Open Access Article
Benjamin R. Nelson
ab,
Vincent Scholiers
ac,
Audrey H. Sakamotoa,
John F. Rynkd,
Paula A. Prandaa,
Filip E. Du Prez
c,
Kristi S. Anseth
abd and
Christopher N. Bowman
*ad
aDepartment of Chemical and Biological Engineering, University of Colorado Boulder, USA. E-mail: christopher.bowman@colorado.edu
bBioFrontiers Institute, University of Colorado Boulder, USA
cPolymer Chemistry Research group, Centre of Macromolecular Chemistry (CMaC) and Laboratory of Organic Synthesis, Department of Organic and Macromolecular Chemistry, Faculty of Sciences, Ghent University, Belgium
dMaterials Science & Engineering Program, University of Colorado Boulder, USA
First published on 1st June 2026
Display technologies require optical adhesives that simultaneously provide high optical clarity, refractive index control, low birefringence and adhesive strength. However, many commercial adhesive systems rely on petroleum-derived acrylates and isocyanate-based urethanes. Herein, a fully biobased optical adhesive is reported that exploits the initiator-free photopolymerization of dithiolanes. Furthermore, hydrogen bond strength is modulated within the prepared adhesives by changing the chemistry with which the dithiolane is conjugated to a macromolecular core, allowing manipulation of properties including glass transition temperature, adhesion, refractive index, and other optical properties. Throughout these variations, all materials maintain high optical performance, exhibiting visible light transmittance above 98% and haze below 0.7%, coupled with low optical dispersion. These results demonstrate that dithiolanes are readily applied as initiator-free crosslinkers for the formulation of fully biobased optical adhesives.
The desire to move away from petroleum-based sources has accelerated interest in biobased polymers for high-performance applications.4–7 Among renewable carbon sources, dimers derived from fatty acids are increasingly used, especially in the production of adhesives.8–12 Commercially available dimer derivatives, such as Priamine and Pripol, provide long hydrophobic aliphatic backbones with low viscosities and glass transition temperatures, allowing for inherent flexibility. When coupled with photopolymerizable moieties, these cores are advantageous building blocks for the creation of optical adhesive formulations.13
1,2-Dithiolanes are an intriguing class of cyclic five-membered disulfide-containing rings that have recently attracted renewed attention and are often derived from naturally occurring resources. Moreover, these functional groups combine several features that make them attractive building blocks for the development of biobased optical materials. For instance, the inherent ring strain of the cyclic disulfide renders them more reactive than their linear counterparts.14 Since their absorption spectra is red shifted into the visible region, 1,2-dithiolanes undergo photopolymerization without the need for exogenous (and often colored) photoinitiators.15,16 Furthermore, the ring-opening polymerization of 1,2-dithiolanes yields dynamically active (linear) disulfides, which contribute to low birefringence, in part because of reduced shrinkage effects and dynamic bond relaxation, especially when compared to conventional (photo)polymerizations such as (meth)acrylates. Finally, the high sulfur content directly incorporates polarizable sulfur atoms, which contribute to an increased refractive index and enable improved refractive index matching with the substrates to be adhered.17 Because of these advantages, dithiolanes have found widespread adoption for the creation of dynamic materials.18–20
Despite these advantages, the exploration of dithiolanes as adhesives has been relatively limited. For example, some dithiolane derivatives (e.g., lipoic acid) had been used to create pressure sensitive,21–23 structural,24,25 and surgical adhesives; however, many of these reported adhesives are simple linear polymers driven by evaporative or thermal polymerizations.26 More recent formulations have taken advantage of pendant dithiolanes functionalities to enable on-demand photocuring.20,27,28 Since optical adhesives require transmittance above 95%,29 both the dithiolane concentration and conversion must be managed to allow suitable transmittance, refractive index, and crosslinking density. Balancing effective crosslinking with effective optical performance is essential to realizing the successful development of a fully biobased adhesive system. Additionally, materials applied in optical elements have strict standards regarding yellowing, with photoinitiator fragments often being the source of post-polymerization colored products.30 When coupled with suitable core structures (small molecules with limited crystallinity), no solvent is needed during application, resulting in resins capable of complete incorporation with no extractables at full conversion.
While many dithiolane adhesives have relied on coordination bonding,25,26 supramolecular assembly,31 or branching,32 few have investigated the role of hydrogen bonding. In other materials, amide functionalities have primarily been used to increase hydrogen bonding in materials as a strategy to increase Tg and crystallinity.33 However, urethane linkages remain the dominant strategy for increasing hydrogen bonding in materials.34,35 While the use of urethanes in dithiolane adhesives has only recently been explored,27,36 these studies involved the use of isocyanates to produce urethane bonds. Recently, isocyanate-free synthesis of urethane linkages has emerged as an alternative strategy for incorporating enhanced hydrogen bonding into adhesives without the need for phosgene, as is needed in the classical synthesis of isocyanates.37 This strategy has previously been coupled with bisfunctional amines for the biobased synthesis of isocyanate-free polyurethanes.38 Utilizing a cyclic carbonate, a β-hydroxyurethane can be produce through the reaction with an amine without the need for an isocyanate. For simplicity, this β-hydroxyurethane linkage is referred to as a urethane throughout. Taken together, using esters, urethanes, and amides as coupling chemistries results in a tunable library of hydrogen bonding in adhesives as a method to modulate material properties.
Recently, hydrogen bonding has been increasingly studied in adhesive systems both as an energy dissipation mechanism39 and as a surface adhesion promoter.40 These reversible interactions enhance surface contact through specific intermolecular attractions while also acting as sacrificial bonds that break and reform during deformation, increasing energy dissipation and therefore increasing toughness, especially when combined with other dynamic chemistries.39 As a result, hydrogen bonding has been applied to traditional structural adhesives,41 pressure sensitive adhesives,42 surgical adhesives,43 and optical adhesives.44 Additionally, hydrogen bonding has seen increased utilization in natural systems that seek to replace petroleum-derived adhesives.45 Combined with the photopolymerizability of dithiolanes, tunable hydrogen bonding offers a route to adhesive systems with enhanced bonding and tunable mechanical properties in biobased optical adhesives.
Herein, fully biobased 1,2-dithiolane-derived photocurable crosslinkers are synthesized by functionalizing Priamine and Pripol cores with lipoic acid via ester, amide, and urethane linkages, enabling controlled degrees of hydrogen bonding, all from biobased precursors. Because of the intrinsic ring-strain, these 1,2-dithiolane-based crosslinkers undergo initiator-free photolytic ring-opening polymerization upon UV irradiation over relatively short timescales. The resulting optical adhesives are tunable and exhibit low optical dispersion and high clarity. Their mechanical, adhesive, and optical properties were evaluated and correlated to the extent of hydrogen bonding present in the system. This strategy represents an advancement in the development of sustainable, non-petroleum-derived optical adhesives with excellent clarity and low dispersion. This work establishes a structure–property relationship between hydrogen bond strength and multiple material, adhesive, and optical properties in fully biobased dithiolane crosslinked optical adhesives as a means for showing their overall feasibility in these applications.
:
50 mixture of ester- and amide-linked monomers that was photopolymerized into a polymer network (hereafter referred to as mixture) was also investigated as an intermediate hydrogen bonding case, further demonstrating the hydrogen bond strength modulation.
Because of the intrinsic absorption of the dithiolane ring at relevant wavelengths (i.e., 365 nm) (Fig. S5), the network precursors are capable of undergoing direct photolytic ring-opening polymerization (Fig. 1c). Films were prepared through direct photopolymerization, and the hydrogen bond strength was directly assessed via Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) spectroscopy. Specifically, FTIR of crosslinked samples was used to track the centroid of the C
O stretch over a wide temperature interval, ranging from 20 to 170 °C with +10 °C intervals (Fig. S6). The net displacement of this centroid over the course of the heating program was used as a proxy for hydrogen bond strength, and the slope of this displacement as a function of temperature was used as a quantitative measure of hydrogen bond strength throughout, as has been previously reported (Fig. 1d).48 The trends observed here confirm the anticipated order of hydrogen bond strength in the materials: ester < mixture < urethane < amide.
To investigate curing behavior, isothermal photorheology was performed by applying a constant small-amplitude oscillatory shear (T = 25 °C, γ = 1%, ω = 1 rad s−1) over a defined time period. For this characterization, the sample was first allowed to equilibrate in the darkness for 30 s after which polymerization was initiated by UV irradiation (50 mW cm−2 at 365 nm) while simultaneously monitoring and the evolution of the shear storage (G′) and loss (G″) moduli (Fig. 2a). All formulations polymerized on relatively short timescales, reaching plateau moduli within 300 s. Taking this reaction rate into account, and to minimize effects of light attenuation, 50 µm adhesive films were produced by exposure to 50 mW cm−2 of 365 nm light for 2.5 min per side for all subsequent films. Notably, the urethane sample exhibited the slowest polymerization rate and achieved a final plateau modulus lower than the other resins. This behavior might potentially be attributed to the presence of free hydroxyls, resulting from the cyclic carbonate ring-opening. Free hydroxyl functionalities have previously been reported to affect dithiolane polymerization, leading to overall shorter kinetic chains despite similar conversion rates.49,50 Therefore, it is postulated that the urethane sample has shorter dithiolane kinetic chains than the other three samples, leading to a lower crosslinking density and potentially explaining both the slower polymerization and lower storage modulus in the urethane sample.
The influence of variable hydrogen bond strength was further evaluated via dynamic mechanical analysis (DMA). In the glassy regime, the storage modulus was found to increase systematically with hydrogen bonding, with the ester sample having the lowest modulus and progressively higher values observed across the series (Fig. 2b). This trend was not observed in the rubbery regime, as the hydrogen bonds do not contribute to effective crosslinks in the rubbery modulus at this time scale. Rather, the rubbery storage modulus is virtually the same across the tested samples, except for the urethane, which had a decreased crosslink density. Furthermore, hydrogen bond strength was also found to have a strong effect on the glass transition (Tg) of the samples. As expected, increasing the strength of the hydrogen bonds leads to a systematic increase in the Tg of the samples (Fig. 2c).51 In addition, the breadth of the glass transitions generally increases with additional hydrogen bonding (Fig. 2d). However, the urethane sample exhibited an unusually narrow Tg for its location in the hydrogen bonding series. This behavior may result from the same disruption of dithiolane polymerization (shorter kinetic chain lengths) that is speculated to contribute to the decreased rubbery modulus; shorter kinetic chains likely lead to a more homogenous network and therefore a narrower glass transition. These trends in Tg as measured by DMA are recapitulated in differential scanning calorimetry (DSC), again with the same anomaly in the breadth of the urethane Tg (Fig. S7).
As solvent resistance is an important characteristic of optical adhesives, the swelling ratio in mulitple solvents (toluene, acetone, methanol, and water) was tested for each sample (Fig. S8). Unsurprisingly, the swelling ratio trended with hydrogen bond strength, with the amide adhesive having the lowest swelling ratios, being as low as 1.2 in water (Fig. S8). In addition, limited extractables are key to adhesive performance. Samples tested via extraction in acetone demonstrated greater than 95% gel fraction (less than 5% extractable) across all formulations (Fig. S9). Additionally, flexibility is key for optical adhesives as they are often used to laminate thin films in flexbile electronics. These adhesives are highly flexible, as demonstrated through twisting a 50 µm thick amide sample between tweezers (Fig. S10). Lastly, while long term stability of materials used as adhesives is important for broad commercial adoption, an evaluation of long term aging is beyond the scope of this work. Generally, dithiolane-crosslinked materials exhibit good stability below temperatures of 120 °C, often well above the range of operating temperatures for optical materials outside of specialty applications.52
Next, the adhesive properties of the cured materials were evaluated by lap shear testing using both glass and poly(ethylene terephthalate) as substrates, with three replicate samples tested per condition (Fig. 3a). While peel is an important failure mode for optical adhesives, lap shear was chosen as an adhesion metric to correlate with hydrogen bond strength, given that these materials are photocured structural adhesives rather than pressure sensitive adhesives. Transparent substrates were chosen to enable photocuring of the adhesives and due to their relevance in optical applications. Notably, all measurements were taken without applying any adhesion promoters on the substrate surface. While this approach likely leads to a lower ultimate tensile strength, it enables a direct comparison of the effects of the hydrogen bond strength and their interactions with the substrate surface on adhesion. For glass substrates, no clear trend in either the lap shear strength or the strain at break (Fig. 3b and Fig. S10) was observed. Although intermediate-strength hydrogen bond systems (such as the mixture and urethane) exhibited the highest lap shear strength and strain at break, all samples had large errors associated with the measurements. This error is likely due to interfacial adhesive failures with the substrates, which are more stochastic than cohesive failures, especially in the absence of adhesion promoters.
In contrast, for plasma treated PET or PMMA substrates, both lap shear strength and strain at break generally increased with hydrogen bonding strength and had significantly lower variability (Fig. 3c, d and Fig. S11, S12). One potential explanation is the difference in the surface chemistry and roughness. Contact angle measurements with water reveal increased hydrophobicity in both the PMMA and the plasma treated PET as compared to glass (66° on PMMA vs. 59° on PET vs. 36° on glass, Fig. S14), indicating notable differences in surface chemistry and wettability. Compared to the relatively smooth glass microscope slides, the polymeric substrates may facilitate additional mechanical interlocking at the interface. Both factors contribute to PMMA and PET samples having more cohesive failure modes, while the glass had more adhesive failure modes (Fig. S15). While these were the predominant modes observed through the lap shear stress–strain curves and sample examination, there is not conclusive evidence to determine that these failure modes are the only ones occurring for all cases.
As previously stated, optical adhesives must meet stringent performance criteria. For instance, high transmittance and low dispersion (high Abbe number) are critical for optically transparent adhesives.1 All formulations had a high optical clarity, as demonstrated in a transmittance photograph of the amide sample between two glass substrates (Fig. 4a). UV-vis spectroscopy, performed on all samples between glass slides after curing, confirmed >98% transmittance across the visible portion of the spectrum for all samples (Fig. 4b), comparable to other optical materials based on sulfur chemistry.53 Additionally, the adhesives exhibited minimal haze, as measured according to the ASTM D1003 standard: all samples measured below 0.3% haze, except for the mixture which had 0.7% haze (Fig. S16). Since the one sample that exhibited the higher haze is a mixture of two hydrogen bonding strengths, this increase in haze is potentially attributed to a small extent of micro-phase separation.
Refractive index (RI) modulation is another critical property for optical adhesives, as the adhesive must have a relatively close match in refractive index with the substrate to minimize optical aberrations. The RI was measured at 22 °C using a prism coupler refractometer and monochromatic light sources at three wavelengths (λ): 404.7 nm, 524.7 nm and 636.6 nm. Refractometry measures the angular position of total internal reflection. Utilizing PET as the substrate enhanced the substrate and film refractive index difference, minimizing any contributions of the substrate effect. The obtained RI were then fitted to the Cauchy equation (Fig. 4c) and used to interpolate the refractive index at the Fraunhofer D line (nD, λ = 589.3 nm) for cross-comparison of all formulations. Notably, the refractive index was found to systematically increase with hydrogen bond strength (Fig. 4d). This difference is postulated to result from an increased density of the materials as expected from the Lorenz-Lorentz theorem, which correlates the density and polarizability of a material to its refractive index.54–56 However, no clear trend was observed in the Abbe number (Vd), a measure of optical dispersion across wavelengths, which often decreases with increasing refractive index (Fig. S17). Regardless, Vd was comparatively high (representing low optical dispersion) for each of these materials.
Finally, birefringence was evaluated. This optical phenomenon originates from anisotropic effects in the molecular polarizability throughout the material and was quantified by taking the difference in refractive index for light polarized in two orthogonal directions. As many optical applications rely on varied polarizations, minimizing birefringence is of high priority, especially in comparison to commercial urethane-acrylate adhesives where anisotropic shrinkage often leads to stress-laden polymer films with increased birefringence.57 To quantify this effect, the RI was quantified in both transverse electric (TE) and transverse magnetic (TM) polarization modes, with the difference between these values being the birefringence. At the measurement wavelength of 636.6 nm, increased hydrogen bonding strength results in lower birefringence (Fig. 4e). We speculate that increased hydrogen bond strength increases dynamic exchange, enabling further rearrangement after polymerization. Notably, these are all low birefringent materials, with the highest birefringence of 0.002 and the lowest at 0.00005 (below the error of the instrument) compared to many common plastics, such as polycarbonate (0.015), polystyrene (0.019), and even performance acrylates (0.002).58 This property is likely due to the ring-opening polymerization of the dithiolanes, which minimizes shrinkage stress during the polymerization, as well as the delayed gelation and disulfide exchange from the polymerization.
Raw data are available from the authors upon reasonable request.
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2026 |