Rohith Phaneendra
Bandaru†
a,
Asmita Dileep
Gaonkar†
b,
Kiran
Vankayala
*b and
Bharat Kumar
Tripuramallu
*a
aDr. LARA Centre for Energy Materials, Department of Chemistry, Vignan's Foundation for Science Technology and Research (Deemed to be University), Vadlamudi, Guntur-522 213, Andhra Pradesh, India. E-mail: aryanbharat@gmail.com; drbkt_sh@vignan.ac.in
bFunctional Materials for Electrochemistry and Solar Energy (FunMatES) group, Energy and Environmental Chemistry Lab, Department of Chemistry, Birla Institute of Technology and Science, Pilani, K K Birla Goa Campus, NH 17B Bypass Road, Zuarinagar, Goa 403726, India. E-mail: kiranv@goa.bits-pilani.ac.in; kiran2cu@gmail.com
First published on 24th February 2026
The study demonstrates the electrostatic driven self-assembly approach to obtain molecular hybrids (POM–POR) of anionic polyoxometalate (POM) and cationic porphyrin (POR). The single crystal structure of the hybrid ion-pair POM–POR has been elucidated. The study not only provides unique opportunities to study the crystal structure of the hybrid, but also deals with the heterogenization of a homogeneous POR catalyst to study oxidative coupling of benzylamine to N-benzylidenebenzylamine under visible-light irradiation with high selectivity and stability.
A variety of design strategies have been developed to integrate POR with POM with the aid of covalent/non-covalent interactions.12–15 One of the widely adopted approaches involves the tris-alkoxylation of POMs with PORs that yields discrete hybrid compounds and/or covalent organic frameworks (COFs).16 Conversely, POMs can be grafted onto metalloporphyrins or metalloporphyrins onto POMs, via pyridyl rings that establish direct covalent linkages.17 Suzuki and co-workers reported another approach to construct a polyoxotungstate (POW)–POR hybrid featuring a face-to-face stacked porphyrin dimer fastened by four lacunary POWs.18 An et al. recently reported a POM–POR hybrid via the encapsulation of POMs into POR-based porous cationic polymers.19 Ionic self-assembly manifested by electrostatic interactions between POM and POR charged moieties represents another attractive approach to obtain POM–POR hybrids.20 Although electrostatic interaction-driven assembly strategies are reported in the literature, very little crystallographic evidence has been reported for ion-pair POM–POR hybrids.15,21 It should be noted that these ion-pair hybrids are soluble in DMF and DMSO only, which poses a challenge in their crystallization process. Although a few crystallographically characterized POM–POR hybrids have been reported, the scarcity of structural information continues to impede a comprehensive understanding of their catalytic behaviour. The crystallization of these ion-pair hybrids having geometrically mismatched species, such as spherical POMs and planar POR derivatives, represents a unique supramolecular challenge to this end.
The present study discusses our approach in obtaining crystalline ion-pair hybrids via simple electrostatic interactions by rationally functionalizing POR and POM with suitable groups. The as-obtained hybrids were explored as visible light-active photocatalysts for the oxidative coupling of benzylamine (BzAM) to N-benzylidenebenzylamine (BzIM) with oxygen as the oxidant.
C and C–N stretching bands of the porphyrin in the 1600–1400 cm−1 region. The absence of peaks corresponding to the tetrabutylammonium ion in the POM–POR hybrid, typically observed in [Bu4N]2[Mo6O19], clearly indicates the formation of the hybrid (Fig. S4). Thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) reveals that the hybrid was thermally stable till 400 °C (Fig. S5). As evident from the FESEM images, the POM–POR hybrid possesses a one dimensional (1D) morphology (Fig. S6). The Raman spectra of POR, POM and the POM–POR hybrid are shown in Fig. S7. The spectra consist of characteristic Raman bands corresponding to POR and POM. Besides, the signatures of the POR and POM are present in the POM–POR hybrid, as expected. Notably, slight shifts in Raman bands corresponding to porphyrin are observed in the case of the POM–POR hybrid as compared to those of pristine porphyrin. This could be due to the presence of POM moieties in the proximity of porphyrin, which is in line with single crystal X-ray studies that will be discussed in the subsequent section. Further, the absorption properties of POM, POR and the POM–POR hybrid were studied using UV-vis diffuse reflectance spectroscopy (UV-vis DRS). The absorption spectrum of the POM–POR hybrid shown in Fig. S8A indicates that the hybrid exhibits enhanced visible absorption compared to pure POM. The impressive visible absorption due to the characteristic Soret (∼400 nm) and Q-bands (500–700 nm), as seen in the absorption spectra, makes them effective visible light harvesters. The optical bandgap (Eg) of the POM–POR hybrid determined from the Tauc plot is found to be 1.84 eV (Fig. S8B). All these measurements suggest the successful assembly of POR with POM via the simple electrostatic interactions.
(Fig. S10A). Both the porphyrin cation and the [Mo6O19]2− anion reside on inversion centres at the core of the porphyrin macrocycle and at the central oxygen of the POM, respectively. The structure consists of one tetracationic porphyrin and two hexamolybdate dianions, along with four lattice DMF molecules. The porphyrin macrocycle retains planarity, while the appended pyridinium rings exhibit significant torsion (∼134°) relative to the macrocyclic plane. Geometrical parameters of the POM, including Mo
O bond distances and O–Mo–O bond angles, are consistent with the literature values, affirming its structural integrity within the hybrid assembly.22,23 In the extended solid-state crystal lattice, a well-ordered layered architecture is observed, wherein cationic porphyrin macrocycles and anionic [Mo6O19]2− clusters alternate in a regular spatial pattern. The porphyrin units were sandwiched between [Mo6O19]2− units and vice versa along the crystallographic axis as shown in Fig. 2A. Another set of [Mo6O19]2− units, oriented differently, occupies the void spaces together with DMF molecules. Each porphyrin unit is surrounded by ten polyoxometalate anions, creating a tightly packed environment around the porphyrin moiety (Fig. 2B). The terminal oxygen atoms of [Mo6O19]2− strongly interact with the porphyrin plane through hydrogen bonding and π interactions. The C⋯O contacts in the range of 2.951–3.173 Å and O⋯H hydrogen bonds around 2.350–2.676 Å, within van der Waals radii, stabilize the lattice packing (Fig. 2C). The dense packing of porphyrin units within the POM matrix restricts access to the C
C bonds at the meso-positions of the porphyrin core (C16 and C7 atoms) by ROS, and thus expected to effectively prevent oxidative degradation and greatly enhance the photostability of the porphyrin moieties (Fig. 2D).
Hirshfeld surface analyses reveal that among all the non-covalent interactions experienced by the porphyrin macrocycle, 43.5% are dominated by C–H(POR)⋯O(POM) hydrogen bond contacts and 9.5% of C(POR)⋯O(POM) π contacts; both these interactions facilitate the tight crystal packing of the porphyrin within the POM matrix and effectively shield the meso positions of the porphyrin (Fig. S10B).
| Entry | Catalyst | Environment | Light | % sel. | % conv. | Yield (%) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | No catalyst | O2 | + | — | — | — |
| 2 | POM–POR | O2 | — | — | — | — |
| 3 | POM–POR | N2 | + | 20.2 | 10 | 2.02 |
| 4 | POM | O2 | + | 32.2 | 14.2 | 4.5 |
| 5 | POR | O2 | + | 100 | 91 | 91 |
| 6 | POM–POR | O2 | + | 100 | 100 | 100 |
The photostability of the POM–POR catalyst was examined by exposing the reaction mixture consisting of the POM–POR catalyst to light in the absence of BzAM. As shown Fig. S14, the absorption spectra before and after illumination show insignificant changes, suggesting the robustness of the POM–POR hybrid. Unlike pristine POR, the enhanced photostability of the POM–POR hybrid may be due to restricted access to meso-positions of porphyrin when it is interfaced with POM moieties as evident from the crystal structure. In other words, non-availability of meso-positions of porphyrin to ROS may be the reason for the observed photostability, in line with earlier reports.11 Notably, the present study demonstrated the impressive oxidative ability of the POM–POR hybrid using O2 as the oxidant as compared to an earlier study that reports a Ru–POM–POR hybrid catalyst for the photocatalytic oxidation of benzyl alcohols using Na2S2O8 as the oxidant with poor yield (∼10%).24 The robustness and repeatability of the POM–POR hybrid for the oxidative coupling of BzAM is further assessed by performing stability tests for repetitive cycles (Fig. 3B). After each run (30 min), the catalyst was recovered by centrifugation, washed with acetonitrile and dried before using it in subsequent runs. The results show that the changes in the activity of POM–POR are insignificant, suggesting the robustness of the catalyst (Fig. 3B). The catalyst recovered after 5 runs was subjected to physicochemical characterization using Raman spectroscopy, FTIR, XRD and FESEM. The data shown in Fig. S15 and S16 suggest that the POM–POR catalyst possesses excellent stability and recyclability. The robustness of the POM–POR catalyst is further validated using a hot filtration technique.25a The data shown in Fig. S17 rule out the leaching of the catalyst during photocatalytic oxidation. Additionally, the absorption spectrum of the reaction mixture collected after catalysis does not show characteristic features corresponding to POM or POR (Fig. S18A), further proving the intactness of POM and POR moieties in the POM–POR catalyst. Unlike the POM–POR hybrid, pristine POR lacking structural protection undergoes pronounced degradation as evident from the absorbance spectra as shown in Fig. S18B.
In order to understand the photocatalytic reaction pathway and to determine the type of reactive species responsible for BzAM oxidation, various experiments were conducted in the presence of different scavengers (Fig. 3C). The yield of BzIM decreases with the addition of triethanolamine (TEOA), a hole scavenger, suggesting that holes are involved in the reaction pathway. Further, a drastic decrease in the yield of BzIM is noted when the reaction is carried out in the presence of 1,4-diazabicyclo[2.2.2]octane (DABCO) and benzoquinone (BQ). These studies suggest that the reactive species such as 1O2 and O2˙− may be involved in driving the oxidation of BzAM as DABCO and BQ are known to act as corresponding scavengers. Notably, no change in the photocatalytic activity is observed when t-butanol was used as an ·OH radical probe, indicating that ·OH radicals are not involved in the reaction pathway (Fig. 3C). It should also be noted that the formation of hydrogen peroxide (H2O2) during the photocatalytic oxidation of BzAM is observed, as evident from the absorption spectra shown in Fig. S19. A clear peak around 438 nm appeared when the reaction mixture collected after 20 min of illumination is mixed with o-tolidine. Based on all these observations, the plausible mechanism for the oxidation of BzAM to BzIM is given in Fig. 3D. Upon visible-light irradiation, the POM–POR hybrid generates hole–electron pairs by photoexcitation. The photogenerated electrons reduce molecular O2 to form species like superoxide (O2˙−) and triplet O2 (3O2). It should be noted that the presence of heavy atoms (Mo in the present case) of POM facilitates the conversion of the triplet state (3O2) to the singlet state (1O2). Simultaneously, the holes oxidize benzylamine to benzylamine cation radicals. Subsequently, O2˙− will react with the benzylamine cation radical to form phenylmethanimine and H2O2. In addition, the 1O2 species also undergoes a reaction with benzylamine forming similar products. In the final step, the benzylamine molecule undergoes nucleophilic attack on the formed phenylmethanimine intermediate yielding the final product, BzIM. Furthermore, the energetics of the POM–POR hybrid determined from the Tauc plot and Mott–Schottky measurements (Fig. S20) suggest that the catalyst possesses the lowest unoccupied molecular orbital (LUMO) at a potential more negative as compared to the redox potential of O2/O2˙− (−0.33 V vs. NHE)25b and the highest occupied molecular orbital (HOMO) is in a favourable position with respect to the BzAM oxidation potential (0.76 V vs. NHE).26 Besides, the versatility of the POM–POR hybrid catalyst is further extended to study the oxidation of BzAM derivatives such as BzAM with electron-withdrawing and donating groups at the para position to the –CH2NH2 group under identical conditions (catalyst dosage, time of illumination, light source, and concentration of the substrate), as performed for the oxidation of unsubstituted BzAM. As noted from previous studies (Table S3), the oxidation of BzAM proceeds relatively faster when BzAM is connected to electron-donating groups (–CH3, –OCH3) as compared to that connected to electron-withdrawing groups (–Cl, –Br, –CF3) (Table S3, entry 1–5).27 Further, the oxidation of other amines such as 2-thiophenemethylamine is also carried out and the obtained results are included in Table S3 (entry 6). Thus, the study demonstrated a wide scope in exploring the POM–POR hybrid as a visible light-active photocatalyst for the oxidation of various amines to imines using O2 as the oxidant. The ionic assembly of the POM–POR hybrid can be strategically extended to polyoxometalates with different nuclearity clusters like Keggin, Dawson, Anderson, etc. and porphyrins with various peripheral functional groups including trans A2B2 porphyrins along with metalloporphyrins. Such versatility enables precise tuning of absorption properties of hybrid materials to meet specific catalytic transformations.
Supplementary information: methods & materials; detailed experimental procedures; 1H NMR spectra; FESEM, TGA UV-Vis DRS and Raman data of POM-POR; Hirshfeld analysis; post-catalysis characterization data; Tables S1–S3 etc. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d6cy00008h.
CCDC 2499082 contains the supplementary crystallographic data for this paper.28
Footnote |
| † Both authors contributed equally. |
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2026 |