Open Access Article
Eito Moriya
and
Junichiro Yamaguchi
*
Department of Applied Chemistry, Waseda University, 513 Wasedatsurumakicho, Shinjuku, Tokyo 162-0041, Japan. E-mail: junyamaguchi@waseda.jp
First published on 16th June 2026
Functional group position plays a decisive role in molecular properties and function, with even subtle positional changes leading to pronounced differences in biological activity, material performance, and reactivity. Access to positional isomers is therefore central to drug discovery and materials chemistry, yet their synthesis has traditionally required independent and often inefficient synthetic routes. Recent advances have given rise to functional group translocation reactions, which enable the direct relocation of functional groups within a molecular framework without altering the underlying scaffold. In this review, we use the term functional group translocation in a narrow sense to describe transformations in which only the bonding position of a functional group changes while the molecular framework and functional group identity remain intact. Such processes offer a concise molecular editing strategy that enables direct access to positional isomers from a common precursor. Enabled by developments in transition metal catalysis and photoredox chemistry, functional group translocation has rapidly progressed beyond classical stoichiometric and substrate-specific processes. This review defines functional group translocation, distinguishes it from traditional rearrangement reactions and broader isomerization processes, and summarizes recent advances across aromatic and aliphatic systems. By organizing the field according to molecular scaffold, functional group identity, and migration distance, this review highlights current capabilities, remaining challenges, and future opportunities in synthesis, drug discovery, and materials chemistry.
Even small positional changes can produce dramatic differences in biological activity (Fig. 1A). In biphenyl-based antimicrobial peptide mimetics, compounds bearing an oxygen substituent at the C1 and C2’ positions exhibit a fourfold increase in activity against Acinetobacter baumannii (MIC = 4 µg mL−1).3 In contrast, the structural isomer substituted at the C2 and C4’ positions shows a 4–8-fold enhancement in potency against the Gram-negative pathogens Pseudomonas aeruginosa and Escherichia coli (MIC = 2 µg mL−1). Thus, positional isomerism directly modulates antibacterial selectivity and potency.
Positional relocation can also markedly enhance intrinsic activity (Fig. 1B). In aminopiperazine muscarinic agonists, formal 1,2-migration of a methyl group improves activity from IC50 = 170
000 nM to 550 nM.4 Similarly, in neuroactive steroids acting as positive allosteric modulators of NMDA receptors, conversion of a tertiary alcohol into a secondary alcohol via formal 1,2-relocation enhances GluN2A potency from EC50 >10
000 nM to 37 nM.5 A related trend is observed for inhibitors of Streptomyces coelicolor type II dehydroquinase: one derivative displays Ki = 45 ± 5 µM, whereas its structural isomer, in which the alcohol and ether side chain are formally interchanged, exhibited Ki = 8 ± 2 µM, corresponding to an approximately sixfold increase in activity.
In some cases, positional isomerism alters not only potency but also pharmacological profiles (Fig. 1C). Osthole exhibits antiarrhythmic, antithrombotic, and anti-inflammatory activities, whereas its structural isomer suberosin displays anti-inflammatory and anticoagulant effects,6 highlighting that positional variation can reshape biological functions rather than merely tune its magnitude.
The consequences of positional isomerism are equally pronounced in materials science. In cyanostilbene derivatives relocation of the cyano substituent from the para to the ortho position significantly changes solid-state packing and fluorescence behavior (Fig. 1D).7 The ortho isomer emits green fluorescence at 488 nm, whereas the para isomer shows yellow emission at 536 nm in both powder and crystalline forms.
Structural isomerism also impacts crystal packing in triisopropylsilylethynyl-substituted pentacenes (Fig. 1E).8 Substitution at the 6,13-positions affords an efficient two-dimensional π-stacking motif with enhanced intermolecular orbital overlap and superior charge-transport properties, whereas substitution at the 5,14-positions leads to a herringbone-like packing arrangement with limited π-overlap and inferior electronic characteristics. Device performance further reflects positional sensitivity (Fig. 1F).9 In dihydroindeno[1,2-b]fluorene derivatives, the para isomer exhibits an external quantum efficiency (EQE) of 9.9%, whereas the meta isomer achieves a significantly higher EQE of 14.8%.
Collectively, these examples illustrate a fundamental principle: molecular function is highly sensitive to positional information. The deliberate control of substituent location therefore represents a powerful means of modulating molecular behavior. However, efficient and general synthetic access to positional isomers remains a longstanding challenge in organic synthesis.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 2 Strategies for accessing structural isomers: (A) de novo synthesis; (B) regio-divergent synthesis; and (C) functional group translocation. | ||
Regio-divergent synthesis has emerged as a conceptually attractive alternative, enabling selective access to different positional isomers from a common precursor by modulating reaction conditions (Fig. 2B).10 Advances in catalyst design, ligand development, and reaction engineering have made selective divergence increasingly feasible, allowing control over regioselectivity through subtle changes in reaction parameters.11 Nevertheless, identifying suitable conditions typically demands extensive experimental screening and careful optimization, and regio-divergent strategies are often limited to specific substrate classes or reaction manifolds.
An alternative and conceptually distinct strategy is to relocate an already installed functional group within a molecular framework. If such relocation can be achieved without altering the molecular formula, the identity of the functional group, or the carbon scaffold, positional isomers could in principle be accessed directly from a single precursor. This approach transforms positional isomer synthesis from a problem of divergent construction into one of controlled molecular editing. The development of such transformations underlies what we define here as functional group translocation (Fig. 2C).
Despite its apparent simplicity, functional group translocation presents substantial synthetic challenges (Fig. 3B). First, the selective relocation of a functional group within a densely functionalized molecule requires precise control over both site and direction of migration. Thermodynamically, positional isomers often differ only marginally in stability, rendering selective and irreversible translocation difficult. From a kinetic standpoint, discrimination among multiple similar C–H or C–C bonds demands exceptional selectivity in bond activation. Furthermore, control over migration distance—whether 1,2-, 1,3-, 1,4-, or longer-range shifts—remains a central issue. Reversibility and product inhibition, arising from small energy differences between isomers, must also be addressed. Historically, most examples relied on harsh acidic or basic conditions, severely limiting functional group compatibility. The development of catalytic, mild, and highly selective processes therefore constitutes a formidable challenge in modern synthesis.
To rationalize recent advances, functional group translocation reactions can be classified along several orthogonal dimensions (Fig. 3C): (i) the molecular scaffold, including (hetero)aromatic systems, aliphatic frameworks involving sp2–sp3 exchange, and fully aliphatic sp3–sp3 systems; (ii) the identity of the migrating functional group, such as alkyl, aryl, ester, amide, acyl (ketone), cyano, amine, hydroxy, halogen, and silyl groups; and (iii) the migration distance, encompassing 1,2-, 1,3-, 1,4-, 1,n-, and double translocation processes. Mechanistically, these transformations proceed through diverse pathways, including strong acid or base activation, transition-metal catalysis, photoredox-induced radical processes, and related relay strategies.
Historically, functional group translocation emerged from classical stoichiometric processes operating under strongly acidic or basic conditions (Fig. 3D, left). Early examples established the feasibility of positional migration but were largely confined to robust substituents and limited substrate classes. Mechanistic studies in the mid-20th century clarified key intermediates and thermodynamic convergence principles, yet translocation chemistry remained fragmented and rarely conceptualized as a unified strategy. What was once a mechanistic curiosity has evolved into a powerful molecular editing strategy (Fig. 3D, right, details are described in Section 2).
A decisive shift occurred around 2020, when advances in transition-metal catalysis, photoredox activation, and radical relay design enabled catalytic and selective translocation under significantly milder conditions (details are shown in Sections 3–5). These developments dramatically broadened the range of migratable functional groups, accessible scaffolds, and controllable migration distances. As illustrated in Fig. 3D right, functional group translocation has evolved from isolated stoichiometric rearrangements into a coherent and rapidly expanding platform for molecular editing.
A. Rearrangement or scaffold alteration16,17
These are transposition-type processes in which the molecular skeleton changes between starting material and product. This represents the broadest sense of transposition. A recent example is the photochemical conversion of isoxazoles to oxazoles reported by Leonori and co-workers.18
B. Functional group alteration19,20
These are transposition-type processes in which the identity of the functional group changes during migration. A recent example includes transformations such as the conversion of aldehydes to thioethers reported by Yamada.21
C. Unsaturated bond isomerization22,23
These involve positional changes of alkenes or alkynes. Although formally a type of translocation, unsaturated bond isomerization has been thoroughly summarized in several recent and authoritative reviews.24 In view of these comprehensive treatments, we do not discuss these processes further here, and instead concentrate on underexplored classes of functional group translocation. The breadth and maturity of this field, exemplified by recent isomerization studies from groups such as Kuniyil, Du, and Guo, place it outside the scope of this review.25
D. Metal-centered translocation26
These involve positional exchange or migration processes centered on metal–ligand frameworks. Representative examples include exchange processes on iridium complexes reported by Ihee, Kim, and Chang. Because this review focuses on carbon–functional group relationships, such metal-centered processes are excluded.27
E. Classical named rearrangements28
Certain classical named reactions contain translocation elements, such as the Truce–Smiles rearrangement discussed by Clayden and others.29 However, these are typically categorized as rearrangements and often involve bond reorganization beyond simple positional change. They are therefore not treated here.
Accordingly, transformations in which either the molecular scaffold or the identity of the functional group changes are classified as A or B and are not considered translocation in the context of this review. In contrast, reactions in which the molecular scaffold and functional group identity are preserved while only the position of the functional group changes fall under the broad definition of translocation. However, categories C–E have already been comprehensively covered in several excellent reviews and are therefore excluded from the present discussion. This review focuses exclusively on functional group translocation reactions outside those categories.
Operationally, the present review includes not only single-step translocation reactions but also concise one-pot or sequential multi-step processes when they achieve direct positional editing of a functional group without reconstruction of the molecular scaffold. Accordingly, transformations involving strategically linked activation, migration, and deprotection or hydrolysis steps are discussed when the overall process conceptually corresponds to functional group translocation. In contrast, lengthy synthetic sequences involving complete removal and reinstallment of a functional group are considered outside the scope of this review.
1. Identifies the corresponding author and year of publication;
2. Briefly summarizes characteristic reagents, catalysts, or reaction conditions associated with the transformation;
3. Classifies the transformation according to the migrating functional group, translocation distance, and the molecular scaffold;
4. Provides a generalized reaction scheme, highlighting in red the carbon bearing the functional group prior to translocation and in blue the new position after translocation, while catalyst structures are shown for catalytic reactions; and
5. Summarizes representative substrate scope, the proposed reaction mechanism, together with the key design feature that enable functional group translocation.
This unified presentation is intended to clarify mechanistic patterns, highlight conceptual relationships, and reveal emerging principle across diverse reaction classes.
This review begins by revisiting classical transformations that laid the conceptual foundations of functional group translocation (Section 2). We then examine major advances reported since 2020, organized according to molecular scaffold and the identity of the migrating functional group. Section 3 addresses translocation on aromatic and heteroaromatic frameworks, Section 4 focuses on sp3 carbon systems, and Section 5 discusses emerging examples of double functional group translocation.
By framing recent developments within the unified concept of functional group translocation, this review seeks to provide a coherent overview of the field, delineate its current limitations, and outline future directions in synthetic methodology, drug discovery, and materials science.
With respect to 1,2-aryl translocation, one of the earliest documented examples involves indole derivatives. In 1888, Fischer and co-workers reported that 3-phenylindole (1), when heated with ZnCl2 at 170 °C, underwent quantitative conversion to the corresponding 2-phenyl isomer 2 (Scheme 1).34 This study represents one of the earliest observations of intramolecular aryl migration on a heteroaromatic framework.
With regard to positional isomerization within a single aromatic framework, a clear experimental demonstration was later provided by Baddeley and co-workers in 1935 (Scheme 2).35 They reported that heating p-di-n-propylbenzene (3) in the presence of aluminum chloride resulted in formation of the corresponding meta isomer 4, thus establishing intramolecular alkyl migration on the aromatic ring. For this reason, this type of alkyl 1,2-translocation is sometimes referred to as the Baddeley isomerization.36
Although related studies were subsequently reported, the reaction mechanism was not initially well understood.37 During the 1950s and 1960s, mechanistic investigations clarified the process, including the proposal of ipso-arenium intermediates.38 Despite the harsh conditions required, this transformation has since been applied in synthetic contexts for the preparation of structurally reorganized aromatic compounds.39
In the 1950s, alkyl migration on indole frameworks was also reported under strongly acidic conditions40 (For further details, see ref. 41). More recently, it was shown that heating a chiral 3-alkylindole bearing a stereogenic center at the benzylic 3-position with TRIFLIC ACID (TfOH) affords the corresponding chiral 2-alkylindole without erosion of enantioselectivity by Nakashima and co-workers.42 This finding highlights that, under appropriately controlled conditions, even acid-promoted alkyl translocation on indoles can proceed with preservation of stereochemical information.
In contrast, 1,2-aryl translocation on simple aromatic systems (as opposed to heteroarenes) was reported somewhat later. In 1942, Allen and Pingert described such a transformation in the context of their studies on the synthesis of ortho-terphenyl (Scheme 3).43 When the synthesized ortho-terphenyl (5) was treated with AlCl3, formation of meta-terphenyl (6) was observed. Later mechanistic studies suggested that these transformations proceed through ipso-arenium ion intermediates under strongly Lewis acidic conditions.44 In this mechanism, coordination of AlCl3 generates an ipso-arenium ion intermediate A. Subsequent intramolecular attack of an adjacent benzene ring leads to formation of a phenonium ion (Wheland-type) intermediate B. Rearomatization produces a new ipso-arenium ion C, ultimately affording meta-terphenyl. Formation of para-terphenyl (7) could be rationalized through an analogous pathway.
![]() | ||
| Scheme 3 Lewis acid-induced aryl 1,2-translocation in terphenyl systems via arenium-type intermediates. | ||
These transformations are particularly valuable for the synthesis of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons that are otherwise difficult to access through conventional functionalization methods, and they continue to find applications in modern synthetic studies.45,46
In addition to thermally or acid-promoted processes, photochemical 1,2-aryl and alkyl migrations have also been reported (Scheme 4). A pioneering example was disclosed in 1965 by Wynberg and co-workers, who described the 1,2-aryl migration of phenylthiophene.47 Irradiation of 2-phenylthiophene (8, X = S, R = Ph) with a high-pressure mercury lamp afforded the corresponding 3-phenylthiophene (9, X = S, R = Ph), albeit in yields generally below 30%. Between the late 1960s and 1970, Wynberg and Hiraoka expanded the scope of this transformation to various aryl substituents, alkyl groups, and related heteroaromatic systems such as furans and pyrroles.48 Although conceptually intriguing and mechanistically insightful, these early photochemical studies were conducted under relatively harsh conditions using high-pressure mercury lamps, which offered limited wavelength selectivity. In addition, purification techniques at the time were less advanced than those available today. Consequently, most examples were obtained in low to modest yields.
The reaction mechanism is highly complex, and the authors discussed multiple possible pathways. One possibility involves photoinduced cleavage of the C2–S bond to generate a thioaldehyde intermediate through a ring opening–ring closure process. However, such a mechanism would be expected to produce multiple isomerization pathways and therefore does not readily account for the high selectivity observed for formation of 3-arylthiophene. Alternatively, the authors proposed that photoexcitation activates the thiophene ring to generate a three-center hypervalent sulfur intermediate A through interaction of the sulfur 3d orbital with the C2–C3 π-bond. Concerted rearrangement of A then leads to re-aromatization with exchange of the C2 and C3 positions, ultimately furnishing 3-arylthiophene. The authors considered this mechanism to best explain the observed positional selectivity and labeling experiments.
Later studies further demonstrated that similar photochemical translocations could occur on pyrrole or thiazole frameworks, and that migrating groups were not limited to aryl substituents but also included cyano, halogen, and silyl groups.49,50
Photochemical alkyl migration was also observed in benzene derivatives. In 1964, Burgstahler reported one of the earliest examples of light-induced 1,2- and 1,3-tert-butyl migration on aromatic systems (Scheme 5).51,52 Historically, this work was inspired by the 1963 synthesis of Dewar benzene,53 which stimulated intense interest in photochemical valence isomerization of aromatic compounds. Upon ultraviolet irradiation (254 nm), substrate 10 first undergoes valence isomerization to generate Dewar benzene intermediate A1. Subsequent skeletal reorganization through prismane-type intermediate B ultimately furnishes products 11 and 12 via re-aromatization pathways involving intermediates A2 and A3. Although the detailed bond reorganization process remains complex, these studies established an early conceptual foundation for photochemical positional translocation on aromatic systems.
Although the above studies mainly involved alkyl substituents, Pincock and co-workers later reported related photochemical positional isomerization reactions of benzonitrile derivatives. Under ultraviolet irradiation, methylbenzonitriles underwent reversible positional isomerization through excited-state rearrangement pathways involving highly strained intermediates. Together, these studies established important conceptual foundations for contemporary photochemical translocation chemistry.
Together, these early studies established key conceptual foundations for contemporary photochemical functional group translocation chemistry.
As early as 1927, Hayashi reported that ortho-benzoylbenzoic acid undergoes acyl migration in concentrated sulfuric acid or in the presence of phosphorus pentoxide, a transformation that is still referred to as the Hayashi rearrangement.54 At the time, however, such migrations were considered exceptional cases restricted to specific substrates. The broader concept of reversibility in Friedel–Crafts acylation was introduced in 1955 by Gore, who proposed that “The Friedel–Crafts acylation reaction of reactive aromatic hydrocarbons is a reversible process”.55 In contrast, Olah later stated in 1973 that “acylation differs from alkylation in being virtually irreversible,” highlighting the lack of consensus at that time.56
Clear experimental evidence for reversible acyl migration first emerged clearly in heteroaromatic systems. In 1972, the groups of Budylin, Kost, and co-workers reported acid-promoted acyl migration reactions of indoles (Scheme 6).57 Under strongly Brønsted acidic conditions, 2-acylindoles 13 underwent migration of the acyl group to the C3 position to afford 3-acylindoles 14. These studies established that acyl groups on indole frameworks can undergo migration under acidic conditions. Shortly thereafter, in 1974, Agranat and co-workers demonstrated analogous behavior in simple aromatic systems (Scheme 7).58 Heating 2-benzoylnaphthalene (15) in polyphosphoric acid (PPA) at 140 °C resulted in migration of the acyl group to the 3-position, affording isomer 16. Subsequent studies reported additional examples of aromatic acyl migration.59 However, these transformations generally required harsh acidic and thermal conditions. As a consequence, substrates bearing sensitive functional groups were generally incompatible, and the scope of such acyl translocations remained limited to relatively robust systems.
Mechanistically, the arylpotassium species A formed via deprotonation is believed to undergo intermolecular halogen–metal exchange twice, thermodynamically most stable arylmetal species. However, when simple benzene derivatives are employed, control over the product distribution is often difficult, leading to mixtures of regioisomers.
The halogen dance reaction is generally driven by formation of the thermodynamically more stable aryllithium species. For example, further lithiation of an aryl bromide already bearing an ortho-lithium substituent is disfavored. Consequently, generation of a more readily lithiated bromoarene under the reaction conditions can accelerate the halogen dance process through rapid halogen–metal exchange. This concept was demonstrated by Quéguiner and co-workers (Scheme 9).64 By adding 3 mol% of bromine as a catalyst, they generated, within the reaction mixture, a more easily lithiated tribromopyridine species, which in turn acted as a catalyst to accelerate the halogen dance reaction. Under these conditions, dibromopyridine or bromochloropyridine 19 underwent efficient 1,2-halogen translocation to afford the corresponding dihalogenated product 20 in 75% yield (X = Cl) and 80% yield (X = Br).
![]() | ||
| Scheme 9 Catalytic halogen dance promoted by in situ generation of a more readily lithiated bromoarene. | ||
![]() | ||
| Scheme 10 Coenzyme B12-mediated enzymatic 1,2-functional group translocation via radical intermediates. | ||
On the other hand, examples have also been reported in which the use of hydrophobic vitamin B12 enables 1,2-migration of carbon-based functional groups. In 1990, Murakami and co-workers prepared a hydrophobic vitamin B12 derivative, [Cob(II)7C3ester]ClO4, incorporated into an octopus cyclophane framework, and successfully applied it to promote 1,2-carbon skeletal migration reactions (Scheme 11).67 Although the yields were modest, 1,2-migration of acyl (24a), ester (24b), and cyano (24c) groups was achieved.
The proposed mechanism follows a radical-based 1,2-shift pathway similar to that described above. Notably, rendering the vitamin B12 complex hydrophobic proved crucial for enabling these carbon-centered functional group migrations, presumably by allowing the reaction to proceed efficiently in nonpolar organic media and thereby promoting productive radical recombination within the solvent cage. These observations highlight the importance of the reaction environment in controlling reactivity.
The proposed mechanism begins with deprotonation at the α-position of the ester to generate intermediate A. A Dieckmann-type cyclization then forms cyclopropane intermediate B. Intermediates A and B are in equilibrium, and ring opening of the cyclopropane from the opposite side produces diester anion C. Subsequent proton transfer furnishes doubly stabilized anionic intermediate D, which is proposed to play a key role in rendering the process effectively irreversible and thereby driving the reaction forward. The existence of such an anionic intermediate was supported in the original study by trapping experiments with MeI. It was demonstrated that diesters undergo migration to give diester 26a, and that cyano esters similarly furnish diesters 26b and 26c, indicating that ester translocation proceeds under these strongly basic conditions.
Collectively, these classical studies established key conceptual foundations for modern functional group translocation chemistry. Although most early examples required harsh acidic, basic, thermal, or photochemical conditions and were limited to relatively robust functional groups, they revealed important mechanistic principles, including thermodynamic positional exchange, radical-mediated rearrangement, photochemical skeletal reorganization, and organometallic-driven migration processes.
In 2020, Bandar and co-workers reported an exploratory study toward catalytic halogen dance reactions (Scheme 13).70 They proposed that non-nucleophilic superbases could promote reversible HX elimination, generating aryne intermediate that undergoes subsequent HX readdition at a different position, thereby enabling halogen isomerization. Consistent with this hypothesis, treatment of bromoarene 27 with the organic superbase P4-tBu at 80 °C,71 resulted in halogen translocation, albeit in modest yields, affording regioisomers 28 and 29. For example, bromoarene 27a furnished isomer 28a in 20% yield, together with the further isomerized product 29a in 10% yield. Similar reactivity was observed for other bromoarenes, including conversion of 27b to 28b, thiophene 27c to 28c, and pyridine 27d to 28d. Although the efficiencies were limited, these results demonstrated that halogen dance reactivity can be induced without stoichiometric lithium amide bases.
Importantly, regioselective trapping of the translocated isomers was achieved by exploiting intrinsic differences in nucleophilic aromatic substitution reactivity. For instance, treatment of 3-bromopyridine (27d) with KOH/KBr in the presence of 18-crown-6 selectively afforded C4-functionalized products 31da (1.6 g scale), 31db, and with more complex nucleophile 31dc (dr = >10
:
1). This selectivity reflects the inherent preference for substitution at the C4 position of the pyridine ring. While not yet a fully developed catalytic halogen dance process, this study established a valuable proof of concept for halogen isomerization mediated by reversible HX elimination under comparatively mild conditions.
On the other hand, intriguing examples have emerged in which halogen dance reactivity is markedly accelerated by a specific catalyst, even though strong bases remain necessary. In 2023, the groups of Hirano, Uchiyama, and Okano reported a catalytic halogen dance reaction mediated by lithium aryltrifluoroborates (Scheme 14).72 When dibromopyridine 33a was treated with BF3·OEt2, followed by a stoichiometric amount of LDA, migration of the bromo group from the C3 to the C4 position occurred, affording the dance product 34a together with the starting material 33a in 70
:
28 ratio. From these observations, the authors proposed that deprotonation of 33a, followed by reaction with BF3·OEt2, generates a lithium aryltrifluoroborate species B which serves as the active catalyst. To substantiate this hypothesis, independently prepared 35 was introduced in 10 mol%, resulting in exclusive formation of 34a in 89% yield. The scope was further demonstrated by varying the substituent on the pyridine framework; styryl (34b), alkynyl (34c), and cyclopropyl (34d) derivatives all underwent efficient halogen translocation under the optimized conditions.
Mechanistically, deprotonation of dibromopyridine 33 generates a pyridyllithium intermediate A, which undergoes first lithium-halogen exchange with catalyst B to form tribromopyridine C and lithium aryltrifluoroborate D. A second lithium–halogen exchange between C and D then furnishes the thermodynamically favored pyridyllithium species E while regenerating catalyst B, and completing the catalytic cycle. In this scenario, the C–BF3Li unit functions as a transient halogen shuttle, and stabilizing F–Li interactions are proposed to lower energy of key transition states. As a consequence, the intrinsic substrate-controlled regioselectivity of halogen dance chemistry can be modulated, leading to substantial rate acceleration.
Although the process still relies on strong base, this study provides the first clear example of catalyst-enabled acceleration of halogen dance reactivity. It thus represents a significant conceptual advance and suggests a viable path toward more general and efficient catalytic halogen translocation reactions.
Accordingly, even after 2020, the development of truly catalytic and highly selective halogen dance reactions with high selectivity had remained elusive. Very recently, however, advances toward this goal have begun to appear. In 2025, Liu and co-workers reported a migratory cross-coupling reaction of aryl chlorides (Scheme 15).73 They found that a Pd catalyst bearing the bulky AdBrettPhos ligand,74 in combination with CsF as an additive, promoted partial migration of a para-positioned chloro group to the meta position. Mechanistically, oxidative addition of the aryl chloride 36 generates intermediate A, which undergoes β-hydride elimination to form a Pd–benzyne intermediate B.75 This step is proposed to be reversible. Re-insertion of the palladium species into the benzyne moiety, followed by protonation, affords intermediate C. Subsequent reductive elimination from C preferentially furnishes the thermodynamically more stable meta-substituted product 37, thereby regenerating the palladium catalyst. DFT calculations supported this proposal, indicating a minimal energy difference of only 0.5 kcal mol−1 between the para- and meta-substituted benzyne intermediates (B1 and B3). The observed regioselectivity is likely governed by thermodynamic equilibration between the isomeric aryl halides under the reaction conditions.
Moreover, under Buchwald–Hartwig-type cross-coupling conditions, the meta isomer was found to react slightly faster than the corresponding the para isomer. This kinetic preference enabled selective formation of the meta-coupled product 38a–38c. Although migratory cross-coupling reactions have previously been described for bromoarenes,76 extension of this strategy to chloroarenes represents a significant and previously unexplored advance in catalytic translocation chemistry.
The scope of the reaction proved broad. Variation of substituents on the phenyl moiety of the ester was tolerated (41b), and heteroaromatic substrates were likewise compatible. In pyridine-derived ester 40c, the ester group migrated selectively from the C4 to the C3 position (41c). Pyrene derivatives also underwent smooth translocation. Notably, phenyl ester 40d, readily prepared from pyrene-1-carboxylic acid ($112/g, Sigma-Aldrich, May 2026), was converted into the corresponding pyrene-2-carboxylic acid phenyl ester 41d. Subsequent hydrolysis provided the corresponding pyrene-2-carboxylic acid ($1001/g, Sigma-Aldrich, May 2026), highlighting the practical utility of ester dance for accessing otherwise difficult positional isomers from simple feedstock materials.
Mechanistically, oxidative addition of ester 40 to Pd/dcypt catalyst generates intermediate A, followed by concerted deprotonation to form a Pd–aryne-type intermediate B. Subsequent protonation, carbonylation, and reductive elimination deliver the transposed ester 41. The reaction operates under thermodynamic control, as supported by calculated Gibbs free energies. For example, product 41a was calculated to be 3.73 kcal mol−1 more stable than 40a, consistent with the observed equilibrium distribution.
Importantly, the authors demonstrated that ester dance can be combined with a decarbonylative coupling to achieve formal cine-coupling outcomes.80,81 In contrast to thermodynamically governed translocation step, the selectivity of the subsequent coupling step is determined by nucleophile reactivity. For instance, coupling of phenyl thiophene-3-carboxylate (40e) with thiazole 42a furnished 43ea preferentially. Although 40e does not undergo ester dance under the reaction conditions due to near isoenergetic ester isomers, coupling proceeds via the more reactive position effectively overriding thermodynamic preferences. Similarly, coupling of phenyl nicotinate (41c) with diphenylamine (42b) afforded the C4-arylated product 43cb, selectively, despite the minimal (0.5 kcal mol−1) thermodynamic bias between positional isomers (40c and 41c).
These studies illustrate that integration of ester dance with downstream decarbonylative coupling enables access to substitution patterns unattainable by either process alone. This contrast between thermodynamically controlled translocation and kinetically controlled coupling selectivity underscores the mechanistic diversity possible within functional group translocation chemistry.
When ortho-silylaniline derivative 45a was heated in toluene at 180 °C in the presence of a [RuCl2(p-cymene)]2, BINAP, and Cu(OAc)2, efficient 1,3-migration occurred to afford the para-silylated product 46a in high yield. The reaction exhibited broad substrate compatibility; even substrates bearing a triethylsilyl group (SiEt3) underwent translocation, albeit in diminished yield, to give 46b. Naphthylamine and pyridylamine derivatives also underwent 1,3-translocation to give products 46b–46d. In contrast, substrates bearing silyl groups at the 2-position of indole or pyrrole preferentially underwent 1,2-migration. In these cases, the reactions preferentially underwent 1,2-migration under identical conditions, furnishing the corresponding 3-silylated indole 46e and pyrrole 46f (Notably, photoinduced 1,2-silyl migration in pyrroles has also been reported).49b These results indicate that the migration distance is highly dependent on the heteroaromatic scaffold, underscoring the distinctive reactivity patterns enabled by metal–catalyzed silyl translocation.
A plausible reaction mechanism was proposed. Cu(OAc)2 oxidizes the Ru(II) precatalyst, to generate active Ru(III) species, which coordinates to the aniline nitrogen to form complex A. Electrophilic attack at the ipso carbon bearing the silyl group produces intermediate B. Subsequent migration of the silyl group, driven in part by relief of steric congestion, affords intermediate C. Rearomatization then furnishes intermediate D, and regeneration of the catalytically active Ru species occurs via protodemetalation with HX, delivering the transposed product 46, and completing the catalytic cycle. Electron-donating substituents such as NMe2, act as directing groups to facilitate the initial electrophilic activation step. Notably, the size of the silyl group proved critical: small groups such as trimethylsilyl (TMS) were ineffective, whereas bulkier substituents including t-butyldimethylsilyl (TBS) and triisopropylsilyl (TIPS) enabled efficient migration. Electron-rich aromatic systems were also found to promote the process, by stabilizing key cationic intermediates.
In 2022, Yamaguchi and co-workers reported an AlCl3-mediated 1,2-aryl translocation reaction of aryl heteroarenes that established both broad substrate generality and bidirectional migration on heteroaromatic frameworks (Scheme 18).85 A range of C3-aryl-substituted benzothiophenes 47, indoles, and thiophenes underwent efficient C3-to-C2 migration to furnish products 48a–48c. Notably, the previously unreported C2-to-C3 migration was realized in benzothiophene derivatives bearing electron-donating substituents at the C6 position (e.g. 47d and 47e). In these cases, Zn(OTf)2 proved crucial as an effective additive to suppress undesired demethylation of methoxy groups under Lewis acidic conditions, thereby enabling productive aryl translocation.
A mechanistic pathway consistent with these observations was proposed. Under Lewis acidic conditions, electrophilic activation occurs preferentially at the more nucleophilic C3 position to generate acid adduct A, which evolves into Wheland intermediate B. Rearomatization, facilitated by lone-pair donation from heteroatom, and subsequent acid dissociation affords the C2-arylated product 48. In contrast, when an electron-donating substituent is present at the C6 position, electronic activation of the C2 position enables formation of adduct A′. This intermediate proceeds through a related Wheland-type species B′, ultimately furnishing the C3-arylated product 47. These results demonstrate that the directionality of aryl translocation on the heteroaromatic system can be electronically controlled with the migration pathway governed by differential stabilization of key cationic intermediates.
Very recently, Liu and co-workers reported an exceptionally distinctive example of 1,2-aryl translocation on an aromatic framework in the context of 1,2-azaborines (Scheme 19).86 1,2-Azaborines, in which one C–C bond of benzene is replaced by an isoelectronic B–N unit, are widely regarded as benzene analogues.87 During investigation into their synthesis and functionalization, the authors discovered a photochemical strategy that enables formal 1,2-aryl migration, thereby providing flexible access to diverse substitution patterns. Upon blue-light irradiation in the presence of the photocatalyst 4CzIPN,88 5-arylated 1,2-azaborines 49, underwent selective migration of the aryl group from the C5 to C4 position to afford 50. Likewise, 3-aryl-5-substituted derivatives 51 furnished product 52, in which the aryl groups initially located at the 3- and 5-positions relocated to the 5- and 4-positions, respectively.
The reaction exhibits broad tolerance toward both electron-rich and electron-deficient aryl substituents (50a and 50b), and accommodate heteroaryl units such as pyrimidine (50c) as well as complex motifs including caffeine (50d). Notably, related azaborine-type substrates (51) also undergo analogous translocation processes. In these systems, migration can occur between an aryl group and a boryl substituent (52a), or between an aryl group and a trimethylsilyl (TMS) group (52b). Importantly, the process can be viewed not merely as aryl migration, but in certain cases as an exchange between an aryl group and hydrogen. or even between an aryl group and boron, underscoring the distinctive reactivity of the azaborine scaffold.
Mechanistically, irradiation first induces 4π-electrocyclization of 49 or 51 to generate a 1,2-BN-Dewar benzene intermediate A. Further photoexcitation promotes homolytic cleavage to form biradical B, followed by a 1,2-radical boron shift to give intermediate C and subsequent radical recombination to afford 1,2-BN-benzvalene D. These steps are consistent with the groups’ earlier studies.89 The crucial innovation arises under visible-light photoredox conditions; oxidation of D by 4CzIPN generates radical cation [BN-benzvalene]˙+ E, rendering the central C5–C6 σ bond highly labile. Bond cleavage leads to a prefulvene-like intermediate F, which undergoes further bond reorganization to produce a rearranged radical cation X.
Finally, reduction by the photocatalyst (Ir(II) or PC−) restores aromaticity and furnishes the translocated products 50 or 52.
Although mechanistically unique, this study establishes a fundamentally new mode of 1,2-aryl translocation on an aromatic framework. Moreover, the authors demonstrated that product 52 (R = Me) can serve as a versatile intermediate for the synthesis of fully substituted 1,2-azaborines, highlighting the broader synthetic potential of this transformation. Very recently, Liu and co-workers further demonstrated that BN-benzvalene intermediates can undergo catalyst-controlled divergent rearomatization to furnish either C3- or C5-functionalized 1,2-azaborines, thereby expanding the concept of positional editing on BN-aromatic frameworks.90
Building on these recent advances in aryl translocation chemistry, Chiba and co-workers reported a photoredox-catalyzed 1,2-aryl translocation on pyridine frameworks (Scheme 20).91 Under irradiation with 427 nm light, treatment of C4-arylpyridines 53 with the organic photocatalyst 3DPAFIPN92 in the presence of potassium formate, Cs2CO3, and HFIP in DMSO promoted migration of the aryl group from the C4 position to the adjacent C5 position, affording translocated pyridines 54. Under related conditions, 2,4-diarylpyridines 55 underwent selective C4-to-C3 aryl translocation to furnish pyridines 56. Interestingly, addition of MeOH altered the reaction pathway, enabling C2-to-C3 translocation of the aryl group to give products 57. The reaction showed moderate substrate generality. For the C4-to-C5 translocation manifold, amide-containing aryl groups and pyridine-containing aryl substituents were tolerated, affording products 54a and 54b. In the C4-to-C3 translocation, products such as 56a and 56b were obtained efficiently. In the C2-to-C3 migration pathway, the presence of a para-methoxyphenyl (PMP) group at the C4 position proved crucial for efficient translocation (57a and 57b). On the other hand, because the reaction operates under relatively reducing conditions, functionalities such as ketones and other readily reducible groups were not compatible.
A plausible reaction mechanism of C4-to-C5 translocation was proposed as follows. First, photoexcited 3DPAFIPN together with formate-derived reductants promotes sequential single-electron reduction and protonation of pyridine 53 to generate intermediate A. Further reduction and protonation convert the aromatic pyridine ring into the corresponding 1,4-dihydropyridine intermediate B. The authors proposed that this process occurs through an ECEC (electrochemical–chemical–electrochemical–chemical) sequence. Subsequent single-electron oxidation of B generates an azacyclohexadienyl radical intermediate C. In this species, the radical center is positioned adjacent to the aryl substituent, enabling intramolecular radical addition onto the aryl ring to form spiro radical intermediate D. Because this spiro intermediate is highly unstable, rearomatization accompanied by C–C bond reorganization proceeds readily, resulting in 1,2-translocation of the aryl group and formation of a new azacyclohexadienyl radical intermediate E. Subsequent single-electron transfer then furnishes the translocated pyridine product 54. The key feature enabling this transformation is that temporary dearomatization generates an azacyclohexadienyl radical manifold capable of reversible aryl migration, while the overall selectivity is governed by the relative thermodynamic stability and redox properties of the resulting isomers. In the C4-to-C5 translocation pathway, the activation barrier for formation of spiro radical intermediate was calculated to be 25.2 kcal mol−1, and the resulting C5 radical was found to be 0.3 kcal mol−1 more stable than the corresponding C4 radical. The reduction potentials of the starting C4-arylpyridine 53 and the C5-translocated product 54 were measured as Ep/2 = −1.73 V and −1.80 V vs. SCE, respectively. In the C4-to-C3 translocation pathway, formation of the corresponding spiro radical proceeds through a lower activation barrier of 22.0 kcal mol−1, and the resulting E intermediate was calculated to be 5.7 kcal mol−1 more stable than C. Correspondingly, the reduction potentials of 2,4-diarylpyridine 55 and the translocated 2,3-diarylpyridine 56 were measured as Ep/2 = −1.82 V and −2.10 V vs. SCE, respectively. Thus, photoredox-induced temporary dearomatization creates a reversible radical translocation manifold that enables positional editing of aryl groups on pyridine frameworks.
In this approach, para-substituted phenol 58 is first oxidized with 2-iodoxybenzoic acid (IBX) to generate the corresponding ortho-quinone A. Subsequent treatment with 2,4,6-triisopropylbenzenesulfonyl hydrazide (TPSH) enables selective diazotization, forming diazo intermediate B. A following Cu-mediated reduction of B completed the sequence, ultimately delivering the meta-phenol 59. The bulky triisopropylbenzene unit of TPSH plays a dual role: it promotes α-elimination and suppresses undesired sulfonylation of intermediate A.
Regarding substrate scope (e.g. 59a–c), efficient conversion requires initial oxidation to the ortho-quinone, and phenols bearing electron-donating substituents generally provide higher yields. Although this strategy proceeds through multiple discrete steps and therefore does not meet the strict definition of a single-step, catalytic 1,2-functional group translocation emphasized in this review, purification is required only at the final stage. Consequently, this method represents practical and conceptually noteworthy solution for positional relocation of hydroxy groups on aromatic rings, particularly in late-stage molecular editing.
Although the phenolic 1,2-hydroxy translocation reported by Lumb and co-workers provides an effective solution, it is subject to several limitations. Most notably, the method requires an electron-donating substituent at the para position of the starting phenol, and consequently the hydroxy migration is restricted to formal para-to-meta translocation. These structural constraints limit both the generality and positional flexibility of the strategy.
In 2025, Dong and co-workers disclosed a complementary approach that overcomes these restrictions (Scheme 22).96 Although their protocol also proceeds through multiple steps, it enables hydroxy migration without requiring a para-substituent on the starting phenol. In this sequence, phenol 60 is first converted into the corresponding nonaflate (ONf) A, which undergoes a Pd-catalyzed norbornene-mediated Catellani reaction.97 This transformation effects ortho methoxylation in conjunction with ipso hydrogenation. Subsequent demethylation of intermediate B furnishes the transposed phenol 61. Under these conditions, meta-naphthol 61a was obtained in moderate yield. Importantly, substrates lacking a para substituent were well tolerated, as illustrated by 61b, and phenols bearing a phenyl substituent also underwent efficient translocation to afford 61c. In the case of benzofuran-derived substrate 60d, a single 1,2-hydroxy translocation delivered 61d, while iterative application of the sequence enabled further positional relocation to give 61e. Collectively, these results demonstrate that the Catellani manifold provides a versatile platform for controlled hydroxy translocation on aromatic frameworks.
This wavelength-dependent selectivity can be rationalized by the proposed mechanism. Under acidic conditions, 62a is converted into protonated arenium ions A and A′. Upon photoexcitation, these species undergo 4π electrocyclization to generate bicyclic cation intermediates B and B′. Intermediate B undergoes a 1,2-methylene shift to give C, followed by rearomatization through arenium ion D to furnish para-cresol (63a). In contrast, B′ proceeds via an analogous pathway through C′, and arenium ion D′ to afford ortho-cresol (64a). Although multiple arenium ions can be formed under the reaction conditions, each exhibits a distinct absorption maximum. Irradiation at 310 nm99 selectively excites the C4-protonated arenium ion A, directing the reaction toward para-cresol (63a), whereas irradiation at 390 nm preferentially excites the C2-protonated arenium ion A′, leading to ortho-cresol (64a).
The generality of the wavelength-controlled strategy was demonstrated across several substrates. Products 63b and 63c from simple natural products were obtained with high positional selectivity, and in the case of amyl-meta-cresol (62d), irradiation at 310 nm furnished 63d in 42% yield, while 390 nm irradiation provided 64d in 86% yield.
The success of this approach relies on advances in LED technology, which enable precise wavelength selection, as well as on the ability to predict absorption properties of reactive intermediates computationally. Together, these features suggest that selective excitation of specific intermediates may emerge as a powerful design principle for controlling functional group translocation in aromatic systems.
Very recently, Grant and co-workers reported a conceptually distinct strategy for 1,2-translocation of substituents on phenolic aromatic systems (Scheme 24).100 In this approach, phenols 65 were first oxidized with PIFA ([bis(trifluoroacetoxy)iodo]benzene) to generate dienone intermediate A. Subsequent photochemical rearrangement followed by treatment with Zn/AcOH furnished meta-substituted phenols 66 through formal para-to-meta translocation of the substituent. In the case of ortho-substituted phenols 67, oxidation with lead tetraacetate generated the corresponding ortho-dienones A, which upon irradiation and subsequent photoredox-mediated rearomatization similarly afforded meta-substituted phenols 68.
Mechanistically, photoexcitation of dienone A induces a di-π-methane rearrangement to generate bicyclo[3.1.0]hexenone intermediate B.101 Under reductive conditions, these intermediates initially form cyclopropyl ketyl radicals. However, β-scission of these radicals was found to be relatively slow, allowing further two-electron reduction to occur. The resulting anionic intermediate then undergoes concerted rearomatization, selectively furnishing the meta-substituted products. Substrates bearing cyclopropyl or aryl substituents at the para position were compatible, giving the corresponding meta-substituted phenols 66a and 66b. Phenols bearing ortho tert-butyl or benzyl substituents also underwent efficient translocation to afford products 68a and 68b in moderate yields.
Collectively, Sections 3.5 and 3.6 highlight several fundamentally distinct modes of translocation chemistry on phenolic aromatic systems. Whereas the methods developed by Lumb and Dong involve peripheral editing through positional relocation of hydroxy groups, the photochemical translocation reported by Leonori proceeds through arenium-ion-mediated alkyl migration. In contrast, Grant's strategy operates through skeletal editing of the aromatic framework itself via photochemical valence rearrangement and rearomatization. These examples illustrate how superficially similar “translocation” reactions can proceed through fundamentally different mechanistic and conceptual manifolds.
In 2021, Yang and co-workers discovered that 1,2-acyl migration on indoles can be markedly promoted by the addition of a Pd catalyst (Scheme 25).102 When C3-acylated indole 69 was heated at 100 °C in HFIP/TFA in the presence of catalytic Pd(OAc)2, complete migration of the acyl group to the C2 position was observed, affording product 70 in high yield. Mechanistically, acid-mediated isomerization of 69 is proposed to generate intermediate A. Nucleophilic attack of trifluoroacetate at the acyl group then induces cleavage to give indole B and a mixed anhydride. The Pd(TFA)2 species formed in situ subsequently activates the mixed anhydride, facilitating nucleophilic acylation of the indole to form intermediate C, which undergoes rearomatization to furnish the C2-acylated product 70. Importantly, the reaction is dependent on substitution at the C5 position of the indole. Indoles bearing an aryl group at C5 afforded the corresponding C2-acylated products in high yield (e.g., 70a, 89%), and a methyl substituent was also tolerated (70b), In contrast, unsubstituted indoles failed to undergo acyl migration (70c), and no reaction occurred in the absence of Pd(OAc)2.
Although the positional outcome remains confined to C3-to-C2 migration, the ability to promote acyl translocation under comparatively milder and catalyst-assisted conditions represents a meaningful conceptual advance beyond classical, purely acid driven rearrangements.
In 2021, Dong and co-workers reported a one-pot or two-step strategy for formal 1,2-carbonyl translocation (Scheme 26).105 In this approach, carbonyl compound 71 is first converted into the corresponding enol triflate, either directly in a one-pot operation or as a discrete intermediate. A subsequent Pd-catalyzed Catellani-type reaction employing ligand L1 transforms the enol triflate into an enamine, which upon hydrolysis furnishes the carbonyl group at the adjacent position, thereby achieving streamlined 1,2-carbonyl relocation to give 72. For example, α-tetralone was converted to β-tetralone (72a) in 72% yield. The method is applicable to six-membered rings as well as five-membered cyclic ketones 72b and bicyclic systems 72c. As a synthetic application, the authors demonstrated access to compound 72d bearing a γ-stereogenic center, a motif difficult to construct. Following enantioselective 1,4-addition of a Grignard reagent to furnish 71d,106 application of the carbonyl translocation sequence enabled efficient conversion to 72d, demonstrating the utility of this strategy for complex molecule construction.
A plausible mechanism begins with oxidative addition of the C–O bond of the enol triflate A to Pd, generating intermediate B. Subsequent norbornene (NBE) insertion affords complex C, and formation of palladacycle D follows. Use of a specifically designed NBE derivative was critical to suppress formation of an undesired byproduct X.107 Insertion of the amine source and β-carbon elimination regenerate NBE and deliver intermediate F. Decarboxylation generates a Pd–H species G, which undergoes reductive elimination to afford enamine H. Final hydrolysis of H furnishes product 72, corresponding to formal carbonyl 1,2-migration. This study represents an elegant extension of Catellani-type chemistry to carbonyl editing, demonstrating how strategic relay process reorganization of carbonyl group within an sp3 framework.
Building upon these studies, Dong and co-workers further expanded the concept of carbonyl editing to atom-swapping reactions. In 2026, they reported a transformation converting cyclic ketones into cyclic amines through a formal CO-to-N atom swap process.108 Using the specially designed NAHA-G2 reagent, ketone substrates first form prearomatic intermediate A. Subsequent radical fragmentation induces sequential C–C bond cleavage to generate an alkyl radical, which adds to p-tosyldiazene (TsN2Ph) B to form the first C–N bond. A second radical generation and C–C bond cleavage then occur, enabling formation of the second C–N bond at the opposite carbon terminus. Final cyclization and hydrogen-transfer processes furnish the corresponding piperidine skeleton.
Particularly interestingly, Dong and co-workers demonstrated that this atom-swap chemistry could be integrated with their previously developed carbonyl translocation strategy. Thus, cyclohexanone derivative 71e was first converted into the transposed ketone 72e through 1,2-carbonyl translocation, followed by CO-to-N atom swap to furnish amine 71e. Although direct CO-to-N atom swap of 71e also provided amine 73e, the combined translocation/atom-swap sequence enabled selective access to the distinct positional isomer 74e. These studies elegantly illustrate how functional group translocation and atom-swapping reactions can be merged to achieve programmable skeletal editing of cyclic molecules.
While the strategy developed by Dong and co-workers represents a powerful, kinetically controlled and irreversible approach to carbonyl translocation, a fundamentally different concept was reported in 2023 by Bhawal, Morandi, and co-workers. They disclosed a reversible, transition-metal-free and thermodynamically controlled 1,2-translocation of carbonyl groups (Scheme 27).109
![]() | ||
| Scheme 27 Transition-metal-free, and thermodynamically controlled 1,2-translocation of carbonyl groups and its application to total synthesis. | ||
This work was inspired by the classical Willgerodt–Kindler reaction,110 in which the carbonyl group of a ketone is formally shifted to the adjacent carbon atom and converted into an amide. In the present study, cyclic ketones 75 were treated with catalytic pyrrolidine and elemental sulfur (S8) in isopropyl alcohol with added water. Heating under these conditions enabled formal 1,2-migration of the carbonyl group, furnishing rearranged cyclic ketones 76. For example, a cyclohexanone derivative was converted to the corresponding 1,2-transposed ketone 76a in 63% yield. Bicyclic substrates (76b and 76c), as well as the tetracyclic steroid androstenedione, were also compatible, affording product 76d. Notably, in substrates bearing two carbonyl groups, the reaction proceeds with high selectivity for one site. Because the transformation operates under thermodynamic control, mixtures of starting materials and further rearranged products arising from additional 1,3-migration can be observed, which may complicate isolation. Nevertheless, this equilibrium-driven process represents a compelling example of reinterpreting a classical transformation in the context of modern molecular editing.
Mechanistically, cyclohexanone 75 first forms enamine A upon reaction with pyrrolidine. Nucleophilic attack of this enamine on S8 generates polysulfide anion B, which then intramolecularly attacks the corresponding iminium ion to form cyclic disulfide intermediate C. Although not explicitly proposed by the original authors, a plausible sequence involving reversible elimination and readdition of pyrrolidine can be considered to establish an equilibrium among intermediates C, D, and E. The thermodynamically more stable intermediate E preferentially reverts to iminium species F, followed by sulfide extrusion to regenerate enamine G. Hydrolysis of G then furnishes the 1,2-transposed cyclohexanone 76. The driving force for this equilibrium lies in conformational effects within the cyclohexanone framework. Specifically, product 76a, bearing only one 1,3-diaxial interaction, is calculated to be 2.8 kJ mol−1 more stable than isomer 75a, which contains two such interactions. Consideration of these subtle steric effects enables rational prediction of the direction and outcome of the carbonyl migration.
Notably, in 2026, Huang and co-workers demonstrated an elegant application of this carbonyl 1,2-translocation strategy in the total synthesis of pentacyclic homoproaporphine alkaloids.111 In their synthesis, the stereochemistry of the spiro center was introduced at a late stage through a desymmetrizing ketone transposition strategy. Specifically, condensation of chiral sulfinamide 77 with meso aldehyde 78 followed by cyclization afforded tetracyclic intermediate 79. Conversion of the methyl ester 79 into the corresponding redox-active ester 80 and subsequent photoredox-catalyzed arylation furnished spirocyclic ketone 81. Importantly, although the spiro center in 81 itself is not stereogenic, subsequent carbonyl 1,2-translocation converted 81 into desymmetrized ketone 82 possessing the desired stereochemical arrangement. During this process, undesired regioisomeric products arising from alternative carbonyl migration were also formed; however, resubjection of these isomers to the reaction conditions partially converted them into 82 under thermodynamic control. Using 82 as a common intermediate, they accomplished the total synthesis of four pentacyclic homoproaporphine alkaloids in only 10–12 steps. This study nicely illustrates how late-stage conversion of a symmetrical ketone into a desymmetrized ketone through carbonyl translocation can streamline complex molecule synthesis, representing a particularly sophisticated application of modern molecular editing concepts in total synthesis.
Following these advances in 1,2-carbonyl translocation, Wu and co-workers reported in 2025 a notably simple, transition-metal-free strategy for formal 1,2-carbonyl translocation (Scheme 28).112 In this approach, ketone 83 is treated with NaHMDS and Commins’ reagent (PhNTf2), and subsequent acidic workup furnishes the corresponding 1,2-migrated carbonyl compounds 84 in good yields.
Mechanistically, reaction of the ketone with one equivalent of NaHMDS and Commins’ reagent generates enol triflate A. Upon warming to 60 °C, a second equivalent of NaHMDS promotes elimination to form a highly strained cycloalkyne intermediate B. Nucleophilic attack by HMDS− or the Ph2N− anion derived from Commins’ reagent occurs preferentially from the less hindered face of the cycloalkyne, affording enamine intermediate C, which upon hydrolysis delivers the product corresponding to formal 1,2-carbonyl migration. The role of NaHMDS is crucial, as these nucleophiles efficiently trap the transient cycloalkyne, which would otherwise undergo oligomerization due to its high instability. Support for the intermediacy of B was obtained by conducting the reaction in the presence of diphenylisobenzofuran, leading to formation of a cycloaddition-derived product in low yield.
Although the reaction can proceed at room temperature, excessive heating diminished the yield. A related reaction was reported by Wang and co-workers in 2021;113 however, differences in base selection, nucleophile identity, and the absence of enamine hydrolysis, mean that the reaction was not interpreted as carbonyl migration. The present study therefore represents a distinct contribution by explicitly framing the transformation as 1,2-carbonyl translocation.
Steric congestion at the α-position is a key determinant of selectivity. Cyclopentenone derivatives smoothly afforded 84a, and substrates bearing coordinating groups such as pyridines were also tolerated (84b). Six-membered rings underwent the transformation efficiently (84c), whereas seven-membered rings gave lower yields (84d), consistent with the reliance on ring strain to drive formation and capture of the cycloalkyne intermediate. Notably, even when the α-position is not a quaternary carbon, sufficiently bulky substituents enable selective carbonyl migration, as exemplified by product 84e.
Overall, this strain-driven, metal-free protocol represents a particularly practical example of carbonyl translocation, proceeding cleanly without recovery of starting material, and avoiding the use of precious catalysts. It highlights the power of transient high-energy intermediates as design elements in functional group translocation chemistry.
In 2026, Yamaguchi and co-workers reported a nickel-catalyzed formal 1,2-carbonyl translocation of tetralone derivatives (Scheme 29).114 Treatment of α-tetralone derivative 85 with K3PO4 and pivalic anhydride (Piv2O), followed by reaction with a Ni catalyst bearing the dcype ligand and N-methylaniline, enabled selective formation of β-tetralone derivatives 86. Quenching the reaction mixture with silica gel led to hydrolysis of the intermediate enamine, affording β-tetralone products 86a–86c in good yields and with high positional selectivity. Notably, this transformation is currently limited to tetralone frameworks and has not yet been generalized to other carbonyl systems.
Mechanistically, α-tetralone (85a) is first converted into the corresponding enol pivalate A. Oxidative addition of its C–O bond to Ni(0) generates complex B, which undergoes a characteristic 1,2-migration of the nickel center to form intermediate C. Subsequent ligand exchange with the amine nucleophile affords complex D, and reductive elimination yields enamine intermediate E with regeneration of the nickel catalyst. Hydrolysis of E during silica workup then delivers β-tetralone 86a. The proposed 1,2-migration of the nickel complex is strongly supported by prior studies from the same group.115 In earlier cine-substitution coupling reactions of tetralones using an analogous catalytic system, intermediate B was isolated and its conversion to C was confirmed by NMR analysis. Moreover, related substrates subjected to comparable conditions were shown to form intermediate C in similar yields. Conceptually, the present transformation builds directly on this cine-substitution platform, replacing the carbon nucleophile with an amine inspired by related work from Dong and co-workers,105 while introducing nickel catalysis in place of palladium as a defining mechanistic distinction.
Mechanistic studies support a radical relay pathway. Upon irradiation with 365 nm light, photoexcited NaDT* abstracts a hydrogen atom from substrate 87, generating a pool of carbon centered radicals through a largely unselective and reversible HAT process. TRIPSH functions as a hydrogen-atom donation catalyst, enabling radical equilibration (radical sampling) among different positions. Selectivity arises in the subsequent intramolecular cyclization step. Radicals capable of forming a five-membered ring undergo rapid cyclization, which determines the migration site under kinetic control. Even in substrates bearing tertiary C–H bonds, migration proceeds via secondary radical pathways when cyclization is faster. The resulting cyclic radical undergoes β-scission to effect 1,4-cyano translocation, followed by hydrogen atom transfer to furnish the rearranged product 88. In cyclic systems, the reaction proceeds via a bridged radical intermediate prior to fragmentation.
From a synthetic perspective, this transformation is particularly valuable because it enables selective functionalization of internal C–H bonds by first installing a cyano group at a terminal position and subsequently relocating it through a 1,4-shift. In this way, molecular architectures that are difficult to access by direct C–H functionalization can be efficiently constructed via cyano translocation.
Specifically, acid-activated ketones 89 were proposed to undergo single-electron reduction under photochemical conditions, triggering C–O bond cleavage concomitant with intramolecular arene attack to generate a spirocyclic intermediate A. Subsequent ring opening of the cyclopropane moiety by the counteranion of the acid affords intermediate B, which then undergoes an intramolecular SN2-type displacement to deliver the product 90 arising from formal 1,2-acyl migration.
The reaction conditions are notably simple. Treatment of 2-acyl dihydrobenzofurans 89 with hydrochloric acid, followed by irradiation at 370 nm in iPrOH/H2O and subsequent addition of triethylamine as a base (Conditions A), or alternatively with LiI in acetone/H2O under 370 nm irradiation (Conditions B), furnishes 3-acyl dihydrobenzofurans 90. Both light irradiation and protic solvents are essential: no reaction occurs in the absence of light, while decomposition predominates without a protic solvent. With respect to substrate scope, benzoyl (90a, and 90b) and heteroaroyl (90c) groups are compatible. Dihydrobenzofuran substrates bearing electron-withdrawing substituents at the C5 position generally afford higher yields, presumably due to facilitated ring opening (90d and 90e). Moreover, switching the irradiation wavelength to 310 nm enables single-electron reduction of ester (90f), carboxylic acid (90g), and amide (90h) functionalities as well. Although the substrate scope remains limited, this study represents a compelling example of “new reactivity from old ideas” and illustrates how renewed interest in functional group translocation has brought such transformations into sharper focus.
In 2025, Wendlandt and co-workers reported an alternative photocatalytic strategy to the 1,4-translocation of ketone functionalities in cyclic systems (Scheme 32).121 The reaction conditions and overall mechanistic logic resemble those developed by Xu and co-workers,116 for cyano migration, with ketones employed in place of nitrile-containing substrates.
Although the current scope is largely limited to seven-membered rings and the reaction typically affords mixtures of diastereomers—thereby reducing its intermediate synthetic practicality—the transformation tolerates a range of substituents at the ketone site, including fluoro (92a), acetate (92b), unsubstituted (92c), and ester-functionalized derivatives (92d). Mechanistically, photoinduced generation of an alkyl radical A from substrate 91 initiates the process. Favorable 5-exo-trig cyclization leads to intermediate B, which accounts for the observed 1,4-selectivity. Subsequent β-scission (C) and hydrogen-atom transfer (HAT) steps then furnish the ketone product 92.
One year later, Palani and co-workers reported an even more sophisticated aroyl translocation strategy on saturated carbon frameworks (Scheme 33).122 The earlier study by Wendlandt and co-workers relied on formation of a kinetically favored bicyclic radical intermediate through radical cyclization, followed by radical fragmentation to achieve remote acyl migration. In contrast, Palani and co-workers introduced a conceptually distinct strategy in which the “cyclization phase” and the “cleavage phase” were decoupled. As a result, the migration process was no longer governed primarily by the stability of radical intermediates, enabling transannular 1,3-translocation that had previously been difficult to achieve.
Specifically, irradiation of ketone 93 in tBuOH at 370 nm followed by treatment with Mn(OAc)3, 1,10-phen (1,10-phenanthroline), and AdSH (adamantanethiol) afforded aroyl-translocated product 94 through formal 1,3-migration of the aroyl group. Mechanistically, photoexcitation of ketone 93 generates a triplet excited state A, and the resulting oxygen-centered radical undergoes Norrish–Yang-type 1,5-hydrogen atom transfer (1,5-HAT) from the γ-position. The resulting biradical intermediate B subsequently recombines to generate strained bicyclo[3.1.1] intermediate C. This sequence constitutes the cyclization phase of the reaction. In the subsequent cleavage phase, Mn(OAc)3 promotes single-electron oxidation of the cyclobutanol moiety to generate alkoxy radical D. This radical undergoes β-scission to cleave the C–C bond, furnishing tertiary radical E in which the aroyl group has effectively migrated to a new position. Finally, hydrogen atom transfer from AdSH affords the 1,3-translocated ketone product 94.
Thus, by decoupling cyclization and cleavage processes, the authors succeeded in enabling transannular 1,3-aroyl migration that had previously been difficult to access through conventional radical translocation strategies. The reaction was also demonstrated on gram scale, affording product 94a with high diastereoselectivity. Bicyclic substrates similarly underwent efficient 1,3-translocation to furnish 94b, and nitrogen-containing heteroaromatic aroyl groups were also compatible, as illustrated by 94c. Furthermore, this strategy enabled unusual skeletal editing processes, including conversion of spirocyclic substrate 93d into macrocyclic ketone 94d. Migration of aroyl groups located at the α-position of ketones was also achieved, enabling transposition to the C4 position as shown in 94e.
Although both the Wendlandt and Palani studies address carbonyl/aroyl translocation on saturated carbon frameworks, they differ fundamentally in conceptual design, mechanism, and accessible migration topology. In this sense, the work by Palani and co-workers can be regarded as a significant conceptual advance beyond the earlier Wendlandt strategy.
If readily accessible organoboron compounds could be converted into other organoboron isomers through boron migration, thereby transforming one or more C–H bonds into C–B bonds, this would provide a powerful entry to further functionalization. However, such transformations are inherently challenging. This challenge was addressed by Xu, Qi and co-workers (Scheme 34).123 Drawing on their previous studies of 1,4-cyano migration,116 they hypothesized that generation of alkyl radicals under tungsten photocatalysis might enable net boron migration. Indeed, using a tungsten photocatalyst, 4(PnBu4)DT, in combination with a catalytic amount of a sterically hindered thiol under 365 nm LED irradiation, they observed 1,2-boron translocation.
![]() | ||
| Scheme 34 Tungsten-photocatalyzed radical 1,2-boryl translocation of tertiary organoboron compounds. | ||
Substrates bearing tertiary C–B bonds underwent 1,2-translocation to adjacent cyclic methylene positions, affording product 96a in 62% yield. Although only modest diastereoselectivity was observed, with a ratio of 1.7
:
1, the regioselectivity was excellent and exceeded 20
:
1. Cyclohexanone derivatives (96b), tetrahydrofuran derivatives (96c), and bicyclic systems (96d) were also compatible, furnishing the corresponding 1,2-migrated products. Importantly, the transformation was not limited to cyclic systems, as acyclic substrates also underwent 1,2-migration efficiently (96e). Boronic acids such as B(OH)2 and Bneo derivatives were likewise tolerated, although yields for these boronic acid derivatives were somewhat lower (96f and 96g). Under optimized conditions, the endo isomer 96h was obtained preferentially; however, under more intense irradiation conditions, selective methyl borylation led predominantly to the exo isomer (96h_exo).
Mechanistically, the reaction begins with generation of an alkyl radical from the organoboron substrate under tungsten photocatalysis. From 95h, several radical intermediates can form, but only radicals A and A’, generated at adjacent carbon atoms, undergo 1,2-boron migration to give intermediates B and B’. Subsequent hydrogen atom transfer furnishes either 96h_endo or 96h_exo. Although a tertiary radical can in principle be regenerated from these products, steric congestion suppresses further boron translocation, rendering the process effectively irreversible. The observed regio- and stereoselectivity between the endo and exo products can be rationalized by the steric environment imposed by the thiol catalyst, which influences the hydrogen atom transfer step.
Although questions remain regarding the relative thermodynamic stability of the starting and translocated boron isomers, this study represents the first example of formal 1,2-translocation of an sp3-bound boron substituent. As such, it constitutes an important conceptual advance in functional group translocation chemistry.
Almost simultaneously, Xi and co-workers reported a closely related 1,2-boryl taranslocation (Scheme 35).124 As in Xu's study, tertiary boronic esters were employed as readily accessible starting materials. Treatment of these substrates 95 with catalytic nBu4NFeCl4 and the disulfide (Trip2S2) under 390 nm LED irradiation afforded the 1,2-boryl-translocated products 96 preferentially. Mechanistically, the reaction is initiated by generation of a chlorine radical from the iron catalyst.125 This chlorine radical abstracts a hydrogen atom from the substrate to form an alkyl radical, after which the process proceeds analogously to that proposed by Xu and co-workers, involving 1,2-boryl translocation followed by hydrogen atom transfer.
A range of substrates was tolerated. Seven-membered rings (96i), heterocyclic six-membered rings (96j), sulfones (96k), and other substrates bearing tertiary carbon centers (96l) all underwent efficient 1,2-boryl translocation. Organoboron compounds derived from complex, drug-like scaffolds were also compatible, furnishing products 96m and 96n in good yields. Moreover, when substrate 95o was subjected to the standard conditions, product 96o was formed, and a second 1,2-boryl shift could occur to give 96p. As noted at the outset, tertiary boronic ester 95q can be readily prepared from halides such as 97a or from carboxylic acids such as 97b using established methods.126 Subsequent 1,2-boryl migration of 95s, followed by treatment with NBS, regenerates the corresponding halide 98a, whereas reaction with carbon dioxide furnishes the carboxylic acid 98b although these transformations proceed via a boron intermediate, they formally constitute net halogen or carboxyl group translocation. This study therefore highlights how a boron relay strategy can be leveraged to achieve functional group translocation beyond boron itself.
As in the previously described systems, the photoexcited tungsten catalyst promotes reversible hydrogen atom abstraction (HAA) at multiple C–H bonds of 99, thereby establishing a dynamic “C–H sampling” equilibrium among various carbon-centered radicals. Among these transient radical intermediates, only radical A generated at the β-position adjacent to the acyloxy group undergoes rapid Surzur–Tanner-type 1,2-acyloxy radical migration through highly charge-separated three-membered (or five-membered) transition states B. Subsequent hydrogen atom transfer from the thiol source to radical C furnishes the translocated products 100.
In the Wendlandt system, addition of TMSOTf serves as a convenient triflic acid precursor for in situ protonation of the pyridyl ester auxiliary group. The resulting cationic pyridinium species promotes proximity-enhanced hydrogen atom abstraction through ion-pairing interactions with the decatungstate catalyst, thereby facilitating generation of the β-radical intermediate required for the subsequent Surzur–Tanner-type acyloxy migration. In contrast, both the Xu and Wendlandt systems employ electron-withdrawing oxamoyl auxiliaries, which facilitate rapid 1,2-acyloxy radical migration by stabilizing the highly charge-separated transition states associated with the Surzur–Tanner rearrangement.
Collectively, these studies demonstrate a fundamentally new design principle for positional editing reactions. Rather than relying on highly site-selective HAA processes, positional selectivity is achieved through reversible radical sampling followed by selective trapping through rapid translocation. The rapid expansion of this concept from cyanide, acyl, and boryl groups to acyloxy groups suggests that reversible radical translocation chemistry is emerging as a general strategy for late-stage positional editing on saturated carbon frameworks.
The first example was reported in 2025 by Pan Xu and co-workers. Inspired by the 1,4-cyano translocation developed by Yan Xu and co-workers, they extended this concept to achieve cyano migration from sp3 carbon to sp2 carbon (Scheme 37).128 Under blue LED irradiation, the use of 4CzIPN as a photoredox catalyst, together with catalytic amounts of quinuclidine derivative and 20 mol% of (TripS)2, afforded the 1,4-translocated product 102. In addition to benzylic dinitriles (102a and 102b), substrates bearing simple aliphatic substituents (102c) or a combination of cyano and ester groups (102d) underwent efficient translocation. Even substrates with a shortened carbon chain delivered the corresponding 1,4-migrated product 102e. Notably, complex molecules containing additional functional groups, including indomethacin derivatives, were also compatible (102f).
Mechanistically, photoexcitation of 4CzIPN in the presence of the amine additive initiates single-electron transfer to generate a radical ion pair consisting of an anion radical and a cation radical A. The nitrogen-centered radical then adds to the olefin, forming an alkyl radical intermediate B. As in the work by Yan Xu and co-workers, this radical undergoes a favorable 5-exo-dig cyclization to give intermediate C, followed by β-scission that effects 1,4-cyano translocation and generates cation radical D. Subsequent electron transfer from the reduced photocatalyst affords an anionic intermediate E, which undergoes proton transfer and elimination to furnish the final product. Thus, although the key difference lies in the generation of alkyl radicals via amine radical addition, the overall translocation logic closely parallels that of the earlier Xu system.
Importantly, this study demonstrates that careful substrate design enables, for the first time, a 1,4-functional group translocation that is net from an sp3 carbon to an sp2 carbon. This finding significantly expands the conceptual framework and structural scope of functional group translocation chemistry.
Almost simultaneously with the report by Xu and co-workers, Zhen and Shu independently disclosed a closely related transformation (Scheme 38).129 In their study, a sodium sulfonyl salt was employed as the additive in place of an amine. Remarkably, the substrate scope closely mirrors that reported by Xu and co-workers, and essentially identical substrates undergo efficient 1,4-functional group transposition to afford the corresponding products 102a, 102c, 102e, and 102g–102i.
Mechanistically, the reaction proceeds through the same fundamental pathway as the Xu system, with the sole difference being the involvement of a sulfonyl radical instead of an aminyl radical. This parallel development further underscores the generality of radical relay strategies for achieving net sp3-to-sp2 functional group translocation.
Mechanistic studies suggest the involvement of photoexcited palladium species. Upon light irradiation, the excited palladium complex engages the aryl iodide to generate an aryl radical A. This radical subsequently reacts with the boron substituent positioned at the 4-position, triggering a 1,4-migration of the boryl group via transiton state B to form alkyl radical intermediate C. The greater thermodynamic stability of alkyl radicals relative to aryl radicals likely serves as a driving force for this translocation process. The resulting alkyl radical then abstracts iodine from the palladium center, delivering product 104 and regenerating the palladium catalyst.
The substrate scope is currently limited to systems bearing an alkyl chain at the ortho position of an iodoarene and a Bpin group at the C4-position. Nevertheless, the transformation tolerates a range of additional functional groups, including chloro (104a), diboryl (104b), fluoro (104c), naphthyl (104d), and olefin-containing substrates (104e), affording the exchanged products in moderate yields. Although the immediate synthetic utility of this transformation is limited, it represents an intriguing example of intermolecular exchange between two reactive functional groups. Because this transformation involves functional groups located on sp2 and sp3 carbon centers, it is also discussed in Section 4.5.
![]() | ||
| Scheme 40 Photochemical permutation of azoles enabling solvent-controlled apparent aryl translocation. | ||
When thiazoles bearing two substituents are empolyed, the reaction appears as an exchange of substituents. For instance, irradiation of 105a in 1,4-dioxane gives the exchanged product 107a in 57% yield. Similarly, 105b undergoes apparent exchange of methyl and phenyl groups to give 107b. Even more complex substrate 105c furnishes 107c in HFIP.
Although azoles are known to undergo various translocation reactions,49d examples in which light, solvent, and simple additives alone enable such clean and switchable control are rare. Given the mild conditions and high selectivity, this photochemical permutation represents a synthetically valuable transformation.
For example, prolonged treatment of a diaryl thiophene 108a under these conditions affords the aryl-exchanged product 109a together with recovered 108a in a 75
:
10 ratio. Benzofuran derivatives are also amenable; diaryl benzofuran 108b undergoes efficient aryl exchange to give 109b with a product ratio of 18
:
82. Although the reaction conditions themselves are not novel, the clean intramolecular exchange of two aryl groups is noteworthy. From materials science perspective, such transformations are particularly attractive, as they enable access to alternative substitution patterns without the need for de novo synthesis of the molecular framework.
In 2025, Leonori, Ruffoni and co-workers reported a strategy for the synthesis of anilines 110 via formal 1,2-migration of a nitrogen source from aryl azides 111 (Scheme 42).132 The transformation proceeds through a three-step sequence. First, aryl azide 110 is irradiated with 390 nm in the presence of an aryl thiol and then addition of trifluoroacetic anhydride (TFAA). This is followed by treatment with N-chlorosuccinimide (NCS) and Bi(OTf)3, and finally by addition of Cs2CO3 with a second irradiation at 390 nm. Each stage requires purification, rendering the process multistep in nature.
Mechanistically, photoexcitation of 110 generates a singlet nitrene A, which rearranges to an azirine B and subsequently undergoes 6π-electrocyclization to give ketimine C. Nucleophilic attack of the arylthiol affords azepine D, which upon activation with TFAA forms intermediate E. A second 6π-electrocyclization (F) followed by rearomatization furnishes ortho-aminothiophenol G. In the second stage, NCS and Bi(OTf)3 converts the amine into an aminothiolium salt H, which undergoes C–S bond cleavage under basic conditions to deliver TFA-protected aniline 111.
Despite the multistep character, the reaction tolerates diverse substituents, including t-butyl (110a), Bpin (110b), methoxy (110c), and imide (110d, derived from aminoglutethimide), affording the corresponding products 111a–111d in moderate yields. Importantly, the transformation proceeds with high positional selectivity, consistently delivering the ortho-aminated products, reflecting a well-defined rearrangement manifold rather than a statistical redistribution of nitrogen functionality. Although the focus here is the formal 1,2-nitrogen relocation, the sulfonium intermediates formed in the sequence provide opportunities for further diversification.133 Accordingly, this method offers a versatile platform for accessing structurally varied aniline derivatives through a formal nitrogen transposition manifold.
Mechanistically, oxidative addition of the C–CN bond of nitrile 112 and the acyl C–O bond of ester 113 to the nickel catalyst, Ni(dcype)(CO)2 (dcype = 1,2-bis(dicyclohexylphosphino)ethane),136 generates complexes A and B. Subsequent exchange of the anionic ligands, namely −CN and −OPh, furnishes complexes C and D, from which reductive elimination provides the diaryl ether 115 and quinoline products 114 bearing the cyano group at different positions. Although the cyano group does not migrate intramolecularly within a single molecule, NMR experiments confirmed the occurrence of ligand exchange at the metal center, supporting the proposed mechanism. This transformation therefore represents a formal, rather than literal, cyano translocation. By exploiting intermolecular aryl exchange on a common scaffold, the strategy cleverly creates the net appearance of positional cyano migration. Conceptually, this work highlights how functional group interconversion chemistry can be leveraged to achieve positional diversification that mimics a translocation process, thereby expanding the design space of functional group editing.
Although the functional group identity changes from an amide to a ketone during the sequence, the positional shift of the carbonyl unit clearly constitutes a formal 1,2-carbonyl translocation and is therefore included in this review. The method is applicable to several substrate classes: eight-membered lactams afforded the corresponding ketones (e.g. 117a) and aryl iodide substituents, often incompatible with transition-metal-catalyzed processes, were well tolerated (117b). Additional eight-membered lactams underwent efficient conversion (117c), and even acyclic amides furnished the desired ketones 117d, albeit in more modest yields.
While currently limited to amide substrates, this work provides an elegant demonstration of carbonyl relocation in a one-pot sequence through orchestrated redox manipulation and skeletal isomerization, thereby broadening the conceptual framework of carbonyl translocation chemistry.
Interestingly, the reaction outcome depends strongly on the ring size of the starting ketone. With five-membered ring substrates, the above pathway predominates.140 In contrast, for six-membered ring systems, nucleophilic attack preferentially occurs at the amide carbonyl group from intermediate A, generating tetrahedral intermediate E. This alternative pathway leads to a retro-Claisen-type fragmentation to give intermediate F, which upon protonation of F furnishes compound 120 (cis/trans = 12
:
1). Although this amide 1,2-translocation was not the primary focus of the original study, it represents an intriguing transformation that could prove valuable if its scope and generality can be further developed.
Over the past several years, functional group translocation has evolved from isolated and often harsh transformations into a catalytically enabled molecular editing strategy. Transition metal catalysis, photoredox activation, and radical relay processes have significantly broadened the accessible reaction space. Migrating groups now include halogens, aryl and alkyl substituents, acyl and ester units, cyano and boryl groups, together with a variety of heteroatom-containing functionalities such as amino, sulfonyl, and alkoxy groups. Translocations have been demonstrated across (hetero)aromatic frameworks, sp2–sp3 systems, and fully aliphatic sp3–sp3 manifolds, and select cases even in double functional group exchange processes.
To provide a systematic overview, we compiled a summary table correlating scaffold type and migrating functional group (Fig. 6). This overview reveals that, despite impressive progress, the landscape remains highly uneven. Aromatic systems are comparatively well explored, whereas fully aliphatic systems remain underdeveloped. Short-range 1,2-migrations dominate the field, while predictable long-range (1,n) translocations are still rare. Certain functional groups, such as cyano and boryl units, have recently emerged as versatile handles, yet many other functional group classes remain largely unexplored in a translocation context. These gaps highlight substantial opportunities for future development.
Several key challenges define the outlook of the field. First, achieving predictable site-selectivity in molecules containing multiple similar bonds remains intrinsically difficult. Second, controlling migration distance and directionality, particularly when thermodynamic differences between isomers are small, requires deeper mechanistic understanding. Third, reversibility and product inhibition, often rooted in subtle energy landscapes, must be addressed to ensure synthetic practicality. Finally, expanding translocation chemistry to complex, densely functionalized molecules will be essential for broader adoption in medicinal chemistry and materials science.
Looking ahead, the maturation of functional group translocation will likely depend on the development of general design principles that transcend individual reaction classes. Integration with C–H functionalization, skeletal editing, and late-stage diversification strategies may ultimately enable the controlled repositioning of functional groups within complex molecular architectures. If such principles can be established, functional group translocation has the potential to become a foundational tool for positional molecular design rather than a collection of isolated transformations. The field remains far from saturated. Its most compelling advances may still lie ahead.
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2026 |