Open Access Article
Shengli
Zhou
a,
Hiroko
Fukaya
a,
Shunsuke
Watanuki
a,
Wei
Liu
a,
Maasa
Yokomori
a,
Muneyuki
Matsuo
ac,
Kazuya
Okada
b,
Yukina
Yoshioka
b and
Keitaro
Yoshimoto
*a
aDepartment of Life Sciences, Graduate School of Arts and Sciences, The University of Tokyo, 3-8-1 Komaba, Meguro, Tokyo 153-8902, Japan. E-mail: ckeitaro@mail.ecc.u-tokyo.ac.jp
bDaikin Industries, Ltd, 1-1 Nishi-Hitotsuya, Settsu-shi, Osaka 566-8585, Japan
cGraduate School of Integrated Science for Life, Hiroshima University, 1-3-1 Kagamiyama, Higashi-Hiroshima, Hiroshima 739-8526, Japan
First published on 11th February 2026
The development of fast, simple, and visual methods for detecting adenosine triphosphate (ATP) is crucial for point-of-care diagnostics and environmental monitoring. Colorimetric assays based on the integration of DNA aptamer-triggered hybridization chain reaction (HCR) with gold nanoparticles (AuNPs) offer high potential, but existing methods often suffer from prolonged detection times (e.g., >130 min). To address this limitation, this study systematically investigated and optimized the core parameters of the aptamer-triggered HCR system and its subsequent mixing conditions with AuNPs to achieve a rapid visual detection platform. The HCR kinetics were accelerated by the high concentrations of single-stranded DNA (ssDNA) components, particularly the H0 initiator, as well as by the critical presence of divalent magnesium ions (Mg2+), which also support the functionality of the aptamer. This optimization allowed for a degree of HCR progression comparable to the traditional 24-hour incubation to be achieved within just 60 minutes. Subsequently, recognizing the inherent trade-off between the high ssDNA concentration required for fast HCR and the AuNP dispersion stability, we optimized the mixing ratio between the HCR product and the AuNP solution. Under these optimized conditions, the assay demonstrated the capability for rapid visual detection of ATP at the 100 µM level within a total assay time of 15 minutes, representing a significant acceleration compared to previously reported methods. Further improvements in sensitivity are anticipated through future fine-tuning of AuNP parameters and the use of post-reaction salt aggregation enhancers.
In recent years, colorimetric detection platforms integrating DNA aptamers with gold nanoparticles (AuNPs) have emerged as promising alternatives, offering instrument-free operation and visually interpretable results.9–16 For instance, Yang et al. developed an aptamer–AuNP sensor for ochratoxin A detection with a limit of detection (LOD) of 20 nM using UV-vis spectrophotometer.14 Similarly, Tu et al. reported a conjugated aptamer–AuNP probe for amyloid-β oligomers achieving an LOD of 3.03 nM, highlighting its diagnostic potential also using UV-vis spectrophotometer.15 Zhu et al. further demonstrated excellent sensitivity (LOD = 26 cells per mL) using potentiostat/galvanostat with a hydrazine–AuNP–aptamer bioconjugate for specific breast cancer cell recognition.16
The color change of AuNPs is useful for developing the visual detection method. To enhance the sensitivity of visual detection, aptamer-triggered hybridization chain reaction (HCR), an enzyme-free isothermal amplification mechanism, has been frequently integrated with AuNP-based colorimetric systems.17–24 However, existing HCR–AuNP platforms still face practical limitations in terms of reaction time. For example, Dirks et al. first reported the aptamer-triggered HCR using three single-stranded DNAs (ssDNAs) and required an extremely long reaction time of up to 24 hours to confirm HCR products via gel electrophoresis. Then, Gao et al. proposed a visual ATP detection method based on a mixture of HCR products and AuNPs, in which they used two ssDNAs for HCR and AuNPs synthesized by themselves. ATP could be detected with a reported LOD of 1.0 nM, which was evaluated based on UV-vis spectroscopic analysis of the absorbance ratio (A630/A520).25 Although Gao et al. developed a visual ATP detection assay by mixing the HCR products with AuNPs, their procedure still required approximately 130 minutes with 37 °C.
Such lengthy, instrument-dependent and heating required workflows significantly hinder their feasibility for rapid on-site testing applications. Therefore, the primary objective of this study was to optimize the procedure by refine the experimental conditions of the essential components constituting this aptamer-triggered HCR-based detection system. Specifically, we focused on the total ssDNA concentration, NaCl concentration, and MgCl2 concentration. Finally, we demonstrated the visual ATP detection within 15 minutes with 25 °C.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 1 Schematic illustration of the aggregation and dispersion of gold nanoparticles (AuNPs) based on an aptamer-triggered hybridization chain reaction (HCR) triggered by ATP. | ||
At first, we investigated the factors that accelerate the aptamer-triggered HCR by the gel electrophoresis analysis. Specifically, we focused on the total ssDNA concentration, NaCl concentration, and MgCl2 concentration. Then, the rapid visual ATP detection using AuNPs was demonstrated.
| a Sequence of ATP binding aptamer is represented by solid underline. Hybridization sequences are represented using double underlines or wavy underlines. |
|---|
|
The total concentration of the ssDNA components is typically the most significant factor affecting the reaction rate of HCR, as it directly impacts the collision frequency of the hairpin structures (H1 and H2) and the initiator (H0). To investigate this effect, we conducted HCR reactions for 24 hours while varying the initial concentration of H0, H1, and H2 from 1 µM to 6 µM (i.e., [H0] = [H1] = [H2]). The resulting HCR products were subsequently evaluated using gel electrophoresis (Fig. 2A). As shown in Fig. 2A, the ATP-containing samples exhibited distinct bands corresponding to the HCR polymerization products in the high molecular weight region. Simultaneously, a clear decrease in the band intensity of the monomer ssDNA substrates, H1 and H2, was observed. Fig. 2B shows the quantitative analysis of the H1 and H2 band intensities in Fig. 2A confirmed the expected outcome: the HCR reaction rate, quantified by the total consumption ratio of H1 and H2, increased proportionally with the increase in the total ssDNA concentration. Specifically, under the 24-hour HCR condition of [H0] = [H1] = [H2] = 1 µM, which corresponds to the concentration set by Dirks et al. in their previous study, a consumption ratio of approximately 44.2% was observed. By increasing the ssDNA concentration 6-fold, i.e., to [H0] = [H1] = [H2] = 6 µM, the consumption ratio of H1 and H2 nearly doubled to 84.1%. Furthermore, the 4 µM condition also demonstrated a high consumption ratio of 77.8%.
![]() | ||
| Fig. 2 Effect of total ssDNA concentration on the reaction rate of aptamer-triggered HCR within 24 h. (A) Gel electrophoresis analysis for HCR products after mixing H0, H1, H2 in the presence and absence of ATP with different concentration. (B) The total consumption ratio of H1 and H2 ssDNA in the presence of ATP depending on the ssDNA concentration, quantified from the bands of [H1] and [H2] in (A). Experimental condition: [H0] = [H1] = [H2] = 1–6 µM, [ATP] = 1.4 mM, [MgCl2] = 10 mM, [NaCl] = 300 mM, reaction time for HCR: 24 h. *The 44.2 of consumption ratio was obtained under the same experimental condition reported previously15 ([H0] = [H1] = [H2] = 1 µM). Data represent mean ± SEM of four independent experiments. | ||
To further investigate the HCR process, we performed a time-dependent analysis of the HCR reaction over a shorter period (0–120 minutes). Fig. 3A shows the total consumption of the H1 and H2 substrates over time under various equal ssDNA concentrations ([H0] = [H1] = [H2] = 2, 4, and 6 µM) with different reaction times. As anticipated, the total consumption ratio of H1 and H2 increased with both higher ssDNA concentration and longer reaction time. Notably, for the highest concentration tested (6 µM), the consumption ratio reached approximately 30% after 60 and 120 minutes of reaction time. While this demonstrated the benefit of higher concentration, the overall consumption rate within the 2-hour window remained insufficient for maximizing the signal, suggesting that the concentration of the initiator (H0) may be the limiting factor at shorter reaction times.
We then specifically investigated the impact of the initiator (H0) concentration while maintaining the hairpin substrate (H1 and H2) concentration high. Fig. 3B shows the total consumption ratio of H1 and H2 when the substrate concentration was fixed at 6 µM, and the H0 concentration was varied from 0 to 12 µM. The results clearly showed that a higher concentration of H0 led to a greater consumption of H1 and H2. Significantly, when the H0 concentration was in the range of 6–9 µM with 6 µM substrate concentration, the consumption ratio reached approximately 40% at 60 minutes. This value is nearly equivalent to the 44.2% consumption ratio achieved under the 24-hour reaction condition, which is asterisked in Fig. 2B ([H0] = [H1] = [H2] = 1 µM). These results clearly indicate that the increased amount of initiator and substrate is highly effective for accelerating the reaction rate of aptamer-triggered HCR, providing a critical step towards realizing rapid detection.
Following the optimization of ssDNA concentrations, we investigated the influence of monovalent salt (NaCl) and divalent salt (MgCl2) concentrations on the HCR reaction rate over a 60-minute incubation period. Appropriate salt concentrations are crucial for neutralizing the negative charge of the DNA backbone, which stabilizes the resulting double-stranded HCR polymers and facilitates the hybridization process. Fig. 4A shows the effect of varying NaCl concentration on the total consumption ratio of H1 and H2. The results indicate that the concentration of NaCl did not significantly correlate with an increase in the HCR reaction rate over the range tested. Notably, even in the absence of NaCl with 10 mM of MgCl2, the HCR reaction still proceeded efficiently. In contrast, the concentration of MgCl2 was found to be highly critical for driving the HCR reaction. As shown in Fig. 4B, the HCR reaction rate exhibited a strong dependency on the MgCl2 concentration. The consumption ratio of H1 and H2 increased steadily as the MgCl2 concentration was raised from 0 mM up to 10 mM. Above this threshold, specifically in the range of 10–15 mM and beyond (up to 50 mM), the HCR reaction rate plateaued and remained high, suggesting that 10 mM MgCl2 is sufficient to saturate the requirement for stabilizing the DNA structures and promoting hybridization. This clear concentration-dependent trend underscores the essential role of the divalent cation (Mg2+) in facilitating the HCR mechanism, likely by reducing the electrostatic repulsion between the ssDNA strands more effectively than the monovalent Na+ ions. Furthermore, Mg2+ ions are known to be indispensable for the proper folding and function of many DNA aptamers, including the ATP-binding aptamer sequence contained within the H0 strand, which is essential for initiating the ATP-triggered HCR process.
To evaluate the performance of the integrated rapid visual detection system, we first examined the colorimetric response using HCR products incubated for 60 minutes and immediately mixed with the AuNP solution (Fig. 5 and S1). The results showed that the method was capable of visually detecting ATP concentrations in the range of 100–500 µM. Furthermore, Fig. 5 highlights the significant impact of the ssDNA concentration ratio on the visual detection sensitivity. Comparing the four conditions—[H0]
:
[H1]
:
[H2] = 6
:
6
:
6 µM, 6
:
4
:
4 µM, 6
:
3
:
3 µM and 6
:
2
:
2 µM—the last condition exhibited a lower ATP detection concentration. This difference is strongly attributable to the lower total ssDNA amount in the 6
:
2
:
2 µM condition, which inherently renders the AuNPs less stable and therefore more susceptible to aggregation and color shift upon HCR consumption, effectively improving the visual sensitivity.
We simultaneously focused on reducing the total detection time by investigating shorter HCR incubation times (Fig. 5 and S1). The results revealed that an HCR incubation time of only 10 minutes was sufficient for effective visual detection. Specifically, even at 10 minutes, the assay could clearly distinguish ATP at 100 µM through a visible color difference. Under the [H0] = [H1] = [H2] = 1 µM condition, the HCR barely proceeded within 120 min due to the insufficient substrates' concentrations (data not shown). Therefore, conditions such as 6
:
1
:
1 µM, which involve even lower substrates levels, were not considered in this study. A comparison between the two conditions tested at 20 minutes, [H0] = [H1] = [H2] = 3.2 µM and 4.8 µM, again demonstrated that the condition with the higher total ssDNA concentration (4.8 µM) exhibited greater AuNP dispersion stability, leading to a less pronounced color shift, confirming the trade-off between HCR efficiency and AuNP signal generation (Fig. S2).
A crucial achievement of this optimization is the substantial reduction in the total assay time compared to previous reports. Gao et al. (2017) utilized a system requiring an 80-minute HCR incubation at 37 °C followed by an additional 50-minute post-mixing for visual detection, resulting in a total assay time of 130 minutes. In contrast, the colorimetric results shown in this study shown in Fig. 5 demonstrate that with the appropriately optimized mixing ratio between the HCR product and the AuNP solution, immediate visual determination of the ATP concentration is possible at room temperature (25 °C), where the total detection time is approximately 15 minutes, representing a significant reduction compared to the 130 minutes required by Gao and co-workers.
Through the systematic optimization of the total ssDNA concentration, their ratio, cation concentration, and the mixing ratio of HCR product with AuNPs, this study demonstrated the capability for rapid visual detection of ATP at the 100 µM level within 15 minutes. Despite the successful achievement of rapid detection, further improvements in visual detection sensitivity are possible. Potential strategies include the optimization of the volume ratio between the HCR product and the AuNP solution, the use of differently sized AuNPs to tune the stability threshold, and the post-mixing addition of a salt, such as NaNO3, like the method implemented by Gao et al., to further enhance the aggregation kinetics and sharpen the colorimetric response.
Supplementary information (SI) is available. See DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d5ay01738f.
| This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2026 |