Open Access Article
Kyle G. Pearce
,
Han-Ying Liu,
Claire L. McMullin
* and
Michael S. Hill
*
Department of Chemistry, University of Bath, Claverton Down, Bath, BA2 7AY, UK. E-mail: cm2025@bath.ac.uk; msh27@bath.ac.uk
First published on 16th June 2026
The strontium alumanyl, [(BDI)SrAl(SiNDipp)], has been prepared from [(BDI)Sr(BPh4)] and [(SiNDipp)AlK]2. Like its previously described calcium analogue, structural and computational analyses indicate that the Sr–Al interaction is only marginally involved in the engagement of the Sr cation and alumanyl anion. Unlike its lighter equivalent, however, [(BDI)SrAl(SiNDipp)] does not react with THF, the presence of which only appears to enhance its presumed dismutation and reaction with the toluene solvent at 100 °C to provide a strontium bis-hydrido(meta-tolyl)aluminate.
Although examples are limited to the lighter metals of the series, studies of alkaline earth (Ae) alumanyls suggest that similar variations in chemistry may prevail down group 2. Both the unique beryllium species, [(xanthNON)AlBeCp],37 and a handful of derivatives in which a magnesium centre is further coordinated by β-diketiminate anions comprise terminal Ae–Al interactions.26,28,32,38 In contrast, the calcium complex, [(BDI)CaAl(SiNDipp)] (3Ca, Scheme 1; BDI = HC{(Me)CNDipp}2), exhibited an Al–Ca separation [3.1664(4) Å] that is 6.6% longer than the sum of the covalent radii of the constituent metals and a calcium coordination sphere augmented by η6-engagement with a Dipp substituent of the Al-coordinated diamide ligand (Ca–C range: 2.9709(17)–3.2215(15) Å).28 Computational (QTAIM) assessment of the Al–Ae interactions of 3Ca and its magnesium analogue (3Mg) identified bond critical points (BCPs) with positive Laplacians (3Mg +0.033; 3Ca +0.020 ea0−5) characteristic of interactions that are largely electrostatic in origin. Although the interaction between the calcium centre and the Dipp π-system was judged to be largely non-covalent and capable of only weakly stabilising the structure, initial studies also highlighted significantly divergent reactivity for 3Ca. For example, whereas 3Mg was stable in ether solvents, addition of THF to 3Ca resulted in the immediate generation of a charge separated species, [(BDI)Ca(THF)3]+[(SiNDipp)Al{O(CH2)4}]−, comprising an aluminate product of C–O oxidative addition to the Al(I) centre of the [(SiNDipp)Al]− anion (Scheme 1).28
Beyond such differences, the isolation of both 3Mg and 3Ca highlights the long-standing utility of the BDI anion for exploration of the coordination chemistry of the lighter alkaline earth elements.39–43 Detailed studies of calcium derivatives, however, have long been hindered by a propensity toward irreversible Schlenk-type solution redistribution to homoleptic species, behaviour that is exacerbated for increasingly labile heteroleptic compounds of the heaviest members of the series, Sr and Ba.43,44 While this reactivity may be suppressed by more sterically demanding variants of the β-diketiminate structure,45–47 the introduction of bulkier N-aryl substituents would also introduce a significant perturbation to an otherwise isoleptic series of compounds and undermine coherent comparison to 3Mg and 3Ca. It is notable, therefore, that the synthesis of both 3Mg and 3Ca utilised the tetraphenylborate starting materials, [(BDI)Ae(BPh4)] (4Mg Ae = Mg; 4Ca Ae = Ca), in metathesis reactions with [(SiNDipp)AlK]2. While not a central consideration at the time of its report,28 the monomeric species 4Ca proved notably stable to Schlenk-type redistribution, a durability that may be plausibly ascribed to the twofold Ca⋯μ-η6-(Ph)2BPh2 arene interactions with the [BPh4]− anion that further encapsulate the calcium centre. Similar π-engagement is slowly emerging as a general feature of heavier alkaline earth behaviour.48–55 In an extension of this chemistry, therefore, we report here that an alumanyl derivative of strontium is accessible via an analogous tetraphenylborate derivative, [(BDI)Sr(BPh4)] (4Sr), without any additional enhancement of the steric demands of the supporting BDI ligand.
Compound 4Sr was synthesised in high yield (80%) in an analogous fashion to its lighter metal congeners by the addition of [HNEt3][BPh4] to a toluene solution of [(BDI)SrN(SiMe3)2] (Scheme 2) and was fully characterised by 1H, 13C and 11B (δ11B = −4.8 ppm) NMR spectroscopy in d8-toluene and single crystal X-ray diffraction.56 4Sr was notably stable toward its dismutation to [(BDI)2Sr] in solution at ambient temperature and the results of the solid-state analysis confirmed its constitution as a mononuclear strontium species in which the coordination sphere of the alkaline earth centre is stabilised by a combination of the BDI chelate and twofold Sr⋯μ–η6-(Ph)2BPh2 arene interactions with the borate anion (Fig. S21).
Addition of a half molar equivalent of 2K to 4Sr in toluene generated an orange solution and an off-white precipitate, presumed to be KBPh4, filtration and crystallisation of which provided a moderate yield of 3Sr (50%) as amber coloured single crystals suitable for X-ray analysis (Scheme 2). Like its calcium alumanyl analogue (3Ca), the structure of 3Sr displays an aluminium-to-alkaline earth separation [Sr1–Al1 3.2953(4) Å] that is significantly longer than the sum of the covalent radii of the metal centres [3.16 Å] (Fig. 2). In a similar manner to that observed in 3Ca, the engagement of the alumanyl anion with Sr1 is augmented by an η6-interaction of the C36–C41-containing Dipp substituent of the aluminium-coordinated (SiNDipp) ligand (Sr⋯Ccent 2.915 Å). The resultant asymmetry in the relative disposition of the {(SiNDipp)Al} and {(BDI)Sr} moieties is, thus, reflected by the significant discrepancy in the N3–Al1–Sr1 [96.96(3)°] and N4–Al1–Sr1 [152.22(4)°] angles subtended at the alumanyl centre.
DFT electronic structure calculations of 3Sr (BP86/BS2, see the SI for full methodology details) revealed similarities to 3Ca, specifically in the QTAIM plot where a bond path was identified between Sr and Al (Fig. 3a), with a minute reduction in electron density at the bond critical point (BCP); ρ(r) = 0.019 (3Sr), 0.020 (3Ca) and ∇2ρ(r) = +0.019 (3Sr), +0.020 (3Ca). These data suggest that the Sr–Al interaction is weakly ionic in nature, confirmed by a small positive Laplacian (∇2ρ(r)) value, though a slight covalency could be interpreted from the negative H(r) value. A bond path was also identified between Sr and the para carbon of a Dipp substituent of the (SiNDipp) ligand framework supporting the alumanyl. Similar attributes were ascribed to the analogous BCP identified in 3Ca, again indicating that the Ae–Ca bond paths are effectively identical.
Natural Bond Orbital (NBO) analysis of 3Sr gives a Wiberg bond index of 0.454 between the Al and Sr atoms, with NPA charges of qSr = +1.715 and qAl = +0.732. Although there were no notable bonding NBOs between Al and Sr, on initial inspection the HOMO (Fig. 3b) mimics a σ-bond along the Al and Sr vector. Scrutiny of the construction of this canonical MO clarifies that the largest component is non-bonding from the Al lone pair (67.1%; LP being a combination of AO 3s 76.7% and 3px 19.4%) with the only other prominent component from a (SiNDipp) nitrogen lone pair (10.8%). Notably, no NBO associated with Sr significantly contributes to the HOMO. A second order perturbation energy (ΔE(2)) of 29.1 kcal mol−1 was identified with donation from the same Al lone pair to the lone vacancy (LV) of Sr. This latter NBO contains 92.5% of the 5s AO, as well as a 7.2% contribution from d-orbitals, the largest (4.5%) from the 4dx2−y2 Sr AO.
Although the 1H NMR spectrum of 3Sr at room temperature in d8-toluene solution presented no indication of asymmetry in the alumanyl-to-strontium interaction, analysis at both mildly elevated and reduced temperatures provided data consistent with those of a fluctional system. This was most readily apparent from the inspection of the iso-propyl methine signals arising from the (BDI) and (SiNDipp) ligands. Consistent with time averaged C2v symmetry, at 298 K the respective environments were observed as two broadened signals at δ 3.88 and 2.85 ppm, each resonating with 4H intensity by relative integration. While both signals appeared as well resolved binomial heptets at temperatures above 323 K, below 283 K they were observed to broaden and ultimately resolve as eight well discriminated signals in the range δ 2.5–4.5 ppm and of the same 1H intensity by relative integration (Fig. S15). Although no precise coalescence temperature could be confidently identified, we suggest that these observations indicate the persistence of a solution structure analogous to that identified in the solid state, but which is also free to pivot at the aluminium centre allowing the (SiNDipp) aryl substituents to interact alternately with the strontium centre.
Mindful of the reactivity of 3Ca summarised in Scheme 1, a slight stoichiometric excess of THF was added to a toluene solution of 3Sr. In contrast to the notably immediate reaction of 3Ca, analysis by 1H NMR spectroscopy provided no evidence of reaction at room temperature beyond an increase in the resolution of the signals assigned to 3Sr. Repetition of the experiment with heating at 100 °C for 16 hours, however, resulted in the complete consumption of 3Sr through the generation of the known homoleptic derivative, [(BDI)2Sr],40 which was identified alongside a predominant new species, 5. It was subsequently observed that similar spectra were also obtained by heating a toluene solution of 3Sr under identical thermal conditions. Although a pure bulk sample of 5 could not be obtained, its constitution was established by a further X-ray diffraction analysis performed by mechanical separation of a single crystal from the mixture of products isolated after storage of the reaction solution at −30 °C. The resultant structure (Fig. 4) identified 5 as a homoleptic strontium bis-hydrido(m-tolyl)aluminate arising from Al-centred activation of a meta-C–H bond of the toluene solvent and, consistent with the concurrent formation of [(BDI)2Sr], dismutation from the initial heteroleptic constitution of the β-diketiminato reagent 3Sr. The centrosymmetric structure of 5 features two aluminate anions that provide the entirety of the strontium coordination environment, interacting through a twofold combination of Al–μ-H–Sr interactions and η6-π-arene engagement (Sr⋯Ccent 2.702 Å) with a single Dipp substituent of each (SiNDipp) ligand. We note that a similar stereoelectronic preference for meta-selective C–H activation of toluene and various other monoalkylated benzenes has been previously described for both 1 and Yamashita's potassium dialkylalumanyl, [(CH2(Me3Si)2C)2AlK].57,58
It has neither proved possible to further deconvolute the processes leading to compound 5 nor to identify whether Schlenk-type redistribution occurs prior to or subsequent to the activation of the solvent. The absence of definitive evidence for the solution speciation responsible for the formation of 5, therefore, dissuades us from further theoretical analysis. The meta-specificity of the toluene activation, however, is evocative of several earlier studies of concerted SNAr Al(I)-to-arene addition implicating s-block-assisted assembly of a Meisenheimer-type transition state that evolves by C-to-Al hydride migration.35,57–59
Despite the apparent similarity of its electronic structure to its calcium analogue, 3Sr evidently presents significantly divergent reactivity toward THF. The thermal and configurational stability displayed by 3Sr in toluene, however, leads us to suggest that the effect, if any, of ether solvent is merely facilitating the solution redistribution of the heteroleptic strontium β-diketiminate rather than acting as a direct participant in any alumanyl-centred reaction. Based on these observations, therefore, we tentatively hypothesise that the generation of 5 results from a combination of the greater lability of Sr toward Schlenk-type redistribution and an enhanced ability of the [(SiNDipp)Al]− moiety to react as a ‘free’ alumanyl anion when combined with strontium.60 We are continuing to explore this and related reactivity.
CCDC 2548846 (4Sr), 2548847 (3Sr) and 2548848 (5) contain the supplementary crystallographic data for this paper.61a–c
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2026 |