Open Access Article
Maialen Terceño-Carrillo
a,
Laura Razquin-Bobillo
a,
Sergio Carrasco
b,
Patricia Horcajada
b,
Garikoitz Beobide
c,
Jose Angel Garcíad,
Pablo Salcedo-Abraira
e,
Andoni Zabala-Lekuona
a,
Antonio Rodríguez-Diéguez
e and
Javier Cepeda
*a
aDepartamento de Química Aplicada, Facultad de Química, University of the Basque Country (EHU), 20018 Donostia-San Sebastián, Spain. E-mail: javier.cepeda@ehu.eus
bAdvanced Porous Materials Unit (APMU), IMDEA Energy Institute, Avda. Ramón de la Sagra 3, E-28935, Móstoles, Madrid, Spain
cDepartamento de Química Orgánica e Inorgánica, Facultad de Ciencia y Tecnología, University of the Basque Country (EHU), 48940, Leioa, Spain
dDepartamento de Física, Facultad de Ciencia y Tecnología, University of the Basque Country (EHU), 48940, Leioa, Spain
eDepartamento de Química Inorgánica, Facultad de Ciencias, Universidad de Granada, Av. Fuentenueva S/N, 18071 Granada, Spain
First published on 4th February 2026
In this work, we report on the structural and physicochemical characterization and an in-depth photophysical study of a family of isostructural coordination polymers (CPs) with the general formula {[M2(μ3-2onic)4(H2O)4](ClO4)2·2H2O}n (where M(III) = Y (1Y), Nd (2Nd), Eu (3Eu), Gd (4Gd), Tb (5Tb), Dy (6Dy), Er (7Er) and Yb (8Yb) and 2onic = 2-oxonicotinate). They consist of a cationic 2D layered structure in which two eight-coordinated rare-earth centres are interconnected by means of 2onic ligands, which demonstrates great flexibility with respect to changes in temperature and pressure (vacuum) derived from partial dehydration implying both lattice and coordination water molecules, which in turn promotes the rearrangement of the hydrogen-bonded network. Similar structural breathing effects are observed under variable gas-pressurization conditions, leading to some metastable phases while vacuum conditions are maintained. Periodic density functional theory (PDFT) calculations performed on 1Y with variable amounts of water successfully reproduced the structural evolution during dehydration. The fact that the vacuum-/pressure-induced effect is fully reversible in addition to the significantly improved photoluminescence (PL) shown by the vacuum-/pressure-activated compounds shifts the attention towards these compounds as potential pressure and humidity sensors. 2Nd and 8Yb, in addition to acting as emitters in the visible range, behave as near-infrared (NIR) emitters, with the former displaying characteristic emission even at room temperature. A thorough analysis of the excitations and energy-transfers by means of semi-empirical methods and multi-configurational calculations on suitable fragment models, and further confirmation by density of states (DOS) theory on the PDFT-optimized structure, allows elucidating the PL mechanism operating in the variable emission in the solid state. The water solubility of the compounds allows the study of the PL properties of the complexes, which surprisingly present quantum efficiencies exceeding those of the solid state especially in the solution of 5Tb (with the quantum yield (QY) increased from 1.6 to 21.5%).
Coming back to the field of sensing, luminescent LnCPs deserve a special mention given their good performance as chemical and physical sensors,24–26 among which the former have been largely revisited during the last few years27–29 whereas the latter remain comparatively less studied and mainly limited to thermometers.25 Thus, other relevant application fields such as luminescence-based pressure-/vacuum-sensing still remain nowadays practically unexplored, with most of the examples referring to O2 sensors.30 In this context, CPs exhibit ordered but “soft” structures, with strong coordination bonds complemented by weaker interactions, particularly involving lattice crystallization solvents or ionic species. Such molecular arrangement may happen to imbue the solid with a particular sensitivity towards small changes occurring in the environment, which can generate a luminescence response. This is why, notwithstanding the fact that O2 is a major component of ambient air, sensing of vacuum under other atmospheric conditions could be equally interesting.
In our quest of finding novel metal–organic materials presenting good PL properties and considering all the previously mentioned ideas, in the present work we have focused on the photophysical characterization of a family of isostructural CPs based on the 2-oxonicotinate (2onic) ligand. This ligand, similar to the previously explored methylated derivative 6-methyl-2-oxonicotinate (6m2onic),31,32 keeps the capacity to establish stable six-membered chelating rings with Lns that allows for providing Ln-centred emission in both solid state and aqueous solution while it also extends the coordination and polymerization. More interestingly, yet the PL properties are comparatively worse for 2onic-based compounds with respect to 6m2onic, and the layered and ionic framework of the former endows the herein described compounds with intriguing variable luminescence that derives from vacuum-/pressure-triggered subtle structural rearrangement mediated by partial dehydration. In this sense, concise characterization supported by both a broad set of experiments and DFT computation allows unraveling framework-level structural mechanisms leading to modulation of PL properties of these materials and their potential sensing of slight physical changes under ambient conditions.
| Coordination sphere of the Tb1 atom | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| a Symmetries: (i) 1/2 − x, y, 1/2 − z; (ii) 3/2 − x, −1 + y, 1/2 − z; (iii) x, −1 + y, z; (iv) 3/2 − x, y, 1/2 − z. | |||
| Tb1–O1w | 2.470(3) | Tb1–O32A | 2.326(3) |
| Tb1–O1w(i) | 2.470(3) | Tb1-O32A(i) | 2.326(3) |
| Tb1–O32B | 2.321(3) | Tb1-O2w | 2.488(3) |
| Tb1–O32B(i) | 2.321(3) | Tb1–O2w(i) | 2.488(3) |
| Coordination sphere of the Tb2 atom | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| Tb2–O21A | 2.367(3) | Tb2–O21B(ii) | 2.382(3) |
| Tb2–O31A | 2.338(3) | Tb2–O31B(ii) | 2.347(3) |
| Tb2–O21A(iv) | 2.367(3) | Tb2–O21B(iii) | 2.382(3) |
| Tb2–O31A(iv) | 2.338(3) | Tb2–O31B(iii) | 2.347(3) |
The two independent ligands present the same µ-κ2O21,O31:κO32 coordination pattern, based on the chelating ring around the Tb2 atom and the monodentate linkage with the Tb1 atom. To acquire such a binding mode, the carboxylate group needs to be twisted out of the aromatic mean plane, where the rotation angle is slightly higher for the B ligand (of 27.8°) compared to the A ligand (26.2°). In this way, the ligands bridge both coordination centres with each other, in such a way that each of the four non-chelating carboxylate oxygen atoms (of 2onic ligands) arising from the Tb2 centre is linked to a Tb1 centre, imposing Tb⋯Tb distances of ca. 5.90 (for the A ligand) and 5.95 Å (for the B ligand). As a result, the coordination between these two centres takes place along two directions in such a way that layers show rhombic rings in the form of a tetragonal plane network with the sql topology and (44·62) point symbol (Fig. 2a). Within the layers, the coordinated water molecules use one of their hydrogen atoms to establish strong hydrogen-bonding interactions with the chelating carboxylate oxygen atoms. From this point on, the second hydrogen atom of the water molecules interacts differently, since it is involved in an intralayer hydrogen bond with a neighbouring coordinated water molecule in the case of O1w whereas that of O2w is directed towards one of the oxygen atoms of the perchlorate anion. Moreover, the arrangement of the ligands pending from both centres is that in which neighbouring aromatic rings get close and parallel to each other to maximise π–π interactions. In particular, remarkable interactions are found between adjacent A and B ligands pertaining to the Tb2 centre and between copies of those ligands pending from both Tb1 and Tb2 centres, in such a way that stacking interactions are observed along the crystallographic b axis. In addition to these interactions, the lattice water molecule is also involved in hydrogen bonds with perchlorate and coordinated water molecules, somehow reinforcing the internal cohesion of the layers. However, none of the aforementioned major interactions are involved in the connectivity between adjacent layers, resulting in weak interlayer packaging, with the layers stacked along the c axis by means of weak interactions involving perchlorate anions (Fig. 2b). This fact seems to indicate that the packing of the structure could present remarkable flexibility, which agrees with the structural polymorphism found for these compounds (similarity to other previously published compounds).
On this basis and considering the limited diffraction capacity of these compounds under heating, softer dehydration conditions were followed to approach the potential dynamics of the framework forced by their controlled dehydration. Accordingly, the evolution of PXRD data for 7Er was followed under high vacuum. As the sample was slightly depressurized from an open atmosphere (OA) down to low pressure (achieving 4.6·10−6 mbar at the end of the experiment), a slight shifting of ca. 0.1° was observed in many diffraction maxima (Fig. 3).
![]() | ||
| Fig. 3 Evolution of the PXRD data of compound 7Er under progressive vacuum pressurization. The insets show augmented regions where key shifting of diffraction maxima occurs. | ||
In parallel, the mass loss occurring for the compounds was studied by gravimetry during exposure of a representative sample to high vacuum (of ca. 10−5 mbar) in an outgassing station (see details in the S7 section of the SI), finding that this process forces the release of not only the lattice but also two of the coordination water molecules (4 H2O accounting for an experimental loss of 6.82% that fits well with the theoretical loss of 6.27%, see Table S5 in the S7 section of the SI), thus leading to the aforementioned compound 7Er-PD. Pattern-matching analyses on selected diffractograms showed slight contraction of the unit cell during the initial pressurization stage although it turns into drastic eventual cell expansion under high vacuum for several hours (Table 2). In particular, it is seen that the partial dehydration (loss of 4 H2O molecules) slightly shortens the crystallographic a and c parameters while it lengthens the b parameter and also closes the β angle. Interestingly, exposure of the sample to air for some hours reverted the process back to the pristine material, as evidenced by PXRD pattern comparison, suggesting spontaneous water uptake from atmospheric moisture under open-air conditions.
| Comp. | Cell parameters | |||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| a (Å) | b (Å) | c (Å) | β (°) | V (Å3) | ΔV (%) | |||
| a Labels employed for the structures simulated under periodic boundary conditions refer to several progressive dehydration steps: (i) compound 1Y without lattice molecules (1Y-WL: {[Y2(2onic)4(H2O)4](ClO4)2}n); (ii) the partially dehydrated compound without lattice and two coordination water molecules (1Y-PD: {[Y2(2onic)4(H2O)2](ClO4)2}n) and (iii) the fully dehydrated compound (1Y-FD: {[Y2(2onic)4](ClO4)2}n). | ||||||||
| Experimental X-ray structure | ||||||||
| 7Er-OA | 10.11 | 6.40 | 28.55 | 95.57 | 1838.6 | — | ||
| 7Er-10−3 | 10.11 | 6.39 | 28.49 | 95.47 | 1832.2 | −0.34 | ||
| 7Er-10−5 | 10.09 | 6.37 | 28.45 | 95.45 | 1820.3 | −1.00 | ||
| 7Er-10−6 | 10.03 | 6.58 | 28.28 | 95.29 | 1858.5 | +1.08 | ||
| PBC-simulated structures | ||||||||
| 1Y | 9.91 | 6.82 | 28.95 | 95.95 | 1944.1 | — | ||
| 1Y-WLa | 9.96 | 6.67 | 28.85 | 96.17 | 1905.9 | −1.96 | ||
| 1Y-PD | 9.67 | 6.94 | 28.72 | 94.28 | 1925.8 | −0.94 | ||
| 1Y-FD | 9.59 | 6.96 | 28.63 | 95.38 | 1902.5 | −2.14 | ||
In order to shed some light on the possible structural transformation taking place during the vacuum-triggered partial dehydration, DFT calculations were performed on the crystal structure of compound 1Y with the CASTEP code of Materials Studio36 under periodic boundary conditions (PBC, hereafter PDFT) given its lighter electronic structure compared to the rest of lanthanide-based counterparts. In an attempt to correlate the water release steps with unit cell parameter evolution, several structures representing all possible dehydration stages (structure without lattice water: WL, partially dehydrated without lattice and half of coordination molecules: PD and fully dehydrated: FD; see footnote in Table 2 for detailed explanation) were optimized allowing unit cell parameters to be slightly adapted. As observed in Table 2, the main experimental evolution of the lattice parameters (shortened a, c and β parameters and lengthened b parameter) and the eventual unit cell volume increase after prolonged vacuum (from 1820.3 to 1858.5 Å3) are both well reproduced for the simulated structures but only up to the data of compound 1Y-PD (for which a slight relative cell volume increase from 1905.9 for 1Y-WL to 1925.8 Å3 for 1Y-PD takes place during the loss of two coordination water molecules). Thus, the similar trend found in the simulated data supports the experimental loss of 4 water molecules (2 crystallization and 2 coordination molecules) and confirms the structural stability and flexibility of the compound even after the loss of coordination water molecules in the Y1 atom and despite the weak interactions dominating the 2D-layered structure. In any case, these non-innocent dehydration dynamics bring important consequences in the coordination environment of both metal atoms, mainly for the Y1 centre in which the reduction of the coordination index from 8 to 6 is accompanied of a substantial decrease in the polyhedron symmetry (from less distorted triangular dodecahedron symmetry (STDD = 0.453) to a highly distorted pseudo-octahedron (SOC = 1.744)). Therefore, as it will be detailed later in the manuscript, significant changes are expected to occur in the properties of these compounds in view of changes occurring in the chromophore.
To further investigate the structural response under external stimuli, a series of variable-pressure powder X-ray diffraction (VP-PXRD) experiments using different gas loadings were performed at 25 °C on compound 3Eu. The first test consisted in several cycles of vacuum-pressurization (Fig. 4). Upon the first vacuum cycle (red), significant shifts of the diffraction peaks were observed. The initial diffractogram displayed a broad reflection that resolved into three contributions centered at 6.27, 6.19, and 6.10° (2θ). Application of vacuum enhanced the 6.27° reflection at the expense of the lower-angle components, whereas restoring atmospheric pressure (blue) partially recovered their relative intensities, reproducing the high-vacuum data collected for 7Er. Consistent with other flexible Ln-MOFs, evacuation triggered partial desolvation, and a PXRD-detectable structural rearrangement that can be reversed upon exposure to air was observed, in line with soft-porous-crystal behavior.37,38 However, the initial pattern was not fully re-established during the experiment, since additional peak splitting at higher angles persisted (e.g., >18° (2θ)). Subsequent pressurization with air up to 1.6 bar (green) irreversibly stabilized the 6.27° reflection, while the lower-angle contributions could no longer be recovered during the experiment. After completing a full vacuum/air-pressure cycle, the diffractogram showed enhanced intensities but no further changes in peak positions, indicating that the vacuum-induced rearrangement had become locked for, at least, P < 2 bar. Following evacuation, subsequent pressurization seems to lock the framework in a metastable configuration, reminiscent of adsorption-driven hysteresis reported for breathing MOFs.39,40 This behavior is concordant with slow rehydration kinetics occurring in the compound that is associated with its non-porous structure and, thus, expected low gas water capture capacity from ambient moisture and subsequent diffusion of water molecules within the particles.41
![]() | ||
| Fig. 4 (a) PXRD patterns of 3Eu upon consecutive in situ vacuum-pressurization cycles (from bottom to top); (b) amplification of the region 5.8–6.4° (2θ). | ||
In contrast, in the second test, samples were directly pressurized up to 1.6–1.7 bar with either air or argon, never below 1 bar and without applying vacuum, exhibiting no significant structural modifications compared to the pristine diffractogram (Fig. 5). Only global intensity changes were detected. Hence, vacuum appeared as the main driving force behind the structural rearrangement observed in Fig. 4, whereas moderate compression alone did not promote any phase evolution within the accessible pressure window, which agrees with previous studies where MOF transitions are typically observed under much higher hydrostatic loads.42 Whether higher Ar/air pressures would induce further transformations remains uncertain because achieving higher pressures lies beyond the operational limits of the in situ setup.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 5 (a) PXRD patterns of 3Eu upon consecutive in situ pressurization–depressurization cycles (from bottom to top); (b) amplification of the region 5.8–6.4° (2θ). No peak shifting was observed. | ||
In order to shed some light on this behavior, additional CO2 pressure experiments were conducted at 10 bar for 16 h on the samples used in the previous experiments. Interestingly, the sample from the first test (vacuum-pressurization) displayed a transient beige/pinkish color to the naked eye immediately after recovering the material from the reactor, although it reverted to its original white appearance within minutes under ambient conditions (Fig. S13). PXRD patterns revealed small yet measurable variations in the main low-angle reflection. For the sample from the first test (vacuum-pressurization; Fig. 6a), the peak shifted from 6.27 to 6.23° (2θ), consistent with a lattice expansion of ∼0.05 Å (interplanar distance, d). Conversely, the sample from the second test (pressurization-depressurization without vacuum, Fig. 6b) showed a shift from 6.21 to 6.23° (2θ), corresponding to a slight contraction of ∼0.03 Å (d). Remarkably, both cases converged to a common equilibrium value of 6.23° (2θ), suggesting that exposure to CO2 promotes structural relaxation towards a similar metastable configuration regardless of the sample history, in agreement with CO2-induced breathing observed by in situ PXRD in other flexible MOFs.43,44 In any case, further PXRD analysis of the aerated sample confirmed the reversibility of the process back to the original compound (Fig. S14). Taken together, these findings reinforce the notion that the framework can explore multiple metastable configurations depending on the applied stimulus, thus supporting its potential as a responsive material for luminescence-based sensing.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 6 PXRD patterns of 3Eu after 16 h at 10 bar CO2 previously used in the (a) vacuum-pressurization test; (b) pressurization-depressurization test. | ||
| Comp. | ZPL | ES (cm−1) | ET (cm−1) | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| S1 | T1 | Exp. | Calc. | Exp. | Calc. | |
| a The experimental energy values for the singlet and triplet states are estimated from the UV-Vis absorption and TRES measurements, respectively. The calculated energy values are obtained from MC-RPA methodology for both H2onic ligand and 4Gd. | ||||||
| Ligand | 26 315 |
22 200 |
28 570 |
30 490 |
20 033 |
19 125 |
| 4Gd | 26 595 |
22 860 |
29 850 |
30 210 |
19 160 |
18 570 |
Once the energies of the excited singlet states were known, we continued studying the PL properties of these samples at variable temperature in order to locate the lowest-lying excited triplet state given its potential implication in the PL mechanism of these Ln-CPs. Under UV light of 365 nm, a polycrystalline sample of H2onic displays brilliant blue emission whereas the sample of compound 4Gd emits blue-violet light as observed in the micro-PL images (Fig. 8). Accordingly, the emission spectrum collected under laser excitation (λex = 325 nm) of the Gd-based compound is dominated by a band peaking at 395 nm attributed to the ligand's emission given that Gd(III) lacks intraionic electronic transitions in that region of the spectrum.45 This band is slightly red-shifted compared to that shown by the free H2onic ligand measured with the same experimental setup (λem = 405 nm), which is associated to the coordination of the ligand in the structure of 4Gd. This fact is also translated into a much shorter Stokes shift, of less than 10 nm in 4Gd while it is of 40 nm in H2onic. Moreover, the H2onic ligand's emission band is also remarkable for its wideness compared to that of 4Gd, seeming to be composed of a second less intense band peaking at ca. 440 nm. The analysis of the decay curves measured at both wavelengths by means of a LED-based pulsed source reveals that both contributions arise from the same electronic level (vibronic progression) given their similar emission lifetime (τav = 5.39 ns at λem = 400 nm and τav = 5.32 ns at λem = 440 nm, Fig. S18). No such equivalent signal could be measured at RT for compound 4Gd due to its both low intensity and shorter lifetime. Given the impossibility of finding phosphorescence emissions which could clarify the energy of excited triplet states, the measurements were repeated at 25 K. To start with H2onic, both the excitation and emission bands are notoriously narrowed, while the emission band is also red-shifted from 400 to 440 nm (being aligned to the RT shoulder, see Fig. S19). Interestingly, although the band maximum maintains a fluorescence signal (increased to τav = 7.84 ns at λem = 440 nm), the band shoulder clearly represents a phosphorescence emission owing to its long-lived component (τav = 71.4 ms at λem = 475 nm, Fig. S20). Such a long lifetime lasting in the range of a few milliseconds suggests that the signal is being emitted from a ligand-centred excited triplet state. A similar effect is observed for compound 4Gd at low temperature, while the emission spectrum also reveals a second broad band centred at ca. 500 nm (Fig. S21) that is attributed to the phosphorescence emission under steady-state irradiation, as supported by its lifetime (τav = 6.4 ms, see Fig. S22). It is also worth noting that the first (main) band of the emission spectrum of 4Gd presents a slightly shorter lifetime than the free ligand (τav = 0.84 ns at λem = 395 nm), which may be due to a more effective intersystem crossing in the compound caused by both the reduction of the vibrational component in the CP as observed in previous works31 and the occurrence of the heavy atom effect caused by Gd(III).46 With the aim of isolating the delayed band corresponding to the triplet state emission, time-resolved emission spectra (TRES) were measured at low temperature for both samples and, gathering the data at t = 3 ms the corresponding phosphorescence spectra were constructed (Fig. S23). Both samples exhibit wide bands peaking at ca. 500 nm in good agreement with the previous measurements. After processing these bands in energy scale and using appropriate fittings (Fig. S24 and S25), the barycentre and zero-phonon energy of the excited triplet state manifold were estimated (Table 3). The results for the triplet barycentre of both compounds are concordant with those values estimated via the vertical excitation method, by which the triplet state energy is calculated as (ET − ES) for the models (the H2onic ligand molecule or the suitable complex model for 4Gd) optimized at the triplet state geometry (19125 cm−1 for H2onic and 18570 cm−1 for 4Gd).
To end up with this section, it must be emphasized that the photophysical properties of these compounds were also computed on the PDFT-optimized structure of 1Y for comparative purposes and to validate the conclusions previously derived from representative fragment models. As observed in Fig. S16 in the SI, though the present computations somewhat underestimate the band gap compared to the experimental measurements (2.79 vs. 3.18 eV, Fig. S17) as usual for this method,47 the calculated UV absorption spectrum reproduces fairly well the shape (two-band structure) of the experimental one. Moreover, the partial densities of states (PDOS, see Fig. S16) in both the conduction and valence bands are shown to mainly consist of s- and p-valence orbitals, confirming the LC nature of the absorption process in these compounds, showing almost residual contributions of Y(III)-based d orbitals in the frontier MOs.
The RT emission spectrum features the characteristic bands assigned to 7FJ ← 5D0 electronic transitions centred at 592 (for 7F1), 613 (for 7F2), 651 (for 7F3) and 699 nm (for 7F4). There are two important facts to be noted from these characteristic emissions: (i) the most energetic band intuited at 580 nm, assigned to 7F0 ← 5D0, presents almost null intensity in contrast to that habitually found for CPs consisting of octacoordinated Eu(III) ions;16,31,48–50 (ii) the so-called hypersensitive band (related to the 7F2 ← 5D0 transition) exhibits an abnormal structureless peak shape (taking into account that the rest of signals are composed of multiplets) with a quite symmetric profile characterized by its narrowness at the top and width at the base, which suggests the presence of less intense unresolved shoulders within this band. The excitation spectrum recorded by fixing the emission at the hypersensitive band shows a broad band peaking at ca. 380 nm, assigned to LC excitation, above which many narrow bands, attributed to the intraionic excitations, are distinguished, with that assigned as 7F0 → 5L6 dominating the spectrum by far. The much larger intensity of this latter band compared to the LC excitation is clear evidence of the limited antenna effect present in the compound (see further details in Fig. S26). Surprisingly, the decay curve recorded under ligand excitation (at λex = 325 nm to avoid the presence of intraionic excitation) for the hypersensitive band presents a monoexponential profile in spite of the presence of two quite distinct independent Eu centres in the crystal structure, with the best fitting giving an emission lifetime of 368(3) µs (Fig. S27). In line with these results, the PLQY for the compound is quite low (Table 4).
| Comp. | λex | λem | τobsb (µs) | QYc (%) | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 293 K-OA | 293 K-UV | 10 K | ||||
| a Note that excitation wavelengths employed to measure the lifetimes correspond to those fixed by the laser and LED pulsed sources.b OA and UV in the columns refer to values recorded in an open atmosphere and under vacuum conditions.c Measured only at room temperature due to technical requisites. | ||||||
| 3Eu | 325 | 613 | 368(3) | 400(3) | 609(3) | 12.7 |
| 305 | 613 | 354(3) | — | — | 9.6 | |
| 5Tb | 325 | 544 | 238(5) | 117(5) | 1130(3) | 1.6 |
| 305 | 544 | — | 119(5) | — | ||
A more exhaustive study of the intramolecular energy transfers (IET) was conducted for compound 3Eu according to the equations originally described by Werts et al.,51 which allow estimating that the ET efficiency from the 2onic ligand to Eu(III) is 73% in the present crystal structure (Table 5, see eqn (S3)–(S5) in the SI for more details).
Moreover, the most representative rates and intensity parameters have been calculated using LUMPAC software based on the experimental spectral data and computational calculations performed on the representative [Eu(2onic)4(OH2)4]− and [Eu(µ-2onic)4]− fragments (secondary coordination environment of Eu1 and Eu2 centres, respectively) composing the structure of 3Eu (see the Computational calculations section in the SI for further explanations).52 The results obtained by this procedure, being practically equal for both models, are close to the experimental ones both regarding the triplet state energies (18780 cm−1 from fitting vs. the experimental value 19160 cm−1) and the QY values (10.2 vs. 12.7%), which supports the calculations although coincidental cancellation of errors cannot be discarded given the large errors associated with the experimental measurement of these parameters (less than 10% of error). The direct-transfer (W) and back-transfer (Wb) rates involved between the ligand and metal were averaged from both fragments taking into account that the two centres are distributed in a 1
:
1 ratio in the structure. As observed in Fig. 10, the largest transfer values involving the triplet mediated state are equally large for both the direct (T1 → 5D0) and back-transfer (5D1 ← T1) rates, which supports the fact that although good sensitization of Eu(III) takes place in the compound, the non-radiative component prevails causing poor luminescence efficiency.
The coordination of 2onic to the Tb(III) ion in the polymeric structure of compound 5Tb promotes poor pale-green emission as shown in the micrograph taken under UV light. In spite of this, the characteristic four multiplets centred at 493 nm (7F6 ← 5D4), 547 nm (7F5 ← 5D4), 588 nm (7F4 ← 5D4) and 623 nm (7F3 ← 5D4) as well as the fifth less intense multiplet around 654 nm (7FJ ← 5D4, with J = 2, 1 and 0) are well observed using a monochromatic laser beam (λex = 325 nm, Fig. 9). Among the bands, the second is the most intense with an intensity that quadruplicates that of the first band, which is in agreement with the results shown by compound 3Eu. Under a fixed emission at the most intense band, the excitation spectrum reveals a dominant wide band covering the 250–430 nm range, assigned to the 2onic ligand excitation in agreement with that observed for 4Gd, in which some narrow lines attributed to f–f excitations are also distinguished (Fig. S28). The decay curve measured through ligand excitation for 5Tb reveals the occurrence of two well distinguished contributions, which give rise to an average lifetime of 238(5) µs (Fig. S29).
At last, the steady-state emission spectrum of compound 6Dy under UV laser light (λex = 325 nm) is composed of both a wide intense band attributed to the ligand's fluorescence and the characteristic narrow bands ascribed to the Dy-centred transitions (Fig. 9). In particular, three single narrow bands are observed at 483, 578 and 667 nm which are assigned to 6HJ ← 4F9/2 transitions (where J = 15/2, 13/2 and 11/2), among which the second band dominates the spectrum and the third one is hardly distinguished from the background. This compound presents light blue emission (see single crystal emission in Fig. 9) in agreement with the calculated CIE coordinates (0.246,198). Monitoring the main emission line, the excitation spectrum exhibits a wide band centred at ca. 350 nm followed by several narrow bands. The former band, according to that shown for 4Gd and solid state absorption data, corresponds to the ligand-centred excitation whereas the latter bands are attributed to the intraionic f–f transitions. This compound presents very short emission lifetimes (both at the ligand's and Dy-centred characteristic bands) of the order or below the employed lamp's pulse length, so all attempts to estimate the emission lifetimes were unfruitful even if deconvolution strategies were followed.
Overall, the observed luminous performance of these compounds may be explained by Latva's empirical law53 that rules the efficiency of the antenna effect in Ln-organic compounds on the basis of the energy gap (ΔE) existing between the triplet and Ln-based donor states. In this respect, this ΔE seems to be more appropriate for 3Eu [of 1660 cm−1 (ΔT1(19160 cm−1)–5D0(17500 cm−1))], in contrast to what happens in compounds 5Tb [ΔE being −1640 cm−1 (ΔT1(19160 cm−1)–5D4(20800 cm−1))] and 6Dy [ΔE being −1240 cm−1 (ΔT1(19160 cm−1)–4F9/2(20400 cm−1))] in which T1 is below the intraionic emitting excited states of both Tb(III) and Dy(III) ions.54 Therefore, while high ligand-to-Eu(III) energy transfer seems to take place in 3Eu, the corresponding energy transfer is hardly probable in 5Tb and 6Dy, in which the back-transfer probability dominates the transfer scenario.
At this point, it is worth highlighting that the compounds described herein perform far below those of related Ln-6m2onic compounds based on the methyl derivative ligand in terms of quantum efficiency (among which Tb-6m2onic presents near unity quantum efficiency, 97%),31,32 which is quite surprising considering that both compounds consist of essentially the same [Ln(L)4]− fragment such as that displayed by the Ln2 centre of herein described compounds. This fact seems to be a consequence of the most appropriate electronic structure of 6m2onic to sensitize Ln luminescence, being this in turn a consequence of its higher T1 state energy (of ca. 22900 cm−1). However, this disadvantage is more than compensated by the interesting vacuum-/pressure-triggered PL response shown by herein described Ln-2onic compounds (vide infra in the “Vacuum-induced modulation of PL properties of visible emitters” section). This behaviour, which as far as we are concerned is a quite unique effect in the field of PL emitters, seems to be derived from their flexible 2D-layered structure that is only available for the 2onic ligand probably due to reduced steric hindrance caused among surrounding ligand copies in the coordination sphere.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 11 Emission spectra of NIR emitting compounds in the solid state: (a) room temperature emission of compound 2Nd and (b) emission of compound 8Yb at low temperature. | ||
In any case, apart from the previous usual effect, the emission spectrum also displayed some other changes as the vacuum was increased from ca. 10−5 mbar to the order of 10−6 mbar (with the vacuum stabilized for at least ten hours). On the one hand, the hypersensitive band was eventually split into a structured multiplet in which the initial shoulders accompanying the maxima sited at 613 nm are fully resolved (peaking at 611 and 615 nm) and two additional peaks (at 618 and 625 nm) were also shown. On the other hand, the first narrow emission maximum becomes visible at 578 nm for 3EuUV, which is assigned to the 7F0 ← 5D0 transition. Both effects are in agreement with symmetry reduction occurring at Eu1 and Eu2 centres present for the DFT-computed partially dehydrated structure based on the theoretical background on Eu(III)-complexes detailed by Binnemans.59 In this sense, the largely distorted coordination shells present in 3EuUV derived from the dehydration, now better described by the C1 point symbol, cause further splitting of the sublevels of 2S+1LJ terms except for J = 0, with the 7F2 term theoretically split into 5 sublevels that match the number of visible signals distinguished in the multiplet of 7F2 ← 5D0 transition. Moreover, the increase of intensity observed for the electric dipole 7F0 ← 5D0 transition is justified by the low symmetry Eu(III) sites, known to display intense signals at 580 nm. On their part, the significantly distinct distorted polyhedra of Eu1 and Eu2 sites present in 3EuUV, pseudo-octahedral in Eu1 and square antiprismatic in Eu2 according to DFT computations (see previous discussion) are well supported in the emission spectrum. In particular, a sextuplet is clearly identified for the magnetic dipole 7F1 ← 5D0 transition peaking in the 585–600 nm range, concordant with the presence of two independent Eu centres in the asymmetric unit, each one giving its own signals taking into account that the 7F1 term cannot further split into more than 3 sublevels. The previous evolution in the emission profile of 3EuUV is also reflected in the excitation spectrum recorded for λem = 613 nm (Fig. S32), in which the 2onic-centred band increases its intensity and dominates the spectrum in contrast to its low intensity observed for the neat compound 3Eu. To end up with this characterization, it is worth mentioning that the sample immediately recovers its initial emission spectrum once it is left to stand in an open atmosphere for some hours, which confirms the reversibility of the process (Fig. S33). It is also worth noting the fact that vacuum-dependent response is also observed for the rest of isostructural compounds although the effect is not that pronounced (see for instance the subtle changes observed in the excitation spectrum of 5TbUV and for the rest of counterparts, Fig. S35–S38).
With the aim of further quantifying the spectroscopic changes of pristine (hydrated) and vacuum-triggered (partially dehydrated) compounds, emission lifetimes were measured at the most intense Ln-centred bands. Strikingly, compounds 3EuUV and 5TbUV present opposed vacuum-triggered trends, with the lifetime being increased (from 368 to 400 µs) for the Eu-based compound under vacuum in contrast to the drastic decrease (from 238 to 117 µs) for the Tb-based compound (Table 4). The latter evolution is quite surprising because it is in direct contradiction with the expected increase for the removal of O2 in the system, meaning that additional factors must be affecting the PL of 5TbUV. However, the opposite trend was confirmed to be fully reproducible for both compounds in OA and UV states, allowing the use of lifetime as a characteristic value to identify each compound. Among others, the fact that the vacuum-triggered dehydration mediated structural changes may be shifting the excited triplet state energy is not surprising at all. According to the lifetimes of 3EuUV and 5TbUV, the T1 energy should be increasing from its reference value at ≈19160 cm−1, which would improve the sensitization of the Eu(III) ion (increasing the T1–5D0 gap in 3EuUV) but would worsen the ET for Tb(III) (decreasing the T1–5D4 gap in 3TbUV). Despite the fact that the barycentre of the T1 state could not be measured for 4GdUV (because no phosphorescent band is observed under these conditions), data collected for the thermally dehydrated compounds (which promote similar dehydration in the structure, see the next section) point in that sense.
At last, taking advantage of the previous characterization, it could be also confirmed that structural evolution achieved under high pressure of CO2 gas (see Fig. 6) is reversible and that those metastable configurations identified by PXRD are eventually spontaneously rehydrated back to pristine material when the sample is left exposed to air for one day (Fig. S14), in the same way as observed under vacuum. As detailed in the SI (Fig. S39–S44), the analysis of PL properties for the sample of 3Eu used for CO2 pressurization experiments reproduces lifetime values of the pristine compound at RT and OA, and it also shows reproducible changes in both the PL spectra and lifetime values during a whole vacuum-assisted dehydration/rehydration cycle.
In the same line, X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) measurements conducted on both the fresh sample of 3Eu and the rehydrated sample of 3Eu recovered from gas-pressurization experiments show coincident results on the analytical content (Table S6), thus further confirming the spontaneous reversibility of the pressurization-triggered dehydration by simply exposing the sample to OA conditions (see the S14 section in the SI for detailed explanation).
Therefore, these materials exhibit reproducible and reversible vacuum-triggered luminescence response that renders them promising candidates for luminescence sensors capable of monitoring variations in pressure and humidity.
| Comp.a | Med.b | λex | λem | τobs (µs) | QY (%) | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 293 K | 10 K | |||||
| a Refers to the as-synthesized or the thermally dehydrated compound.b OA and UV have their previously mentioned meanings: open atmosphere and under vacuum, respectively. | ||||||
| Eu-based compound | ||||||
| As-synt. | OA (3Eu) | 325 | 613 | 368(3) | 609(3) | 12.7 |
| UV (3EuUV) | 325 | 613 | 400(3) | — | ||
| Dehyd. | OA (3EuD) | 340 | 614 | 328(4) | 771(5) | 16.5 |
| UV (3EuD-V) | 340 | 614 | 303(4) | — | ||
| Tb-based compound | ||||||
| As-synt. | OA (5Tb) | 325 | 544 | 238(5) | 1130(3) | 1.6 |
| UV (5TbUV) | 305 | 544 | 117(5) | — | ||
| Dehyd. | OA (5TbD) | 340 | 544 | 180(2) | 774(5) | 13.4 |
| UV (5TbD-V) | 340 | 544 | 152(2) | — | ||
On another level, when the samples are placed under high vacuum (hereafter 3EuD-V and 5TbD-V) they do not show such drastic changes as those discussed for pristine compounds, probably because 3EuD and 5TbD are already fully dehydrated, which reasonably prevents the structural changes derived from vacuum-triggered partial dehydration. Moreover, the emission lifetimes are slightly decreased for both solids by the effect of vacuum (see Fig. S46 and S48 and data in Table 6).
The effect of lowering temperature was also studied for these samples in view of their rich PL response to physical factors, seeking for potential thermometric activity. At this point, it must be noticed that the procedure employed to cool samples down to cryogenic temperature requires previous application of vacuum on them and thus, all previous effects will be omitted here. Starting from pristine materials, the excitation and emission spectra of 3EuUV at 12 K reflect sizeable increases in both the intensity of the emission bands (particularly for the hypersensitive one) and the observed lifetime (Fig. S56, see also Table 6), as expected for the rigidity gained by the molecules in such a frozen state. On its part, the low-temperature response for compound 5TbUV is comparatively more pronounced in both the shape of PL bands (Fig. S57 and S58) and the emission lifetime (shown to increase by more than 965% of its value at RT (from 117 to 1130 µs, Table 5). In spite of these latter changes, both compounds exhibited poor linear dependence with temperature (Fig. S60a) that translated into low thermometric activity, which can be summarized by a maximum relative sensitivity (Sm) of 0.54% K−1 at a temperature of 30 K for 3EuUV and of 0.70% K−1 at 110 K for 5TbUV, thus far from those best performing Ln-based reported thermometers.25 An even poorer performance was also found for the dehydrated compounds 3EuD-V and 5TbD-V (Sm = 0.09% K−1 at 135 K and 0.12% K−1 at 45 K, respectively, Fig. S61 and S62). At last, the measurements were also repeated for the in situ thermally dehydrated compound 5Tb (eventually rendering 5TbD, Fig. S60b). Nonetheless, the poor performance shown by this compound (Sm of 0.75% K−1 at 513 K), in addition to the irreversibility of the dehydration process which causes sample amorphization, suggest that the dehydrated compounds could only be single-use thermometers, far from ideal thermometers.
| Comp.a | Med.b | λex | λem | τobs (µs) | QY (%) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| a It refers to the as-synthesized or the thermally dehydrated compound.b OA refers to an open atmosphere for the solid state conditions. | |||||
| Eu-based compound | |||||
| 3Eu | OA (solid state) | 325 | 613 | 368(3) | 12.7 |
| Aqueous (3Eu@H2O) | 335 | 612 | 193(2) | 18.5 | |
| Dehydr. | OA (3EuD) | 340 | 614 | 328(4) | 16.5 |
| Aqueous (3EuD@H2O) | 330 | 612 | 178(2) | 17.7 | |
| Tb-based compound | |||||
| 5Tb | OA (solid state) | 325 | 544 | 238(5) | 1.6 |
| Aqueous (5Tb@H2O) | 330 | 544 | 484(5) | 21.5 | |
| Dehydr. | OA (5TbD) | 340 | 544 | 180(2) | 13.4 |
| Aqueous (5TbD@H2O) | 304 | 544 | 407(3) | 14.7 | |
| Dy-based compound | |||||
| 6Dy | OA (solid state) | — | — | — | <1 |
| Aqueous (6Dy@H2O) | 305 | 575 | 5.13(1) | 3.5 | |
| Dehydr. | OA (6DyD) | — | — | — | <1 |
| Aqueous (6DyD@H2O) | 305 | 575 | 5.01(1) | 3.0 | |
With respect to the dehydrated samples, they are also quite soluble in water, which allows one to prepare solutions of the same concentration (1.25 mg mL−1, referred to as 3EuD@H2O, 5TbD@H2O and 6DyD@H2O) to perform comparative measurements (Fig. S85–S91). A priori, although the excitation wavelength-dependence behaviour is reproduced for these samples, their PL signal is slightly weaker than for the corresponding solutions based on as-synthesized compounds as confirmed by the shorter lifetimes and lower QYs registered.
On another level, aqueous solutions of 1.25 mg mL−1 were also prepared for NIR emitters to check if this particular luminescence is also preserved in water. Despite the fact that the signal intensity is strongly decreased, 2Nd@H2O and 8Yb@H2O solutions keep their characteristic emission although the water medium (Fig. S92 and S93) is considered as an excellent quencher of Lns’ PL emission.60,61 As far as we are concerned, the occurrence of PL emission in the NIR by water-dissolved Ln complexes is not common and the number of stable compounds displaying strong emission is quite scarce and limited to the use of macrocyclic ligands able to establish multiple chelating rings with Lns.62,63 Therefore, the present compounds consisting of small 2onic ligands may be taken as inspiring results to develop competitive NIR-emitting compounds in future.
In parallel, a detailed experimental and calculated photophysical study has been accomplished to fully understand the luminescence mechanism. On the one hand, absorption spectra are well reproduced by complementary DOS on the PDFT-optimized structure of 1Y and TDDFT on an isolated optimized model of 4Gd, permitting to understand key electronic transitions governing the excitation. On the other hand, semi-empirical methods on suitable models of 3Eu clarify the main ETs in the compound and confirm that the 2onic ligand sensitizes Eu(III) emission (which displays a modest QY of ca. 13%) whereas it provides poor Tb(III)-based emission (QY less than 2%), which also concords with Latva's law on the basis of the energy gap between the ligand-centred triplet state and the Ln-centred intraionic excited states. While thermal treatment of these materials presents serious limitations due to uncontrolled and irreversible dehydration rendering amorphous compounds, in spite of the interesting behaviour found in their thermometric PL, vacuum-assisted and gas pressurization mediated dehydration trigger reversible PL-response of compounds 3Eu and 5Tb. Among all changes induced by changes in the ETs governing PL properties, changes in their emission lifetimes, showing opposed trends (increase for 3Eu and steep decrease for 5Tb), can be taken as main reference values of the process. In fact, being consistently reproduced along various dehydration/rehydration cycles, lifetimes allow identifying hydration stages of the compounds, supporting their use as pressure and humidity sensors.
Taking advantage of the solubility of these compounds in water, PL properties of water-dissolved complexes have been studied. As confirmed by ESI-MS, the crystal structure appears to be split into discrete complexes that remain stable in solution without apparent speciation (i.e. excision to free ligand) for at least one month as confirmed by 1H NMR analysis. Surprisingly, the aqueous solutions of these complexes exhibit even higher emission efficiency than solid samples, with the Eu(III)-based complex leading the group with a QY of 18.5%. At last, it must be also emphasized that Nd- and Yb-based compounds also retain characteristic NIR emissions in aqueous solution.
Overall, the interesting vacuum-/pressure-induced PL response and emission capacity of the water-soluble complexes underline their potential use as physical sensors or luminescence probes in biological media.
The powder X-ray diffraction (PXRD) patterns collected on polycrystalline samples to confirm their purity were acquired on a Philips X’PERT powder diffractometer as detailed in the SI.
On another level, variable-pressure PXRD experiments under argon and synthetic air as well as additional experiments of the samples under CO2 pressure were performed on a BRUKER D8 Advance A25 diffractometer as detailed in the SI (see the S1 section).
CCDC 2456148–2456153 (1Y, 2Nd, 3Eu, 4Gd, 5Tb and 6Dy) contain the supplementary crystallographic data for this paper.72a–f
| This journal is © the Partner Organisations 2026 |