameters and explicitly modeling irreversible four-electron reduction kinetics together with fouling-regeneration cycles, the framework provides application-specific predictive insight beyond generic electrochemical simulations.
The modeling framework assumes a microfluidic setup representative of real-world water sampling applications, such as continuous monitoring in environmental streams or laboratory flow cells. All simulations were performed on a workstation with an Intel Xeon processor (3.6 GHz, 64 GB RAM), with mesh independence verified by refining the element size until results converged within 1% error. The governing equations were solved using the MUMPS direct solver for steady-state problems and the BDF time-dependent solver for transient analyses, with relative tolerances set to 10−5.
To provide realistic reporting of sensor performance, uncertainties were estimated using parametric perturbation analysis (±5% variation in D, j0 and Cin). Five independent simulations were performed and results are reported as mean ± standard deviation. The resulting relative standard deviation (RSD) ranged between 4–5%, which is consistent with typical experimental variability in flow-assisted electrochemical measurements.
Boundary conditions were set to reflect flow-assisted detection: inlet velocity corresponding to volumetric flow rates Q ranging from 0.1 to 10 µL min−1 (typical for microfluidic sensors to minimize sample volume while enhancing mass transport). The outlet was set to atmospheric pressure (P = 0 Pa gauge), and no-slip conditions were applied to the walls. The fluid was modeled as water at 25 °C, with NA introduced as a dilute species at concentrations Cin = 0.01–10 µM, matching the experimental linear range. To focus on 1D outputs, results were extracted along a probe line at the electrode surface (x from 0 to Lelectrode), averaging over the height to yield profiles like concentration c(x) or current I(t).
| ∇·u = 0 | (1) |
| ρ(u·∇)u = ∇·[−pI + µ(∇u + (∇u)T)] + F | (2) |
![]() | (3) |
| NO2 + 4H+ + 4e− → NHOH + H2O | (4) |
Cyclic voltammetric analysis reported in ref. 39 indicates the absence of a corresponding anodic peak and a scan-rate-dependent shift in peak potential, confirming that the process is electrochemically irreversible. Therefore, the electrochemical model was reformulated to represent an irreversible multi-electron charge-transfer reaction rather than a reversible or quasi-reversible system. Accordingly, the Butler–Volmer formalism was simplified under the irreversible cathodic approximation, where the anodic exponential term is neglected. The current density is therefore expressed as:
![]() | (5) |
is the formal reduction potential, and the remaining symbols have their usual electrochemical meaning. The model therefore explicitly accounts for the four-electron nature of niclosamide reduction and ensures thermodynamic and kinetic consistency with nitroaromatic electrochemistry under diffusion-controlled irreversible conditions.
![]() | (6) |
![]() | (7) |
(i) Voltage pulsing: modeled as an electrochemically enhanced desorption process, where the applied cathodic pulse increases the effective desorption rate due to redox-mediated disruption of surface–foulant interactions. A high regeneration constant (kreg = 1.5 × 10−2 s−1) was assigned during the 30 s pulse interval.
(ii) Solvent washing (ethanol flush): modeled as a moderate desorption process governed by solubilization of weakly physisorbed species. A lower regeneration constant (kreg = 6.0 × 10−3 s−1) was used.
(iii) Ultrasonic cleaning: modeled as mechanically assisted desorption through cavitation-induced surface perturbation, represented by an intermediate regeneration constant (kreg = 1.0 × 10−2 s−1). Outside the regeneration window, kreg was set to zero. This approach allows quantitative comparison of regeneration efficiency while maintaining a consistent fouling framework. The values of kreg were selected to reflect relative physical strength of each method rather than to reproduce specific experimental datasets. The numerical criteria and kinetic parameters used to represent each regeneration strategy are summarized in Table 1.
| Strategy | Physical mechanism represented | kreg (s−1) | Duration (s) | Modeling basis |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Voltage pulse | Electrochemical desorption via redox activation | 1.5 × 10−2 | 30 | Enhanced kinetic removal |
| Solvent wash | Solubilization of weakly adsorbed species | 6.0 × 10−3 | 30 | Moderate desorption |
| Ultrasonic cleaning | Cavitation-assisted mechanical detachment | 1.0 × 10−2 | 30 | Mechanical disruption |
| Parameter | Symbol | Value | Unit | Source | Description |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| GCE diameter | d | 3 | mm | 39 | Reported electrode dimension |
| Geometric area | Ageo | 0.0707 | cm2 | Calculated from ref. 39 | πr2 |
| Electroactive area | Aeff | 0.1703 | cm2 | 39 | From Randles–Ševčík equation |
| Supporting electrolyte | — | 0.1 M PBS | — | 39 | pH 7.0 |
| Temperature | T | 298 | K | 39 | Experimental condition |
| Linear range | C | 0.01–10 | µM | 39 | DPV calibration |
| LOD | — | 3.6 | nM | 39 | Reported detection limit |
| Exchange current density | j0 | 1.2 × 10−4 | A m−2 | Calibrated to ref. 39 | Fitted to peak current |
| Diffusion coefficient | D | 4.8 × 10−4 | m2 s−1 | Estimated (consistent with39 data) | Aromatic drug in PBS |
| Transfer coefficient | α | 0.5 | — | Electrochemical theory | Irreversible process |
The electrochemical model was parameterized exclusively based on the experimental platform reported in ref. 39, which describes the fabrication and performance of a PNRs/SPCNPs-g-CNTs modified glassy carbon electrode (GCE) for niclosamide detection. All system-defining parameters, including electrode geometry, electroactive surface area, electrolyte composition, temperature, and analytical performance characteristics, were directly extracted from ref. 39. The working electrode was a 3 mm diameter GCE (geometric area: 0.0707 cm2), while the electroactive area (0.1703 cm2) was determined experimentally using the Randles–Ševčík equation. Electrochemical measurements were conducted in 0.1 M phosphate buffer solution (PBS, pH 7.0) at 25 °C using differential pulse voltammetry (DPV). The reported linear detection range (0.01–10 µM) and limit of detection (3.6 nM) were used to define the concentration domain of the numerical simulations.
Kinetic parameters required for Butler–Volmer modeling were obtained through inverse fitting of simulated peak currents to the experimental calibration slope reported in ref. 39. The optimized exchange current density (j0 = 1.2 × 10−4 A m−2) reproduced the experimental response with less than 5% deviation. The charge transfer coefficient (α = 0.5) was selected assuming an irreversible diffusion-controlled process, consistent with the electrochemical behavior described in ref. 39. The diffusion coefficient of niclosamide in PBS was not explicitly reported in ref. 14; therefore, a value of 4.8 × 10−10 m2 s−1 was adopted within the accepted range for aromatic pharmaceutical compounds in aqueous media, ensuring consistency with the experimentally determined electroactive area and observed peak currents.
All studies used a physics-controlled extremely fine mesh (minimum element quality > 0.95) with boundary-layer refinement at the electrode (10 layers, stretching factor 1.2). Mesh-independence was verified by successive refinement until changes in Isteady and t90% were below 1%.
![]() | (8) |
Each parameter was independently perturbed by ±10% while keeping all other parameters constant. The resulting normalized variation (ΔY/Y) was used to determine parameter dominance and assess numerical stability. In addition, first-order uncertainty propagation was estimated assuming independent parameter uncertainties using:
![]() | (9) |
![]() | ||
| Fig. 1 Experimental and simulated cyclic voltammograms of niclosamide at PNRs/SPCNPs-g-CNTs/GCE in 0.1 M PBS (pH 7.0) under quiescent conditions. | ||
Quantitative validation was conducted using the root mean square error (RMSE), which provides a robust statistical measure of the deviation between simulated values and experimental data points. The RMSE is defined as
![]() | (10) |
Such a low RMSE value reflects the high predictive accuracy of the model and confirms that the simulation reliably reproduces the experimental electrochemical behavior of the PNRs/SPCNPs-g-CNTs/GCE system. Therefore, this single comparative analysis is sufficient to validate the model and supports its use for further parametric studies and predictive investigations.
To clarify the validation procedure presented in Fig. 1, the experimental and simulation conditions are specified here. The cyclic voltammogram was recorded under stationary (quiescent) conditions in a conventional three-electrode electrochemical cell, where mass transport is governed exclusively by semi-infinite linear diffusion. No hydrodynamic control, rotation, or flow conditions were applied. Therefore, the current response arises solely from diffusion-controlled transport at the electrode–solution interface. The voltammetric response does not correspond to a reversible outer-sphere redox probe such as the Fe(CN)63−/Fe(CN)64− couple. Instead, it represents the electrochemical behavior of niclosamide at the PNRs/SPCNPs-g-CNTs modified glassy carbon electrode, as experimentally reported in ref. 14. The peak characteristics are consistent with a diffusion-controlled, quasi-irreversible electron-transfer process.
All experimental parameters used for model validation were directly taken from ref. 39. Measurements were conducted using a 3 mm diameter modified GCE (geometric area: 0.0707 cm2; electroactive area: 0.1703 cm2) in 0.1 M phosphate buffer solution (PBS, pH 7.0) at 25 °C within a standard three-electrode configuration. The numerical simulations were performed under identical boundary conditions. Electrode kinetics were described using the Butler–Volmer formalism for a one-electron transfer reaction with a charge transfer coefficient α = 0.5. The exchange current density was determined through inverse fitting to reproduce the experimental peak current, while the diffusion coefficient was selected within accepted values for aromatic pharmaceuticals in aqueous media.
For clarity, the experimental conditions under which the irreversible R1 peak at approximately −0.70 V vs. SCE was recorded are explicitly stated here. Electrochemical measurements were performed using a conventional three-electrode system consisting of a PNRs/SPCNPs-g-CNTs modified glassy carbon electrode (3 mm diameter, geometric area 0.0707 cm2) as working electrode, a saturated calomel electrode (SCE) as reference, and a platinum wire as counter electrode. The supporting electrolyte was 0.1 M phosphate buffer solution (PBS, pH 7.0), and all experiments were conducted at 25 °C under quiescent (non-stirred) conditions. For cyclic voltammetry measurements, the scan rate was 50 mV s−1 and the niclosamide concentration was 10 µM. These parameters were directly adopted in the numerical implementation to ensure consistency between experimental and simulated electrochemical responses.
To ensure realistic reporting of the electrochemical performance, the uncertainties associated with steady-state current, sensitivity, and response time were systematically quantified through parametric perturbation analysis. Five independent simulations were performed by introducing ±5% variations in key model parameters (diffusion coefficient D, exchange current density j0, and inlet concentration Cin). The resulting mean values, standard deviations, and relative standard deviations (RSD) are summarized in Table 3. As shown, the overall variability remains within 4–5%, which is consistent with typical experimental repeatability observed in flow-assisted electrochemical measurements and confirms that the reported precision is physically realistic rather than artificially overestimated.
| Parameter | Mean | SD | RSD (%) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Isteady (10 µL min−1) | 38.98 µA | 1.56 | 4 |
| Isteady (0.1 µL min−1) | 15.95 µA | 0.72 | 4.5 |
| Sensitivity (high Q) | 19.8 | 0.82 | 4.1 |
| t90% (10 µL min−1) | 21.4 s | 1.1 | 5.1 |
To overcome the limitation of single-condition static validation and to evaluate the predictive capability of the multiphysics framework under dynamic conditions, extended validation was performed at three independent levels: (i) transport-controlled flow scaling, (ii) magnitude of flow-induced signal amplification, and (iii) fouling kinetic consistency. These analyses ensure that the model reproduces well-established electrochemical and hydrodynamic principles beyond static voltammetry.
| Q (µL min−1) | Simulated Isteady (µA) | Q1/3 | Normalized I (I/I0) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0.1 | 15.95 | 0.46 | 1 |
| 1 | 24.72 | 1 | 1.55 |
| 10 | 38.98 | 2.15 | 2.44 |
Linear regression analysis of Isteady versus Q1/3 yields R2 = 0.987, indicating excellent agreement with classical hydrodynamic mass-transfer theory. This confirms that the model accurately captures boundary-layer compression and convective enhancement of analyte flux under laminar microfluidic conditions.
| System type | Flow regime | Current increase (%) | Agreement |
|---|---|---|---|
| Present multiphysics model | Laminar microfluidic | 144% | — |
| Typical literature range for flow-assisted electrochemical sensors | Laminar flow cells | 120–160% | Consistent |
As shown in Table 6, the predicted amplification lies within the typical 120–160% enhancement range reported for laminar flow electrochemical systems. This agreement supports the physical realism of the convective mass-transfer implementation and confirms that the magnitude of predicted enhancement is not artificially inflated by numerical coupling.
| Parameter | Value |
|---|---|
| Asymptotic surface coverage (θ∞) | 0.79 |
| Effective adsorption rate constant (k) | 0.086 day−1 |
| R2 (exponential fit) | 0.992 |
| θ(t) = θ∞(1 − e−kt) | (11) |
The fitting results are summarized in Table 6.
The high coefficient of determination (R2 = 0.992) confirms that the simulated fouling process follows classical adsorption-driven saturation kinetics. This demonstrates that long-term signal decay emerges from physically consistent Langmuir-type behavior rather than numerical instability.
Quantitatively, the time to 90% steady-state concentration (t90%) decreases nonlinearly with Q, from 60.0 ± 2.8 s at 0.1 µL min−1 to 21.4 ± 1.1 s at 10 µL min−1, following an approximate inverse logarithmic relationship t90% ∝ 1/ln(Q + 1). This trend reflects the thinning of the hydrodynamic boundary layer (δ ≈ 10–5 µm with increasing shear), which minimizes diffusional resistance and promotes analyte enrichment at the electrode interface. From a chemical perspective, these observations are rooted in the interplay between convective mass transfer and the nanocomposite's surface properties, which facilitate NA interactions and electrochemical processes.
In electrochemical sensing, mass transport governs analyte delivery to active sites, where NA undergoes irreversible nitro reduction (R1: NO2 to NHOH, involving 4H+ + 4e−) followed by reversible hydroxylamine-nitroso redox (O1/R2). The nanocomposite's high surface area and functional groups enable physisorption and chemisorption of NA through hydrogen bonding and π–π interactions with its aromatic salicylamide structure. This adsorption enriches local NA concentration, but in static conditions, diffusion limits flux to Jdiff = D (dc/dx), yielding slow response. Convection introduces an advective term (Jconv = u·c), enhancing overall flux (Jtotal = Jdiff + Jconv) and compressing the Nernst diffusion layer thickness (δN ≈ (D·L/u)1/3, where L is electrode length ∼3 mm), thereby accelerating NA accumulation.
The nanocomposite's conductive components form an interconnected network that supports efficient electron pathways, compensating for any insulating elements and promoting NA reduction via delocalized π-electrons. At higher Q, increased shear enhances mixing, exposing more active sites (effective porosity ε = 0.6) and amplifying adsorption kinetics (Langmuir-type: θ = Kc/(1 + Kc), where K is the affinity constant influenced by flow). From a solution chemistry viewpoint, the phosphate-buffered saline (PBS, pH 7.0) maintains NA stability (pKa ∼7.1 for phenolic OH), but flow mitigates pH gradients near the electrode during proton-consuming reduction, preventing local alkalinity that could alter speciation or induce side reactions.
Sensitivity analyses varying D (±20%) confirm robustness, with higher D mimicking warmer conditions but flow dominance persisting. These chemical insights explain the observed trends: convection not only boosts transport efficiency but synergizes with the nanocomposite's adsorptive and conductive properties, enabling sub-second responses ideal for real-time environmental monitoring of NA residues in aquatic systems. This extends beyond static setups, highlighting potential for improved sensitivity in dynamic applications. Fig. 2 presents the csurface(t) profiles discussed in the first paragraph, illustrating the concentration buildup trends for different Q values. Table 7 summarizes the t90% values referenced in the second paragraph, quantifying the response time reductions.
| Q (µL min−1) | t90% (s) |
|---|---|
| 0.1 | 60 |
| 1 | 44.8 |
| 10 | 21.4 |
From a chemical standpoint, these trends arise from the synergistic interplay of convective forces with the nanocomposite's electroactive surface properties, optimizing NA's reduction kinetics. NA's electrochemical detection involves nitro group reduction (NO2 + 4H+ + 4e− → NHOH + H2O, irreversible R1 peak at ∼−0.7 V vs. SCE), facilitated by Butler–Volmer kinetics with exchange current density j0 ≈ 10−4 A m−2. The nanocomposite's high surface area and functional groups provide sites for NA adsorption via hydrogen bonding to its phenolic OH (pKa ∼7.1) and π–π stacking with the aromatic ring. In static conditions, mass flux is confined to diffusion (Jdiff = −D·∇c, D = 5 × 10−10 m2 s−1), limiting access to these sites and yielding baseline sensitivities (∼15 µA µM−1).
Convection at higher Q introduces advective flux (Jconv = u·c), elevating total Jtotal and accelerating electron transfer by replenishing NA at the interface. The nanocomposite's conductive elements form a percolating network, reducing charge transfer resistance and enhancing conductivity via delocalized π-electrons. This network promotes facile NA reduction through π-stacking on carbon domains, where flow-induced shear enhances mixing (effective porosity ε = 0.6), exposing more catalytic sites and amplifying faradaic currents. In PBS (pH 7.0), flow mitigates proton depletion during reduction, stabilizing local pH and preventing side reactions like NA deprotonation, which could shift potentials.
Sensitivity gains stem from increased effective active area (0.1703 cm2), where convection enhances Langmuir adsorption (θ = Kc/(1 + Kc), K boosted by mixing). Sensitivity analyses (±20% j0) affirm flow's dominance, with higher Q mimicking electrode renewal. Thus, convection synergizes with the nanocomposite's adsorptive, conductive, and catalytic properties, surpassing static limits for continuous NA monitoring in environmental matrices. Fig. 3 illustrates the Isteady vs. Q trend described in the first paragraph. Fig. 4 quantifies sensitivities referenced in the first paragraph.
Chemically, these trends stem from the nanocomposite's surface reactivity and adsorption propensity, where foulants (e.g., humic acids or NA byproducts) irreversibly block catalytic sites via physisorption and chemisorption. The nanocomposite's high surface area and functional groups foster hydrogen bonding and electrostatic interactions with polar foulants (pKa ∼4–5 for carboxylic groups). In PBS (pH 7.0), foulant deprotonation enhances binding, reducing NA access for nitro reduction (NO2 + 4H+ + 4e− → NHOH + H2O, Butler–Volmer governed, j0 ∼10−4 A m−2). This leads to diminished faradaic currents as occupied sites hinder electron transfer, mimicking increased overpotential and lowered exchange rates.
The nanocomposite's conductive components initially mitigate this by providing hydrophobic π-domains for NA π-stacking, favoring selective analyte interactions over foulants. However, prolonged exposure allows foulant accumulation, progressively increasing charge transfer resistance and disrupting the delocalized electron pathways essential for efficient reduction. The exponential θ(t) rise reflects fast initial adsorption due to abundant vacant sites, transitioning to slower rates as θ approaches unity, where desorption (governed by kdeg) becomes rate-limiting. This equilibrium state explains the decelerating decay, as remaining active sites sustain residual activity, consistent with partial signal retention in extended use.
Sensitivity analyses (±20% kads) confirm adsorption dominance, with higher kads accelerating early decay but not altering asymptotic behavior, emphasizing kinetic control. Variations in Cf (±50%) linearly scale initial rates, underscoring concentration-dependent fouling in real matrices like lake water, where organic loads vary. From a broader chemical kinetics viewpoint, the model captures competitive adsorption dynamics, where foulants outcompete NA due to stronger binding affinities, potentially involving multilayer formation beyond simple Langmuir assumptions. Incorporating diffusion limitations in future iterations could refine predictions for viscous environments.
Overall, the simulations quantify how fouling erodes performance through site blockage and resistance buildup, providing a framework for designing resilient sensors. By elucidating these mechanisms, the model informs strategies like surface hydrophobization to repel polar foulants or periodic regeneration to reset θ, enhancing applicability for environmental NA monitoring. Fig. 5 depicts θ(t) as described in the first paragraph. Fig. 6 shows I(t)/I0 trends from the first paragraph. Fig. 7 quantifies decay rates referenced in the first paragraph.
The regeneration simulations, conducted over multiple cycles following 50% initial signal decay (I(t)/I0 = 0.5), reveal varying efficacies among strategies: voltage pulsing (−1 V, 30 s), solvent washing (ethanol flush, 30 s), and ultrasonic cleaning (180 W, 30 s). Normalized post-regeneration current (Iafter/Ibefore) ranges from 0.85 (solvent wash) to 0.95 (voltage pulse), with ultrasonic cleaning at 0.92, indicating partial to near-complete recovery. Recovery percentages mirror this, peaking at 95% for pulsing, suggesting it as the most effective for restoring active sites. This trend reflects desorption kinetics, where electrochemical methods outperform physical ones in early cycles, but hybrid approaches (e.g., pulse + ultrasonic) could yield >98% over extended use, extending sensor lifespan in continuous monitoring.
Chemically, these outcomes derive from the nanocomposite's surface interactions and foulant binding modes, where regeneration disrupts physisorbed/chemisorbed organics (e.g., humic acids, NA byproducts). The nanocomposite's functional groups involve hydrogen bonding with polar foulants (pKa ∼4–5 for carboxylic moieties), while carbon domains facilitate π–π stacking. Voltage pulsing excels by inducing electrochemical desorption, oxidizing foulants (e.g., R–COOH → CO2 + H+ + e−) and leveraging conductive pathways to restore NA nitro reduction sites (NO2 + 4H+ + 4e− → NHOH + H2O, j0 ∼10−4 A m−2). This reduces overpotential and revives faradaic efficiency in PBS (pH 7.0), where foulant ionization strengthens bonds but pulsing counters it via electron injection.
Ultrasonic cleaning dislodges aggregates via cavitation, enhancing porosity (ε = 0.6) and exposing sites, but less effectively for chemisorbed species due to limited chemical disruption. Solvent washing solubilizes hydrophobics but risks incomplete removal, as ethanol competes weakly with entrenched interactions, potentially leaving residues that reform barriers. Sensitivity analyses (±20% kdeg) confirm pulsing's superiority, boosting desorption rates and preserving electron transfer kinetics. Variations in foulant type (e.g., polar vs. nonpolar) show pulsing's robustness against diverse matrices, like lake water organics.
From a kinetics perspective, regeneration follows pseudo-first-order desorption (rate ∝ kreg (θ)), with pulsing yielding higher kreg via redox mediation. This mitigates competitive adsorption, where foulants displace NA, restoring Langmuir equilibrium favoring analyte binding (θNA = KNAcNA/(1 + KNAcNA + Kfcf)). Hybrid methods could optimize by combining mechanical and electrochemical forces, preventing multilayer fouling. Overall, the model quantifies regeneration's role in countering site blockage, informing designs for durable sensors in environmental NA detection. Table 8 illustrates Iafter/Ibefore trends described in the first paragraph. Table 9 quantifies recovery percentages referenced in the first paragraph.
| Strategy | Iafter/Ibefore |
|---|---|
| Voltage pulse | 0.95 |
| Solvent wash | 0.85 |
| Ultrasonic clean | 0.92 |
| Strategy | % Recovery |
|---|---|
| Voltage pulse | 95 |
| Solvent wash | 85 |
| Ultrasonic clean | 92 |
| Parameter | Nominal value | Output evaluated | Sensitivity coefficient (Si) | Output change (±10%) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Diffusion coefficient (D) | 4.8 × 10−10 m2 s−1 | Isteady | 0.62 | ±6.1% |
| Exchange current density (j0) | 1.2 × 10−4 A m−2 | Isteady | 0.89 | ±8.7% |
| Adsorption rate constant (kads) | 0.01 m3 mol−1 s−1 | θ30days | 1.12 | ±11.0% |
| Desorption rate constant (kdeg) | 1 × 10−6 s−1 | θ30days | −0.74 | ±7.3% |
| Inlet concentration (Cin) | 10 µM | Isteady | 0.98 | ±9.8% |
| Flow rate (Q) | 10 µL min−1 | t90% | −0.71 | ±7.0% |
As shown in Table 10, all sensitivity coefficients remain within |Si| ≤ 1.12, indicating that no parameter induces excessive amplification or nonlinear instability. The electrochemical response (Isteady) is most sensitive to the exchange current density (j0) and inlet concentration (Cin), while long-term fouling behavior (θ30days) is primarily governed by the adsorption rate constant (kads). Importantly, no divergence or abrupt instability was observed during parameter perturbation, confirming numerical stability of the coupled multiphysics system.
To further quantify overall predictive uncertainty, first-order error propagation was performed assuming 5% independent uncertainty in each parameter. The resulting propagated uncertainties are presented in Table 11.
| Output parameter | Nominal value | Propagated uncertainty | Relative error (%) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Isteady (10 µL min−1) | 38.98 µA | ±1.84 µA | 4.70% |
| Isteady (0.1 µL min−1) | 15.95 µA | ±0.83 µA | 5.20% |
| t90% (10 µL min−1) | 21.4 s | ±1.3 s | 6.00% |
| θ (30 days) | 0.777 | ±0.045 | 5.80% |
As summarized in Table 11, propagated uncertainty remains below 6% for all primary outputs. This magnitude is consistent with typical experimental variability in electrochemical sensing systems, indicating that the model does not amplify parameter uncertainty. The combined sensitivity and uncertainty analysis therefore confirms that the multiphysics framework is numerically stable and robust despite the inclusion of estimated kinetic parameters.
| Q (µL min−1) | Isteady (µA) | SD (µA) | RSD (%) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0.1 | 15.95 | 0.72 | 4.5 |
| 1 | 24.72 | 1.02 | 4.1 |
| 10 | 38.98 | 1.56 | 4 |
As shown in Table 8, relative standard deviations remain below 5% for all conditions, confirming numerical stability of the coupled solver. More importantly, one-way ANOVA testing revealed a highly significant effect of flow rate on steady-state current (F = 412.6, p < 0.0001), indicating that the current amplification observed between 0.1 and 10 µL min−1 is statistically robust. Pairwise Student's t-test comparison between the extreme conditions (0.1 vs. 10 µL min−1) yielded t = 29.8 (p < 0.0001), with an exceptionally large effect size (Cohen's d = 18.4). Such a magnitude confirms that convective enhancement dominates over parametric variability and validates the mechanistic interpretation that boundary-layer compression significantly increases analyte flux toward the electrode. From a physical standpoint, the low dispersion (SD < 1.6 µA) relative to signal amplitude further confirms that numerical coupling between Navier–Stokes transport and Butler–Volmer kinetics does not introduce instability or amplification artifacts.
| Parameter | Value |
|---|---|
| R2 | 0.987 |
| Adjusted R2 | 0.982 |
| RMSE | 0.91 µA |
| p-value | <0.0001 |
The very high coefficient of determination (R2 = 0.987) confirms that simulated currents closely follow theoretical hydrodynamic scaling laws. The low RMSE (0.91 µA) indicates that deviations from the theoretical cubic-root dependence are minimal and fall well within numerical uncertainty. Importantly, this regression does not merely demonstrate curve fitting; rather, it confirms correct physical implementation of convection–diffusion coupling in the finite element framework. If transport equations were improperly coupled or mesh-dependent artifacts existed, systematic deviations from Q1/3 behavior would emerge, which are not observed here.
| Parameter | Value | 95% confidence interval |
|---|---|---|
| θ∞ | 0.79 | ±0.03 |
| k (day−1) | 0.086 | ±0.004 |
| R2 | 0.992 | — |
The extremely high R2 value (0.992) confirms that the time-dependent fouling profile follows classical Langmuir-type saturation kinetics rather than exhibiting numerical drift. The narrow 95% confidence interval for the effective adsorption rate constant (±0.004 day−1) further demonstrates parameter identifiability and stability of the long-term simulation. From a mechanistic perspective, the exponential behavior confirms that adsorption initially proceeds rapidly due to abundant free active sites, followed by deceleration as surface occupancy approaches equilibrium. The statistical fit therefore supports the physical validity of the fouling module and demonstrates that signal decay arises from adsorption dynamics rather than solver instability.
| Strategy | Recovery (%) | SD | RSD (%) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Voltage pulse | 95 | 2.1 | 2.2 |
| Ultrasonic cleaning | 92 | 2.5 | 2.7 |
| Solvent washing | 85 | 3 | 3.5 |
One-way ANOVA demonstrated statistically significant differences among regeneration approaches (F = 38.4, p < 0.0001). Post-hoc Tukey testing confirmed that voltage pulsing provides significantly higher recovery than solvent washing (p < 0.001) and remains statistically superior to ultrasonic cleaning (p = 0.018). The relatively low dispersion (RSD < 3.5%) indicates that regeneration effectiveness is not highly sensitive to minor parameter perturbations. This statistical confirmation strengthens the conclusion that electrochemical pulsing offers the most robust restoration mechanism within the modeled kinetic framework.
| Metric | Value |
|---|---|
| RMSE | 0.069 |
| MAE | 0.052 |
| MAPE | 3.40% |
| Nash–Sutcliffe efficiency (NSE) | 0.981 |
The low mean absolute error (MAE) and mean absolute percentage error (MAPE < 5%) confirm strong agreement between simulated and experimental responses. The Nash–Sutcliffe efficiency coefficient (NSE = 0.981) approaching unity further demonstrates excellent predictive performance and indicates that the model explains nearly all variance in the validation dataset. First-order uncertainty propagation assuming 5% independent parameter uncertainty resulted in <6% propagated output error for all primary observables (Isteady, t90%, θ30days), confirming that the multiphysics framework does not amplify parameter uncertainty through nonlinear coupling.
Collectively, the statistical analyses presented in Tables 12–16 demonstrate that the flow-induced enhancement of the electrochemical signal is highly significant (p < 0.0001), confirming that the observed amplification arises from physically meaningful hydrodynamic effects rather than numerical variability. The regression analysis further verifies that convective scaling closely follows theoretical laminar boundary-layer predictions (R2 = 0.987), thereby validating the correct implementation of convection–diffusion coupling within the multiphysics framework. In addition, long-term fouling kinetics exhibit statistically robust exponential behavior (R2 = 0.992), consistent with classical adsorption-driven saturation dynamics and confirming that the predicted signal decay reflects physically realistic surface processes. The comparative statistical evaluation of regeneration strategies reveals significant and reproducible differences in recovery efficiency, demonstrating that the superiority of electrochemical pulsing is not incidental but quantitatively supported. Finally, extended validation metrics, including a Nash–Sutcliffe efficiency of 0.981, confirm the high predictive fidelity of the model and its ability to reproduce experimental behavior with minimal systematic deviation.
In addition, long-term stability under continuous operation remains a major limitation in flow-based electrochemical sensing. She et al.33 developed a sono-electrochemical platform to mitigate biofouling during continuous measurements, highlighting the critical role of regeneration strategies in maintaining signal reproducibility. Reviews on emerging contaminant detection also emphasize that durability and fouling control are often insufficiently addressed in conventional flow-assisted sensors.34
Compared with these systems, the present multiphysics framework predicts a 144% enhancement in steady-state current under laminar microfluidic flow conditions, demonstrating a substantial improvement in mass transport and electrochemical activity at the electrode interface. In addition, the model indicates a 64% reduction in response time (t90%), highlighting the capability of the system to achieve faster analytical performance. The framework also enables quantitative prediction of fouling behavior over a 30 day period based on Langmuir adsorption kinetics, providing valuable insight into long-term operational stability. Furthermore, the simulations suggest that electrochemical pulsing can achieve regeneration efficiencies of up to 95%, underscoring the effectiveness of the proposed strategy for restoring sensor performance and extending device lifetime.
While previous studies experimentally demonstrate flow-enhanced sensing,21,27,33 they do not integrate hydrodynamics, irreversible Butler–Volmer kinetics, long-term adsorption-driven fouling, and regeneration modeling within a unified predictive framework. The present study therefore provides a mechanistic and quantitative extension beyond experimentally focused flow-assisted electrochemical sensors. The comparative results summarized above indicate that the present system achieves competitive flow-induced signal amplification while uniquely incorporating predictive fouling–regeneration modeling, which is rarely integrated into existing flow-assisted electrochemical sensor designs.21,27,33,34
Second, surface fouling was modeled using a generalized Langmuir-type adsorption–desorption framework with a representative foulant concentration. The model does not explicitly distinguish between specific environmental foulants such as humic acids, natural organic matter (NOM), proteins, or inorganic particulates. Therefore, the fouling kinetics presented here represent an idealized adsorption process rather than chemically resolved surface interactions. Incorporating species-specific adsorption parameters and competitive adsorption mechanisms would further enhance predictive realism.
Third, although the electrochemical behavior was validated against experimental data under stationary conditions, no dedicated flow-assisted experimental validation was conducted within this study. Consequently, the predicted flow-induced signal enhancement and response time reduction are theoretical extrapolations based on well-established hydrodynamic scaling laws rather than direct experimental confirmation. Future experimental microfluidic studies are necessary to fully validate the quantitative predictions under dynamic flow conditions. Despite these limitations, the model provides a consistent theoretical framework for analyzing coupled hydrodynamics, electrochemical kinetics, and adsorption-driven degradation, and it establishes a foundation for future experimentally validated developments.
Furthermore, the long-term simulations provide quantitative insights into surface fouling-induced signal degradation and sensor durability under continuous operation. Progressive accumulation of foulants was shown to significantly reduce electrochemical activity over time, while regeneration studies revealed that electrochemical voltage pulsing offers superior recovery of active sites compared to solvent washing and ultrasonic cleaning. The close agreement between simulated and experimental electrochemical responses confirms the robustness and predictive capability of the proposed model. Overall, this work establishes a versatile theoretical platform for rational sensor design, enabling systematic optimization of flow conditions, electrode architecture, and maintenance strategies, and thereby facilitating the development of reliable and high-performance electrochemical sensors for continuous environmental monitoring of niclosamide and other emerging contaminants. It should be emphasized that the present results represent a predictive computational framework based on simplified geometry and generalized fouling kinetics, and further experimental validation under real flow conditions will be required to fully confirm quantitative performance.
Supplementary information (SI) is available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d5ra10070d.
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2026 |