Open Access Article
Patrick Moser‡
a,
Subhra Kanti Roy‡a,
Marvin Herzog
a,
Felix Bauera,
Felix Wollensacka,
Bernhard Breit
a and
Henning J. Jessen
*ab
aInstitute of Organic Chemistry, Albert-Ludwigs-Universität Freiburg, Albertstraße 21, 79104 Freiburg im Breisgau, Germany. E-mail: henning.jessen@oc.uni-freiburg.de
bCIBSS-Centre for Integrative Biological Signalling Studies, University of Freiburg, 79104 Freiburg, Germany
First published on 14th April 2026
The magic spot nucleotides (MSNs), (p)ppGpp and (p)ppApp, play central roles in bacterial stress signaling, yet their selective detection and chemical accessibility remain limited. This work presents a scalable chemo-enzymatic synthesis of natural and functionalized pentaphosphorylated MSNs based on a cyclic pyrophosphoryl phosphoramidite (cPyPA) mediated phosphorylation and RNase T2-catalyzed hydrolysis. This approach enables preparative access to defined 3′-monophosphates (ppAp, ppGp) and the pentaphosphorylated products pppApp and pppGpp. In parallel, a metal–ligand disassembly-based fluorescence probe that operates in water was developed for the selective detection of MSNs. Coordination of the alarmone to an Fe(III)-salen complex induces its demetallation and fluorescence activation through salicylaldehyde release, supported by theoretical and spectroscopic studies. The probe displays a two- to threefold selectivity for (p)ppGpp and (p)ppApp over other nucleotides and responds most strongly to MSNs bearing 3′- and 5′-pyrophosphate groups. The probe also detects enzymatically generated ppGpp from Staphylococcus aureus RelP reactions in vitro. This work combines a robust synthesis route for pentaphosphorylated MSNs with a readily accessible fluorescence sensor, thereby laying the foundation for future investigations into bacterial stress signaling.
Given their central regulatory functions, access to (p)ppGpp and (p)ppApp is of great importance for understanding bacterial persistence and signalling pathways. The detection methods available to date include radiolabelling, thin-layer chromatography, HPLC-UV, LC-MS and CE-MS analysis.8–10 The accumulation of ppGpp in Arabidopsis thaliana has also been quantified using UPLC-ESI-qMS/MS.11,12 Although LC-MS-based methods offer higher sensitivity, they require complex instrumentation and are not well suited for real-time measurements.8,13 In recent years, colorimetric and fluorescence-based sensors have been developed; however, some of these systems suffer from synthetic complexity or poor stability in aqueous media.14
The efficient chemical synthesis of MSNs has also been a challenge. Classic phosphorylation strategies or enzymatic methods usually yield only milligram quantities of the highly charged nucleotides and can result in 2′/3′-regioisomer mixtures that are difficult to separate.15 To address these limitations, we developed a robust and scalable chemo-enzymatic route to the pentaphosphorylated MSNs pppGpp and pppApp. This is based on cPyPa-mediated phosphorylation, followed by ring opening with ethylenediamine and RNase T2-catalysed hydrolysis, which enables the regioselective formation of 3′-monophosphates (Scheme 1a).16–18 These intermediates can be further converted into canonical and functionalized pentaphosphorylated MSNs.
Building on this synthetic approach, we further developed a turn-on fluorescence sensor for the real-time detection of (p)ppGpp and (p)ppApp in water. Inspired by the so-called disassembly strategy for phosphate and pyrophosphate sensors, we investigated a probe based on a Fe(III)-salen complex. Binding of the target analyte to the metal centre triggers disassembly of the complex, resulting in a fluorescence turn-on response (Scheme 1b).
Here, we report (i) a compact and scalable chemo-enzymatic synthesis of pentaphosphorylated magic spot nucleotides and (ii) the development of a disassembly-based Fe(III)-salen fluorescence probe for their detection. Together, these advances provide an integrated chemical toolbox for studying bacterial stress signalling in biochemical and analytical applications.
The reaction of adenosine and 2-N-(Fmoc)-guanosine (2) with an excess of cPyPa (3) in the presence of 5-(ethylthio)-1H-tetrazole (ETT), followed by oxidation with mCPBA, affords the corresponding bis-cyclotriphosphate intermediates 12 as a mixture of the 5′,2′- and 5′,3′-cyclotriphosphorylated isomers (Scheme 2). The Fmoc protecting group from the guanosine derivative had to be introduced beforehand due to the low solubility of guanosine in DMF.
Upon incubation with ethylenediamine, these intermediates undergo a sequence of linearization and intramolecular cyclization reactions, removing the γ-phosphate as a phosphorodiamidate 14.16,17 The amine acts as both a nucleophile and a base and also facilitates 5-exo cyclization to the corresponding 2′,3′-cyclophosphate intermediates. The large excess of amine also cleaves of the Fmoc protecting group from the guanosine derivative. The resulting 2′,3′-cyclophosphates 15 were hydrolysed overnight, catalysed by RNase T2 at 37 °C and pH 5.5, yielding exclusively the corresponding 3′-monophosphates ppAp (4) and ppGp (5) – in line with previous reports on ribonuclease-mediated hydrolysis of MSNs.16,17 After purification via SAX chromatography, ppAp (4) and ppGp (5) were isolated as their ammonium salts in 64% yield, and 42% yield, respectively.
Subsequent phosphorylation using Fm-P-amidite chemistry20,21 in the presence of ETT, followed by oxidation with mCPBA and Fm removal with DBU, yielded ppApp (7) and ppGpp (8) in isolated yields of 89% and 86%, respectively. The sequence discussed herein also only requires two isolation steps, as all other steps can be carried out in a one-flask reaction. Overall, this leads to a very efficient synthetic access to the pentaphosphorylated magic spot nucleotides pppGpp & pppApp.
ppGpp and ppApp, which were also used for evaluation of the chemosensor (vide infra), were synthesized from adenosine and guanosine according to Haas et al.21 In this approach, treatment of the nucleosides with pyrophosphoryl chloride affords chlorophosphate intermediates 17 (Scheme 3), which upon hydrolysis yield the corresponding 2′,3′-cyclophosphate intermediates.21 When performed on a larger scale, however, the quenching step can become less selective, leading to partial, non-selective ring opening and formation of 2′/3′-regioisomeric pNp mixtures 18 and 19. These mixtures are difficult to separate by SAX or RP chromatography and thus limit straightforward access to defined 3′-monophosphate building blocks (Scheme 3, top). To address this limitation, we investigated a chemoenzymatic correction strategy (Scheme 3, bottom). The regioisomeric pNp mixtures 18 and 19 were first converted into the corresponding ppNpp derivatives 21 and 22. Subsequent incubation with RNase T2 at 37 °C and pH 5.5 led to intramolecular cyclization via a transient 2′,3′-cyclophosphate intermediate, followed by selective enzymatic ring opening to the 3′-position.22 Full conversion was confirmed by 31P NMR spectroscopy (see SI, Fig. S1). This sequence yields the 3′-monophosphates and ppAp (4) ppGp (5) as their ammonium salts in quantitative yields after SAX purification. While RNase T2-mediated hydrolysis of ppGpp to ppGp has been described previously,21 its ability to selectively process regioisomeric ppNpp mixtures – particularly ppApp – has not been reported. This newly described enzymatic reaction represents an efficient and selective method for recovering defined ppNp from regioisomeric ppNpp mixtures and underscores the practical relevance of RNase T2 for MSN synthesis. ppAp was in turn used to synthesize a clickable pppApp analogue (see SI, Chapter 3.5). Such MSN derivatives represent a versatile platform for chemical modifications and can, for example, be derivatized into pull-down probes, as previously demonstrated by Haas et al.23
Complex 9 (Fe-Sal) was prepared according to a known procedure.25 This Fe(III)-salen scaffold has previously been used as a disassembly sensor for pyrophosphate. We now investigate its response toward the hyperphosphorylated alarmones (p)ppGpp and (p)ppApp and other nucleotides. Upon incubation of Fe-Sal (9) with 10 equivalents of both (p)ppGpp and (p)ppApp in Tris buffer (10 mM, pH = 7.4), a decrease in absorbance was detected at 320 nm, 392 nm, and 485 nm. The observed decrease in absorbance at these wavelengths was more pronounced when using pentaphosphate (pppGpp and pppApp) compared to tetraphosphate (ppGpp and ppApp) (Fig. 1a). Disassembly of the Fe-Sal complexes was further investigated by titration with (p)ppGpp species. Upon incremental addition of ppGpp sodium salt to a solution of Fe-Sal (50 μM) in 10 mM Tris buffer (pH 7.4), a progressive enhancement in fluorescence emission intensity was observed. Specifically, excitation at 375 nm resulted in an emission centred at 510 nm, which increased proportionally with the amount of ppGpp added. An eightfold enhancement in fluorescence intensity was recorded upon the addition of 10 equivalents of ppGpp (Fig. 1b). The disassembly process was found to be time-dependent. As the reaction progressed, a gradual increase in fluorescence intensity was observed, reaching a maximum after approximately 40 minutes for ppGpp. This behaviour indicates a dynamic disassembly process driven by interaction of the analyte with the Fe centre of the complex (Fig. 1c). pppGpp induced faster disassembly, with maximum emission reached after approximately 25 minutes. However, the overall response time precludes real-time detection under the conditions employed necessitating end-point detection.
To determine the binding stoichiometry between 9 and ppGpp, a Job's plot analysis was conducted based on emission intensity at 510 nm (Fig. 1d). The result suggested a 1
:
1 binding between 9 and ppGpp, while [9 + ppGpp] = 100 µM was maintained throughout the experiment.
Given the pronounced response of 9 toward MSNs, we next evaluated its selectivity against a panel of biologically relevant phosphorylated molecules. To this end, the probe was incubated with inorganic phosphate (Pi), inorganic pyrophosphate (PPi) and common nucleotides (ATP, ADP, AMP, GTP, GDP, and GMP) under identical conditions (10 mM Tris buffer, pH 7.4, 40 min). As shown in Fig. 2a, the probe exhibits stronger fluorescence responses toward MSNs compared to other phosphorylated species, while no selectivity is observed against inorganic pyrophosphate (PPi).
Selectivity was further assessed using a set of structurally related bacterial alarmones, including pGpp, ppGp, ppAp, pGp, and adenosine 5′-tetraphosphate (Ap4). In this series, significantly stronger fluorescence responses were observed for pGpp, ppGp, and ppAp compared to pGp and Ap4 (Fig. 2b). This trend indicates that the presence of a pyrophosphate moiety at either the 3′ or 5′ position is a key determinant for efficient probe activation. In contrast, alarmones lacking diphosphate units at these positions elicited weaker responses, underscoring the importance of both phosphorylation state and phosphate positioning for recognition by 9.
We further investigated the interaction of ppGpp with probe 9 by DFT calculations. Starting from the water-coordinated complex [Fe(salen)(H2O)2], ligand substitution by ppGpp was examined. Coordination of ppGpp to the Fe(III) centre with displacement of both water ligands affords a thermodynamically favoured mono-ppGpp complex, [Fe(salen)(ppGpp)]5−. The optimized high-spin structure (Fig. 3) reveals bidentate coordination of the polyphosphate chain to iron.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 3 DFT-optimized structure of the mono-ppGpp complex [Fe(salene)(ppGpp)]5− (high-spin configuration). Relative Gibbs free energies of all calculated Fe-Sal-ppGpp species are provided in the SI. | ||
Overall, the calculated Gibbs free energies support a strong thermodynamic driving force for ligand exchange of the Fe-Sal complex with ppGpp, consistent with the experimentally observed fluorescence activation. A complete overview of calculated species and relative ΔG values is provided in the SI.
To further support the proposed disassembly mechanism, 1H NMR experiments were performed using a water-soluble sulfonated analogue of the Fe-Sal complex (Fe-Sal-SO3), which facilitated measurements at higher concentrations required for NMR. Upon incubation with ppGpp, a new resonance at ca. 10 ppm appeared, consistent with the aldehyde proton of the liberated salicylaldehyde ligand. This observation provides additional evidence for ppGpp-induced complex disassembly via competitive coordination to the Fe(III)-center (for full spectra and signal assignment see SI, Chapter 6).
To evaluate the applicability of probe 9 for the detection of enzymatically generated ppGpp, we conducted an in vitro enzymatic assay using the S. aureus RelP synthetase (Scheme 4).27
![]() | ||
| Scheme 4 Enzymatic generation of ppGpp by RelP and its subsequent detection via Fe-Salen probe disassembly. | ||
The reaction mixture contained ATP (2 mM), GDP (2 mM), and RelP (10 µM) in Tris-HCl buffer (20 mM, pH 8.0), MgCl2 (15 mM), KCl (15 mM), and β-mercaptoethanol (1.5 mM). A 1
:
1 ATP
:
GDP ratio was used to reduce interference from excess ATP given the limited selectivity of probe 9. The reaction was incubated at 37 °C for 1 hour and HPLC analysis confirmed complete consumption of the ATP and GDP substrates, indicating successful and selective synthesis of ppGpp (Fig. 4a). The reaction was subsequently quenched by heat denaturation, and aliquots of the reaction mixture were added to a solution of probe 9 (50 µM in Tris buffer, pH 7.4) to afford final ppGpp equivalents of 3.5, 5.0, 6.7, and 13.3 relative to the probe concentration. Following incubation for 45 minutes, fluorescence emission spectra revealed a significant increase in emission intensity, consistent with the disassembly of the Fe-based probe 9 (Fig. 4b). This fluorescence enhancement is attributed to the coordination of enzymatically produced ppGpp to the iron centre, leading to displacement of the ligand and release of the fluorescent aldehyde. This probe has potential for applications in inhibitor screening of ppGpp synthetases, provided that the nucleotide ratios described herein (1
:
1 ATP
:
GDP) are maintained to minimize ATP/GDP interference and pyrophosphate is absent. Notably, RSH enzymes comprise both mono- and bifunctional members, with RelA and small alarmone synthetases lacking hydrolase activity, whereas bifunctional enzymes such as SpoT can generate PPi;2,28 in such cases, PPi levels may need to be controlled, for example by enzymatic removal (e.g., pyrophosphatase). Accordingly, the applicability of the probe is limited to defined in vitro systems as described herein.
:
1 stoichiometry. The probe exhibits moderate selectivity for (p)ppGpp and (p)ppApp over common nucleosides (ca. twofold for GDP and ADP and threefold for GTP and ATP), indicating that the presence of a di- or triphosphate ester unit alone is insufficient for complete activation within the studied time frame of 40 minutes. Notably, 5′-triphosphorylated alarmones (pppGpp & pppApp) induce a stronger and more rapid response than their diphosphate counterparts (ppGpp & ppApp). The system also detects enzymatically formed ppGpp from S. aureus RelP under optimised conditions. Together, the synthesis and sensing strategies provide a useful set of tools for accessing, modifying and functionally analysing MSN. This creates new opportunities for chemical biology applications, such as screenings for inhibitors of MSN synthesizing enzymes.
Footnotes |
| † Dedicated to Kim and Jay, in celebration of their enduring awesomeness. |
| ‡ These authors contributed equally to this work. |
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2026 |