Open Access Article
Marianna Tosato
*ab,
Fortuna Pontec,
Sara Franchid,
Nora V. Maye,
Mikael Jensenf,
Helmut Mäckeg,
Valerio Di Marco
d,
Laura Pigani
h,
Erika Ferrari
h,
Emilia Sicilia
c,
Mattia Astii and
Caterina F. Ramogida
*ab
aDepartment of Chemistry, Simon Fraser University, V5A 4Y8 Burnaby, British Columbia, Canada. E-mail: marianna_tosato@sfu.ca; cfr@sfu.ca
bLife Sciences, TRIUMF, V6T 2A3 Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada
cDepartment of Chemistry and Chemical Technologies, University of Calabria, 87036 Cosenza, Italy
dDepartment of Chemical Sciences, University of Padova, 35131 Padova, Italy
eCentre for Structural Science, Research Centre for Natural Sciences, 1117 Budapest, Hungary
fThe Hevesy Laboratory, Department of Health Technology, Technical University of Denmark, 4000 Roskilde, Denmark
gDepartment of Nuclear Medicine, University Hospital Freiburg, D-79106 Freiburg, Germany
hDepartment of Chemical and Geological Sciences, University of Modena and Reggio Emilia, 41125 Modena, Italy
iRadiopharmaceutical Chemistry Laboratory, Nuclear Medicine Unit, AUSL-IRCCS Reggio Emilia, 42122 Reggio Emilia, Italy
First published on 23rd April 2026
Coinage radiometals such as 64/67Cu and 103/111Ag offer unique opportunities for cancer theranostics, providing matched diagnostic and therapeutic radionuclides within the same chemical family. However, their clinical translation is limited by the lack of robust chelators for 103/111Ag and by the redox-induced instability of 64/67Cu complexes. To address these chelation challenges, we developed DO2S2Py, a sulfur-containing cyclen (cy)-based macrocycle incorporating pyridine (py) donors, introduced to create a protected coordination environment for silver and copper ions. DO2S2Py rapidly forms highly thermodynamically stable and kinetically inert 1
:
1 metal-to-ligand complexes with both Cu2+ and Ag+. Structural investigations reveal distinct yet strongly stabilized coordination environments for Cu2+ (4Ncy2Npy) and Ag+ (4Ncy1Npy1S and 4Ncy2Npy), underscoring the crucial contribution of the pyridine donors. Under highly diluted radiochemical conditions and mild labeling protocols, DO2S2Py efficiently binds 64Cu and 111Ag. The 64Cu complex demonstrates exceptional stability in PBS and human serum (>95% intact complex after 24 h), while the 111Ag analogue, though somewhat less stable (75% intact after 24 h), outperforms the current gold-standard chelator. These findings validate the incorporation of pyridine donors as an effective strategy toward unified chelation of theranostic coinage radiometals.
Among these, copper-64 (64Cu, t1/2 = 12.7 h) has a versatile emission profile that includes β−, β+ and electron capture decays and is highly suited for positron emission tomography (PET).5 Complementarily, copper-67 (67Cu, t1/2 = 2.58 d) is a pure β− emitter with accompanying low energy conversion and Auger electrons as well as γ rays that make it a candidate for therapy and single photon emission computed tomography (SPECT) imaging.2,3,5–10 On the other hand, silver radioisotopes, including silver-103 (103Ag, t1/2 = 65.7 min) and silver-111 (111Ag, t1/2 = 7.45 d), have recently attracted interest for their theranostic potential despite being less explored.1,5,11–15 These radioisotopes offer decay profiles suitable for β− therapy and associated SPECT (111Ag) or PET (103Ag) imaging modalities.1
A major challenge in the development of group 11-based theranostic radiopharmaceuticals lies in designing chelators that can form thermodynamically stable and kinetically inert complexes with both copper and silver ions under physiological conditions.16–21 Indeed, in the absence of such robust chelation, metal dissociation may occur in vivo, leading to uncontrolled redistribution of the radionuclide throughout the body. This can result in significant off-target toxicity, compromising patient safety and diminishing the diagnostic/therapeutic efficacy by preventing the radiation from reaching the tumor site. Developing a single ligand capable of effectively coordinating both copper and silver ions is also of strategic value, as it would enable the construction of chemically analogous radiopharmaceuticals that differ only in the choice of the radionuclide. Such a unified approach could streamline radiopharmaceutical development, simplify regulatory pathways, and offer clinicians a flexible toolkit for personalized nuclear medicine by switching between different diagnostic and therapeutic radioisotopes without altering the molecular architecture of the radiopharmaceutical.
Over the past decade, a variety of chelators, such as 1,4,7,10-tetraazacyclododecane-1,4,7,10-tetraacetic acid (DOTA), 1,4,8,11-tetraazacyclotetradecane-1,4,8,11-tetraacetic acid (TETA), and their cross-bridged analogues, have been developed to accommodate the borderline Lewis acid nature of [64/67Cu]Cu2+. Nonetheless, limitations such as in vivo transchelation, redox instability due to Cu2+ bioreduction to Cu+, and slow radiolabeling kinetics have limited their broader clinical adoption.9,22–32 More promising results have been achieved with 1,4,7-triazacyclononane-1,4,7-triacetic acid (NOTA) and its bifunctional derivative (NODAGA), as well as sarcophagine-based chelators (e.g., DiamSar), which currently represent the gold standards for [64/67Cu]Cu2+ binding.8 However, these chelators are poorly suited for Ag+, which prefers softer donor atoms compared to Cu2+.33 Designing effective ligands for Ag+ remains especially demanding due to its high lability and strong tendency toward ligand exchange reactions. In fact, despite the growing interest in silver radioisotopes for theranostic applications, the coordination (radio)chemistry of Ag+ remains largely unexplored, highlighting the need for further systematic studies.34–37
In response to these challenges, in recent years, our research group has focused on developing chelators for soft (radio)metals.38–46 In particular, we previously synthesized and characterized a library of sulfur-rich macrocyclic ligands tailored to the coordination preferences of group 11 metals (Fig. 1 and Fig. S1).38–44,47 These ligands exhibited high affinity for both Cu2+/+ and Ag+, even under highly dilute radiochemical conditions. Among them, 1,7-bis[2-(methylsulfanyl)ethyl]-1,4,7,10-tetraazacyclododecane-4,10-diacetic acid (DO2A2S) emerged as the top-performing candidate for copper radioisotopes, while 1,4,7,10-tetrakis[2-(methylsulfanyl)ethyl]-1,4,7,10-tetraazacyclododecane (DO4S) showed the best performance for silver radionuclides.41,43 However, the [111Ag][Ag(DO4S)]+ complex demonstrated limited stability in human serum, undergoing a noticeable degradation within a few hours.43 While this may still be acceptable for proof-of-concept preclinical investigations with short-lived Ag radioisotopes (e.g., 103Ag), it highlights the need for improved chelation strategies for this metal ion, especially for longer imaging windows or therapeutic use.
To overcome these limitations and develop a single versatile platform for the chelation of group 11 radiometals, in the present study we designed a novel octadentate macrocycle, namely 1,7-bis[2-(methylsulfanyl)ethyl]-4,10-bis[(pyridin-2-yl)methyl]-1,4,7,10-tetraazacyclododecane (DO2S2Py) (Fig. 1). The choice of a cyclen (cy) backbone was driven by our previous comparative studies, in which cyclen-based ligands outperformed those containing different macrocyclic cores (Fig. 1 and Fig. S1) in terms of stability and coordination efficiency with both Cu2+/+ and Ag+.38–40,42,43 We retained the two opposite sulfur-containing pendant arms, as they had previously shown a fundamental role in the metal coordination.38–40,42,43 To enhance complex robustness, we inserted two pyridine (py) moieties in the trans (1,7-N,N″-) positions. These moieties were selected for their known affinity for copper and silver, and their steric bulkiness, which we hypothesized would help to enforce a more spatially shielded coordination environment.48–51 This conformational constraint is expected to benefit the kinetic stabilization of the metal center, in particular Ag+ (the more labile metal ion), by reducing the susceptibility of the complex to dissociation or transchelation by endogenous biomolecules.
In this work, we report the synthesis and a comprehensive theoretical and experimental evaluation of DO2S2Py as a chelator for both copper and silver radioisotopes for nuclear medicine applications. We investigated its solution behavior, determined the thermodynamic stability constants, studied the complexation and decomplexation kinetics, and elucidated the solution structures of its Cu2+ and Ag+ complexes. The ability of DO2S2Py to bind [64Cu]Cu2+ and [111Ag]Ag+ under extremely diluted radiochemical conditions was also assessed and complemented with the evaluation of the in vitro stability of the corresponding radioactive complexes in biological environment, a pillar requirement for further in vivo applications.
In the second step, di-Boc-cyclen was reacted with 2-chloroethylmethyl sulfide in acetonitrile in the presence of K2CO3 to yield 1,7-bis(tert-butyloxycarbonyl)-4,10-bis(2-(methylsulfanyl)ethyl)-1,4,7,10-tetraazacyclododecane (3, di-Boc-DO2S). Subsequent acidic deprotection using trifluoracetic acid (TFA) in dichloromethane afforded 1,7-bis(2-(methylsulfanyl)ethyl)-1,4,7,10-tetraazacyclododecane as a TFA salt (4, DO2S), which was then alkylated with 2-(bromomethyl)pyridine hydrobromide in acetonitrile and in presence of K2CO3 to produce DO2S2Py (5). All the intermediates and DO2S2Py were fully characterized by Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (NMR – 1H NMR, 13C{1H} NMR, 1H–1H COSY, and 1H–13C HSQC), and high-resolution mass spectrometry (HR-MS). The corresponding spectra are reported in Fig. S2–S15. The overall multistep synthesis allowed to provide the pure chelator DO2S2Py, although in low yield (8%).
The 1H NMR spectra of DO2S2Py as a function of pH are shown in Fig. 2, along with signal assignments. The methyl protons (H1) of the thioether arms (SCH3) of DO2S2Py remain almost unaffected across the investigated pH range, consistently appearing as a singlet at ∼2 ppm. This behavior is attributed to their positioning far from the proton binding sites, making them essentially insensitive to the protonation state of the molecule. In contrast, all the other proton signals display a clear pH dependence, consistent with their proximity to protonable sites. At acidic pH, the methylene protons of the sulfur-containing sidechains (SCH2 and NCH2, H2 and H3) appear as two distinct broad singlets at 2.85 and 3.35 ppm, respectively. As the pH increases, these signals shift upfield and coalesce into a single resonance at 2.50 ppm at pH > 12. A similar trend is also observed for the NCH2 protons (H4) of the macrocyclic ring (i.e. they resonate as two separate singlets at 3.60 and 3.22 ppm at pH 2, and merge into one signal at 2.95 ppm above pH 12). The CH2 protons bridging the pyridine rings and the macrocycle (H5) resonate as a singlet throughout the titration but exhibit a continuous variation in chemical shift with increasing pH. The aromatic region also displays pronounced pH-dependent changes: the pyridine protons experience progressive upfield shifts upon deprotonation while the meta protons (H6 and H8) relative to the aromatic N coalesce into a single resonance below pH 7. The ortho (H9) and para (H7) protons remain distinct across the entire pH range. The pH-dependent chemical shift trends were fitted to derive the pKa values, reported in Table 1. The obtained data were corroborated by pH-potentiometric titrations (Table 1). The corresponding species distribution diagram is presented in Fig. S16. These results indicate that a mixture of bi- and monoprotonated species (H2L2+ and HL+) exist under physiological pH conditions.
| 1H NMR | Potentiometry | UV-Vis | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Equilibriaa | pKa | ||
| HL+ ⇌ L + H+ | 10.76 ± 0.03 | 10.8 ± 0.1 | — |
| H2L2+ ⇌ HL+ + H+ | 7.75 ± 0.09 | 7.82 ± 0.05 | 7.78 ± 0.1 |
| H3L3+ ⇌ H2L2+ + H+ | 3.10 ± 0.06 | 3.19 ± 0.05 | 3.33 ± 0.02 |
| H4L4+ ⇌ H3L3+ + H+ | 2.6 ± 0.1 | — | 2.53 ± 0.02 |
| Equilibriaa | logβ | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| a L represents the completely deprotonated form of DO2S2Py as shown in Fig. 1. The reported uncertainty was obtained by the fitting procedure and represents one standard deviation unit. | |||
| Cu2+ + L ⇌ [CuL]2+ | — | — | 23.62 ± 0.07 |
| Ag+ + L ⇌ [AgL]+ | 16.94 ± 0.08 | 16.83 ± 0.04 | — |
| Ag+ + HL ⇌ [AgHL]2+ | 20.64 ± 0.05 | 20.6 ± 0.1 | — |
| Ag+ + L + H2O ⇌ [AgL(OH)] + H+ | 6.65 ± 0.09 | 6.6 ± 0.1 | — |
DO2S2Py is formally a hexaprotic molecule, containing four tertiary amines within the macrocyclic ring and two pyridine nitrogen atoms. However, only four pKa values could be determined under our experimental conditions. The last two (pKa,5 and pKa,6) are attributed to the deprotonation of the two macrocyclic nitrogen atoms located opposite each other (Table 1). This assignment is supported by previous studies on cyclen-based ligands, which show preferential protonation at opposite sites to minimize electrostatic repulsion between adjacent protonated centers.47 The intermediate two pKa (pKa,3 and pKa,4) are ascribed to the deprotonation of the pyridine nitrogen atoms (Table 1). The first two protonation steps (pKa,1 and pKa,2), corresponding to the remaining tertiary amines of the cyclen ring, were not detected, likely due to their very low values (pKa < 1). These highly protonated species are typically unstable and only appreciably formed at extremely acidic pH (pH < 1), making their detection challenging. This behavior is well-documented in the literature and is a characteristic of cyclen-based macrocycles.47,52
The pKa values associated with the macrocyclic amine groups of DO2S2Py closely resemble those previously reported for sulfur-containing analogues such as DO4S, as well as for pyridine-functionalized derivatives including cyclen-1Py, cyclen-2Py, and cyclen-4Py (Table S1).47,50,51 Similarly, the pKa values attributed to the pyridine moieties of DO2S2Py are in good agreement with those of related ligands bearing only pyridine substituents (Table S1).50,51 This indicates that the presence of the sulfanyl side chains does not significantly perturb the protonation behavior of the pyridine nitrogen atoms, suggesting minimal electronic/steric influence on their basicity.
The protonation constants determined by 1H NMR spectroscopy were further corroborated through pH-dependent UV-Vis spectrophotometric titrations. Representative pH-dependent electronic spectra of DO2S2Py are shown in Fig. S17. The UV-Vis spectrum of DO2S2Py exhibits electronic transitions originating from both the aliphatic sulfur-containing macrocyclic core, which gives rise to absorption bands below 250 nm, and the pyridine rings, characterized by a distinct absorption maximum centered at 262 nm. The latter band closely resembles that observed for the monopyridine-functionalized cyclen analogue (cyclen-Py), suggesting that it can be attributed to the π–π* transitions of the pyridine moieties.50 Systematic pH-dependent variations in the electronic absorption spectra enabled the determination of the acidity constants of the ligand (pKa,2, pKa,3, and pKa,4), which are summarized in Table 1. Notably, these values are in excellent agreement with those obtained with other techniques.
No significant spectral changes were observed in the pH range 3–12, indicating that the speciation remains constant across this range and that a single Cu2+-containing species predominates. In contrast, at pH < 3, a marked decrease in absorbance was noted, and the spectral features increasingly resembled those of the free ligand (compare Fig. 2 with Fig. S21). This behavior is consistent with proton-induced dissociation of the complex and the release of the uncoordinated ligand occurring at highly acidic media (pH < 2). These spectroscopic data were fitted using a suitable equilibrium model, yielding the stability constant reported in Table 1. According to the derived speciation, DO2S2Py forms a single mononuclear complex with Cu2+, namely [CuL]2+. The stoichiometry of the complex was further confirmed by pH-potentiometry and mass spectrometry (Fig. S22). The latter revealed a single peak corresponding to the 1
:
1 metal-to-ligand species, with no evidence of polynuclear aggregates. The corresponding speciation diagram is presented in Fig. 3.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 3 Distribution diagrams of (A) Cu2+-DO2S2Py and (B) Ag+-DO2S2Py (CDO2S2Py = 1 × 10−4 M, CM = 1 × 10−4 M, M = Cu2+ or Ag+). | ||
Interestingly, compared to previously developed sulfur-containing analogues (e.g., DO4S), the Cu2+ complexation behavior of DO2S2Py is identical in terms of speciation: in all cases, only the fully deprotonated mononuclear species is formed.38 This suggests that the presence of the pyridine moiety does not alter the speciation profile. The formation of protonated species appears disfavored, likely due to the neutral nature of the ligand, which would lead to highly charged complexes ([CuHL]3+, [CuH2L]4+ etc.). The speciation model is also consistent with that of Cu2+-cyclen-1Py but differs from that of Cu2+-cyclen-2Py, where additional species such as the monoprotonated complex ([CuHL]3+) and a hydroxo-containing complex ([CuL(OH)]+) were observed (however, in this case, a different supporting electrolyte was used, i.e. NMe4NO3).50,51
At pH values above 11, the 1H NMR spectra are invariant, suggesting the predominance of a single species. Similarly, in the pH range 5–8, the 1H NMR spectra remain unchanged, implying the existence of a second complex. Below pH 4, additional spectral changes are observed, consistently with the presence of other species. The pronounced pH sensitivity of the spectra supports the presence of multiple, pH-dependent complexes differing in their protonation state, as also indicated by pH-potentiometry. The obtained 1H NMR and pH-potentiometric data were fitted to a suitable equilibrium model, from which the stability constants of the complexes were derived (Table 1). According to the proposed speciation model, DO2S2Py forms exclusively 1
:
1 metal-to-ligand complexes, namely [AgHL]2+, [AgL]+ and [AgL(OH)]. The corresponding species distribution diagram is reported in Fig. 3.
As with Cu2+, the speciation model determined for Ag+-DO2S2Py closely resembles those previously reported for analogous sulfur-containing chelators.42,43 The only notable difference is the detection of a hydroxo complex with this ligand, which was not observed for other cyclen-based chelators. The differences observed between Ag+ and Cu2+ also reflect previous findings, where the lower charge of Ag+ had shown to favor the formation of more protonated species.38,42
The high values observed for the pCu2+ and pAg+ of DO2S2Py indicate that the ligand exhibits strong affinity toward both metal ions (Fig. 4).
When benchmarked against the sulfur-containing chelators previously developed (e.g., DO4S and DO2A2S), as well as established ligands like NOTA and DOTA, DO2S2Py exhibits exceptional affinity for Cu2+ (Fig. 4).38 In particular, its pCu2+ value (pCu2+ = 20) exceeds that of DO2A2S (pCu2+ = 19.4), previously identified as our best-performing S-rich Cu2+ chelator, as well as those of NOTA (pCu2+ = 18.2), DOTA (pCu2+ = 17.4) and TETA (pCu2+ = 16.2).38 Notably, compared to other cyclen-based pyridine-containing ligands (e.g., cyclen-2Py and cyclen-1Py), DO2S2Py consistently forms more stable Cu2+ complexes (Fig. S26).50,51 This enhancement in stability suggests that the simultaneous presence of soft (S) and borderline (N) donor atoms allows us to fine-tune the ligand's coordination environment improving metal binding. Regarding Ag+, the complex formed with DO2S2Py exhibits thermodynamic stability nearly identical (pAg+ = 14) to Ag+-DO4S (pAg+ = 14.5), the current benchmark chelator for silver radioisotopes (Fig. 4).42 These results underscore the versatility of DO2S2Py as a chelator capable of effectively coordinating these metal ions despite their different coordination preferences, highlighting its potential for radiopharmaceutical applications.
The EPR spectrum of [Cu(DO2S2Py)]2+ in frozen solution is notably broad (Fig. 5) and could be described with parameters g⊥ = 2.067, g∥ = 2.248, and A∥ = 144 × 10−4 cm−1. Due to the broad perpendicular line, approximate axial g- and A-tensors could be simulated (Table 2), with considerable uncertainty in the perpendicular components. This pronounced broadening is likely the result of rhombic distortion in the coordination geometry, indicating a deviation from axial symmetry.
| Anisotropic parametersa | g0,calc b |
|||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| gx | gy | gz | Ax/10−4 cm−1 | Ay/10−4 cm−1 | Az/10−4 cm−1 | |
| a The experimental errors were ± 0.002 for gx and gy and ± 0.001 for gz, ± 2 × 10−4 cm−1 for Ax and Ay and ± 1 × 10−4 cm−1 for Az.b Calculated with the equation g0,calc = (gx + gy + gz)/3. | ||||||
| 2.067 | 2.067 | 2.248 | 12 | 12 | 144 | 2.127 |
In Table S3, the EPR parameters of several relevant Cu2+ macrocyclic complexes are compared with the values obtained in the present study.38,51 Based on this comparison, 4N and 4NS coordination modes can be excluded, as these typically exhibit significantly smaller g∥ values and larger A∥ values than those observed for [Cu(DO2S2Py)]2+. Instead, the parameters are closer to those reported for DO2A2S, in which two carboxylate side chains and two ring nitrogens occupy the equatorial plane, while the remaining two macrocyclic nitrogens are located farther from the metal center in axial positions.38
A similar coordination mode can be envisaged for Cu2+-DO2S2Py if the pyridine nitrogens coordinate in place of the carboxylate groups. In this case, the pyridine donors would be displaced slightly above and below the equatorial plane to minimize steric repulsion between them. The somewhat smaller g∥ values observed in our spectra are also consistent with this model, reflecting the stronger ligand field exerted by nitrogen donors compared to oxygen. Such geometry has also been confirmed by single-crystal X-ray diffraction for [Cu(CRpy2)],51 whose EPR parameters reported in frozen DMF solvent (150 K) were found to be close to those measured for [Cu(DO2S2Py)]2+. Deviations from an ideal elongated octahedral geometry (e.g., donor atoms bound to copper ions deviate from the equatorial plane or the axial donor groups forming angles smaller than 90° with the equatorial plane) contribute to strong rhombicity and the resulting spectral broadening.
The EPR spectrum of [Cu(DO2S2Py)]2+ at room temperature (Fig. S27) can be simulated by averaging the anisotropic parameters obtained from the frozen-state analysis. As in the frozen spectrum, the room temperature signal is also extremely broad, which is partly due to the relatively small copper hyperfine coupling constant. In addition, the rotational correlation time of 4.2 × 10−10 s suggests slow molecular tumbling, likely caused by steric hindrance from the non-coordinating side arms, which impede rotational motion.
To obtain further insights into the structures of the complexes formed by coordination of the DO2S2Py ligand, quantum mechanical DFT calculations were performed. All the relevant coordination geometries of DO2S2Py with Cu2+, as well as Cu+ and Ag+, were explored to identify the preferred coordination modes for each metal ion and to rationalize the experimentally observed behavior. The fully deprotonated form of DO2S2Py was considered in all the calculations.
Based on our simulations, the most stable structures were obtained when the metal was inserted into the cavity of the DO2S2Py ligand. All the optimized structures of the Cu2+ metal complexes are shown in Fig. S28 along with their Gibbs free energies (ΔG) calculated in water (Table 3). The most important distances between the ligand and the metals are reported in Table S4.
| Metal ion | Coordination mode | ΔG [kcal mol−1] |
|---|---|---|
| Cu2+ | 4Ncy2Npy | −34.3 |
| 4Ncy1Npy | −32.9 | |
| 4Ncy | −31.9 | |
| 4Ncy1S | −25.2 | |
| Cu+ | 3Ncy1Npy | −26.1 |
| 3Ncy1S | −24.2 | |
| 4Ncy | −23.2 | |
| Ag+ | 4Ncy1Npy1S | −21.7 |
| 4Ncy2Npy | −21.3 | |
| 4Ncy2S | −17.5 |
Upon coordination of Cu2+, all the computed structures exhibit high stability, indicating that the ligand has a strong affinity for the metal center, in agreement with experimental observations. The most stable structure is obtained when the Cu2+ cation is placed in the middle of the macrocycle but slightly displaced above the cavity, forming strong coordination bonds with three nitrogen atoms of the macrocyclic core (Ncy) and with the two pyridine nitrogen atoms (Npy). A weaker interaction is established with the fourth nitrogen atom of the macrocycle. This coordination mode is denoted as [Cu2+–4Ncy2Npy]. The resulting coordination geometry confirms experimental findings of a distorted elongated octahedral arrangement, with the two pyridine nitrogens lying within the equatorial plane, whereas two nitrogen atoms of the macrocycle occupy the axial position.
The calculated electronic spectrum for this configuration closely reproduces the experimental one reported in Fig. S18. The optimized structure of the [Cu2+–4Ncy2Npy] complex, together with its UV-Vis spectrum, computed using the same theoretical protocol, is reported in Fig. 6. The electronic transitions describing the absorption spectrum were fully characterized and are collected in Table S5. The Gibbs free energy calculated for the formation of [Cu2+–4Ncy2Npy] species is −34.3 kcal mol−1 (Table 3), corresponding to a logβ value of 25.1. This calculated value is in surprisingly good agreement with the experimental logβ of 23.6 ± 0.07 (Table 1).
![]() | ||
| Fig. 6 (A) DFT optimized geometry of the most stable structure of [Cu(DO2S2Py)]2+, namely [Cu2+–4Ncy2Npy] and (B) the corresponding calculated TDDFT absorption spectrum. | ||
For the geometry denoted as [Cu2+–4Ncy1Npy], in which the metal, lying in the center of the cyclen backbone, is simultaneously coordinated to the four ring nitrogen atoms and one pyridine ligand, the calculated free energy is −32.9 kcal mol−1 (Table 3), corresponding to a logβ value of 24. DFT calculations, therefore, do not completely rule out the coexistence of multiple stable coordination modes of the ligand in aqueous solution.
A third stable complex was computationally identified, indicated as [Cu2+–4Ncy1S], that exhibits a Gibbs free energy of formation of −25.2 kcal mol−1 (Table 3) and a corresponding logβ value of 18.5. Unlike the species described previously, this complex involves the coordination of one of the sulfur atoms from the pendant arms, which results in an evident minor stability. The soft character of the sulfur atom, and its lower σ-donation ability compared to nitrogen-based donors, likely contribute to the lower affinity of this ligand toward the Cu2+ metal ion. In the fourth and least stable configuration, [Cu2+–4Ncy], all pendant arms of DO2S2Py are oriented away from the metal center, leaving Cu2+ coordinated exclusively to the four nitrogen atoms of the macrocyclic cavity. This geometry can be classified as a pseudo square-planar arrangement with no axial donor interactions. The calculated Gibbs free energy for this species is −31.9 kcal mol−1 (Table 3), corresponding to a logβ value of 23.4. For all the optimized structures, the calculated Gibbs free energies indicate a good stability of the formed complexes, and all the corresponding electronic spectra were calculated. Among them, only the spectrum of the complex named [Cu2+–4Ncy2Npy], reported in Fig. 6, closely matches the experimental one.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 7 Comparison of 1H NMR spectra of [Ag(DO2S2Py)]+ and free DO2S2Py (HL+ form) (400 MHz, D2O, T = 25 °C). | ||
Comparison of the 1H NMR spectrum of [Ag(DO2S2Py)]+ with that of the free ligand bearing the same net charge (HL+) provides important insights into the solution structures of this complex (Fig. 7). The pyridine protons (H6–H9) are consistently deshielded in [Ag(DO2S2Py)]+ compared to the free ligand. A similar downfield shift is observed for the SCH3 and SCH2 protons (H1 and H2) and the NCH2 protons connecting the cyclen backbone to the pyridine arms (H5). In contrast, the aliphatic N-bound protons on the macrocyclic backbone (H3 and H4) experience an overall upfield shift. These variations are consistent with coordination-induced electronic effects: deshielding near the metal due to its electron-withdrawing nature and shielding on the nitrogen-bound protons due to increased electron density upon metal coordination. Indeed, in the free ligand, protonation is localized on the amines, which leads to relatively lower electron density in these protons. In contrast, in the complexes, Ag+ likely interacts simultaneously with both nitrogen and sulfur donors, redistributing electron density and shielding the N-bound protons. Similar trends have been previously reported for Ag+ complexes of analogous sulfur-containing ligands.42,43
Collectively, the combination of chemical shift changes and the presence of single resonances for each set of chemically equivalent protons of [Ag(DO2S2Py)]+ indicates that all donors are, on average, involved in the metal binding. The data further suggests a dynamic binding regime, in which the donor atoms undergo rapid binding–unbinding events. In particular, the sulfur-containing side arms appear to experience relatively slow-exchange dynamics, as evidenced by their very broad resonances (almost approaching coalescence), whereas the pyridine donors are in fast exchange, resulting in averaged and relatively sharp signals. This fluxional behavior highlights that a flexible coordination mode is favored when Ag+ is confined in a highly dentate macrocyclic scaffold, as previously observed with similar systems.42,43
To support NMR data and clarify coordination geometry of Ag+, DFT computations were performed. Fig. S29 reports all the optimized molecular structures for [Ag(DO2S2Py)]+, along with their corresponding Gibbs free energies (ΔG) calculated in aqueous solution. In line with experimental observations, Ag+ forms less stable coordination complexes compared to Cu2+, with the metal located inside the macrocyclic cavity but weakly bound, as indicated by the coordination bond lengths exceeding 2.5 Å. This behavior is reflected in the Gibbs free energy value for the complex formation, which increases by approximately +10 kcal mol−1 in presence of Ag+ rather than Cu2+ (Table 3). The two most stable configurations were identified, which have similar formation free energies, but different structural features (Fig. 8).
![]() | ||
| Fig. 8 DFT optimized geometries of the most stable structures of [Ag(DO2S2Py)]+ calculated in water together with the relative binding energies (kcal mol−1). | ||
The first one, denoted as [Ag+–4Ncy1Npy1S], has a Gibbs free energy of −21.7 kcal mol−1 (Table 3) corresponding to a logβ of 15.9. In this species, the Ag+ ion is located inside the cyclen backbone and coordinates the four nitrogen atoms of the macrocycle, one pyridine nitrogen and one sulfur-containing side arm. The second configuration, named [Ag+–4Ncy2Npy], is slightly less stable and features the coordination of all nitrogen atoms of DO2S2Py to the metal. The calculated Gibbs free energy is −21.3 kcal mol−1 (Table 3) corresponding to a logβ of 15.6. Both complexes are therefore predicted to be formed in aqueous solution, with logβ values close to the experimentally reported one of 16.94.
When both sulfur atoms, even if softer than nitrogen, are coordinated to Ag+, a decrease in free energy and logβ is observed (Fig. S29). For this configuration, named [Ag+–4Ncy2S], the Gibbs free energy is −17.5 kcal mol−1 (Table 3) and the calculated logβ is 12.8.
Representative time-dependent UV-Vis spectra for [Cu(DO2S2Py)]2+ in different competitive media are shown in Fig. S30. Notably, no significant spectral changes were observed over 24 hours, indicating that [Cu(DO2S2Py)]2+ is inert under these conditions and that DO2S2Py does not form stable complexes with the selected competing cations, as no spectral changes relative to the free ligand were observed upon addition of these ions. Furthermore, the complex remained stable in phosphate-buffered saline (PBS), further supporting its high kinetic robustness under physiological conditions. A similar behavior was observed for the Ag+ counterpart, as illustrated in Fig. S31. No evidence of demetallation or complex degradation was detected over time, underscoring the exceptional inertness of this complex.
Representative changes in the electronic spectra of [Cu(DO2S2Py)]2+ upon incubation in increasingly acidic solutions are shown in Fig. S32 and the corresponding dissociation half-lives (dt1/2) are reported in Table S6. The observed first-order dissociation rate constants (dkobs) exhibit a linear dependence on proton concentration (Fig. S33), suggesting that only one complex undergoes dissociation and that the protonation constant of the predissociation step is low.40 Accordingly, the second-order rate constant (dk) was derived using the relationship dkobs = dk[H+].
A comparison with dk values for other sulfur-containing chelators is provided in Table 4. Based on the data, the kinetic inertness of the Cu2+ complexes follows the order: DO2A2S > DO2S2Py ≈ DO4S ≫ TE4S. This indicates that the inclusion of both sulfur- and pyridine-containing pendant arms on a cyclen backbone does not enhance the kinetic inertness of the complex against acid-induced dissociation, which on the other hand is enhanced in the presence of negatively charged groups such as the acetate of DO2A2S. However, this ranking reflects behavior under highly acidic conditions and may not directly translate to in vivo environments, where such extreme acidity is not encountered. Therefore, other tests such as the human serum stability were conducted (see below).
| DO4S | DO2A2S | TE4S | DO2S2Py | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| dk [M−1 s−1] | (5.7 ± 0.1) × 10−4 | (1.04 ± 0.02) × 10−4 | ∼10−2 | (5.32 ± 0.05) × 10−4 |
The decomplexation kinetics of the Ag+ counterpart were only qualitatively evaluated. Indeed, upon dissolution of [Ag(DO2S2Py)]+ in highly acidic conditions (pH ≪ 2), the 1H NMR spectrum changes immediately, becoming identical to that of the free ligand with no further spectral changes over time. This observation suggests that the Ag+ complex is significantly more labile under these conditions than its Cu2+ counterpart. This difference likely arises from the intrinsic electronic characteristics of the two metals: Ag+ is a d10 ion, generally more labile, while Cu2+ is a d9 ion, forming more inert complexes.
The theoretical results indicate that DO2S2Py can coordinate the Cu+ center, but the resulting complexes are approximately 10 kcal mol−1 less stable than the corresponding Cu2+ complexes (Table 3). Several attempts were made to explore in detail all the possible coordination modes, but only three distinct configurations were identified. In all cases, Cu+ is located within the macrocyclic cavity. In the first geometry, designated as [Cu+–3Ncy1Npy], the copper center forms three coordination bonds with three nitrogen atoms of the macrocyclic ring and additionally coordinates one of the two pyridine donors. In the second geometry, identified as [Cu+–3Ncy1S], the coordination of the pyridine nitrogen is replaced by the sulfur atom from one pendant arm.
The calculated free energy for the former is −26.1 kcal mol−1, corresponding to logβ = 19.1, whereas for the latter the free energy is −24.2 kcal mol−1 with logβ = 17.7 (Table 3). In the third configuration, denoted as [Cu+–4Ncy], the Cu+ center coordinates all four donor atoms of the cyclen ring, but this arrangement is approximately 3 kcal mol−1 less stable than the most favorable geometry (Table 3). The corresponding free energy is −23.2 kcal mol−1 (Table 3), corresponding to logβ = 17.0. The reduced stability of the Cu+ complexes compared to the Cu2+ analogues can be rationalized in terms of a reduced macrocyclic effect, a trend widely reported in the literature for this metal center.54 Under these conditions, Cu+ preferentially adopts a coordination number of four, and realizing this geometry requires several structural adjustments within the chelator to maximize the metal–ligand interactions.
Cyclic voltammetry (CV) was performed, and the resulting voltammograms are shown in Fig. S35. Unexpectedly, the voltammogram of [Cu(DO2S2Py)]2+ displayed an irreversible reduction signal located at approximately −0.5 V. In the reverse scan, the voltammogram instead shows a peak at around 0.05 V, very close to the oxidation peak of free Cu+ in solution.38 This suggests that the ligand is unable to effectively stabilize the reduced Cu+ species.
This voltammetric behavior appears surprising given that DO2S2Py can bind Ag+ and that DFT calculations support the formation of stable complexes with Cu+ as well. We hypothesize that, upon reduction, the ligand cannot reorganize rapidly enough to enable an effective coordination by the softer sulfur donors, likely due to steric hindrance and the conformational rigidity imposed by the bulky pyridine groups. This behavior contrasts with that of other sulfur-containing chelators, such as DO2A2S and DO4S, which have been shown to stabilize both oxidation states of copper.38 However, a similar lability is often observed in the literature with other cyclen-based chelators.50,51
![]() | ||
| Fig. 9 Concentration-, time-, and temperature-dependent [64Cu]Cu2+ radiolabeling with DO2S2Py at (A) pH 4.5 and (B) pH 7. | ||
At pH 4.5, quantitative radiochemical yields (RCY > 99%) were obtained at a maximum apparent molar activity (AMAmax) of 1 MBq nmol−1 (corresponding to a CDO2S2Py = 10−5 M) both at room temperature and 95 °C. Notably, no significant differences in the achievable AMAmax were observed upon extending the reaction time from 5 min to 60 min. Indeed, when the chelator concentration was reduced to 10−6 M and 10−7 M, the RCY dropped below 50% and 10%, respectively, highlighting a limit in the achievable apparent molar activity under these conditions.
At pH 7, quantitative RCY > 95% was achieved at room temperature within 5 min at AMAmax = 1 MBq nmol−1 (CDO2S2Py = 10−5 M). Also in this case, prolonged incubation did not increase the AMAmax that remained limited to 1 MBq nmol−1. In contrast, heating the reaction mixture at 95 °C enabled a tenfold increase in apparent molar activity (AMAmax = 10 MBq nmol−1, CDO2S2Py = 10−6 M) with respect to ambient temperature. No impact on the reaction time was observed.
The differences observed between the two investigated pH values are consistent with previous results obtained using analogous sulfur-rich chelators.39,41 These changes are attributed to the lower degree of protonation of the chelator at higher pH, which facilitates complexation by reducing electrostatic repulsion between the protonated donor sites and the incoming [64Cu]Cu2+ ions.
Compared to one of the current standards for radiocopper chelation, NOTA, DO2S2Py shows a similar performance at both pH values (Fig. S36). In contrast, when evaluated against previously reported sulfur-rich cyclen-based chelators (e.g., DO4S and DO2A2S), DO2S2Py performs at a comparable or slightly lower level. However, this apparent discrepancy may arise from the use of different copper batches in the respective experiments.39
![]() | ||
| Fig. 10 Concentration- and temperature-dependent [111Ag]Ag+ radiolabeling with DO2S2Py at pH 7.4 after (A) 5 min and (B) 60 min. | ||
Quantitative radiometal incorporation was achieved up to 0.1 MBq nmol−1 within 5 min. The RCY dropped to approximately 50% at 100 MBq nmol−1. Heating the reaction mixture to 95 °C significantly enhanced the radiolabeling efficiency, increasing the AMAmax to 1 MBq nmol−1. Extending the reaction time did not produce appreciable improvement in the radiometal incorporation.
Under these conditions, the AMAmax attained was 1 MBq nmol−1, roughly one order of magnitude lower than that observed with [64Cu]Cu2+. However, this difference may reflect varying levels of metal impurities between the two radioisotopes, which can influence complexation behavior. Consequently, no definitive conclusions regarding chelator selectivity or preference can be drawn. Nonetheless, the results indicate that the chelator exhibits strong affinity for both radiometals. Compared to DO4S, the performance of DO2S2Py appears slightly inferior (Fig. S37).
As illustrated in Fig. 11, [64Cu][Cu(DO2S2Py)]2+ showed excellent stability under both conditions, with no detectable radiometal release and retention of >95% integrity after 24 h. [111Ag][Ag(DO2S2Py)]+ displayed lower stability compared to its copper analogue: after 24 h, it maintained ∼90% integrity in PBS, while it dropped to ∽75% in human serum. The modest decomplexation observed in PBS likely reflects competitions with chloride ions, while the further stability decline in serum is probably caused by interactions with serum components (e.g., albumin). However, it is important to note that [111Ag][Ag(DO2S2Py)]+ outperformed the previously best-performing chelator for silver radioisotopes (DO4S), underscoring the beneficial effect of incorporating pyridine arms (Fig. S38). These additional donor groups appear to provide enhanced shielding of the metal center, thereby reducing susceptibility to competing biological ligands.
![]() | ||
Fig. 11 Integrity of (A, B) [64Cu][Cu(DO2S2Py)]2+ and (C, D) [111Ag][Ag(DO2S2Py)]+ in PBS (A and C) and human serum (B and D) (1 : 1 V/V dilution). | ||
Organic reactions were monitored by thin-layer chromatography (TLC) on aluminum plates coated with silica gel 60 F254 (Merck). Flash column chromatography was performed using high-purity silica gel (60 Å, 230–400 mesh, 40–63 μm, Merck), with the appropriate eluents, as described in the corresponding section. The final product (DO2S2Py) was purified by reverse-phase semipreparative high-performance liquid chromatography (RP-HPLC) using a Phenomenex Luna C18 (150 mm × 100 mm) column. NMR spectra were recorded on a Bruker AVANCE AMX 400 spectrometer (1H: 400.12 MHz; 13C: 100.13 MHz) or a Bruker AVANCE AMX 600 spectrometer equipped with a CryoProbe BBO H&F 5 mm in inverse detection (1H: 600.13 MHz, 13C: 150.13 MHz). 1H and 13C{1H} NMR spectra are reported on the chemical shifts (δ) scale and referenced to residual solvent peaks or 3-(trimethylsilyl)propionic acid sodium salt (TSP) in D2O. Signal multiplicity is reported as follows: s = singlet, d = doublet, t = triplet, br = broad peak, m = multiplet. Mass spectrometry (MS) analyses were performed on an Agilent 6210 TOF LC/MS, an Advion expression LC-MS, or an Agilent 6300 Ion Trap LC-MS system equipped with an electrospray (ESI) source. The pH was measured with a Mettler Toledo SevenEasy pH-meter and a Crison (pH 0–14) combined glass electrode. UV-Vis spectra were recorded on a JASCO V-770 UV/Vis/NIR spectrophotometer over the 200–800 nm spectral range, using quartz cells with 1 cm optical path. EPR spectra were acquired with a Bruker EleXsys E500 spectrometer. CV measurements were carried out using an Autolab PGSTAT-30 potentiostat, under the control of GPES software. Unless otherwise stated, no uncommon hazards were noted during the experiments.
:
2) as eluent to afford di-Boc-cyclen as a colorless oil (520.8 mg, yield = 60%). 1H NMR (400 MHz, CDCl3, 25 °C) δ (ppm): 3.26 (t, 8 H, NCH2), 3.03 (s, 2 H, NH), 2.76 (t, 8 H, NCH2), 1.37 (s, 18 H, CH3). ESI-MS: m/z 373.28 (found); 373.28 (calc. for [C18H37N4O4]+).
:
1 + 1% NH3 to 95
:
5 + 1% NH3). The desired product, di-Boc-DO2S, was obtained as a light-yellow oil (210.5 mg, 33% yield). 1H NMR (400 MHz, CDCl3, 25 °C) δ (ppm): 3.34 (s, 8 H, NCH2), 2.67 (t, 12 H, NCH2), 2.54 (t, 4 H, SCH2), 2.09 (s, 6 H, SCH3), 1.43 (s, 18 H, CH3). 13C NMR (400 MHz, CDCl3, 25 °C) δ (ppm): 156.0 (C
O), 79.5 (–
(CH3)), 54.3 + 54.7 (NCH2), 46.8 (NCH2), 31.5 (SCH2), 28.6 (CH3), 15.9 (SCH3). ESI-MS: m/z 521.32 (found); 521.32 (calc. for [C24H49N4O4S2]+).
:
1 metal-to-ligand ratio) in buffered media (e.g., pH 2 HCl 10−2 M, pH 4.5 acetic/acetate buffer). To ensure the equilibrium was reached, the spectra of all samples were also re-acquired after heating at T = 80 °C until no further changes were observed.
:
L molar ratio of 1
:
1) were recorded at T = 25 °C in D2O. The pH was adjusted by proper additions of DNO3/DCl or CO2-free NaOD. 0.41 log units were added to the instrumental pH values to account for isotopic effects, i.e. pD values instead of pH ones were considered.
For each complexation reaction, the free energy was computed replacing water molecules in the reference complexes. The reference complex for Cu2+ is square planar, with four water molecules in the first coordination sphere and two water molecules in the second coordination sphere. For Ag+, the reference complex is linear, with two water molecules in the first coordination sphere.
The free energies of formation of these complexes are calculated using the reaction (1):
| [M(H2O)n]z + L → [ML]z + nH2O | (1) |
Gibbs free energies were obtained at T = 25 °C and 1 atm including zero-point and thermal corrections. Therefore, the formation energies of the examined complexes were calculated as:
| ΔG = ΔG([ML]z) + nΔG(H2O) − ΔG([M(H2O)n]z) − ΔG(L) | (2) |
The stability constant (logβ) value is related to free energy change for the complexation reaction by:
![]() | (3) |
Complexation energies were corrected for the basis set superposition error (BSSE) by using the Boys-Bernardi counterpoise technique.65
:
1 V/V dilution) were added to a solution of the preformed complexes and spectral variations induced by the additions of the competitor were monitored at room temperature over time using UV-Vis (Cu2+; CDO2S2Py = CCu = 1 × 10−4 M) or 1H-NMR (Ag+; CDO2S2Py = CAg = 1 × 10−3 M). All experiments were performed in MilliQ water at least in triplicate to ensure reproducibility.
:
CH3OH 9
:
1 + 0.1% NH4OH as mobile phase. Under these conditions, free [111Ag]Ag+ is retained at the origin (Rf = 0) while [111Ag][Ag(DO2S2Py)]+ has Rf = 0.6. To track the radiolabeling of [111Ag][Ag(DO4S)]+, the conditions previously described were used.43 The TLC plates were exposed to a multi-sensitive medium phosphor screen (PerkinElmer) and analyzed using a Cyclone Plus Storage Phosphor System (PerkinElmer).
:
1 V/V dilution), respectively. The 1
:
1 V/V dilution was selected to maintain consistency with previously conducted studies, allowing reliable comparison of the data. The solutions were incubated at T = 37 °C to simulate the biological environment. The integrity of the radiometal complexes was monitored over time via radio-TLC, using the mobile and stationary phases described above. Free [64Cu]Cu2+ and free [111Ag]Ag+ in human serum were used as controls. Any [64Cu]Cu2+ transchelated with serum proteins migrated with EDTA solvent front (Rf ∼ 1), while intact radiometal complex remained at the baseline (Rf ∼ 0). In contrast, any [111Ag]Ag+ transchelated with serum proteins remained at the baseline (Rf ∼ 0) while intact metal complex had Rf = 0.6. The percentage of intact complex was determined by integrating the areas under the curves corresponding to the free and intact species.Building on our previous work on sulfur-containing macrocycles for the chelation of theranostic radiometals, we sought to enhance the biological stability of the resulting radiometal complexes. Although these earlier ligands displayed promising coordination properties, the corresponding radioactive complexes showed only moderate stability under biologically relevant conditions. To address this limitation, we incorporated pyridine donor units in the macrocyclic framework, creating a sterically protected coordination environment.
The resulting ligand, DO2S2Py, rapidly coordinates both Cu2+ and Ag+, forming complexes that are highly thermodynamically stable and kinetically inert. In [Cu(DO2S2Py)]2+, the copper center adopts a distorted elongated octahedral geometry involving the two pyridine nitrogen atoms and the four nitrogens from the cyclen backbone (4Ncy2Npy). In contrast, [Ag(DO2S2Py)]+ displays multiple coordination modes in aqueous solutions (4Ncy1Npy1S and 4Ncy2Npy) reflecting the adaptable yet strongly binding nature of the ligand scaffold. In both cases, the pyridine donors play a key role in reinforcing metal coordination and enhancing complex stability.
Importantly, DO2S2Py also efficiently complexes the corresponding radioactive isotopes (64Cu and 111Ag) under highly diluted radiochemical conditions and mild labeling protocols. [64Cu][Cu(DO2S2Py)]2+ exhibited exceptional stability in biologically relevant media (>95% intact after 24 h), specifically PBS and human serum. Although [111Ag][Ag(DO2S2Py)]+ was less stable (75% intact after 24 h in human serum), it showed improved performance compared to the current best-performing chelator for 111Ag, i.e. DO4S.
Collectively, these results demonstrate that incorporation of pyridine donors effectively enhances complex stability and inertness in biological environments, thereby validating our design strategy. Overall, DO2S2Py represents a significant step toward the development of a unified chelator platform capable of stabilizing theranostic coinage radiometals under physiologically relevant conditions.
| This journal is © the Partner Organisations 2026 |