Open Access Article
Yuki Komoto
ab,
Wataru Takahagi
c,
Takahito Ohshiro
ab,
Sumire Nishihatad,
Kosuke Fujishima
ce and
Masateru Taniguchi
*a
aSANKEN, The University of Osaka, 8-1, Mihogaoka, Ibaraki, Osaka 567-0047, Japan. E-mail: komoto@sanken.osaka-u.ac.jp
bArtificial Intelligence Research Center, Osaka University, 8-1 Mihogaoka, Ibaraki, Osaka 567-0047, Japan
cEarth-Life Science Institute, Institute of Science Tokyo, 2-12-1 Ookayama, Meguro-ku, Tokyo 152-8550, Japan
dSt. Andrew's Senior High School, 1-1, Manabino, Izumi, Osaka 594-1198, Japan
eGraduate School of Media and Governance, Keio University, 5322 Endo, Fujisawa, Kanagawa 252-0816, Japan
First published on 29th April 2026
Protein phosphorylation is one of the most prevalent post-translational modifications regulating biological functions, and its dysregulation is closely associated with neurodegenerative diseases such as Alzheimer's and Parkinson's disease. Despite extensive studies, direct detection of phosphorylation at the single-molecule level remains challenging because conventional mass spectrometry and antibody-based assays require complex pretreatments and cannot comprehensively resolve site-specific modifications. To address this challenge, we employed mechanically controllable break junction (MCBJ) measurements to probe the single-molecule conductance of serine (Ser), threonine (Thr), tyrosine (Tyr), and their phosphorylated counterparts. Distinct conductance trends were observed depending on the amino acid species, reflecting the influence of phosphate substitution on the electronic states. Density functional theory (DFT) calculations revealed that phosphorylation-induced shifts in HOMO levels and changes in π-conjugation account for the observed conductance variations. Furthermore, statistical analysis combined with machine-learning-based classification enabled discrimination between phosphorylated and non-phosphorylated amino acids with high accuracy, demonstrating that single-molecule electrical signals contain sufficient molecular information for identifying phosphorylation. This study establishes an electronic readout approach for amino acid phosphorylation and provides a proof of concept for extending single-molecule electrical techniques toward quantitative and sequencing-oriented analyses of protein modifications.
To overcome these limitations, we focused on single-molecule electrical measurements as a new approach for detecting phosphorylation. In this technique, a metallic nanowire fabricated by nanolithography is mechanically broken to form a nanometer-scale gap electrode, through which the current mediated by individual molecules can be directly measured.14–16 Using single-molecule measurements, conductance has been previously characterized for nucleic acids,17–19 amino acids,20,21 phosphorylated tyrosine,20 and phosphorylated peptide.22 This approach is therefore expected to be applicable to the simultaneous identification of phosphorylated amino acids, including serine and threonine, which are of particular interest in disease studies.7,8 Recent studies have shown that applying machine-learning algorithms to single-molecule signals can improve the discrimination accuracy.21,23–25 In this study, we developed a method for distinguishing phosphorylation at the single-residue level by combining single-molecule electrical measurements with machine learning. While the present work is limited to individual amino acids, it provides a proof-of-concept for extending this approach to more complex peptide systems, including the potential identification of multi-site phosphorylation in the future. In addition to sequence analysis, detection of phosphorylated serine as a potential biomarker.26 Detecting phosphorylation events at the single-residue level provide a basis for developing novel, simple diagnostic technologies.
We performed mechanically controllable break junction (MCBJ) measurements in aqueous solutions of serine (Ser), threonine (Thr), tyrosine (Tyr), phosphoserine (pSer), phosphothreonine (pThr), and phosphotyrosine (pTyr), as shown in Fig. 1.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 1 (a) Chemical structures of target molecules, Ser, pSer, Thr, pThr, Tyr, pTyr. (b) Schematic view of single-molecule measurement of pSer. (c) Schematic view of MCBJ set-up. | ||
It is well known that signals obtained from single-molecule measurements inherently exhibit variability in conductance due to differences in molecular orientation and electrode structure.37,38 Therefore, it is difficult to discuss the characteristics of single-molecule conductance based solely on individual signals, and a statistical analysis of all pulse signals is required. Table 1 summarizes the average conductance of the maximum current values (Ip) for each amino acid. Ip was defined as the maximum current of each pulse signal as shown in Fig. S3 in SI. For Ser and Thr, a decrease in average conductance was observed upon phosphorylation, whereas Tyr exhibited an increase in conductance after phosphorylation.
| Amino acid | Ip/pA | Td/ms |
|---|---|---|
| Ser | 36 | 6.0 |
| pSer | 34 | 4.4 |
| Thr | 33 | 5.6 |
| pThr | 26 | 4.6 |
| Tyr | 34 | 4.3 |
| pTyr | 38 | 4.0 |
To further analyze signal variations beyond the mean values, the histograms of the maximum current Ip and the two-dimensional histograms of Ip versus the duration of the pulse (Td) are shown in Fig. 3(a–f). The high-conductance signals decreased upon phosphorylation for Ser and Thr, whereas they increased for Tyr. However, the statistical differences in signal distributions between phosphorylated and non-phosphorylated species were small, and the histograms largely overlapped. To better visualize the subtle changes induced by phosphorylation, we conducted an additional analysis. Fig. 3(g–i) show differences in probability density between phosphorylated and non-phosphorylated amino acids. In this analysis, probability density maps were obtained using kernel density estimation (KDE) for both amino acids and their phosphorylated counterparts. KDE estimates the overall probability density by summing Gaussian kernels placed on the observed data points. By subtracting the density map of amino acids from that of phosphorylated amino acids, we can identify regions where one species appears more frequently than the other. In Fig. 3(g–i), positive values (red) indicate regions where phosphorylated amino acids are observed more frequently, while negative values (blue) correspond to regions where non-phosphorylated amino acids are more likely to appear. These heat maps reveal that, upon phosphorylation, the probability density increases in the low-conductance region for Ser and Thr, whereas it increases in the high-conductance region for Tyr. Thus, the probability density analysis based on KDE supports the same trend as observed in the average conductance results.
Single-molecule measurements revealed conductance changes upon phosphorylation (Fig. 2). Charge transport in a molecular junction depends critically on the energy alignment of the transport orbitals relative to the Fermi level of the Au electrode (EF ≈ −5.31) and on the electrode–molecule coupling Γ. In general, better level alignment (smaller |EF − ε|) and stronger coupling both promote higher conductance, but neither factor alone is sufficient.16 To interpret the experimental trends, we performed first-principles geometry optimizations and electronic-structure calculations (DFT; details in section 2.4). Fig. 4 shows the frontier orbital energy diagram. The HOMO of Ser and Thr resides mainly on the carboxylate group (−9.474 eV and −9.455 eV), while that of Tyr localizes on the aromatic ring (−8.233 eV) (Fig. 5). Upon phosphorylation, the HOMO of pSer/pThr relocates to the phosphate (−8.620 eV and −8.612 eV), i.e., energetically closer to EF, which would naively suggest higher conductance. Experimentally, however, Ser/Thr show a conductance decrease upon phosphorylation. This indicates that level alignment alone cannot explain the data; one must also consider Γ, which is governed by effective distance, orientation, and interfacial environment. In particular, phosphate anions exhibit strong hydration and pH-dependent specific adsorption on Au(111), which restructures the double layer and can weaken the contact (reduce Γ).39 Consistent with this model, the HOMO through HOMO−4 orbitals of pSer/pThr are localised on the phosphate (Fig. 4).
![]() | ||
| Fig. 4 Isosurface of HOMOs/LUMO of Ser, pSer, Thr, pThr, Tyr, and pTyr calculated by DFT ωB97X-D/def2-QZVPP//ωB97X-D/def2-TZVPP32–34 (Isovalue = 0.05). Solvation effects were incorporated with the Solvation Model based on Density (SMD) implicit-solvent model, parameterized for water. | ||
![]() | ||
| Fig. 5 Schematic energy diagram of HOMOs of Ser, pSer, Thr, pThr, Tyr, and pTyr. The spatial distribution of the HOMOs marked with asterisks is almost evenly split between the phosphate site and the carboxylate sites (see Fig. 4). | ||
Single-molecule conductance is commonly associated with frontier molecular orbitals. However, molecular conductance is not exclusively determined by orbital energy alignment; the strength and nature of electrode–molecule coupling also play a significant role.40 Typically, such efficient coupling between a molecular orbital and the electrode is established via strong covalent anchoring groups such as thiols, where the spatially diffuse sulfur 3p orbitals extensively hybridize with the gold electrodes to form broadened, highly transparent transport channels.41,42 In contrast, the oxygen 2p orbitals of carboxylate groups exhibit increased spatial contraction, resulting in inherently weaker electronic coupling.43 In the non-anchored system, the phosphate group, despite possessing high-lying HOMOs, experiences steric hindrance arising from hydration and interfacial electrostatic effects. These factors restrict the physical approach of the group to the electrodes and thereby limit its contribution to tunnelling transport. Consequently, although HOMOs localized on the phosphate group are relatively high in energy, the difficulty in securing close proximity to the electrodes may act to lower Γ. This interpretation suggests transport via deeper-lying orbitals as one of the possible mechanisms contributing to the reduced conductance observed in pSer and pThr. Orbitals localized on the carboxylate group, such as the HOMO−5 of pSer and pThr, can be involved in the tunnelling current. Despite the absence of a covalent anchoring group or a conjugated bridge in the molecules, the carboxylate group remains physically accessible and may transiently approach the electrodes. Consequently, HOMO−5 can also function as a possible tunnelling pathway and can contribute to charge transport under dynamic fluctuations. These deeper-lying orbitals are located farther from the Au Fermi level than the HOMO of the non-phosphorylated species as represented in Fig. 5. This energy offset may contribute to the observed decrease in conductance upon phosphorylation.
The LUMOs of pSer and pThr also exhibit spatial distributions localized on the carboxylate group, similar to HOMO−5. However, DFT calculations indicate that these orbitals lie farther from the Fermi level than HOMO−5, as shown in Fig. S3 in SI 4. Their contribution to tunnelling transport is therefore considered to be less significant, although it cannot be excluded entirely.
As an alternative transport mechanism, a decrease in conductance can also be considered even when transport occurs via HOMO. The molecular sizes are summarized in Table S1 in SI 5. Phosphorylation can increase the effective tunnelling decay distance, due to both increased molecular length and hydration, thereby reducing conductance. As a result, even for HOMO-mediated transport, the conductance may decrease upon phosphorylation.
By contrast, the increased conductance observed for Tyr upon phosphorylation appears to be related to the HOMO of pTyr localized on the aromatic ring. In pTyr, the aromatic π HOMO usually sits higher than oxygen-centred occupied orbitals because differential solvation stabilizes phosphate/carboxylate lone-pair states far more than the ring π level. In aqueous or other polar media, phosphate (PO4n−) forms a strong, structured first hydration shell with slowed water dynamics, and carboxylates likewise show pronounced hydration signatures; both effects pull down the energies of n(O)-type occupied orbitals relative to vacuum. By contrast, the hydrophobic phenyl π system couples weakly to the reaction field and is much less downward-stabilized, leaving the ring-centered HOMO relatively higher.39,44 This solvation asymmetry is compounded by limited π-conjugation across the Ph–O–P linkage: aryl phosphates transmit mostly inductive rather than effective π-resonance into the ring, so the phenyl π level remains close to that of a phenoxy/phenyl unit instead of being pulled down by extended delocalization. Phosphorylation also renders the molecule anionic, which tends to raise all occupied levels on a vacuum scale; however, because oxygen-localized orbitals are preferentially re-stabilized by hydration and hydrogen bonding, the aromatic π HOMO remains the highest after competing shifts are accounted for. For transport, note that conductance depends on level alignment and electrode–molecule coupling Γ, not alignment alone.
The broad conductance distribution reflects contributions from multiple configurations, including those with more effective π-metal interactions as well as configurations where the π-plane is more parallel to the electrodes and through-space tunnelling becomes significant.45–48
The results of this experimental and theoretical study suggest that conductance in such dynamic nanogap systems is governed not only by absolute orbital energy alignment but also critically by physical accessibility, spatial orbital distribution, and transient electrode–molecule coupling under fluctuating configurations. The present discussion of transport is necessarily qualitative, as the DFT calculations in this study primarily provide information on energy levels and orbital localization in solution. Therefore, the proposed mechanism should be regarded as a plausible interpretation consistent with the observations. A more complete understanding will require transport calculations that incorporate molecular configurations in solution.
For completeness, we note that earlier single-molecule studies have demonstrated that Tyr and pTyr can be distinguished based on the statistical properties of current pulses. In our measurements, the observed current signals do not arise from transport through stable molecular junctions, but rather from stochastic tunnelling events mediated by transient molecular configurations within the nanogap. This behavior is conceptually related to both recognition tunnelling approaches49 and prior research.20 Similar to previous method,20 and unlike recognition tunnelling methods,49 our system does not utilize any recognition molecules. The measured conductance originates from probabilistic tunnelling through temporarily oriented molecules. However, despite the presence of orientational freedom, this study differs from previous work20 in that a narrower nanogap is employed. This spatial confinement is expected to restrict the accessible molecular configurations, thereby influencing the observed current distributions. Therefore, the measured signals should be interpreted not as steady-state molecular conductance, but as configuration-dependent tunnelling events under spatial confinement. The conductance behavior observed in this study differs from ref. 20, and thus direct up/down comparisons should be made with care. Theoretical studies show that phosphorylation affects conductance increase/decrease, consistent with our observations.50 In these models, the phosphate group may directly participate in the transport pathway. The lower observed conductance supports the interpretation that coupling is weaker and configuration-dependent in our solvated and transient conduction system. The phosphate group is more likely to influence conductance indirectly. This interpretation is supported by recent work emphasizing the role of molecular configuration.51 Overall, our DFT results corroborate that single-molecule conductance captures molecule-intrinsic features, while also emphasizing that the transport orbital closest to EF is not necessarily the dominant channel; interfacial coupling Γ can be equally decisive. Moreover, solvent/double-layer effects and surface chemistry modulate transport systematically, as highlighted in recent measurements.52
Changes in conductance were observed in the single-molecule measurements, and these experimentally observed variations could be rationalized by the DFT calculations. However, the distributions of the peak current and signal duration were broad, and the corresponding histograms showed substantial overlap. Therefore, it was not possible to identify each molecule solely from the peak current or duration of a single signal. To overcome this limitation, we applied a machine learning-based classification approach, which has been reported to enhance molecular discrimination in various single-molecule systems, to achieve identification at the single-molecule level.21,23 Fig. 6(a) illustrates the classification scheme. Current traces were recorded using the MCBJ technique, and pulse-like signals were extracted. Each extracted signal was converted into a 15-dimensional feature vector consisting of the peak current (Ip), pulse duration (Td), average current, and 12 averaged shape factors normalized by Ip obtained through average pooling as shown in Fig. S4 in SI. These features were used for training and testing with 10-fold cross-validation. A random forest classifier was employed for discrimination. The classification results for the phosphorylated and non-phosphorylated forms of each amino acid are shown in Fig. 6(b–d). The classification accuracies were 0.70, 0.79, and 0.75 for Ser, Thr, and Tyr, respectively. The highest accuracy was achieved for Tyr, which exhibited a pronounced increase in high-conductance signals upon phosphorylation. The same classification procedure was also applied to discriminate among all six molecules. The results are shown in Fig. 6(e). In all cases, the correct class was predicted with the highest frequency, and the overall six-class classification accuracy was 0.51. Considering that random classification would yield an accuracy of 0.16, the classification of amino acids and their phosphorylated forms was successfully achieved. Feature importances analysis of the classification model was performed (see SI 6). The results show that the Ip and the average current contribute most significantly to the classification, confirming that differences in conductance are the primary factors governing discrimination. Fig. 6(f) summarizes the classification accuracy obtained by integrating multiple signals based on the confusion matrix in Fig. 6(e). By applying a majority-voting scheme described in SI 7 to 10 individual signals, an average classification accuracy of 0.88 was achieved. Increasing the number of integrated signals further improved the accuracy to 0.97 for 20 signals and 0.99 for 30 signals. For 30 signals, the accuracies of Ser and pSer are over 0.999. These classification accuracies are achieved through the accumulation of multiple signals; therefore, reliable discrimination requires the integration of multiple events rather than relying on single-event measurements. These results demonstrate that single-molecule measurements enable reliable discrimination between amino acids and their phosphorylated forms.
Supplementary information is available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d6nr00687f.
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2026 |