Jeongsuk
Seo
*,
Seongeon
Mun
and
Van-Huy
Trinh
Department of Chemistry, College of Natural Sciences, Chonnam National University, 77 Yongbong-ro, Buk-gu, Gwangju 61186, Republic of Korea. E-mail: j_seo@chonnam.ac.kr
First published on 28th October 2025
This study demonstrates that BaTaO2N photoanodes grown on Ta substrates via bottom-up fabrication exhibit highly efficient and stable photoelectrochemical (PEC) seawater splitting under simulated sunlight. Enhanced H2 evolution is achieved, particularly in acidic to neutral pH conditions, where the oxygen evolution reaction (OER) typically proceeds at a slower rate. This improvement is attributed to the predominant chlorine evolution reaction (CER), facilitated by a kinetically favorable two-electron transfer pathway. The high crystallinity and cuboidal morphology of BaTaO2N, combined with uniform Co(OH)x catalyst loading, result in over 80% photocurrent retention and a faradaic efficiency close to 100% after continuous seawater splitting for 24 h. This outstanding efficiency is attributed to the distinct band structure of BaTaO2N, which hinders the formation of hydroxyl radicals and selectively promotes oxidation through CER and OER. Remarkably, CER outperforms OER at pH levels below 7.5, while OER becomes more dominant at higher pH levels. Moreover, the free chlorine produced during CER decomposes gradually back to O2 and Cl− through photolytic and chemical processes, which ensures continuous regeneration of Cl− in the bulk electrolyte. This self-sustaining cycle facilitates prolonged photoreaction within a fixed seawater volume, which eliminates the need for continuous seawater flow configurations. By overcoming a crucial obstacle in the scalable generation of solar H2 from seawater, these results provide a promising route for sustainable and selective PEC seawater splitting.
Seawater is rich in halide salts, with chloride (Cl−) being the most prevalent at around 0.55 M. The thermodynamic potential of the chlorine evolution reaction (CER) at 1.36 VNHE is more oxidizing than that of the OER at 1.23 VNHE, which is reflected in the following equations:6
| 2Cl− ⇌ Cl2 (g) + 2e− E° = 1.36 VNHE | (1) |
| 2H2O ⇌ O2 (g) + 4H+ + 4e− E° = (1.23 − 0.0592 pH) VNHE | (2) |
Although CER is thermodynamically more oxidizing than OER during seawater splitting, it can be preferentially driven due to its kinetically faster two-electron transfer compared to the four-electron transfer of OER. CER is especially likely to compete with OER in environments where OER kinetics very slow, such as acidic or neutral electrolytes.7–10 A nanostructured WO3 photoanode produced chlorine (Cl2) with an average faradaic efficiency of 70% during sunlight-driven seawater splitting in aqueous 0.5 M NaCl solution at pH 2, with O2 as a minor byproduct.9 Our group demonstrated enhanced seawater splitting activity using perovskite oxynitrides ABO2N (A = La, Sr; B = Ti, Nb) in a 0.5 M NaCl electrolyte at pH 6.4 under simulated sunlight.10,11 At neutral pH, the anodic photoactivity (including CER and OER) in artificial seawater at an applied potential of 1.23 VRHE was more than three times higher than that of OER in aqueous buffer solution, which indicates that CER was preferentially catalyzed. Quantitative analysis showed that a large amount of O2 was produced, which corresponds to a faradaic efficiency of approximately 50% with hypochlorite (ClO−) detected as a minor species—even when CER proceeded more rapidly than OER.10 These results indicate that CER dominates in seawater, although its products vary depending on pH.
In seawater splitting, the oxidation of Cl− produces Cl2, hypochlorous acid (HOCl) and/or ClO−, depending on the pH (Fig. S1).12 Cl2 evolved from CER may dissolve in water and undergo hydrolysis to form HOCl, a weak acid that partly dissociates to ClO− according to the following chemical equilibria:13
| Cl2 + 2H2O ⇌ HOCl + H3O+ + Cl− Kh = 4.2 × 10−4 M | (3) |
| HOCl + H2O ⇌ ClO− + H3O+ Ka = 3.0 × 10−8 M | (4) |
The concentration of Cl− has a strong effect on the fraction of HOCl produced in acidic pH environments (Fig. S1). CER produces mainly hydrolyzed HOCl in acidic seawater, including 0.5 M NaCl, while it releases Cl2 in a concentrated 3.4 M NaCl solution employed for the industrial chlor-alkali process. In addition, the increase in pH gradually alters the product ratio of CER from HOCl to dissociated ClO−. In addition to the dependence of pH, CER products are partly oxidized to toxic chlorate (ClO3−) and/or perchlorate (ClO4−) during seawater splitting due to their own oxidizing power and/or the presence of hydroxyl radicals.12,14,15 These products can also undergo partial photolysis under ultraviolet (UV) irradiation, forming O2, chlorite (ClO2−), ClO3−, and/or Cl−.8,15 Because of the diversity of products and the resulting undesirable chain reactions, the faradaic efficiency of seawater splitting has remained low, and the selectivity for CER becomes unclear. This limits the development potential of solar seawater splitting for efficient H2 production. Moreover, while the pH dependence of electrochemical seawater splitting has been investigated, the effect of pH on the activity and selectivity of PEC seawater splitting for CER and/or OER has not yet been reported.16,17 Therefore, it is necessary to investigate the reaction behavior between CER and OER during PEC water splitting at different pH levels, and to determine the faradaic efficiency and selectivity for CER through quantitative analysis of the actual products.
Perovskite oxynitrides with the general formula AB(O,N)3 (A = La, Ca, Sr, or Ba; B = Ti, Nb, or Ta) can absorb a wide range of visible-light wavelengths up to 750 nm. They are also capable of driving various artificial photosynthesis reactions, including (sea)water splitting, due to their favorable band structures, which enables a theoretically high solar-to-fuel conversion efficiency.6,18 Among the perovskite oxynitrides, BaTaO2N with a bandgap energy (Eg) of 1.9 eV (λ < 660 nm) is the most promising semiconductor for (sea)water splitting because its photoactivity under simulated sunlight has been found to be the highest (the onset potential of approximately 0.6–0.7 VRHE and 5–6 mA cm−2 at 1.23 VRHE) and significantly stable for 24 h (79% retention of initial photocurrent).19–21 Nevertheless, its high photoactivity is still limited to strong alkaline electrolytes, such as pH 13, rather than neutral pH. The splitting of neutral seawater using BaTaO2N under sunlight should, thus, be scientifically meaningful to discuss the pH dependence of CER on its selectivity and feasibility for efficient and stable H2 evolution. In addition, the regeneration of Cl− in the bulk electrolyte via decomposition of CER products (i.e., free chlorine species indicating Cl2, HOCl, and ClO−) has not been explicitly investigated during long-term PEC seawater splitting. If the Cl− consumed during CER can be replenished in situ by the decomposition of free chlorine species, it would enable a closed-loop PEC cell for sustainable H2 evolution without the need for external Cl− replenishment. Such a mechanism would not only enhance the stability and scalability of solar-driven seawater splitting but also mitigate the accumulation of harmful byproducts (e.g., ClO3−, ClO4−). On the other hand, a gradual decrease in bulk Cl− concentration over time may reduce the diffusion-limited photocurrent, thereby lowering the rate of H2 evolution even under stable light and operating potential.22 This highlights the critical importance of continuous Cl− regeneration in maintaining steady-state reactions for long-term PEC performance.
In this study, we demonstrate the sustainable long-term seawater splitting using a highly crystalline cuboidal BaTaO2N photoanode grown on a Ta substrate (prepared via bottom-up fabrication and subsequently loaded with a Co(OH)x electrocatalyst) in artificial seawater under simulated (AM 1.5 G) sunlight. Prior to the prolonged photoreaction, the photoactivity and selectivity for CER of the synthesized BaTaO2N were investigated in aqueous 0.5 M NaCl electrolytes at various pH values, which were compared with those in aqueous buffered electrolytes. High faradaic efficiency and selectivity for CER were also estimated during the PEC seawater splitting of oxynitride—as determined by quantitative analyses using gas chromatography (GC) and colorimetric detection. In addition, the photo-assisted decomposition studies of CER products, i.e., free chlorine species, provide critical insights into previously ambiguous findings (particularly the unexpected excess O2 gas detected in quantitative analyses). These observations provide valuable insights into the underlying mechanisms that govern long-term seawater splitting. Based on these results, this study aims to identify the optimal optical properties of semiconductors and the electrolyte pH values that enable enhanced solar-driven seawater splitting. Under these conditions, a Cl− regeneration mechanism will be investigated. Ultimately, this work proposes a set of photoreaction strategies to sustain a continuous H2 evolution rate and offers practical guidelines for achieving efficient and durable solar seawater splitting.
:
50 vol%. Thirty microliters of the Ba(NO3)2 solution were uniformly drop-cast onto the anodized Ta substrate, which was followed by annealing in air at 413 K for 5 min. The resulting Ta substrate was nitrided in a 100 mL min−1 flow of high-purity NH3 (6 N grade) at 1273 K for 1 h, with a ramping rate of 10 K min−1. After the first nitridation, loosely bonded BaTaO2N particles on the substrate were removed by ultrasonic treatment in a water bath. The surface-modified substrate then underwent a second nitridation under the same conditions. The final substrate, which exhibited a reddish-brown color, is hereafter referred to as the BaTaO2N/Ta photoanode.
| ERHE = EAg/AgCl + 0.0592 × pH + 0.197 | (5) |
Linear sweep voltammograms (LSVs) were recorded by cathodically scanning the potential from 1.4 to 0.4 VRHE at a scan rate of 10 mV s−1. The Mott–Schottky (MS) analysis of BaTaO2N/Ta photoanode was carried out in Ar-saturated 0.5 M NaCl electrolyte buffered with 0.2 M KPi at pH 5.5 in the dark, at different frequencies (0.5, 1.5, and 2.5 kHz). The quantitative amounts of gaseous H2 and O2 that evolved from a Pt wire and the Co(OH)x/BaTaO2N/Ta photoanode during seawater splitting were estimated using GC analysis (YL6500, Young In Chromass). Moreover, the quantitative amounts of free chlorine species (Cl2(aq)/HOCl/ClO−), which were produced during the photoreaction, were determined using the colorimetric detection method (V-770, JASCO) utilizing a quartz cuvette with a path length of 1.0 cm, based on the oxidation of 3,3′,5,5′-tetramethyl benzidine (TMB).24 The amounts of Cl− and byproduct ClO3− traces were estimated using ion chromatography (Dionex ICS-5000, Thermo Fisher Scientific) in an alkaline environment.
| EB + EK + Φanalyzer = 21.2 eV | (6) |
Here, EB, EK, and Φanalyzer represent the binding energy referenced to the Fermi level, the kinetic energy of electron, and the work function of analyzer, respectively. Furthermore, the surface morphology and elemental mapping of the BaTaO2N/Ta and Co(OH)x/BaTaO2N/Ta photoanodes were examined using a scanning electron microscope (SEM; Gemini500, ZEISS) equipped with an energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscope (EDS).
| H2O ⇌ ˙OH (aq) + H+ + e− E° = 2.73 VNHE | (7) |
In n-type BaTaO2N, upward band bending is formed at the interface between semiconductor and electrolyte, driving photogenerated holes toward the surface and facilitating oxidation reactions including OER and CER. Although this interfacial electric field enhances charge transfer, the EVB of BaTaO2N remains more negative than the potential required for ˙OH formation. Moreover, the ˙OH production at the surface of photoanodes generates chlorine radicals, such as Cl˙ and Cl2˙−, during seawater splitting, which causes complex chain reactions and toxic, undesirable byproducts (ClO3−, ClO4−, and so on).14,26 Therefore, these results demonstrate that BaTaO2N crystals grown on Ta have the potential to enable sunlight-driven seawater splitting, encompassing OER and CER, while simultaneously suppressing PEC side reactions.
Fig. 2 shows SEM images and EDS elemental mapping results of BaTaO2N particles synthesized through bottom-up fabrication. The oxynitride particles, which grew randomly on the Ta substrate, had an average size of 430 nm (Fig. S4), featuring smooth and cuboidal surfaces. Then, uneven, stick-type Co(OH)x nanoparticles applied to enhance photoreactions were covered at the smooth surface of oxynitrides as depicted in Fig. 2(c). The cross-sectional image of the photoanode reveals that the BaTaO2N layer on Ta was approximately 2 μm thick. An EDS elemental mapping analysis indicated that the cuboidal oxynitrides consisted of Ba, Ta, O, and N elements, which were uniformly distributed within the oxynitride layer. For the synthesized BaTaO2N/Ta photoanode, the surface elemental composition ratios of Ba/Ta = 1.1 and O/N = 1.8—while not reflecting bulk composition—were nevertheless close to the theoretical stoichiometry (Fig. S5).
Based on the theoretically possible optical properties of the BaTaO2N/Ta photoanode, the PEC seawater splitting activity was evaluated over the oxynitride surface loaded with Co(OH)x electrocatalyst under chopped simulated sunlight (AM 1.5 G) in aqueous 0.5 M NaCl solutions buffered with 0.2 M KPi at different pH levels ranging from 1 to 13 (Fig. S6(a) and (b)). The neutral pH was chosen based on the pKa 7.5 of HOCl (eqn (4)). Although phosphate buffers were prepared with a total concentration of 0.2 M at each pH, the ionic strength of electrolyte slightly varied due to differences in phosphate speciation depending on pH. The seawater splitting of the oxynitride was additionally conducted at pH 5.5 using a 0.1 M KPi (Fig. S7). The photo-response was almost identical to that obtained with 0.2 M buffer, indicating that the variation in ionic strength has a negligible effect on the photoactivity. The photoactivities were compared with the splitting activity of pure water in aqueous 0.2 M KPi electrolytes, which provides a reference to evaluate the pH dependency of both the seawater splitting activity of the BaTaO2N/Ta photoanode and the selectivity of oxidation reactions. Fig. 3(a) and (b) show bar charts illustrating the onset potentials (for 0.1 mA cm−2) and photocurrent densities at 1.23 VRHE of Co(OH)x/BaTaO2N/Ta photoanodes at different pH levels, extracted from LSV curves acquired during the (sea)water splitting (Fig. S6). Across all pH values, the onset potentials of the BaTaO2N photoanodes for seawater splitting were more negative compared to those for water splitting. For water splitting, the photocurrent onset exhibited a clear pH dependence; across pH 1–13 it shifted by approximately 0.16 VRHE: as pH increased to 13, OER kinetics became faster and the required overpotential decreased, shifting the onset to more negative potentials, whereas at lower pH the slower OER kinetics shifted the onset positively. By contrast, in the NaCl-containing electrolyte, although the bulk concentration of Cl− did not vary with pH (unlike OH−), the onset potential for seawater splitting also exhibited pH dependence, but with a smaller shift (approximately 0.1 VRHE) than that observed for OER. Moreover, their photocurrent densities at 1.23 VRHE were consistently high during seawater splitting in aqueous 0.5 M NaCl solutions, irrespective of the pH. It is widely acknowledged that the OER is readily catalyzed in highly alkaline electrolytes like pH 13, even in the presence of 0.5 M NaCl.27,28 However, in this study, the presence of NaCl in the aqueous solution at pH 13 further enhanced the photoactivity, including the onset potential and photocurrent, of the oxynitride photoanode, which suggests that CER as well as OER were concurrently occurring during its seawater splitting.
At low pH values such as 1 and 2, the seawater splitting activity over the oxynitride was remarkably high compared to its OER activity. Its onset potential was negatively shifted by as much as 0.2 VRHE, and the photocurrent was also more than twice as high. These results clearly demonstrate that seawater splitting over BaTaO2N photoanodes was significantly more photoactive than pure water splitting at low pH, and that CER driven by two-electron transfer is kinetically faster than OER via the four-electron pathway despite its more oxidizing thermodynamic potential. Such fast kinetics of seawater splitting were similarly observed with increasing pH values up to the neutral pH 7.5. This is remarkable because the increase in pH accelerates the hydration of Cl2 originating from CER to HOCl and its subsequent dissociation to ClO− (Fig. S1), and the thermodynamic potentials of CER become much more positive according to the following equations:6,12
| Cl− + H2O ⇌ HOCl + H+ + 2e− E° = (1.48 − 0.0592 pH) VNHE | (8) |
| Cl− + 2OH− ⇌ ClO− + H2O + 2e− E° = (1.72 − 0.0592 pH) VNHE | (9) |
In fact, even though CER requires a thermodynamic potential more positive, at least 0.25 V (eqn (8)), than 1.23 VRHE for OER, it was kinetically favored during seawater splitting at pH 5.5. Using sulfite oxidation as a hole-scavenging benchmark, the charge injection efficiency, ηinj, was quantified from LSV curves for seawater and water splitting at pH 5.5 (Fig. S8). At 1.36 VRHE, ηinj reached nearly 80% for seawater splitting but only 46% for water splitting (OER), indicating kinetically faster interfacial charge transfer for CER. The (sea)water splitting activity of Co(OH)x/BaTaO2N/Ta photoanodes was measured in the dark at the potential range higher than 1.23 VRHE, as shown in Fig. 3(c). The seawater splitting kinetics was much faster than water splitting kinetics, consistent with the PEC result of the oxynitride. The electrochemical seawater splitting of the catalyst Co(OH)x loaded on FTO substrate, evaluated at different pH values, also showed markedly faster kinetics, particularly at pH values below 7.5 (Fig. S6(c) and (d)). These results indicate that the fast kinetics of seawater splitting, which depends on pH, was not limited to PEC configurations. Nevertheless, the acquisition of photocurrent initiating from approximately 0.7 VRHE clearly demonstrates the effectiveness of PEC seawater splitting, which is largely enhanced at low pH values, i.e., unfavorable environments for driving OER.
The products obtained during the seawater splitting activity of Co(OH)x/BaTaO2N/Ta at the applied potential of 1.23 VRHE for 1 h were quantitatively analyzed using GC and colorimetric detection. The anodic current density remained relatively stable, without sudden degradation during the photoreaction, regardless of measured pH conditions (Fig. S9). Moreover, the quantitative amounts of evolved products resulting from seawater splitting at pH 5.5 were repeatedly estimated every 15 min and compared with those from pure water splitting (Fig. S10). The gaseous H2 was detected in the Pt wire compartment, whereas gaseous O2 and liquid HOCl were observed in the compartment of the Co(OH)x/BaTaO2N/Ta photoanode. The amounts of evolved gases increased linearly during stable seawater splitting for 1 h, being two times larger than those during pure water splitting—consistent with the photocurrent result shown in Fig. 3(b). The faradaic efficiency of seawater oxidation (CER and/or OER) was determined by the total amounts of O2 and half of HOCl evolved from four- and two-electron transfer, respectively (Fig. S10(c)). The faradaic efficiency of seawater splitting was almost unity, demonstrating that the anodic photocurrent acquired over the BaTaO2N photoanode indeed resulted from sunlight-driven seawater splitting. It is worth noting that the amount of HOCl product was negligibly detected in the initial 15 min and increased over time, while a significant amount of O2 was estimated and decreased over time. The amount of HOCl product, exclusively corresponding to approximately 14% of faradaic efficiency, was estimated in 1 h photoreaction. These results contradicted the faster kinetics of CER in seawater splitting compared to OER. In addition, the faradaic efficiency of seawater oxidation (estimated by total detection of O2 and HOCl) was slightly lower (approximately 2%) than that of seawater reduction producing H2. Tiny ClO3− traces were also detected from the electrolyte obtained after seawater splitting for 1 h using ion chromatography (IC) in an alkaline environment (Fig. S10(d)). Although it is unclear whether the HOCl originating from CER was partly oxidized to ClO3− during the photoreaction or the alkaline IC measurement, the presence of ClO3− traces would slightly lower the faradaic efficiency of seawater oxidation. Therefore, the seawater oxidation, which involves only CER and OER and exhibits a high faradaic efficiency (approximately 98%) in this study, was attributed to the optical band structure of BaTaO2N, which is incapable of generating ˙OH photoelectrochemically—thus preventing undesirable chain side reactions.
Fig. 3(d) shows the faradaic efficiencies of seawater splitting operated for 1 h at different pH levels (1, 2, 7.5, 10, and 13 as well as pH 5.5), which were determined by quantitative analysis of the evolved products in the same manner as above (Fig. S11). In this study, the identification of Cl2(aq)/HOCl/ClO− products originating from CER was determined by calculating the composition fraction of free chlorine species, as determined by pH dependence (Fig. S1). The seawater splitting of Co(OH)x/BaTaO2N/Ta photoanode resulted in faradaic efficiencies exceeding 95% at all pH values, generating free chlorine species through CER and O2. These results clearly prove that the increase in anodic photocurrent, driven by the rapid kinetics of CER, was fully utilized to boost the H2 production rate, especially at low pH levels. At pH 1 and 2, the dissolved amount of Cl2(aq) was relatively high (corresponding to a faradaic efficiency of approximately 25%) compared to the levels of HOCl/ClO− detected under conditions with a pH above 5.5. This difference may be attributed to the higher seawater splitting activity in comparison to OER under lower pH conditions. Interestingly, a measurable amount of ClO− was observed at a high pH of 13, where OER kinetics is considered dominant, despite a slight increase in photocurrent, as shown in Fig. 3(b). Conversely, it is noteworthy that the detected amount of O2 remained considerably high regardless of pH, exceeding a faradaic efficiency of 83% even at pH 5.5, where rapid CER kinetics were observed. Nevertheless, considering the high faradaic efficiency, the fact that the high photocurrent observed during seawater splitting in neutral and acidic electrolytes indeed enhanced the rate of H2 production is highly significant.
The photo-assisted decomposition of free chlorine species was investigated at different pH values to determine why a high proportion of O2 gas was observed in quantitative analyses of sunlight-driven seawater splitting, as mentioned above. The constant concentrations of free chlorine species in aqueous 2.7 μM NaOCl solutions, buffered with 0.2 M KPi at different pH values, were irradiated under AM 1.5 G simulated sunlight, and the remaining amount of free chlorine functioned with time was quantitatively estimated using colorimetric detection (Fig. S12). Fig. 4(a) shows decomposition curves of the free chlorine species at different pH values (2, 5.5 and 7.5). The free chlorine species are well known to undergo decomposition through several mechanisms, such as photolysis, chemical disproportionation, and thermolysis.14,29 In this study, considering the substantial amount of O2 detected after seawater splitting, it is most plausible that the detected O2 originated from the decomposition of HOCl (which is the predominant free chlorine species at pH below 7.5). The decomposition of HOCl is typically attributed to either a spontaneous chemical reaction—i.e., disproportionation (eqn (10))—or radical-mediated photolysis (eqn (11)), as illustrated by the following reaction pathways:29–31
| 2HOCl → 2Cl− + O2 + 2H+ | (10) |
| 2HOCl → Cl2O + H2O | (10-1) |
| Cl2O + H2O → 2Cl− + O2 + 2H+ | (10-2) |
| 2HOCl + hv → 2Cl− + O2 + 2H+ | (11) |
| HOCl + hv → ˙OH + ˙Cl | (11-1) |
| 4˙OH → 2H2O2 → O2 + 2H2O | (11-2) |
| ˙Cl + H2O → Cl− + ˙OH + H+ | (11-3) |
In addition, the free chlorine species itself was found to act as an oxidant and further reacts to produce ClO3− as shown in the following reaction:14
| 2HOCl + ClO− → ClO3− + 2Cl− + 2H+ | (12) |
The presence of ClO3− byproduct was qualitatively determined after seawater splitting at pH 5.5 for 1 h using ion chromatography, as discussed in Fig. S10. Nevertheless, it was evident that the free chlorine was primarily decomposed to O2 because only a negligible amount of ClO3− was detected in this study. As shown in Fig. 4(a), the decomposition rate of free chlorine species increased with decreasing pH, which indicates strong pH dependence. The fast decomposition of major species HOCl at lower pH may be attributed to its increased oxidizing power and the acid-favored formation of reactive intermediate Cl2O (eqn (10-2)), which facilitates the subsequent O2 evolution via chemical disproportionation.32,33 In addition, the photolysis of HOCl was promoted under acidic conditions due to its higher molar absorptivity and more efficient radical generation compared to its conjugate base, ClO−, thereby accelerating O2 evolution via a radical-mediated pathway.34 Since the initial decomposition rate showed a linear relationship in the plot of log[free chlorine] versus time, the reaction can be described as pseudo-first-order. In general, the HOCl photolysis is known to follow pseudo-first-order kinetics with respect to its concentration.34,35 Therefore, the initial stage of O2 evolution is likely driven primarily by the photodecomposition of HOCl.
The decomposition rate of HOCl decreased gradually over time, following an initially rapid degradation phase, regardless of the pH. The photolysis of HOCl is known to be wavelength-dependent, with rapid O2 generation driven by ˙OH formation upon absorption of ultraviolet (UV) light (eqn (11-1)), particularly at shorter wavelengths (around 250 nm).33–35 The simulated sunlight (AM 1.5 G) used in this study provided only UV light with wavelengths above approximately 350 nm, which inherently limited the photodecomposition rate of HOCl. Fig. 4(b) shows the decomposition behavior of free chlorine under visible light irradiation (λ > 400 nm) at pH 5.5 using a 400 nm cut-off filter. The decomposition continued even under visible light exposure, and an analysis of the initial decomposition rate revealed a linear relationship in the plot of 1/[free chlorine] versus time, which suggests a second-order reaction. This finding is consistent with the second-order kinetics of spontaneous chemical decomposition of HOCl with respect to its concentration.30,31 In this study, both photolysis and spontaneous chemical degradation of free chlorine species co-occurred under simulated sunlight irradiation. Fig. 4(c) shows the quantification of O2 gas generated during the sunlight-assisted decomposition of free chlorine at pH 5.5 through GC analysis. Nearly complete decomposition was observed at the initial stage within 1 h, followed by a period of stable O2 evolution, and a gradual decrease during the final phase of decomposition. The decrease in decomposition rate over time, as indicated by the slope of the decomposition curve, likely reflects the concentration dependence of free chlorine decomposition—through chemical pathways following second-order kinetics and/or photolysis proceeding via a pseudo-first-order pathway—for O2 evolution. In other words, the reduced concentration of free chlorine led to a slower decomposition rate. However, the prolonged exposure of the dilute free chlorine under sunlight appeared to result in other, undetected decomposition pathways rather than the continued O2 evolution. It presents the involvement of additional pathways in the decomposition, possibly including oxidation reactions that yield byproducts such as ClO3−, as qualitatively detected by IC in this study. Despite these parallel decomposition routes, the quantitative result clearly shows that O2 gas was the dominant product through the decomposition of free chlorine species under simulated sunlight. In other words, the decomposition data provide compelling evidence why the predominant portion of products was identified as gaseous O2 during seawater splitting of the BaTaO2N photoanode under neutral and acidic pH environments—even though CER was kinetically more favorable than OER in seawater.
The reactant Cl− for CER is regenerated through the subsequent decomposition of free chlorine species as a CER product into O2 gas (eqn (10) and (11)). Therefore, long-term solar seawater splitting was investigated to explore the feasibility of continuous H2 production under a constant Cl− concentration. Fig. 5(a) displays the photocurrent curve of a Co(OH)x/BaTaO2N/Ta photoanode functioned with time acquired during seawater splitting for 24 h at the applied potential of 1.23 VRHE in an aqueous 0.5 M NaCl solution buffered with 0.2 M KPi under AM 1.5 G simulated sunlight. The seawater splitting of BaTaO2N was operated at pH 5.5, where the highest O2 evolution, corresponding to a faradaic efficiency of more than 83%, was observed as discussed in Fig. 3(d). Simultaneously, the concentration of reactant Cl− in the aqueous electrolyte was quantified using both IC in an alkaline environment and the Mohr titration method based on silver nitrate. After 24 h of operation, approximately 81% of the initial photocurrent was retained, which demonstrates the high photocurrent stability of the oxynitride photoanode. In contrast, the previously reported SrNbO2N photoanode, prepared via a bottom-up fabrication, exhibited limited long-term activity for PEC seawater splitting.10 Whereas prior BaTaO2N photoanodes have shown high photoactivity and, in some cases, appreciable long-term stability under strongly alkaline electrolytes such as pH 13, sustained long-term operation under neutral pH environment has not been reported previously (Table S1). Thus, in this work, the markedly enhanced stability of the BaTaO2N photoanode at pH 5.5 is particularly noteworthy. The improvement can be attributed to the more uniform deposition of Co(OH)x on the smooth, cuboidal BaTaO2N particles (Fig. 2), contrasting with the porous morphology of the SrNbO2N particles. The enhanced crystallinity of BaTaO2N crystals, as discussed in Fig. 1, may also facilitate efficient charge separation during the photoreaction. Therefore, the uniform loading of the electrocatalyst on highly crystalline BaTaO2N particles likely contributed to the sustained photocurrent and enhanced long-term durability during the seawater splitting. Furthermore, the amounts of H2, O2, and HOCl produced during the photoreaction were quantitatively analyzed in the same manner as above, as shown in Fig. 5(b). The faradaic efficiencies of oxidation (O2 and HOCl) and reduction (H2) reactions consistently remained above 98% throughout the 24 h operation, respectively. On average, the crystalline, cuboidal Co(OH)x/BaTaO2N/Ta photoanode produced H2 at a rate of 31 μmol h−1 cm−2. These results clearly indicate that the photocurrent generated during prolonged seawater splitting predominantly contributes to H2 evolution, which demonstrates that sustainable H2 production through solar seawater splitting is feasible even under competitive CER and OER pathways.
In this study, the selective contribution of CER to the measured photocurrent could not be directly determined due to the rapid initial decomposition of free chlorine species. However, a bar chart showing faradaic efficiencies over time, displayed in Fig. 5(c), reveals that HOCl was detected with a faradaic efficiency of approximately 3% in the initial 15 min of seawater splitting, which gradually increased to 23% over 24 h. This result indicates that CER continued to proceed during prolonged seawater splitting and that the accumulation of its products became more significant over time. In contrast, O2 gas accounted for more than 95% of the faradaic efficiency in the early stage but decreased to approximately 75% by 24 h. As shown in Fig. 5(a), the Cl− concentration remained nearly constant at 0.5 M during the initial phase but exhibited decreasing behavior over time. Nonetheless, the final Cl− concentration remained significantly higher than what would be expected if CER had proceeded with complete conversion of Cl− to free chlorine, which was not decomposed to O2 gas. These findings collectively suggest that the majority of O2 generated during the initial stage resulted from the rapid decomposition of free chlorine, as indicated by the high rate of Cl− regeneration. However, the observed decrease in O2 production over time, along with the concurrent increase in free chlorine accumulation, implies that the formation of free chlorine by CER became more pronounced relative to the decomposition rate of its products as the reaction proceeds. As a result, the slow decomposition rate of free chlorine increasingly hindered the complete regeneration of Cl− as the photoreaction proceeded.
An intriguing aspect is that the faradaic efficiency of seawater oxidation remained nearly constant at approximately 98% for 24 h. It indicates that the unique band structure of BaTaO2N, which is insufficient to generate ˙OH, predominantly produces free chlorine and O2 gas driven by CER and OER. The decomposition of free chlorine primarily led to the evolution of O2, with other side reactions occurring at negligible levels. As discussed in Fig. 4, the gradual decrease in the concentration of free chlorine over time reduced its decomposition rate to O2 while facilitating alternative (yet unidentified) decomposition pathways. In contrast, during the prolonged seawater splitting process of 24 h, the continuous generation and accumulation of free chlorine instead resulted in a concentration-dependent acceleration of its decomposition to O2, which suppressed competing decomposition pathways. This finding indicates that under the steady-state photoreaction, the sustained formation of free chlorine by CER promoted preferential O2 production over other undesired byproducts.
In addition, although a high faradaic efficiency of nearly 100% for H2 evolution was maintained for 24 h, a gradual decline in photocurrent resulted in a decrease in the H2 evolution rate. In general, the depletion of reactant Cl− in the bulk electrolyte could decrease the diffusion-limited photocurrent.22 In this study, despite the initial recirculation of Cl− concentration during the early stage of the photoreaction, the photocurrent gradually decreased. Furthermore, although the recirculation of Cl− became slower as the reaction proceeded, the decreasing rate of the photocurrent remained essentially unchanged. These observations suggest that while Cl− recovery contributed to photocurrent behavior, it was not the sole determining factor in its long-term stability. After 24 h of photoreaction, a relatively high surface coverage of Co(OH)x remained on the BaTaO2N surface (Fig. S13). However, the SEM analysis revealed that the Co(OH)x particles became smaller and more porous compared to their initial state prior to the reaction, as shown in Fig. 2. The decreasing photocurrent may be mainly attributed to the corrosion of the Co(OH)x electrocatalyst during the photoreaction. Therefore, in order to sustain a stable H2 evolution rate, it is essential to not only identify a corrosion-resistant electrocatalyst for CER but also to maintain a consistent concentration of Cl− in artificial seawater. To address this problem, a flowing system of seawater could be introduced to replenish Cl−; however, this approach may introduce spatial limitations and incur additional costs for seawater splitting. Alternatively, this study demonstrates that the reactant Cl− was gradually replenished in the bulk electrolyte during solar seawater splitting, although the decomposition of free chlorine into O2 occurred slowly. In conclusion, as shown in Fig. 6, if the generation rate of free chlorine during CER can be matched with its decomposition rate into O2, a steady Cl− concentration can be maintained, which enables a stable long-term H2 production rate under constant volume of seawater (similar to conventional water splitting systems).
![]() | ||
| Fig. 6 Schematic illustration of Cl− regeneration and closed-loop operation during solar seawater splitting using a BaTaO2N photoanode under sunlight. | ||
Crucially, this work also reveals that free chlorine species generated via CER gradually decompose back to O2 and Cl− through photolytic and chemical pathways, which enables in situ regeneration of Cl− in the bulk electrolyte. Although this decomposition is not immediate, the accumulation of free chlorine over time is self-limiting due to its eventual breakdown. This closed-loop mechanism enables the sustained long-term storage of seawater in a fixed electrolyte volume, eliminating the need for flowing seawater configurations. Finally, this study addresses a significant bottleneck in solar H2 production from saline water: the challenge of selectivity and stability in non-alkaline media. The combination of CER-dominant oxidation pathways under mildly acidic to neutral pH and the self-regenerating behavior of Cl− presents a practical and scalable route to efficient, durable, and sustainable solar-driven H2 generation directly from seawater.
| This journal is © the Partner Organisations 2026 |