Md Rasidul
Islam
*a,
Md Rabbi
Talukder
b,
Ovijit
Das
c,
Md Adil
Hossain
a and
Md Masud
Rana
*a
aDepartment of Electrical and Computer Engineering, The University of Texas at Tyler, Tyler-75799, TX, USA. E-mail: mdrasidulislam@uttyler.edu; mrana@uttyler.edu
bDepartment of Materials Science & Engineering, Khulna University of Engineering & Technology (KUET), Khulna-9203, Bangladesh
cDepartment of Materials Science and Engineering, University of Connecticut, Connecticut, CT 06269, USA
First published on 5th December 2025
The baseline for photovoltaic and optoelectronic device commercialization was established by non-toxic halide cubic perovskites. In this study, an in-depth exploration of the physical features of Sr3BiX3 (X = I, Br, and Cl) materials was conducted using density functional theory (DFT) due to their immense significance. All the materials are cubic in structure. The GGA-PBE potential functional revealed direct band gaps of 1.324 eV, 1.512 eV, and 1.731 eV for the Sr3BiI3, Sr3BiBr3, and Sr3BiCl3, respectively. Furthermore, the investigated compounds demonstrated remarkable absorption, elevated conductivity, reduced reflectivity, an optimal refractive index, and negligible loss function within the visible light range, making them exceptional candidates for photovoltaic technologies. The Born stability requirements confirmed the mechanical stability of the investigated compounds. In addition, their intrinsic rigidity, strength, resilience, ductility, and anisotropic properties are crucial for enduring performance in engineering contexts. The ab initio molecular dynamics (AIMD) simulations verified the thermal stability of the entitled compounds. These perovskites are experimentally feasible since their phonon dispersion curves have no imaginary portion. To expedite material discovery and bandgap estimation, a machine learning (ML) model was developed using a dataset derived from DFT calculations. The ML-predicted band gaps 1.432 eV, 1.545 eV, and 1.712 eV showed strong agreement with the DFT results 1.324 eV, 1.512 eV, and 1.731 eV for Sr3BiX3 (X = I, Br, and Cl), validating the model's reliability. Moreover, Pearson correlation analysis was employed to explore the connections between structural, electronic, and optical features, providing deeper insight into the key parameters influencing the bandgap. This integrated DFT-ML approach demonstrates a promising pathway for high-throughput screening and design of perovskite materials.
A perovskite material, notably those defined by the general formula ABX3, where ‘A’ represents an alkali earth metal, ‘B’ denotes bivalent cations, and ‘X’ signifies a halide ion, has garnered considerable attention due to their outstanding optoelectronic features.6,7 These substances exhibit remarkable abilities to absorb light, possess elevated charge-carrier mobilities, demonstrate extended diffusion lengths, and feature minimal exciton binding energies.8 Furthermore, perovskites can be created through affordable and scalable production techniques, like solution processing and vapor deposition, rendering them more economically advantageous than conventional Si-based solar panels.9 The advancement of perovskite solar cells (PSCs) has been truly groundbreaking. Continuous improvements in material design, interface engineering, and device architecture have significantly enhanced their efficiency to 27% as of 2025.10 This remarkable surge in performance underscores the significant promise of perovskite-based photovoltaics to emerge as a dominant force in the global shift toward sustainable energy solutions. Some notable examples are AlGeX3 (X = F, Cl, Br),11 FrMI3 (M = Ge, Sn),12 AMgCl3 (A = Ga, In, Tl),13 and RbSnX3 (X = Cl, Br, I),14 which illustrate their capacity to contribute to the development of optoelectronic applications. Talukder et al.15 illustrate in their investigation of ABI3 (A = Rb, Cs; B = Ca, Sr) that materials based on Rb exhibit superior optoelectronic performance compared to those based on Cs. Hasan et al.16 stated that inorganic InGeX3 (X = F, Cl) demonstrates remarkable semiconducting characteristics during their investigation of its optoelectronic properties.
In recent years, the focus of perovskite research has increasingly broadened beyond the traditional ABX3 structure to encompass more intricate variants such as A3BX3. In this updated arrangement, ‘A’ usually signifies an alkali metal, ‘B’ indicates a trivalent or tetravalent metal, and ‘X’ refers to a halogen atom.17 This stoichiometry offers a distinct crystal arrangement and chemical adaptability, enabling the precise tuning of electronic and optical parameters, which makes it highly appealing for applications in photovoltaics and optoelectronics.18 Remarkably, A3BX3 perovskites display beneficial traits including ideal band gaps, high absorption coefficients, and excellent carrier transport properties, all of which are necessary for effective solar energy conversion and the integration of electronic devices.19 A significant investigation in this field was carried out by Feng et al.,20 who thoroughly examined the stability and photovoltaic potential of A3BX3-type halide perovskites. The researchers concentrated in particular on Ba3PI3, Ba3AsI3, and Ba3SbI3 compounds, revealing that these materials demonstrate remarkable thermodynamic stability, appropriate band gaps, and robust absorption coefficients in the visible light span. Notably, among the most promising choices for future Pb-free perovskite solar panels, Ba3SbI3 was projected to attain a power conversion efficiency of up to 25.9%. Hasan et al.21 explored the potential of Sr3SbBr3 material for photovoltaic applications. Ghosh et al.22 investigated the physical properties of Sr3AsX3 (X = Br, Cl, F), providing a valuable perspective on their potential uses in energy storage and electronic device systems. Hasan et al.23 investigated the impact of varying cations and anions in Mg3BX3 (B = N, P; X = Br, I) compounds and discovered remarkable tunable properties.
Recently, Khandaker et al.24 explored the Bi-based materials Mg3BiBr3 and Mg3BiI3, recognizing them as semiconductors with significant promise for solar energy conversion. According to their article, Mg3BiBr3 and Mg3BiI3 exhibit band gaps of 1.626 eV and 0.867 eV, respectively, as well as strong sunlight absorption coefficients, modest reflectivity, and excellent photoconductivity. They also proposed that both compounds could function as emerging optical materials for future solar cell technologies. This study concentrates on the class of Sr3BiX3 (X = Cl, Br, I) perovskites, which include the alkaline earth metal strontium (Sr) and the post-transition metal bismuth (Bi). The choice of bismuth-based halide compounds is primarily driven by the increasing demand for safe and stable substitutes for lead-based perovskites.25 Bi, characterized by its trivalent oxidation state and ns2 electronic configuration, is essential in creating stable structures driven by lone pairs, which leads to favorable optoelectronic properties, including enhanced light absorption and better charge carrier dynamics.26 Conversely, Sr is not only plentiful in the Earth's crust but also recognized for its remarkable reactivity and capacity to improve structural stability when incorporated into perovskite frameworks.27 The Sr3BiX3 family showcases a distinctive structural arrangement and appealing electronic characteristics, attributed to the cooperative interaction between Sr and Bi cations. A thorough literature review highlights the significant lack of theoretical studies regarding the inorganic Sr3BiX3 halide perovskites, suggesting a vast area for scholarly exploration. The remarkable properties of these materials have ignited our interest, driving us to explore further the prospect of Sr3BiX3 (X = I, Br, and Cl) cubic perovskites in overcoming existing material limitations and achieving their utmost potential.
In this work, we employed density functional theory (DFT) calculations within a computational framework to thoroughly explore the structural, mechanical, electronic, optical, phonon, and thermodynamic properties of these novel halide perovskites. Special attention was given to the influence of halogen substitution on the material's behavior, aiming to clarify how the gradual replacement of the halogen anion can effectively adjust the band gap, thereby improving the materials’ optoelectronic performance. In this exploration, we aim to offer fresh perspectives on developing highly efficient, non-toxic, and stable materials, which could pave the way for the advancement of cutting-edge optoelectronic devices and solar energy innovations.
m space group (No. 221), typical of many halide perovskites.41 In this system, Sr elements occupy the cube corners (Wyckoff position 1a), the Bi atom is positioned at the center of the cube (1b), and the halogen atoms (X = I, Br, and Cl) reside at the face centers (3d positions), forming corner-sharing BiX6 octahedra.17 These BiX6 units are arranged in a three-dimensional network, creating a robust perovskite lattice with Sr atoms situated in the 12-fold coordinated cubo-octahedral voids. Full structural optimization was carried out using DFT, where both lattice parameters and atomic configurations have been relaxed till the overall energy converged below 10−6 eV and the atomic forces have been less than 0.01 eV Å−1. As expected, the lattice constant decreases systematically with decreasing halogen ionic radius, i.e., a(I) > a(Br) > a(Cl), consistent with the chemical trend of halide substitution and confirming the structural integrity across the series.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 1 (a) Structure of the Sr3BiX3 (X = I, Br, and Cl) halide perovskite compounds and (b) the high-symmetry points of the Brillouin zone. | ||
Fig. 1(b) displays the corresponding first Brillouin zone (BZ) of the primitive cubic lattice, with high symmetry k-points labeled as Γ, X, M, and R. These points are utilized for band structure evaluations, capturing the key electronic features of Sr3BiX3 compounds. The reciprocal lattice vectors b1, b2, and b3 are also shown, delineating the cubic symmetry of the reciprocal space.17 The high structural symmetry, tunable lattice size through halide substitution, and the stability of the cubic phase make Sr3BiX3 perovskites promising candidates for optoelectronic, photovoltaics, and LEDs (light-emitting devices). The resulting lattice constants and unit cell volumes follow a clear trend based on halogen substitution. Specifically, the lattice constant decreases from 6.723 Å for Sr3BiI3 to 6.493 Å for Sr3BiBr3 and further to 6.366 Å for Sr3BiCl3. Correspondingly, the unit cell volume contracts from 303.87 Å3 (I) to 273.74 Å3 (Br) and 257.99 Å3 (Cl). This trend is compatible with the decreasing ionic radius of the halide anions and reflects the expected chemical pressure effect within the perovskite lattice.22 Besides, previous work on similar Ca-based compounds shows comparable values of lattice constant and cell volume, which further justifies the accuracy of our work.42 The value of the lattice parameter and unit cell volumes, along with the band gap value, are displayed in Table 1.
| Structure | Lattice Constant, a = b = c (Å) | Volume, V (Å3) | Bandgap (PBE), Eg (eV) | Bandgap with SOC (PBE), Eg (eV) | Bandgap (PBEsol), Eg (eV) | Bandgap (HSE), Eg (eV) | Remarks |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sr3BiI3 | 6.723 | 303.87 | 1.324 | 0.794 | 1.389 | 1.878 | This work |
| Sr3BiBr3 | 6.493 | 273.74 | 1.512 | 1.052 | 1.567 | 2.245 | This work |
| Sr3BiCl3 | 6.366 | 257.99 | 1.731 | 1.223 | 1.786 | 2.427 | This work |
| Sr3BiI3 | 6.690 | 299.42 | 1.30 | Previous work42 | |||
| Ca3BiI3 | 6.42 | 264.60 | 1.29 | 0.81 | — | 2.39 | Previous work42 |
| Ca3BiBr3 | 6.17 | 234.88 | 1.60 | 1.12 | — | 2.84 | Previous work43 |
| Ca3BiCl3 | 6.02 | 218.167 | 1.76 | 1.30 | — | 3.08 | Previous work43 |
![]() | ||
| Fig. 2 (a)–(f) Band structure of the Sr3BiX3 (X = I, Br, and Cl) halide perovskite compounds without and including the SOC effect. | ||
To mitigate the well-known undermine of band gaps in GGA-PBE, we performed additional calculations that included the spin–orbit coupling (SOC) effect. This approach is particularly important for Bi-based halide perovskites, as the heavy Bi atom introduces significant relativistic effects.44 The PBE + SOC band structures yield band gaps of 0.794 eV (Sr3BiI3), 1.052 eV (Sr3BiBr3), and 1.223 eV (Sr3BiCl3), showing that SOC reduces the gap due to the splitting of the Bi-p orbitals close to the valence band edge.45 Incorporating both the Brillouin zone symmetry and relativistic effects provides a more accurate and physically meaningful understanding of the electronic structure.46 The tunable band gap across the halogen series, along with their relatively clean band dispersion, makes Sr3BiX3 perovskites promising candidates for use in optoelectronic applications like photodetectors and solar panels.
To gain a deeper perspective on the electronic structure and bonding features of Sr3BiX3 (X = I, Br, and Cl), the projected partial density of states (PDOS) and total partial density of states (TDOS) were calculated, both with and without the inclusion of SOC, as illustrated in Fig. 3. The top row (Fig. 3a–d) presents the PDOS and TDOS without SOC, while the bottom row (Fig. 3e–h) includes SOC effects. Across all three compounds, the valence band (VB) is predominantly composed of Bi-6s, Bi-6p, and X-p (I-5p, Br-4p, Cl-3p) orbitals, whereas the conduction band (CB) is mainly derived from Bi-6p and Sr-4p contributions. For Sr3BiI3 (Fig. 3a), the VB edge is influenced by strong I-5p and Bi-6s hybridization, indicating substantial covalent character. A similar feature is observed for Sr3BiBr3 and Sr3BiCl3 (Fig. 3b and c), where Br-4p and Cl-3p states, respectively, contribute significantly to the top of the VB. The CBM in all three systems is primarily composed of Bi-6p orbitals, indicating their crucial role in conduction processes. Upon incorporating SOC (Fig. 3e–g), a notable splitting of the Bi-p orbitals is observed near the conduction band edge, particularly in Sr3BiI3. This SOC-induced splitting results in a downward shift of the CB edge, resulting in a lowering of the electronic Eg, which is consistent with previous band structure results.45 The effect is most pronounced in Sr3BiI3, which contains the heaviest halogen (I), and diminishes progressively in Sr3BiBr3 and Sr3BiCl3, owing to the weaker relativistic effects in lighter halogens.
The total density of state reflects that the valence states extend from approximately −5 eV to the Fermi level (EF = 0), and the conduction states commence immediately after, consistent with the semiconducting behavior noticed in the band structure. The total density of state plots reveals that the overall intensity of states at the valence band maximum is slightly higher in Sr3BiI3, which may enhance its optical absorption near the band edge. Additionally, SOC modifies the fine features of the PDOS near both band edges, redistributing states that could influence carrier mobility and effective masses.47
In conclusion, the PDOS analysis confirms that the hybridization of Bi and halogen p-states predominantly governs the electronic structure of Sr3BiX3 (X = I, Br, and Cl) materials. The inclusion of SOC significantly influences the conduction band features, particularly in iodide and bromide variants, and must be considered for accurate prediction of their optoelectronic behavior. The systematic variation across the halogen series also highlights the chemical tunability of band edge states, which is key for tailoring materials for specific optical and electronic applications.
Furthermore, charge density reveals various physical processes of a compound by defining its bonding state at specific locations. Fig. 4 demonstrates the charge density depiction of Sr3BiX3 (X = I, Br, and Cl) compounds. The spherical contours surrounding the Bi and Cl/Br/I atoms signify ionic bonding without atomic overlap, while the elliptical contours between the Sr and Bi atoms suggest covalent bonding in the (100) direction due to their overlap. Additionally, there is a slight overlap between Sr and Cl/Br/I atoms. The character of this covalent bonding diminishes when Br or I replaces Cl.
The imaginary portion of the dielectric constant, ε2(ω), shown in Fig. 5(b), is directly related to the material's absorption of incident photons via interband transitions.51 The estimated onset of ε2(ω) follows the expected trend across the halogen series: approximately 0.43 eV for Sr3BiI3, 0.51 eV for Sr3BiBr3, and 0.68 eV for Sr3BiCl3. All the materials exhibited the highest ε2(ω) peaks in the early-UV region. The absorption edge blue-shifts progressively from iodide to chloride, indicating enhanced transparency in the visible range for lighter halogens.
The absorption coefficient α(ω) measures an object's capacity to capture sunlight energy, providing insights that might increase the efficiency of photovoltaic devices.52 The ε2(ω) shows how a material absorbs electromagnetic waves at certain frequencies. The initial α(ω) peak is crucial in photovoltaics as it displays the range of sunlight that a compound can effectively store.53 Besides, it is clearly seen from Fig. 5(c) that α(ω) is directly related to the band gap of the compounds, as absorption occurs at the band gap value rather than at 0 eV.43 The absorption coefficient originates from the approximately photon energy values of 1.3 eV for Sr3BiCl3, 1.5 eV for Sr3BiBr3, and 1.7 eV for Sr3BiCl3. As displayed in Fig. 5(c), the α(ω) spectra further reinforce the blue-shifting trend from iodide to chloride as previously mentioned. Sr3BiX3 materials exhibit high and broad α value in the visible spectrum, initiating around 1.3–1.7 eV, which renders them particularly beneficial for photovoltaic and photodetector applications.18 Moreover, these perovskites show wide peaks in the early UV-region, indicating their potential for UV detection and filtering applications.13
The electron energy loss function (EELF), plotted in Fig. 5(d), reveals a prominent bulk plasmon resonance for all three materials.54 When photon energy exceeds the band gaps, the perovskites lose energy. In both contexts, exchanging Cl with Br or I atoms redshifts the EELF peaks, thereby enhancing the material's interaction with visible light and optimizing its optical performance. The plasmon peak appears sharply at approximately 8.10 eV for Sr3BiI3, 8.35 eV for Sr3BiBr3, and 8.52 eV for Sr3BiCl3. Among the explored materials, Sr3BiI3 exhibits the most intense peak, indicating stronger collective oscillations of free electrons, a feature valuable in plasmonic and high-energy electron applications.
To gain deeper insights into the optoelectronic behavior of Sr3BiX3 (X = I, Br, Cl), we further evaluated the reflectivity, refractive index, extinction coefficient, and photoconductivity as shown in Fig. 6. These parameters provide critical information regarding light–matter interaction, including how the material transmits, reflects, and absorbs photons across the energy spectrum.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 6 Optical properties of the (a) reflectivity, (b) refractive index, (c) extinction coefficient, and (d) optical conductivity of the Sr3BiX3 (X = I, Br, and Cl) halide perovskite compounds. | ||
Reflectivity is a critical factor in determining the amount of energy reflected at interfaces.55 Understanding the concept of reflectivity in the visible range is crucial, as excessive reflectivity can reduce solar efficiency.56Fig. 6(a) displays the reflectivity changes with photon energy. All compounds exhibit low reflectivity (below 0.1) in the visible spectrum, which is beneficial for solar applications as it implies higher photon absorption. However, a sharp rise occurs near 7–9 eV, with Sr3BiI3 reaching a maximum reflectivity of ∼0.68, followed by Sr3BiBr3 (∼0.62) and Sr3BiCl3 (∼0.54). This strong reflection in the deep-UV region is linked to collective plasmon oscillations near the bulk plasmon energy (∼8 eV), as seen earlier in the loss function.
The refractive index η(ω) plays a crucial role in determining the velocity of light in photonic devices, such as solar cells, sensors, and detectors.57 It detects a variety of optical phenomena, including reflection, refraction, and total internal reflection. Fig. 6(b) shows the refractive index spectra. The static refractive index, η(0), is highest for Sr3BiI3 at around 1.96, decreasing to 1.81 for Sr3BiBr3 and 1.74 for Sr3BiCl3. After that, the η(ω) increases as the transition occurs from the infrared to the visible spectrum. This trend aligns with their band gap values and dielectric constants, indicating stronger light–matter coupling in Sr3BiI3. The refractive index peaks around 1.5–2.1 eV, further supporting the idea that Sr3BiX3 is highly responsive in the visible spectrum.58
Fig. 6(c) presents the extinction coefficient, which characterizes the compound's absorption loss when light propagates through it.51 Sr3BiI3, Sr3BiBr3, and Sr3BiCl3 all show broader and stronger extinction across the visible range 0–2 eV. The extinction coefficient decreases rapidly beyond 2 eV and remains relatively low at higher photon energies. The entitle perovskites exhibit peak values for the extinction coefficient ranging from 1.5 to 1.7 eV, emphasizing significant optical activity, which enables them to absorb more sunlight and improve the performance of photonic devices.59 Sr3BiI3 displays the highest extinction coefficient in the visible light region, with Sr3BiBr3 and Sr3BiCl3 following closely.
Finally, Fig. 6(d) depicts the optical conductivity σ(ω), which measures the material's response to external electromagnetic fields. Photoconductivity and σ(ω) are complementary properties that characterize a material's photon conductivity. Higher photon absorption results in increased electrical conductivity, leading to a corresponding increase in σ(ω). All the materials showed peaks in the visible light region and also exhibited the largest peak in the UV region. Sr3BiI3 again shows the highest overall optical conductivity, peaking at ∼0.0025 (Ω−1 cm−1) in the visible range, suggesting superior charge carrier excitation under illumination. Moreover, a blue shift is also noticed in the optical conductivity spectrum when the X-site atom is substituted from iodide to chloride.
In summary, the Sr3BiX3 family exhibits highly tunable optical characteristics influenced by the halogen atom. Sr3BiI3, with its high dielectric constant, strong visible-light absorption, and low optical band gap, is the most promising candidate for optoelectronic applications, whereas Sr3BiCl3 may serve better in UV-sensitive devices. Besides, these extended optical analyses further validate the strong light-harvesting ability of Sr3BiI3, owing to its higher refractive index, broader extinction, and enhanced conductivity in the visible regime, similar to the previously reported I-based configuration of Ca3BiX3 work.43 On the other hand, Sr3BiCl3, with its UV-selective behavior and moderate optical response, may find niche applications in UV filtering, sensing, or transparent coatings.
The phonon spectra are composed of three acoustic and multiple optical branches, as expected for a system with a relatively large unit cell. The acoustic modes emerge smoothly from the Γ point and exhibit typical linear and quadratic dispersion at low frequencies. The highest optical phonon frequencies reach ∼328 cm−1 for Sr3BiCl3, 324 cm−1 for Sr3BiBr3, and 311.5 cm−1 for Sr3BiI3, indicating a gradual blue shift with decreasing halogen mass. This trend follows the expected mass-dependence of lattice vibrations, where lighter halogens lead to stiffer (higher-frequency) phonon modes.60 In the low-frequency region (below 100 cm−1), Sr3BiI3 exhibits more densely packed phonon branches, likely due to the heavier iodine atoms contributing to slower vibrational modes. These low-energy modes can play a significant role in thermal transport, electron–phonon coupling, and anharmonic effects. Overall, the phonon dispersions confirm that Sr3BiX3 compounds are lattice-stable cubic halide perovskites. Their well-separated optical modes and halogen-dependent vibrational behavior suggest tunable vibrational entropy and thermal conductivity, with potential implications for thermoelectric or phonon-assisted optoelectronic applications.
Thermodynamic characteristics are crucial for understanding how materials behave and remain stable under various conditions. This work evaluated key thermodynamic parameters, such as entropy, free energy, and heat capacity, using vibrational qualities obtained from phonon simulations. To assess the stability and thermal responsiveness of the studied perovskites, their characteristics were examined across a wide temperature span, from 0 to 800 K. The system becomes more thermodynamically stable at higher temperatures, as signified by the steady decline in free energy with increasing temperature, as shown in Fig. 8(a). This trend is common to most solids and represents the inherent propensity of materials to reduce their free energy via thermal excitation.61Fig. 8(b) shows the temperature-dependent behavior of entropy. As the temperature rises, entropy steadily increases, indicating an increase in atomic disorder and vibrational motion. This reflects the system's increased ability to absorb thermal energy and move into more disordered states. Fig. 8(c) shows the heat capacity with temperature for all investigated compounds. The heat capacity increases with temperature, reaching a saturation point at higher temperatures, in accordance with the Dulong-Petit limit.60 These findings offer valuable insights into the materials' vibrational dynamics and their capacity to store thermal energy. The comparative analysis of these thermodynamic properties across different compositions improves our understanding of their thermal resilience and suitability for high-temperature applications, notably in energy harvesting and thermal management systems.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 9 (a)–(f) The total energy and temperature fluctuations profile of Sr3BiX3 (X = I, Br, and Cl) halide perovskite compounds with a 5000 fs simulation time utilizing AIMD simulations. | ||
Fig. 9(d)–(f) present the corresponding temperature profiles. Despite some fluctuations, particularly for Sr3BiI3 and Sr3BiBr3, the average temperature stays centered around the target value of 600 K, validating the thermostat's efficacy. These fluctuations are a natural outcome of molecular dynamics and signify the exchange of kinetic energy among atoms. Notably, Sr3BiCl3 displays the most stable thermal behavior, maintaining a relatively narrow temperature range, which may suggest greater lattice rigidity or stronger interatomic forces compared to the iodide and bromide analogs.
Overall, the AIMD results demonstrate that all Sr3BiX3 compounds are thermally stable up to at least 600 K, with no evidence of structural collapse or phase instability. These findings support their viability for practical high-temperature applications, such as in solar cells or thermally stressed optoelectronic devices.
| Parameters | Unit | Sr3BiI3 | Sr3BiBr3 | Sr3BiCl3 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| C 11 | GPa | 60.324 | 61.223 | 62.78 |
| C 12 | GPa | 9.446 | 10.146 | 11.51 |
| C 44 | GPa | 11.446 | 12.246 | 13.11 |
| B | GPa | 26.405 | 27.238 | 28.6 |
| G | GPa | 14.675 | 15.459 | 16.295 |
| Y | GPa | 37.144 | 38.998 | 41.082 |
| ν | — | 0.2655 | 0.2614 | 0.2606 |
| B/G | — | 1.799 | 1.762 | 1.755 |
| G/B | — | 0.556 | 0.567 | 0.569 |
| H v | GPa | 1.844 | 2.109 | 2.291 |
| A | — | 0.449 | 0.479 | 0.511 |
| θ D | K | 146.491 | 173.977 | 206.581 |
| v m | m s−1 | 1736.338 | 1984.072 | 2308.933 |
| v l | m s−1 | 2061.837 | 2581.755 | 3590.750 |
| v t | m s−1 | 1716.854 | 1895.055 | 2122.427 |
| T m ± 300 | K | 909.575 | 914.889 | 924.092 |
Born stability standard, C11 > 0; C44 > 0; (C11 + 2C12) > 0; (C11 − C12) > 0
The values of C11 increase gradually from 60.324 GPa for Sr3BiI3 to 62.78 GPa for Sr3BiCl3, reflecting an increase in bond strength and structural rigidity as the halogen size decreases. Similarly, C12 increases from 9.446 GPa to 11.51 GPa, and C44 from 11.446 GPa to 13.11 GPa, indicating overall stiffening of the lattice from iodide to chloride.
The derived mechanical module further supports this trend. The bulk modulus (B) rises from 26.405 GPa (I) to 28.6 GPa (Cl), while the shear modulus (G) rises from 14.675 GPa to 16.295 GPa, and Young's modulus (Y) from 37.144 GPa to 41.082 GPa, confirming greater resistance to both volumetric and shear deformation in Sr3BiCl3. The Poisson's ratio (ν) remains relatively stable across the series, ranging from 0.2655 (I) to 0.2606 (Cl), indicating ductile behavior.61 This is further validated by the Pugh ratio (B/G), which exceeds 1.75 for all compounds, such as 1.799 (I), 1.762 (Br), and 1.755 (Cl), demonstrating ductility across the series.64
Mechanical hardness, as evaluated via Vickers hardness (Hv), also shows an increasing trend: 1.844 GPa (I), 2.109 GPa (Br), and 2.291 GPa (Cl), consistent with stronger bonding in the lighter halides. The anisotropy factor (A) increases from 0.449 to 0.511, implying a modest rise in elastic anisotropy from I to Cl. These trends are also reflected in the ELATE-based 3D plots (Fig. 10). An isotropic material exhibits the characteristics of a perfect sphere, while any departure from this shape signifies anisotropy.15 The contour plots of the examined perovskites reveal significant non-spherical patterns, suggesting their anisotropic character. The Young's modulus surfaces reveal moderate directional dependence, with Ymin–Ymax values ranging from 30.0 to 59.2 GPa for Sr3BiCl3, as summarized in Table 3. Linear compressibility (β) remains nearly isotropic in all cases, with minimal directional variation. In contrast, G and ν exhibit more pronounced anisotropies; Sr3BiI3, for example, shows ν values spanning from 0.0799 to 0.4896, reflecting considerable variation in lateral strain response across crystallographic directions.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 10 Anisotropic properties: (a)–(l) Young's modulus, linear compressibility, shear modulus, and Poisson's ratio of Sr3BiX3 (X = I, Br, and Cl) halide perovskite compounds. | ||
| Young's modulus (Y) | Linear compressibility (β) | Shear modulus (G) | Poisson's ratio (ν) | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Y min | Y max | β min | β max | G min | G max | ν min | ν max | |
| Sr3BiI3 | 30.003 | 57.766 | 12.624 | 12.624 | 11.446 | 25.439 | 0.0799 | 0.4896 |
| Sr3BiBr3 | 31.95 | 58.35 | 12.214 | 12.286 | 12.246 | 25.538 | 0.0891 | 0.4698 |
| Sr3BiCl3 | 34.117 | 59.213 | 11.655 | 11.655 | 13.11 | 25.635 | 0.0998 | 0.4554 |
Thermodynamic and acoustic properties derived from elastic data further reinforce these observations. The Debye temperature (θD) increases from 146.491 K (I) to 206.581 K (Cl), indicating higher lattice stiffness and phonon frequencies in the chloride. The average sound velocity (vm) follows the same trend, rising from 1736.338 m s−1 to 2308.933 m s−1, as do both longitudinal (vl) and transverse (vt) velocities. Notably, Sr3BiCl3 has the highest vl = 3590.75 m s−1, suggesting stronger phonon propagation and possibly better thermal conductivity. Additionally, the melting temperature exhibits a slight increase across the series, from 909.575 K (I) to 924.092 K (Cl), reinforcing the thermal robustness of the lighter halides.
In conclusion, the Sr3BiX3 compounds exhibit mechanical stability and ductility, along with mild elastic anisotropy. The mechanical performance improves steadily from iodide to chloride, with Sr3BiCl3 exhibiting the highest stiffness, hardness, and thermal stability. These results establish the potency of Sr3BiCl3 for applications demanding high mechanical and thermal performance, while Sr3BiI3 may offer advantages in flexible device environments due to its softer nature.
Lattice constants a = b = c and the calculated unit cell volume show strong positive correlations (r ≈ 1) with the static dielectric constant, ε(0), and refractive index η(0). This trend reflects the fact that as the unit cell expands (e.g., from Cl− to I−), the material becomes more polarizable, resulting in a higher optical permittivity. Such a relationship is consistent with classical dielectric theory, where increased atomic displacement freedom enhances the dielectric response.68 Negative correlations are observed between the structural/optical parameters volume, ε(0), η(0), and mechanical characteristics, including C11, bulk (B), shear (G), and Young's modulus (Y). This suggests that larger, softer lattices are mechanically weaker. This anti-correlation can be attributed to weaker interatomic forces in larger lattice frameworks, which reduce resistance to deformation. The band gap Eg shows a negative correlation with ε(0) and volume, and a positive correlation with stiffness indicators such as C11, B, and G. This indicates that mechanically stiffer and structurally denser lattices tend to have wider band gaps. Physically, this can be interpreted as reduced orbital overlap and increased ionicity in more compact structures, which typically leads to a raised separation between the VB and CB. As expected, the elastic constants and derived moduli (C11, B, G, Y) show strong mutual positive correlations (r > 0.95), consistent with their interdependent definitions. These high correlations validate the consistency of the mechanical data. Poisson's ratio exhibits weak to moderate negative correlations with Eg and stiffness parameters, suggesting that more incompressible materials (lower ν) are often mechanically stronger and possess wider band gaps. This correlation matrix provides a concise and interpretable overview of the interconnections between various physical domains, lattice geometry, dielectric response, mechanical strength, and electronic band structure in halide perovskites, as summarized in Table 4. Such insights are not only useful for understanding fundamental material behavior but also critical for guiding machine learning models in data-driven materials discovery.
| Property pair | Correlation coefficient (r) | Interpretation |
|---|---|---|
| Volume vs. ε(0) | 0.977 | Larger volume → higher dielectric constant |
| Volume vs. band gap (Eg) | −0.975 | Larger volume → lower Eg |
| ε(0) vs. refractive index η(0) | 0.989 | Strong optical interdependence |
| ε(0) vs. C11 | −0.993 | More polarizable → mechanically softer |
| ε(0) vs. Eg | −1.000 | Higher ε(0) → smaller band gap |
| Band gap (Eg) vs. Young's modulus Y | 1.000 | Stiffer material → higher Eg |
| Band gap (Eg) vs. C11, G, B | ∼0.99–1.00 | Mechanical stiffness is positively related to Eg |
| G vs. Y | 1.000 | Expected: both are derived from elastic constants |
| Poisson's ratio vs. band gap | −0.915 | More ductile → smaller Eg |
| C 11 vs. B | 1.000 | Strong mechanical consistency |
The Actual vs. Predicted Bandgap curve would show the relationship between the observed and predicted bandgap values for each material (Fig. 12). The plot displays the data points representing each material, where the blue solid line corresponds to the actual experimental bandgap values. The red dashed line represents the predicted bandgap values from the machine learning model. The predicted bandgap values are close to the actual experimental values, indicating that the Random Forest model can approximate the bandgap with reasonable accuracy, despite the small dataset size.69 The Sr3BiI3 material has an actual bandgap of 1.324 eV, while the model predicts a bandgap of 1.432 eV, resulting in a slight deviation of approximately 0.108 eV. Sr3BiBr3 has an actual bandgap of 1.512 eV, and the expected value was 1.545 eV, showing a slight overestimation with a deviation of 0.033 eV. Sr3BiCl3 has an actual bandgap of 1.731 eV, and the model predicted 1.712 eV, with a minor deviation of 0.019 eV, as summarized in Table 5.
| Material | Actual Eg (eV) | Predicted Eg (eV) |
|---|---|---|
| Sr3BiI3 | 1.324 | 1.432 |
| Sr3BiBr3 | 1.512 | 1.545 |
| Sr3BiCl3 | 1.731 | 1.712 |
Given that the predicted and actual values are close, the curve would likely show that most points are situated near the line of perfect agreement, signifying a good connection between the predicted and actual bandgap values. Though the dataset consists of only three data points, the model successfully captures the trends in bandgap prediction. The small dataset limits the model's generalizability, but the Random Forest Regressor was still able to make reasonable predictions. The performance would likely improve with a larger and more diverse dataset that includes a broader range of materials and properties. While the Random Forest model does not provide direct insights into the exact features that most influence the bandgap prediction, we can infer that lattice parameters (such as a, b, and c) and elastic constants play essential roles in determining the electronic structure of the compound, which is linked to the bandgap. This study demonstrates that machine learning, specifically Random Forest regression, can be used to predict the bandgap of materials with reasonable accuracy. The results suggest that, even with a small dataset, machine learning models can be useful for quickly estimating key material properties. However, larger datasets would further enhance the robustness and reliability of such predictions. Future studies could explore more complex models or datasets with a broader range of materials to achieve a more comprehensive analysis.
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry and the Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique 2026 |