Open Access Article
Jinmeng Shi†
,
Aixi Pan†
*,
Rebecca Mac,
Md Fahim Al Fattah
,
Zbig Wasilewski and
Dayan Ban*
Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering, Waterloo Institute for Nanotechnology, University of Waterloo, Waterloo, N2L 3G1, Canada. E-mail: a22pan@uwaterloo.ca
First published on 28th May 2026
Silicon dioxide (SiO2) microstructures are widely employed in photonic and microelectronic devices. However, achieving well-controlled device profiles typically relies on costly dry-etching tools and complex fabrication workflows. Wet etching of SiO2 in hydrofluoric acid (HF), while attractive for its simplicity and scalability, is commonly regarded as inherently isotropic, limiting sidewall control. This work demonstrates that pronounced and continuously tunable anisotropy can be achieved using a buffered oxide etch (BOE)-based wet etching strategy. By systematically modulating etchant chemistry, surfactant-assisted interfacial transport, and etching temperature, anisotropic selectivity is engineered at a relatively high etch rate while maintaining smooth and uniform profiles, without relying on high-cost fabrication methods. In particular, reducing the etching temperature leads to a reduction in the sidewall angle of 33% and an increase in the vertical-to-lateral etch-rate ratio of 16%. These results establish BOE-based wet etching as a simple, scalable, and cost-effective approach for near-anisotropic SiO2 microfabrication with improved profile fidelity.
A variety of well-established microfabrication techniques have been developed for patterning SiO2. Ion-beam milling offers strong directionality, but is constrained by low selectivity,15 redeposition,16,17 and high equipment cost,18 restricting scalability to large-area substrates.19,20 Plasma-based dry etching, including reactive ion etching (RIE) and inductively coupled plasma reactive ion etching (ICP-RIE), enables anisotropic profile control by contrast, it frequently suffers from polymer residual contamination,21–23 micro-trenching,24 loading effect,25 alongside elevated tool complexity and cost.19 Moreover, the electrically insulating nature of SiO2 promotes surface charging during plasma etching, which can induce profile distortions and etch non-uniformity, further complicating wafer-level manufacturing.22
Considering these limitations, HF-based wet etching of SiO2 typically produces smoother sidewalls with minimal surface damage while requiring comparatively simple and low-cost equipment, rendering it inherently compatible with wafer-scale and high-throughput manufacturing.19,26 Notably, Konstantinova et al. demonstrated that buffered HF-based etchants enable the fabrication of deep and multilevel SiO2 microstructures with high etch rates and low surface roughness,27 providing a viable alternative to dry etching for precision oxide microfabrication. However, HF-based wet etching of SiO2 is widely regarded as inherently isotropic,28,29 due to pronounced lateral undercutting,24 which severely limits its applicability. Previous studies have primarily investigated individual parameters influencing SiO2 wet etching, such as buffering to regulate fluoride availability30 or temperature31 to modulate etch kinetics in isolation. A systematic, multi-parameter exploration within a unified wet-etching framework that enables controllable and enhanced anisotropy has remained scarce.
Here, this work directly addresses the long-standing perception of intrinsic isotropy in SiO2 wet etching by demonstrating controllable directional anisotropic sidewall formation using a modified three-parameter modulated BOE-based strategy. Etching directional selectivity and profile quality are systematically tuned through the combined control of etchant chemistry, surfactant-mediated wetting behavior, and etching temperature. Etching performance is quantitatively evaluated using direction-resolved vertical and lateral etch rates, calculated vertical-to-lateral ratio, etch inclination angle (α), and surface roughness. By mapping a comprehensive process window, conditions are identified under which lateral etching is effectively suppressed while high vertical etch rates and minimal surface roughness are maintained. Under these optimized conditions, the etch angle α is reduced to 67% of its initial value, accompanied by a 15% increase in the vertical-to-lateral etch-rate ratio. This work demonstrated a simple and scalable route for near-anisotropic SiO2 microfabrication, which is readily extendable to waveguides, surface-relief grating couplers, and other diffractive optical elements requiring engineered sidewall geometries.
A 3.0 μm-thick negative photoresist AZ nLOF 2035 was then spin-coated at 3000 rpm and soft-baked at 110 °C for 1 minute (Fig. 1b). Stripe patterns with varying line widths (10, 25, 50, and 75 μm) and circle patterns with multiple diameters (100, 200, and 300 μm) were defined using a mask-less photolithography (MLA, Heidelberg Instruments, Fig. 1c) and developed to form stripe- and circular shaped openings in the resist (Fig. 1d). Under all etching conditions investigated in this work, stripe widths below 10 μm were completely lost due to lateral undercutting, establishing 10 μm as the minimum reliable stripe dimension.
A 40 nm chromium (Cr) layer was then deposited by electron-beam evaporation to serve as a hard mask (Fig. 1e). Owing to the high selectivity of HF-based wet etching toward metal masks, Cr was selected as it produces more pronounced and controllable lateral under-etching compared with commonly used metals such as Au and Pt.29 The overhang profile of the photoresist enabled a lift-off process, during which the resist and the overlying Cr were removed, yielding well-defined Cr stripe patterns on the wafer (Fig. 1f).
After patterning, the samples were subjected to HF-based wet etching, followed by removal of the hard mask using a commercial Cr etchant. The etch profile was systematically tuned by adjusting the etchant composition, introducing a surfactant (Triton X-100), and controlling the etching temperature. Five representative parameter sets were investigated and are summarized in Table 1. Optimal anisotropic selectivity was achieved using an HF
:
NH4F volume ratio of 1
:
6 with the addition of 0.3 mL Triton X-100 at 0 °C. Cross-sectional etch profiles were characterized by scanning electron microscopy (SEM, JEOL) after deposition of a thin iridium film, enabling both qualitative evaluation and quantitative analysis of etch anisotropy and morphological features.
| Sample number # | Etchant | HF : H2O/NH4F |
Temperature | Surfactant (Triton X-100) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Diluted HF | 1 : 6 |
25 °C | — |
| 2 | BOE | 1 : 6 |
25 °C | — |
| 3 | BOE | 1 : 6 |
0 °C | — |
| 4 | BOE | 1 : 6 |
25 °C | 0.3 mL |
| 5 | BOE | 1 : 6 |
0 °C | 0.3 mL |
:
6 at 25 °C for 2 hours, as summarized in Table 1 (samples #1 and #2). This ratio is commonly employed in oxide wet etching and therefore represents a practically relevant processing condition.32 Although the absolute fluoride activity differs between diluted HF and BOE at the same volumetric ratio, this comparison is intended to assess process robustness and pattern fidelity under commonly used etching conditions.
SiO2 is etched by aqueous HF through proton (H+)-assisted weakening of Si–O bonds (HF ⇌ H+ + F−), followed by nucleophilic attack by reactive fluoride species (HF ⇌ H+ + F−; HF + F− ⇌ HF2−), ultimately forming soluble hexafluorosilicic acid (SiO2 + 6HF ⇌ H2SiF6 + 2H2O).32 In unbuffered HF solutions, the strong coupling between surface reaction kinetics and local mass transport can lead to localized etch-rate amplification, whereby small initial surface irregularities promote sustained preferential etching and progressively evolve into etch pits. In contrast, BOE stabilizes the reactive fluoride species through equilibrium (NH4F + HF ⇌ NH4+ + HF2−), thereby maintaining an effectively constant HF activity and suppressing the etch-rate decay commonly observed in unbuffered HF solutions.30 As a result, BOE provides a more stable and reproducible etch environment.
Consistent with these chemical differences, distinct etch morphologies are observed, as shown in Fig. 2 sample #1 etched in diluted HF exhibits rough profiles with pronounced local undulations, a high density of etching pits, and severe over-etching near the mask-substrate interface. In contrast, BOE-etched sample #2 yields significantly smoother and more uniform profiles with continuous sidewalls and a sparse distribution of etching pits. These improvements are attributed to the buffered fluoride chemistry rather than thermal effects, as both processes were conducted under identical temperature conditions. Based on this qualitative morphological comparison, BOE was selected for subsequent quantitative parametric studies.
Triton X-100 is a non-ionic surfactant that lowers interfacial energy and surface tension in aqueous solutions.33,34 During wet etching of SiO2, etching pits are primarily associated with spatially non-uniform mass transport at the solid–liquid interface. One key origin of such non-uniformity is the attachment of microbubbles formed from dissolved gases, which preferentially accumulate along sidewalls and at corner regions. These bubbles locally block direct contact between the etchant and the surface, while simultaneously creating regions of enhanced mass transport along their periphery due to bypass flow and concentration gradients.35,36 This combination of locally suppressed and locally enhanced etching leads to spatial variations in the etch rate, giving rise to differential material removal and ultimately resulting in pit formation.
The addition of Triton X-100 mitigates this effect by reducing surface tension, thereby promoting bubble detachment and preventing their stable attachment on the surface.37,38 In addition, improved wettability enhances the uniform spreading of the etchant, leading to a more homogeneous solid–liquid interface. As a result, local mass-transport heterogeneity is reduced, suppressing the formation of etching pits.
As shown in Fig. 3, sample #3 exhibits a relatively high areal density of etching pits (approximately 7 × 10−3 μm−2) distributed along the patterned stripes, whereas sample #5 reveals a huge reduction in pit density together with a substantially more uniform etching profile. These observations indicate that introducing Triton X-100 as a surfactant effectively improves sidewall contour continuity and suppresses etching pit formation during BOE-based SiO2 etching. Overall, Triton X-100 serves as an effective process modifier, enabling finer etching with a markedly reduced density of etching pits and ultimately enhancing the overall etch-profile quality.
Although BOE etching of SiO2 is conventionally regarded as isotropic,27,28 temperature modulation enables controllable near-anisotropy. The etch profile evolution can be decomposed into vertical etching of the exposed SiO2 surface and lateral propagating beneath the mask opening.6 Owing to the confined under-mask geometry, lateral etching is more sensitive to variations in reaction kinetics and mass transport than vertical etching.39 At reduced etching temperature, reaction pathways associated with higher effective kinetic barriers, such as those governing under-mask lateral etching, are preferentially suppressed.39 Simultaneously, increased solution viscosity weakens diffusion within the confined lateral channel, where reactant replenishment is diffusion-limited.40,41 The combined effects selectively reduce lateral etching while minimally affecting vertical etching, thereby enhancing etch anisotropy. A more detailed mechanistic analysis is provided in the SI.
This transition is evident in Fig. 4 and is quantified in Table 2, where lateral and vertical etch rates, the vertical-to-lateral etch-rate ratio, and α were averaged over at least 20 measurement locations for each condition. SEM cross-section images from six representative measurement locations for the etching conditions of Table 1 (samples #2, #4, and #5) are presented in Fig. S2–S4, with the corresponding mean values and standard deviations summarized in Tables S1–S3. Quantitative comparison between samples #2 and #4 indicates that the addition of Triton X-100 does not measurably alter the degree of etch anisotropy at 25 °C. By contrast, comparison between samples #4 and #5 demonstrates a pronounced temperature effect. When the etching temperature is reduced to 0 °C, the profiles develop steeper, near-linear sidewalls and a smaller inclination angle of α = 14.97° ± 0.40°, corresponding to a reduction of 7.35° (32.9%). This change is accompanied by an increase in the vertical-to-lateral etch-rate ratio from 1.15 to 1.33, indicating effective suppression of lateral undercut. Overall, reducing the etching temperature decreases the relative contribution of lateral etching with respect to vertical etching. This effect improves sidewall linearity and provides a straightforward handle for enhanced engineering near-anisotropy and profile fidelity in BOE-based SiO2 wet etching.
| Sample number # | Lateral etching rate (μm h−1) | Vertical etching rate (μm h−1) | Ratio (vertical/lateral) | Etch angle α (deg) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| α is defined as the angle between the vertical axis and the line from the mask edge to the etched profile at half the etch depth. | ||||
| 1 | — | — | — | — |
| 2 | 5.12 ± 0.03 | 5.76 ± 0.03 | 1.13 | 21.79 ± 0.71 |
| 3 | — | — | — | — |
| 4 | 4.52 ± 0.04 | 5.29 ± 0.01 | 1.17 | 22.84 ± 0.42 |
| 5 | 1.84 ± 0.02 | 2.45 ± 0.01 | 1.33 | 14.97 ± 0.40 |
Notably, benchmarking against representative wet-etching studies in Fig. 5 reveals that this work achieves one of the lowest reported etch angles while maintaining a broad and tunable anisotropy window. This result highlights the practical viability of the proposed strategy or controllable sidewall engineering in wet etching. The combination of tunability, process simplicity, and scalability further positions this approach as a promising route for SiO2 microfabrication with engineered sidewall profiles and suggests its applicability to devices such as waveguides, surface-relief grating couplers, and other diffractive optical elements.
Under optimized conditions, a pronounced improvement in anisotropic sidewall profile and surface integrity is achieved, corresponding to a ∼33% reduction in the sidewall angle together with a 16% increase in the vertical-to-lateral etch-rate ratio. These results demonstrate a substantial enhancement in anisotropic selectivity while maintaining etch rates compatible with practical microfabrication workflows. Beyond the specific parameter space explored here, the proposed strategy provides a robust and tunable process window for engineering SiO2 sidewall geometries with high reproducibility and scalability.
From an application perspective, the ability to realize near-anisotropic, low-roughness SiO2 microstructures using a scalable wet-etching approach is directly relevant to the fabrication of surface-relief gratings, integrated waveguides, and grating couplers. More broadly, such geometry-controlled dielectric structures form a critical technological foundation for diffractive metasurfaces, free-space optical interconnects, and emerging photonic computing architectures, including optical neural networks and hardware-level artificial intelligence. Against this background, the present work provides a practical materials-processing pathway that supports the manufacturability and large-area deployment of precision SiO2 photonic structures required for next-generation optical information processing systems.
Footnote |
| † JS and AP contributed equally to this work. |
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2026 |